Discussion Locked

Christmas has been hijacked

0 helpful
237 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I received an email recently inviting me to a [i]Holiday Party[/i]. Okay, nothing new there. [i]Christmas Parties[/i] have long been replaced by [i]Holiday Parties[/i] in most places, and extra effort is often made to include those from faiths outside Christianity, as well as agnostics, and atheists. What was interesting about this particular invitation, however, was that while it excluded any mention of Christian themes, it INCLUDED themes from other religions and cultures.

Happy Hanukkah, it said, below an image of a Menorah; Happy Kwanzaa, it said, below an image of a Kinara; Happy Holidays, it said, below an image of a snowman and snowflakes. What? No Christmas? Neither in word or image?

I blame stupidly and ignorance on the part of the person who generated the invitation, and an over-zealous attempt to let political correctness trump reason. What happens when Christians feel offended because their religious faith and culture is excluded while others are specifically included?

Now I'm no Bible thumper by any stretch of the imagination. And I hardly ever discuss my own spiritual beliefs. But if people don't like others who celebrate the CHRISTAIN HOLIDAY called, CHRISTMAS, then don't celebrate.

What was once an almost exclusive Christian day of celebration and remembrance, soon became watered-down, and has now expelled the very thing that started it all - Christmas.

MERRY CHRISTMAS, everybody. And if that offends you, that's just too bad.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SXh7JR9oKVE

237 replies

by Member 25348569

You know, they are nearly always white, middle-class and guilt-ridden (about what?). They are the people responsible for "inclusion policies" in schools that removes all of the fun from Christmas in an effort to avoid "upsetting" those of different faiths. Hey, guys, Muslims and the like really couldn't give a chuff! Many schools are dropping the traditional Nativity Play in favour of a multi-faith or secular alternative. I don't have kids but, if I did, even this rabid atheist wouldn't be offended if my girl got to play Mary. The STARRING ROLE! Christmas is a time for fairy stories and pantomimes and the Nativity story should be considered in the same spirit.

The bureauprats are joined by the simple kill-joy. Bah! Humbug! A school carol concert in Dudley in the UK was scrapped because a resident objected to the application for an entertainment licence by the organisers. Oh, I do hope his name leaked out...

I LOVE listening to traditional Christmas Carols.

HAPPY CHRISTMAS!

:D

by santeewelding

Does no one see the Magic?

It has nothing to do with the schlep of religion.

If you see the magic, are you not compelled to speak?

by nicknielsen

For me, that song wraps the season up in a neat bow. When done well, it brings tears to my eyes. (When done poorly, it does the same.) She does well.

My favorite arrangement is Mannheim Steamroller. Unfortunately, it doesn't seem to be on Youtube, and you can't play it anywhere else without a membership.

by maxwell edison

..... I never said that I was offended.

I said, [i]"What was interesting about this particular invitation, however, was that ....."[/i]

Interesting does not mean offended.

And I went on to say, [i]"I blame stupidly and ignorance on the part of the person who generated the invitation, and an over-zealous attempt to let political correctness trump reason."[/i]

But me being offended? I never said that. I did, however, wonder about other people who might be offended because of the convoluted and warped way Christmas has come to be seen in a politically correct world of not offending non-Christians.

[i]"What happens when Christians feel offended because their religious faith and culture is excluded while others are specifically included?"[/i]

And when I made that comment, I didn't - nor have I ever - claimed to be a Christian. I've not discussed that one way or the other.

[i]"Now I'm no Bible thumper by any stretch of the imagination. And I hardly ever discuss my own spiritual beliefs."[/i]

I might be a Jew, or something else, or nothing at all, for all you know.

P.S. Good job of reading something that wasn't there.

by purpleskys

I couldn't agree with you more. Christmas has become over-commerialized, a "who got the better gifts" type competition.

For me, Christmas time is all about family. We don't often get to all be in the same place at the same time, so it's important to me that we're together at Christmas. We spend Christmas Day with my family and Boxing Day with Darryl's family.

Now, I don't take anything from the beliefs of other cultures, but by golly, Christmas is part of my culture, please don't bully me into making it something it isn't.

This one is by The Rankin Sisters from Cape Breton, it's a pretty song and it's sung in Gaelic
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HOHKA0elcCc

by ansugisalas

Apparently some people never got the idea that "lying in viking" is a seasonal job. Never bothered to return to base, just kept going ;)

by santeewelding

Making out the character of the responses so far. What Max said leading up to his "introduction" of the YouTube video was schlep.

The video was nothing less than an ambush by God, no matter how you count yourself.

by Member 25348569

but I don't really consider the "God" part.

I've seen (well, listened to, really) Messiah live several times and it's just something to wallow in.

:)

by nicknielsen

That's a good description of what I do: stretch out my legs, cross my arms, close my eyes, and tip my head back. Then just listen and smile until it's over...

Brahms' Requiem has the same effect, as does Beethoven's Ninth, Ravel's arrangement of Pictures at an Exhibition, Gregorian chants, and any Russian liturgical music.

by santeewelding

Is to come on full force, legions represented in their front lines, by stellar examples such as these.

Otherwise, stay down where you belong.

by santeewelding

Just watched the food-court performance again -- sixth or seventh time, now.

Until atheists stand one after the other, under an Arbys sign, and stun the assembled with surprise excellence, your cause has no chance.

by santeewelding

Dumbstruck at all else that others do, and have done through all these ages, that I have proven incapable of doing myself.

It's what I mean by, "the rest of you", meaning in no small measure those of you here.

by nicknielsen

achievements of your own, among them the creation of art, in more than one form.

With regard to creation, I am a novice; my art is seen only indirectly.

by Member 25348569

Yes, the music was inspired by Handel's faith and the words are from the Bible, but to imply that only Christians sing it...

Or enjoy it?

But, because it's nearly Christmas - Season of Good Will - I'll let it go.

:)

by ansugisalas

but as I'm caught up in it, I wonder if it's a figment.
And figs with mint?
BleX, no thanks.

by ansugisalas

A religion around the nonexistence of a worthy target for worship cannot fly. To try and disprove an infalsifiable is a hobby for willful nobility and practising royalty - and I think you all can guess what should be done to those.

by jardinier

I personally consider Handel's Messiah to be the greatest single work of music ever written. I also love the traditional Christmas carols, well known hymns and other liturgical music for the SOUND, not the words or the message.

I would consider it hypocritical for an atheist to declare a liking for this kind of music and at the same time deny the existence of God. Without the religion of Christianity this music would never have been composed in the first place.

Now I will try to embed these videos in my Christian website. :)

by nicknielsen

It is hypocritical for an atheist to appreciate a thing of beauty? That statement assumes facts not in evidence.

Beyond this comment, not even going there. I can hear the merry-go-round.

by ansugisalas

I would consider it a folly of the highest order if an atheist (or an agnostic) were to dislike such works on the grounds of it's literal content.

If it's a question of taste, that's acceptable, but there really are atheists out there so insecure that they can't enjoy a thing of beauty (subjectively, to them) on account of it's associations.

by Member 25348569

To repost my comment to Santee.

"Some of the most beautiful music has been inspired by faith. One need not have faith to appreciate these things, but one should accept that it shaped their makers."

I see no hypocrisy in that. Merely acceptance of what has been, and what is, now. And what will probably be.

Neil

Oh, and compared to Mozart's Don Giovanni or Verdi's Aida - among many, many others - Messiah is an advertising jingle. But that's just my opinion.

by jardinier

Indeed music is a matter of personal taste. I find opera unsufferably boring, with the exception of isolated arias.

It is not necessary to call me an "arse" just because you don't like my opinions.

I will not digress to a comparison between atheists and religious. I take each person as I find them. In my opinion you are an ....... fill in the blank as you please.

Go worship your non-god and stop annoying me.

by jamesrl

Its a piece I know well, having performed it more time than I can count. In the mid 80s I actually had the bass choral parts memorized, and on one occasion sang it with no music.

But I don't consider it the greatest piece of music ever composed or even the greatest piece of Christian choral music.

There are many lovely moments in it. The Hallelujah chorus is not my favorite.

And I don't think you have to be Christian to appreciate its beauty. I appreciate many kinds of music, some sung in languages I don't understand but that doesn't mean I can't appreciate good technique in the wirting and performing. In one major choir I was in we had a few Jewish members who didn't hesitate to sing the Messiah and they enjoyed it, without believing in everything in the piece. In turn, I've sung in a synagoge, in Hebrew and appreciated that music.

by ansugisalas

Awesome piece... four hours long. Sort of like a singing marathon, had to rehearse carefully to get everything together and still not wear everybody out.

I was in the third Basso group - that is; lower than the ones that are lower than the baritones. There was, as I recall, an H under the Low C in there... now that's not going to be really audible, can't even shout with notes that low - but the overtones will have their effect.

by tony hopkinson

asks the local bishop, with twenty boys in red gowns behind him.

Having given the extremely obvious answer.
"So seeing you are a good christian fellow, could you knock up a nice tune for us?"
Boys in red capes produce instruments of torture, pile of wood, some matches, but still have an anticipatory bulge left under their capes.

That genius George disappoints them with the right answer again! His promising musical career, not ony continues but is provisionally endorsed by the catholic church who were an early version of Simon Cowell, though not as nice.

So you were saying....

I love it when christians call others hypocrites, it's so easy to do people in when the catholic church had your back. Look them up, you'll find them in any decent dictionary under hyprocrites.

by jardinier

As I am not a Christian, never have been and hopefully never will be, I guess you are not referring to me.

I am "religious" but I do not align with any particular religion or belief system as anyone who is familiar with my posts over the last several years would know.

The fact remains however that, if it was not for the Christian religion, Western music would never have evolved in the manner it has, and there would be no Christmas music for people to enjoy.

So people who enjoy Christmas music must accept that it has been created by people who do believe in the Christian god. This is not proof that such a god exists, but belief in this "being" must be respected as acceptable and due consideration given to those who have found their belief an inspiration to create beautiful things in various of the arts.

by ansugisalas

Ain't shintoists allowed in, either?

And heretics? Say, that protestants wouldn't be allowed to dig the work of catholic composers?

Where do you draw the line?

by tony hopkinson

It separates the believers, the soon to be quite dead, and soon to be lit pyres from the people they haven't caught yet..

Step back quick....

by Member 25348569

"Sven", says the chieftain, "Do you wonder why you're not a very popular member of any raiding party? Well, it's just that you don't seem to have grasped the Rules of Viking: First rape, then pillage, [i]then[/i] burn."

:)

by jamesrl

I never saw them in concert but I did see Jimmy Rankin on a solo tour a few years back. My wife even flirted with him.

by tony hopkinson

Christians hijacked multiple solstice celebrations.

Commercialism hijacked christmas.

Now the PC boys have picked it out as a suitable vehicle for their dogmatic unreasoning stink.

by peconet tietokoneet

I do not deny anyone having their own faiths, BUT leave Christmas alone to people who enjoy it. This is a Christian way of life so lets us celebrate this Christmas and leave the Bureaucrats/political correctness (stupid people) in the COLD where they belong.
Christmas is a happy time for many so why do these political correctness (stupid people) want to destroy it?
Merry Christmas:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Y5GtaTrPHM

by tony hopkinson

early christians destroyed other celebrations of the solstice.

To supplant, to subvert, to utilise in the propagation of their own belief system.

You guys set the precedent, no point in crying about it now, never listened to the Druids and the Mithraists amongst others did you?

Come to think of it the followers of those two belief systems weren't exactly reticent about supressing opposition with pointy implements either. Pehaps Ug the caveman's belief that the big burny thing in the sky was important is the answer to all your woes.

by jamesrl

I don't have any problem with Merry Christmas, OR Happy Holidays, or Happy Hannukah, or Diwali, or whatever.

To be honest I am more offended by the blatant commericial exploitation of the holiday than someone saying Happy Holidays.

The gifts of the Three Wise Men only appears in one of the four gospels. Yet if you gage by popular culture, Christmas is more about the orgy of gift buying than the birth of the messiah.

If you ask me, the ugly commericialism is much more likely to destroy Christmas than those who wish to acknowledge and celebrate other religions holidays, which have been around for centuries (well perhaps except Kwanzaa).

by boxfiddler Hot topic

[i]To be honest I am more offended by the blatant commericial exploitation of the holiday than someone saying Happy Holidays.[/i]

by tony hopkinson

espousing a set of acceptable behaviors and then failing to follow them is hypocritical.
As in practice what 'you' preach'

Enforcing them while not applying them to 'yourself' is worse.

If a PC berk describes someone as unskilled working class coloured, what are they really saying?
Just a way of using the N word without being obviously impolite.

F'ing condescending whiny ass ****y babies, the lot of 'em.

I'm not offended by Happy Christmas barely means Christ's Mass at all now does it, so why should I be?
I could do with people not starting celebrating it in August mind, and better Xmas tv, but other than that, it's smiling grand children, some time off work and a new pack of socks.

by ansugisalas

I feel dumb!
Wait... I am dumb - no bad! :p ;)

Atheists can't win. I'm overlooking something.... Hey! You know what that means?!? I can learn something new!
That's awesome! :D
-Unless of course you don't tell me what it is... that'd be evil! :O

by jamesrl

I will add a few more in.

As a singer I have an aversion to the 9th. Its something to do with the vocal straining that inevitably happens. I know professionals who hate to perform it. I do like the sentiment.

As for Requiems, the Mozart is dramatic. But I prefer to perform the Faure. Its vision of heaven "In Paradisium" to me is subtle and nicely coloured and sublime. My youngest daughter would accompany me to rehersals, and she would cry(and not because she missed someone or because it was bad) during that piece.

I've always liked any of the Russian group of 5. I played that piece in High School, once as a brass player, once on ympani, and loved it.

As for Gregorian Chant, I went here during my Austria/Czech trip:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heiligenkreuz_Abbey

Didn't get to hear them live but bought a CD, great stuff.

My favorite Ave Maria (and I'm not catholic) is by Biebl. He combines Gregorian chant and modern choral singing. I'm sure you can find it on YouTube, I can't access it from work.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franz_Biebl
Sadly I was in a choir, trying to produce an album, and we tried to record this and it wasn't up to our standards, because it was a demanding piece and we didn't have time to learn it. Chanticleer does it very well, if you look maybe you can find their televised concert on TV near Christmas, it is very good.

by Member 25348569

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EDc2FD-vy8M&feature=related

Well, I was at a concert on this tour and, you know, I didn't boo! Ah, what a hypocrite! :D

Neil :)

The original recorded version. Sh:t! Was it THAT long ago! Ah, man. Where have the years gone? But I've loved these guys since the 70's and, damn, but we're ALL looking old!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lN9AJj9rtlk&feature=related

Maddy is still keeping it together, though, even though she's over 60! :D

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Now, let me spend a few hours hunting up more of their stuff. I've just been introduced. :D

Thank you!

by Member 25348569

If you want some traditional English, Google Tim Hart and Maddy Prior. They later joined/formed the group Steeleye Span, a bit more "electric" who I've been a fan of for over thirty years.

There's a couple more of Maddy's, below. Although I prefer her in Steeleye Span

Merry Christmas, again.

:D

by jamesrl

One year after they did the Vespers, and for many of them it was one of the most demanding things they have done.

Not for the music itself, but for the challenge of Russian.

As a choristor I've sung many many times in Latin, German and French. Occasionally I've sung in Hebrew and Gaelic. I've sung in made up languages. But I trust my peers about singing in Russian, I'm sure that for Russians or other slavic natives they feel the same about some other language.

I'm a baritone, there have been times I've had to try to sing that low. An e flat below the Bass stave is as low as I can make any real noise. On the other hand I can sing almost as high as a tenor, albeit for a limited time.

by ansugisalas

Russian as such isn't a problem, just have to take control of one's tongue.
I can't do tenor range-stuff without going all-out. I'm ok as long as it's a forte fortissimo or greater.
Piano pianissimo? No way!

I can do contra-tenor range stuff in falsetto of course, but I haven't trained it.

by jamesrl

In the 80s and even early 90s, I could force myself to sing tenor. But now its too much of a strain. As I'm sure you know tenors are in high demand and last year I was asked to sing the Messiah as a tenor. It took a lot out of my voice, and I told the conductor after it was done, never again.

If you listen to the Biebl "ave maria" that I posted the link to, when my choir did it I did both the chants, which are baritone, and I was part of the trio that sang above the main choir. There were a few notes above G that I had to do in falsetto.

by jamesrl

I went through the link, I knew it was a Canadian mall by a few visual clues.

Following through, I discovered it was a choir not far from here - near Niagara falls, and the conductor is one I've sung with in workshops.

by seanferd

the same way you have done it before.

It's amazing what I'll take the time to do, and what I don't bother with. Sometimes it seems there is no rationale or pattern, but in this case, I'd say it is because this link-trashing behavior was the final straw.

And god forbid you go and edit a post in which you have had to insert HTML entities.

by av .

I'm glad I work for a place that still has a Christmas party. They might have a Menorah lighted during Hanukkah in the reception area, but the party is a full-blown, Secret Santa, Christmas party.

The person who generated the invitation you received was an idiot. What about Christmas? Shhh, don't say the word?!? Where is that idiot video when you need it.

Merry Christmas, as it was and always will be, to me.

AV

by oz_media

As always, include everyone but don't expect everyone to include you. It's the same with race and even language (for Canadians/pour Canadienes).

Obviously the poor design, perhaps the oppostie of ignorance though and instead more of an issue of over awareness or trying too hard to be PC.

by jutpro

Thank you for this. You spoke truth.
I wish you and family a very Merry Christmas

by jardinier

Because I have been associated with Christianity all my life, having attended many churches primarily for social reasons (i.e. to meet girls). I met my first lover, and later my wife, at Christian fellowships.

I also love the sound of the organ (which I play to a modest degree) and the singing of the better known hymns.

Because I live totally alone, as a way of interacting with people, I participate in online discussions at certain Christian website. I skate on thin ice there as my heretical views quickly become obvious.

Because I enjoy building websites, I decided to put my knowledge of Christianity to some use and so created the website. It is possibly unique among Christian websites as I am not pushing any agenda.

If you take a moment to read the introductory statement, you will find that I do not state that I am, was or am ever likely to be a Christian.

Rather than waste time calling me an "arse," Neil might consider building an atheist's website.

by Member 25348569

Why would I bother? Everyone's beliefs are their beliefs and I don't wish to foist my lack of belief on anyone. If I were going to set up a web presence it would be a fishing or walking blog as 'atheist' is rather a small part of my life. I generally only bite when prodded or when I have the views of God-botherers or the wilfully ignorant pushed in my face.

by ansugisalas

I couldn't do a tenor gig... not a baritone gig either; they never allow enough bühnenforterung for getting me off the ground comfortably.
Like I said, ff is the very least volume I can do... I have strong cords, and strong lungs - I can get there, but only [b]LOUDLY[/b].

by jardinier

His responses to my posts are always the same: "Julian, you're being an arse again" (at least we both spell "arse" correctly) and this is regardless of the topic under discussion.

Perhaps I should add that if someone called me a hypocrite, I would respond with something more imaginative than "You're being an arse again."

by Member 25348569

Hypocrisy is professing beliefs, feelings, or virtues that one does not hold. With respect to religion, that just isn't possible for an overt atheist such as myself as we HAVE no beliefs. It really doesn't stop me liking a nice tune - and admitting it. I'm quite amazed that you might think that you could call me a hypocrite and expect no response.

Setting that aside, though, I'm hugely impressed that you're now adding literary criticism to your skill set.

by jardinier

Hi Neil. You enjoy music that was composed by people who had faith in God.

If that God didn't exist, as you believe, there would be no such music for you to enjoy.

Therefore you are enjoying something which, according to your viewpoint (there is no god), would never have been written in the first place.

I think that's logical enough.

But I'm biased. I think atheism is an illogical viewpoint. I know rather a lot about Christians, mainly from the online discussions. Many of these people's faith is supported by tangible, subjective experience.

Perhaps you could offer some personal experience which has convinced you that there is no god.

If you cannot, then it is just an opinion without substantiation and is quite meaningless as far as I am concerned.

by tony hopkinson

but you like xmas music, and Neil who also isn't a christian is a hypocrite for liking some of it.

Would a follower of the prophet be a hypocrite if they liked it. Is it theism that unites you?

Would being a christian and not liking make someone a hyprocrite, or perhaps a heretic.

Do you confuse yourself on a regular basis as well?

As for the rest of that self justifying post rationalising drivel, I will say only this another great talent also divinely inspired.

I give you, Torquemada.

Drum roll, etc.

by eyesak

There is an open full force attempt to remove Christians rights.
I am against it, this is another example among many. I E-Mail Stores that I will not shop there if they do not include Christmas in their adverts. It is already commercialized - that cannot be stopped and is good for the economy. A time when people have an excuse to perform random acts of kindness.
Whatever your religion, you can wish me happy Hanukkah, it will not deeply offend me.
I will not try to have it removed.
This is discrimination plain and simple.

Thanks again Max.
Merry Christmas