Gays Serving in the U.S. Military - Who should decide?
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
After Hours
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by ansugisalas
to the people who went into the hedge rows...
At some point it becomes clear to people that letting one through means friends dying, self too.
But shooting to kill is usually uneconomical anyway.
by oz_media
by nicknielsen
But my service started just as Vietnam was ending (Saigon fell when I was in basic) and ended before 9/11. I can, however, understand why it might have gotten worse, and may even agree with them.
All those currently on active duty in all services [u]volunteered[/u] to defend their country, and many did it during an actual, live, shooting war. While they are deployed and trying just to survive, they look back to the States and see:
- life going on as usual, with no sacrifices on the part of the majority of the population.
- @$$holes like those clowns from Iowa protesting at military funerals.
- all those brokers and speculators busy lining their pockets and taking down the economy.
- Congress too busy trying to make political points to govern the country.
Are you surprised that an attitude of disdain toward civilians is evident under such circumstances?
There's an easy way to take care of the problem: universal national service. [u]Everybody[/u] who is physically and/or mentally capable performs two years of national service: military, medical, conservation, whatever. All at minimum wage (less room and board), all under the auspices of the federal government, and [b]never[/b] within 500 miles of home. Maybe, just maybe, we can then stop focusing on the differences and start seeing how we are all alike.
But that will never happen. It takes special people to make those kinds of sacrifices, and most Americans aren't that special. (See the attitude coming through?)
by nicknielsen
by nicknielsen
Each enlistee has a different reason, but the common trait I encountered is a strong belief in the need to give something back.
During the late 70s, I served with several who enlisted because the military was the only honorable escape from whatever backbreaking industry (usually mining) was the prime employer in their town. Many of those who enlisted during the Bush recession in the late 80s came in for the GI Bill, then took a step back and said "Whoa!" when faced with an actual shooting war in 1991.
One thing many don't understand is that in the past, the vast majority of military members were not usually placed in direct danger. The use of suicide bombers and IEDs has changed that dramatically.
by oz_media
Personally, as someone who knows a former American who served with the marines, he agrees that MOST of his batallion/company, whatever, were there because they didn't want to be on the streets with the gang violence. It was better to be paid to shoot, they were underprivileged, downtrodden and just plain pi$$ poor broke. The military was a job, one that paid more than MacDonalds and, if you really wanted to get ahead, paid for your college education.
I have referred to it as America's answer to welfare, but those were initially his words, not mine. Sure many here would disagree, but they are also people who have been to college, were mainly not in a visible minority, have good jobs etc.
What about the rest?
Dental and medical coverage? Food, clothing, quarters AND pay?
Luxury, and all you have to do is shoot at people? Growing up in a neighborhood where that is a daily event makes it seems no different than home, except MUCH cushier.
by nicknielsen
I had them myself.
This paper provides some very enlightening (and, if you wish to claim over-representation by the urban poor, possibly disheartening) numbers.
What did not surprise me is that the military is, on average, [u]more[/u] educated than the general public.
by oz_media
ON machismo, I think you nailed it right there. It just ain't cool to be gay as gay is seen as soft and submissive. Even though many gay guys are actually in better physical shape, more macho and far more masculine than a many straight guys. Gay guys aren't always effeminate, which is why most people are so shocked when they find out a friend is gay, those we expect are no surprise.
Suppose they feel it would diminish the HOO-RAH, followed by primitive chest beating and baring of teeth! (and some people still think we aren't an evolved primate, LOL )
by delbertpgh
This was, I believe, the underlying sentiment in making my comment in the first place:
[i]In that same vein, so many people in this discussion have presumed to do two things: they first seem to group everyone of the gay persuasion as having a like-mind; they then seem to presume to know, with absolute certainty, what goes on in the minds of all those like-minded people. Both of those suggestions, if you really think about it, are utterly preposterous![/i]
So if you really think about it - and look at all of the messages - it's other people who've made the preposterous presumption there was a [i]gay mind[/i], not me.
Case in point:
By the way, other than my own, I've never been into the mind of a heterosexual person either! Would that comment draw the same reaction from you?
If you take anything derogatory out of either comment, mountains and molehills immediately come to this mind.
You're too funny!
Needless to say, I'd be voting for Newt!
.... just about impossible. It would be no more than your typical [i]Demonize Republicans[/i] nonsense.
By the way, both Newt Gingrich and Bill Clinton would acknowledge that they worked together, behind the scenes, to achieve a balanced budget in the 1990s. But if you buy into said [i]demonize Republicans[/i] nonsense, your bias just wouldn't allow you to see it.
.....care to read the comment above my reply and you will understand what I was talking about.
thanks and cheers!
Re: [i]Dude's smart ..... I haven't seen any other economist who has seen the issues on this mortgage/banking crisis as well or as early as Krugman. [/i]
Let's see who can find proof as to who - economist or otherwise - might have predicted the mortgage/banking crisis earlier. You nominate Paul Krugman, so give me a date of the prediction. Otherwise, it's an empty and unsubstantiated comment.
Having said that, I'll call your Paul Krugman, and raise you a Ron Paul.
July 2002:
http://www.ronpaul.com/2008-09-26/ron-paul-on-the-housing-bubble-july-2002/
In 2005, Barney Frank said, [i]"You're not going to be seeing a collapse [in the housing market] that you see when people talk about a bubble..."[/i]
http://www.dailypaul.com/node/91615
[i]"I hope my colleagues join me in protecting taxpayers from having to bail out Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac when the housing bubble bursts." [/i]
-Ron Paul again in 2005
What was Krugman saying in 2002?
You, no doubt, mean, "On Killing", by Grossman.
Please be more clear about your sources.
by oz_media
Many WWII and other war Documentaries state this too, not just for US but for all other solders too. It's actually a pretty widely discussed fact that has been known for years and the US military has tried to address it for decades. They even talk about how it has slowly gotten better over time but is still very apparent in the field.
Sources? Open your eyes and ears, I'm sure it's not the first time it's been said. Google is your friend.
It was reported that in Vientnam, of every 1 enemy killed, over 50,000 shots were fired. Now I know that every bullet can't hit and there was a LOT of suppressing fire, but as far back as Napoleon, it is proven that soldiers often purposely fire over the heads of the enemy. This is actually what spurned the use of suppressing fire to begin with. They have tried many resolutions to get soldiers to fire AT enemies instead of 'toward their general area'.
But On Killing, I have heard of but never read not seen much on it nor have I read it, though I believe it shares a similar, common theme.
Unfortunately, as always, for those who feel it is not right, they will take such a book that has been found questionable and use it to dispel any such reports from any sources, whether fact or fiction. Just close your eyes and plug your ears and pretend it applies to all others.
by oz_media
"We are now, I fear, in the early stages of a third depression. It will probably look more like the Long Depression than the much more severe Great Depression," Krugman writes in the New York Times."
June 28th, 2010 - LOL :D
Like they say, hindsight is 20/20 :D
by oz_media
by delbertpgh
Certainly there was give and take to get a budget passed.
To say they collaborated to balance the federal budget overstates their shared contribution to the outcome.
The budget was balanced in the last couple years of the Clinton presidency, but only after Newt had quit as speaker (Jan 1999), and because tax revenue soared with the swelling capital gains from the stock market bubble. The Dow went from 3740 to 11490 in the six years from Newt's ascendency to the speakership to Bush's victory in 2000. Everyone was quite surprised and pleased, except Alan Greenspan.
It would be fair to say they cooperated on welfare reform. Both had interests that converged on that topic.
by ansugisalas
They can also show that people who, during exercises using blank rounds, don't actually bother to aim to hit (since there's no chance of hitting with blanks anyway), also don't hit the target very well when in live situations.
But if we look at the trench warfare of WWI, I'd wager that lots of someones (mostly draftees) aimed to hit. Letting the other bloke get to grenade-lobbing range wasn't very appealing. And that was a warzone with really apalling morale issues, and even worse command issues.
by oz_media
Perhaps people are trying to iterate the gay mindset, way of thinking, the opposite of a heterosexual mentality.
However, there IS question and study as to the actual brain of a gay man being somewhat different.
[i]
"A compound taken from male sweat stimulates the brains of gay men and straight women but not heterosexual men, raising the possibility that homosexual brains are different, researchers in Sweden has reported."
"...This time they compared the reactions of 12 women, 12 heterosexual men and 12 homosexual men.
AdvertisementAdvertisement
They let them smell EST, AND and ordinary odours such as lavender, and used positron emission tomography to watch their brain responses.
"In contrast to heterosexual men, and in congruence with heterosexual women, homosexual men displayed hypothalamic activation in response to AND," Savic's team wrote.
And a region of the brain called the anterior hypothalamus responded most strongly - an area that in animals "is highly involved in sexual behaviour".[/i]
I'm not too sure I swallow it, perhaps gay men AND women are attracted merely because it indicated MAKE to them and they have actually trained their own brains to recognize and respond to such subtleties.
by ansugisalas
So... it's ok to be homosexual, as long as you don't behave?!?
That's so twisted :p
But seriously; how can that keep homosexuals out of the military if they do not engage in "conduct" while serving? Wouldn't it then be allowed them to serve openly, and openly gay, as long as they're celibate?
Confusing.
by nicknielsen
654(b)(2) applies when ...[i]the member has stated that he or she is a homosexual or bisexual, or words to that effect, unless there is a further finding, made and approved in accordance with procedures set forth in the regulations, that the member has demonstrated that he or she is not a person who engages in, attempts to engage in, has a propensity to engage in, or intends to engage in homosexual acts. [/i]
The [half-joking] interpretation of the qualification on further findings when I was active was that the only way to verbally "come out" and not be forced out was to have more than three kids born out of wedlock or be married with children.
The law states you cannot serve on active duty if:
- you participate in homosexual acts;
- you say you are homosexual; or
- you are in, or tried to enter into, a homosexual marriage
by ansugisalas
Also, completely pointless.
But then, it was all just partisan warfare to begin with, and it shows.
So, to Maxwell; I would say that letting partisan crap ooze all over your military isn't something you'd normall subscribe to. Or is it?
EDIT:+ > PLUS
by oz_media
I thought that, despite the fact that many heterosexual relationships take place in the military, they were not supposed to and that coming out as heterosexual was no big deal.
I think there is a very broad difference between that and coming out as a gay male in the military.
by nicknielsen
Primarily service regulations and two articles in the UCMJ:
There is an article on sodomy, but I don't think that has been used in the last 40 years, outside prosecutions for rape or homosexual activity
by oz_media
The specifics of the Article are irrelevant.
There are marines that get married, there are many married couples in the military. Chasing after girls around base is sexual harrassment, just as and guys hitting on other guys, gay or straight, would be.
The issue of sexual harrassment charges alone keeps people's inner feelings under wraps, when it doesn't they face charges, just as they would in civilian life too.
by ansugisalas
Have you noticed how much effort is put into dehumanizing (demonizing) the public's opinion of soldiers of enemy nations during warfare? It's the same thing, it's hard to come to terms with having to destroy arbitrary fellows, especially seeing how that trend applies also to them against you.
It's like "Do unto others..."
Statistically, trying to harm another human is emotionally difficult, that much I'm sure of, too.
Sadly, that doesn't stop us from doing it without trying.
OMG what a laff !!
The only point of my note is that the manner in which people act in the showers, the bus stop or in the office is [b]not defined by their sexuality[/b].
It's a point you either continually miss or deliberately disagree with, but lack the honesty to confront.
Being "the devil's advocate" diminishes not the message. If you have to ask the question in the first instance, then you are fundamentally missing the point.
by nicknielsen
died in 1937, only 9 years after the discovery of genetic transformation, and 7 years before the determination that DNA was responsible for that transformation. For most of Adler's life, genetics was understood primarily through Gregor Mendel's observations.
How can somebody from an era with little more than rudimentary genetic knowledge be considered an authority on what is or is not genetically-determined?
I, too, studied intensively Adler, along with Freud, Brenner, Brill, Jung, and the rest.
Came away thinking even before all what we think we know about genetics and epigenetics, "These guys don't have a clue!"
They go around in circles, along with Kant and his brethren.
Means you get to roll up your own sleeves -- assuming any of this matters -- and do it yourself.
I did. I do not appreciate anyone who fastens himself, for want of his own wits, to anything, this [b]carlo[/b] guy included.
and based his conclusion that homosexuals were neurotics on direct observations of patients, knowing inside out the history and background of each of them. He concluded that Homosexuality is a neurotic vice acquired in the course of certain life circumstances, as humans learn to practice all sorts of defects and vices, hardened by continuous training to get deeper and deeper in oneself. You have numerous examples of this dynamic in almost all human activities: positive and negative alike. In certain cases the disorder can be cured with psychotherapy and methods such Autogenic Training by I.H. Schultz, though very often it's seated too deep. Adler says that it's like trying to make out of a coward a courageous man. This modern legend of covering human misbehavior by claiming GENETICS is to be outright dismissed. Alfred Adler was not so deficient when observing his patients very well known to him at times when the debate was alive. The actual word ''Homosexuality'' appeared for the first time in 1914 on an American magazine: The Homosexual Problem. Fashion and social trends are nowadays the main learning source of this phenomenon, like drugs usage and all exotic and punky exibitionism since the 60's, mainly in Anglo-Saxon countries spread later all over the Western World via media and tourism. English Public Schools for Boys were famous for early learning of the perversion. Later in life many of those students 'converted' to normal behavior when they had become more proficient in approaching the by far more appealing opposite sex: Women.
NickNielsen I suggest you have a deep reading of Adler's work: Das Problem der Homosexualitaet and then you will see how genetics can be the answer. Cheers!
by nicknielsen
http://www.thestate.com/2010/10/31/1536122/friedman-cant-keep-a-bad-idea.html
I particularly like the juxtaposition of these two sentences:
...[i]Let's pay for more tax cuts by uncovering waste I can't identify, fraud I haven't found and abuse that I'll get back to you on later.
All that's missing is any realistic diagnosis of where we are as a country and what we need to get back to sustainable growth.[/i]
edit: flippin' ? marks
by nicknielsen
before Strom Thurmond "converted" in 1964. All those other people were Democrats (or their forebears).
The Republicans were "the Party of Lincoln" and that just wasn't happening in South Carolina until after Strom took the plunge.
by oz_media
I have read that, specifically during WWI, trench warfare and even further back to Napoleonic trench warfare, that is where they started to notice people firing overhead. Napoleon used to walk through the trench and smack anyone firing high and tell them to bring it down he was shocked at how the majority of his men choose to aim high and hope it suppressed the enemy and hopefully some other soldier would kill them.
Of course trench warfare is generally fought hand to hand, with bayonets fixed. But when firing from trench to trench, it has been noted that since military history has been traced, soldiers tend to purposely aim high. Modern training has made accurate fire more common but it still has a way to go before all soldiers will start to properly aim down the sights to target his enemy head on.
Interesting article!
[b]From memory to history
After the deaths of Harry Patch, at 111, and Henry Allingham, at 113[/b]
[i]"In old age both men had an urgent message, so urgent that it almost exhausted their small supply of breath. ?War?s stupid,? said Mr Allingham. ?Nobody wins. You might as well talk first, you have to talk last anyway.? ?T?isn?t worth it,? said Mr Patch. ?War isn?t worth one life.? They did the job they were asked to do??for 18 pence a flippin? day.? And they knew that the German enemy, too, were fighting under compulsion. From the first day, Mr Patch made a pact with his mates on the Lewis gun that they wouldn?t shoot to kill, only to wound. As far as he knew, he kept his pledge. Even the German who tried to bayonet him in no-man?s-land was only to be brought down with bullets in the leg. Similarly Mr Allingham, billeted with a German family after the Armistice, gave them the two precious oranges he received from Dorothy for Christmas. ?We were all victims,? said Mr Patch.[/i]
Yes just one rough example but the page is very interesting! Such mentality is not alone, just like Vietnam or Iraq, many people really didn't want to be there or thought they should be once they got there.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by oz_media
In many cases, and I know my father once told me too, when it comes down to it, that split second when you realize you are now about to take another human life, many people just can't do it or at least prefer not to unless they absolutely must or die themselves.
The fire high exercise was what commonly happened in past wars, so much so that there were more purposely missed shots than aimed and accurate.
The mentality of the soldier has been changed through training, if the whole country hates the enemy, whether founded or not, as well as the solder, there is a greater chance of accurate shots to kill. of course with modern weaponry having much greater accuracy, it's a bit harder to fake it too I would expect.
But for those with very strong morals, they will be more reluctant to take another life.
And, I agree completely. I would add to what you said below about morality that strength of morality is not a factor. I see it as cognizance of morality in the first place.
Taken down to the wire, morality may get you killed. Morality abandoned at the last moment may keep you alive.
In, The Daily Reckoning, has been taking both -- Friedman and Krugman -- to severe task for years, not to mention Geithner, et al.
I am inoculated, by, as well, Whiskey and Gunpowder.
Not to mention, other denizens of the financial and economic world who do this all for their contrapunctual, free-market living.
by delbertpgh
In a NYT column titled "Double Dip", he predicted that if Greenspan lowered interest rates, the deflationary risk incurred by the stock market asset bubble would be avoided, but only by a new bubble in real estate.
http://www.nytimes.com/2002/08/02/opinion/dubya-s-double-dip.html
He said: The basic point is that the recession of 2001 wasn't a typical postwar slump, brought on when an inflation-fighting Fed raises interest rates and easily ended by a snapback in housing and consumer spending when the Fed brings rates back down again. This was a prewar-style recession, a morning after brought on by irrational exuberance. To fight this recession the Fed needs more than a snapback; it needs soaring household spending to offset moribund business investment. And to do that, as Paul McCulley of Pimco put it, Alan Greenspan needs to create a housing bubble to replace the Nasdaq bubble.
I'm aware that a certain crowd of influencers is trying (dishonestly) to spin his comments as advocating a real estate bubble. Given that it would be unspeakably stupid for anybody to stump for a new bubble as medicine for the last bubble, it would be inexplicable that a professional economist would commit professional suicide by advocating such a thing. The explanation is that he was explaining the consequences, and not recommending a bubble as an objective, of the sole tool that Greenspan had at hand, which was prolonged easy credit. Fortunately for these bloggers, their readers' credulity is matched by a shortness of economic I.Q., so they pretty much get away with peddling their crazy story.
Krugman made reference to an article by Paul McCulley of PIMCO:
http://www.pimco.com/Pages/FF_08_2002.aspx
The critical piece of the article that explains the context of Krugman is this:
Renewed bank appetite for corporate liquidity lending, outright and on a contingent basis, is the necessary condition for truncating debt-deflation risk, not cuts in the Fed funds rate. Not that I'm necessarily against further cuts in the Fed funds rate. (I've often been accused of never meeting a Fed funds cut that I didn't like, and there is some truth to that.) My point is that if all the Fed does is cut the Fed funds rate, the risk of a debt-deflation melt down will remain the dominant risk in the macroeconomic outlook. Restarting the rate-cutting engine, alone , would be the start of a journey to zero Fed funds - not in real terms, but nominal terms. Hello, Sir Greenspan-san!
Indeed, since Fed funds cuts "work" through the government-supported housing finance sector, the dominant risk of a Fed funds-only policy of "accommodation" is an unrelenting deflationary bust in the corporate assets and an accelerating inflationary boom in residential property prices. The Austrians are right that fighting busted bubbles with new bubbles is a lousy way to run a railroad. They are wrong, however, in arguing that busted bubbles should be allowed to bust in Mellonesque fashion.
The right approach is to directly contain the deflationary fallout of the busted bubble, without inflating one somewhere else. And the conventional Fed tool of changes in the Fed funds rate ain't the right tool, even when applied counter-cyclically. It's time for the Fed to act unconventionally, and break the conventional pro-cyclical pattern of bank lending and bank regulatory policy. Further cuts in the Fed funds rate would be easy, but not wise. In contrast, opening up the banking system conduit for the Fed's lender-of-last-resort function will not be easy, but wise.
So, to sum up, Krugman (like McCulley) said Greenspan had limited choices, and he was going to gin up one dumb-ass bubble to replace the one that just popped. It was a critique of the Republican vacuity that dominated policy making and thinking in the Bush years. In the Clinton years, too, for that matter. I can't absolve the Clinton team of their hand in this mess. The housing/banking disaster was 20 or more years in the making, and required the full complicity of the American people, as well as business, banking, Congress, presidents, and the Federal Reserve.
You probably thought you had me in some sneaky trap there, huh?
by delbertpgh
I admit that I haven't consulted a scientific census of the military; all I've done is watch the end of the PBS News Hour and their roll of the last few days' dead, for the last eight years. I've missed a few, but generally when they come on I stop and look.
What I see is there are a lot of people from small towns and few from big cities. There are more from southern and midwestern states and from California than from the northeast. And there are proportionately more blacks and Hispanics than in the general population, but that whites are by far the majority among the war dead.
Nowhere did I assert there is no order in nature.
I simply question YOUR definition of that order.
I also point to demonstrable fact that people's definition of the "natural order" concerning other people is fluid over time, marked by bias and prejudice (and thus typically fear), and often defined by those who feel they have access to, or ownership of, some higher moral ground.
If you wish to play fun games, Carlo.di.giorgio, state your family's national background. I doubt it to be any better or worse than the English, but I'd just love to be surprised. You have no idea of my personal background but are happy to draw the usual inane generalisations.
Absolutely not!
Your quote 'I also point to demonstrable fact that people's definition of the "natural order" concerning other people is fluid over time, marked by bias and prejudice (and thus typically fear), and often defined by those who feel they have access to, or ownership of, some higher moral ground''
Since Adam and Eve there have been on Earth Two Genders: Males and Females and from their sexual unions the humanity has grown bigger and bigger reaching currently 5/6 Billons. I do not have a definition of the natural order of things, Mother Nature has it and she defines what the humans are: males and/or females and gives to each new born child a specific gender organ. According to that the child is named and registered at the local Registry as MALE and or FEMALE. The so-called sexual orientation is a modern terminology forged by Western liberal societies for political reasons and it is a clear cut sign of social decadence as the rest of the world claims. In my case I was born male and since early age and adolescence I was attracted to females by natural instinct and as such I can't imagine, apart from more or less close friendship, feeling any sexual attraction to same sex humans, which I would find abhorrent and disgusting. In fact, my father was attracted to my mother and together they had 3 children. Billions and Trillions (and more) of humans have been experiencing the same since the beginning of human history. Homosexuals do not have children because their relation is sterile and serve no natural purpose but simply appears to satisfy their perverted mind and that not without pickering.
I am an Italian born and Swiss multilingual cosmopolitan living in Britain with many more life stages in other European and American nations.
by delbertpgh
Your libertarian Nostradamus beat my economist in getting his opinion into print, by a month. Yup.
Incidentally, McCulley's article is pretty interesting, for the general economic principles it explains, showing the problems and the lack of helpful alternatives a central bank manager faced at the time of the stock market bubble's collapse. Here's the link again.
http://www.pimco.com/Pages/FF_08_2002.aspx
by delbertpgh
by oz_media
by oz_media
by oz_media
I oppose turns in war, such as the about face to bugger off to Iraq. Afghanistan was an allied force, a global presence to root out the terrorists that attacked an ally. I stand at any American's side when it comes to such actions, I feel for those who lost loved ones when the towers were terrorized and I support a NEED, a real NEED, to go after such aggressors.
The rapid withdrawal of the US Embassy, the support, he troops, the financing and all the good that was going into Afghanistan and Kandahar was where the tides turned for me.
Off it was to Iraq, mission accomplished!
The hospitals that were being protected by allies (from the "thugs" who were stopping woman from training)were then turned over to "security". Security which composed of the exact same 'thugs' we had initially been protecting them from.
Two water towers were destroyed the same day Bush was shown on TV in front of the Mission Accomplished sign on the US naval ship.
A women who had FINALLY made it into the government to speak for women and actually be heard, left in exile the next day and escaped Afghanistan with the help of the UN troops.
Women were once again repressed, the Taliban repopulated Kandahar etc.
After the Iraqi government was toppled, the biggest US mistake of this entire war so far, unrest in Iraq took a new turn. Once innocent citizens took up arms, small pockets of combatants started turning up everywhere, easily lead on by terrorist regimes who had since moved into Iraq to follow the fight. Eventually AlQaeda took over and organized all the small terror groups. Bin Laden himself is said to be offering $467 million per week to support their organized efforts.
None of this happened UNTIL the US moved in and eliminated the government. Even the top US brass all the way down to the soldiers on the ground agree it was a huge mistake on America's part.
UK citizens opposed Tony Blair following too, it wasn't just the US that was in the wrong.
Now after years of saying, "it'll get better!" nothing really got any better and Iraq is in a horrendous state, that they will have to see to themselves as now it is BACK TO AFGHANISTAN again.
Just a really bad move.
Okay, so that was a very long preamble, my apologies for that.
Point is, while all this is going on, more and more people's sons and daughters, more young children's fathers and mothers are dead each day. For what? A mistake? woops, sorry about that we made a boo boo but we can straighten it out I think.
At what cost? A recession, thousands of parents losing their children, thousands of children losing their parents?
Yeah, I opposed it because it had no direction and was unjust. For what? Saddam did a better job at holding it together than the allied troops did, even the citizens that were supposedly repressed by him say it was better under his rule. Was he a good leader? Not at all. Did he work toward a democratic Iraq? nope. Did he manage to keep the terrorism at bay, yup for the most part and certainly better than we did. Could he have been "seen to" at a later date? Yes, it was not imperative to turn and run in another direction, Afghanistan was improving but far from improved.
So where is it all now? Back to square one, sort out Afghanistan, clean up Kandahar and watch the Taliban and AlQaeda populate Pakistan.
That Texas yokel who was given the White House keys was nothing but a danger to the world, we should be pulling his smug,m uneducated arse out of a hidey hole in some farm instead of Saddam.
And yet you watch the body count and toast the dead almost every day. I feel for you, I really do, there were people in power, not just Bush, who should not be able to walk free again, however they are now national heroes.
And now people, who supported that war,chastise Obama for only achieving SOME of what he had set out to do, halfway through his first term? Get real. Nuke every Republican over 56 and lets move forward to a more modern world where we all have a real chance at life again.
by herlizness
keeping it simple, DOD secretary Les Aspin issued directive 1304.26 in Dec 1993, which spells out the "don't ask" part; "don't tell" is implicit in 10 USC 654 ...
you're right ... the underlying prohibition on homosexual conduct was not altered by 1304.26 ... and I suppose for now it's not really clear what is meant and intended by those supporting military service for "openly gay" people .... HOW open?
about qualifications needed to counter argue
Alfred Adler, who wrote his work on Homosexuality in a very difficult German, to my knowledge never translated into English. Are you a psychiatrist and psychologist with long years of medical practice? Can you read and understand German?
I am showing my real name while you hide behind fantasy and have no real serious arguments about the dynamic of the phenomenon. By just repeating the trendy ''pensee unique'' of the western liberals and homosexuals you can hardly dismantle the simple truth that humans are fallible creatures and prone to deviations of all sorts, from mild neuroses to psychotic perversions of appalling nature.
Good bye!
...that guy Carlo... as you put it very politely!
by nicknielsen
[i]NickNielsen I suggest you have a deep reading of Adler's work: Das Problem der Homosexualitaet and then you will see how genetics can be the answer. [/i]
Adler was wrong and genetics [u]is[/u] a factor? Make up your mind.
Given the times, and the prevailing attitudes toward homosexuality, I'm not surprised his homosexual patients were neurotic. What I question is whether Adler's homosexual patients represent a valid sample of the homosexual population of the time. People who are comfortable with their lives and sexuality aren't very likely to consult a psychologist or psychoanalyst, so his patients do not represent an entire population. Basing any conclusions on his limited sample may have been good psychoanalysis, but it's lousy science.
by delbertpgh
to not care who knows about it.
Sam Nunn, a Democrat and the once-powerful former chair of the Senate Defense committee, once held hearings on whether gay people could serve, and he asked a witness what did he think would be the outcome of a case where two gay soldiers came as dates to a military ball. He had a page full of non-sequiturs like that.
On such weighty questions were civil rights held in abeyance.
by herlizness
<< Sam Nunn ... asked a witness what did he think would be the outcome of a case where two gay soldiers came as dates to a military ball >>
thing is, that's precisely the kind of scenario which can make a fair number of people very uncomfortable and in some cases lead to bad behavior ... at the same time, it's also precisely the kind of thing that a lot of gay people want to be accepted as a matter of simple and ordinary human dignity
by delbertpgh
After all the questions that can be raised concerning effectiveness under fire, and unit cohesion in the face of the enemy, and retention of career military professionals, all of which (it had been asserted) could be adversely impacted by dreadful homosexual influence, Sam Nunn comes up with some goofy question about what soldiers would think about two boys together at a military ball?! Good lord. Talk about your major national defense issues.
At the last two jobs I've worked in, and in fencing clubs, I've encountered gay men and women who've brought their same-gender dates to the annual Christmas party. In no case did I see them go out on the dance floor, or put their hands on each other's butts, or make out (and showing better taste than some of the straight couples who'd had too many drinks, may I add.) They were thinking about their careers, their professionalism, the sensibilities of the audience. I imagine it would usually work the same way at a military ball.
by oz_media
[i]"...he asked a witness what did he think would be the outcome of a case where two gay soldiers came as dates to a military ball.[/i]
I can't see that there would be an issue or HOW there could be an issue. I don't see any difference that a male GI taking a female GI to a military ball, unless ballroom dancing is now a military exercise and you need to pass a dance class to be admitted to the army.
Maybe I'm just exposed to a more accepting public, if two guys dace at a club around here, gay club or not, it wouldn't make a difference to anyone in the club, except perhaps a girl who was trying to pick up one of the gay men. You don't HAVE to go to a gay club to see gay males or females together and nobody gives a rats arse either way.
How can people POSSIBLY not accept what others do in their free time? If it effects the persons ability to fight or do the job they are hired for then they should be dismissed accordingly, but not for being gay.
Is a different animal, Oz.
Dress uniform, formal function among officers and their ladies (not enlisteds and their "wives"), and you [i]will[/i] be there, mixing with senior officers according to strictest military protocol. You will be judged not only by your own conduct, but also by the appearance, character, and deportment of your invite.
by nicknielsen
The law in question only addresses homosexual conduct because that's the way Congress wrote it.
Yes, there are service members who date, have heterosexual relations, and even marry each other. And where did sexual harassment come into it? What point are you trying to make? If you're aiming for hypocrisy, fine, say so. But do it somewhere else, I neither agree with the law, nor did I have any say in it at the time.
by jamesrl
by delbertpgh
From what memoirs I have seen of gay men in magazines and movies, I see that many of them never are attracted to "the far more appealing opposite sex," as you put it. My nephew, for example, loves to be with girls, but only so he can talk about clothing and boys. When it comes to sex, he and girls are never in the same room. I don't think he will ever find happiness satisfying "normal" appetites. To his mind, what he does and wants is normal, and irresistable.
Apparently you think that he has chosen to be homosexual. He could change, you say; he perhaps just never wanted to develop mature tastes and find happiness chasing the superior female form. What he wants is a matter of choice, you say, not identity.
Well, if that's true, I imagine you are also prepared to want men sexually, to feel desire when looking at them and satisfaction when getting them. If you think there's no difference between my nephew and a straight man, then you'd agree there's no difference between my nephew and you, and that his willingness to engage in perversions could just as easily be yours. Or, maybe you think you're a little more complicated.
For my part, if I were looking down at some guy's bony butt, and up his hairy back, seeing his idiot face smiling over his shoulder at me, I could not find myself aroused. The thought of it makes me slightly ill, and not the least bit excited. I never went for it as a boy, and can't see how I ever would as a man. However, if that were a lady in the same position, I would be willing to admit new and delightful possibilities. It's the essential element of excitement for me, the difference between compulsion and revulsion. It has steered my life. If I were gay, and if that fascination were as strong, I could not help but be guided by it.
So, I don't begrudge gay men their ugly tastes. I can't stand the idea myself, but I'm dominated by my own instints, and recognize as justice that they must reconcile themselves to their own.
If you're a Christian, contemplate that God made us all, and God don't make junk.
by ansugisalas
That's a simple transition. Push the right button.
If you want to see homosexual neurosis, you have to find a homosexual who believes what he does to be wrong. That happens in cultures with strong dogmatic indoctrination... as the indoctrination is reduced, so is the neurosis.
But I guess, if all us hetero types lived in a culture where we had to hide our preferences, and feel dogmatic guilt on account of what we like... I guess that'd make us a bit neurotic. Our entire self-image would be entirely different than now, and we would have to invent ways of expressing ourselves that would differ entirely from the homonormative hegemony that'd surround us.
Being forced into rebellion for no good reason is enough to throw any one off the bend.
I see so many things going on in your post that I cannot even call you, "wrong".
You are, just, out there, indistinguishable from your subject.
by ansugisalas
You're the Pope!
Whatshisface... "Maledictus DCLXVI"... no... "Pope formerly known as Angstschweiss" ... no, not that one either. Ah well, at least I know who you are, in principle at least :p
by ansugisalas
Zebras, Dingoes and other undomesticatables too.
You're just making up straws to grasp at as you go along.
I now have to decide whether you're intellectually dishonest or simply dishonest or a lying scumbag. I'll get back to you with the results ;)
by ansugisalas
Apparently there are tribes out there that feel that a young male's manlyness needs jump-starting. I'll leave the rest to your fevered imagination.
But what you say about brutality, need I remind you of the Crusades and the countless atrocities committed therein? That's Italy, and that's religion. Shame on you! Go stand in the corner Giorgio. And I place upon you also blame for the atrocities of Rome.
Ew, how can you even show your face around here?
You perpetrator of the killing of the Christ!!! You sicken me! Italians... may the earth swallow them up!!!
And then spit them at the moon.
Except for a certain Andrea and his kin and whoever he may choose to include in this pardon. I know him, he's a good sort.
But not Giorgio here, he's one of them what killed our Jesus!
by oz_media
I am starting to picture gay man as walking hunched over, in leg irons and beating their chests like some freaks from Planet of The Apes.
It's weird how such ignorance can cast such a ridiculous light upon something that is so irrelevant and uneventful where I live.
Talk about archaic and this guy actually claims he is educated?
by herlizness
<< The law in question only addresses homosexual conduct because that's the way Congress wrote it >>
I don't know which section of "the law" you're referring to at this point but my read of the UCMJ sodomy section is that it does and would apply to, for example, oral sex between male and female soldiers. There's really almost no room for alternative interpretation. I can't imagine that it's enforced very often but that's a separate matter.
by ansugisalas
would be a fart in a bottle floating in a paranthesis.
Now, he's "important" mainly on account of being abused to support flat-earthers and intelligent design nutters and the fearers of teh ghey.
Nobody cares about Adler. Except you and your ilk, and you and your ilk are not interested in psychology except where it can be twisted to support your prejudices and religious dogma.
about who should decide whether homosexuals should be allowed to serve under the USA banners. My modest opinion is rather radical: The military themselves and not elected politicians should have the final say. Before the creation of the USA the pre-Columbian aborigines (hence away from Judeo-Christian-Moslem cultures) with homosexual tendency were considered unfit as warriors and were relegated to domestic tasks. I believe that in every single language and/or dialects there are funny and descriptive names for those who divert from the sexual norms dictated by The Laws of Nature. After reading a few of the comments signed by AnsuGisalas I would suggest him to consider seriously to seek help and advise from health professionals.
Thank you, AnsuGisalas, for your colourful contribution, which describes vividly your own orientation.
by ansugisalas
between the Inquisition Fanboy and the Sharia Fanboy.
Let's hope they get a room before they come out of their respective closets, otherwise we'll all need some corrective laser eye-surgery!
And electro-therapy to "fix" our mnemonics :p
by oz_media
Your explanation or your loosely used terms begins with a complete fallacy.
[i]Since Adam and Eve there have been on Earth Two Genders: Males and Females[/i]
FALSE, the Earth was around for billions of years prior to any supposed Adam or Eve being 'put on Earth'. Science proves how fast light travels, light years can be calculated by the colour of the light. There is more proof supporting Earth being around several billion years before Adam and Eve and supporting the natural evolution of life, than there is the tale of Christian religion.
You then propose another fictional being to support your next claim, Mother Nature? Yeah, met her myself, didn't believe her, didn't like her.
[i]"...gives to each new born child a specific gender organ.[/i]
Wrong once again, there are many that have a mix of both organs or a completely unidentifiable organ. At one point we are neither identifiable as a male of female.
[i"According to that the child is named and registered at the local Registry as MALE and or FEMALE." [/i]
This is where WE make the choice for the child regardless of how the child will develop, or think. It has also been proven incorrect, many once seemingly female babies are later found to develop full male genitalia.
[i]"I was attracted to females by natural instinct and as such I can't imagine, apart from more or less close friendship, feeling any sexual attraction to same sex humans, which I would find abhorrent and disgusting.[/i]
Therefore you are unable to grasp such a concept and as a result, admittedly completely ignorant on such matters.
Your conclusion is devoid of any reason, science, logic, fact, sanity.
In fact, your opinion has been put forth so ignorantly that it is laughable and [b]perverse[/b] in the true sense of the word.
by oz_media
No, I have just been reading this most ridiculous thread and can't believe the mindset of some people.
You suggest that the law only addresses homosexual conduct, my point is that it should be addressed as any other relationship as there is no added 'danger', as implied by others here, when referring to homosexual relationships.
the possibility of sexual harassment was brought up as one reason it would not be accepted. Males fearing showering with gay males, as if thwarting homosexuality in the ranks would solve such issues and that gay men would not be able to conduct themselves accordingly if around other naked men.
How many gay men have been arrested for attacking other men in the showers at your public pool? Common issue?
The mention was merely an addendum.
The point being, there is no difference between straight or homosexual relationships when it comes to sexual harassment. If straight people are able to refrain form such actions, or face charges if not, then why would it be seen any differently with gays?
by ansugisalas
Interpretation and arbitration give arbitrary results.
Given that arbitrary is not exactly the same as random, it holds up.
by oz_media
We are not talking about an annual Christmas Party.
We are talking about those to whom we confer the power to kill in our name. The "ball" has been around since, whenever.
They do not muster muskets.
They have within their power to turn around, saying with all that they have at their modern disposal, "This is how it will be." This is how I know it. They are, a "brotherhood", regardless of your inclinations.
by ansugisalas
I loathe the interjection of a purposeless ban into an organization that should be all about purpose.
On the other hand... I just had a vision of an all-male army, where gaiety too is boot-strapped for purpose. An all-male military ball, with no females to dampen the aggressions, the needs for furtiveness, the desire to go from purpose to fruition.
- Now that, was a scary vision.
Ultimately I think it's funny how the right wing are so scared about gay men. It's like they don't realize that gay men, if not marginalized and oppressed, would be inherently far more right-leaning (on economic issues and others) than heterosexual couples.
Why would a person in all-male relationship care whether or not women get fair pay? Not for personal reasons at least - no point of intersection with personal space.
There's a study that shows that people that have daughters tend to modify their views "towards the left" (as ludicrous as such a statement is - it's simply a realization of the need for equal opportunities). Likewise, having a woman in one's life is probably a leftifying factor for men (unless the woman in question is some kind of Stepford wife) - so members of all-male couples are, all things being equal, more ripe for conservatism than members of other couples.
Nothing is clear-cut, is it?
by nicknielsen
I keep forgetting you're in the business of pissing people off simply because of the location of their current domicile.
That they might agree with you on the issue is immaterial.
by nicknielsen
This is where I was: 10USC§654. I have no idea where Oz was going with it.
You are correct about the sodomy article in the UCMJ. As I stated in my previous post, I never saw it applied in court martial except in the case of rape or homosexual activity.
by ansugisalas
See, I speak to you as you speak to others.
I add some gravel sometimes, and sometimes chalk, but by and large I give you my impression of you.
If you think I talk crazy, it's because you do.
As for my orientation, in any space real or imagined, one such as you cannot know it :p
by jamesrl
There is a name for coutries where the military are an authority unto themselves and don't answer to anyone. Its called a military dictatorship. In a democracy, we recognize the need for some method of control of the military. In the US, the President, elected directly by the people, is the commander and chief of the armed forces.
For all your comments on unfit warriors, you ignore ancient Greece and Rome, which tolerated and even in some cases encouraged homosexual behaviour. Yet someone they were very successful militarily - ever hear of Alexander the Great?
And we've already covered the animals in nature that display same sex behaviours.
As for discriptive and funny names, many societies had that for people of different races or cultures, its nothing to be proud of, racism, xenophobia etc.
I think Ansu has a healthy balanced view of the situation. I don't know one way or the other his orientation. I wouldn't judge Carlo to have the same.
by oz_media
So you would most likely understand when I refer to Eric the half a bee and the man seeking a license for his pet bee Eric.
With that taken into consideration, all I can say from reading many of your posts is that, "you're a bleedin' looney, mate!"
While you defer the decision to the Military and not government, which is a completely valid argument, you then destroy any hope of retaining credibility when you resort to Aboriginals and their views of gay warriors. The required relevance to the US military just isn't there.
America is a massive, democracy, a world super power, not a third world country where the military wear war paint made from mud and berries, life moves on people understand each other better, we have grown beyond such an idiotic mindset. With hundreds of years of development, hopefully we shall not revert to such in order to justify modern law.
Several of your comments have lead in with straight up, opinions that have validity, you then destroy all hope of sanity and validity when you start on about Adam and Eve, Columbian aboriginals etc.
For you to even assume you know someone's sexual preference based on nondescript posts on line, is pure idiocy. Either way, Ansu's "orientation" is of no interest to anyone here, it holds absolutely no relevance to the discussion or topic at hand, if it did, it would mean that his opinion were more qualified as he was speaking from first hand knowledge, which it seems nobody has here, unfortunately.
Take off the grass skirt, put down the spear and realize you are living in the 21st century already.
by oz_media
LOL, you really are a numpty when it comes to reality, logical thought and reason, aren't you?
To think that Oxford has churned out the likes of you is horrific and a real kick in the pants to someone who is proud to have family that has received the world class education that prestigious institution is renowned for.
You refer to HIV as a pestilence that has spread due to perversion and how these "perverts" represent the most vulnerable section of humanity.
What about smokers and alcoholics?
Is cancer not still one of the US' major killers? 430,000 people in the US die each year form smoking related illness. Since the discovery of the HIV epidemic, an estimated 600,000 have died. Considering that number is amassed over 30 years, it is safe to say that the perversion of cigarette smoking kills MANY times more people than HIV does.
There are an estimated 17,000 new cases of people 'LIVING' with HIV in the US each year, there are an estimated 700,000 new cases of terminal lung cancer due to smoking in the US each year.
Now there's a perversion that also tracks back to Columbian aboriginals that kills many times more people than this "perversion" that you keep referring to.
That is also ignoring the fact that HIV is not just a gay disease, and has little or no impact on the topic of gay military members, unless orgies have now become a part of basic training.
by oz_media
Nicely slipped in there, I guess you really aren't done after all.
I am sure a US member will correct you but CNN, is NOT exactly a source of information, CNN is the STAR or Enquirer of sensational news outlets, they create controversy for themselves to debate.
Usually when there is no opposition to policies, the majority would be in agreement, therefore 'dictatorship' dos not apply.
regarding Alexander the Great, you suggest "the perversion was mental" as he was also married and accepted women into his sexual life.
You may very well be correct in that and other cases of bisexuality, where sexual preference is a matter of instant, sexual stimuli. Bisexuality was not really frowned upon, orgies involved people from both sexes of course and once exposed to such sexual pleasures, many found themselves quite comfortable. I would even suggest that many had no real preference when it came to sex but sought our their preferred life partner when it came to matrimony or long term relations. We all party, it doesn't mean we are ALL alcoholics too.
[i]In today's Persia (Iran) one risks death penalty if caught in perverted sex, as it is the case in some parts of Africa, in the vicinity of wild animals! "[/i]
If you are thinking that what happens in Persian society should offer any relevance to how we act in Western society, then how do we address beheading criminals and disparity of women. Should that archaic and repulsive mindset apply to us too?
by oz_media
You might have been able to make your point.
I pay less attention to a peer's place of residence than most here. I often don't even pay attention to the alias, merely the words typed which I am replying to.
Your assumption of my regional bias is as ignorantly biased as any.
I don't give a rat's where you live, I didn't offer my reply because you were American, Indian, French or pygmy.
keep on with your unqualified assumptions, you only display your own ignorance and bias in the process.
After reading the list you linked to above, I still see the relevance in my last post.
To break it down into simpler terms for you. This thread is about who should be in charge of decisions regarding gay men or women into the military, clearly it is the discretion of the military. One argument raised defended their disinterest in gay members due to the fact that men would have to shower together and it would cause unrest.
In such a case it would obviously result in sexual harassment charges, as indicated in the text you linked to, which equally applies to heterosexuality also.
Therefore, regardless of anything else, there are already ample protections from such conduct in place today and therefore being gay wouldn't/shouldn't hold any further bearing on one's ability to join the ranks.
My comments have had NOTHING at all to do with where you live or what nationality ANYONE is. I haven't made this an issue of personal nationality of governing the nation in any way.
by jamesrl
Ancient Greece had many examples of men engaging in same sex with other men, until the age of marriage. This included Sparta, which had to be considered the dominant military power (on land) and Athens (naval power).
There is a fair amount of evidence that Alexander was bisexual. Of course he would marry to produce an heir, that was expected.
In Roman society, until Christianity took hold, it was common for men to have same sex relationships, the only issue was that Roman citizens were to be shamed if they weren't the "dominant" partner. Similar to Greece, Romans were expected to marry to produce offspring no matter what their preference.
by oz_media
YOU obviously don't realize that I come from a military family and have lived on an AirForce base in Singapore. As for formality, I wasn't referring to a Christmas party either, no matter how much you wish to minimize an average citizens knowledge of the tabula rasa that you deem the military to be.
The military is not some secret society that only military personnel can comprehend, that's what they would LIKE to believe but that's not reality at all.
The secret clubhouse has an open door, and in this case 'Gerlz are aloud' but gayz are not.
as the most common practice in Anthropology. The same method used by famous anthropologist and psychologist like Carl Gustav Jung to go to the roots of the subject. The fact that cultures not influenced by Western conquerors used to have the same objections to homosexuality is by all mean a very solid argument to prove that the phenomenon is human but not genetics as humans, being intelligent creatures, can do whatever they are fancy even if that habit is dangerous and pervert like smoking and drinking above the tolerable limits. My words are directed to those who have raised opposition to famous psychologists works such as those of Alfred Adler. HIV became all of the sudden headline news in the early 80's in association with numerous homosexuals, even celebrities falling ill and subsequently dieing. Considering the long years of incubation of the virus it can be easily related to the orgies of the tumultuous 60's, the modern birth era of liberal and shameless perverted sex.
Yes, smoking and drinking can be extremely dangerous but those 'vices' have never been associated to genetics, and are only the most common of the many humans indulge at their peril.
by oz_media
Smoking and drinking are said to both be related to genetics. There is a growing body of scientific evidence that alcoholism and smoking have a genetic component, but the actual gene that may be the cause has yet to be identified.
Studies of laboratory animals as well as human test subjects indicate that genetic factors play a major role in the development of alcoholism and smoking habits, but just how much a factor remains undetermined.
As for homosexuality and HIV in the 80's, you fail to recognize that the virus has also been spread through heterosexual couples, possibly ORIGINATING due to homosexual activity but propagated through heterosexual sex as well. So we have two perversions as the cause for this outbreak and it is not solely limited to homosexual coupling or sexual perversion as you prefer to call it.
[i]Considering the long years of incubation of the virus it can be easily related to the orgies of the tumultuous 60's, the modern birth era of liberal and shameless perverted sex."[/i]
Why should ANY sex be deemed shameful? Not in your bedroom? I'm fine with that.
You suggest it is easily related, perhaps it is for the sake of simplicity but not factually or solely. It's always easy to associate but harder much to prove as fact.
Judging by my views of US government, one would assume I was a liberal or democrat, however I am neither, in fact I am very conservative. Therefore such simplistic conclusion based on association is merely simplicity and far from accuracy, as you like to pose your comments as.
Your concepts are just that, concepts, based loosely on association, not fact at all.
Much of anthropology and science as a whole, is based on loose association, with very little substantiated fact but a collection of evidence that results in a viable conclusion...which you seem to feel is the same as fact.
So far, you have posed little or no facts at all to support your conclusions. Yet you continue with your insistence as if you have.
Your conclusions are merely your opinions but nothing more.
by oz_media
as far as the dominant partner, even gay men prefer to be the pitcher rather than the catcher. Male dominance and masculinity thrives in the gay community too, no differently than in straight communities.
Despite what many think, just because a man is gay it doesn't mean he is effeminate. In fact I was in a situation years ago where I was left to wait in a friend's apartment with some gay men were leading me on as a joke. They knew I was scared shirtless, as they were all HUGE, one guy was an NFL player two were CFL players and three others were personal bodyguards. I actually had no idea any were gay, yet alone all of them, and I am talking MASSIVE black men! They could probably smell the fear in me as one put a hand on my knee and smiled while saying, don't worry, we are all hugs and kisses around here.
They all started to laugh and the joke was clearly on me. They were actually such nice, kind and gentle guys but not effeminate, not bloody likely, they had me sweating good! :D
Ah, the lessons we learn as we grow.
by jamesrl
...it is sometimes difficult to overcome an ingrained prejudice.
To me his dogged faith in Adler suggests to me he isn't a true academic, but someone who has found a few heroes whose beliefs match his own, and nothing will disaude him from his belief that he and his heroes are correct and the rest of us are wrong.
Adler died in the 30s. Both Psychology and Genetics have advanced much in the intervening years, but he ignores what they might have to say on the subject because it doesn't fit his world view.
I'm betting he had very strong parental influencers as a kid.
by oz_media
I was trying to give him the benefit of the doubt but with every keystroke I read it becomes harder to accept.
Truly misguided but self assured of keen insight? Gawd what a mess! :D
by nicknielsen
Sort by Trending