Discussion Locked

A challenge to the Linux Users of the World

0 helpful
242 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

242 replies

by xwindowsjunkie

then the Microshafties seem to want to believe.

I wouldn't wish Exchange Server of any variety on anyone. Ex 5.5 was bad enough and that was long before the idea of a "collaboration" server got grafted onto Exchange!

A long time ago I tried a 120 day "drop-dead " demo disk for Small Business Server and tried using Exchange as a "family email server". It was a pain in the posterior, all I ended up doing was "bringing my work home" since I was also running an Exchange Server at work.

There are a number of Linux email packages, some of them more than adequate to serve as a personal or family email server. Although the plan at first is not to implement an email termination or congregating server on my version of a Linux based Home Server, that's an obvious extension especially for multiple accounts for multiple users in the family. That becomes even more useful when you can add filtering and spam rejection packages that are not Windows based.

by neon samurai

One of my wishlist items is building a central mail/contacts/calendars/tasks server for the family; we all work off one calendar and can access it indavidually through any machine in the house.

If I was still working for an MCSP I'd be running Exchange at home for education but I don't have that lovely binder of install disks or the license costs associated with a baught copy. (I'm out of highschool, the illicit suppy channels are no longer acceptable.)

Back to the topic though, what are your ideas about setup of a Exchange Server functions? Any ideas on how to cover off the four data types in one location? It would have to support *nix, osX and Windows based clients. Ideally, palmOS also.

I started looking at openXchange but wasn't motivated to go through the compile on my clean work station just to test it out. It's about time I cut a custom VM to check it out though. Any other big name competitors to Exchange seem to include enterprise pricing; my issue isn't paying for software, it's paying an enterprise fee for home users.

by xwindowsjunkie

There are alternative MAIL servers. But the other functions might have to be pieced together.

Evolution is an email client for Exchange server. It started out as Ximian and they were going to release an open source Exchange-like server. I do not know where that project went . But there is likely something else out there that should work.

My experience was that Exchange was way-over-kill for home use. For collaborative calenders have you thought of just using a spread sheet with 31 sheets. Time on the left hand side, Family member's names in the columns?

Make a template with thirty one sheets, one for each day of the month. Nice thing about using the spreadsheet, size of rows and columns can be changed to allow more detail if necessary.

Notes can be passed back and forth using a Wiki or a blog

by doug

I really disagree. I use Exchange at home more than I do at work. My cell phone numbers are in it, I have reminders scheduled sometimes a year in the advance. I have e-mails from several domains feeding into it.

And I've heard this overkill idea before, it doesn't make a lot of sense to me. Exchange takes about a week to setup, working maybe a half hour a day or so. That's not bad for a hobby. After that it's painless. I haven't been in my Exchange server for years.

The thing is, I want to be doing more at home than at work. I'm not the Microsoft guy at work responsible for Exchange. But as the senor IT guy it really impresses people that I know my way around it.

That's the thing. I don't want to be messing with less than business quality software at home. I want at least the chance that something I learned at home benefited my professional life.

by apotheon

"[i]And I've heard this overkill idea before, it doesn't make a lot of sense to me. Exchange takes about a week to setup, working maybe a half hour a day or so. That's not bad for a hobby.[/i]"

By contrast, using the built-in MTA and calendar utility of a FreeBSD system, combined with about fifteen minutes of script and configuration setup, I get the functionality you described as taking a week at half an hour a day.

"[i]I haven't been in my Exchange server for years.[/i]"

I hope you at least install security patches. I'm sure you do -- but in case you don't, you might want to look into that.

"[i]I'm not the Microsoft guy at work responsible for Exchange. But as the senor IT guy it really impresses people that I know my way around it.[/i]"

That's easily the best justification I've ever heard for running Exchange at home. I find, in my life, that it's more valuable to know how to achieve functionality much like Exchange's with lighter-weight tools (preferably tools built into the base system) -- but obviously our career paths are somewhat different.

by grax

?Exchange takes about a week to setup, working maybe a half hour a day or so.?

Great, and you?re an IT Professional. What chance, Joe Public? That is the market for "Xwindowsjunkie Home Server". It clearly wouldn?t do for you. I dare say there would be ample scope to upgrade the basic Server should one wish to.

by xwindowsjunkie

In the respect of an "educational" or as a professional SOHO system it makes sense. I used the 120 day demos to learn the systems for practically everything I got certified for. In that respect Microsoft is extremely intelligent about their system software.

I had Exchange 120 day demo disks for the system I ran at home. I made absolutely sure that whatever I learned at home, I tested more than twice at home before I modified the machine at work. I had to completely re-install Exchange Server more than once at home! I can't say that I was ever an expert on Exchange but I managed to get certs on all of the other major NT 4.0 and Win2K systems.

I finally got out of the IT business and moved back into engineering systems by changing companies! So I have made an extra effort to not let anybody know that I know that much about IT!

by neon samurai

I'm also not dealing with tech savvy family members. My wife won't use it unless she doesn't notice the difference between using iCal now and later with it feeding off a shared calendar. My little one will be fine but her days of computer use are still far off. My systems are where things get more complicated. Just supporting the *nix programs is easy but the challenge is syncronizing supported functions across *nix, Windows and PalmOS (PalmOS currenly needing a second tier sync from Outlook once it's synced to the central calendar).

I think the server component of the Evolution is one of Novell's retail packages so it falls outside my budget like an Exchange license. Either would be overkill for some homes but they'd make use seamless for the other family members and have better luck supporting whatever crazy puzzle I take interest in.

by neon samurai

I just glanced down the feature list but I'll give the website a more detailed read after work and let you know what further I find.

by xwindowsjunkie

Since I don't make money working on Linux, I've gotten into a bit of a time crunch and so I apologize for my update delays.

Bacula has such an attractive feature set I think I'm going to break my own word and build it. I found a couple of Help pages that will certainly make the process a lot more painless.

HOWEVER, this isn't the method the typical USER is going to be able to handle. I'm not going to expect everybody to whip out their C, or C++ compiler and build an application for their own installation!

If I can believe what I read on the Windows Home Server website, RC1 has been released and I didn't make the cut for the release. So I'll be building the Linux Home Server without a Microsoft product to compare it to. I'll check with the guys at work and see if any of them got into the WHS RC1 or beta program.

In any case the comparison really isn't that much of an issue now since it seems as if it will be a lot more interesting to combine Linux applications together instead.

More to come!

by apotheon

There's a GUI Bacula management interface built using the wxWidgets graphical toolkit that runs in both X Window System and MS Windows Explorer environments. You might find it's an effective backup tool for end-users after all. It's also available both through the ports tree of FreeBSD and the APT archives of Debian, so no manual source code wrangling needs to happen to get it installed on the server. [url=http://www.bacula.org/dev-manual/Windows_Version_Bacula.html][b]Here[/b][/url] is some information on the MS Windows installer for the client software, too.

disclaimer: I've never used the graphical management interface. I have no idea how it works, or how easy it is to use without shooting yourself in the foot. I'm just pointing out the possibility of it being exactly what you need.

by doug

When I installed my SuSE server I fet the same way about installing the C compiler that you do. Who wants to mess with that?

However, it seems the compiling applications is a fact of life in the Linux world. Very little seems to want to install without running make. One of the reasons I'm building a new Linux server is to install the compiler and make sure I'm set up to recompile the kernel when needed.

by dumphrey

The whole point of this process, as I see it, is to develope a working platform with the correct services installed and configed. Once that is complete, creating the appropriate install routine can be accomplished by another interested party that may have more knowledge of the process. I envision this similar to creating a custom live cd from an existing linux install.

So, from an end user point of view, the server should be installed, and a script auto run to fill in appropriate config info, and then its all done. All thats left is to run security patches as they appear (kernel updates should be avoided so as to not break any thing). Once set up, there should be no real need for most end users to compile. But, untill that unified install process, custom compiles will be a normal state for any multi-purpose server.

by neon samurai

That's the good stuff. I don't look for things to compile from source but I do like to specify my processor in the kernel then boot the custome compile.

So far I've only needed gcc, make and the kernel source/kernel header packages installed. gcc and make both include there own dependencies handled by the package manager. It should also go in easy as an add-on rather than rebuilding your system just for that function; I'm not sure what distro your using though so it may be different.

by apotheon

"[i]However, it seems the compiling applications is a fact of life in the Linux world. Very little seems to want to install without running make.[/i]"

I spent several years using Linux systems with only one occasion where I needed to compile something I hadn't written myself to install it. That includes kernels -- never had to compile a kernel for Linux.

What are you doing wrong that causes you to have to compile stuff all the time?

by jaytmoon

Just a little update, WHS RC is available as a public down load right now. Just fill out the "request" form for a valid Key, then dl the files. The only down side is the release is good till december '07, then ends. I gues MS will be releasing a retail ver by then.

by xwindowsjunkie

The underlying OS looks to be Debian 4.0.

At this point it looks like the major server applications I will be using will include:

Bacula -- for system backups, incremental backups and bare metal restores

Samba -- obviously for Windows compatibility. But not so obvious, operate it in Domain Controller mode for both Windows and Linux logon account control eliminating the need for a Win2K3 Server.

Apache, obvious choice.

MySql, again, it seems as if 90% of the applications out there need this as a dependency.

GNU C, C++ compilers

FireFox 2.0x for the web browser interface. It has an especially consistent appearance across both Linux and Windows desktops.

A DNS tertiary server coupled with a DHCP server, no choices here yet. Samba offers a DHCP service coupled with a WINS server (a good thing to have for Windows boxes) that might become the defacto DHCP service.

LDAP, I'm not completely convinced that I need this service in a small network. It might come up as a dependency at some point.

Some sort of Digital Video Recorder package with a video capture card will be a secondary upgrade item. Although it might be cheaper to buy a a DVD player with a digital output port on it instead and just use it to feed digital video to the hard drive.

I personally think that that Remote Access from an Internet location into the home network desktops is asking for trouble. I will not implement that on the first iteration of the system. Likewise serving digital media files to the Internet is again asking for trouble. DMZ's were made for these situations. I can't see most home owners wanting to invite worldwide hackers into their home virtually.

Using Kerberos, RADIUS and VPN technology for remote access and/or control is a possibility.

I can see it setup to download RSS, email, news feeds from specific sites, weather maps and forecasts from weather services, traffic updates etc.

MythTV is definitely going to be a project for the future and most likely on another computer.

by apotheon

I tend to wonder how Microsoft thinks that's going to work, anyway. Internet bandwidth is far from limitless, and can get downright scarce depending on where you're connected. I'd love to see the looks on some Home Server users' faces the first time they have to wait more than two minutes for Internet Explorer to render when opened remotely.

by doug

To me remote access is one of the most important functions of a home server. Right now I am posting this from my home server that I am terminal served into from work.

I want to keep everything in one spot, on my home server. Whereever I am, I can start RDP, go to my home server, and do programming, e-mail, word processing, or whatever. I don't want to have to lug around a huge powerful laptop that can run a java IDE, or install all my apps on two or three computers so I can keep up with work at different locations.

Right now I have 20 users at another office running all their apps thru RDP over a T1 line. That's 1.5 megabyte. Almost everyone nowadays has a line that fast running into their home.

by apotheon

There's a metric arseload of web-based open source "groupware" software out there. If your users are as happy with web-based email as with POP or IMAP email, you might consider looking into those options. They're pretty much all written in PHP and use MySQL on the back end, which has its ups and its downs of course, and tend to be a breeze to work with. Things like more.groupware, eGroupWare, and phpGroupWare come to mind (two of which are available on Debian, all three on FreeBSD, in the software management archives of the respective systems).

For a more traditional (non-web-centric) server setup, options like Kolab are out there, too. You can also roll your own solution pretty easily, often requiring nothing more than base system services and utilities plus a few glue-code scripts. Servers like OpenXchange are only necessary if you actually need Exchange compatibility.

Anyway, I guess the moral of the story is that your options are nearly endless, especially if you don't specifically need Exchange compatibility.

by neon samurai

It was an accidental discovery while seeing if my distro included OpenGroupware. The project website claims that eGroupware will also support sync with iCal and other client applications. I'll get a test system running as a browser interface then start branching out to the specific client apps we use at home.

Mysql is killing me though. I started fighting with it two weeks back while rebuilding my "toolbox" machine and including the latest msf. msf runs fine except for returning obscure errors when trying to read/write through db_mysql. Now with trying to get eGroupware working, I'm able to see a more descriptive error telling me "1001 can not connect. Please confirm if server is running." (or something similar anyhow)

This is pretty much the same post as moments ago in this same thread but after three weeks, I have some ill will towards Mysql, Postgresl and sqlite; all of which seem to install but don't actualy talk to anything trying to use them.

I guess Mysql is the one to pick out of the bunch. Now to spend a romantic evening with google and the search term "mandriva 2007.1 mysql setup"

by dumphrey

"Exchange takes about a week to setup, working maybe a half hour a day or so"

Why? are you compiling it from scratch?

I know Exchange is not the most reliable program in the world, but if your AD domaine and dns are in order, exchange installs pretty much in about 45 min. Setting it up properly can take a few hours to a few days depending on the complexity....

Now, a multi tiered system with many front end servers and a back end cluster could take a week....

But either way, exchange has to have AD, which means a home domaine, which means windows server. Massive overkill for a semi-stable program.

by dumphrey

"over a T1 line. That's 1.5 megabyte. Almost everyone nowadays has a line that fast running into their home."

T1 is a synchronous connection. 90% or more of home connections are asynchronous, and as such, tend to bog down badly if you have many out going connections.

Example. I have 5 mbps cable at home, but thats download, it only has 256 kbps upload, only enough for e-mail and conrol info for tcp/ip really. The 5 mbps download speed is a total gimmick, as you can never get a single file to download at that speed, and with the upload speeds caped, your control info gets choked out on multi-user, multi-process uploads such as p2p, web servers etc. On a normal day, I can brows the net nice and quick. If I set up a bittorrent download, caped at 45kbps up, 200 kbps down, no more the 200 connections, and let er rip, if I check my rouer, it still has 60% of its ram free, and is only using about 20% of its processor. So, the router is not the choke point. I attempt to browse the net, and google takes 30 sec to load, my upstream bandwidth was choked off. i can do the same experiment at work, and it does not slow down my web browsing at all. Cable vs T1. Now all this is just my experience, but it seems to play out with others I have talked to as well.

by doug

Well, cable sucks. That's why I use DSL. :)

RDP doesn't use much bandwidth, tho. The 256K upload speed on your cable would be plenty of bandwidth for terminal server.

Again, I'm using it right now. I like to keep all my stuff in one place. I really consider remote access essential to a home server.

by w2ktechman

I like cable Internet. Although the more people on the line causes more slowness.
It used to be faster on average than it is now though. When hardly anyone around me used it. Now everyone does, and although the bandwidth has increased twice and is 4x faster than it was, I suffer from bad performance at certain times in the day.

But, overall it is usually much faster than the current DSL offerings in my area last time I checked.

by now left tr

My home connection has an advertised download speed of around 20Mbps (only goes 16-18) and an upload speed of 768Kbs (only goes around 600)!

by neon samurai

I keep a VM build as close to my native boot install for the same reason. If I make a change, update the system or install some bit of software I'm curious about and it doesn't break the VM and is what I need then it goes onto the native host OS; I refresh to previous snapshot on the VM if it doesn't leaving test and live systems ready for the next experiment.

by neon samurai

First thing I did after getting home yesterday was cut a VM for a specialized server build. Before downloading the RPMs, I checked the Mandriva package manager and didn't find openGroupware but it does come with eGroupware.

I'll give eGroupware a go and let you know how it is. I'm checking it out first since it's already vetted and included in the distro but I won't have any hesitation about scrubbing it and downloading OpenGroupware or cutting an OpenGroupware VM for comparison.

So far my issue is Mysql not accepting connections. A howto I stumbled across says:

urpmi mysql
services mysqld start
mysql -U username databaseserver

.. and I get "error 1001, can not connect to database server"

BAH! So tonight will be learning how to install a mysql server unless someone out there has ten steps or less for installing Mysql on Mandriva 2007.1

Once Mysql is working I can go through the config setup for eGroupware and actually see what it does. At present, I can only confirm that the PHP runs clean within the httpd deamon.

by apotheon

Of course, I'm using SSH for a remote console, not trying to run GUI apps over the Internet. Holy crap, a 256K upstream cap for GUI desktop remote access over the Internet would be like bamboo shoots under the fingernails.

by sepius

I use webmin on all my systems, and one over the DMZ for remote administration. I always use a different admin account on the webmin to add some security, but I have not been hacked in years. The other reason I use it is so I dont need a monitor on the system once its set and running.
I have used VNC over dialup and on 256ADSL. not really much point doing that actually as webmin will cover most admin, but possible.
I strongly recomend it.

by apotheon

I was speaking of remote access to applications on desktop machines and the like, though -- not just sysadmin capabilities.

by doug

Microsoft's terminal services has no problem running GUI apps over 256k lines. Why should Linux be any different?

A lot of people like VNC. I'm convinced, tho, that I should be able to run X-windows over the NET. Cygwin seems a bit slow over low speed connections, so I'm trying to get NX installed.

http://www.nomachine.com/developers.php

by apotheon

"[i]Microsoft's terminal services has no problem running GUI apps over 256k lines. Why should Linux be any different?[/i]"

It's not any different -- and if you've never had any problems running GUI apps over 256k advertised speed upstream across the Internet, you're either absurdly lucky, very inexperienced with running GUI apps over 256k advertised speed upstream across the Internet, or lying -- especially with MS Windows.

by danlm

I never have had experience with DSL, but I've talked to enough people that don't like it. Cox cable treats me right, and they have some nice bundle packages.

Other then right after work when I get home, I really notice no slow downs. I have never had a 30 second delay on a web page unless the page was hosted by a crap server. Well, thats not true. hehehehe, TR sucks some days. But everyone complains also, so I know its not my connection.

Dan

by w2ktechman

for a few hours after work, it is usually slow. I mean really slow sometimes. But I am usually outside and/or doing something else anyway. later in the eve, like when I come in it is usually fine.
And no, I have no intention of downgrading to DSL either. Comcast works fine for me (but it is expensive).

by xwindowsjunkie

From the wonders never cease department...

Got home today and found an email in my box from the Gorilla in Redmond telling me that I was one of the select few tens or hundreds of thousands that are allowed to test RC1 of Windows Home Server.

Guess they called my bluff, or similar sorts of mutterings. Yes I downloaded it and all the other bits and pieces so NOW I have to test it even if I was beginning to really not want to.

In any case it will be interesting to see what happens. From the propaganda on the download site it looks like the feature set isn't much different from what I skimmed out of the advertising chum on the WHS website.

Day at work was a killer, put in 12 hours, some of it spent teaching screwdriver jockies which is a lot harder than it seems.

I'll get a fresh start tomorrow night and will report if the ISO was actually possible to burn onto DVD, yes it was at least i GB of ISO with 2 other smaller isos for 300 and I think about 30 MB. So it will be a hot time with NERO tomorrow night. BCENU ( Think The Prisoner!)

by xwindowsjunkie

Well it looks as if everything for Windows Home Server RC1 got burned onto DVD-R and CD-R's OK. Discs are all readable.

Then I realized that my Celeron test machine doesn't have a DVD reader! Now I have a bit of a reason to delay the inevitable for a while longer.

Yes that's right, the WHS RC1 was a DOWNLOAD! (Gee I wonder where they got that idea?) I think that this is a first for MS. It is NOT available on disks for order, at least that I was able to determine. The ISO for the install on the server is a DVD image a little over 1.1GB. No there weren't options for a couple of CD-ISOs instead.

A second ISO of about 296 MB is a Windows bare metal restore disk that probably loads Windows PE (Pre-install Environment, fancy name for No-GUI Windows) and talks sweet to the established WHS and restores the current backup image from there.

Finally the third ISO was a 37 MB image of a "Connector" installation disk that you would use to set the Windows' ONLY client systems up to connect to the local WHS. This method has been often used in the past for installing Exchange server clients, Proxy Server, ISA clients, and Active Directory installs on NT 4.0 workstations and Win9X clients of an Active Directory Domain. You'll notice that most of the products I mentioned are all before "push-technologies" that Microsoft has produced in the past.

Remote Terminal Services would be an ideal means to make this work. But I'm willing to bet that the default security settings of SP2 and the hundreds of quick fixes since then probably won't allow MS' Terminal Service to work at installing the software.

Trying to keep it all in the family, I downloaded it to my Windows XP SP2+ system. I used Nero and followed the advice given me on the website specifically about Nero so I shouldn't have any issues there. The test drives I will be using all comply with the recommended sizes and with the 512 MB RAM I'm ok there as well.

I haven't tried installing the ISOs yet and I will wait until I'm able to do it with a DVD burner installed in the Celeron test machine. I'm very loathe to give up my Little Debby Linux box though (currently running on the same Celeron) so I think I will resurrect my old 1.8 GHz P4 and do an Debian 4.0 install on that one so I can keep learning more about Debian even as I'm testing the 2 Home Server installs.

Setting up the Debian client will give me 2 different Linux clients (the other is SUSE 10.2) to connect to both types of Home Servers and that might be instructive as well. If I see any significant differences in performance I might try using Ubuntu and Fedora since I have current ISO releases of those as well.

I do have another XP Pro client and a Win2K Pro client (my kids machines) so there will be plenty of clients to beat on both HServers.

Having dual-booted Linux and Windows using GRUB before, I do not see much of an issue of doing that on my Celeron test box for the 2 Home Server installs. That should allow me to try the same functions almost back-to-back after rebooting from one server to the other. It will also give me a good idea what will happen when the client suddenly experiences the server going off-line!

More to come.

by cactus pete

Sounds like you're just about done with your experiment, but if you want to retry after having some experience, or want to test on one of your other boxes...

I didn't read ALL the posts, so I don't know what all was suggested... here are a few things I've used in that past, in which you may be interested:

Freevo
MythTv (favored)
bacula

I'll add more after I have some time to digest your ... ample writing.

by xwindowsjunkie

Yes I tend to run at the mouth as well. I've done a lot of teaching and manual writing at work because I don't like taking service calls from our field techs in the middle of the night. My first question is: "Did you read the manual?" If they tell me that they haven't read the manual, I hang up on them. That usually gets the point across. We publish all of our service manuals on a website that they can reach from anyplace in the world with an Internet connection.

I'm finding out that I've just begun my Linux Home Server experiment. Just got the competition's (Windows Home Server) RC1 disks burned last night. In between errands today I'll be bringing up Billyboy (WHS) and then cloning Debra (Little Debbie, Debian 4.0) into another partition on the same drive. Assuming I don't screw things up, by late Sunday I should have a dual booting Linux/Windows Home Server system. I'm hoping that this will allow me to do semi-side-by-side comparison tests on the same hardware. That's when I'm hoping the fun really starts.

by apotheon

"[i]In between errands today I'll be bringing up Billyboy (WHS) and then cloning Debra (Little Debbie, Debian 4.0) into another partition on the same drive. Assuming I don't screw things up, by late Sunday I should have a dual booting Linux/Windows Home Server system.[/i]"

Are you going to call the whole setup [url=http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0075296/][b]Sybil[/b][/url]?

by apotheon

. . . and thus remember these things.

Don't ask what I had for lunch yesterday, though. I don't recall.

by xwindowsjunkie

I haven't seen Pirates3 but in Pirates 2 I remember a critter called the Kraken, a octopus/squid thing that devoured entire ships. OK, imagine a computer's hard drives being ships. The Kraken in the WHShip eats all of the ships and you have to have one that's as big as 65 really Big Guns or the Kraken stalls. What's interesting though is that if the ships are flying the Penguin flag, it can't do anything to the ship, not even wipe it off the ocean!

Sure glad I didn't plan to do anything meaningful this weekend. The Kraken reports he'll be done in 51 minutes but 10 minutes ago, he reported he would be done in 52 minutes. Its definitely a Beta, its got nothing but 50% gray backgrounds (for at least half the time) no attempt at wowing you with pretty wallpaper or color washes.

Kraken says he's only 4 years old and that he has a much bigger brother. He kind of surprised me. He burped twice and then came back flying a much prettier flag but then he said he be done in 39 minutes. I've seen that before many times and I didn't believe it then either!

Kraken's watch isn't a very good one. He thought I wasn't watching when he jumped from 32 minutes to 25 minutes till he's done. What's also very odd is that he keeps saying the exact same 6 or 7 things over and over again. Some of his older siblings have at least 15 to 20 different things to say over and over. He has also been a little confused because he tells me he's one thing then he tells me he's something else. He's kind of a patchwork critter.

He still keeps telling me he's 4 years old but then he decides to tell me he's brand new. hmmmm. But I saw some free stuff being flashed on the the little windows that all ended in 6 instead of 7.

Well Kraken took 1 hour 25 minutes to finish belching and burping. I lost count at 7 or 8 burps. He tells me I have 30 days to turn the key in Davy Jones locker to get 180 days of uninterrupted action. Feels like I'm running an XBOX360 demo game. yipee.

UPDATE am 6-17-2007

Kraken didn't find the 4 year old NIC. Winsta Beta and RC1 did though! We're talking [u]OLD[/u] stuff here. Pretty desktop though, nice integrated console. BUT outside of eating the entire "ship", Kraken can't do anything since he can't hear or talk!!! No wonder the sniffer never caught a whiff of fish. To ripoff Harlan Ellison, "he has no mouth and he must scream!" Big Whoops for the Redmond Gorilla. This little baby Kraken is not ready for the consumer masses, its a geek-toy.

By the way, Kraken's wristwatch is really dumb. Date and Time came up all messed up, looks like it grabbed clock time of build compiler to start the clock.

Kraken also had to run out a moldy fishNET, and like always it took half an hour to self-compile, really annoying. I have a sneaking suspicion that when I fix Kraken's ears and mouth, Kraken and the Gorilla will have a long talk and the old stuff might magically disappear.

by grax

?I haven't seen Pirates3 but in Pirates 2 I remember a critter called the Kraken, a octopus/squid thing that devoured entire ships.?

The tentacled Sea Monster is a very old myth, particularly in Norse mythology, that must have originated with the very real Giant Squid. The beast was resurrected by Jules Verne in his story ?Twenty Thousand Leagues under the Sea? and has been much abused since.

Kraken comes from old German and means an octopus. Linnaeus includes it in his early work (1735). Perhaps the most famous modern use of the name was in John Wyndham?s story ?The Kraken Awakes.? (He?s better known for inventing Triffids.)

So, does one really want to call the beast ?Kraken?? I prefer ?Sybil?; originally a Greek oracle (soothsayer) but now, more associated with multiple personalities, thanks to that film. On that basis it probably isn?t suitable and you might see this whole project as a monster of your own creation.

Alternatively, try ?Sophia?; Greek for Wisdom!

Plenty more to choose from. Must give the "thing" a name.

by xwindowsjunkie

I wasn't given a chance to name the beast so Kraken it is. If I can find a way to rename him I will.

Tomorrow Little Debbie gets a new sister. I'm going to do a new install of Debian 4.0 and this time do it from the CD stack I accumulated when I downloaded and installed all 21 CD ISOs of Debian. I will install just the applications I want with the required dependencies.

My plan is to gleefully wipe the hard drive that Wista RC1 was installed on. What a piece of crap. I got so damn mad at it after an hour trying to do ordinary things, I decided right then that Redmond could take Wista and shove it up their Kraken-hole. I hated that OS even more than I hated XP when it came out. BUT XP at least could be set to "emulate" Win2K. That was NOT an option in Wista, at least in the copy of RC1 I got.

This time zone is in the deep darkness and I really do need to get to bed.

by apotheon

If it's going to have WHS on it, you might want to go with Cassandra -- prescient, but nobody believed a word she said.

by xwindowsjunkie

so much of it is under water where you can't see it! Actually for a consumer that's good. Because if s/he sees it, s/he might mess with it and things get really messy. Having had to design system images for oilfield personnel with, amazingly, a lot of time on their hands, I can appreciate what they did. The roughnecks and drillers like to poke at all the buttons and things to see what they will do. Not good to do on Windows AnyVersion since you practically have to run it all the time in Admin mode!

by sepius

Some time back, webmin supported running VNC from the browser, I used it heaps, impressed many with full web access to remote machines, but in the last few versions webmin have since dropped this. I have not really been that stressed by the omission, I use VNC on all my systems have done for around 6 years i guess. My media centre has it and it is used for music, vids and Azuareus (or however it is spelled). I used to run 3 clients on the old dual 450, but have moved on from there.
Oh and in case you are wondering, I use VNC because it is cross platform, My partner and daughter can use it on either a Linux box or Windows, so just one thing to teach.
I would prefer to do all from the browser, but I have other interests now and have not really pushed to find a remote GUI client that runs from the browser that is not MS.

by grax

From recent posts it seems clear that anything with WHS(Beta) on it will be a ?Kraken?. It sounds just like a slimy tentacled monster. Perhaps we could use ?Cassandra? for when Microsoft come up with a commercially viable offering?

My suggestions were intended to refer to the finished Linux Home Server. Can?t call it LHS can we? The only names I could find with all three letters are ?Ashley? and ?Shirley?. After that I couldn?t be bothered.

Following the Greek idea stream; how about Pandora, the ?All Gifted?? I know she?s suffered a bad press with that box business but she does have an alternative, little known name:
Anesidora, "the one who sends up gifts".

Now that?s a fair description of what LHS is supposed to do but I do think ?Anesidora? is a bit of a mouthful.The diminutive, however, is ?Dora? in all its many variations.

by richard_p

Probably not; Pandora's box contained all the ills of the world, but it also contained hope.

Perhaps Arachne ... started out as a weaver of brilliant things and turned into a monster.

by xwindowsjunkie

Well Debbie's big (but younger twin
) sister is up and running. And I'm sorry to say that it actually took twice as long to install compared to Kraken. But that included a lot of time shuffling Debian Binary CDs around. Yes in case you missed it, I downloaded and burned ALL 21 CD's of the Debian disk family.

WOW what a load!

Yes before you guys jump my back and tell me that I could have downloaded just one disk etc etc.

I wanted to have the entire distribution at my beck and call in case the DSL line trashed out and it has on very few ocassions. Its probably the only thing good about having a PHONE company deliver your data stream. They DO know how to keep the damn thing up and running even in monsoon season. Something that the TV cable ninnies (idiots etc, you catch my drift) haven't a clue about. Not to mention that the cable idiots don't seem to understand the technology of a yardgate. Thank goodness my dogs are smarter than the normal cable idiot and stay home even when the idiots leave the gate open. (Sorry, had to get that out. Its been caught down there for awhile!)

Debbie the server got installed COMPLETELY without straying from the yard so to speak. Everything I wanted to put on the Linux Home Server was already available in the Debian 4.0 distro. WOW! I love it! Eat Plankton Kraken!

I also played around with IceWeasel (FireFox for Debians) I would have called it SnowFox. There is a breed of Fox called Snow Fox that start out red and brown during the summer and then turn white as snow during the winter. They are really inoffensive and small critters that live above the Arctic circle. They seem to thrive in places larger (think software bloat) creatures don't exist.

The one piece of software I know and love completely in the Linux repretory is Samba. I didn't have to do a thing to make it work but type my user name and password that I use on the remote (next to it in the desk) Windows box.

Now comes my BIG disappointment with Linux, MySql. I am NOT a database geek, never have been, don't see much reason to be and hope I never have to turn into one. I will write VB.NET programs before writing SQL queries! Here's where Linux fans need to do some work. Like in the Windows world, SQL Servers are taking over everything. I discovered that ALL of the applications I wanted to add used MySql except for SAMBA.

The problem is that all of the other apps had to have MySql not only installed BUT also RUNNING. Whats with that? How about a method to run a script after an event occurs like MySql gets up and running OR do a check to see if MySql IS RUNNING before you try to install?

I said I would be evaluating this whole process from a USER viewpoint. Please don't write me flamemail. The next step is to figure out what I F'edup and learn how to fix it so I can get on with the whole thing. I wil be RTFMing it for awhile. Then later I will try to see if I can sequence the build so that MySql gets installed before most everything else that seems to depend on it.

Update follows:

OK I found a PDF that is helping somewhat. I managed to get access to my own MySql server. Always nice when the software you installed lets you run it. Something that's not always a given on the other side of the software world.

The Big Gorilla does not have a twitch (nose-clamp for horses, used to keep them focused on what's going on in front, not in back where a guy with a hammer is pounding on their hooves) on the obtuse manual market. But it might be me. I have studiously stayed away from SQL Servers as much as possible. I use them only when I have to. SO the fact that I can read the words and still not a freaking clue what they are really talking about could actually be my fault. I'll be poking at it.

I think I have Bacula installed but I'm not sure.

More to come

by apotheon

"[i]I said I would be evaluating this whole process from a USER viewpoint. Please don't write me flamemail.[/i]"

No worries on that score where I'm concerned -- I, too, think the state of databases in the open source world is suboptimal. Of course, it's simply atrocious [b]everywhere[/b], not just in open source software. Some databases, you have to be insane to use (if you know anything at all about database technology). Some, you have to be some kind of minor expert just to get working. The remaining minority of them, you don't actually use at all -- you pay someone else tens of thousands of dollars to use it for you.

by sepius

Impressive ... I could only get MySQL started via webmin, thats how narrow I have become. I dont have a clue about running it any other way, and I like command line stuff! Yeah ... open stuff is a bit raw, but you can do what ever you like with it (and charge $$$$ for it). Have to admit though, my favorite DB ever, was one that came with MS works 3.0 for windows 3.1, I had a list of home brew recipes with grading on quality and critics notes (when friends tried it), my tape and vinyl collection, and it took very little time to set up. How embarrassing to admit that ....

by neon samurai

After some learning I've got Apache working with MySQL; or atleast the eGroupware part of it (my past DB experience is Access and MS SQL Server which doesn't really count). I still can't get any joy from MSF or even gmysqlcc. On this hobby project, I now have to setup a pop mail deamon; any suggestions? I thought Postfix was only the smtp portion of the server; either way, it?s not in eGroupware?s list of recommended pop servers.

MSF (for ethical use before anyone get's uppity) still gives errors when I try a db_create so I need to do some searching for a more detailed howto on that. Postgres and sqlite give the same issues but I?ve settled on MySQL since it?s what I have for a backend on other systems.

gMySQLcc confounds me outright. It?s a GUI front end for managing DB, you?d think that its rpm install would be configured to access properly. It?s a smaller priority though, if I learn MySQL through the minimalist client included with it then I?ll likely understand the issue with the GUI front end client.

Databases sure are an area that things are lacking but as you point out; that?s not just FOSS, DB everywhere are a mess. Heck, SQL isn?t even standard across databases; it?s like the java of the DB world because everyone has there own flavor.

by doug

I'm using SuSE 9.3 right now, but a lot of the stuff I wanted to install won't because I didn't install the gcc compiler.

One of the reasons I'm setting up another Linux box is to make sure I install all the compiling software so I can get the applications I need to run. The two main ones I'm having problems with are Truecrypt and NTX, for remote access.

by neon samurai

Especially with Suse, you should be able to simply install gcc through the applicable package manager without need to scrub and build from scratch. I'm not discouraging a reinstall for fun as I learn something new every time but if it's just gcc you need then see if you can simply add it through the package manager in either GUI or command prompt. It could save you a half day if installing from scratch isn't fun for you.

Example:

I reinstalled my desktop after Mandriva 2007.1 was released. As with every install, I put in only the minimum allowing my system to expand organically; needs and new needs get added in as discovered while "chaff" from the last install get's left out.

I'm installing the latest kernel package and VMware server package. This is when I discover that I've not yet installed gcc and the kernel headers. I pop open drakrpm (GUI rpm manager), select a few checkboxes and gcc is on the desktop with all dependencies. A moment after that, I'm recompiling my kernel; only because I specify my cpu type for whatever miniscule advantages it provides. After that, VMware installed clean including building all custom modules for my kernel.

Last night I sat down to watch a video only to find that I've not yet installed VLC since the last rebuild. This is my preferred program for video media so "urpmi vlc" at my closest terminal prompt and moments later, the video is playing.

Suse should be able to add any missing components in this same manner without requiring a system reinstall. I don?t know the personality traits of the Suse distribution specifically but there must be someone else reading who can give you the command line or five GUI steps to get gcc in place.

by doug

Well, it's encouraging that you've had no problems installing appliacations on Linux. I usually run into the "missing dependencies" bit, or when I run it it complains about missing something in the kernel.

But if you've figured it out I'm sure I can! :)

A critical aspect of moving my Windows 2003 server to Linux is rewriting my ASP pages to Java Studio Creator. So I'm afraid to recomplle the kernel on this machine, which would interfere with my rewrite. I'm actually planning on building up a new machine. I've got one specced out with 3ware raid for around 1200.

by doug

I had cable back when you could get fixed IP addresses from Cablevision. I then switched to DSL when Cablevision changed the infrastructure in some sort of corporate deal and the new equipment wouldn't allow fixed IP's.

I ended up prefering DSL. The speed is more regular, you're not sharing the line with everyone in the neighborhood. At time cable is much faster, but then other times it would bog down for hours.

by now left tr

using a windows GUI over a VPN from home in the past. Server end was on a 2Mbps leased line and the other my old 4Mbps Cable Broadband!!

MSTS has got better over the last few years however.

by neon samurai

Actually, I've eaten at least three distribution installs by not using the distro's perfered packages resulting in dependency hell. This was back before Red Hat pulled support for .mp3 and other "questionable" things out of the enterprise distribution.

"oh, program X needs static library Y to compile? Sure, I'll add that in. Oh, look, it broke all this other stuff that needed the previous version which was incompatible with this one. Guess it's time to format and start over."

Actually, this was what made me start downloading only src.rpm then compile the .rpm for isntall (rpm --rebuild). If it would build, I new I had the dependencies in place. I've stopped that for a number of reasons.

I've since prefered to stick with the distribution's perfered package type unless there is reason to do more. Even if an rpm is not included in the repositories, it'll likely pull any dependencies from the repositories.

by doug

With terminal services or a program like VNC, the gui desktop is actually running to on the server, not locally. So all that's getting transferred over the internet is the changed pixels on the screen. That's why it can fast on even slower internet connections.

With a VNC you're going to be loadling large files over the internet.

by neon samurai

Ah, that makes me a little more comfortable. MSF finds nothing to complain about on the inside of my network. Now to boot up my other VMs and see how the older OS rate.

Turns out it was missing dependencies rather than MySQL configuration issues. Ubuntu uses one packaging naming convention, Mandriva uses another. I'd post the detailed solution but this isn't really the place.

Just thought I'd post back as it wasn't the database this time.

by xwindowsjunkie

Microsoft has quite a way to go before their RC1 should be released to the general public. Please note that I reported that XP, 2 beta versions of Wista, and 3 or 4 versions of Linux all installed using that NIC with absolutely no problems. The linchpin to the entire system is the network port. If the Server can't talk or hear on the Ethernet port, what's the point?

As I reported earlier my install of Windows Home Server RC1 did not find and install the driver for the NIC. I went into the registry to see if it found the PnP ID string, I surmised that could not match the ID with anything in its database of drivers. I went to DELL's site and downloaded a 2003 dated driver and manually installed it. The DELL driver install package looked at the OS and wouldn't install it since it wasn't XP. I dropped the INF, the SYS and CAT files into the appropriate places and it worked just fine.

After that I went ahead and registered the install with the Gorilla and went to Windows Update and updated everything I could including Internet Exploder 6 to 7. Something that was interesting was that the IE6 install looked to have a considerably toughened-up bunch of settings but with the really annoying popup boxes it got old fast. I agree with MS that nobody should use IE6 or IE7 or any browser on a Server. The reason its there is because the management interface is handled with an IIS webserver.

I think I'm going to look at Debbie for a day or two to see if I can get more than the basic functionality going.

More to come......

by absolutely

I was likewise disappointed at first, but by the end of the process, prefer to start with a minimal, base system, and add each module individually, with the easier visibility to the "full menu" provided by Synaptic.

by xwindowsjunkie

When one of them is running, the other one is disconnected. I found that its easy to try out or focus on specific features of both systems by alternately connecting the drive with Kraken or Debbie on it and running some tests. Debbie is still running more than Kraken simply because I have a lot steeper learning curve with her than with the beast. His stuff I've seen a lot of already!

Been spending a lot of time reading on-line Debian manuals. Unfortunately a number of them are somewhat irrelevant to the current distribution. Debian Reference seems to have large chunks of fairly good info. I plan on finishing it today.

My Debian server has all of my selected applications with a few additional applications I didn't expect (OpenOffice Writer for one) but they don't seem to be much of an issue. All of the needed applications were a part of the Debian distro or the on-line apt-get system. In that regard -Excellent work! Debian-maniacs (or whatever you've decided to call yourselves!)

I'm still doing research on Debbie and Kraken. I found that the only way to use the backup facilities of either was to use an agent included with each of the respective backup aps that is installed on the target desktops. Windows Home Server (Kraken) uses a install module that can be installed ONLY on Windows boxes. Bacula on Debian has a similar method but has agents that can be installed on practically everything. Advantage -- Bacula.

Apache installed with no fuss whatsoever. In fact I had to pop open browsers on three or four different computers to believe how easy it was. Like nothing had to be done. I'll be checking out the configuration within this next week. Considering my history with IIS4, 5 & 6, advantage ? Apache, absolutely no question.

Ice Weasel, the Debian version of FireFox, works very well perhaps faster than the Windows version of FireFox. No Active X support (no popups!), two points for Ice Weasel. Able to use every FireFox extension, plugin and addon, another two points for Ice Weasel. I have been a fan of FireFox since .9 Beta. FireFox gets my vote and usage not only here but at work as Primary Browser. I especially like the fact that Microsoft has bowed to pressure and allows FireFox on most of MSDN to work properly. The only places I have to use Internet Exploder is on the Passport/Live/(whatever-the-hell-they're-calling-it-next-week) websites.

The GNU C, C++ compilers are installed, along with all of the samples, tutorials and docs I could find! I have no idea how to vote on these boys yet. The price was right. Visual Studio 2005's IDE is very attractive and easy to use. Its probably the best piece of software Microsoft has ever put out. Considering the idea was that I wouldn't get into to programming on this project, maybe I should ignore this issue.

DNS caching server, DHCP3 and letting Samba handle WINS. DNS cahing is working very nicely. I haven't starting running DHCP3 yet since my other Linux system is currently supplying IPs.

File Serving is a little bit different obviously since we are matching bananas and pears. (You expected me to use Apples and oranges?) On Kraken, the WHS sets up a workgroup with a set of shares with permissions divided up by users and/or groups. Logon security can be enabled with Kerberos, hashed or not Lan Manager or https. There might be more mechanisms, this was a quick first look. Files can also be set for local workgroup access with and without web serving access. Obviously any access on the Kraken from a Linux client will have to be through Samba client services on the Linux clients which handles Kerberos and Lan Manager, at least in the Debian distro it does. The Linux client's Samba logon will have to be programmed into the WHS as a valid client even for files marked as for Everyone. That is a side effect of dumping fast-user switching and enabling controlled shares on any Windows server or workstation, not unlike leaving security wide open on a bunch of Linux systems or running a workgroup of Win9X boxes (no they aren't EXACTLY the same but just somewhat similar(;-).

My previous experience with Windows says that file sharing with Kerberos enabled will not be really possible on Win9X clients, it will be difficult with Win NT 4.0 and OK with Win2K and XP. So with WHS operating as the server, the security options will require some compromises if the home clients aren't all XP or Vista. All of the above will operate properly as Lan Manager clients. However, ?Fast User Switching? can't be used on the XP Pro clients since it breaks the access to shares that are shared with anything other than simple Windows folder shares. Vista clients, who cares? I'm not paying for Vista anything after battling with Vista Beta and Vista RC1, forget it. In any case I would not expect something based on Windows 2003 Server to support those sorts of simple shares.

As you would expect with a Linux server, everything to be accessible by Windows clients has to be served by Samba. Since Samba now has the abilities to operate as a Domain controller in what would normally be a small workgroup, I'm going to take advantage of that to deal with the security issues for all the Windows and Linux clients that way. Samba, as long as you are using Lan Manager sorts of file sharing without Kerberos, will allow all Windows based clients to connect. The Linux clients will connect through the normal NFS. So I have to call this file serving function a tie until I can really exercise both systems.

The characteristics of both operating systems' methods of serving shares are similar. Folders on the WHS are not associated with a drive letter on the server just as the Linux filesystem does not use drive letters.*1 This is somewhat of a departure from traditional Windows file serving systems in the past. Its a sort of cross between the Distributed File System (DFS) and Active Directory ?containers? or Organizational Unit folders. The Windows users will see an Icon or object with a label that they can drag and drop a file or folder to put the media files or data files onto the server. In other words nothing Linux users haven't seen for years.

I'm going to have to do a bunch of testing to see which works better but just from looking at it, the windows clients (XP and Vista only) will have a real easy time connecting only to the WHS (Kraken). Whereas the Linux and ALL Windows clients will require a little fussing but it can be done easily enough so that scripting can automate the process fairly well on the Linux Home Server (Debbie) I suspect.

*1. Come on guys! Do you really think that hiding a drive partition with hda, or hdb is
fooling anybody? I agree that most users don't often need physical awareness of where or what is holding your data. But when the physical world slaps you into back into chaotic reality, when you're trying to fix a system with a dead drive and you can't remember which drive has hda or /home/username on it, it might be nice to know what PHYSICAL drive has what! I will eventually get used to it.

by neon samurai

c: "hda1"
d: "hda5"
n: "hdb1"

It'll get you used to the naming if it doesn't become a prefered habbit in general. I also use bin/ for .bat and single file win32 executables and lib/ for win32 programs that don't need to run a setup wizard though.

by xwindowsjunkie

Actually I had tried that already but in a timid, woosh kind of way. I named the second partitions on some of my drives at work hdb etc.But it was easier to just not do it. Kept me from trying to copy executable .exe files to/from Linux to/from Windows.

by doug

Well, not to step on your thread, but I
just had an interesting experience along
these lines.

Last Thursday my Windows 2003 server
started acting up. I tried to reboot it,
but the fan on the power supply had failed.
Rather than trying to fix it right away, I
decided to move to a Dell Poweredge I have.

So I decided to move to Linux. Since my
license to Microsoft products
expires next month, I had been planning on
moving to Linux anyway.

Over the weekend I got SuSE 10.2 installed,
and most of the basic services working.
Yesterday morning I got my email running,
and a few minutes ago I got remote access
running using freenx. I am posting this
from my home server I'm accessing from 20
miles away.

I'm currently quite pleased with the
change. It would have probably taken me
longer to get Exchange running, even tho
I've worked with it for years.

by neon samurai

With eGroupware, I now have an Exchange Server centralizing calendar/contacts/todo and email. osX iCal, Linux Korganizer and Windows Outlook all sync perfectly. Now to move some live test data to the server and see if I can get PalmOS connected also.

by xwindowsjunkie

I considered Exchange a big enough headache! Not only syncing a single application with multiple clients, now multiple OS apps with multiple clients.

Like I probably wrote earlier, glad I'm not in IT anymore!

by xwindowsjunkie

but I hadn't gotten to the point where I felt confortable with it before I felt like I should try something else.

I've been very pleased with the Debian distro/system so far.

by doug

I had lots of problems with SuSE 9.3, so I
almost went with Debian. I would have
except for the principal of trying to use
stuff at home that I might use in my
professional life.

I am very impressed, tho. It seems more
user friendly than windows, I love being
able to adjust font sizes.

And postfix+dovecote was much easier to get
running than exchange.

by danlm

I've been following the thread's off and on and no longer have a firm hand on where your at with your project.

I'm not sure what OS you decided to go with.

Remember seeing you wasn't real thrilled with Windows Home Server, and didn't think you could do a valid comparison.

What I'm interested in is your backup solution. What your using and how your using it. Curious about how you did remote access too..

I'm sorry I lost track, I get scattered brained sometimes and don't follow topics like I should. That, and I ended up starting a few projects of my own.
1). I'm rewriting my idiotblocker application. It's currently written in sh scripting for parsing my auth.log looking for brute force attempts and then feeding the ip's to a firewall table. Does a few other things also, but I know of some holes in it. So, I'm rewriting it in Perl so that it will be easier to manage modifications.
2). I've found how to monitor bandwidth with my firewall using labels and another application I want to write. I currently have a server that I rent which only provides me with overall bandwidth for the full server. But, I have 16 ip's on that server defined internally a config file(alias) level. I've been wanting to track bandwidth per ip/service for some time. This also will give me a chance to do some graphics with Perl which I haven't done to this point.
This will be my next project.

It's taken me some time to get pfctl firewall to where I want it(still not sure if I worked out the ftp issues), but this is a kick butt firewall that is well worth learning.

Oh well, hope your project is going well.

Dan

by xwindowsjunkie

Been spending a lot of time trying to get up to speed learning enough to figure out why the debian install went so well. I know that sounds idiotic but I need to learn a lot about different chunks of technology written by different groups of programmers. So its like learning a new language for each application.

For instance Apache 2.2 went in so fast and easy it works without absolutely no input necessary. I typed "localhost" into a webbrowser (Ice Weasel/Firefox) and I got a page "It works!" came back immediately and I'm going Huh? How did that happen? I have NEVER had such an easy install with Windows IIS anything!

I've figured out that Bacula didn't get installed right but I still haven't figured out what I screwed up. I'm fairly certain that something is missing since I get no information in process listings, boot logs etc. that its even on the system except that files are in the folders I would expect them to be. Before it will work though I need to understand more about Apache and MySql to really make Bacula work so I'm starting with them.

To be honest its going to take more time than I expected but it looks as if the payoff will be very well worth the effort.

Kraken the WHS beast works but its kludgy and works only with Windows XP and Vista (gag-gag!) so I consider it a fairly limited product.

by xwindowsjunkie

named Debbie & Kraken, Like the Wolf and the Falcon.

I sort of summarize where I was about 3 days ago. What still amazes me was that I was able to install all of my selected options from the Debian website and I didn't have to modify or fiddle with installs.

It cracks me up that Debain, XP and Vista RC1 all installed without any issues but the WHS croaked and couldn't install the network interface

by dumphrey

Since Debian, XP, and Vista are all desktop machines with big driver databases. WHS is based off of the Server 2003 code, so if the netcard is supported there, then it SHOULD work in WHS, but no promises.

by dumphrey

use Debian in your professional life? I mean, the joke is that Debain will move new packages to "stable" "any decade now". Debian is more then ready for enterprise use, you just can't pay them for support.

by doug

The first thing a boss or executive is
going to ask is what kind of support does
the software company give. It's their neck
on the line as well as yours.

SuSE could really take off, Novell is well
known as a server OS company in a lot of
places.

by dumphrey

agree whith your post. But, Debian is as stable or more stable then the Enterprse distros. And, apt is so dern convenient. As for Novell takeing off, I think they have had their chance. At this point its more about increasing a tiny portion of market share then anything else. They have several strikes against them: 1) Linux people do not trust them after the MS deal. 2) MS people would prefer to just use MS. and 3)Novell people prefer Novell, not linux. If Novell could find away to lower the price of their Directory server, and provide solid migration paths and tools from other platforms, then they could take off.

by neon samurai

It seems it's the only way to properly sync my varous desktops, my wif's Mac and my PalmOS device. Until I get a chunck of hardware set aside, it's only a VM test build anyhow.

by neon samurai

eGroupware
on Apache/PHP/MySQL
on Mandriva Linux

All the functions I want from a groupware server with non of the obsurd Exchange Server license fees. It's within my budget and adds to my hobby-work; what's not to like.

Browser connection is the natively method.
Korganizer syncs directly.
Outlook syncs through a FOSS third party app.
iCal syncs through a FOSS third party app.
PalmOS syncs through a FOSS third party app.

I'm still testing the last two but Korg and Outlook are setup. I'm also finalizing https setup since very few other things on my network transfer in plain text. After that, I just have to do enough reading to be comfy with eGroupware and PHP apps in general.

by xwindowsjunkie

I guess the point I was unsuccessfully making was that if there is ONE area where a server driver database absolutely needs to be the biggest, beefiest it can be, it needs to support every freaking network card ever made. Because there will be some jackass (like me!) that will come along and stuff a NIC in a slot and expect the server to install the card without a hiccup. I mean after all it is a server, right? HA!

Really though I think what it shows is that some where along the line somebody at Microsoft goofed. Or the WHS product didn't go through the usual channels at the market engineering department. The install screens are obvious patchwork, the dialogs are obvious pieces of this and pieces of that, the system does not have an overall single brand name identity until it gets close to finishing the install process. The total product package was distributed across 3 different ISOs (all three had to be downloaded!) that in a more polished product would be on a single DVD ISO and there would be a menu system that would allow you to make install CD or DVD ISOs from that.

Network cards for a server are the only way the system can talk to and hear the rest of the digital universe. You would have thought that somebody would have thought about that since its the only way also that Kraken can report home and tell the Redmond Gorilla how the Beta site host (me!) is treating him!

by xwindowsjunkie

"Key codes! Key code! We don't need no steeeenking key codes!" (Think Blazing Saddles making fun of Sam Peckinpah!)

"Linux, for when you're tired of being treated as a pirate by your shrink-wrap software vendor!"

"WGA, Windows Greatly Aggravates!"

I couldn't resist!

by dumphrey

under the impression WHS would be sold as pre-built machines, and that OEM versions of the OS would not be available for a while (other then the betas). This would explain the limited support for network cards.

by xwindowsjunkie

Well I would have thought that a product that was designed as a network server would get every freaking network driver they could find simply because it is a server. It needs to communicate even more so than a desktop! In any case I used a XP Pro driver that was OLDER than Server 2003 which is what WHS is based on to get it up and working. So at least in my opinion they goofed. But as I've seen, I think they either rushed the RC1/Beta out the door, it bypassed the normal conformation for market process or its somebody's pet project. I suspect that they wanted to generate some marketing data to show the manufacturers a pent-up demand for a "home-media-server" that presumably is easy to customize for market differentiation.

by dumphrey

I will have to look into it. Is the app to synch to outlook provided by the eGroupware company, and if not, do you know its name?

by xwindowsjunkie

Well I've been running Kraken (Windows Home Server) enough to know that I really don't like it much. Yeah you figured that out a couple of weeks ago, right? But I had to give it a good crack at changing my mind.

If you've read and followed the server specifications and you have everything fairly up to date, meaning you are running Windows XP and Vista and NTFS partitions on all of your client computers, then Windows Home Server might work very well for you. If you are like me and you've pushed the Win9X and the Win2K licenses off on your kids or heavens-to-betsy you're running (shudder) Linux! Well then it won't. It doesn't even come close. In fact its reason d'etre, systems backup, does not work, at least on my fully legitimate, up-to-date-with-Windows-Update XP Pro SP2 P4 system.

The hot off the DVD burner, not ready for prime-time, Windows Home Server Release Candidate 1 is a fairly tightly focused package that I think misses the point of offering inter-operable services. Microsoft has to wake up to the fact that a lot of their customers are still running much older versions of their software. The last statistic I saw was that XP Pro was still only running on about 35% of ALL Windows boxes out there. The bulk of the computers were running either Windows 9X or Windows 2000. This tight focus will dis-enfranchise some of the still very large numbers of Windows 9X/Win2K users that haven't upgraded (and won't) and the part-time Linux users that see wide-open possibilities with Linux-based multi-media applications. I count myself in both camps.

Basically the server offers secured folders, public folders and backup services. I know Microsoft touts remote access and remote serving to and from Internet locations as a special function of this product BUT, technically that's a service that comes with Server 2003 and Windows XP and Vista. So its not really a product feature of WHS.

First off the limitations, and they are many.

1) Only Windows XP Pro and Vista OS equipped computers are supported, no Win 9X, 2K or NT 4.0 need apply. Support for Linux I didn't expect but it would have smart for Microsoft to do that at least through Samba.

2) Only NTFS partitions are supported. Come on! Why not FAT and FAT32? Don't give me any BS about security. Microsoft is using workgroup and not Domain security.

3) Computers must not be active members in an Active Domain. This is the first restriction that makes any sense. It screws up the sharing mechanism used in WHS to have conflicting local security policy on the client.

4) All logons that will need to have access to the Windows Home Server backup functions must have valid backup rights on the supported client computer. The account you use to install the WHS connector has to have the backup and restore capabilities. Other accounts will have access to the WHS. This is normally not an issue but I have some severely limited user accounts that are setup without backup or restore capability to deliberately prevent my kids from doing that behind my back.

5) The client logon used on the client computer must be programmed into the Windows Home Server user applet. This is the same restriction seen in workgroup logons to allow easy sharing to occur. If you've used XP Pro SP1 or later, you've dealt with the logon box each time you connect to a share on some other system. That's gone with WHS shares.

6) First backups are of entire partitions, this obviously is for the restore functionality, but it enforces an all or nothing mentality. I never could get it to work properly on my XP Pro system either manually or automatically. Even after I did the suggested fixes to my partitions, it still didn't work. It would not backup the C drive (system/boot) and it would not backup the F: drive, a compressed NTFS partition. The only partition it would backup was D:, a NTFS partition I first created on Windows 2000, go figure!

7) It will not backup a NTFS compressed partition, and I assume that would include an encrypted partition since they use the same software mechanism. This I consider absolutely asinine. If you've gone through the trouble to compress or encrypt the files on that partition, why can't you back them up?

8) What I also find really annoying is that the system could not find one of the two drives that are supported on a PCI IDE card on my XP client. In addition, neither of the two drives can be identified by looking at the WHS backup applet. No drive letters. No indication that they are there. You need to understand that the "discovery" agent used to find partitions to backup runs on the CLIENT computer. The client computer knows what partitions are there and presumably can access and serve those files and partitions up to the server for backup but no it doesn't work that way!

9) The WHS as I noted earlier did not support the NIC adapter that was on my DELL Celeron CPU board. Actually it only supports one NIC, the Realtek 8169. I would suspect that either this product will have more drivers installed before it goes public or it will only be available as a configured and setup system from OEMs.

10) It has only 14 video adapter drivers from ATI, Via and Intel. So I guess we know who's aching to get product out the door using this software! That's usually not as much of a problem but it would have been nice to had at least the generic Microsoft VGA and XVGA adapter drivers just to get the system up and running. Video after the system is up and running is not so much an issue. Lucky for me I had an Intel video adapter on the CPU board.

11) It has absolutely nothing that couldn't be delivered even on a Windows XP, 2K or Linux workstation except the duplicate file control and that might be scriptable with some file comparison utility. The only advantage is the "instant" connection mechanism to the server and that can be delivered in a logon script.

I never could get to the "bare metal" restore function test since the backup function never worked right. Likewise an incremental restore from the backup wasn't possible.

What does work right? The public folders and the private folders work quite well. The user account structure works well and is easy to use. Once the accounts are setup, the only password needed is the Administrator account password to open the Administrative webpage. Users once logged onto their usual computer have access to the public folders almost immediately.

One item that will cause a little confusion is that there are two different security policies for passwords. Passwords for accounts that are used for Internet access to the WHS use a "strong" policy but the internal password policy is weak. Either you have to create new user names set with policy-matching passwords or change the internal password policy to match the external policy and reset all the passwords to make them much stronger for internal use. This will maintain connectivity and not require changes to security settings on shares and file permissions but I don't suggest that.

Using a new strong password with a new user name for remote access perhaps allows for tightened security and could conceivably improve security above the usual possible in workgroups or local group policies. With one account set for access from outside only and another with access only on the inside, it might prevent some forms of attack. Adding VPN and IPSEC to the requirements for external access will provide a secure connection from remote Internet locations.

The remote access capability is there, it just doesn't seem to work right. I did get it to setup a DDNS URL on a service that Microsoft evidently has provided for the duration of the RC1 test. But there doesn't seem to be anything that allows the user to set up incoming VPN connections through the administration webpage. Now if I go to the Win2K3 Server and logon there I can set up a VPN account and VPN connections on it but I'm not sure if they can be attached to through the client interface on the client computers. This function as far as the user is concerned doesn't really exist. I'm not interested in doing VPN debugging for Microsoft without an employment contract.

The software in the WHS seems to assume that it has a connection to a UPnP router that connects to the Internet. Since I'm running a real firewall that is not running UPnP on the router functions, remote access does not work. There were no messages that were meaningful that the user could have utilised to open ports up in those cases where the router wasn't a UPnP router or was a user adjustable firewall. Yes I remember this is a USER test but with all the other issues I had with the WHS software I wasn't really interested in exposing my home systems to potential trouble for the sake of the Beta test.

Looking at this "product" from a User point of view as it stands today as a RC1, I would not recommend it to anyone not already conversant with the feature set of Windows 2003 Server. A lot of the functionality of Win2K3 is still there and it will make a very good stand-alone server for a home environment or even a small home office assuming those features remain in the final product but I wouldn't count on it. It could be improved considerably with a large number of consumer-friendly wizards. But its not ready for the consumer market, not by a long cannon shot. WHS needs to go back into drydock and add more planking and sails. This buccaneer says "Kraken gets the black spot! arrgh!"

by absolutely

[i]4) All logons that will need to have access to the Windows Home Server backup functions must have valid backup rights on the supported client computer. This is normally not an issue but I have some severely limited user accounts that are setup without backup or restore capability to [u]deliberately prevent my kids from doing that behind my back[/u].[/i]

I might have misread, but it looks like Windows Home Server will preserve the restriction you have set, not introduce any new restriction. You included that observation in your list of "limitations", leaving me a bit confused.

Meanwhile, configuring squid in Debian to cache web pages for XP was a cinch, and I have finally coaxed Samba to share a directory with Windows XP, after cifs was working for a couple weeks, doing the converse. Turns out I technically "only" needed to use the command "smbpasswd -a username" at a command prompt! In fact, however, I "needed" to hunt & peck through several relatively well-known sources of relatively well-written documentation of open source software. No wonder so many impatient people don't prefer GNU/Linux!

;)

by xwindowsjunkie

I guess what I should have said is that the WHS connector has to be used BUT the logon used in the WHS connector has to be a full Admin logon or at the very least one that has a backup privileges. Thanks I'll fix my post.

by xwindowsjunkie

Mr Absolutely has a point and is aptly self-named as well. Item #4 was originally not as clear as it could have been.

Here is the original #4.
4) All logons that will need to have access to the Windows Home Server backup functions must have valid backup rights on the supported client computer. This is normally not an issue but I have some severely limited user accounts that are setup without backup or restore capability to deliberately prevent my kids from doing that behind my back.

This is how I modified or edited my item number 4.

4) All logons that will need to have access to the Windows Home Server backup functions must have valid backup rights on the supported client computer. The account you use to install the WHS connector has to have the backup and restore capabilities. Other accounts will have access to the WHS. This is normally not an issue but I have some severely limited user accounts that are setup without backup or restore capability to deliberately prevent my kids from doing that behind my back.

Outside of making absolutely, positively clear, the necessity of installing a WHS connector under Admin user privileges it doesn't do much more than that.

by xwindowsjunkie

With the posting I did yesterday I hope to have buried Kraken at least in consideration as an alternative server for my backwater bay.

For a product that supposedly offers "new" features and advantages to the computer and media consuming public I was marvelously under-whelmed. The second biggest reason to use a home server, that of backup for the other systems on the local subnet, failed in my case miserably.

I doubt very much that I will bother to do a forensic postmortem simply because it was supposed to be a almost finished product and wasn't. Yes I could spend a lot of time and fix all of the problems and yes I know how to fix the backup problem. I'm not on Microsoft's payroll. If I'm going to expend that much effort, its going to be on something I OWN, from the top of the mast to the keel.

But this started out as a user test and to be entirely and brutally honest, Debian (Debbie) failed as well as Kraken (Windows Home Server). But I expected Debian (and all other Linux distros) to fail simply because the Linux programmer's universe hasn't bothered to approach the consumer market except in specific targeted devices. Nobody writing Linux applications sees anything profitable in generic Home appliances. A Home Server is still fairly general purpose and not that much different from any other desktop, NAS or computer. All of the profitable Linux appliances are specific purpose devices, set top boxes, DVR's, DVD players etc.

I'm going to continue working on and writing about Debbie simply because it does fill a need I have here for a generic file and media server. When its done I hope to be able to release the "cookbook" I used and hopefully a distro variation.