Discussion Locked

How to manage name and file structure of a file server any advices ?

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi everybody,

I am working in a company were we have a serious probleme with the files management.

Many users dont give a date to their files like : 2007/01/15 - File name and a correct name.

Do you know where i can find on internet a method who explain which is the best way to organize a file server ?

Thanks a lot for your answers.

7 replies

by wayne m.

There does not appear to be any problem statement here. Don't try to force a solution, a file naming convention, upon your users. You will get frustrated, they will get frustrated, and nothing will get better.

by marco7683-info

Hello !

Thanks for ur answer.

It s appear that for a lot of file it is impossible to know when the file have been modified !
Here is the deal... That s why we want to create a policy for this. My question is do you know if it is possible to download a such policy on internet ?

Best regards

Pierre

by wayne m.

Every file system I have ever worked with records the time and date when a file of any type is saved. Again, it is still unclear as to why this information it valuable to you.

If you are trying to implement version control on a set of documents, I think you will find that relying on a user naming convention to be undependable and difficult to enforce. I would suggest looking at various file or document control systems to do this, instead. CVS is freely available, others include Microsoft SourceSafe and SharePoint.

I would suggest stepping back and defining the problem that you are trying to solve. Whatever that problem may be, I will assure you that a file naming convention is one of the least effective solutions.

by marco7683-info

Dear Wayne i think u are right but:

most of our employes use such file name:
thing-2 finalFinal! v3 (with new changes) 05b.psd
for example... it is so hard to manage !

So my meaning we need to create a file policy for the file naming!

Otherwhise user never check the latest date through operating system. I also see sometimes the date recorded by the operating system is not good all the time. What do you think of this ?

Pierre

by wayne m.

If the problem is allowing the users to find and possibly update the laltest version of specific documents, I would recommend looking at either a file or document management system. Possibilities include SharePoint, CVS, SourceSafe.

The basics of a file or document management system are pretty simple. Typically, a read-only copy of a file or document is globally available for reading. To update, a user must obtain a writable copy through a check out operation. Many systems will only allow a single user to have a copy checked out. When the user completes his update, he checks the fle back in and the updated version is now globally available and the previous version is hidden from view (though still accessible through history operations).

If you want to avoid installing a file or document management system, you can do it manually through an e-mail process. Create the baseline of a document and set it to Read-Only mode. If a user wishes to update it, the user can send an e-mail request and you can e-mail back a writable copy. When the user is done, he e-mails back his update and the system admin overwrites the previous version with the new, Read-Only version.

Either of these approaches will work as long as the user community agrees there is a problem. Published naming conventions are rarely successful in managing documents.

by bbpellet

An opensource option would be KnowledgeTree.

For a full bells and whistles you have to buy support for it. But I have been using the OSS version for over a year, and have currently..257,000 documents indexes and stored in this DMS, work well for exactly what your doing.

This discussion is closed to new replies.