Discussion Locked

How to trick young people into becoming programmers

0 helpful
54 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

It seems young people these days aren't dopes. They've seen what happened during the tech bust, and it'll be a long time before they start trusting business talk of "wonderful opportunities in IT" again. The number of those in the West choosing to study to be programmers is plummeting, and this has business groups really worried.

But rather than doing something like, say, increasing salaries or improving benefits, business groups in the US have hit on a new strategy. They're going to trick young people into becoming programming fodder.

"Entice kids to study programming by focusing on the 'products' of computer science that they're already familiar with," a Business Week story on the strategy says, "animated movies, video games, and social-networking sites?rather than the process of writing code. Not only does this make the discipline seem less tedious, it gives programming an element of cool."

So researchers, in coordination with EA, have built a game to teach kids to program. That makes the whole thing seem like more fun.

"But the real return for EA will likely come years from now in the form of large pool of software programmers for hire," the story says. "At least, that's the hope of EA and the CMU researchers. And given the plummeting number of U.S. computer-science students, it should be the hope of everyone in the business world."

Then, once you've got them trapped, you can work them hard, sack them at will, cut their pay and threaten to outsource their jobs to Asia. Man, I'm getting cynical as I get older.

http://www.brainbox.com.au/brainbox/home.nsf/link/09112006-How-to-trick-young-people-into-becoming-programmers

54 replies

by tony hopkinson

Should expand on it.
Lets trick people into being managers as well by telling them they can run peoples lives. How about boxers, you get to hit people without going to jail. Soldiers you get a gun....

What a set of nipple heads!
Obviously the reason they never made programmers is they are incapable of logic.

by bigbigboss

After the kids go without food for six months, and their parents told them to find a job or else, they will smart up.

by deb

A lot of parents these days aren't the same we had as kids where they're pushing the kids out of the house. Just read any article on "helicopter parents" to see that some parents will go to any extreme to help their kids, even if it means supporting them well into their late 20's to enable them to be completely absorbed in their own being. There's a hole new generation of geeks living in their mom's basements.

by techexec2

American university students are choosing to not study computer science because they don't think enough of career prospects in the field these days. It has nothing to do with how "cool" programming is.

The relevant factors are:

- The dot com bust started the problem. This factor would go away except...

- Corporations are offshoring many thousands of computer programming jobs to India and China (the number is very big but secret for obvious reasons).

- The US government is permitting the importation of hundreds of thousands of cheap foreign programmers under the H-1B and L-1 visas in the USA (and the 457 visa in Australia), driving down pay rates.

Getting children interested in computer games and the programming behind them will have absolutely no effect on them when they enter the university, choose a major, and plan for a career.

The BusinessWeek article, and the Carnegie Mellon University researcher's work, is absurd. And what of EA's involvement? The only logical explanation is to sell more computer game software to the children right now. It has nothing to do with converting them into computer science students 10 years from now.

Solving the problem of low interest in computer science is very simple: Make the field more attractive to the American (and Australian) university students. Stop the offshoring and onshoring (H-1B, L-1, 457). Reestablish job and career security and the students will return to the field.

by jkameleon

Reducing the problem to H-1B is a bit simplicistic and one sided, IMHO.

In the olden days before globalization, there were dozens if not hundreds of small, more or less closed national markets, with dozens of competing companies on each of them. Each company had to do its own R&D.

Nowadays, there is only one global market, with a couple of competing megacorporations. Demand for creative, R&D work is correspondingly lower. It doesn't matter, whether a software product is sold in 1, 10, or 10 millions of copies- in any case, it has to be developed only once. The only thing that grows with the market is call center, marketing, and other non-technological job positions.

Employers, the business community, want to keep their supply of workforce high, of course, but I don't think they are behind the latest wave of "alarming decrease if interest"/"precipituos drop in enrollments"/"youth not excited about IT" hysteria. It's academic sphere. Lower demand & supply of IT workforce means less academic "raw material", and consequently less jobs and funding. Their lobbying is sometimes pretty silly

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/6155998.stm

"There is a real danger of a flight of jobs overseas [due to lack of computer science graduates]", says Professor Shadbolt from the University of Southampton. Looks like this guy just woke up from the 10 year hybernation, or something.

Economy aside- no matter how you turn it, no matter how you spin it- IT work seriously sucks, plain and simple. For the last 10 or 20 years or so, it was all about being user friendly, management friendly, business friendly, friendly to everyone except developers. As a matter of fact, the field became increasingly developer hostile. Enormous ammount of research effort was devoted to turn the production of software into assembly line type of work- measureable, manageable, predictable, non-empiric, and so on. One has to be seriously mazohistic to study only to become a mental assemby line worker.

Our Indian colleagues share this sentiment as well

http://www.businessworld.in/sep2004/contrary.asp

"In all this excitement about BPO creating jobs in India, we haven't really looked at what kinds of jobs they're creating. I'll tell you. They're all, without exception, low-end, sub-100-IQ type jobs, and - as the current attrition rate shows - we're consistently staffing them wrong."

This pretty much applies to the IT & programming too.

There will be no shortage of a bright, and innovative CS graduates; not because kids aren't interested in CS, but because there simply is no need for them.

by jmgarvin

As IT infrastructure becomes more complicated and the Baby Boomers exit the work force, there's going to be a interesting gap, esp in IT.

Why? We're losing HUGE amounts of experience all at once. We're not training, we're not prepping, and god forbid we actually think about REPLACING those that are going to retire.

It seems all corporations want are part time workers and H1Bs. You want to know the scary part? While CS enrollment is down, that also means CS graduate enrollment is down. So all that cool stuff that came out of R&D from academia is going to be no more. That gravy train is OVER...

by csmith8

I was enrolled for my CS but many employers want certifications. I wish that acredited colleges would start teaching OS's as well as basic programing. It would give the graduating students a better chance at landing a good job. I had a former teacher in the lab I created working on his Master's in CS and could not tell me the difference between a switch an a router. Maybe this was a isolated but I am not too sure. This was not the first time this happened to me. This kind of problem scares me.

by apotheon

The answer is open source software development. Online communities of intelligent people are increasingly seeing activity from people aware of, and interested in, open source development. As more intelligent people with a talent for programming grow up and make contacts in such online communities, many of them will be lured into open source development by a natural interest in it.

Increased use of open source software by businesses will cause them to increasingly desire the help of local open source developers to hire or contract with for support and modification of the software. This will be increasingly affordable because money will be saved on acquiring the basic software itself. As a result, open source developers will mostly be paid to support open source software, which is best done locally or by hiring the people who wrote it in the first place.

This tends to lead to people being paid based on what they've accomplished with their skills, rather than based on their ability to toe a bureaucratic line at a university.

. . . which leads me to the fly in the ointment. Corporations like EA are finding it difficult to hire people who meet their employment qualifications for the same reason open source software development may have a very difficult time reaching the state toward which it is trending, as described above. Specifically, the problem is that people place value on the wrong characteristics in a programmer -- corporate and university sanction, and the business model of powerful corporations that cannot abide runaway successes in open source software development. In reference to the corporate and university sanction, it's not your skillset that gets you hired by these companies, but rather your employment history and degree. I tend to guess you can figure out the other part for yourself.

by jmgarvin

I designed an entire elearning app as a master student. Yet, that wasn't good enough to be a software developer at most places. I hadn't proven myself.

What do you have to do to prove yourself? Writing and entire app isn't enough?

by lastchip

Incentives are not the answer.

A desire to know how things work and motivation are far more important and that's why open source projects (if seen through to a conclusion)will always be as good or better than commercial offerings.

by Former member

Sometimes open source is as good as closed source, most often not. Sometimes there is money in open source, mostly not. Open source has been debated since 1985 or earlier from memory with BSD Unix.

by problemsolversolutionseeker

I will be encouraging my children to be true businessmen and/or to take on a trade that requires local involvement such as plumbing...

Do not laugh - you can make a lot of money with a dry wall company if you have enough workers and business.

Selah.

by locolobo

I'm not laughing. The plumber comes out spends 1/2 hour running a snake through my sewer and collects $200. Of course I'm not considering drive time and overhead.

Paul

by jmgarvin

However, academics look down a certs as dirty little things. We all know the ol' sheep skin is FAR more worthy...right?

I think a big problem is that academia is pretty monolithic and it is HARD to get things to change. However, it seems some schools are coming around with various interesting methods and I have seen school partnering with MS, IBM, etc.

If you REALLY want certs, just drop the $100-$300 on the test and get the cert. I know it sucks, but it'll pay for itself pretty quickly.

by apotheon

"[i]it'll pay for itself pretty quickly.[/i]"
. . . if it gets you a job or a raise.

by lastchip

My daughter completed a CS BSc Hons two years ago and is always asking me how to fix her computer.

I often jibe a little and tell her she's the one with the degree and she should be telling me. Her honest reply? They didn't teach us anything useful!

The point being, she can program and has now gone a different route and is teaching IT in a High School, but when it comes to the practical "pull a computer a part, diagnose and fix a problem", she's lost!

That's why they have "techies" in schools!

by amyhr

The problem everyone here seems to be posting is that one person with a BS cannot do every job in IT. I know a graduate that can design a network with his eyes closed, but couldn't code his way past "Hello World" in any language. IT is no longer a "jack of all trades" industry where a single person can do everything. The standard now is that some people know programming while others know hardware. Even application maintenance is becoming more specilized as the skills for a successful backup/disaster recovery plan become much different than the skills for a successful security infrastructure.

Right now we're trying to hire an IT person to do Networking/Telecommunications. I could care less if the person hired knows how to track down a blocked email message unless the application side of the house identifies it being blocked below the OS layer. As the company looks to create a DBA position and hire for it we won't care if that DBA can upgrade the memory in their home computer as long as they can write and tune SQL queries and help to plan and impliment a SQL cluster to consolidate all our databases to one or two server clusters.

by half9

I had a similar experience when I was doing my A+. They bought the grads down and put them in front of a table with diffrent hardware on it, quite a number could not tell what it was, and the real killer was telling a vidio card from a sound card. They didnt know, these guys were guns on theroy, put a computer in front of them with a hardware prob and it all turns to custard

by deadly ernest

can understand the links across sub-fields. It's already a problem. Four years ago, I had some contract work for a major IT organisation, one that sold IT services. The email system was randomly messing up emails.

The people running the Lotus Notes servers said it wasn't a problem with their servers, it had to be the gateway. The gateway people had evidence that it wasn't happening at the gateway. They started keeping copies of all emails, and when we found some that we OK at the gateway, but messed up at the recipient, well, that proved it was within the Lotus Notes network. The emails came out of the Internet into the Sendmail mail servers OK, they got handed off to the Lotus Notes mail servers OK, and got messed up later.

I got the job of trying to identify the problem. Much research and testing later, I was able to map the Lotus Notes servers, and who was behind which - something the Lotus Notes specialist experts didn't have, and hadn't been able to do. Seem they didn't know a thing about networks and routers, just Lotus Notes.

Well, all the problem areas were behind three specific Lotus Notes servers. Well, the short of is - the Lotus Notes servers were all one version, except those three - they hadn't been able to afford to upgrade them yet.

The latest version of Notes can be set to handle all mail SMTP as native default. The previous version handled all mail as UUCP native default, and could be set to detect and handle SMTP as SMTP. The network used SMTP, but sometime the older version thought it was getting UUCP emails, and messed up the headers, killing the reply to addresses.

It took me 50% of my time over three weeks to sort this out, document, and give them the answer to a problem they'd be playing with for 12 months. The Notes people said I was mad, as all the Notes servers tested OK, never mind my being able to show copies of messages from either side of the suspect servers, showing them good and corrupt. Eventually, they got in experts from Lotus, and it took them 4 weeks to read, and duplicate my work, and say the same thing - cost in the tens of thousands of dollars.

I was the only person in that state office who understood the basics of the network, the gateway, the servers, and how they interacted. I knew enough about them all to look at the issue holistically, all the rest are specialists in sub areas and have no idea on what happens when the data leaves their servers, or sub area. I had an argument with one senior tech because he couldn't understand why he couldn't assign the same IP address to both the main server, and its back up - that would have made his documentation easier.

No one is taught the general basics any more.

by deadly ernest

international IT company that sells IT services to others. Headquarters had hired a new tech, ad uni graduate with a Bachelor of Science, I had to take him around the place for 6 months and teach him what the various items of hardware were, how they worked, and how you powered up a server, after a crash. The poor guy was amazed that he was expected to work on hardware as a computer tech. Seems he thought he was being hired as a computer systems designer - the ad he answered was for a network engineer. HQ HR thought a uni grad with BaSC Comp could do the job, he didn't even know the difference between Ethernet and Fibre Optic or what a router was.

I never did find out what they did with him, he was totally useless for the job he was hired to do.

Mind you this same company also appointed a senior network engineer as the manager of the high security gateway team, when they merged two sections. The guy didn't even know what AV meant, or why you had to harden a gateway server. He thought the microwave sensors would deal with all cases of Intruder Detection. The troubles they had when ever he decided to check what the gateway people were doing - he was totally lost, but would never admit it - cost the company many thousands of bucks, all passed on to the clients in the end.

by dr_zinj

I was looking for a job like that a few years ago. And I actually do have a clue!

LOL.

by deadly ernest

the job was in a high security area in Australia, one prerequisite being Australian Citizenship. Pity, that HR didn't consider the ability to do the work as being important as having a uni degree.

by carlk2

The GateSatan of Mordorsoft has erected an electrified barbed wire fence around the computer. Mac too. A ChemE I knew chose an Apple II over a Mac in 1983 because he could get at the CPU and I/O chips. He learned more!

Now you "Develop" softwhere by praying to the OS Shamens' proprietary patented API, not the computer.

Open the hardware and the law, open newbies to programming!

by tony hopkinson

When I started learning programming, it was after seeing duck shoot on a ten digit eight segment LED display. I found it fascinating.
What are the lead in starter projects now ?

All we can do is giver everybody at school a real chance to write some code. The actual exercise itself should be about as unsexy as it's possible to be.

The one who like programming may take it up, the ones who think it would be cool to write the next wow on the video games market, will bog off and do something they are more suited to.

by apotheon

That sounds pretty accurate.

I think what CarlK2 was talking about is more of a problem for people once they're already hooked by a fascination for programming -- not for hooking people in the first place.

by tburgak

What you predict as happening as already happened with regard to customer service jobs. For example, I have AT&T long distance which is paid through my local carrier but I do not get an itemized bill. I called AT&T twice to try and get an itemized bill but I instead got some moron in India or Pakistan that tried to tell me what I am paying for my other phone services (and they were wrong each time) and tried over and over again to sell me addtional AT&T services. I have just about had it; good bye AT&T. The same goes for all you other POS (piece of sh_t) American companies that did not even give Americans a chance to do the job at a reasonable price. I hope you all lose your business asses...I'm going to do my part!

by dr_zinj

There are 3 types of college students.

Anyone can get a degree if they show up for the classes on time and hand in some homework and projects once in a while. They don't actually need to learn anything except how to play the college system. Usually they can talk a good story, but that's the only skill they have. Unfortunately, way too many of them go on to become business managers and end up directing the people who really know what they're doing.

The second type goes to college, does the classes and homework honestly, but doesn't do much more than that. They can tell you why you do something, but not necessarily how to get there. They become productive workers, but take a considerable amount of additional training. They usually have all the certs and little of the experience.

The third type, the ones that we'd all like to hire, are the ones that do the classes and homework, and then roll up their sleeves and dive into the systems; tear into the hardware, decompile the software, make a bazillion mistakes along the way, but emerge with an indepth understanding of why and how things work. Usually lots of experience, but are often weak on certs because that's not what their primary purpose was.

This categorization could also apply to those IT people who don't have degrees.

You have the ones who talk well, and know how to turn on a computer and bill themselves as IT experts.

Then you have rank and file folks who actually know how to work applications, and actually know how to do "User Maintenance", as originally defined. They can do remove and replace work fairly well, run cabling, but not necessarily tell you why things work the way they do. Usually quite a few certs.

And of course you have some self-taught experts with no degrees and some to many certs who also know how to roll up their sleeves and dig into things. They may have made a huge number of mistakes starting out, but don't make many any more. They know how to set things up, but may have interesting blind spots due to a lack of formal training.

by apotheon

I'd be the last one in that list. I've actually gone to school for computer science, but changed majors because I loathe geometric mathematics (trig and calculus), and frankly geometric mathematics is useless to someone that wants to work in IT -- give me linear algebra any day. Keep the calculus where the sun don't shine, 'cause I don't want to see it.

Sure, I have a few "blind spots", but as someone who loves to learn I've learned to keep an eye out for them, and to learn what I need to correct the problem whenever something like that comes up. More importantly for purposes of this discussion, though, is the state of being for people with formal degrees.

Everybody has blind spots, not "even college graduates" but, more accurately, [b]especially[/b] college graduates. You see, college graduates think they know what they're doing because they've been taught by professionals the "right" answers, and they tend to be entirely unaware they have blind spots -- which is the biggest blind spot of all. Look around you. How many college-educated IT professionals know the first thing about setting up a heterogeneous Windows and Linux network?

If they figure out how to get it done at all, their answer will typically be to hire me.

by tony hopkinson

True competence is measured by an accurate appraisal of when you aren't :D

Course if you turn out to be too expensive, I'll just have to roll my sleeves up again.

Besides how can you learn anything, if you don't know you need to learn it, that is indeed the regular blind spot of those straight out of academia.

A bit of experience and you realise, that you still have a lot to learn, loads in my case.

Fun isn't it.

by crabbyabby86

There are really two distinctions--people who go to university to learn what to think (your first two categories), and people who go to university to learn how to think (your last).

The whole idea of university is to train people how to think. And in a computer science department the primary element is one of pure logical problem-solving.

The person who can be told what to think (which includes being taught to manipulate the system to suit their level of laziness) are the 'rank and file' sort, to use your phrase, but the one who knows how to think will forever be able to learn new skills and solve real problems on their most core levels.

I can't really say I'm disgusted with a computer science graduate who doesn't know the difference between a switch and a router. I'm not even that surprised. They probably made it through the system by learning what to think and left it at that. I know plenty of people who are currently doing it that way.

But it also doesn't take a degree to learn that particular tidbit--It takes about one minute of really good explanation. It doesn't even have to be that good an explanation if the person learning it understands how to think.

It's a unfortunate that the very thing university is for, learning how to think instead of what to think, is exactly what gets lost in the highly bureaucratic nature of the university system. We more or less have to learn it on our own. But just knowing how often gives us the skill and passion to become valuable computer scientists, in whatever area of IT we actually land.

by metilley9

This is the dumbest thing I have heard in a long time. No one needs to be "tricked" into programming. Not everyone has the aptitude to be a programmer. There is enough talent to fulfill every programming position in the United States if companies would do just one thing: EDUCATE! I am so tired of seeing more of these idiots coming into this country from India, Pakistan, and elsewhere that don't know the language, don't know a thing about American business (or ethics), don't know how to drive, and a lot of other things. If employers would just TRAIN their current employees and/or people interested in working for them! I don't understand why they can't see this.

Of course, I am also seeing the programming field evolving into a non-field. Many employers that want, say a chemical engineer, "assume" those persons already have programming skills when they are hired. Ditto for other positions such as architecture, medicine, chemistry, biology, etc.

As an APL programmer developer, I find this requirement dwindling rapidly. When I do see APL as a skill, something else is bundled as a mandatory skill as well, such as actuarial licenses. I don't want to get an actuarial license, I want to code in APL! I don't need an actuarial license to code in any field. Sure, it may help, but I don't need it! I wrote refinery simulators (in APL) for a very large oil company and I don't have a chemical engineering degree. It pisses me off when I think of how many thousands of dollars I spent putting myself through college just so I can sit idle reading the job wanted ad's.

I can learn and do other kinds of programming languages if given the chance and the education. Employers need to recognize this. There are a LOT of us out there and you don't need to bring in unskilled labor from other countries to achieve your goal(s). Face it, by the time you spend the time to bring in these people and train them to speak English, you will have also taught them the programming skills (because many purport themselves to already know the computer skills, but really don't have them). I have worked in places like this in the past. The consulting companies bring them in, furnish them with cars, teach them to drive, teach them the necessary skills to accomplish their job assignment, furnish them with corporate apartments, teach them the English language, etc. Do they still work at a lower salary then Americans do? I don't think so!

Think about it. Training new American applicants and current employees is a bargain. Just give it some thought. There are plenty of us out there ready to work for you and give you our very best!

by km8295

I am constantly amazed at the "business is evil" crowd. Businesses sell a product or service, and they get money from the customers. If they don't have people working for them that do the work that makes the money, they can't very well increase salaries, now can they? OK, it can be abused, but how do you really know that it is? You are assuming that they have all this money so they can afford to let their workers do whatever type they want to do, increase the salaries and benefits, and pay for it all by having a very few people at the top cut their fat salaries to compensate. Well, take a look at the airlines and the auto industry to see what that sort of give-the-worker-what-they-demand mentality gets you in the long run. Go back to business school, then make an educated assessment of the situation. This is just plain ignorant.....

by tony hopkinson

just stupid sometimes. You can't trick anyone into being a good programmer any more than you can into being a good businessman.

You can trick them into a career they won't enjoy and be crap at though, is this clever?

by jkameleon

> Go back to business school, . . .

Forget about programming, IT, and that stuff, and go to business school.

Techies are at the mercy of the economy, while MBA's make the economy. Techie will always be employed by an MBA, and never the other way round.

by iago9999

I'm on the tail end of completing my A.S. degree in Computer Programming and I'm having a tough time finding an entry-level programmer/developer postition.

I don't need to be "tricked"...just need to get my foot in the door to an actual paid programming position.

Thus, the pursuit continues......

by tig2

I see a great many postings come out (I'm in your area of the world) seeking all manner of certification or broad knowledge in a variety of areas that are only peripherally related to the actual work to be done. This is disheartening for those of us who are qualified to do the work- and potentially more besides- but the "resume" experience doesn't specify all those points.

I started life in Network and got pulled into Project Management. I want to go back to a hands on environment- I personally think I am better suited to tracking and fixing problems. I am also well suited (those 10 years in PM) to documenting the solutions in order to expand the general knowledge. But regardless of what I have done in my career holistically, I am not considered for hands on roles. My resume doesn't reflect the work I have done outside the public sector and volunteer work gets edited out as "not applicable".

It is a real challenge to find any employer who values a person with multiple capabilities. Many older IT workers have exactly that. But it is exactly those multiple capabilities that can make us valuable.

I agree, my ability to read, write, and understand COBOL is not important in the world of networking. But my understanding of multiple protocols, multiple OSs, the end user environment, and documentation can be.

The breadth of the field, in my opinion, simply means that there are more things to learn and grow in.

by apotheon

Some of us really are more than merely competent in a wide range of skill areas. The problem is that HR personnel are looking for resume bullet points, rather than what will actually give them an all-around expert: someone with enthusiasm who learns new things because (s)he enjoys the process of learning. Those of us who really love working with computers often have "core competencies" that include application programming, web development, system administration, network architecture, hardware maintenance, and two or three other areas as well.

by peacjen

You hit another point right on the nail! Trust me after 4 years of college and being up to my ears in debt... I was floored when I couldn't land a job because I had no certifications.

Personally, my university drilled programming into my head. They didn't have anything dealing with OS or even basic hardware courses. Even though I took the time to learn myself, most companies wanted certifications.

I think I would go back for my Master's if more universities had a more comprehensive and real world degree program. If I can get my Master's & all my certifications to boot, I would be happy.

by jevans4949

When I started my programming career in the banking sector UK in the 1970's, the only people who had computers were large corporations. Because there were no trained IT staff around, they trained employees with aptitude in-house. They expected to hold on to those people, if not for life then for a good number of years.

Come the 1980s, all the small specialist banks in London started getting AS400s. Result: national shortage of AS400 programmers, but nobody with other IT experience need apply. All these firms to eager for the quick buck to think about training or re-training people.

Same thing happened more recently with VB, but more so - must have version 6 experience.

Another problem, certainly in the UK, is that 90% of IT recruitment is done through specialist agencies. These scan the CVs (automatically) for buzzwords; the recruitment consultants run a query, and these are the CVs that reach the hiring manager. Heard of one guy who amended his CV to say "I have no knowledge of VB6" (or whatever the fashion was) and the calls came flooding in!

Anyone who goes into commercial programming now in the belief that it will be "fun" is likely to be disappointed. In my last position I spent 10% of my time programming, about 20% regression testing and the remaining 70% doing the paperwork!

Earlier this week I got a mailshot for my one-man company from a guy with a better CV than mine, looking for a job. Shortage? What shortage?

by apotheon

That's a great explanation of much of what's wrong with hiring practices in the IT industry.

by tony hopkinson

May be we should put ourselves up for H1B status, once we've picked up the ethics and the language, we'll be dollars in :D

Pimps are bloody annoying, I keep having to fend off oracle dba jobs. DBA and oracle appear on the cv, but there are about two paragraphs between them.

I'm still having fun, but no one had to trick me into the industry.

by industrial controller

Gents and ladies, we have a problem if we think employers are going to serve up IT/Programming jobs with good pay and benefits that are stable and free of annoying politics and paperwork. That is a dream. If you want a job like that, start your own company, work like a dog 24x7 for a few years, train up some good managers and create a perfect, cushy niche for yourself because you are the boss. Of course, you never wanted to be the boss, but that is the only way you can write your own ticket in this life.

by tony hopkinson

There is a shortage of programmers. Please address this issue.

PS you'll get no respect, bog all money and we'll outsource you at the first opportunity.

Not even a business blind super geek is going to fall for that one.

by jmgarvin

We want a job where the management doesn't treat us like we are wasting their money. We don't want a job that hangs H1-Bs over our heads. We want managers that have a clue as to why when we say "the sever is on fire, we need a new one," we really mean the server is on fire and we need a new one...

by apotheon

"[i]Sometimes open source is as good as closed source, most often not.[/i]"
You got that backwards.

"[i]Sometimes there is money in open source, mostly not.[/i]"
No -- sometimes people decide to make money on open source software, mostly not. It's not that the money isn't there, but that money isn't used as a weapon against end users.

by lastchip

I'm not sure where you get those assumptions from.

Open source software is driven by a passion for creating a piece of software that not only does the job effectively, but efficiently as well. There is a spirit within the community to not allow even the smallest bug to remain unchecked or security to be compromised. In other words, cost is not an issue. Peer recognition however, is valued.

Try and find that same motivation in a commercial environment, where date deadlines are paramount and costs are closely scrutinised. Yes, commercial competition dictates that a product will be usable, but in general, the passion for perfection is non-existent. "Good enough" is King! A few bugs here and there (providing they are not show stoppers) are acceptable and will probably never be fixed. The games market is perhaps the biggest perpetrator (but not exclusively) of these types of problems.

by carlk2

As I remember fishing there were 2 steps

1. Tempt with tasty bait or a colorful lure.
2. When they grab you set the hook with a tug.

Mordorsoft and proprietary over-complication PREVENTS setting the hook by preventing young programmers from tasting the sweetness of making the machine do what YOU want!

After college FORTRAN and IBM asm I learned SHARP's BASIC in a week, wrote debugged and the result was USED in 1985 for field data from I-670! Then u-processor asm. HOOKED!

by tony hopkinson

A calculator made people say cool back then.

MS's business practices are causing people to use the wrong bait, it's the doing that hooks the programmer mentality, not the end product.

My duck shoot example was from 1976, would it have got you in the class room?

by charles1nagler1

I can only reply by saying that the comments made by jkamelon are not only childish, but also very foolish. The attitude suggested would put young minds off the idea in time and would destroy the chances of having good programmers for the future. My advice is "GROW UP" and adopt a different andd honest attitude, so that the next generation of programmers might just suprise us all with their imagination and wisdom.

by tony hopkinson

if they are imagining a rewarding job in IT as programmers they aren't being very wise.

Are you saying that selling business IT programming should be sold like it was writing a game?

JK often has a bit of mutter about IT and career choices, he recommends you do something else. The state of the current market in the US, bears out this advice quite well.

Over here , still not so bad, but far from brilliant.

by apotheon

I think the advice shouldn't be to avoid IT as a career choice, but to avoid traditional corporate IT as a career choice. There are other options and, with a good head on your shoulders, they can be rewarding. Some of it's an uphill battle, but if you start out aiming for the right approach to your career, you should have a leg up on the competition. Most of them, after all, are just trying to get cubicle jobs that are likely to get offshored next week.

by jkameleon

First of all, it's not about programming profession as such, it's about a soviet style propaganda business community and academia resorts to theese days. This 1948 poster is pretty illustrative

http://eng.plakaty.ru/posters?cid=4&full=1&page=6&id=1975

Translation:

[top] BE A METAL WORKER!
[bottom] LADS ANS LASSES!
Let's help the Soviet state create a powerful manpower resource reserves.
ENROLL
[illegible]

Change "metal worker" to "IT worker", and you'll come pretty close to a typical ACM spin.

> . . . so that the next generation of programmers might just suprise us all with their imagination and wisdom.

Don't be silly. Programming skills alone will never pay your bills. They never did, even in the good old times before offshoring. It's the knowledge about so called "problem domain" that counts. If you are writing programs for business, you must be familiar with business. If you are writing programs for chemical plant, you must understand a bit of chemistry and physics as well. If you are writing hardware drivers, you must know a thing or two about computer hardware and peripherals. "Pure" programming is useless, it always was.

by jkameleon

Everyone wants it, everybody praises it, everybody sings about it, but nobody would let you gain it on his account.

This discussion is closed to new replies.