Discussion Locked

Heads you win, tails I lose - all based on a false premise

0 helpful
391 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

391 replies

by tonythetiger

[i]That's the answer as we can know it, now.[/i]

I just gave it to you...

[i]We haven't the wherewithal to pinch the infinite. [/i]

You are of course, speaking for yourself and ???

by tonythetiger

I can't control them (that, at least, should be obvious), and I can't explain them :)

The only thing I do know is that Totality came into existence with my first conscious thought, and as long as I continue to think, it will continue to exist.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

[i]...Totality came into existence with my first conscious thought, and as long as I continue to think, it will continue to exist.[/i]

That makes you God, does it not?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

[i]came into existence with my first conscious thought, and as long as I continue to think, it will continue to exist.[/i]

How can it be otherwise?

by santeewelding

You are getting dreamy on me.

I hope you know: I can be down and dirty with God.

Don't you -- nor, anyone else -- be go getting indistinct with me.

by dr dij

one snowstorem invalidates GW!

We're entering a new ICE AGE,
This data refutes GW totally:

In august it was 70oF
each month it has dropped a few degrees.

It is now 10oF!

At this rate we'll be at the temp of Pluto (the diss'd non-planet) in a couple years.

never mind that it is 90o in Australia and rising! Woops, we're all going to fry like Venus!

by oz_media

LOL, that's not wat was said at all. The 800K years was simply a correction on the age of the ice core samples.

The whole CO2 straw man argument was devised by the ANTI-GW crowd. :D

That is teh one miniscule tidbit of data that was taken well out of proportion and dismissed as proof the GW wasn't occuring. GW scientists don't propose that CO2 is directly the cause for GW, if youd get up to speed onteh subject you wouldn't post such laughable comments that are so off base, in this case, an absolute opposite of the real debate.

Jeepers, how damn lost can you get on this subject? You've already proven you don't have a clue what your on about, now you don't even know what the topics of debate are? I posted a link for you, suggesting you wouldn't read it, that explains all this and how the naysayers hang onto the CO2 straw man argument.
This proves that, as predicted, you didn't read it and again are proving it with clueless posts due to your lack of knowledge on the subject.

by oz_media

That I posted describing correlation vs association. Anti GW fanatics, ar ethe ones who raise teh CO2 straw man argument, not teh scientists. Scientists don't say one causes the other, that's a weak argument from the anti-gw crowd.

by oz_media

"I looked out into my own backyard and it doesn't support global claims."

The fact that Americans don't see beyond their own yards and have no clue what the rest of the world is doing, is the big problem in America.

by oz_media

All of your posts and all of your views here are not about accepting questioning at all, they are focused on the fact that science questions data which results in their conclusions, thus cannot be trusted.

Unfotunately, I don't think God is going to let us know the facts on the subject, therefore predictions and conclusions based on findings and questioning causes is all that is left...'science'.

To you, that is not black and white enough.

[b]Your basis of argument is that it is not a proven fact, therefore such science is hogwash,[/b] as is the reson behind this entire thread.

If you are trying to suggest that your dismissal of scientific conclusion is in iteself 'science' you are out of your mind, but that's nothing new.

I used to be amused at how you pruposely take comments out of context to support yoru own conclusions, but in teh last few years I think it's a result of you simply not understanding what you are reading anymore. As proven with your article that you started the thref with.

by oz_media

Was how Max [i]thinks[/i] he has used scienctific methods to support his CONCLUSIONS, which is why he doesn't buy into GW. Yet overtly dismisses scientists using the same method of questioning data to arrive at their conclusions, as it is not factual.

'When they do it, it is not credible. When I do it it creates a solid argument.'

by oz_media

" Why are 99.99 percent of those pulling and/or riding the mm gw/cc bandwagon left-leaning politicians, supporters, pundits, and activists?"

You see CC as a leftist view and see it as a left vs right issue, as you do all political issues too.

Anyone believing in CC is immediately deemed a left wing activist, in your eyes, and that is why there is no support from what you accept as the right.

Until the GOP tells you they are on board with CC, it will always be a leftist issue to you. However then you'll probably say they are flip flopping and weak in their convictions, as they are really leftists.

by oz_media

Science has proven evolution beyond a reasonable doubt. We can see it in carbon dating methods and astrological discovery. We know the Eart wasn't simply made as we see how other planets form too.

ANY preacher of ANY religion will tell you to simply have FAITH and look for your own signs/reasons to believe.

by puppybreath

That would seemingly disprove a couple of bible stories but doesn't disprove the existence of God (or a group of Gods depending on the religion).

You've asked Max, a non-believer, to disprove human assisted global warming when many supporters are following along with this psuedo-religion "just in case".

I'm asking you, a non-believer, to disprove the existance of God (or Gods) when many supporters of their religion are following along in their religions "just in case".

I don't want you to disprove any or all of stories told in some religious document, just prove beyond a reasonable doubt that God doesn't exist.

by oz_media

Your ignorance of the subject is once again proven in your comment:[i]"What is the proof that CO2 is a significant contributor to climate change?"[/i]

You refuse to read the facts, you refuse to read the corrections when you misunderstand what people are saying. It's as if you have one train of thought and simply can't ingest anything else. As a result you throw around the same old, weak, argument that is the onlly argument anti-CC crowd has offered and yet it is not even an issue of debate.

NOBODY, get this for once [b]N O B O D Y[/b] is saying that CO2 CAUSES CC or GW. That is just what people such as yourself wrongly use as a defense.

Again, look at the what scientists are REALLY saying.

The dominant mechanisms to which recent climate change has been attributed all result from human activity. They are:

-increasing atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse gases (one known greenhouse gas, of MANY, is CO2)
-global changes to land surface, such as deforestation
-increasing atmospheric concentrations of aerosols. (no, not just aerosols as in hairspray)
- sulfate aerosols from fossil fuel combustion, exert a cooling influence on the climate which partly counteracts the warming induced by greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide. Aerosol impacts are admittedly unconfirmed conclusions that are the current basis of scientific studies.

Attribution of recent change to anthropogenic forcing is based on the following facts:

-The observed change is not consistent with natural variability.
-Known natural forcings would, if anything, be negative over this period.
-Known anthropogenic forcings are consistent with the observed response.
-The pattern of the observed change is consistent with the anthropogenic forcing.

By studying the Earth's changes over 800,000 years, they can safely say that the changes we have seen recently are NOT in course with natural actions and that there are many other contributing factors that are a result of our industrial focused existence.

They have illustrated that CO2 levels are but one of MANY greenhouse gases that are highest when climate change occurs. They are NOT saying it is the reason, YOU are concluding that yourself and offering it as your sole, weak argument that isn't in debate by anyone anyway.

SEE: Attribution of "recent" climate change:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attribution_of_recent_climate_change

Perhaps you'll take off the broken record. Who am I kidding, you don't read.

by oz_media

[i]"one can define god as the embodiment of the Laws of Nature", but that most people think of god as "a human-like being with whom one can have a personal relationship. When you look at the vast size of the universe and how insignificant and accidental human life is in it, that seems most implausible". [/i]

http://forum.richarddawkins.net/viewtopic.php?p=40817

Link includes a link to the BBC interview where he stated the above.

by Member 25348569

"Man causes CO2 to be emitted into the atmosphere.", nor is it, "CO2 is a greenhouse gas.", and it's not "CO2 levels higher than they've been in at least 800,000 years."

If those things are true then how can this CO2 NOT be having an effect?

by Member 25348569

OK, I have a cup of tea. Well, I actually have my Morning Mug which is around 3/4 pint (our pint and not your piddly pint). It's raining hard and so I was going to try and answer some of your questions. It would have been nice if you could have put them in the order that's most important to you.

But I need more information because I'm "me". I consider most of your questions are the set always posed by those who are against the MMGW concept. Most of them are in the form of flat statements of "fact" that I don't even know to be true!

The easy one first - Denmark. It's Shakespeare, said by Marcellus in Hamlet and it's pointed at Denmark because the play is set there. The phrase is generally misused. Given YOUR particular views, however, I would think that you would consider it very apt. It's a finely targeted phrase as the "state of Denmark" rather than "Denmark" implies that the "rotting" is from the head down.

A couple that I can partly answer as "me".

[b]Why don't you (scientists, et al) make all of your data and papers available for peer review.[/b] WE DO! I'm guessing what you mean here but everything that I've ever seen referenced is published in scientific journals available for ANYONE to comment on. The process of getting the material published is the "peer-review". My own scientific papers - I have a couple - were sent out to members of a panel of workers in the same field for critique before publication. It's designed to limit bias, misinterpretations and errors entering the pool of data that other scientific examination is based upon.

I assume that you're suggesting some sort of pro-GW cabal controls this process for all of the atmospheric science and suppresses the work that purports to "disprove" anything? Please point to specific examples.

[b]And why do the media (except for the Internet media) refuse to give equal-time to the climate skeptics?[/b] I'm sorry, but where does this requirement of "equal time" originate? I would guess the same notion of "fairness" that puts Intelligent Design alongside Evolution. Irrelevant. Anyway, I don't know about the USA but over here nothing other than readership figures forces the newspapers in any direction other than the one they want to go. Most people over here - including me - would be ecstatic if MMGW could be disproved (reluctant believers, most of us) and the newspapers know this. The "leaked emails" and the "Himalayan Glaciers" stories broke bigger than anything "pro" has ever done.

[b]"demonizing and blaming capitalism?"[/b] Well, jeaving aside the question as to whether they caused it all, MMGW is something that is going to really bite in ten, twenty years or more and Capitalism doesn't look past the next Board meeting.

It's brightening up and I'm going out now so I'll try some more later. Most are - as posed here - implicitly rhetorical so I'm not going to bother to try.

by Member 25348569

But I didn't know there were particular thread rules operating. I was answering Maxwell and he was answering me. When dealing with someone who is rabidly set against ones own position, I have long realised that a certain relaxed style is necessary.

Max knows this too! :)

I believe that an apposite - although quaint - American phrase is "bite me". Is the context correct?

:D

by Member 25348569

to give it a shot!

Which of the many gods - and godesses - would you like me to have a stab at disproving? I can't do for ALL gods because the goalposts can get moved too easily but one at a time we can do easily. Once you've actually got the "god" defined, they disappear up their own arse in a burst of logic. Getting agreement on the definition is the difficult bit.

Really, though, the burden of proof is on the believer but that NEVER happens.

I infer from your post that Max's position and the position of those who think that MMGW is a real phenomenon is somehow equal, that some form of parity exists. I don't want him to prove anything. I just want him to step outside of his libertarian, "no one is telling ME what to do" shoes for a short while and examine the evidence.

:)

Of course I [b]know[/b] that gods are "outside logic and science" else this would have been nailed long ago.

by puppybreath

How about Buddha? That way we can get away from the Christian bashing; at least for a little while.

:-)

by Member 25348569

I quite like Buddha and I have no problem with Siddartha Gautama and the Eightfold Path. All the Buddhists that I know are nice people.

:)

by puppybreath

I have never studied Buddhism so wasn't clear on their history or beliefs. I just thought of it after hearing Tiger over the weekend. That's what I get for trying to stay away from Christianity. :-)

How about Vishnu?

by oz_media

He exists in millions of human minds.

But as science proves more and more fact about the Earth's formation by studying other planets that have and continue to form in the exact same fashion, BELIEF falls flat.

I won't ask you to prove your FAITH; that is in your personal set of BELIEFS that help you to continue your life and feel you have purpose. Everyone needs 'faith' in something, whether religion or the science of creation and evolution.

However when compared to facts found in modern times, as opposed to beliefs carried on for two millenia, religion has nothing other than a history of people showing faith with no supporting facts.

I agree that a simple farmer named Noah may have actually built an ark, it doesn't matter that filling it with a collection of Gods creatures is unrealistic and impossible. However it was simply a man who THOUGHT he was instructed to do so as he had faith and believed in God.

Again, there are no priests, God's supposed voice, that will or can prove the existence of the lord they ask you to follow. They simply tell you you MUST believa dn have faith, then all of a sudden random acts of life will appear to be a message from God.

The more you look at it, the more BELIEF and FAITH is required and facts simply don't exist to support it.

As for Bhuddism, I too agree that it is an excellent system of being, again based on faith. In fact many of my "personal" more spiritual "values" fall in line with Bhuddism, another set of beliefs tah I feel create more preferable character to Christianity comes from North American native Indians who are far more in tune with the Earth than most other faith I see.

I don't think a man in a acmoe crosses the sky and sets the moon up every night, but I certainly admire their respect for wisely using land's resources and nature's right to life.

If I had followed Christianity 'religiously' then I would be hard pressed to choose either the old or new testament. God wants me to be a bastard that doesn't accept anyone non Christian or God wants me to accept everyone, but have faith in only him anf ollow only his unspoken word. Hmmmm.

by Member 25348569

and the problem is that I know relatively little about it. Vishnu, if I remember correctly, is the Top God. However, disproving Vishnu's existence is something that I'll still try and do once I find out what Vishnu is all about. I can't apply logic when I don't know what Vishnu does...

The number of different religions has always intrigued me and the way that most personal religious beliefs can be inferred from the beliefs your parents or the culture in which you were raised.

A Saudi Arabian will be a Muslim, an Irish citizen will likely be Catholic and an Indian will be a Hindu. I wonder how many theists ask the question: "are my religious beliefs a product of cultural and familial brainwashing?"

:)

by maxwell edison

How many of us remember when the global warming scare first came onto the political scene with its full steam ahead agenda, and the advocates were predicting catastrophic rises in sea levels that would result in major seaboard cities, such as New York, London, Miami, et al, finding themselves totally submerged by sea water in, what they then predicted, a mere 50 years.

Well, we're about half-way there on their initial time-line, but nowhere close on their predicted rise-line. And now, the ones who cling to the sea-level lifeboat, decided to talk in a time-line measured by centuries, not decades. (I suppose they think we can meet on the shores Miami Beach to verify their predictions - or Orlando Beach, of course, if their predictions actually came true.)

The future King of England is still clinging:

[i][b]PRINCE CHARLES ON CLIMATE CHANGE: GLOBAL WARMING SCEPTICS ARE ALL LIARS[/b]:

"Well, if it is but a myth, and the global scientific community is involved in some sort of conspiracy, why is it then that around the globe sea levels are more than six inches higher than they were 100 years ago? This isn't an opinion - it is a fact."[/i]

http://www.express.co.uk/posts/view/156294/Prince-Charles-on-climate-change-Global-warming-sceptics-are-all-liars

Really, Prince? Who's the lair, here? Other than natural and historic fluctuations in global sea levels, there is absolutely nothing to even remotely conclude that anything has been caused by human activity! Moreover, the current predictions - for whatever they may or may not be worth - are both insignificant and consistent with what might have happened anyway in the absence of ANY human activity.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2010/feb/21/sea-level-geoscience-retract-siddall

[i]"Retraction is a regular part of the publication process ..... Science is a complicated game and there are set procedures in place that act as checks and balances."[/i]

Too bad the good Prince and those still on the [i]rise in sea level[/i] floating bandwagon - including many around the TR water cooler - don't know the meaning of the word [i]retract[/i].

But still, doom and gloom persists:

[i]"I can only appeal to you to listen to the cries of those who are already suffering from the impact of climate change," he said.[/i]

http://www.express.co.uk/posts/view/146265/Prince-Charles-Executive-jet-with-big-carbon-footprint-gets-him-to-climate-change-talks

And who might those people be, Charlie? Let me guess. You'd cite all those people - mostly in underdeveloped countries - who have been suffering the impact of ....... (whatever - including political corruption) anyway. And you use taxpayer funds to justify and [i]offset[/i] YOUR hypocrisy.

Sorry, Charlie, the [i]rise in sea level[/i] football has, yet again, been pulled away from you at the precise moment you thought you would make a successful kick, and you've ended up flat on your back. (A little mixing together of cartoon characters - Charles and Charlie! With all due credit, of course, to yet another Charles - Charles Schultz.)

by oz_media

You are so overwhelemed with trying to discount the factors that surround GW/CC, that clearly you are the one who is drowining in the GW/CC theory.

Similar to politics, you expend so much effort trying to disprove the opposition that you miss the important part in between, living life.

If by 'drowining in a sea of lies' you feel that people are over infatuated with the GW/CC concept, then the same can be said for yourself in your effort to dispell GW/CC due to it conflicting with your political acceptance of personal liberties.

If time is also money then is not your time vested, in what you believe to be a false theory, simply just wasting more of your money than the tax dollars you oppose spending?

Have you ever heard the term, "Not worth wasting my time over?"

You most obviously believe in the theory of CC but simply doubt there is substantial proof for it to become fact.

Proof that you need in order for you to feel that you have retained, or that the government has respected, your civil liberties.

Proof which can only be shown by centuries if not millennia of future time, which you nor I have.

Therefore your argument, once again, is simply one of sustaining your personal liberties.

You also keep posting these arguments as if they are proof and not the mere conjecture that they are.

by Member 25348569

Yes, I know I'm following my usual tack of shooting your messenger before commenting on the message but in this case I'd rather you quoted Al Gore than that hypocritical royal arsehole!

Look, Chas is a complete waste of space who's only in the newspapers because he's got a famous mum. He isn't very bright in what he says or when he says it. He's supposed to keep his gob shut - it goes with his job that we pay through the nose for - but he thinks that he is some sort of campaigner. All he manages to do is to prove over and over again that he is completely out of touch with everything.

As for the sea-level rise, I refer you to a quote in the guardian article "Siddall said that he did not know whether the retracted paper's estimate of sea level rise was an overestimate or an underestimate."

And?

by maxwell edison

[i]I (you) refer you (me) to a quote in the guardian article "Siddall said that he did not know whether the retracted paper's estimate of sea level rise was an overestimate or an underestimate."[/i]

Meaning they don't know squat. Yet the false claims are used over and over again by the mm gw/cc advocates - including two of your favorites Cousin Charlie and Uncle Albert - as [i]proof[/i] of their theory and justification for their intrusive solutions.

NONE of these people should be taken seriously.

Even you, Neil, have repeated the [i]London will flood[/i] argument. Are you ready to retract that prediction and call it unfounded?

by oz_media

Why would Prince Charles be goven any creidbility on such issues? That's like saying GWB or Obama knows what they are saying with respect to climate predictions.

They may parrot scientific conclusions that they themselves believe in, and feel it is their position to bring such findings to public attention, however it is people who are charged with the task of collecting evodence and supporting claims either for or against that support their own conclusions.

In short, people should make up their own minds. Anyone so easily coerced into conformity is obviously a sheep waiting to be lead, whether by a politician, monarch, media reporter etc. It's not the fault of the sources conclusion, its the fault of the person supporting it, as is that case with Prince Charles and those who support his objectives.

by maxwell edison

That's what I always thought growing up - that [i]the universe[/i] is everything, it's all that exists.

However, science has, since those formative years, suggested the big-bang theory is what started it all. That's all fine and dandy, but it does beg the question, if the universe began with the big-bang of something, where did that something reside before-hand?

Moreover, we also hear that the universe is still expanding. Therefore, if the universe is all that exists, into what is it expanding?

So when it's all said and done, I suppose it depends on what the meaning of the word [i]is[/i] is - or in this case, what the meaning of the word [i]exists[/i] is.

by oz_media

On if you believe that there is such thing as nothing. In order for something to become, there has to be nothing prior to it's beginning.

How many posts do you think we can reach with black holes? :D

by Member 25348569

Some of the visual noise on the screen is from the CMBR, cosmic microwave background radiation, which originated in the Big Bang.

It's just a few percent, the rest being random thermally generated signals in the electronics. The microwave photons were created in the first minute or so of the history of the Universe. since then, they've cooled to around 2.73 Kelvin.

Five minutes before THAT, there wasn't anything.

I'd post the maths but I don't understand it at all and I couldn't even guarantee to post it the right way up.

:)

by maxwell edison

I would concede that, at the instance of the big-bang, there wasn't anything that fits into scope of what we mere humans have discovered and/or have come to understand up to the present point in our on-going history of discovery and understanding.

If human history can be used as a guide, however, it stands to reason that what we do understand and have discovered up to now, pales in comparison to what we don't and haven't respectively. Would you agree?

In the book, [i]The History of Human Understanding and Discovery[/i], what chapter are we currently up to, and how many chapters are left to be written?

by oz_media

Wicked, retro moment, I LOVE IT!!!

I saw your link to YouTube and though, Oh No, here we go again, some indefinite clip from a university student. You tube is full of those scientific conclusions that are fodder of endless debate.

After only just finishing a ridiculous conference call with a motor mouth woman in Texas (she spoke faster than me when I was 18!) I just wasn't into more of a headwreaker.

But noooo, Billy Preston Jammin his little heart out!

Again, THANKS, I really needed that. Made my day! I have some new energy now and gonna get stuff done. (bookmarked for another day, if not right now)

by oz_media

I completely understand your viewpoint here but to suggest that what we have discovered is greater than what we haven't is pessimistic, if not arrogant.

We have no idea how much or how little we have discovered, compared to what we could or have not discovered.

Historically compared, we have definitely come leaps and bounds. But who's to say we have learned ANYTHING respectively when compared to what other possible civilizations on other planets may have learned in the same time?

For all we know, we are the dumbest race in the universe. And, if there were a god watching down upon us, would he be slapping his forehead and thinking "DAMN, this lot is stupid", or "MAN, they finally figured it out" or "Holy CRAP! What are they doing now?"

We have learned a lot about ourselves, our composition and the composition of the LAND we inhabit, but seeing as we haven't even properly explored the sea or outside our galaxy (apart from afar) we really can't say we know squat in the grand scheme of things.

Still got Nothing from Nothing in my head now! Tap tappin' away. That there is some damn funky music!

by Member 25348569

At the moment, at the very highest tides, the Thames rises to within a few feet of the top of the protective embankment walls. Even without additional rise in sea level if there is a strong atmospheric depression in the North Sea at the spring tides, London will flood. That's why we have the Thames barrier.

A couple of feet sea rise and even that might not be enough.

:)

The reason that I've maintained that London will flood is because it WILL.

by maxwell edison

.....dikes, dams, and levees.

You could take every automobile in the world off the road and shut down every coal fired power plant forever, and STILL the only fix would be found in dikes, dams, and levees.

Do you disagree?

([i]Factopinguess[/i] disclaimer acknowledged, since we obviously can't take every automobile in the world off the road and shut down every coal fired power plant forever.)

by Member 25348569

Why is action on cutting CO2 and action to protect the city in other ways in any way mutually exclusive?

That way, we make the dykes, levees and barriers lower.

:)

by maxwell edison

..... artist to get co-credit on a Beatles track (Get Back); he played the keyboards on that track as well on several others during those last [i]Let it Be[/i] sessions.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQOATAW-ZqE

He also joined the group for their last performmance together on the rooftop of Apple Records.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nT6325bmcsQ

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9MVWy09RQYo

[i]"......a bit of an imposition to disrupt all the business in the area....." [/i]

The guy probably later bragged about being there!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1_PS0fReYh8

Billy Preston on the [i]Get Back[/i] track. Gotta' love it. Rest in Peace, Billy. You live on in your music.

by maxwell edison

.....or your comment was for others.

[i]If human history can be used as a guide, however, it stands to reason that what we do understand and have discovered up to now, pales in comparison to what we don't and haven't respectively. Would you agree?[/i]

It appears that we agree.

by maxwell edison

...... cutting CO2, so to speak, will not only have NO affect on sea levels, but ALL - I repeat, ALL - of the proposed solutions to do so are anti-capitalism, anti-freedom, anti-free market; and they ALL - I repeat ALL - are pro-socialism and will wreak havoc on personal and economic freedom.

In short, because there is EVERYTHING to lose, and NOTHING to gain.

P.S. Here's where you go back to your doom and gloom predictions to justify your perceived gain.

by maxwell edison

[i][b]New Climate Agency Head Tried to Suppress Data, Critics Charge[/b]

The scientist who has been put in charge of the Commerce Department's new climate change office is coming under attack from both sides of the global warming debate over his handling of what they say is contradictory scientific data related to the subject.[/i]

http://www.foxnews.com/scitech/2010/02/22/tom-karl-tried-to-suppress-data-critics-charge/#/scitech/planet-earth/ci.New+Climate+Agency+Head+Tried+to+Suppress+Data%2C+Critics+Charge.opinion

by oz_media

Didn't Locke die?

Kidding aside, one rather unqualified man is not about to prove or disprove science.

I also don't buy a single Fox news source changing the views of the world, without the rest of the world acknowledging it. I think if there were supporting facts, it would preempt life as we know it, every news channel every radio station on the globe blasting the great news. We'd be burning vats of oil in the streets to celebrate. Unless it's a secret scientific breakthrough/dicovery of course.

That's kind alike saying someone found a bigfoot carcass or has God in his basement, but is not telling the rest of the world.

Proof it is not, not of anything.

So Karl is in bed with politicians and people have ACCUSED him of misrepresentation.

I can accuse you of murder, it doesn't make you a killer no matter how many blogs and rags I submit it to.

I assume you also feel that the IPCC is the only scientific body that supports CC/GW too. Maybe that's the root of your disbelief and why you always see a political slant on it.

by oz_media

Firstly, yes I did misread your post and reneg my comment, was was based on a complete misunderstanding of your comment.

Billy P. yes I remember the rooftop performance, don't remember what BIO it was in but I've seen the movie/doco that details it. He also covered Blackbird of course, but I dont know if that was a Beatles original, I just assume it was.

by oz_media

You both exist, therefore you are.

As for the political, Anti-freedom BS, that's your expected and rather typical take as an American. Anti-capitallism? BS

Perhaps there will be some repercussions or changes for people who wnt to be as environmentally irresponsible as they please.

That doesn't make anything Anti-Freedom or Anti-Capitalism in anyway. Pro scoialism?

I assume you lump conservative leaders in your list of Anti-capitalism, pro-socialism findamentalists too then. They are really socialists in diguise.
If they don't follow your beliefs, they must be?

by oz_media

I often wonder why you bother commenting.

You have only ever offered comments that rate other people's comments here. Just yuor typical peanut gallery commenting, with nothing relevant or useful to add to the discussion at all. Do you actually have a purpose other than mere judgement of other people's discussions without offering content of your own?

I suppose by saying nothing, you don't have to defend your opinions. You can just sit in the background and hold up scorecards while thinking you are still being a relevant participant.

by jdclyde

Between expressing yourself in a discussion verses going around intentionally trying to offend others.

Hate crime laws are stupid. Should it be more of a crime to kill someone I don't like compared to someone I don't know? Is it worse to kill someone because of race/sexual orientation instead of for their wallet?

Many dishonest people in this country claimed GW Bush was racist because he didn't apply "hate crime" status on some rednecks that dragged a man to death. They were already convicted of murder and given the death sentence, what more can you do to them?

by jdclyde

Your statement is equal to me demanding non-believers PROVE their is no God.

The burden rests entirely on the people bringing the case before the world, and everywhere we look, they have failed miserably.

The hottest year was 15 years ago? The world naturally warms and cools. Always has, always will.

If the claim that CO2 = increased temp, the world would be continuing to warm at a faster rate, which has not happened. CO2 continues to rise but the temps are not rising? Or are you not honest enough to admit such a thing?

Think maybe deforestation has more of an impact than anything else? Instead of declaring war on companies, lets declare war on deforestation.

by jck

[i] Wrong again JCK, go stand in the corner.......[/i]

No thanks. I'm sitting in my office chair :)

[i] Your statement is equal to me demanding non-believers PROVE their is no God.[/i]

Well if you want me to believe YOU and that it doesn't exist...then prove it to me.

Science has already proven that CO2's thermal retention within the Earth's atmosphere.

Therefore, greater CO2 concentration in the atmosphere means greater heat retention.

It's simple science that they teach kids.

Now, can you prove otherwise?

Please do so, if you can.

[i]The burden rests entirely on the people bringing the case before the world, and everywhere we look, they have failed miserably.[/i]

Wrong. If YOU want ME to believe YOUR side that says "CO2 is not causing global warming", YOU have to provide me PROOF.

Science has provided me with scientific data showing CO2 retains heat in the atmosphere, and that increasing that level of CO2 increases the amount of heat retained.

Again, simple science. If you can conclusively prove otherwise and show irrefutable proof that CO2 does NOT retain heat, then you can get me to say I'm wrong.

[i]The hottest year was 15 years ago? The world naturally warms and cools. Always has, always will.[/i]

The hottest year on record [b]globally averaged on record[/b] was 2005...not 1995.

True. The earth has cycles. One of them is El Nino. That's part of the reason there has been some cooling the past few years.

[i]"There's substantial year-to-year variability of global temperature caused by the tropical El Ni?o-La Ni?a cycle. But when we average temperature over five or ten years to minimize that variability, we find that global warming is continuing unabated."[/i]
-James Hansen, director of the NASA - Goddard Institute for Space Studies

But if you look at temperature alone compared to CO2, you're ignoring other greenhouse gas concentrations that have diminished greatly over the past 600k-800k years ago which made the planet more suitable for mammalian lifeforms vs the warmer, moister planet that was here previously.

[i]If the claim that CO2 = increased temp, the world would be continuing to warm at a faster rate, which has not happened.[/i]

Funny. The statistics show that global temperature is up.

Now, keep those cycles in mind you claim to be so prevalent.

The hottest year on record: 2005
2nd hottest year on record: 2009

[i] CO2 continues to rise but the temps are not rising? Or are you not honest enough to admit such a thing?[/i]

The temperature is rising still on global average.

Remember those cycles you mentioned? El Nino-La Nina. cause periodic coolings. The temps are going back up again.

[i] Think maybe deforestation has more of an impact than anything else? Instead of declaring war on companies, lets declare war on deforestation.[/i]

I've suggested that too.

But, here's some more elementary science for you: All those plants they have already cut down (some 20% of the Amazon greenery already) eats that CO2. Oops!

But, some people (including some of your TR cohorts here) eat that McDonalds burger that is from cattle raised and butchered and shipped from...The Amazon...where they are stripping the land for farming cattle because it pays better than farming trees or fruit.

Yay fatness! :^0

by tony hopkinson

Perhaps a bit of a rethink required on your part.

Any position on climate change just like any position on god is onbe based on faith, we are not capabale of proving or disroving the contention of their existance.

Faith is acceptance of fact without proof.

by maxwell edison

...... into the lies, deceptions, and mistruths perpetrated by the mm gw/cc advocates, including, but not limited to, the testimony given by former Vice President Al Gore, who has reaped millions of dollars as a result?

by Member 25348569

Why not just put some proper money into an independent and public inquiry into whether MMGW has any basis in fact? See if you can keep the politics out, keep the lobbyists out and just stick to the science.

No chance while such attitudes as yours and Al Gore's are the norm for the two opposing sides.

Neil :)

Oh noes. Godwin's Law. Mmm mmmfh mmm...

by maxwell edison

[i]Why not just put some proper money into an independent and public inquiry into whether MMGW has any basis in fact? See if you can keep the politics out, keep the lobbyists out and just stick to the science.[/i]

That's an interesting idea. I wonder.........

However, money and politics (of some sort) usually go hand-in-hand. That would be the biggest obstacle. News outlets used to provide such a thing, but even they have become politicized.

How could it be done?

At the risk of using an over-used term, it would have to be a grass-roots effort that would, somehow, collect a lot of small donations from individuals who really do want to know. Big money - which usually comes with big influence - would have to be turned down.

Thoughts?

by jck

Even grass roots efforts get corrupted.

Greed isn't lost below a dollar level.

Someone is always money hungry...even for $.01.

by jck

[i] Or B.P. at 11 yrs. old with Nat King Cole
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1loV9_xLF8Q [/i]

If you get a network called Ovation TV on your cable/satellite, there is a program called "Nat King Cole: When I Fall In Love" that is a great tribute to the man, and includes the clip of Nat playing with Billy Preston on his former NBC television program.

I was raised on Nat King Cole. He's another case of an incredible talent and pioneer who was gone far too early.

by maxwell edison

No, I don't get that channel. I have rabbit ears - no cable TV.

But I love Nat King Cole - especially the stuff he did with the King Cole Trio in the late 1930s - 1940s. I have quite a bit of that music on 78 RPMs.

A great story about Nat King Cole:

In the late 1940s, he bought a home in an all-white neighborhood outside LA. The home owners association knocked on his door one night and told him that they were trying to keep out undesirables. His reply: [i]If I see any undesirables, I'll be the first to complain.[/i]

And a sad story:

He was an extremely heavy smoker. So much so, that he intentionally chain-smoked before performances and recordings because he though it kept his voice lower. He died of lung cancer at a too-early age.

by Member 25348569

You can't possibly use any oil-derived substances on the Messiah of Climate Change.

Anyway, I just want him silenced.

Permanently.

:)

But, because I care, I want it done in a way that is good for butterflies and green growing things.

This discussion is closed to new replies.