Heads you win, tails I lose - all based on a false premise
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Windows Forum
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by oz_media
by oz_media
Science is an art of reaching conclusions based on fact finding.
"According to Webster's New Collegiate Dictionary, the definition of science is "knowledge attained through study or practice," or "knowledge covering general truths of the operation of general laws, esp. as obtained and tested through scientific method [and] concerned with the physical world."
What does that really mean? Science refers to a system of acquiring knowledge. This system uses observation and experimentation to describe and explain natural phenomena. The term science also refers to the organized body of knowledge people have gained using that system. Less formally, the word science often describes any systematic field of study or the knowledge gained from it.
What is the purpose of science? Perhaps the most general description is that the purpose of science is to produce useful models of reality.
Most scientific investigations use some form of the scientific method. You can find out more about the scientific method here.
Science as defined above is sometimes called pure science to differentiate it from applied science, which is the application of research to human needs. Fields of science are commonly classified along two major lines:
- Natural sciences, the study of the natural world, and
- Social sciences, the systematic study of human behavior and society. "
by oz_media
Those against demand proof, however are unable to offer contradictory proof to support their disbelief. Any proof that is provided is then dismissed as heresay, just as their unsupported argument.
It is almost like a Schrodinger debate. :D
by jck
by tonythetiger
is to be "just fine".
It is the burden of those who think it's not "just fine" to prove it to a fairly high probability. I liken it to "beyond a reasonable doubt".
To put the burden of proof on those who think the earth is "just fine" is equivalent to a defendant having to prove he didn't commit a crime.
by oz_media
As I said before, it's like erring on teh side of caution.
I don't go to a proctologist for an ear infection either...though it could be kinda interesting...nah, maybe not.
by oz_media
One part of accepting science is accepting changes too. I welcome information from any viewpoint, however when someone simply says, "no it isn't,...because I don't think it is", it just doesn't stand up against scientific proof.
The so called PROOF shown against GW doesn't stand up against the slightest scrutiny at all. If scientists started to PROVE they were wrong, which any good scientist always seeks to do, then perhaps the antiGW debate would have a leg to stand on. People, simply attributing it to political posturing, have an ulterior motive to ofering proof, they simply have a political bias. As I don't buy into any poltical BS, I have no such motive.
I, however, am inclined to bellieve these and their ilk:
They have less to gain and less to hide - and make much more sense.
I, too, am skeptical of a lot of warming assertions, because this is an emerging field with a lot of unsettled doctrine, the scientists are way more likely to know what's going on than the average citizen, be that Al Gore, Nancy Pelosi, Harry Reid, Ed Shultz, Randi Rhodes, et al. My confidence is also with the nerds on this one - just different nerds.
by oz_media
Just like politics, one's choices of the unqualified are not considered when more qualified sources are available. Like I said earlier, you would't go to a proctologist for an ear infection, even though an ENT specialist and a proctologist are both doctors with a PHD.
As for agenda, wouldn't youthink that, if you were a climatologist an actually found PROOF either way, that you would hapily offer it and make a global name for yourself. There would have to be a nobel peace prize in proving it either way.
So really there's no agenda in such a community. They aren't out for votes or public support, they are out to prove theory, no matter where it falls. Either way, they become renowned in their field and woud receive greater funding and credibility as a result.
by ic-it
Just found the site below. Initially it appears to be an information center for both the pro and con viewpoints.
I especially like the categories on the left side of their page, tons of reading.
by oz_media
by tonythetiger
by jck
by jck
Lucky you, Tony.
I'll just be happy to leave the state I reside within, let alone my profession.
Ah well, who said you work 30 years and retire didn't say lawnmowing and paper routers don't count.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
There is not one single iota of proof that CO2 levels have a significant effect on the average temperature of the planet.
There IS plenty of evidence that when one rises, so does the other, but... correlation is not causation.
As I've said before. It has been warmer, with much lower CO2 levels.
The IPCC's mission statement:
[i]"The role of the IPCC is to assess on a comprehensive, objective, open and transparent basis the scientific, technical and socio-economic information relevant to understanding the scientific basis of risk of human-induced climate change, its potential and options for adaptation and mitigation."[/i]
They have a pre-formed conclusion! That's NOT science!
by jck
the atmosphere is "better", yet the increases in pollutants are documented gone up in all but one case (the CFC for which legislation forced reductions), I tend not to believe the party/people who would mislead/lie/truth-stretch to me that way.
Whether not proven or proven not, their deceptive nature was are proven.
Hence why someone as goofy as Al Gore can be is given more creedence for a glamorized presentation of facts from scientific sources, than those from the opposite side who'd tell you
"believe us...it's not true".
In the end though, right now I am for a major ouster of most incumbents from their seats in Congress, especially the US Senate who has been nothing but a bed of political wrangling instead of getting America fixed now for a year.
And I mean that for both sides of the aisle.
Enough politics. Fix America.
by jck
It's the so called science on both sides that's doing me in.
It's bollocks, models and statistics is the entirety of it.
Psuedo science equivalent to finding codes in the bible, or evidence of aliens landing because you can draw a line through some pyramid shaped edifices on two different continents, if you squint just right.
Last I heard every decently complex model of our climate we have can't reliably predict even gross local climatic conditions beyond ten days, and all of those have to be tweaked so they don't fall into white earth.
Any one who takes the above as scientific proof of human derived climate change or lack of it, has absolutely no defence against the opposite conclusion, becasue there isn't enough quality evidence to generate more than an opinion.
The only real science we have that's of any use is chaos, and that tells us.
Different starting conditions means different behaviour, and we don't know what they were or are.
That small factors can have huge effects.
That any non linear system with feedback when peturbed can go through violent changes in state, before settling into stability.
That the more factors there are in a system, the more attractors towards stable states it has.
So any conclusion either side draws from their pseudo science is mere opinion.
By their methodology I could claim and then prove that enough of us wearing odd socks would stave off climate change or cause it.
The 'scientific' positions in the debate are essentially whether these odd socks are different sizes or different colours, perhaps both in the more complex scenarios...
The motivations of both camps are obvious and that's what drives their science.
Theye are choosing evidence that matches a conclusion they've already drawn.
Scientists my f'ing arse. Pollsters, lobbyists, pedants, and self deluded fanatics, the lot of them.
As a personal philosophy I have and do sacrifice many expressions of freedom, to the benefit of my family, my community , my society, my nation, even my humanity.
What do you call a common ethic, morality, law, civilisation but a constraint on individual freedom?
What is an infringement of your or my freedom, who defines it us, you, me, them?
Given it's you or I who feels our rights are being infringed by the other, whether that's more disposable income to spend on petrol, or less to not have to rely on personal transport.
Which of our individuals freedoms doesn't infringe on the the other's?
Which one of us has more of a right than the other. Either collapses the argument, neither doesn't address it.
So you make me pay for roads to run your car on, and I make you pay for rail, so I can get about with out a car.
One infringement justifies the other.
In a community of two, it's a simple proposition.
We both pay for each other's freedoms.
Or one of us isn't free...
by tonythetiger
[i]Sounds more like an edict to make an assessment of facts and data in regards to how to deal with climate change in the future, rather than to conclude that it exists without study. [/i]
you left out [u][b]human induced.[/b][/u]
That's important, because without it, they have no leverage to "deal with" anything!
And once you're assessing how to deal with it, you've already concluded that it exists. Anything done after that is to defend the conclusion.
Of course, I'm not sure what a railroad engineer/climate profiteer/soft-core porn writer should be doing differently :)
http://www.climategate.com/ipcc-chief-pachauri-do-as-i-say-not-as-i-do
by boxfiddler Hot topic
[i]The only truth in either for or against human caused climate change belief, is some people see a way to gain power,[/i]
Nub.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
Oh yeah.
[i]It's the so called science on both sides that's doing me in.
It's bollocks, models and statistics is the entirety of it.[/i]
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by boxfiddler Hot topic
might, maybe, odds are long but still, survive in the event Yellowstone blows.
You might wanna think twice about that. :|
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by boxfiddler Hot topic
are the Universal Mind?
[i]There are absolutely NO facts to the contrary of scientific conclusions.[/i]
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by oz_media
First of all, when the news broke of the Arctic ice being at its 30 year low in 2007, thousands of scientists saw a similar pattern, however the U. of Illinois reported the Antarctic at its record high.
So that FACT is that ice caps are diminishing in the Acrtic. To counter that FACT, the U of Illinois countered that it isn't in Antacrtica? So if I say life in Iraq if horrific, a fair counter is that life in Australia is not?
The variety of climatic proxies in an ice core sample is greater than in any other natural recorder of climate, such as tree rings or sediment layers.
The heavier, water, isotopes offer lower vapor pressure so, when the temperature falls, the heavier water molecules will condense faster than the normal water molecules. This makes dating and atmospheric contect to temperature measurement actually rather accurate, even moreso than carbon dating which is also considered very scientifically accurate, but not as accurate as ice core sampling.
So you rash dismissal is simply a rash dismissal.
You say it is a result of politics, however many nations supporting different political views, agree on the same scientific conclusions?
Scientists have nothing to gain by not presenting the truth of their findings and everything to gain by proving otherwise. So if there is proof that it is a hoax, why hasn't some scientist proven that and claimed his Nobel Peace Prize already and gone down in history? Is it that these 1000's of scientists worldide are all being paid off to keep quiet by their respective governments, it is a mass corraboration of government? Not bloody likely.
You have made it more than clear that you simply ignore any 'news and discoveries', you dismiss any reports instantly without further consideration, resulting in the ignorance you have shown here.
You won't convince me that God exists, you won't convince me that science is a government hoax.
by oz_media
[i]"There IS plenty of evidence that when one rises, so does the other"[/i]
So if they have already proven that CO2 levels have increased, then, by your understanding of the facts, the temperature will increase proportionately.
In your reply to jck, you indicate that predicting events in the future is not something we can/should act upon now.
Fact is, if we wait until later, it is too late to have a subtantial impact on the situation. A stitch in time saves nine.
Do you ever listen to yourself?
by oz_media
With a cycle said to take thousands of years, should we wait and leave it for our future generations to prove when they can't do anything to have a positive enough effect? That's the whole immedicay issue behind the sceince of climate change, it is already not reversible or preventable, but unless we make changes, there may be no hope for ANY positive effect later on.
However, we'll all be dead and gone by then so who cares, it's a problem for future generations? As long as it doesn't effect my life, it is irrelevant?
by oz_media
Have you been hanging out with santee or something?
Your brief comments are not exactly pithy wit demonsrtrating intelligence. Just that you are someone with nothing to say but offering a peanut gallery comment.
by jck
Greenpeace do something radical?
What a shock.
Since you like youtube, here:
by oz_media
From what I read, from people comfusing Antacrtica with the Acrtic Cirlcle, we simple need to find a way to rotate the Earth, vertically, 180 degrees and we should be good to go. Then the cold south will once again become the cold north and the warm south will become the warm south again.
I think the key indicator of such need is teh fact that Arizona had more snow than Vancouver Canada this year and neared lows equal to BC northern Interior. Simple problem solved! TADA!!!
Now if we can just het Bruce Willis and his drill team to make another movie, they might be able to nidge the Earth enough to start that North to South rotational swap.
As for your link, I was also rather amused with his explanation of the straw man argument as used by the anti-GW crowd, it is so reminiscent of the falacies we read here so often.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hWJeqgG3Tl8&feature=channel
"I would dance and be merry, life would be a ding-a-derry,
If I only had a brain."
by tonythetiger
[i]Hence why someone as goofy as Al Gore can be is given more creedence for a glamorized presentation of facts from scientific sources,[/i]
Actually some of the material he used was PROVEN inaccurate. Data that pointed away from the "conclusion" he was trying to portray was intentionally "adjusted" or omitted entirely. And the VERY SAME PEOPLE were involved in creating THAT deception are involved in the current controversy.
There should never be a reason to hide data that doesn't point to what you want it to point to. That confers a passion on science that simply should not exist.
by tonythetiger
[i]So if they have already proven that CO2 levels have increased, then, by your understanding of the facts, the temperature will increase proportionately.[/i]
What part of "correlation is not causation" are you having trouble with?
If the relationship was direct and proportional, we'd already all be dead!
[i]In your reply to jck, you indicate that predicting events in the future is not something we can/should act upon now.[/i]
I do not believe the predictions are accurate (many of their predictions have already failed to materialize), so to act on them would be foolish.
[i]
Fact is, if we wait until later, it is too late to have a subtantial impact on the situation.[/i]
The fact is, that is no fact at all. It's not been proven that there IS a "situation".
by tonythetiger
Evidence against AGW that has been peer reviewed
http://www.americanthinker.com/2010/02/the_agw_smoking_gun.html
by jck
There are a lot of holes, half-truths, etc., in this piece.
Namely that CO2 is effected by and vibrates at very specific frequencies of IR.
Any molecule, with enough energy applied to, can be made to resonate or alter its resonation with energy from a very broad spectrum.
That is called harmonics.
I could go on, but that piece shows little science and draws a lot of illogical conclusions.
Plus, it cites Lindzen who (as I have shown before) was paid by Exxon to produce material in alignment with their corporate direction.
by tonythetiger
You're questioning "peer reviewed" articles?
But the contradictory side isn't allowed to?
How quaint!
by tonythetiger
[i]That is called harmonics.[/i]
The molecule will only vibrate at the harmonic when the exciting waves at the primary resonant frequency are subdued or not present. I don't think the sun varies its output THAT much.
by oz_media
by tonythetiger
The presumption that CO2 is a [u]significant[/u] contributor to climate change.
There is zeeeerrrroooo evidence to presume any such thing!
Part of the abstract of the later paper referred to:
"Previously published work using satellite observations of the clear sky infrared emitted radiation by the Earth in 1970, 1997 and in 2003 showed the appearance of changes in the outgoing spectrum, which agreed with those expected from known changes in the concentrations of well-mixed greenhouse gases over this period. Thus, the greenhouse forcing of the Earth has been observed to change in response to these concentration changes."
Snipped from the conclusions to the same source paper for the rather strange website that you linked to:
"Changing spectral signatures in CH4, CO2, and H2O are observed, with the difference signal in the CO2 matching well between observations and modelled spectra."
So? The authors don't seem particularly excited about their paper even though the Hadley Centre is part of the UK Met Office's establishment and so is part of The Enemy from your perspective. Ah! I know. They are keeping quiet about their research because to publish the data would mean that their jobs are on the line.
by tonythetiger
[i]Ah! I know. They are keeping quiet about their research because to publish the data would mean that their jobs are on the line. [/i]
... a lot of that going around. Anytime there's a bureaucracy involved...
I can say, for myself, that I log your every word, every pause, every punctuation point, for dimensional analysis.
Nor, am I anyone else. I take you at your word.
by tonythetiger
[i]Nobody steals my money, I pay taxes are part of accepting Canada's government and laws, again that is by choice, I can always leave.[/i]
From whence comes this "choice"? Did someone give it to you?
by jck
Let's look at this logically:
Due to ice cores taken at both poles with all over 400k years of pre-human evolutionary chemicals which can be analysed for information, I think we can safely say we can derive the natural planetary function back to when the only human incurred effects were the methane from their farts and the CO2 they breathed out. :^0
It's the study of human caused elevations since industrial times that we are looking to evaluate.
And since CO2 is known to trap atmospheric thermal energy, it's a pretty safe bet that with increased CO2 levels that are proven to have been rising out of the normal cycles of the past 100-120 years are going to cause global warming.
by jck
Show me where it was "not proven"...and, I don't mean just because other scientists said so. I would like the contrary data/studies.
I know that the chart he showed from the CO2 research that one professor did was from the 1950s when the research began to 2000-whatever (2005?).
That's a pretty complete timeline. Not like he left out years.
Of course, I fell asleep during that show...twice. It was all repeat to me. And, Planet Green TV tends to show it late at night when I finally am tired. :^0
by jck
I am saving that for someone else's :^0
Oh dear...I feel a bit...swillish. ]:)
It's a fact that my socks match in size and colour, medium, navy blue for the intensely curious.
What concusions do you draw from this fact?
That I either wear white shoes and trousers exhibiting absolutely no sense of colour, or that I wear dark casual or sober shoes and jeans.
Perhaps if you surveyed the rest of the TR membership, who habitually wear dark matching socks, you could get a more 'scientific' appraisal of my fashion sense, or lack of .
Perhaps you could do a model, hue of socks and trousers predicting fashion sense , artistic school, introvert or extrovert....
All this 'science' might have some value, but for two crippling details that stop you from drawing any conclusion about teh object of study, moi.
Never told you what colour of shoes I wear did I?
And dark socks with light trousers on occasion is seen as fashionable.....
Read a real scientific proof of something, it might lack the rigour of a mathematical proof, but won't have this sort of bollocks in it. Accepting it as proof simply shows that you believe the theory.
No control = no scientific method.
by tonythetiger
[i](1) it's possible for human activity to affect climate, and (2) it probably already has. There's not a big debate about these two principles.
[/i]
how, and how significantly?
If CO2 is how we're doing it, we're not affecting it very much, since it has been warmer with much lower (280 ppm) levels. (I think we're just over 380 now.)
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by jck
Questioning their claim without a quantitative, logical explanation of fact that is proof to back their statement of that which they say is false.
I can let anyone "peer review" my code.
Does that mean if they say it's done wrong that it doesn't work?
Nonetheless, I pointed out the weakness in just one of their points in their argument to the contrary that was false.
CO2 is not solely, majorly or in any greatest quantity *only* responsive to "specific" IR frequencies.
That was an out and out untruth, and meant to mislead or misinform people about how thermal propagation occurs atmospherically.
I'll be glad to find you theses and dissertations on molecular harmonics and thermodynamics, if you so desire to prove your source wrong.
by jck
It vibrates...harmonically resonant or not.
That is why there is something called "inharmonic resonance" as well as "harmonic imbalance".
A piece of matter accepts energy *best* at its *true harmonic phase*. However, I can take a string cut to the length for F#'s frequency. I can blow an F note in front of it, and as inharmonic as that is, it [b]will[/b] vibrate.
Oh and btw. In case you didn't know:
The energy put off from the sun is cross-spectral from that of the ultra-infrared to gamma (and even some say cosmic) radiation.
So yes, there is a greatly varied band of energy being put forth by the sun.
The sun isnt blowing just one frequency of energy at a time.
by tonythetiger
[i]A piece of matter accepts energy *best* at its *true harmonic phase*. However, I can take a string cut to the length for F#'s frequency. I can blow an F note in front of it, and as inharmonic as that is, it will vibrate.[/i]
But while you're blowing the F, someone else is blowing the F# with equal energy, and the string will "prefer" to vibrate at the right frequency.
[i]So yes, there is a greatly varied band of energy being put forth by the sun.[/i]
I know. I was trying to say that the sun's energy output [b]at any given frequency[/b] doesn't change appreciably from one (relatively short time period) to the next.
by jck
Requires evidence.
NOAA has evidence that dates back 400k+ years, that up until the industrial age there was a standard norm for how the Earth's atmosphere, ecology, climatology, etc., behaved., which even [b]predated[/b] homo sapiens.
However in the past 100 years or so, there have been two things occurred that are the most likely causes for the increase of CO2 in the atmosphere, which are:
1) An increase of approximately 3 times the people walking on the face of the Earth
2) Industrialization of approximately 80 percent of the world population.
Since those two things started, the CO2 levels in the atmosphere have climbed above anything in the data that science has retrieved from ice core sampling, gas analysis, etc.
We, as a race, are guilty of taking the planet from "just fine" (which is its natural state) to "polluted".
So, want proof we are unnaturally putting contaminants in the air?
When you drive your car, does it put more CO2 and other pollutants than if you just rode a bicycle and didn't burn fuel?
Yes, it is just that simple.
Guilty.
To alleviate those who would commit an act of selfishness from their responsibility to mankind and their planet is to let the killer walk away with the smoking gun.
;)
by oz_media
Canada accepts me residing here, they haven't forced me to, that was my 'choice'.
If I didn't agree with Canada's taxation laws, I actually have two CHOICES. I can become a citizen and vote for my preference, or I can leave. I am not bound to this country's taxation or laws unless I DECIDE to live here.
As far as paying taxes period,any decmocratic country allows you to elect the government of people's favour. Government, by definition, includes taxation and the allocation taxes.
All governments tax their citizens, sorry to disappoint your no taxation objectives, as it supports the infrastructure required to function in the world and protects the people within the nation.
HOW those taxes are allocated is challenged at every election; that is when you get to have your say, not now.
Should your preferred government not be elected, you can either stfu and deal with it, as most people do until they are able to vote again, or move somewhere else where their laws coincide with your more idyllic tax allocation desires.
by oz_media
Jeff Dunwoody, is a ventriloquist with a purple, monkey like puppet, that whenever he tells Jeff something that he just doesn't get he fans his wiso of hair to indicate that it flew over his head.
Your replies are so dense sometimes that it makes me just want to bang my head on a wall.
You really have no idea what you are saying. You suggest something is not proven, so I say it is best to err on the side of caution. You then reply that it is not because the end result is not proven. Zooooooom, right over the head again.
You are a great guy, I'm sure, but bloody frustrating to try and have a logical conversation with. :D
You don't only miss the point of what I am saying, you don't even get what YOU are saying.
by oz_media
is your belief anyway. no criteria is your belief.
As for the colour of your socks, I have yet to own blue socks of any sort, something I may consider if I take up banking I suppose.
by oz_media
by oz_media
I thought that the most recent core illustrated an 800K year history.
but Tony will just quickly dismiss it due to Smarties not all being the same colour anyway.
by jck
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
[i]It's a fact that my socks match in size and colour,[/i]
Mine don't. I have a pair on right now. One is blue and the other black. I have another pair just like them at home :)
by oz_media
by tonythetiger
that the energy output at any particular wavelength does not change much from second to second.
I would have said "stable" instead of "static".
by oz_media
by oz_media
So many people say DUCK tape as opposed to duct (me and my peeves again).
..even though there is now a brand of low quality, utility tape made from fibre reinforced PolyPro, that is branded DUCK tape.
Oh and it is comforting also to know you won't be 'popping' the cat in the near future too. :D
Ahh, what a thread of nonsense this has become.
supply this morning to human impact. Mind you it could have been the missus, mixing blue and black do to poor lighting conditions in an unseasonal storm.
'Proof' climate change leand to increase in mismatched socks.
:D
If you wish to assess the impact of factor in an experiment, you subject none and some to the same conditions, the difference in behaviour is what you measure.
My greenness, is essentially an aesthetic position.
I'd rather see awoodland habitat teeming with life, than a car park and a slightly healthier bank balance.
by oz_media
As far as automotive batteries, Canadian provinces either charge a recycling fee or impose an environmental levy on all such batteries, have done for a couple of years now. They also have to implement a proper recycling program, some won't even let cash and carry consuers but a battery. Just an in vehicle swap. Unless of course for a boat, motorhome etc.
WIth more common dry cell batteries (AAA, AA, C cells etc) Radio Shack (now Circuit city) has that such a recycling program as long as I remember. I remember having a batter club card as a 10 year old, once a month I could go to RS and give them the 9-volt from my Electronic Quarterback game and get a new one.
Canadian Tire and most other garages offer free oil recycling services. You just drop off your old oil jugs, even after hours in most places they offer a cart to leave oil on, and they recycle it. Many gas stations allow for bulk oil dumping etc now too.
THESE are some of teh mroe simple tasks that people need to take upon themselevs that will help us reserve our resources and become more aware of the other products we waste. I was just wondering yesterday about some stuff I had to take to teh dump and started thinking SOME of these things I don't really want to dump, like a couple of really old matress and box sping sets, today I did my homework and found out that several local furniture retail outlets will actually pick it them for free and send them for recycling, saving me time, energy and dumping fees.
It;s just a matter of becoming more resourceful on a global scale and wasting less. Do we really need to buy everything in COSTCO size portions, that has been shipped from the other side of the world, just to save a dollar when we wind up wasting more?
by tonythetiger
by oz_media
the media has focused on that spin. Which is what makes the issue a focus for anti-GW supporters to focus on.
Ignoring other facts of the Earth's visible and easily confirmed changes.
CO2 levels are 100% proven to be at their highest during such time of change, that's all.
EDIT: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attribution_of_recent_climate_change
I kn ow it's just a wiki page but that's the easiesy way to review a collection of various sources and their contritbuting articles. All noted sources are listed if yuo decide to further investigate them.
As you failed to even read a simple post that Max rpesented before runnign off at teh mouth, ignoring his requested guidelines for reply, I doubt you will take more than a glance (if even that) before spouting your unqualified and outdated rebuttal. But its there if you would like a refreasher on the real issues people are discussing outside of teh local media buzz.
by tonythetiger
[i]CO2 levels are 100% proven to be at their highest during such time of change, that's all.[/i]
I didn't claim otherwise. What I claimed was that it has not been proven that higher CO2 levels contribute significantly to climate change.
that Americans do not understand irony.
:)
by tonythetiger
the source for the original data, is in my country then I do have to believe that any comment you or the somewhat ineptly named "American Thinker" have to make about them is pretty irrelevant and - in this case - wrong.
As for the irony...
by webdes2000
by tonythetiger
that CO2 is the highest level in the last 800k years.
That is actually evidence that CO2 is NOT a major contributor to global warming, [u]since those very same records show the earth has been warmer with lower levels of CO2.[/u]
You guys keep pushing that CO2 straw man though. The result will be the near total alienation of science, and then when they really DO see something, nobody will listen.
Remember "The Little Boy Who Cried 'Wolf'".
[i]Science is more than a body of knowledge; it's a way of thinking. A way of skeptically interrogating the universe with a fine understanding of human fallibility. If we are not able to ask skeptical questions, to interrogate those who tell us that something is true - to be skeptical of those in authority - then we're up for grabs by the next charlatan, political or religious, who comes ambling along.[/i]
-Carl Sagan
I think it's appropriate - especially in this case - to [i]ask skeptical questions, to interrogate those who tell us that something is true - to be skeptical of those in authority[/i] - because I think they're a bunch of [i]charlatans[/i].
by tonythetiger
You don't ASK any questions. You are not sceptical. You are a committed nay-sayer.
The only way to "interrogate those who tell us something is true" is with knowledge of your own. You might also try - even occasionally would be good - interrogating those who tell you something is false. But the latter feed your personal requirements.
Does this truth/falsity crap have to do with [i]science[/i]?
Are you all emissaries from the Office of Error?
Note: the use of the word [i]you[/i], in most cases, is plural, addressing the whole of the mm gw/cc advocates.
I ask:
Why don't you (scientists, et al) make all of your data and papers available for peer review to other climate scientists who disagree with your theories and conclusions, and who claim that your computer models are flawed or incomplete?
And why don't you answer their questions?
And why doesn't the UN have any climate skeptics on the IPCC?
And why do you use words like consensus and majority when they are neither proven nor accurate?
And why do you claim that mm gw/cc is a foregone conclusion when it clearly is not?
And why do you misrepresent (or flatly lie about) glacier characteristics?
And why do you misrepresent (or flatly lie about) Arctic and/or Antarctic ice characteristics?
And when introduced to climate skeptics, why do you (including the singular [i]you[/i], Neil) only discredit the person instead of seriously addressing the argument presented?
And why do the media (except for the [i]Internet media[/i]) refuse to give equal-time to the climate skeptics?
And why do ALL of the, so-called, solutions to mm gw/cc conveniently fall under the umbrella of socialist and/or collectivist ideals, always demonizing and blaming capitalism?
And why are 99.99 percent of those pulling and/or riding the mm gw/cc bandwagon left-leaning politicians, supporters, pundits, and activists?
And why won't James Hansen participate in a public discussion with Bill Gray and allow Dr. Gray to directly challenge Dr. Hansen on many of his assertions?
Bottom line question: What do you have to hide?
I ask the questions that I'm qualified to ask. I don't presume to be a global warming and/or climate expert (like jck and others who hang around the TR water cooler).
Something's rotten in the state of Denmark, so to speak, and I ask what it is? However, no one will dare answer any of these questions. Why is that?
I ask a lot of questions - none of which have come even close to being answered.
P.S. I wonder how the state of Denmark was selected for that particular saying? If I was Denmark, I'd be offended.
P.P.S. Grab a brew or a cup of tea, Neil, and try to answer those questions, one by one.
P.P.P.S. To the mm gw/cc advocates (as described above), why does [i]just in case[/i] trump individual freedom and liberty? And why does prevention trump adaptation?
by tonythetiger
[i]The only way to "interrogate those who tell us something is true" is with knowledge of your own.[/i]
What is the "knowledge" that allows one to question... say... the existence of God?
That's so "Middle Ages", Neil. What?, "You peasants will heed us... because we KNOW, and you are not qualified to question us!"? As you once said... bollocks!
What is the [b]proof[/b] that CO2 is a significant contributor to climate change?
(And no, Oz, the answer isn't, "Man causes CO2 to be emitted into the atmosphere.", nor is it, "CO2 is a greenhouse gas.", and it's not "CO2 levels higher than they've been in at least 800,000 years.". None of these facts, alone or in combination [b]proves[/b] that CO2 significantly contributes to climate change.)
The kings are down to their knickers. Next hand!
by tonythetiger
has as its first order of business, its own survival.
...[i]any comment you or the somewhat ineptly named "American Thinker" have to make about them is pretty irrelevant and - in this case - wrong. [/i]
If it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck...
I paraphrase Steven Hawking.
(I'll find and provide a link to the exact comment if anyone questions.)
The how (the beginning of the universe) is less important than the why. If we can find the answer to why, we will have tapped into the mind of God.
I wonder how Hawking defines God?
I was recently watching a YouTube video of an interview facilitated by, I believe, Charlie Rose, with Stephen Hawking, Carl Sagan, and ..... dang - I forgot who the third guy was.
Nonetheless, I'm not inaccurate with my paraphrase. I'd lay 1000-1 on it.
by tonythetiger
[i]If we can find the answer to why, we will have tapped into the mind of God.[/i]
The answer is: Because :)
By way of causality, you have tapped into the Algorithm of the Almighty, have you?
Lay it on us.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by puppybreath
Sort by Trending