Discussion Locked

Hard Drives, Whats your favorite?

0 helpful
18 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello all, been out of touch with the holidays and what not, but I would like to know peoples opinions on Hard drives.

I have been a die hard fan of three HD manufacturers Western Digital, IBM (True Blue) Not the made in China ones, and Hitachi.

We recently had a 1.5 TB external Maxtor up and fail on us and I always felt Maxtor?s were a piece of ?C?p?. My Manager felt that it was a safe medium to store some of our most critical data. So after recovering everything I was wondering if anyone has had a differing opinion and/or if they have a brand they would recommend.

Happy New Year!

18 replies

by cmiller5400

It's just more fail than others :p

My Ranking:

1. Seagate
2. Western Digital
3. Hitachi

Had to RMA tons of Hitachi/IBM drives about 5-6 years ago. The newer Hitachi's seem quite good though.

by larryd4

About two or three years ago IBM farmed out its PC and laptop manufacturing and though they said IBM on the HD it came from a third party manufacturer in China. This business would eventually become Lenovo. But I have never had issues with "True Blue" Harddrives.

Sadly Its getting harder and harder to find the "True Blues". Since the PC sell off, the HDs IBM are making a primarily for mid range and mainframe systems.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

IBM, Western Digital, and Maxtor. I'm running all three in various machines, and they have proven to be long lived and reliable. I'm sitting on an 8 year old IBM and Maxtor as I type.

I'm talking desktop, not notebook. I don't build notebooks.

by larryd4

I know their will be people who use Maxtor and are very happy. They've been around for a while and have to be doing something right.

I guess I might need to be more specific. We average anywhere from 600 megs to a gig a day in new data. So we have a need for terabytes of storage.

I have built SANs and local RAID systems and Maxtor has always been the hw that fails most often.

So I tend to stick with the hardware that is more reliable for me.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I build for home users. Quite a difference in data storage and transfer.

Sorry 'bout that. :)

by jpesadilla

My favourite 3.5" HDD has always been SeaGate. I have built a few machines and I always go with Barracudas for both SATA and IDE drives. Never had an issue and I have a few systems that are going on 8+ years.

The drives I have had to repair/replace the most have been Western Digital, though with their warranty I just send them back and I get a new one no problem.

by ---tk---

then RAID it ... In my opinion they are all the same, no matter what brand you purchase they will eventually fail...

by jsaubert

Everything will fail no mater what you do. RAID is becoming more common at home, thankfuly.

I normally don't go for the super cheep ones, I try to get a good balance of price life expectancy and size.

by notsochiguy

I'd vote for Seagate as my preferred HD choice. They seem to last longest, and when I do need support, they have been exceptionally helpful.

More and more of our systems seem to be coming with Hitachi drives; and so far, they have performed fairly well.

by larryd4

I have been browsing the Seagate Forums, since Seagate now owns Maxtor and I have seen a lot of positive posts for Seagate customer service.

I have also seen a lot of posts that express that seagates support people are very supportive for the Maxtor users with problems. It seems they have been dealing with a lot of Maxtor issues.

by notsochiguy

...could learn a lesson from them, based on my experience. They've gone so far to help out on an issue that wasn't the fault of their product (which was out of warranty, to boot). Their reasoning for helping was something along the lines of 'it gave them a chance to try out something'.

Cool friggin' beans in my book! :)

by jck

internal file storage: Seagates

internal performance: WD Velociraptors

External file storage: Cavalry's solution...cheap and good.

by cg it

The Hitachi aren't bad. Sun/HP drives are pretty reliable.

I find the higher size drives fail more often then the smaller drives so I stick with the smaller ones. Means more drives but then they don't fail as often.

by slayer_

Still alive and kicking, SMART test shows 90% fitness. It however does show anouying signs of failure, every time I boot the OS it says there MAY BE damaged clusters and forces a surface scan, but it never finds anything. The drive still works perfectly.

It's almost double it's 7 year life expectancy, they just don't make stuff like they used to.

by jsaubert

Western Digital has given me the best life/size/performance for the price on external. Seagate is second for me on internals, they seem to give me a slightly better performance speed wise but seem slightly more prone to bad sectors than the Western Digitals. Every other maker seems kind of Hit or Miss for the last year or so, you might get a great one ... you might get a lemon.

Maxtor external drives fail more often but they are cheep enough to buy two and have a backup off site for safekeeping.

by Member 19291532

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hitachi_Deskstar

Pay careful attention to the portion of the wiki titled "Deathstar"...

I know they've "addressed" these problems, but I've yet to rebuild my trust in them.

I've been pretty solidly a Seagate guy professionally, as much as possible, and a WD or Seagate guy at home, depending on price. But other than Hitachi, I'll buy just about anything (Maxtor, for example) if it is inexpensive enough.

I've still got an old ST-225 RRL Seagate 5.25" half-height winchester drive somewhere in my basement, I think - that works. 30mb. I've had fairly good luck with hard drives, overall... although I've had more than a few failures over the years, too.

by jaqui

for reliability:

Maxtor, fails more often than not on me.
Toshiba, usually in notebooks, but danged reliable drives.
"True Blue" IBM drives
want a couple of 350 MB True Blues? still working. :D
Western Digital. [ though their 200 GB ide drives weren't reliable for me, the smaller and larger ones are doing great ]
Seagate. never had one fail on me.

This discussion is closed to new replies.