Discussion Locked

Best Options for backing up users hard d

0 helpful
34 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have clients that need the ability to back up information that they store locally on their hard drive. Because my server is running tight on space and can not upgrade server until next year, I need to give a few individuals the ability to easily backup large amounts of information that they are storing, incase their hard drive dies (which has happened).

These workstations have Windows NT 4.0 Workstation loaded. I currently have Iomega 100 Meg Zip drives on some machines. Their backup software requires you to turn off the antivirus software first, before allowing for backup to occur, which is not something I want to allow a user to do.

Any suggestions or advise on what would be a clean and easy backup method for clients to use would be helpful.

Thank you.
Barbara

34 replies

by ebob

The "standard" way of doing this that I have used is to run any of the brand name backup software on a server (ArcServe, Legato, Seagate, whatever) with an attached tape drive (or better yet, tape jukebox). The media has to have lots of capacity, which is why most of the new units going in are DLT with capacity of 80 GB (!!) or more.

The users just leave their PCs running (lock the screensaver) overnight, and the server is scheduled to backup the PCs. Some software uses agents on the PCs, some just connect across your network to an administrative share.

But this is NOT cheap, either.

But assuming that you're already backing up your server(s), and not just using Windoze Backup, then it should not be much additional cost. It will likely require you to rework your backup scheme, of course. And then there's that issue of user training...

Another approach is to have a DAT or DLT tape drive that the users just share. They take a couple of hours out of their day (maybe over a long lunch), plug the tape drive in and do their own backups. They could use Windoze Backup for this. You might be able to pickup a 2nd hand drive cheap, as other people move from single DAT to DLT jukeboxes.

You'll infer that I am not a fan of the ZIP/JAZ/CD-RW approach. Why? When local storage is measured in GB, and backup media in MB, I only see dozens, if not hundreds, of pieces of backup media lying around, with all sorts of risks, and time lost.

by ebob

The penultimate solution (today) is to build a Storage Area Network with lots of redundancy and reliability. Have your users either save their apps directly to partitions on the SAN, or at least backup to the SAN. Then back the SAN up.

This is really NOT CHEAP. But it is very kool!

by bsquillacote

What's the cost for DLT Tape Drive?

As for SAN, what is approximate cost for doing something like this?

Barbara

by clarkmk

We have started to install removable hard drives in our PCs. You can buy shuttles which make PC hard drives removable for about $35-$45. Once your hard drive is installed in one of these shuttles, you simply turn a key and pull on a handle to removeit from your computer. This is a lot simpler than opening the case and removing the cables and mounting screws on the drives.

To use this product, you install the unit base in a drive slot with front-panel access, and install your existing hard drive in a special carrier which plugs into the base.

If you buy multiple carriers, then you can swap additional hard drives in and out as needed. If you shop around, you can get 40 GByte drives for less than $200. In terms of cost per byte of storage, hard drives are one of the cheapest storage media available.

We use a product called UltraBac for Windows NT to do backups. We usually do an image copy of the main hard drive(s) to backup drives.

With image backups, if the nain drive fails, we can simply boot to a backup drive and restore the system.

by atroxodisse

You can buy USB or Firewire drives which can be moved around easily. Assuming of course that these systems support USB or Firewire...I understand NT 4.0 with service pack 6 does have USB support though I've never used it. Removable drives are handy, so long as you have a lenient BIOS. If the user has to reconfigure the BIOS everytime the drive is added or removed it won't be good for novices, and from the sounds of it you wouldn't want your users going into the BIOS anyway. If you do all the adding and removing of drives yourself its a great and very inexpensive idea.

by mckaytech

A DLT tape drive will cost a couple of grand but that pales in comparison to the costs of feeding them tapes ($75-100 per tape).

It's hard to project the cost of a SAN without knowing how much total storage you need but the systems we've been looking at have been in the range of $180,000 per terabyte.

I think the best option is a CD-RW drive. The drives themselves can be obtained for around $100 and the storage media is dirt cheap. At about $0.30 to store nearly 700meg, it's by far the most economical option.

The other option would be one of the remote backup solutions that pull everything across the wire - some are actually amazingly efficient but the licensing costs are significant.

paul

by admin

is in case their hard drive dies, as opposed to needing offsite or secure back-ups, a cheap dirty yet highly effective solution is to add a second harddrive to the machines that need back-up. Automate the process to either copy everything (with system files or do an image) from the first drive to the second after hours each night or use a BU program that writes to the second drive. It'll cost about 100$ a machine and you'll never be swapping media or need to do it manually. When you get a smallextra amount of money, build a more secure back-up server and use these drives in it so that they at least have copies in another (preferably fireproof) room. When it comes time that a machine breaks, you can easily restore the first or new disk, orif you image or include all system files, just swap the ide cables and they are running almost immediately on the second disk. I wouldn't even mess with hot swap -how long does it take to open a case and swap an ide cable? At any rate, if the users don't have to spend their time actually doing a BU it should more than justify the 1000.00$ or less in parts so you can put a simple BU server in with.

Just my 2 cents on a cheap approach that works.

BTW- you might be able to build a BU serverfor real cheap for these users if you have some parts laying around.......this could mean buying a smaller amount of disks and be cheaper even than a disk in each power users machine.

by admin

the hard disk prices, just explain to them how much a gigabyte (or whatever each user needs now and in the future)of zip disks costs, and then the fact that they are paying the users to sit and swap disks. It should be a no brainer when the facts are presented in this case.
If they are still needing a little bit of swaying, inform them about your concerns regarding the infamous "click of death"...

by mayurd

Why not just install another hard drive in the users machine or if there are too many users buy two large hard drives (80Gb) and install them in a spare machine and then mirror the disks for RAID 1 and instruct the users to back up to their share onthis machine...

by davevw

If it is clean and easy you are looking for, then Norton Ghost is the answer. First install a second drive in each workstation. Second, install Norton Ghost on each workstation. Setup the software to do an image copy of the original drive to the slave drive. You can run this manually or create a batch file or script to run it every night. This way the entire drive is backed up every night.
If you have a problem the next day, just make the slave drive primary and vice versa, you have last nights backed up image and are working again in minutes. since it is an exact copy of the master image, you will have to do no configuring or installing of software.
This method is fairly inexpensive unless you have 50+ workstaions you want to backup, then a DLT tape drive is the answer. Zip drives are pointless in this case because of their limited storage.
Good luck!

by bsquillacote

This sounded like a good option until to got to the part that stated "If you have problems the next day".

What can happen and how often, since I am not familiar with how Ghost works? I service over 100 users, so I am not looking to add more tomy list of crisis management if you get my meaning.

by admin

It will add less to your list of crisis management, not more. What can happen is in your original question -a hard drive dies. Instead of data recovery, reloading disks etc. you just change the slave to master and put a new blank drive into the slave position and voila! you are back to where you were right before it crashed. Disk imaging is way faster and easier in real life to get up and running compared to back-up and restore- but it does take up more disk space. Is this that much of an issue when disks are around 100$ these days though? especially with the cost and hassle of tape back-ups? Ghost is an additional cost- there are also other excellent drive imaging programs. A long time ago I just wrote a batch file to xcopy everythingand added it to a program scheduler to run each night. I've been doing different forms of this ever since, and don't understand why (except that sales people will never suggest it..hehehehe) that more people don't do this- especially for standaloneslike those financial folk that work at home etc.

by st0ut

Why not just have a linux box with SAMBA that can see Windows File systems...
copy the data from the clients and tar to tape. you can even script and run it as a cron job and all for free.

Guy

by craigwassel

We also use Norton Ghost. It is an EXCELLENT product.

You would also be acquiring not just a backup solution, but an invaluable utility for other daily uses. For instance, you can send up images of VIPs systems before you do any major work on them. If the work ends up doing more harm than good you wont break a sweat - just bring the image back down and put the computer back EXACTLY as it was. You can also send up master images of servers. If disaster strikes, just bring the known good image down, then restore data from the last backup.

by dpark68

If you are using Backup exec from veritas you do not need additional licenses to backup nt workstations or 2000 pro machines. You can just add them to your backup strategy. It may extend your backup window. But you will also not have to purchase anyadditional equipment or software. Of course this solution is taking for granted that certain criteia are met.
a) You have sufficent room on your tape drive to handle the extra data form the user shares
b) You are running veritas Backup exec.
c) your users are running nt 40 workstation, win 2k pro, or 98

by chipw

In my company we use Backup Exec to backup 6 servers and (right now) 6 workstations - about 40 gigs total, every night. We don't back up the apps (on the workstations), just the data files. The users have been trained to save all files to certain directories, which get backed-up, the rest of their system does not. Also, all 50-or-so people here have a private directory on one of the servers to save all their data files, so very little gets saved to the local workstations anyway. (I would preferdumb terminals at the desks myself).

by admin

but I have thought about the glory of a back-up program that would actually send a number of small date-stamped files out continuously over the network (or internet)to reside on other willing hosts which shared the back-up service.
In effect, I would agree to accept, say, 500mb of files on my machine and would gain 500 mb of storage on other participating machines. A technology similar to Gnutella could be used, but secured.
This would potentially make it easier for small networks to have multiple off site back-ups or to use their own network as a part time redundant storage facility.
Of course their are security concerns here, and encrypted compressed files etc. would need to be used...and probably a whole host of other things.

A related idea is that if you ever wanted to get an internet resident IE program out, it would sure be good to have it replicating itself as many places as possible to ensure it's survival. Backing itself up through multiple hosts in a similar fashion may ensure it's life even over long internet outages.

by st0ut

Reimaging a client from a Ghost disk will only reimage it. Save the drivers but the data that was written after the ghost image was taken will be lost on recovery.

unless i am missing something.

V/r
Guy

by admin

correct. The original request was asking (I believe) for a way to back-up, not recovery of the total disk.

Did I miss something?

by craigwassel

.... . if the user experiences a catastrophic driver failure at noon, it won't matter what backup solution has been implemented. There will likely be loss of data that was created that morning (unless, unlike most of the users with whom we all deal with, he/she does frequent saves to a network drive).

by tomsal

I agree, Ghost is one of the more useful "tools" in my little black software case where I keep all my most used utilities programs (right in there with NeoTrace Pro, Black ICE, L0pht crack, Snort, RotoRouter and Winzip...among others)

Did a full 6 GB drive image on a server in under 30 minutes.

Note: This particular server was slow as molasses too, probably our slowest even.

by atroxodisse

Ghost is a great program, I don't know the price but I don't imagine it costs more than $100, probably half that. I've used it hundreds of times and never had any problems. The only problem with Ghost is diskpace, it backs up the entire drive. Ifyou're just backing up Projects and keeping multiple versions it makes more sense to just copy the files to a secondary hard drive.

by admin

solution. I would consider writing to a second hard disk as an option too, and depending on your needs and disk space, you could compress it with tar or not.
the original message "tar" is the ultimate low cost geek solution though, great post! :>

by jchronos

I have to say that the tar idea is great and lw cost considering that you can come up with an old computer but would like to add that although it would be a good idea to do a full backup of the systems that it would be alot of tape and you would still have to sacrifice the Casio Calculator watches to the pc gods for data purity. so proposed that you also install cdrw drives that are scheduled to do incremental backups of local data files. this would not only secure the systems data overnight but also up-to-minute data recovery.... the users machine is down and you can still pull up a close copy of the important proposal.

just a thought

by apdumas

I assume you have already archived unused or seldom used information to free space on your server. If it is only for a few users, I would add inexpensive storage to the server for the "select few" who need it and create a batch file to copy from thier workstations to the added drives. This way the info is secured, NO caddies or drive trays laying about to be "misplaced" in a home PC. A pair of 40 gig (<$300)IDE drives (mirrored for fault tolerance) are more than enough for 10 people needing additional storage, and later the drives (after your NEW server is up) they could be utilized elsewhere like in a secondary backup server from existing parts OR in a workstation that needs the extra space in a pinch. So the investment is not wasted on a short term solution.

Again, I have been there with servers low on space and this was my "low-buck" solution to keep the budget people happy and still be able to get the job done.I also put archived info on CD that was needed only as a reference and wasnt to be changed saving room on the server as well for backup purposes.

by admin

OK, I feel silly now! This would be the most obvious, practical, cost-effective solution to the original problem :>

~Thanks!

by spanchakshari

I have 2 NT Servers and 55 Win 2000 Prof. Workstations with 3 roaming Laptops ! Ideal storage was NAS (HP Disk System) where users store all their Data and that is Backed up onto HP DDS Tapes on daily basis and for the Disaster Recovery - use NortonGhost ! Ghost gives an compressed image of the OS Partition and can be easily stored onto CD ReWritables ! Its investment plus lot of efforts to setup - but works great !!!

by ebob

Just get a deity to keep things safe and sound and guarantee you to never have a problem.

OF course, you might have to keep feeding virgins to volcanoes to make this happen...

by ebob

Or, I suppose if your MOBO or O/S can handle it, just turn up RAID (0?)/disk mirrorring. If your primary fails, your box just switches over. Tricky bit is knowing that you have gone into fail-over...some systems don't tell you too much about their state.

by admin

Yes, this is the slickest! I love the fact that RAID controllers are so inexpensive now :>

by wgonzlez

Some server based backup software allow to backup a user's hard drive by using backup agents. Backup agentes are "software clients" installed in workstation's h.d. Those agents can be configured to backup user's hard drive to the server's tape drive. BackupExec could be one solution.

by oliviu

I suppose you have a backup solution for your server (a tape drive).
You can do this:

1. If you have a small number of workstations you want to backup, simply map the directories you want to backup in the server and add them to your backup configuration. A problem will arise if some of the workstations are down.

2.This can be fixed by adding a new (big) HDD into your server (or using a different computer that you will be maped and will be always on), make a shared directory and have the files transferred during the lunch time or manualy by the user (create a batch file and an icon on their desktop). You can compress the files for space saving. Add this new directory(ies) to your backup configuration.

by info

I agree with Admin on this suggestion. In fact, you can take it a step further. As one member responded with drive shuttles. You could build two servers, one for primary access, the other for backup domain controller. With the combination of RAID 1 and drive shuttles, if a drive fails, all you need to do is pop out the dead drive, swap the jumper on the slave drive to "master", slide it back in and add a new drive as a slave, then reboot. You'll be back up and running in under five minutes. Also, having Ghost on the system will allow for direct imaging of the drive to restore it quickly. Then, let RAID do the rest.

This discussion is closed to new replies.