Discussion Locked

5-4-3 Rule - I have broken it

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Not sure how to word this question - so I will just jump right in. I have a NT 4.0 (sp6) server with 26 Win98 workstations. I had to put an additional 5 port hub at the end of my run so that I could add 2 more workstations to that department. I believe that action affected my network. I have attempted to map it below.

Starting with:
Cable Modem to
3' cable to
Linksys Router to
3' cable to
24 Port 10/100 Switch - 15 workstations + uplink to
280' cable to
8 Port 10/100 Switch - 6 workstations + uplink to 3' cable to
16 Port 10 base hub - 1 webcam + Uplink to
120' cable to
5 Port 10/100 switch - 3 workstations (farthest workstation is 40')

According to the 5-4-3 rule, I have too many sections, with too many of them populated. The network still runs, but I get unreliable bandwidth now.

I feel that I should replace the 8 Port 10/100 and the 16 Port 10 base hub with a single 16 port 10/100 Switch. This should put me back into the proper design.

Is this correct?

5 replies

by jschein

only use hubs for network printers and a location where possibly a laptop would need to hook up.

Your server should be directly hooked into a switch - nothing else.

*Switches have the same bandwidth across the board.

*Hubs share the bandwith such as a cable modem shares with 800 people in the area...

If any of your high end systems or servers are running off a hub, your net speed on your system will dramatically drop.

good luck.

by wroming

In my opinion HUBS should never be used and unless you can give a switch a IP it is really not a switch. Because an unmanaged switch works a lot like a hub. Also the cable lenths you have for the type setup is WAY TO LONG. My suggestion would be to run cables to where ever you need network connectivity and not exceeding 100m rule including patch cords and then just have a centralized switch that away you have less congestion on your network. Hope this helps and have a great day.

This discussion is closed to new replies.