Discussion Locked

About Tags

0 helpful
16 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

For an excellent example of how tags really, really suck as a search tool, the results from the TR Store for Linux:

Linux

500 Things Every Technology Professional Needs to Know
box Did you know... Did you know Microsoft's
RegClean does not work with XP but you can use shareware to clean your registry? Did you know most wireless access points don't have encryption enabled by default? Did you know there are 500 tidbits of information contained in TechRepublic's 500 Things Every Technology Professional Needs to Know that will help you become a successful IT professional.
List Price: $24.95
Bookstore | Category: Networking | Format: Download

Quick Reference: Linux Commands
box Reduce stress and speed up resolutions with the easiest command references right at your fingertips. TechRepublic editors have updated and expanded our popular Linux Commands chart and made it downloadable for instant access. You'll receive a PDF file covering Linux, packed with the most common commands you'll need and use daily.
List Price: $14.95
Bookstore | Category: | Format: Download

Windows Administrator's Guide to Open Source Software
box TechRepublic's Windows Administrator's Guide to Open Source Software in the Enterprise takes a look at some of the most popular open source options available from a Windows administrator perspective. It presents field-tested recommendations for making open source program play nice in a Windows environment. This e-book and electronic file combination get you up-to-speed quickly with how to use open source tools. From proven advice from in-the-trenches IT professionals to time-saving cost calculators, ROI worksheets, cost tracking templates and more, the e-book and accompanying files were developed to help a Windows administrator become familiar with open-source alternatives in their organization.
List Price: $89.00

yup, THREE items, and the very first one, seems to be ALL about MICROSOFT, nothing about Linux.

the Third one is better, it at least is about open source software, but, it's open source ON WINDOWS.

only one result is actually on topic, the quick linux command reference.

sad really, that only 33% of results are on topic.

Shall we see what discussions come up with a tag search for Linux?
browse discussions, then hit linux tag link gives us:

System Security
Discussion by nick_cephas@...
Tags: networking, programming, software, project management, career, linux, security 5 02/25/2008 @ 11:14 PM

how to delete temporary internet files in registry
Question by hr_gp@...
Tags: e-mail, hardware, networking, software, windows, linux, it management, security 2 02/25/2008 @ 8:08 PM

OpenSSL
Question by Arp22
Tags: security, linux, programming, networking, ssl, openssl, software 1 02/25/2008 @ 5:37 PM

Users folder size in Linux RH Ent 5
Question by AYJE
Tags: linux, folder size 4 02/25/2008 @ 1:09 PM

FTP Server Access
Question by masoodsharif?
Tags: linux, linux ftp 1 02/25/2008 @ 12:24 PM

Coming out party with Linux
Discussion by starkwead@...
Tags: windows, linux 21 02/25/2008 @ 7:28 AM

linux
Question by rsushobhit@...
Tags: windows, linux 1 02/25/2008 @ 2:53 AM

Help with vista
Question by shan_tel69@...
Tags: feedback, windows, software, it management, project management, linux, hardware, networking, programming, e-mail, please help confused with vista

top 8 results actually gives us a 50% return of being on topic. better than the store.
but not much.
windows registry questions.
windows temporary files questions
windows vista questions
have ZERO to do with linux, so should not be able to be tagged with linux.

16 replies

by beth blakely

that tags suck as a search tool. That means that the people who tagged the items as "linux" suck. When you figure out how to make people stop sucking, let me know. :-)

by the scummy one

Just because some people suck -- Edited before Beth strikes
me down......... -- nothing to see here, move along, move
along...

by beth blakely

'Cause I seem to be posting rapid fire, however, I do pay attention and research this stuff when you guys point it out, and...

While "500 Things Every Technology Professional Needs to Know" SEEMS to be about Windows, it probably has some Linux stuff in it since it's tagged as such by a staffer.

Discussions are tagged by your peers through the categorization when they start a thread. We started standardizing the tags with the check boxes because most people didn't understand how tagging worked and still don't, thus the recent Friday Yuk (with date attached) debacle.

Basically, I hear you, we see the problems.

by charliespencer

"...most people didn't understand how tagging worked and still don't..."

Okay, I'll admit to being one of those who don't understand tagging. I'm aware tags are in use in other places besides TR. I believe they're connected with the term 'metadata', although I'm vague on what that entails. I'm not aware of the use of tags at any site I frequent besides TR, but maybe I'm not seeing it.

Hell, I can't even replicate Jaqui's results. I went to the Store and enter 'linux' without the quotes in the search box at the top for Bookstore. I got "No matches found - browse our top tags" and an alphabetical list of apparently every tag that's ever been used.

Sounds like a topic for an article to me.

by beth blakely

Tagging is just a way to group things together using words, or "tags." See those words at the top of this post after the word "Tags"? Those are the categories associated with this post. If you click them, you should find other related items.

On TR, staff-created content gets tagged by some techno-magic that runs while we're sleeping. All content that contains, for example, the word "Linux" a specific number of times becomes "tagged" as "Linux" content and will appear when you click a Linux tag.

Member-generated content, like Questions and Discussions can be tagged two ways. First, when you pick a category, like "off-topic" for example, the thread becomes searchable by that tag. When you type words in the tag box below the categories, you create your own tags, like "Friday Yuk." You have to be sure to separate the tags with a comma, though, and be sure to use consistent verbiage or it doesn't work.

So, for example, all of these discussions:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5260-1-0.html?query=friday%20yuk
Have been "tagged" as Friday Yuk by the members who started the threads.

Make sense?

by jaqui

the "category" tags are almost always mis used, specially by new members

the one category per discussion / question system before tagging was implemented helped get better results on a search.

and this morning's discussion results was unusual in that it was only 50% miss tagged.

hmm, maybe a slight change to the worst one..
make a tag of "Operating Systems" that excludes there being more than one "child" tag of Windows, Linux, OSX, Macos, BSD, Unix ... then anything that is a cross platform is just tagged with operating systems, and when it is os specific the one child tag appropriate can be selected.

most linux / unix /osx / *bsd content has zero in common with content for MS options.
when there is a commonality, it is usually cross platform so all are affected.

by beth blakely

I hear you, but don't expect any changes anytime soon. (Don't shoot the messenger, I'm just being honest!) There are benefits to this system that you can't see, plus rethinking it is not likely to be near the top of any queue anytime soon.

Your feedback is still appreciated, though! Keep it coming.

by seanferd

Howzabout: When starting a thread off an article or blog entry, tags from the content are automatically entered for the first post? If this were to be the case, the "tag space" would also have to be enlarged, as a user cannot enter the full string length for all categories and tags off the article without editing some out.

[I usually copy/paste tags from the content, remove any primary tags I can select from the check boxes, then edit for redundancy, and finally remove what I imagine would be the least useful tags until it all fits within the "tagspace".]

by jaqui

but I'll keep complaining about BROKEN navigation / searches until it is fixed. :D

if we didn't tell you what is bugging us about the site, there wouldn't be any way it could get fixed. :D

by absolutely

[i]There are benefits to this system that
you can't see...[/i]

Never mind, it doesn't matter. These
benefits we can't see don't benefit
[u]us[/u]. I think maxwell edison &
deepsand have the right idea. Cnet killed
TechRepublic. 'Bye.

This discussion is closed to new replies.