Discussion Locked

Australia to implement mandatory internet censorship?

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

It appears as though Australia is on the verge of censoring the entire Internet, much as China does.

http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/story/0,21985,24568137-2862,00.html

This is being done in the name of restricting the trade in child pornography. An original proposal would have allowed subscribers to opt out of the program. However, the government has declared it will not let any users opt out of the proposed national internet filter.

Nobody is really surprised that totalitarian countries such as China would restrict Internet access. However, such an extreme proposal from a supposedly free country is not a good trend. Will this actually happen, and how long will it be before it spreads to other ?free? nations?

9 replies

by hal 9000

That you can not visit AU and then lookup your Favorite Kiddy Porn Sites?

Personally as one supposedly affected by this I don't have a problem with it at all but I very much doubt the ability to actually Implement this Proposal.

With the current Federal Government here there isn't a problem at all but I wouldn't say the same thing if the Previous Government was still in power as they where a Rat Bag lot who did as they pleased and to hell with the General Publics Wishes. Kind of like your Current Administration in the US Actually. :^0

Col

by jdclyde

because it is for more than kiddy porn.

[i]"The plan was first created as a way to combat child pornography [b]and adult content, but could be extended to include controversial websites on euthanasia or anorexia."[/i][/b]

by hal 9000

And they have no idea how to implement it. It originates from the Senate and if anything that are even less associated with the Real World than the other Politicians.

It is a Wish List of what the Polly's would like to have in place as apposed to what can be put in place. Currently the Industry is giving the Politicians some small idea of what will be required to implement this Proposed Development if it is even possible.

The reality however is that they are talking about preventing access to sites that promote Illegal Activities here in AU so what they want and what they end up getting can be different things. :D

As for Euthanasia the Federal Government overruled a Territory after it introduced Euthanasia Provisions in their local Legislation that where just about impossible to comply with anyway. This was the result of a Rabid Catholic Believer who was part of the then Government who was only too happy to force their beliefs onto others. He has since been voted out of office.

As far as Web Sites relating to Anorexia are concerned only those sick people who are likely to be adversely affected visit these places so if it is possible to save just one person from this Disease it's worth the trouble.

As things stand now if you visit certain Web Sites there is Mandatory Reporting to the Authorities which is heavily Policed and sometimes to the extreme where accidental visiting these sites for under 3 seconds can result in a Visit from the Feds who impound the Computer hardware and issue a nice little [b]Please Explain[/b] request. If these sites are prevented to be opened places like Whitehouse.com if it is still running what's the harm?

After all the Proposed Legislation is no where near as Restrictive as the Patriot Act and it doesn't impact on the general population to prevent the few from following their demented ways.

Col

by johnmcgrew

...this is the "foot in the door" of censorship of the Internet. And you actually answered the question when you mentioned the less than comfortable proclivities of the previous government. Sooner or later, the current government that you are comfortable with will be replaced by another one with different priorities and values. Sure, nearly everyone can agree that stopping "kiddie porn" is a worthwhile endeavor. But now that the mechanism (both legal and technical) is in place, how easy would it be for a "Rat Bag lot" who does what they please to address what they see as other social and political evils on the Internet?

If governments are consistent at anything, it's in their tendency to ask for an inch, and eventually take a mile.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

There you have it.

Don't know about you, but I have yet to find anything that is free. Please, impose no limit/s on the word 'free'.

by hal 9000

In the Middle of nowhere it is called Cantberra. The Polly's and those who live in this artificial city miscall it Canberra under the mistaken belief that they actually achieve something there.

The land that this is built on was donated by the Original Inhabitants as they didn't want it either but Cantberra is an Aboriginal Word which when translated means [b]Useless area fit for nothing worth while.[/b] The New Airlines only offer one trip a day to & from this backward place and the established remaining airline who provides several flights per day that means 3 only offer 125 Seat Aircraft that are in drastic need of maintenance. If they fall out of the sky Insurance is paid out to the Airline who gets a new plane and lots of money for Loss of Business. Over all it works out quite well provided that the Politicians and prospective Pollutions don't actually realize that they are a standing Joke which we all ignore.

If you jump up and down about their actions you only encourage them to do as they or their Religion Please. If you ignore them they go away and don't cause problems.

If you allow Politicians to think that they are Important they leave you alone but if you annoy them they go on a power trip and actually do something so it's best to ignore them completely and let them do their own thing. The worst that they have so far managed to do was impose a GST or Go Slow Tax that has increased the paperwork that business has to do. They wouldn't have even bothered pushing that one through if so many people didn't complain about it.

With Polly's you have 2 real choices ignore them and forget about what they do and they end up doing very little or jump up & down screaming at them and they then do as they please believing that they are actually achieving something. Their way of measuring their success or lack of it is to see how much inconvenience that they can impose on others.

Basically you need to understand how Polly's and the Bureaucracy around then actually works the more input that they get the more they do. If you ignore them totally they end up doing [b]Bugger All[/b] which is just fine with the majority of Aussies. What you need to do to get rid of unpopular things that Polly's do is let them leave office and then challenge their Legislation through the courts and it gets defeated as Unconstitutional the new lot don't care as they didn't impose it and the old lot is now powerless to do anything if there are enough of them left to even bother.

All you have to do is let em call each other names across the Floor of the House and they are happy. If you encourage them to do anything at all it's going to bite you on the Bum quite hard latter so it's best to leave [b]Well Enough Alone[/b] and let them do nothing as usual.

The previous bunch which I called a Rat Bag bunch is only that way because they had too many Fundamentalist Christians in it. Once they where gone things returned to normal and the old ones no longer in the Parliament are now touring the US Speaking Circuit as they are the only ones willing to listen to them.

Personally I hope you keep them over there we don't want them back. :D

Col

by delbertpgh

There is so much socially undesirable behavior running around; it's hard to imagine government having a tool and being given the mandate to use that tool, and then having the restraint to stop using it. It's easy to find support for stopping child victimization; actually, I'd be happy to see that sort of law in effect, if it can be guaranteed that enforcement is limited to that one type of heinous criminal activity. I just don't see anything about limits.

Right now, the kiddie smut is illegal to produce, illegal to view, and illegal to buy. I think you've got enough tools there to wage the fight (which, face it, will never go away regardless of how many laws are passed.) You don't need to add censorship before the fact.

This discussion is closed to new replies.