Discussion Locked

Am I underpaid

0 helpful
114 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have worked in IT for 3 years while going through school. I currently have an Associate?s degree in Computer Science and have been out of school for 1 year. I started late with computers mainly because my family never could afford one. I tend to learn things very fast and graduated with a 3.89 GPA and have sense gotten a job as Sys Admin for a Software Developer. I have been here for over a year, but in that time I have maintained our Microsoft, Linux, and UNIX servers and desktops. I also maintain our website, security, and have designed User and Security policies as well as implement a DR plan. I started at 40K and just received a 4% raise, but I was really hoping for more since I was straight out of school and needed to prove myself. I will be taking my CCNA and MCSA soon and going back to school for my Bachelors.

Bottom line is that I have 3 kids, wife, 2 mortgages, and 2 cars to pay for and almost out of savings. It seems at this rate I will be able to save for my kids' college and retirement when my youngest is in high school and I am wanting to retire in a 10 years. Not quite enough time.

Edit for spelling

114 replies

by jamesrl

You are not paid by your GPA, your certs or the size of your family, or the size of your debtload.

You are paid by what tasks you do for the company. Now some companies do pay more for certs, mine does not. But we pay people according to ther job description, and we have people whose job it is to catagorize a job description by pay band.

I can't tell you whether 40K is good for your market or not - you should do some research on that - your location, current employment rate all factor into your pay.

The relevant question is, are you being paid a fair wage for the job you do?

A 4 % raise by the way would be only given to well above average performers in my company.

You very well may be unappreciated and underpaid at your current job. You can try to get that at your current employer, but you may have better success jumping ship to a company that pays better.

But you may also find that the grass isn't always greener. Some places that pay well have higher turnover and more stress. Ask yourself if you like your job, your boss, and your work environment, because many people do not.

James

by naughtymonkey

In my area, the job that my title says I have is in the 40-50K range. But when I look at the descriptions I am more in line with an IT manager as far as duties go since I do everything within the company which pays from 65-80K. Due to my lack of experience, even though I have proved myself capable of doing the job, I believe I should be compensated ny being paid at least in the 60K range. I am getting the certs, because it is required to find a job elsewhere.

by naughtymonkey

I do like my job even though it is very stressful and the people I work with are good. I would however gladly sacrifice those things that I like about this job just to provide for my family. Only a complete self absorbed a** would say they wanted to make less money and not provide for their family to the best of their ability becasue a higher paid job was stressful.

by jamesrl

Manage people. Do you manage people? Managing people does put you in a whole different role.

I stand by my earlier assessment. You have to compare your role to other similar roles in the company. And yes, people are paid also on experience. Its a fact that you can have two people in a role who do exactly the same job, and the person with more experience will be most often be paid more.

If you feel that you have the wrong title, and therefore are in the wrong pay grade, thats something that typically does not fix itself. You have to approach your boss, and your boss may have to work with HR to re-evaluate your job. I have done that for many of my employees with good results, but it was not quick or easy - it took 9 months to push through the bureaucracy.

Like I suggested, thats one route, and it may or may not be the right one. The other route is looking for another position, where the pay is commensurate with your expectations.

James

by tonythetiger

For each worker directly under you, add 10% to the wage of the highest one and that is what you should ask for.

For example, employee a and b make 35k, and employee c and d make 4k.

That's 4k (10%) times 4 employees = 16k, added to 40k = 56k.

(Never mind, I just made all that up :) I thought this was Friday yuk)

by shellbot

hey James, hope its all ok your neck of the woods.
oh, booked for canada, but we don't have huge amounts of time between flights so won't have enough time to go into toronto itself.
all's ok here..must email you soon with life update. :)

by lockoutgirl

I learned alot from my dad while I was looking for a job. We lived in a suburb of Atlanta, Georgia, where jobs pay alot more than they do most other places in the state. He was coaching me on the finer points of deciding on jobs, what to look for and how to compare.

First, what kind of benefits package do you have? Salary is not everything, folks. I ended up taking an IT job in a much smaller city near where my father grew up. Why? Because it got me out of Atlanta. Yes, I could have stayed and made almost 10k more than I make now, but this place has a KILLER benefits package. Profit Sharing, 401K, Health insurance like you wouldn't believe. And the atmosphere is great - good people who really care about their employees. I would never trade that for some cold corporation that would dump me in a heartbeat. I came for the whole deal, not just the salary.

When I was looking at the salary, my dad sat me down and we did a budget - what were my expenses versus what was I going to be bringing home. At the rate they quoted me, I wasn't going to be able to make it on my own, even in a 1 br apartment. But, it all worked out in the end. I work about 4 hours of over time each week, and a few Saturdays a month. I get half days during the week, and life is good. I'm happy, I'm learning and I'm very comfortable with where I want to be.

Basically, what I'm saying, is you're only focusing on the pay. For someone only 3 years in, that pay sounds right to me. But, as was mentioned by James, take a look at your market. Take a look at a similar job and see what the range is for that. And then look at what that company offers in benefits. You make take another job for better bottom line, but the benefits are worse. That is really hurting you down the line.

Don't just assume because you're not getting the number you thought you should that you're not appreciated. Maybe if you see everywhere else looks better, go to your super or HR and ask them why their pay scale is as it is. That may help you understand.

by naughtymonkey

Most people are jsut mad at me at this point. I am considering benefits when looking for jobs. Honestly my insurance is way to expensive here, but if I mad more it wouldn't be so bad. I do have a 401K, free gym membership, employer contributions to 401K, and to HSA account. Unfortunately, this is a small family owned company and I don't feel that it would be wise to start asking about making more money until I have a job to go to if they tell me they can't pay anymore. They may decide that since I am not happy with my pay, that I will find another job so they had better go ahead and find a replacement.

My brother-in-law works for the same size company, makes about 80K, nobody to manage but has IT Manager as title. He doesn't actually do any work though because they have contracts with Dell. He just calls them to come fix machine when they break or they need to upgrade. He got his job because his brother gave it to him. I guess it's all in who you know.

by computergreek

I know exactly how you feel. I'm 23 and been in IT for 5 years and I'm leaving one highly touted tech job from a regional jewelry company with decent pay but terrible people to work with and highly overbearing managers to a smaller tech consulting company with slightly better pay but wonderful people. Included in the perks are a better 401k, commision possibilites, better health ins, and compensation for any certifications that I may want to get while I'm with the company. I'm excited that I get to work with actual IT people who know what and how active directory works and dont have to stare at a screen for hours on end to figure out a problem. Its not all dollars and cents.

by goodoh

I'm quite concerned with a company that reserves a 4% raise to 'well above average performers'.

Since the Canada/USA CPI is running at 2.4-2.6% we are looking at a real rise of about 1.5% for the best employees. I assume simply 'above average' and 'average' are getting less, maybe going backwards after taking inflation into account.

Beware companies that pay like this, if the company doesn't even pay in line with inflation then your real productivity should, in all fairness, decrease with the decline in your real wage.

I'm going to place a small bet that the CEO is getting more than 4% raises, or am I wrong?

by tig2

4% is considered to be a high end raise. Any higher and someone would start asking searching questions about sheep and actual duties.

This has been a standard in the US for awhile. If someone wants a real raise, they change jobs.

Is it right? No. Is it reality? Yep.

Edited typo

by jamesrl

Well I don't know about the CEO, but I do know about senior VPs. The average raise is the average raise across the whole country.

Now there are some factors to consider. We also calculate an average wage for a position, and people below the average tend to get higher increases than those above average.

And people getter larger increases for promotions - getting a senior tacked on to your title etc.

And of course, there are bonuses that are much more variable that base salaries. Thats where the CEO would have the chance to make big gains because there is more scope for variability. And since the bonuses are calculated on profits and meeting key financial, sales and other strategic objectives, the CEO has a big influence.

James

by naughtymonkey

essentially dong the job of 2 people, should you not be given a raise to jsutify the extra work and responsibility. Especially when they stated you would not be doing those other duties.

If you worked at McDonalds and the becam Manager, should you just get a 4% raise.

by shellbot

now i'm saying this in a "friendly" type of way ok..

but where do you get off making the assumtpion that only an a** would turn down money?

What are you aiming to provide for your family? I mean your personal finance is your own business..but your the one who posted the details..so do you go for quality over quantity?
Do you need 2 cars?

Two weeks before christmas i turned down a position that would have paid me over 9K a year more than i make now. Why you ask?
Because i believe in quality of life. The extra stress would not have made my life any better. So i would have a bit more money to buy "things" with..chances are that money would have been spent on prepackeaged meals (because by the time i get home i'd have been in no mood to cook), and presents for my hubbby and daughter because i'd be trying to make up for being cranky and b1tchy all the time.

Its a personal choice mate..i enjoy quality of life..a nice glass of red wine with my meal after a good days work..but you know what..when times are a bit tough, its strawberry kool-aid (thanks to my mom who mails it to me) instead.

Don't get me wrong, I've worked myself up from a wee canadian farm girl who didn't finish school, to a DBA. I know what its like to go without..and i've drank a lot more Tang in my life than i'd like to admit, ah the good old days of having $10 left a week before payday..what to buy, food for child, gas or smokes?
I quit smoking for 5 days, walked everywhere and bought fruit and vegetables for my child.

3 years is not a whole lot of experience..your not playing with the big boys yet.. sure you may do the work they do, but thats not how it works a lot of the time. the big boys get 80K a year because they also doing the job of the people over top of them and they feel they should be making 100K a year.
Maybe get a new job..maybe try and get a raise..4% is about standard for a good employee around here. Don't expect to walk into a job making 80K ..maybe in a couple years, but not right now.

Curious, did you get into IT for the money or because you liked it?

I'm such a geek....i rarely admit it, but i LIKE databases..i want to be a SQL Programmer when i grow up..i work on this stuff at home for the fun of it..

I obviously want to make the most money i can, however, not at the sacrifice of my life and family

by naughtymonkey

I said I would like to make 60K which is well below minimum for the work I am doing in my area. I don't think I should have to sell my house, walk the 40 miles to work, or leave my wife at home without a car to pick the kids up from school and take them to their extracuricular activities. I may think that my family deserves a lot, but they do. I don't give a damn how hard I have to work, my family will live the life I feel they should and I couldn't.I will never take anything away from my family. I did landscaping for eight years and made 50K, but had my leg crushed by a damn Mexican who thought he knew how to drive a Bobcat. Now I can't do that work and instead of living off the state, I went back to school and worked my a$$ off. Now I just want to know if it is unreasonable for me to expect more, but not as much as the minimum, than I am making now when I clearly do the work.

by shellbot

i wasn't being specific..it was just a number mate.
not saying you have to sell yer house and walk..your not quite getting what i was saying.
"I don't give a damn how hard I have to work, my family will live the life I feel they should and I couldn't.I will never take anything away from my family"

And when your marriage disintegrates, and you never see your kids because of work and stress will they be living the life you feel they should?
Not saying you have to live like a pauper..not at all..but maybe some things are more important than others..

fair f*cks for not taking the easy road. you've done more than a lot of people i know in a similar position have done.

but you can't expect it all overnight.
no, its NOT unreasonable to WANT your fair dues, but sometimes it takes a bit to get there.
I do the job of User Support, Tech Support, Dev Support,Server Support, DBA, Proj Manager, Business Analyst, Data Analyst, and general all around "how do i use word, excell, outlook..etc" person.
Its a case of Jack of all trades, master of none.
If i specialised and went full DBA i'd be able to make about 20K more..but will take me a couple years to gain the experience to command that type of money.
Even with the experience i have, its proving hard to find a job i WANT that will pay me what i want. ALl the jobs i don't want ARE paying what i want. Its my personal choice to hold on and wait.
Salary serveys are great..they show us what we could attain..just takes a few years to get there.

by donaldcoe

Reading your post placed chill bumps on my sphine cause I am GEEK Too, I am in this field for the LOVE OF IT, the money is also nice but I have had the 24/7 stress of long nights and weekends fixing things I did not break. I seen the museums of parchment and sheep skins that hang around the desks of some of my colleagues, but all the cert's in China still can not titter the scales. If you want to get paid give up the family and friends, eating out, chasing the skirts, driving faster cars and learn to Octopus (suck up to what ever the BOSS needs) and make them believe they can't live without you. But if you have a misstep or health issue all the money in the world will not make it better. I salute you Ms. Shellbot cause it truly is not about the money.

by naughtymonkey

I completely understand about other compensations as I said in a different post. I understand workplace stress, balancing work and family, and understand average raises. I have compared salaries as I listed in ohter posts. This discussion has generated some other ideas that got me thinking in a different direction adn have really made me change my question a few times. Something I need to remember is that you can get screwed in every job you have no matter what industry.

At this point, I know I have comparable experience and higher education and training than others in the same job with roughly the same benefits. I am also exposed and manage many differnet platforms than some I know. I am being paid less and I should expect a raise. How long I should wait before I consider it being them dropping the ball, I don't know.

I have got a variety of experience with differnet platforms that can help me move into another job. I do like this company, but some of those things I do I was told I would not be doing those. It has turned in the direction of the one doing them does not have time to do them. This should be under System Administration. I don't mind doing the job, but I want to be compensated for it. I just am not comfortable with renegotiating right now until I have another job to bring to the table as well.

So, I do appreciate the help. I was not being defensive, except for those that wanted to say I was wrong for wanting to raise my children the way I want or that I needed to cut back. I have cut back to the point that I can without neglecting my family and taking away from them in a way I don't want to do. I have lost 30K in income due to the 10K I lost when switching to IT from Landscaping and my wife had to quit working due to a hard pregnancy where she was on bed rest for 5 months and is still having problems. To the others, it was not defensive, it was more of a debate justifying why I felt as if I am underpaid.

I left out details like I have cut back on expenses because it doesn't have a place in the discussion. The question was not how I lived my life, it was am I being compensated for the work I am doing.

So how long should I wait for them to realize I should get compensated for the extra work before I ask. I am used to getting compensation for taking on more responsibility in most other jobs I had. Those that didn't were not worth the negotiation so I just found another job.

So that is what my question is now.

by gadgetgirl

My husband got greedy. Wanted to have more money so changed jobs. More stress.

Alienated family.

Alienated daughter.

Didn't have time to spend the "extra" money he earned.

Alienated me.

Had nervous breakdown.

Spent 10 weeks constantly at my heels whilst recovering, after 2 years of hardly being around.

Totally changed in personality, outlook and everything else.

Alienated me.

Took three years to get him into full recovery; three years later, I left.

Now my EX husband.

All through stress.

Don't go there.

GG

by shellbot

we were "living the dream"
big house in the burbs, both workin like dogs..all that money and no time to do anything with it..except b1tch and nag at each other
thats why we sold house..moved back into town..its such a weight off out shoulders.
i reckon if we had done another year like that we'd be ex's in a couple years.
but back on track now so its all good :)

by naughtymonkey

I personally like stress. Stress means you are being challenged. I have 3 kids, it can be stressful, and don't even get me started about my wife. Why should I work 10 hour days, go home, log into work and continue working, and work weekends, but get paid for a job that shouldn't have anywhere near the responsibility I have.

by jamesrl

I have worked in some very stressful 60 hour a week jobs. A few years back I was working a job that required me to travel a great deal. I was laid off, and I took the chance to reconnect with my kids. I spent time with them, went with them on school trips, took them places.

When job hunting, I looked for opportunities to find a job that would be closer to 40 hours a week. Guess what, it pays less.

And my wife and kids know it, and they wouldn't have it any other way. They would rather have more time with me than more money. Thats why I stay even though I could make more money by going.

So call me a self absorbed a** if you like. My family needs me to be there. Money isn't everything, and people tend to overspend no matter what their level of income.

James

by naughtymonkey

We have to go live in a trailer and eat hamburger helper (it is good and I insist we eat it at least once a week), because Daddy doesn't feel like working a job that he has to work hard. I worked two jobs and went to school full time and still managed to pull off graduating with honors, taking my family on vacation once a year for at least a week, a few weekend trips, went on field trips, was on the PTA board, and was at every school function. It can be done as long as you are willing to do it. Since I started this job, I have still done all of the things I have always done and I don't believe working somewhere else will be more demanding. The point is that I am not getting paid for it.

by jamesrl

I know that I'd like to pay for my kids education, buy them their first house and help them marry the partner of my dreams. But I have to work in the real world.

I am not in any way denegrating your effort to make a new life for yourself, thats admirable. But your employer doesn't pay based on your personal situation. They pay based on what they feel the job is worth. And you accepted the initial wage, you accepted that. If you think you have taken on more responsibility since then, you have a valid case for asking for more money and bigger wages. But there are limits. Very few employers will just decide to make that huge an increase, unless the company can't continue to do business without you.

If you think you are more valuable, you can make your case, or you can look for another position.

I was simply trying to point out that it isn't being an a** to accept less money. I try to make my money stretch farther. I haven't taken expensive vacations until last year, and even then it was moderate by most people's standards. I try to save 10% of my net income, knowing I won't retire rich. I bought a very modest home, and I have to live with it, I can't afford more.

My first computer job, 22 years ago, I took less money than they had initially discussed. They had said that things were tight at the company and when things picked up they would be generous. Guess what happened? Things picked up and they forgot that verbal committment. When I called them on it, they tried to fire me, but they couldn't because I was working hard and did a good job. Eventually I was laid off when they had one bad month. The VP called me into his office to lay me off and told me it was the best thing that could happen to me, as I would find more money and be better appreciated elsewhere. Guess what? He was absolutely correct.

You might not want to wait. There is no risk in just looking at other job postings out there in your area for similar positions and seeing what they pay and what the benefits are. If you are substantially below, then I'd apply for them.

Doesn't Dice or some of those other surveys have a slary comparison? And like I said in the other post, don't compare yourself with an IT manager, in most companies they have staff. I have 10 staff as a manager, at another company I still had the manager title and have 30 staff(including 3 supervisors).

James

by oneeyed

You stated: "Since I started this job, I have still done all of the things I have always done and I don't believe working somewhere else will be more demanding. The point is that I am not getting paid for it."

Then QUIT, and stop complaining about it. You'll soon learn that peace of mind and quality time are worth a lot of money. My wife just accepted a position making nearly $10K less than she currently does, and I applauded her for it. The most important thing in my life is that she is happy, and we both know that happiness does not equal wealth. We will scrape by for a little while, but we will both be in positions we enjoy, working for companies we like. And we will move up the ladder...EVENTUALLY.

I'm editing my post because I realized that it may come across as me lecturing you. I don't mean to do that. I DO respect your reasons, hell, we all want to give our children better lives than we had, but that does include spending time with daddy.

by sgt_shultz

although you may be heartened to know that I recently was told my salary requirement was too high and when I asked for clarification they said 'we want to pay what you NEED to make, not what you think you should make.'
in the states, you can sue for that.
ah well. i just keep looking. i think it is fun and i am becoming more professional (well, in my job interviews anyhow)
anyway, the question you need to ask is:
How can I make more money?
that puts the responsibility on you, see, where it belongs, imho. you are attempting to make it your current companies 'fault' imho. an interesting approach to advancement, imho.
If you want/need to make more, specialize.
Learn java, mysql, php, database administration or security.
those all will fetch you more in the 60-80k range. good luck.

by maxwell edison

.....then yes. If not, then no.

You're making $41,600 per year, plus vacation time, plus medical coverage, plus paid holidays off (I'm assuming, of course, but you should be able to adjust accordingly).

$41,600 divided by 2080 (working hours in a year) equals $20 per hour. If you get 80 hours of free vacation time, that's worth $1,600. If you get five paid holidays off (and it might be more -- federal employees get something in the ten day range), that's worth another $800. If your medical costs your company $300 per month, that's worth another $3,600. Oh, and let's not forget the 7.5 percent of your Social Security that your company pays on your behalf, so that's worth another $3,120.

$41,600 + $1,600 + $800 + $3,600 + $3,120 = $50,720 that your company pays for your services.

Where am I going with this, you might ask? Well, your worth is commensurate with what you can provide for another. If you feel that you're worth more than $50,720 (which is just under $25 per hour), than market yourself. If you branch-out on your own, you'd have to make at least $50,720 to equal what your company is paying you. If you market yourself to other companies, and you want to join their payroll, you have to show that you can provide more than $50,720 worth of value to them.

You can DOUBLE your salary, if you can sell your time (at least 2080 hours of it) for $50 per hour. That?s how you should look at it. Market yourself and sell your time. Entrepreneurs do it totally on their own, while employees rely on the safety net of a company. The former have no restraints, while the latter do.

Regardless of which you do, it?s YOUR TIME; it belongs to you. The question is how much value you place on your own time and how you choose to sell it. Would you sell YOUR TIME to another person for 10 cents an hour? Of course not. Would you sell it for $1,000 an hour? Most likely, you would. Of course, no one is obliged to buy it, so it?s an effort in finding the common ground between the available supply (of whatever it is you?re selling) and the demand for your ?product?. If you want to sell a year?s worth of your time to one company (with almost automatic extensions), it might only be worth $50,720 to them. If they were to buy the same product, but only three months of it, it might be worth $20,000 to them. Do that with four companies, and you just increased your income to $80,000 (but you lose your ?safety net? and you have to work differently).

The question you should be asking yourself is what your value is. Your challenge is to sell that to potential buyers. Employers are buyers, while employees are sellers. If you can prove to your company that your value to them is more than $50,720, and/or your value on the open market is more than $50,720, and/or they can?t find the same amount of value by paying another person the same amount of dollars, then you WILL make more. If your ?value? is not worth more than that, then you must be content to limit your income to that OR you need to find ways to increase your value -- and learn how to market that value, either to your employer or to others.

(Hint: It has NOTHING to do with certifications.)

by naughtymonkey

I just want to know if others agree or if they have advice. Not much advice on here though. I tried the entrepreneur thing a few years back when I did landscaping. Made alot of money when the work was there, but now I prefer the safety net. Besides, if someone doesn't take my money and put it away for retirement where my wife can't get it, she will spend it.

by maxwell edison

You apparently missed my point. I didn't suggest that you limit your career to the [i]".....entrepreneur thing....."[/i], at least not as you see it to be. Even if you limit yourself to the "employee thing", you're still an entrepreneur in selling yourself and your services; you're only limiting your target customer to one.

If you think you're worth $60,000, then you are. What in the heck are you asking us for? If you're not getting it, you're selling yourself either the wrong way or to the wrong people -- or both.

You also said, [i]Besides, if someone doesn't take my (your) money and put it away for retirement where my wife can't get it, she will spend it."[/i]

Well, that might be her excuse for not doing it. What's yours?

by jmgarvin

1) Your experience level is pretty short (only 3 years).

2) You only have an AS CS.

3) 4% is a pretty healthy raise. If you are making 2% raises you are doing something wrong and if it is 3% you are like most Americans.

4) Finish your certs and education. That BS will open more doors for you and in some cases count as experience.

The bottom line is that your job doesn't care how many kids, cars, or mortgages you have. If you feel like you are worth more negotiate with your job or move on. Lose a car, sell you house and move to a smaller one, put smaller amounts into your 401k or do whatever you need to to live better.

Let me give you some advice though, moving into another job might not be the answer. Money isn't the only thing (as others have pointed out) and you need to take into account the behavioral decisions you could make. Do you have a good boss? Can you move ahead in your company? Do you have good hours? How much over time have you had to put in and do you get comp time for it? If your wife has a job, do your hours match (eg both work 9-5) and do you like that? Are your kids in school and do you like the area? These go on and on...

You need to ask yourself a lot of questions before you go off half cocked.

by naughtymonkey

Currently drive 40 miles one way to work and can't move into smaller house. If I moved into a smaller house it would technically be illegal due to the whole boy/girl ratio to bedrooms laws in SC (maybe other states), and I refuse to make my 11 year old son who is going into middle school be in a room with an 8 year old daughter and a 13 week old baby. That is not fair to him. It is not that I can't pay my bills. I can't provide them with a college education or retire until I am 90. The job I do pays more than I make in other companies. I get no travel expenses or overtime, just salary. I like the company I work for. I just want to make more so I can plan for my family's future and not go into that half cocked.

by jmgarvin

You know what BS stands for? Bullsh*t
You know what MS stands for? More sh*t
You know what PhD stands for? Piled Higher and Deeper

by naughtymonkey

I am the only IT in this company other then the developers, who honestly think they know alot, but sure do screw up a lot of stuff. I have interns come from local colleges and high schools when I have big projects and need someone to scan logs and reset passwords so that is far as my managing people goes in this job. I do however make decisions that a Systems Administrator, by job description on most sites, should not be doing. They shouldn't make decisions as to what ISP to go with, what phone system to have put in, training users, writing policies, and othe high level decisions. I sit in a room of Mangers and VPs once or twice a month and plan on the what route the company should go with technology. I jsut think I am not getting paid for the work I do.

A lot of people seem to think I am greedy which is not true. I just want for my family the things I never had.

My plan is to get Certs (because most compamies around here will not accept your resume without them), find another job closer to home hopefully ( drive 80 miles a day right now), ask my current employer if they would like to match the offer (I do like it here), and go from there with a new plan for the future as far as compensation goes.

And from my first post, I just listed kids and bills so people wouldn't think I just wanted more money because I was a greedy 20 year old who just got out of college, I actually need the money to maintain my families current investments.

by shellbot

i just think your on the fast track to burnout land.
if you can keep it up..all the power to you. most can't after a couple of years.

i think maybe your taking some of our commetns in the wrong way..we're not attacking you..we're giving you our expeiences. we're a "caring and sharing" group here..

one of the most important things i have learnt is this, and i kepe it in my head at all times:

a company that employs you is out to make money. athlough there ARE exceptions, the vast majority pay you what they deem is sufficent. the more they pay you, the less they have in the bank. a lot of places purposely have positions which cover a multitude of workloads, because they are saving money on staffing costs.

Each company puts thier own spin on Job Titles as well..don't get too hung up on that. One mans Sys Admin is anothers Tech Support :)

You may be able to negotiate a pay rise, you may not..if not..move on.

you say you work for a smallish place..chances are they may not be able to afford to pay you more. Now that you have a couple years experience under your belt you may be able to go soemwhere else and get closer to what your looking for..

by naughtymonkey

Most of it has not been on subject. I just don't want to hear about how I should cut back or not pay for my kids school. I wanted to know how mu job duties/compensation compared with others in the field. I am looking for another job and am looking at different areas. And with the numbers I gave about my area, I wanted opinions on the duties/compensation for it as well. Now it is how long should I wait before renegotiating. I hope they would realize they have expanded my duties in areas that I wasn't supposed to be in.

by naughtymonkey

I am comparing job description for IT Manager to my current responsibilities and aside from having people under me, I do the rest. My duties are way over a Systems Administrator. I guess I am a Systems Manager or an IT Administrator. A big part of an IT Manager is also the big decisions, like policies, service, vendors, etc..., that do not go with System Administration. I feel that once you start making business decisions you are more than a Systems Administrator.

I would however like to pay for my children to go to college. I had to pay my own way and I don't think my kids should have to do the same. I don't think I will be able to pay for it up front, but will not have to take out such a large loan. I also plan to pay for my daughters' weddings. That is not living in a dream world, it is doing what most upper middle class and above families do.

And I never said I should get paid for my financial situation either. I just believe I should be paid for the job I do. I ma not asking to make the minimum amount that an IT Manager makes in my area, but I would like to make more than the minimum for a Systemm Administrator.

I don't think it is being an a$$ to accept less money either if you are not taking away from your family. If you find a job with less money, less responsibility, but still enough for you to maintain your lifestyle and family the way you feel is the best for them, then by all means take it. But if you feel that you are not providing enough for your family and were offered a job making more money, you would take it. I can always find time for my kids working multiple jobs while going to school, working 80 hour weeks, traveling, or whatever. I have always done it and always will. Just because some of these other people here say they couldn't do it, doesn't mean I should lower my standards to theirs.

I will find another job after I get my Certs that employers love so much around here and give my current company a chance to counter. I do appreciate others opinions, but do not appreciate their attempt to make others think there way is wrong. If you want to live a modest life and have your kids pay for their own first car, college, weddings, etc... good for you. I choose to give every opportunity to my kids that I can so they don't start off on a bad path like I did.

by maxwell edison

As you probably know (since we've conversed so much), I have a teenage son for whom I pay to attend a very fine private high school. It sets me back about 10k a year -- a significant "after tax" and "after 401k" portion of my income.

He has his sights set on attending one of several universities, all of which carry a hefty price tag, anywhere from 2x to 4x what I'm currently paying for his high school (and that doesn't include room and board and extracurricular activities). We've discussed how his college will be paid for (and by whom), and he knows that my "deal" is that I'll continue to pay the 10k a year, but he has to pay the rest. I told him that I'd pay it for up to six years if he wants to stretch out the college so his grades won't suffer by him having to work at the same time. I've also said that the funds will be cut-off if his GPA drops below a 3.0.

I'm amazed at the ideas he comes up with as a way to make it happen. (The six year idea was actually his, when he suggested a scenario in which he could hold down a ~40 hour a week job and still take a two-thirds class load.) He also wants to do it without having to take-on any significant student loans. He has some scholarship possibilities, which keeps him somewhat diligent in high school, but none are a slam-dunk by any means.

Where's the rule that says parents must "save" for their kids' college? Actually, if you were to ask most financial experts, they'd say to reduce your own debt and save for your own retirement first. Saving for kids? college should be last.

One thing that is absolutely true is this. If there?s a will, there?s a way. And I?ve never met an able-bodied, reasonably smart teenager who couldn?t work his or her way through any college of choice if the will was really there. Moreover, who might get more out of the college experience ? the one who goes to school (and parties?) on mom and dad?s dime, or the one who has to work his/her butt off to get through?

by naughtymonkey

I need to sell myself to employers, but you went on so long about this amount for this many hours and this amount for this, I couldn't help but think you were also talking about contracting as an idea as well. There is a lot of it out there.

I took this job without putting much thought into it for two reasons:
1. I could get good solid experience with a variety of platforms.
2. It was System administration and not Help Desk.

I feel like I was lied to and taken advantage of because I had a solid education with many high reccomendations from internships and consultants that I had worked with. I was told I would be the System Administrator which involoved maintaining the Windows servers and desktops. Now I do security, UNIX, Linux, maintain Oracle and mySQL, manage Web page, provide business decisions as far as vendor selection, service providers, wirte policies, created Disaster Recovery plan, and I am sure there is more. I provided pay scales for different jobs in my area and a list of duties. I asked for opinions on if 60K was what I should make. 60K was under minimum for IT Management and above System Administration. I just wanted opinions on if that sounded about right.

Somehow everyone decided I needed a good talking to and have since preceeded to post things that either have nothing to do with the question, say they can't tell since they don't have information I provided after the first person asked, told me I expect too much out of life, want to do too much for my family, should make my kids life as hard as mine was when I have the ability to make it better, sell my house and cars and cram my family into a smaller house and walk 40 miles to work, and lots of other crap.

As for the thing about my wife spending the money, that was a JOKE. I have managed to save money over the years even when I worked for myself. As I stated in my first post, I am almost out of savings. I took a pay cut going into this industry. Not my fault, got hurt, couldn't do old job, had to find other work. This job should pay more, not less, than I was making.

by maxwell edison

Here?s how I read all of your messages. You asked for advice and/or opinions, some people were kind enough to share their time and thoughts, and you?re arguing with almost each and every one of them.

I changed my mind on everything I said to you. On second thought, I actually think you?re overpaid now. Moreover, I believe that a person with such close-mindedness and limited thinking ability as yours, not to mention the total lack of listening skills, has nowhere to go but down. The cellar?s the limit for you, and the sky?s beyond reach.

You think you can?t, and you?re absolutely right. I was wrong. Please pardon me for posting such prattle as I did before this.

by naughtymonkey

Apparently you have a problem for thinking that was a bad thing. I have only asked people to answer a question about duties/compensation, not critique the way I live or the ideals I have. Everyone has gotten personal and I explained my way of thinking about those personal things and asked for their opinion on the actual question. What I provide my family with, how many cars I have, or how I spend my money has nothing to do with a salary comparison for a list of duties, average salaries in my area, or how much I am paid.

I understand, all the numbers must be confusing to you.

by jamesrl

You received an offer of a job. You accepted a job.

Has the scope of your job changed? Yes. Does that happen to many people? Yes it does.
Does that justify a 50% pay increase? Thats between you and your employer.

I hate to tell you but I did security, did vendor selection (for a Fortune 100 company), wrote policies etc, without the title of IT management.

You are in a different position than many because you are in a one man shop.

If you want more money, and you can earn more money elsewhere, go find that job elsewhere.

You have gained something at your current job. You have gained valuable experience. You are worth more than when you started. Parlay that into another job.

There are salary comparison sites out there. Use them.

Many IT people took pay cuts after the IT bubble burst. Most contractors I know are not yet back to the rates they were charging in 2002. Life changes. The market determines what people get paid, and if you are correct that you are currently underpaid, you should have little difficulty finding another position that pays more.

I would also share with you that I have never met anyone in IT who thinks they are paid too much, and not met many who think they are paid enough.

James

by naughtymonkey

Titles don't mean that much, it is the work you do. When your duties expand, they can compensate you or you can leave. I will get a backup and then re-negotiate. I am trying to utilize the experience here the best I can and hopefully it will pay off. Maybe in a few months I will have the job I want and I will post it.

by shellbot

you sound like a 2 year old..who told you to sell yer house and walk to work?
i made a comment that we sold our house to move closer to work so had more time to live our lives and spend the moeny we make more intelligently.
dang it, with the skills of inferenece you have you'll not go far at all boy.
you sound like my teenage daughter..apparently her allowance should go up because not only does she clean her room, she ALSO rinses out the tub after she shaves her legs..now there's multitasking for you.

you ask for advice, we give it, you take it the wrong way, think we are picking on you..do you think i give a sh1t about your life..?? we were simply passing along things we have already learnt in the IT business.
I'm still not sure what you expect..3 years experience is not a lot..in most areas your just above a junior..i think your getting apid pretty good, but if you want more, then go out and get it.

life is all how you live it and the friends you share it with.

i wish you the best of luck in all you do, you've worked hard you deserve it..but yer no hero..we all work hard to get to where we want to go..and to give our kids better than we had..i've tried to teach my daughter that being a hard worker, an honest person and a good friend are the basis for a good life..anything after that is a bonus. (and no i'm not trying to tell you what to do with yer kids)

by naughtymonkey

Now I don't know if those nice things I said about you were worth it. Someone else said I should move into a smaller house and sell my cars. I wasn't talking about you on that one.

I just wanted to keep the discussion on topic of duties/compensation and not about how I live that most wanted to comment on. I took the actual advice that applied to the question out of the posts and reworded my question to go in the direction it was leading me.

I appreciate all of the advice and I heard it. Why can't we leave the other crap out of it. I mean, why should any of you give a sh1t how much time I spend with my family... then don't talk about it. That was all I asked, but most people wanted to repeat the same thing over and over after I responded about their concerns.

Have you actually looked at how much of this discussion is related to the question. Not much, most is about how to raise families and spend time with them. Didn't ask for that.

by jamesrl

I qualified for some grants and some loans. The amount loaned was based on a presumption my parents would kick in a certain percent. Instead of thousands of dollars they gave me hundreds. But I didn't begrudge them at all. Instead, I worked hard during my summers and I worked part time through the year and I made it through. Yes my diet was always great and yes I didn't spend a lot on beer and pizza.

I will provide some money for my kids, but I can't pay the full ride. They know that even though they are many years from college.

I don't think it is realistic to think every generation will have "substantially" more than the previous one. And I don't measure myself solely on my income. I'd rather have people judge me on what kind of kids I and my wife have raised.

My wife could have worked when my kids were toddlers, and we could have had a nicer house as a result. We chose to have her take care of our kids. We don't judge people who make the other choice.

I will make sure my kids have a good chance at a good life. I improved my life from that of my parents by working hard and I learned and grew because of it. I would hope that if what they want is to have something like my life, they earn it, if they want something more, they earn it.

I read an interesting book about big business and families. Very few kids inherit the family business and have as much success as their entrepreneurial parents. Many of them screw it up and lose everything. There is a lesson there somewhere.

James

by Former member

Lets weigh this up, you have:
1) Two houses.?
2) Two cars
3) A good job
4) Food on the table.
And you are saying you want more?.
I will say this to you, you are lucky.
Out in the real world you be lucky to earn 10k let alone 40k+ 4%.
Be thankful for what you have done to achieve where you are today instead of complaining.

by naughtymonkey

If you don't have a response that has to do with the actual discussion, shut up, it's getting old.I work hard and want to be paid for the work as appropriate to my area. I don't know you and you don't know me so don't tell me about the real world. You probably has a silver spoon shoved so far up your a$$ that you don't know what real is.

I worked my way up from nothing, living on the street or in place I would not ever let my family go any where within a 10 mile radius. I know what real life is.

by absolutely

Apply for more lucrative jobs. If you get one, you will then know that you're now underpaid.

by jmgarvin

You might want to look at some of the state schools as well. It depends on what he wants to major in, but schools like UC Davis and UC Berkeley are pretty reasonable (for in state).

I should also plug my alma mater, the New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology. If he wants to be a geologist, computer scientist, or EE, that's the place to go. It's inexpensive and the curriculum keeps pace with the "name brand" schools.

Just to let you know, I pwninated a dude from Columbia that was some super excellent happy fun grad student. So, name doesn't always mean a good education.

by jmgarvin

A) What is the median salary
B) What is the average salary
C) What is the median housing cost
D) What is the average housing cost
E) What is the cost of utilities
F) What is the cost of fuel
G) What is the average household food cost
H) What is the median household food cost

So on and so forth.

by naughtymonkey

A) What is the median salary
Since titles mean nothing, I will look at duties.
median-72.5K
B) What is the average salary
average-68K
C) What is the median housing cost
1800/month
D) What is the average housing cost
1300/month
E) What is the cost of utilities
700/month
F) What is the cost of fuel
$2.90/gallon
G) What is the average household food cost
800/month
H) What is the median household food cost
800/month

MOst of these are rough estimates from what i know of families my size.

So on and so forth.

Car Insurance
200/month median 150/month average

Health Insurance
500/month median 400/month average

Car payments
600 median 400 average

Taxes
3000/year median 2500/average

by jmgarvin

I'm not sure I buy that utilities are that much, but the rest ok...sure.

So, basically, you want 60+k per year. Ok, so since you've held your job full time for 1 year, you can either:

A) Get a new position
B) Ask for 60k/year at your present position given the data you've given us.

That's about the size of it.

by tig2

I have read the entire thread as it currently stands- 30 something posts.

What I am hearing...

I think that you are frustrated because you chose this line of work after doing something more lucrative for the lion's share of your career. It happens sometimes.

I will say that I did not appreciate the "oh poor me" tone in your statement that you had been injured on the job, thus leading you to this career decision. Guess what? You aren't alone. I have a good friend that darned near lost a hand in his well paying job. Re-training isn't much of a possibility for him because of this disABILITY. He forges on regardless and doesn't have pity parties. I personally had to battle cancer, a declining job market, and identity theft in the same week. Guess what? Sometimes life sucks.

Should you be paid more for what you do? Very different question and will beg different answers. I get the sense that you are in a very unique position with the company that currently employs you. You are given responsibility beyond what a 3 year grad (with an AS!!!) would normally be given. You are obviously a trusted member of an (albeit) small team.

Why not stay in place for another couple of years and recognise that you will need to deal with the hand you have. Gain knowledge and experience. Then check out what else is available?

With managerial level experience, you will show up candidates that have more length of experience. You will be able to seek higher level roles that ARE more lucrative.

Why not consider that you have a unique opportunity and seek to make the most of it?

by naughtymonkey

a lot more than I hated my old one. I just asked a question that nobody could answer apparently. Got a few good bits of advice in a lot of bullsh1t. I don't want your pity or anyone elses. When someone asks a question or says something that needs clarification, I respond. I know what I need to do and I have gathered enough info to know what to expect in this industry. Now I am done.

by jmgarvin

Everyone here was more than helpful and trying to help someone new to IT out. Yet you come in here with your attitude that you know more than we do and your life experiences are more important.

You also come off as a someone who feels they are entitled and greedy SOB, so you might want to fix that while you're at it.

by maxwell edison

.....and we are looking at State Universities. But when he has aspirations of going to a school like Notre Dame (one of the schools on his list), I'm not gonna' discourage it.

by jmgarvin

I can't knock all name brand schools....It REALLY depends on the major and if your kid wants to go to a certain grad school (or grad school at all).

Notre Dame sounds pretty cool, esp if he gets into CS and wants to get into distributed computing (they have some bitchen research happening)

by shellbot

if you like stress then fair enough..however, does not mean you are being challenged.
stress is being micromanaged, having a boss that knows nothing about IT, having unrealistic deadlines, working all hours to get your work done, etc etc and it eventually does you in. My last job i was medication for high blood pressure off and on for 2 years..wierd thing, a month after i left it, they took me off the pills and I've not had a problem since.
Yes kids are stressful, and so are wives..god knows i pity my husband cause i'm a right b1tch somedays..but thats different stress than work stress..at the end of the day you can relax with your family and watch tv, play a game or have a nice meal..
at the end of a day at a stressful job all yer good for is going home and wanting to zone out which in turn adds more stress to your family life..

by tonythetiger

[i]I choose to give every opportunity to my kids[/i]

Exactly. That's your choice, not someone else's obligation. And it doesn't change your options: Live with what you have, ask for more, or go somewhere else.

by naughtymonkey

I am very passionate about my family. I know how much I can work and how much stress I can take. I have been dealing with that for a long time. Just because I just got out of school, doesn't mean I am not experienced in workplace stress and managing family and work. I am 30 and have been working for 12 years with a family.

You did give me some information I didn't think to ask for though. Is it common in this industry to do more work than originally outlined in a job and not get paid for it? You do a lot of different things, as fo I in my job. Did you know that going into your job, and if so, do you feel that you are being paid enough for doing the work?

Would you be disappointed in your job if you found out that someone in another company was doing the same job or less, in the same area, same title, same size company, but was making 30K more?

by jamesrl

Larger corporations like mine like to have job descriptions for every job, so that they can catagorize a job. Wee evn have questionaires that explore things like decision making responsibilities, levels of supervision, budget reposibilities, technical skillsets etc.

But every job I've ever done in IT in the last 22 years has included things that were not in the job description. If you do them, and you do them well, and they become a permanent part of the job, they are fuel for you asking for more money or a promotion.

At my current job, after a reorganization I am in a new group and my responsibilities greatly increased. A year after that, I got a promotion. I didn't have to ask for it, or even hint at it.

You may have been doing three years of part time IT work, but you have been a full time employee for a year. Thats not a lot of time. You can't expect to be paid what someone with 3 or more years of experience in the same role is paid.

I'm not suggesting that your pay is or is not fair, you have to do your homework on that, by check the ads and salary sites.

But I would suggest that there is a "relationship" between employee and employer, and this one is broken. You said in another post you felt they lied to you. I would suggest its easier to find another employer than to "repair" this relationship.

I know I've been there.

And yes, I have taken a job for less money that I was currently making at one point in the past. I did it to get my foot in the door at a large corporation, where I could learn alot more than working with the small mom and pop businesses I was consulting with. And in the end it paid off, financially and otherwise, but it took years to climb the ladder.

I really think you should just focus on the job hunt. You have had a good position in other ways, you have learned alot of different technologies and had lots of responsibilities that improve your employability. Just look forward, not behind.

James

by jmgarvin

Lemme start here...at TR it's all about tough love. We're here to help you, but you gotta want to be helped. You've been pretty defensive and most of the replies have been the voice of experience (we've all been there).

"I am very passionate about my family. I know how much I can work and how much stress I can take. I have been dealing with that for a long time. Just because I just got out of school, doesn't mean I am not experienced in workplace stress and managing family and work. I am 30 and have been working for 12 years with a family."

So is Joe Smith. Jobs don't care about this.

"You did give me some information I didn't think to ask for though. Is it common in this industry to do more work than originally outlined in a job and not get paid for it?"

You never served in the military did you? By the needs of the government comes up a lot...in the private sector it's by the needs of the company...so yes, you typically get a lot more on your plate than your original job description.

Typically your job description is a short list of duties. You'll gain more as your bosses find out about your strengths and weaknesses.

"You do a lot of different things, as fo I in my job. Did you know that going into your job, and if so, do you feel that you are being paid enough for doing the work?"

Money is only part of a job. By being so focused on money, you're losing the big picture.

"Would you be disappointed in your job if you found out that someone in another company was doing the same job or less, in the same area, same title, same size company, but was making 30K more?"

No. The intangibles might not be worth 30k. Does their boss suck? Do they work 24/7? Are they on call 24/7? Will they go to jail if they are audited and something comes up missing?

Don't gauge YOU off others, gauge you off you.

by naughtymonkey

I know how I can balance my time and I know how hard I can work and spend the time I always have with my family. I just want to know if it seems I am not being paid enough for the work I do or if it is common to be over worked and under paid in this industry. I asked for opinions on that. Nobody can give that. They want to tell me how to live my life or to tell me things I already know. If you don't want to give your opinion on the question, then don't post.

by naughtymonkey

that was the first straight answer I have received. Maybe they will give me a raise for taking on the added responsibility after a while, but how long should I wait.

And I have been doing IT for 3 years full time, not part time.

by jamesrl

Have you been three years at the same place?

Its been one year since the degree?

Personally, I look at things with a 2 year view. If they don't make a substantial improvement after 2 years, thats when to go.

And part of that is how it looks on a resume. If you leave too soon it looks like job hopping. If you have made an honest effort and not been able to work it out after two years, most hiring managers, myself included, won't hold it against you.

James

by naughtymonkey

I will give them some time while I get what I need and if they don't want to negotiate when the time comes, I'll leave. I spent 8 years on the same job before, but it takes a while to find a good one when you enter a new field. Hopefully it won't take too long in this one. I'm getting old.

by jamesrl

We have been telling you. You don't seem to want to hear it.

It is more than common practise to have extra duties piled on to your job, thats been life at every job I've worked at for 22 years. If you do them well, you earn promotion. If you do them well for a couple of years and master them, and don't get promoted or get decent raises, leave.

When you signed on, you were given a job offer and you accepted - its a contract. If they add to the scope of the contract, you can ask for more money. Have you done that?

What steps have you taken?

Have you done what I and others have suggested and looked at other similar jobs just to see what their salaries are? Have you tried talking to a recruiter?

You have been given lots of advice by people who have been in this business a long time. Listen to it.

James

by jmgarvin

You just aren't listening to it. You are are going against everyone, who has been in the exact same position, and act like you are 100% unique and that poor you needs more.

We've told you what you need to do, but you keep saying we don't know what we are talking about....

So, don't take our advice, make the same mistakes we made and then, in a few years, post here again and tell us that we didn't give you good advice.

*edit for spelling

by naughtymonkey

I have always found time to spend with my kids and I always will. I work alot no and I don't think it could get much worse. Lets not talk at all about my persoanl decisions, because to each his own. Lets talk about jobs and compensation.

by naughtymonkey

Tony,

I know it is my responsibility to provide for my family and not someone elses. I never said it was. It is also nobodies business but my own. But it is their responsibility to provide compensation for the work I provide. You apparently have not paid attention and should just not post.

James,

I think it was Shellbot that said she was going to pay 10K a year to her kids college. I think that is a great idea and I will be discussing that with my wife as a possible solutions. I plan on my children getting jobs when they can and working through high school and college. I do not plan on spoiling them. I had nothing, they deserve something, but they need to work for it. That has been my plan all along, but I have got to figure out the best way of doing it. I will not leave it entirely up to my children to pay their own way 100% though. I feel like I should provide assistance while still maintaing a work ethic for them.

And as for Post 29 earlier, I have done all of those things as stated in posts all over this thread. How long should I wait on them before renegotiating. I feel like I should let them have the chance to realize I am doing work that they stated I would not be doing. I don't want to approach them too soon and not without a job to compare with though.

by naughtymonkey

I never said nobody knew what they were talking about, I just want to stay on the actual question. My personal choices have nothing to do with it which seems to be all people want to talk about. I know how to make time for my family and I know my limits. Everyone just keeps saying I should leave time for my family. I KNOW (stressing not yelling). I just want to know now is how long should I give my employer to recognize I have exceeded my duties and am doing others duties that I was told I would not be doing.

by oneeyed

Greg, I'm sure that your employer DOES realize that you perform a job function exceeding that in your job description. However, as long as they think you're satisfied, nothing will change. You've been doing a lot of sticking up for yourself in here...it's time to stick up for yourself at work as well.
Just scheduling a meeting and sitting down with your boss to discuss this can make a world of difference. No one is a mind reader, and he/she may think you're perfectly content. You state that you do like the company and the people for whom you work. I'm sure the feeling is mutual, and broaching the subject is a perfectly professional response. Even if they can't do what you'd like, they almost definitely respect you for speaking up. Just make sure you've got your research done about salaries in the area, and bring documentation should they ask for it.

by absolutely

This article will tell you exactly how to use them all.

http://articles.techrepublic.com.com/5100-22_11-5269527.html

Note: [b]Bold[/b] is not helpful in titles because they are already in [b]bold type[/b].

by jmgarvin

I've worked in plenty of places where it wasn't possible or where your job expanded with you and your yearly evaluation would show compensation for those expanded job duties.

by naughtymonkey

I will try to re-negotiate then. I just need to get some certs so I can find another job easier to take to the table with me. I guess I have always had good luck with jobs in the fact that they recognized considerable changes and compensated their employees for doing them. Maybe this place will be the same, but I cna't afford to have a backup if they don't when I ask them.

by naughtymonkey

I just wanted to know if 10-15K below minimum salary for my duties was too much to ask for considering I only have 3 years full time experience. Is that an easier question. This all got very carried away in the wrong direction of the actual question I originally asked.

by slappymcnasty

Reading through this post and the various rants I think there are some things we know.

You make 40k
You do more than you signed on for
Estimate for job duties is around 65k
you work for a small family owned company
You are working on certifications

You are the only one here that can say if you are underpaid, from the things you have said, it sounds like you think you are.

So now you have three choices.
1) get a new gig
2) Ask for more money
3) maintain status quo.

My advice is chase option 1. Don't bother waiting for certs, jobs that you may get now won't be there when you finish your certs and there is no harm in looking. this will either prove your belief that you are worth more than you are getting now or disprove it.

I don't think option 2 is very viable. A 15k bump would be a very hard swallow for most companies let a lone a small family owned one. And then how long will it be before you see another dime. If you get the bump today, now way you get 4% next raise period.

Option 3 doesn't advance anything, and you can do that while chasing option 1.

by naughtymonkey

Looking for a job now. still going to finish my certs since most companies around here will not take your resume without them (necessary evil), and once I find another job I will give them a chance to counter.

by slappymcnasty

Good call, I don't have a single cert other than my BS in comp sci which I don't really remember aything about. I'm doing just fine without them.

by jmgarvin

Make sure to go in with all your ducks in a row and make sure you've got the research to back you up.

Go in with hard data from reputable sources (DoL is a good place to start) and tell what it means.

by naughtymonkey

on if it was normal across the board to be underpaid when comparing with salary report sites, or if they were right, if I should be paid more for my duties after 3 years of experience, and what any IT Managers thought about my situation. After the initial postings about family and stress, people started actually giving advice that pertained to the question. It just took a while to get everyone on subject. Of course there are still some stragglers.

by naughtymonkey

people who talk down to me because they think they know what is best for my personal life, those who insist upon telling me that my family will suffer (that is my decision and not the question I asked), those who refuse to discuss the actual topic, those who make one post criticizing me and don't read the response, those who just don't read in general and assume (there is a lot of that on posts all over the place), And those who act like I do not understand working and family (then when I point out reasons that I do understand and examples of my experiences, they question why I am talking about my personal life).

In the cases where I have attitude, I have a right to do so since it is usually after repeated attempts to get someone to either talk about the topic or stay out of it. Generally when you have to repeat the same thing over and over again, you get annoyed. Some people on here are like talking t my kids. I have accepted the advice of many people here when it was on topic and hope that I have shown that I did not mean any disrespect, but wanted to talk about a certain topic to those who actually gave advice that pertained to the subject.

Really only you, James, and Shellbot have given advice that had something to do with the subject and I thanked you for it and tried to explain my frustration with previous posts. I can't do anymore than that.

It isn't attitude, it is being frustrated that nobody would talk about the topic at first. If you were to post that the sky was blue and everyone wanted to respond that grass is green, that would bother you too I am sure.

by bobsaggtot

Not meaning to gripe here but, I am in the military and get paid around 20k a year. The more you know of our field in the military only means one thing, more work and the same pay as the next guy. When we have a WAN link drop or a routing problem ground troops are not able to request artillery or air support. So it's a pretty big deal when we have links drop. I understand in the civilian sector when a link drops or a routing problem occurs, lots of money is lost. When we have a link drop we have Americans dying. So I am not meaning to be a prick here but if you want to talk about stress? Yeah, yeah I know I signed up for it so I need to stop complaining. On the bright we have more servers, routers, switches, and CCM?s than we know what to do with. So I get to play around with some pretty intensive labs.

by clark1

I have a degree in Network Administration including Cisco, Microsoft, Novell, and A+ courses. My GPA is similar to yours, inducted into Phi Theta Kappa blah blah blah.

I would LOVE to have your position considering so far all I have been able to get is a part time position in a Sheriffs Office taking care of all the laptops, desktops, printers, server admin. Yea I feel I should have a better job or at least better pay but you know what, nothing beats experience. What I have learned and will learn in my current position will translate to a better job eventually. Yes the degree looks nice on the wall but what employers want is experience, proven real world experience. The canned labs in college very rarely have anything unusual to have to figure out unlike real world issues.

The money your making is right in line for your experience if not even a bit on the high side, the fact that you have 2 mortgages, 2 car payments, 3 kids and a wife have absolutely no bearing on what your worth to an employer. I wont even get into a rant as to why you have 2 car payments AND 2 house payments, thats for a different thread.

by naughtymonkey

I got an offer for 60K. They said even though I only have a few years experience, the experience i have is better than some who have been in the field for 10 years. Thanks to all the different experience I was getting at my job with different platforms and systems, I got a better paying job. I let my company counter, offered me 50K plus mileage for driving so far and continued 4% raise every year. I took their offer because I know the company and the job. Getting into the game so late, I need to stay somewhere instead of jumping from job to job.

On top of that, both my cars are now paid off, as well as my second mortgage so it feels like an even bigger raise.

by wtb1956

For what it?s worth its always a bad idea to use a job offer somewhere else to ?entice? your current employer to increase your salary. They have a tendency to start thinking of you as a mercenary and not very loyal. I had a friend that did that years ago and he didn?t survive a downturn. Seem that management thought he would be the first to leave since money was a major motivator??

I stumbled on this post doing some research and quite honestly, got sucked into this to see how it turned out. I feel for you, I was a mid level technology manager that moved into hard core IT years ago. I took a 50% pay cut, it?s hard at first but you do make it up eventually. 60K is really good for a three year old so enjoy it?..

by locrian_lyric

but beware the fact that you are now seen by your company as disloyal.

Oddly enough, your best way to protect yourself is to agressively demonstrate your value to your company.

Kick it up a notch and waste no opportunity to demonstrate how happy you are that your skill and talent are recognized.

There is also a self-serving aspect to this...
You get to add bullet points to your resume :D

by naughtymonkey

I did show them that I wished to stay with their company instead of running off at the first hint of more money. I also accepted less than the job offer to stay with my current company. I think I worked with them to satisfy their needs for a reasonable salaried IT professional while obtaining my earning requirements as for where I wanted to be today and the future. I took their offer and provided documentation of current salaries for my position in my area. I tried to set it up for a long future with the company, so I hope they will not see me as disloyal.

by now left tr

In just over a month since the first post......

"Both my cars are now paid off, as well as my second mortgage so it feels like an even bigger raise"

Right then!