7 replies
by goodspeed
I think Windows 2000 Pro is better. You are looking at 7000 or more workstations and win2K will provide more stability than XP. Also there still more bugs & security holes in XP.
Hope this helps.
by 12345
by ebob
This is an opinion thread, so I'll drop my op. in right about here...
What matters is: what do you want to "serve"? Or, what do you want the server(s) to do? That's much, much, much more important than trying to match your server O/S to your workstation O/S.
Most environments with the number of workstations that you talk abotu will actually end up with a mix of servers.
Certainly some Windoze boxes. And if you have a choice between NT4S and W2KS, I would go for W2KS. I don't think XP is ready for use as a server yet.
Of course your server applications may require "real O/Ses" (he says ducking for cover) like some sort of Unix, or perhaps "faux-Unix" (a.k.a. Linux).
It's even possible that you might have a server in a large organisation running a proprietary O/S. But that is TBD on your requirements.
by 12345
by torque2k
I'll agree with the others, what you serve makes the decision much easier...
If you are set on using XP as your client OS, and you want a server to basically manage the addresses and logins, like a PDC server, then Windows 2000 Advanced Server with an Active Directory tree should work for you, but be prepared to buy a VERY powerful system. We currently have our PDC on a Win2KAS IBM Netfinity server (with dual PIII-933's) and 1 GB of RAM, and it's slow in the morning for our 1000+ users logging in on all sorts of client machines, and we're not using Active Directory, which we've tested to be slower than Dynamic DNS.
Just my two cents worth. Personally, I'd get away from the idea of using XP on the clients; Microsoft has changed their license recently for OEM installs of XP. You should look into it; it's now allowable to DOWNGRADE to 2000! Also, most OEM manufacturers are advertising that their newest PCs come with XP preinstalled, but watch out... if you're buying a bunch of PCs which aren't "business-class", you'll probably get XP Home Edition, which CANNOT join a domain!!! Most business-class PCs are selling with an optioned install; you have the choice of installing 2000 or XP, and once you choose, the other disappears from the hard drive. You can later upgrade to XP Pro, though. Windows 2000 has two service packs out, and one in beta-testing. XP has none. Always shy away from using the newest latest OS release from Microsoft; let someone else be a bug-catching post-beta employee! :)
by 12345
by 12345
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Networks posts
Sort by Trending