Discussion Locked

Finding your discussions -- A question for our uber-community members

0 helpful
28 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hey, several of you have said that you're having a hard time finding the threads that you're participating. We're trying to better understand this so that we can fine-tune what's displayed in your profile.

Can you help by telling us what you're having a hard time finding and/or what's missing from the current My Stuff | My Discussions?

Thanks for your feedback. We're going to keep tweaking and tuning, with your help.

28 replies

by ansugisalas

A list of discussions I've posted to (listed by discussion name, and showing last contributor).
A list of discussions my contacts have posted to (listed by discussion name, and showing last contributor).
**I put these in the suggestions sheet a while ago...**
Also, having a terse, densely packed thread view is necessary... otherwise, trying to find the live end of a large thread is like trying to navigate a mountain through a magnifying glass... really cool would be if we could have both the expanded and the dense view, side-by-side!!! That would be awesome.
Making chain-linked scrolling between two different listings sounds like it might be difficult, but that can wait... just having the "birds-eye" view would help enormously.
If I'm reading an enormous thread, showing all posts expanded, it gets to be quite a lot of work to get to the bottom of it, or back to the top.
On the other hand, showing 100 at a time, the threading is cut between "pages", which is also a royal pain in the backside!

by tink!

on any page that lists discussions with a "Last Post" time stamp. It's faster to spot new content via the name rather than a time stamp.

by charliespencer

as finding the new content within an existing discussion. Only the newest post is identified as 'Just In'. This makes it hard to locate any other comments added since I last viewed a discussion. There's no equivalent to the old ' *NEW* ' tag flagging all the latest entries; 'Just In' only flags a single one.

by ansugisalas

*New* - sorely missed.
Especially with those 100+ monsters (notice how it used to be 500+ monsters, that's the magnifying glass).

by jasonhiner

We're working on a new implementation of the *New* concept. It's basically a "Read" or "Unread" indicator on each post, and if you're logged in then it would use your cookie to follow you, so that even if you change computers you'll be able to tell which posts in a thread you have already clicked into and which ones you haven't.

We've already got the backend work for this feature finished, so stay tuned. We're pushing to deploy this soon.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

But I'll say this, as it pertains to the Forums and navigation.

The previous setup was far more efficient, for many reasons.

It let me know who the last poster was to a discussion when I opened the Forums 'front door'. I don't care who started a Discussion/Question. I do care who the most recent poster to it is.

The current 'View More', that at least in Discussions includes a synopsis is not of near as much value to me as the old 'View More'. I don't remember how many Discussions/Questions were displayed in 'View More', but there were far more than is currently displayed.

When viewing posts from my contacts, I need a far more extensive list than the last three or four discussions/questions they've posted to. I may not remember the exact post/Discussion I'm looking for from a contact. I need to see more than the most recent five...

Any sense of community and personality is missing now when I open to the Forums. This is precisely because so few usernames are listed. It was the sense of community and personality that kept me here. Sure, I'll still read things. But each time I enter through the Forums, which is my preferred entry method, I just get saddened because there's such a loss of 'community feel' with the new interface.

Revamping the new interface with the inclusion of the complete functionality of the old would go a LONG way towards re-personalizing the Forums.

[i] We need numbers back on the posts, too. And an easy way to view the context in which 'Just In' and 'Highest Rated' and 'Editors Choice' have been posted. Though frankly, those three are pretty unnecessary and glob up the opening page of a Discussion.[/i]

[i]edit to rearrange...
This new scrolly comment box is too small[/i]

by charliespencer

displayed around 50 discussions.

Ditto not being as interested in who started the discussion as who last opened their mouth.

by av .

I miss the "my forum posts" link that used to be at the top of the discussion. Now, I sometimes have to go into my account, my stuff to find the discussions I posted to or sometimes I can use the community preferences link.

The layout of the new site is very confusing to me. I don't like the "just in" and "top rated" at the top of the page either. Its just not necessary and takes up too much space.

Less is more.

AV

by charliespencer

at least move the identifying tags to the LEFT side of the post titles. As a 'set in my ways' old timer incapable of adapting to change, when I open a discussion I expect the first posts I see to be the first comments posted. I keep forgetting that's not what I'm looking at now. I can't help the habits y'all have ingrained in me over the last decade. I can live with the 'last in, first out' sort order many other sites use. But this approach of having two 'out of context' posts at the top is confusing, especially when you're opening the discussion for the first time and have to scroll down to learn what it's about. If nothing else, move them beneath the original post.

by cmiller5400

I posted a comment in a water cooler thread and I couldn't find it in "My Stuff". I had to go digging through the water cooler to find the post.

by ansugisalas

Off-topic discussions don't show in "my stuff"... but they do show in the "view more" listing found at the bottom right of the main discussions listing... this "view more" is very promising, really, except it's ridiculously verbose. If it could be trimmed down to just thread name, and who posted last, it would be awesome. Especially if it could be more densely arranged.

by michael jay

stuff but being able to sift thru all that I have, and others have said.
There used to be a way to look at separate lists of posts such as;

Discussions I Started
Discussions Posted To
My Questions
My Posts to Questions

These were links in my profile that I would use to bring up that content, and these links also existed in other users profiles that I visited enabling me to reference what others had said in these categories.

There was also a section on recent activity, showing all of the posts I was subscribed to whenever they had any new posts added, or someone added me as a contact.

There in the contacts section, it would show who was online of my contacts, always nice to know who was sitting at the table with you, I add contacts for people I think are smart, entertaining or just to keep an eye on them. :)

by nicknielsen

The visibility, and the granularity, provided by the old Workspace. The Workspace was the best way to keep up with TR without either inundating your inbox with hourly updates or overloading your feed reader. The ability to view the discussions you had subscribed to and seen the name of the last poster in that discussion is what is missing now.

Losing that capability and removing the names from the discussions front page did more, for me anyway, to take the community out of the community than anything else in the upgrade.

by jasonhiner

we made the "Just in" and "Top Rated" collapsible (like the three feature boxes at the top of the page)?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

it could work. But if we have to collapse them each time we enter a Discussion, that's a major boo-hiss.

by ansugisalas

The feature boxes do seem to stay collapsed... just in and top rated really had better stay collapsed too... I hear lots of folks are having intermittent logout issues or settings reset issues, etc.

Did you mean global setting?

by charliespencer

if only because it might be measurable. I'd like to know what percentage of the active membership sets them to collapse by default.

by ansugisalas

How does it track whether a person has lingered long enough at a section of the "expanded" view to know if something's read?
Ah, I get it, it'll be "posted since you last perused this thread", right?
That would help.

by ansugisalas

Right now "hottest" looks at amount of posts, and or points, and or something I can't see...
What I'd like would be if it shows which threads are generating the most posts per time unit in the last 24 hours for example.
Awesome would be : Showing number of posts per time unit (preferably variable time unit, 1h, 12h, 24h, 1week) AND showing number of posting participants (total, and in the time period).
That digest would show what we'd better check out.
Also, a thread with two active participants showing ten posts per hour, that's likely a flamefest (or lovefest, who knows).
That would be good.

by av .

I looked for your official upgrade thread to report problems, but I couldn't find that. When I searched on your name to find it, it pulled up all of your posts. I wanted to show the most recent, but when I clicked on the relevance button, I couldn't get to date. It wouldn't let you select it. The related tags on the left hand side of the screen have overtyped words. Can't read any of them. I'm using a 1280 x 1024 screen resolution.

Its not only that search. If I search on Catch up Cafe, its a much smaller search, but the same issue happens with the relevance button and the tags.

The site does not seem to refresh on its own and I find if I post something, I have to manually refresh the screen to see that its posted in the right place. The post does show, but I'd like to see where its posted.

I posted something in the wrong place a couple of days ago and decided to move it, so I removed the text and put in "posted in the wrong place, etc.". I saved it, saw the post pop up, but I spelled something wrong and went to edit it. The original text I deleted was there instead of "posted in the wrong place." I canceled my action and refreshed thinking this would fix it, but it didn't. The original text was still there. I had to delete my temporary internet files and go back into TR to fix it.

When I go into my stuff and look at my recent posts, they are not all there.

I'm not sure if these issues have already been reported.

AV

by ansugisalas

Something happens when you reload the discussion after posting.
It puts the post at its final position, for once.
So, the pre-edit text being there may have to do with not reloading between edits.

by tigger_two

Once I post this comment, I will have to click discussions, click "View More" under the Water Cooler, then click "Last Modified" twice to get a listing of the topics sorted by their last modification time. Give us a single click solution that will let us see Water Cooler threads.

I would put money on people mis-tagging threads so that they don't fade into obscurity in Off Topic. Alternatively, individual use of the site could easily fade.

It would seem to me that creating a tab for Off Topic posts would be the easiest approach to fixing this.

I understand that Off Topic posting isn't exactly TR's bread and butter, but it DOES provide a draw for people, many of whom hang around for the tech content.

Beyond that, it would be lovely to see more two way communication.

by maxwell edison

I want new comments to jump out and bite me ....... well, you know. The RED NEW did just that. Why was it taken away?

by hal 9000

At the moment it's impossible to follow any discussion that gets more than a few posts to it.

Col

by tigger_two

I just scroll to the bottom to find the most recent post. If it isn't there and the discussion is a long one, I tend to give up.

The "Just In" thing at the top is meaningless. I'm not glued to the site every minute of every day. No one is. I have no way of knowing what I missed in addition to the comment labeled "Just In". Besides, reading a comment out of context is worse than meaningless, it's idiotic. Without context, you have no way of understanding the poster's meaning... ESPECIALLY if that poster is Santee.

I suppose we need to give them time to iron out the kinks, but it is really hard to commit any meaningful time to being frustrated.

This discussion is closed to new replies.