Question Locked

Can i Use ECC ram to run a workstation (xp pro 64 bit) instead of a server

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

im planning on building a extreme gaming machine, and just wondering if i can use ecc memory to power my machine ?

ive heard and believe that apple mac's are the gaming gods wen it comes to hardware bcoz all there ram is all ecc! (error checking capeability)!

although it'll b much more expensive to max-out a mobo with 16gb of ecc ram, would it b possible to use it as a workstation, NOT AS A SERVER ?!!?

many thanks in advance for all ur help folks!

5 replies

by thumbsup2

The motherboard you buy will determine if you buy non-ecc or ecc RAM. You'll have to learn to read the SPECs. If you didn't already know that, building your first system could well prove to be a very expensive experiment.

As far as which is better for gaming, PC or MAC, I will defer to the gamers among us.

Any PC can serve as a workstation. The OS you install on it is what determines its possible uses.

by oh smeg

Decide to purchase. Generally speaking Server M'Boards only use ECC Ram and Workstation M'Boards only use Non ECC RAM. You [b]Can Not[/b] use Parity Checked RAM on a M'Board that doesn't support it.

Just the same as you can not fit a 1366 Pin CPU into a 775 Socket. If you try all you will achieve is destroying one or both of the components. At least if you force ECC RM into a M'Board that doesn't support it it's only going to cost you a Replacement M'Board and any RAM Sticks that you may break.

As for what you chose to use that all depends on what type of CPU you want and then you need to Match the M'Board tot eh CPU and the RAM to the M'Board and so on. You can not just buy different parts and throw them together and expect things to work. Just the same as you can not buy a Tire for a Cortina and expect it to fit a Truck. ;)

Col

by butkus

Depends on MB. They will either take ECC in the BIOS or not even boot with ECC installed.
Any MB that took ECC was very specific as to what ECC chips would work. They used to use ECC because the old memory was not that great at times. This check the memory since server applications didn't want bad data written to the disks. Newer MB's or server don't even use ECC.

by jamesrl

It is a Dell Workstation (Precision 470) with 2 Xeon CPUs. The thing that enables it to run ECC RAM and 2 physical CPUs is the chipset. So if you look for motherboards with the same chipsets as a server MB, you will be able to run ECC.

Now I am a Mac fan, but I would have to dispute the idea that Macs are better for gaming, and that they are better because of ECC. ECC does give you a more stable system, and pairing RAM does give a small performance increase, but gaming performance has a number of factors, And above a certain point, having more RAM or faster RAM doesn't give you any more performance. There are very few games written to take adavantage of a 64 Bit OS, so most games run no different with 16 GB of RAM than they do with 4GB.

Buying a faster video card would be a better investment than buying 16GB of ECC RAM.

I think you will find that running multiple cards in SLI/Crossfire mode will give you the biggest bang for the buck.

James

This discussion is closed to new replies.