Discussion Locked

I found things on my bosses

0 helpful
273 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Laptop that turned my stomach. He had pictures, movies and other things that a company President should not even let others know he looks at. The way I found out about them was because he bought a new laptop and I had to migrate the data to it. It is a boring process, you just watch the files go by. That was when I saw alot of jpg, pic, mpg and other things going by.
A question to all if you see things you should not know about should you tell your boss?
I ask because there was things that were Illegal
to have like pictures of people and mpgs from actors. I did not dig into the files because I do like to bother other peoples info.
This could really hurt this guy and his company. I do not want that but if he steals others things and pictures what do I do?

273 replies

by sleepsalot

You say things that are illegal how illegal?? Is it things like CP or just yhings you think he should not have?? Sorry to sound negitive but the way you put it he is a thief.

Wayne

by michael549

In two instances of your message, the words, "He bought" and "His laptop" were used. Many people consider "their" laptops to be a part of their personal space whether it is used for "company" work as well. What your superior asked of you was a data transfer operation, not for you to be looking through his files - no matter what they were. Curiosity has often killed more than a cat.

Absent actual illegal documents, or pornography involving children -- and proof of such activities - the mere statement that the files appeared "offensive" to you - is not enough to gamble your job upon. While it often is the job of the network manager to be the "policeman" of the network ("the public streets") - there is a whole gray area when it comes to another's personal space - their own bought and paid-for laptops. Of course, reviewing network logs, etc - for breaches of company policy a good thing to do.

One possible solution is a program like "LapLink" or similar data-transfer programs, to teach and allow your superior to transfer his own files by himself. This becomes a "teachable moment" for you and him, and it removes you from having to be involved with information or files that you find to be offensive.

Just a thought.
Mike

by w2ktechman

Hello Michael,
I have many times 'accidentally' found non standard software and photos on the work systems where I work. This happens everywhere you go. Usually, I just try to ignore stuff, but if I do run into something that is against company policy, I will confront the person in question. BUT, Be tactful about it. DO NOT tell them what to do.
What I usually do is when I am dropping off the system, I will make a comment that there may be some things on the system that are against company policy. And, as such, you are required to bring it up. I also let them know that I transferred the files anyway, but if the system gets serviced by another technician, these types of files should not be on the system. I also give them a printout of what the company policy is. The whole time, not offending them, but casually brought up as a oh, by the way... This will take a lot of tension out of the scenario.
However, not all companies have a written policy on this matter, and many only have 1 tech. This makes it a bit harder, but it can still be done.
You can also offer to loan a cd burner to remove and store the files on their home system, but decline to transfer the files onto a cd for them, because you do not want to get involved any further.

by zlitocook

The company network. And any good computer person with any tech experince can look at anything on the network. Well it would only take time and most techs have a lot of that.

by mmcdonal

Why would a company tech be transferring files between personal laptops? It sounds like this is a company laptop. In any event, search and seizure restrictions only apply to the government, not to another citizen. And in this case, the person who "owned" the laptop gave it and the right to see all their files to this tech. So there could be NO reasonable expectation of privacy (requirement for s&s to take effect) in these files. This becomes plain view, or consent to search, etc. both exceptions to s&s protections, but again, only as to the government.
If you neighbor walks in on you doing something illegal, that is not illegal s&s, even though they may have been trespassing, so it is admissable testimony if a case is brought and the neighbor is a witness against you.
So in this case, I think the user is an ignorant user, and needs more "training moments" from this tech.

by zlitocook

Of new movies, new porn movies and other things. I keep up with the list of files that are not free and what is legal to have.

by alanchcc2000

Surely if your network policy precludes installation of software, offensive material,downloaded music/video files,then as network manager/techie one is just as responsible for policing the network and everything on it.
We have a clause that states that the Network Manager reserves the right to delete any and all files that go against company policy
Remember that it is after all the company network
When I was training I was told "view what you want but think who may be looking over your shoulder"
Having said all that its still a highly contentious area
I certainly wouldnt want to be drawn into anything as an accessory especially if it involved porn by my inaction

by shellbot

So there is no C Porn then ? Cause if there is CP, then go postal on him. Otherwise i'm inclined to say leave it alone.
I understand your problem, that the stuff if on a laptop used for work. But how many of us are guilty of similar offences ? lets get off our high horses and think about it. I'm a DBA, so I should know better than to go aganst company policy, yet here i am , online, while at work and have other things to do. I've loads of jokes in my email, some would be offensive to others. These were sent to me by people who found them funny. I find most of them funny, the ones i do not find funny, or offensive, I delete immediatly. I used to have a copied version of Tetris that i did not pay for, and i played it every day ! Unfortunatley i lost it when my pc was wiped. I have no interest in porn, but if someone does, that is thier thing, its not up to anyone else to say otherwise. Have you never copied a cassette (remember those), or burned a cd for a friend or borrowed a book instead of buying it yourself? Have you ever exceeded your licenced number of users for software ?The list goes on. I'm in no way condoning theft, but unless you have actually seen this guy commit a crime and you have video footage (which if you did would probably be illegal anyways) to prove it, get on with your life. There are bigger things to worry about. Take the sun for instance, did you know that in a few billion years its going to swell and swallow the earth. This worries me. Or what if goldfish mutated and grew to the size of whales overnight...big probs there my friend..!

by dantezcomedy

If you say you are no longer with the company then what are you still hanging onto their stuff for. Also you have never come out and said that it was a company computer or his own personal. Big difference here.

As far as you doing the transfer for him. That was up to you. He asked you in good faith to do it for him and here is were we are. As with the other guys have said. If it is kiddie porn or other illegal things of that nature by all means you are required to report it, but if it is just some mp3s and a couple of movies he as an adult are legally able to own, then hey it is a moral call.

As far as you having backups, kinda scary, and legally you are now illegally holding what might be proprietary company info. You turn him in for what might be 6 or 7 movies, he might own at his house, and he turns around and sues you.

Your call.

by tony hopkinson

company pcs.
Sounds like a P2Per, say you don't work for the RIAA do you ?
Is it his pc or a company one.
Is he contravening company policy.
Are the files illegal or offensive at least in terms of file names. If they are illegal is it simply IP related.
Do you want to sue him for offending you.

If it's his company and therefore his pc and he has n't got potential pedo porn on his pc, if you you don't want to try the offensive law suit, then it's keep your mouth shut time. Until you've at least found another job. Unless you can get enough to go for contructive dismisaal when he hounds you out for knowing about him.
Big 'ol question number one , have you got any evidence other than your say so.

by zlitocook

But this it a company PC as much as his new car is a company car. The files are not offensive to me but to the company I worked for! I have not looked into the compleat back up. And I have left the conpany as of this week. I may send the back up CD to the FEDS.

by davesims2

OK, you left the company why do you care now? What if these movies you are talking about are copies of movies he owns? What if indeed... Unless you are part of the corporate security team it is not your job.

Unless you find absolute and explicit evidence of real honest to god impropriaty you leave it alone. Further, what are you doing with your former company's intelectual property? Those back ups you want to send to the feds aren't really yours are they?

by just some guy

Some porn and some new movies - sorry, but this is no big deal. If this was your brother's laptop, would you be sending a copy to the fed's? I'm just guessing here but as you recently left the company, it sounds like there's some bad blood between the parties. Going any further with this will hurt you as much as the old boss......

by senior program analyst

If you kept a copy and didnt report it, Um what makes you any different than him? Also as some note you have left the company and you still have data belonging to the company? What about Equipment still have some of that as well?

If you have kept these without reporting it at the time and you now send it to the authorities - what makes you think they wont investigate you?

by senior program analyst

You are no longer with the company, but you kept the copies? What makes you think the authorities wouldnt investigate you if you sent these now and not at the time. (Not a good idea) if you thought you might report it SOON then you wouldnt keep copies just report it so the stuff would be found on that equipment (and not yours). If you wait after finding this to report it you are only stringing yourself up for MAJOR issues, besides you have given him time to possibly not have anything found (if he had any idea that you might report something).

Also as mentioned by others; You have kept stuff owned by the company that you no longer work with and to boot you still have THESE files? Even if it was backup tapes/or CD and they had one proprietary piece of data from the company on them then you have stollen this - it belongs to the company and you are now as guilty as your now ex-boss.

by neildsouza

Just remember that whatever gets into the office network is ultimately your responsibility...

I would suggest content filtering software or firewall based solutions to eliminate the risk of potentially damaging downloads.

Porn might be a problem but certainly video and/or pirated software could be eliminated.

For portable computers, there are logging software that help. But if it is his laptop then it might be a problem.

Nevertheless, always keep a watch on what is going on onyour network. Print out partial logs and file them at home. It's better to know firsthand than to find out later!!

by stress junkie

If you work for a large corporation and your boss is a lower level manager then the corporate management would probably want to know about it. If you work for a 5 person company and your boss is the company owner then it's not so clear what the reaction would be. If you work for a large business then ask your Human Resources department manager about the issue from a hypothetical standpoint. If you work for a small business then ask the General Manager about it from a hypothetical standpoint. Very often the real answer will be encoded. For instance you might be told that the business would not tolerate that sort of thing but they can't imagine anyone doing that sort of thing. That could be a coded message to keep your mouth shut.

If the offender is the General Manager then your first responsibility to maintain confidentiality of what you see in the course of doing your job.

I completely disagree with the post from desertlife. You are not responsible for everything that is transmitted over the corporate network.

by oz_media

It may have been downloaded at home and not actually transmitted over the company neywork though.

if he OWNS his laptop, then he it is his business what he stores on the hard drive, as long as it isn't downloaded on the company network.

Then again, I have been to a company with strict P2P policies on the network, but the bosses ALL used Kazaa and Fileshare to swap porn and email it to each other. Kinda hard to fire the manager when others are in on it, their job is FAR more important to the company than yours from a revenue standpoint.

by jck

last job I worked at, I talked to some of the IT network admins.

They said they monitor stuff that comes over the network, except for PCs at Director level and above, and that those IPs are static and never checked. Hence, a low-level guy can click a link and it brings up a porn ad he can get fired for, but his Director can go watch live feed sex stuff from Amsterdam without repercussion.

Amazing...I guess when you belong to the Executive Boys' Club...like American Express...membership has its privileges.

by louk

If what you found was all to do with consenting adults I'd probably forget about it, after all what grown-up's do in their own time is their business. If this is the case I'd also lock down the network so no nasties that lurk on those sites could hurt the network if he attaches his laptop to it. But if any of thoses images or movies were of children I would not hesitate to turn him in to the authorities which I'm sure could be done anonomously so you don't implicate yourself.

by lmayeda

It is possible that the stuff you see may be the result of a download virus/worm and your boss is clueless about it. I found porn on a user's PC and debated my course of action with HR. Upon closer inspection, I determined that the downloaded files occurred while he was not on the PC ... how do I know? Because I was on it at the time. Not sure how to determine if your bosses' download was intentional or not but you should consider this possibility. You could even give him and "out" by mentioning the existence of such a virus ... (you could scan first to verify) and ask for permission to clean.

by oz_media

Other than child porn (which should be reported to police) you would be amazed at some o fthe stuff SOME bosses have in their drives.

I've seen a VERY snooty and uptight employerwith scat and watersports pix & mpegs too. Well to each his own, it's HIS equipment, HIS company and HIS fetish.

If I saw my neighbours 11 year old daughter,well things woul dbe different, the police owuld be informed AFTER I had faced him with it.

AS for people having 'disgusting or questionable' stuff, who cares, the internet is a wierd place sometimes, it's no different than searching their bedroom and not liking the magazines in the closet.

Celeb pix and mpegs? So what, they aer all over the net. It's not illegale per se, even if tasteless to you.

Child porn's a NO NO, anything else, whatever.

by synthetic

Child Porn, something hurting minors, or depicting illegal activity (rape, murder), these are issues you should act on, otherwise, you are not just morally responsible, your legal responsible for facilitation. Anything else, well honestly, do you want other judging you by your passions and likes? I would also wonder how well things will go over with future employees, if your know for jumping the gun on legal, yet tasteless personal objects on the bosses system. I would delicately let him/her know that anything on the system, being on a public, or private network, can be made public, and that nothing should be kept on a system that he/she doesn't want the buying public, board, manged employees, or spouse, to know about. I also find that it doesn't hurt to stated your uncomfortable with the content, and ask that this type of material be removed before he/she next ask you to work on their system. Just having this data for display to you could constitute harassment.

by jck

if there is something illegal such as child pornography, you should take the information to the local police. Otherwise if you were to be known to have knowledge of it and did not turn him in, you can be charged as an accessory.

If it's just dirty pictures and movies...and he's the company president...and you turn him into HR:

1) his buddies on the Board aren't gonna give a crap...he'll get "reprimanded" (told he's a bad boy, hands slapped, etc...nothing major)

2) there will become some reason to let you go because he'll have the power and won't like you for exposing him as some pervert to other employees.

3) If you have no morals and want to make some money and you know he and his wife project a very religious image...blackmail him and threaten to disburse the hard drive image to his entire church. Image is often more important than honesty to shallow, wealthy folks.

Otherwise if it's *not* illegal but just immoral...forget about it...you'll end up suffering more in the end.

by oz_media

Allhe has to do is deny it, fire the employee that created such horrendous images APPARENTLY from his laptop and he's good as gold.

YOu will also be facing lawsuits left right and center.
I am gettng tired of admins thinking they are corporate police, your jobs not worth the paper the check is written on when it comes to revenue generation, most o fthese companies survived years without IT and grudgingly accept it as a way of life now. Your job is not worth a dime to most managers, you are disposable and replaceable by THOUSANDS of others.

Just be thankful you are employed at all and get on with your job, which in this case is transferring data.

AGAIN: unless we are talking child pornography, and even then only if MULTIPLE images etc are oin the drive. Anyone can download what they THINK is Paris Hilton's video and get duped into downloading the wrong images, films unknowingly.

Thin ice for the admin, just do your job. It most likely doesn't include monitoring management's notebooks, they are more concerned about JOE the sales rep wasting time and bandwidth than managers in most cases. Company policies usually don't really cover ALL areas, just those which are disposable, such as yourself.

The owner will see his manager, responsible for 8 million in revenue, and an whiny admin, worth a nickle to him. Who loses the job?

And if you don't lose it directly over this, they will just find a reason to let you go in the future.

A lot of Admins should get off their high horse and realize they are just disposable company nobody's, not the company gods they think they are.

by jck

an employee can replicate stored private memos and emails that no one else has seen outside his secretary, a board of directors, etc?

30 minutes extra with Norton Ghost and I could have enough on someone to own them if it exists together on a hard drive.

And if he has kiddie porn on there, I would have the FBI in the offices first thing next morning makin sure he'd be getting some sweet lovin from a big burly guy in prison by the end of the year.

Execs might sit up high (like the vultures they are), but there are silver bullets that will knock them off their perch :)

by jamesrl

None of the places I have worked have allowed anything different for senior management.

Never worked at a place where one click can get you fired. At the places where there has been monitoring, you have to have repeated transgressions, after you have had your first warning. If you get a warning, and you chose to ignore it, then maybe you have a bigger problem.

James

by oz_media

Employment Standards Canada = infraction notices.

People are scared to fire employees here without some EXTREME reason behind it, a single click just isn't going to sit well as a reason for dismissal.

We have the government on OUR side, in the US the government is usually on the employers side.

by tony hopkinson

If it's child porn you can nail him to the wall figuratively or literally.
If it's not illegal but simply not to your taste, then you can go for being offended by a filename, good luck with that one with no evidence. Or you can simply ignore it.
If you haven't got the clout to get the guy removed, it never happened, after all why would sit there watching the names of files being transferred ?
In terms of porn on corporate networks, managers 'above the law tend' to be the absolute worst offenders, I'm a pretty broad minded chap, but I've seen stuff that gave me nightmares on upper management pcs and in the old days that was in exes with 8.3 names.

by oz_media

An exec is alowed such leaniency becaus eof his VALUE to the company, his ability to drive revenue or manage teams.

Team members are lining up at the door, and pretty much anyone is immedatly disposable.

When a 80K a year IT employee makes waves, th eboss sees him as an 80K annual expense. Not a person who brings revenue in, even on an ecommerce site.

When a 200K employee is surfing porn, the value of their revenue stream usually supersedes their value by far, so the boss says keep him and ditch the idiot who's costing me 80K a year instead.

by derek

Unless it's child prn or something you are certain is absolutely illegal then leave it alone. You arent the HR police, you're a techie. You'll make no friends and it will cost you . . people look on techs as snoops already who brag about being able to access email and files, this would jst prove the point. It's like someone going thru your bedroom and reading all your jazz mags

by oz_media

And there I was thinking you were gonna say jizz mags.

Oh well, you have a solid point.

by jck

even tho executives really generate no revenue stream. They are figureheads that make lots of money off of others' ideas and hard work.

Yakov...you're alone

by sleepsalot

It seem that this post has generated a lot of feedback but zlito has yet to come back and give any more info. I don't want exact details but as my first post said. Is the guy a real thief or just like most people that surf the net?? And getting pics that are public domain??

Wayne

by jkaras

I know zlito has been apart of this site for some time, however I think this is a hypothetical scenario that is a great topic that has been discussed a couple of times on this site. I mean no disrespect to him, just feel this is too vague and open to interpretation. This topic is a hot button issue in our field and knowing what can happen while attempting to do the right thing can arm us with the proper etiquette saving our butts when this situation rears it's ugly head.

The way I see it is that if the person or boss owns this laptop it is their property and it doesnt effect the network, none of your business. Dont transfer the bad files and when he asks, if he (pres)has the nads to discuss this with him that you transferred the only files that you could do legally. The files or illegal software are still there for him to do whatever he needs or wants with it.

If he gets caught viewing or showing this material, then he will face the music in shame. There would be no trace of your involvment of facilitating the material, case closed. Its not our job to play the moral police, no more than a pharmacist denying a woman birth control products because it is against his/her religion, tend to your own garden.

How exactly do you explain you were snooping into his files as they cascaded by in the transfer? Did you investigate to verify their content? However if you saw a file named hot underage philly (you get the picture, no pun intended)then visit HR with the laptop and request a police officer to be present, then disply the file. If this ruins his career, good, if it ruins yours well then I say you got a great lawsuit, because I dare to find any company that would take any backlash of hiding kiddie porn for any form of mamagement. Nobody will think less of you.

by timmedsker

His Company? Who are you going to tell? If he owns it and writes the paychecks, what are you going to accomplish by "telling your boss"?
I suggest you find a new job...or, breathe an ounce of this out to coworkers and then collect unemployment after he fires you....at the least!
I am not sure where you are on the "food-chain" at this Company but, I suggest you understand the consequences of such exposure.

by dc_guy

Unless he is a total moron he knew quite well that you would very likely see that stuff. He probably wants to know how much you can be trusted. He probably has other tasks in mind for you that require discretion and loyalty.

If you don't want those tasks but you'd like to continue working for the company, follow the very excellent advice in posting #2. Be non-confrontational, and show him that you have both discretion and loyalty, but that you're not interested in handling material of this sort.

If you take him on you may or may not get him fired, but you will ultimately lose. People in power don't go down quietly. If I'm right and this is a test, then he's got himself covered and if you try to out him you'll be in for some sort of surprise that he's got cooked up for you.

Never assume that people in power are stupid. Of course sometimes they are, but 99 times out of 100, making that assumption will destroy you.

by zlitocook

Computer stupid. He asked me to set him up to the new computer network, and I asked him what type connection he needed? A DNS connection or a VPN and he said what ever he needeed.

by dc_guy

If I hand you my laptop and give you enough passwords to do what this man asked, I know frelling well that you can browse my hard drive. Just because people don't happen to have the interest or the aptitude to be computer geeks doesn't make them stupid.

This guy is either trusting you or testing you, or both. If you think you're so much smarter that you can take him down, you're making a big mistake. You could be right but the odds are way against you.

by jck

the responsibility of management to know technical details of all the operations under their influence.

In the good old days, you had guys that worked their way up. But now, your IT boss is as likely to be an Accounting grad as they are a CIS or IT or CS grad.

Face it...90% of IT bosses are going to be hands-off and technically ignorant of their operation. Business expects them to get things done by managing people, not systems.

I'm lucky. My boss knows his stuff pretty much. I can talk tech to him, and if he doesn't understand he isn't afraid to ask. Communication is a good thing.

So, don't down your boss for not knowing what you do every minute. Remember: he could know and be micromanaging your butt like a school master.

by willcomp

One sees all sorts of things when working on personal and small business PCs. Everything from pornography to financial information.

My philosophy is to look at as little as posiible and then forget that which was necessary to view. I would suggest you take the same approach, i.e. forget what you saw.

Dalton

by br-549

You did not say if it was a public company, but, even if it is, the board is unlikely to do anything and you will forever be remembered.

by etruss

Many years ago there were discussions about computer people who have access to other peoples' data needing some kind of code of conduct like other professions - kind of an IT to user confidentiality agreement. I think this has pretty much been forgotten or no one in this discussion has heard of it. We've even had people suggest that the boss be blackmailed for having this stuff. The original poster has apparently not been offended enough to not keep a copy of the "illegal" files for himself. If someone found out about him owning these files, how is he going to prove where he got them? If it were me, I certainly wouldn't have kept a copy - actually, I never would have even noticed in the first place what the boss had on his computer. My advice is: throw away the backup, forgot it ever happened and move on.

by jmgarvin

Since you didn't look at the mpgs, jpgs, or whatever how do you know they were illegal? How do you know he didn't have legal mpgs?

You do know that some movies and most pictures of famous folks are public domain and freely available?

Sure ripping a DVD and putting it in mpg format may be technically illegal, but if he owns the dvd and just ripped it to watch on a business trip, is he really pirating? Plus, laptops have limited storage space, so he couldn't have had that much!!!

by av .

I have always been very uncomfortable with dealing with people's private info. Unfortunately, its become part of today's IT job at times.

I think you should ask him about all of the pictures, even indirectly, and see what he has to say. Then you can decide what to do about it.

You can always say that you wanted to make sure that all of his data is intact. But, he will know that you know about his private files.

I always try to emphasize to people like that, that keeping your private life private is the best solution for all.

Unless the person is a real threat, why should you have to be the one to judge?

by bigaldepr

The only problem with the comment about privacy is almost all company policies state that the network is for the sole use of the company and by using the network you agree to be subject to survelience as deemed neccessary by the company. SOx act demands public companies adopt such a policy and train the employees in appropriate use and security policy.

Unfortunately techies are not well equipped to deal with these matters. They are not trained in dealing with such matters. Companies do not give clear direction on the appropriate action when such material is found.

Clearly criminal activity such as child porn should be reported to authorities.

by bhunsinger

I'm not ready to assume that a person is a thief like that. wheere these files in the temp folder? by new to you mean dvd new or theater new.
Finally, it is none of your business. Yes, if he did not have his files configured for privacy and someone on the network had his password, they could hack into his computer to see these. Hack being the word.
personally, the only time I look at pictures is when I check IE temp files on a machine suspected of spyware/adaware- Porno pops up, case closed, out comes the file scrubbers. I make some assumptions, granted, but I know that those shots can come from popups as well.

by jdclyde

Do you think this would make you some kind of hero because you got someone fired? What is your opinion of people that get other people fired? A freaken rat, that is what they are and NO ONE will want anything to do with a known FREAKEN RAT. After all, they don't want to be your next target.

Let it go or update your resume. Push it and you are through.

by sulls

I can see no reason for you to be rude in this discussion as it is a reasonable question. A few years ago I discovered information on a compnay pc used by the Procurement Director. I kept quiet thinking it not my place and when it came out, I was questioned and given a verbal warning for not reporting it further. I am now an outsourced consultant and make sure that when I get a new client, we agree on the action to take if I find files/data which should not be on the pc. This affects even the MD. We are always hit hardest and should always cover ourselves. Perhaps one way to proceed would be to put a process in place for further discoveries.

by jereg

I worked for a state agency that hired a new woman as Assistant Director. She had a problem with her new laptop. I went through it and put it back in order and was just about to close it down and decided to check the contents of the root drive.

Well, I saw some .jpg files and I mentioned the name out loud. The guy next to me then wants to see them. When we look, these are indeed, dirty pictures, and a big no-no in a state government agency. I really didn't know what to do. Since we had an IT Security Officer, I told him about it, pointed them out, and left it at that. My job had been done to the letter, and it was out of my hands. He told me to delete the files.

As I found out later, he went to the IT Director, who went to this woman. It turns out, her son had "borrowed" the laptop to surf the internet late one Saturday night. He turned out to be the guilty party.

I don't think I'd want to get that lecture from mom.

by projectworker

I have to agree with the above. Not too long ago I cleared off a lot of spyware and browser hijackers off a colleague's laptop. To her embarrassment it kept on going to porn sites. She has three teenage sons who must have been doing "research" on her laptop.

Did I report her for porn? - of course not. Nothing illegal was happening - just some boys who thought that no one would notice if they surfed the net on Mom's computer. She just learned that she can't leave her laptop unmonitored at home.

by hockeyist

...a lot of illegal and embarassing moments being captured for all the office to see, especially hurtful to the company if they fall into the wrong hands.

by a.techno.geek

You seem to be awfully bent on doing something to this manager, are you? You mention in this discussion that you now have a new job. I like the others here, unless it is Child Porn, there isn't much you can do. And what are the Feds going to do to the CD that you are thinking of sending or have sent? If it is just straight homosexual or heterosexual not involving child participation there is not much you can do. Offensive yes, maybe, illegal NO! Was there tax information on the CD, bookkeeping info? In all honesty you kind of sound like the type "I've got the goods now I am going to use it!" When that didn't happen you just moved on to someplace else. What are you some kind of "I am just witnessing for the lord" information filtering types. Actually, I have found a book filled with incest, debauchery and you know where I find it? In the BIBLE! Lot, King Solomon, Genesis, Cain and Able, where did their wives come from? So if they had some verses from the bible on the PC, hell lets just hang them NOW! You are so bent on being righteous, bet given time dirty could be found you too!

by nano_watt

Seems like everybody given you the advise. The choice is yours. Whichever way you decide you will have to live with your concience and have a good night sleep.

by chughlett

If your boss has some questionable items on his computer, maybe it is good reason for an increase in your security budget. Perhaps some naughty "hacker" broke into your boss' computer and left terrible little surprises behind. Of course, if you have put in a security solution that claims to prevent break-ins, then maybe you shouldn't give your boss an excuse to point the finger at you. If your boss admits he put the files there, then maybe it's still embarrassing but at least it's out in the open, at least between you and your boss, and you have a dirty little secret that might work to your advantage in terms of the boss' appreciation of how discreet and unassuming you were. This may be a case where you don't migrate THAT data, and if the boss asks you just say it looked like temp files or whatever so you didn't copy it over.

Then again, you could always copy the files and not say anything, or put them into a new directory called "UNKNOWN" and make a note that you suspect some spyware may have put the files on his original computer but you weren't sure so you just dumped them there.

by ss

I think you should take the issue to HR or your bosses bos but I'm afraid that you will most probably be eliminated.

by chughlett

No matter what, the files present a risk to you. Do you prefer the risk of being fired for copying or for not copying? Don't ask, don't tell? If it is definitely illegal material, then you have to decide which interpretation of the law you want to take. On one hand, you are acting as an employee of the company, following the orders of your supervisor so you are doing your job. On the other hand, you may be duplicating illegal material which is illegal and if the boss feels threatened may exact revenge on you.

Then again, you could take the position that your boss knew what was on his computer and sexually harrassed you by causing you to be exposed to the illicit material. Maybe sue for lots of money. Maybe go to a shrink and tell them how distraught you are over the whole ordeal. This would prepare a credible witness in your favor if a legal issue came up, and would effectively absolve you of the idea of malicious intent.

by mattbakeruk

Take a snapshot of the data before you ask anyone for advice. Remember if the company can get away with it they will so you might need evidence if it goes sour.
don't tell any of your colleagues but ask the hypothetic question. If nothing is done then you've got ammo for the future in case something or someone goes against you.

by chughlett

Maybe you could tell your boss you scanned his data files and a bunch of media files were suspected of having viruses which could not be cleaned out, so you didn't want to copy them over and you didn't want to open them because it might trigger the virus. Have him confirm any files turned up in the "virus scan" so he has to explicitly tell you he wants those files copied.

by tech supporter

Escalate the issue via another route. The antivirus line is always good as it alerts the user if thier at all concerned and suggests there will be further work required by IT. If he's concerned he'll remove the files.

I've read the other responses with interest and also agree that it would come down to a slap on the wrist for the boss whilst you would undoubtadly suffer more in the long run. Unfortunately the old boys club is alive in all sizable organisations.

by sue's comment

My response to a very similar problem was
1. Don't assume the boss is responsible for putting the stuff there - in my case he wasn't.
2. If you can, share the information with a peer (another technician) and check times and dates on downloads and other files. Then the pair of you should approach someone higher up but keep names out of it. This relieves you of responsibility. As I said your boss could be innocent so don't name names.
3. Decide on a strategy with the manager. Our solution was to delete the stuff and put a sticker on the PC to informing that the PC had been cleaned with a date. This wouldn't alarm an innocent party. If not innocent, then it is very unlikely he would do it again!
4. So how did we know the boss wasn't guilty?
We first found out when the stuff was downloaded and then ascertained where the laptop was that weekend. In my case a technician had taken the laptop home to add software and his flatmate had done the browsing between 1 and 3 am in the morning. His flatmate didn't own up until we said we had a credit card number ... we didn't, we just knew one had been used. Then he asked us how to clean up his PC at work!

Dates are great for ascertaining whether the stuff was downloaded over a period of time or all at once and what else was going on with the laptop at the time - but before you go down this route you may want to make sure that you really want to know the answer.

by lord-of-the-token-rings

When it comes to Illegal stuff and porn on our network, I am the Rottweiler from Hell. BUT... If the Laptop is your Bosses personal property, just do what your BOSS asked you to do, and SHUT up. You may have the right to make corporate policy, and to enforce it, but remember, it Ends where Corporate ends and Personal Begins. If you have a problem with porn, and illegal stuff, just b upfront about it and say that "your religion forbids you to touch laptops with questionable content on it" and then give the guy a laplink cable and show him how to do the transfer himself. Windows XP has a reasonable settings transfer mechanism built right into the OS, perfect for people such as these. Remember, the toe that you step on today, is attached to the foot that will kick you @ss tomorrow. As a Network Tech, You will have access to a lot of priviledged information. I have been in rooms, doing my thing, while board decissions were being taken, that affected other peoples lives. I may not like what's going on, but that does not give me the right to analyze it. Stick to you JOB, and just do what you are supposed to do!!! BTW. you don't have to have the laptops connected to the Network to do file transfers. so that takes "protecting the Corporate Network" out of the picture. if you don't have the cable, get him to buy his own. it's inexpensive, and it will be his own.

by webmaster

Policy: is it his own? If so, why was he "mis-using" corporate resource rather than paying an independent contractor. If not, what's company policy?

I would merely have migrated the data, without being curious as to what was in the files - there's no requirement to investigate when migrating data.

However, since you have snooped, is what he has illegal in your state. And does your legal code require that you report criminal activity to the law, as here in the UK?

It is possible that he has teenagers who have downloaded material (as mine have!!!) and doesn't have a clue that the stuff is there!

Suggesting a virus and deleting what YOU think is inappropriate is a solution, but highly judgmental.

Perhaps you might subtly let him know you don't want to be asked to repeat the exercise.

He sounds unreliable - I'd not discuss it, and I'd find a new job whilst enjoying the pay checks until I jumped ship.

by lord-of-the-token-rings

I'm glad you are not working for me webmaster. I'd hate to think that when anything controversial comes up, you'd just start to look for a another job, on the companies' pay cheque. We actually have a policy against that. Immediate dissmissal without a reference!

by admin

So, you are now setup as the Department of Morality. Seems to be a favorite topic around here, I found . . . ., he/she is wrong. . . ., what should I do . . . .! Do your job mr./ms. IT 'Super Guru' and leave moral evaluation to those that matter. Why are so many with access to browsing history so concerned about so many other's accesses? This subject is getting a little time worn. Somebody needs to tell you and all the others that think they are the morality barometers of web surfing to perform their IT tasks and get off the soap boxes.

by valis

if someone posts on a public message board detailed information about their boss that could be bad for their boss and damaging to their company, and through a series of google searches you're able to (because you're a techno mage) find out pretty easily (at least to you) not only where they are, who they work for, and then most likely name of their boss, should you leave a comment in the discussion informing them that what they did wasn't all that bright?

valis
CEO
Valis Enterprises
http://www.valissoft.com
http://www.helpdeskhell.com
http://www.jackosuicidewatch.com

by bartlmay

that you know the true identity of zilto and know who he used to work for? He said in a reply above that he left that company a week ago.

by bartlmay

I realize that you are no longer with that company but I still would like to know something. Apparently the laptop was his private property that was used on the company network. Then he purchased a new laptop and wanted to use it on the company network. Since neither laptop was company property he had no right or business asking you in the capacity of your employment to transfer the data from one to the other. He could have asked you either as a personal favor or hired you privately to transfer the data.
If the illegal material was copyright infringement then it's up to you if you want to report the piracy issue. If the illegal material is Child Porn then you really should report it to the authorities. Bottom line is that it is your decision and I have only expressed my opinion. In any case I personnally would have let him know that the next time he asks for data to be transfered to first remove illegal or offensive material. And maybe cite cases where the tech department at Best Buy turned in a customer that had child porn on their computer.

by bartlmay

But the Boss should have asked which do I need or what is the difference. Not just "do it". Or zilto trying to get more info to determine which was needed.

by kevin.ison

I would be careful... reporting him could cause him to accuse you of putting illegal material on his laptop. One of the other posts mention teaching him how to do this data migration himself... a good idea.
If this person is a sleezebag, he would probably just say that you put it on his laptop.... so be wary of jumping off.

by valis

yup, from just the information provided in that one post it is possible to find out exactly who he works for, where he works, and a very probable name and phone number of the supervisor that he's talking about.
people should be a smidge more careful ;)

by a.techno.geek

It took me couple of months, but I was able to track down a couple of High School friends through the internet. One friend was or probably has never been on the internet or just has not used the ISP email that came with the service. I found that he lives in a town to the north of me in the thumb area of the lower Peninsula of Michigan. Located him in "Anywho". The other friend I found through a series of articles. One in a book review in a Tucson paper. Then I found out he is an amateur radio operator, found his email through an amateur radio organization and contacted him, only to find out he never really considered me a friend, how do you like that? So yeah really shouldn't post too much crap because ya give away the farm.

by bigaldepr

This is the correct approach. The use of phrase "there maybe some" is perfect. Explain that there is no expectation of privacy on the company network and he runs the risk of others finding the questionable material. Someone holding grudge could use this against him.

Another senerio I have encounter is the son/daughter of the manager had access to the laptop at home. Someone else had loaded the material and she was not aware of it.

This approach avoids what I call the Network cop image and you are performing in a helpful advisory role that is to his benefit. If he is reasonable, he will remove the material himself and you have achieved the desired result. Otherwise, he is an idiot and deserves what ever happens.

by stevedart

I've been in a similar spot and i have been saved by company policy. So confront him but never accuse him. Truth is, you don't know for fact that he actually is the culprit (even though he probably is).
If there is no company policy (most small companies? don?t have any) take the initiative and set one. Site the problems that come with the questionable materials as reason: spyware and viruses to name the two big ones.

by patwhatsthat

How about just grow up. Do your job, mind your own business, and stop sounding like a whining, sniveling little geek

by ccvenard

I've seen some interesting input, but this is definitely the most realistic. Thanks, patwhatsthat!!

by eugene_meenan

He replaced a drive in his buddy's PC - He forgot the cardinal rule of checking and wiping the drive he took out - He was bought to the authorities attention for downloading music - but the confiscated everything (as they would) and in the course of their investigations found child porn on the drive - Luckily he had a receipt and proof of where the stuff came from - but it implicated his buddy - as it turned out, his buddy didn't even know how to use the internet - it was his sixteen year old son. this took three years to investigate and destroyed two families because everybody assumed where there was smoke there was fire. I would only point out that if someone is more senior than yourself and in a position to fire you if your wrong - then just point out the corporate policy to them, mention that data on the laptop could be construed as being in contravention of that policy and let them then decide what they would do, it may be enough to make them realise that big brother is watching.

by mmcdonal

You migrate the data, then re-image the hard drive on the boss's laptop, then have a friendly matter of fact discussion with him/her about how to erase tracks on a computer. Perhaps a mention of copyright laws and penalties in another friendly discussion.
End of story.

by thelurch

Seeing as how this operation is suppose to be performed as part of a business related piece of machinery, I'd suggest moving ONLY those files and programs that are related to the busijness at hand.

All the other stuff can stay on the original machine.

by edeldoug

Well, let's see... From a MORAL standpoint I see your dilemna. The guy's doing wrong stuff! From a practical standpoint - it probably wouldn't do your career or personal life any good to do anything about it. The "amnesia" suggestions are probably the way I'd go... with one caveat. You are legally bound to report finding certain things such as child porn. FAILURE to do so can make YOU criminally liable - if it can be shown you had knowledge and did not report.

by michaelpo

What are the company policies? Does the company walk the walk or just talk the talk? My company believes its policies and moral standards. After turning the info over the the head of HR, the president of the business unit left suddenly. It must be objective and presented to the right person as the moral issue that it is. Don't share with your buddies.

by catfish182

OK while the boss may think that he is above the law i do agree that it has to be handled. But here is the thing. get all the information first. and yes i know you left but for in the future use this. get all the information. The laptop may be company owned but he does own the company. If he takes the laptop home with him and does it then I dont really see what you can do. If he is using company bandwidth then honestly I would go to him and tell him. " sir i am here to talk to you about a issue and i have reason to believe that it will deveolp itno a very bad situation."
IF he gets angry then turn it over to be honest, IF he is using bandwidth. otherwise i would tell him that the stuff he has is setting off the AV and cut him off from the network until they are gone.

by dekid

This is the question you have to ask yourself. I see a lot of advice here in these posts. Many of them are on the right track.

The sooner you forget about this the better. Wipe it out of your memory. Migrate the data and be done with it. You didn't see anything unusual. You did your job like you get paid for! End of story.

by etruss

I'm only a few messages into this and I can't believe some of these people live on the same planet I do. Techs with enough spare time to notice what files a user has on his computer and to worry about the morality of them? Give me a break. A tech should try to tell his BOSS what to do? Have you heard of career-limiting actions? Same for refusing to work on personal computer equipment. We have execs who expect people to walk their dog for them when they bring them to work - and they do it!
I agree with the approach one person suggested - to treat the person as if it is not their fault. Act like it might have happened at home when someone else had access to the computer. I've seen cases where owners of laptops did not know their children were downloading stuff onto the laptop when the owner was not using it. Don't assume that the owner is the problem without proof.

by higdon

All adults are responsible for their actions. I would email the entire company re-iterating the Internet use rules and regulations. The way I see it, he's made his own bed and now he has to sleep in it.

by quincysrevenge

Now is the time to demand more money. Sticke it to the fool. Don't forget to make copies of all the data that on the system. Or encrypted it on his computer so he will have to ASK you for the code. Then charge him to view it.

by kpanco

Perhaps your company should invest in a professional tool to do data migration, such as PT Pro. Then you simply transfer the personality and data without looking into the files. It's much quicker too.
As a tech, you were not tasked to do forensic work.

by lanmanjs

You must realize that if the images on the system are illegal then you can now be held as an accessory to it if you do not report it. If it is child porn then I don't see the need to even think about it. That kind of thing is not only ridiculous but downright perverted and should be reported no matter who it is. Yes there?s the possibility that you could lose your job and no one would want that to happen to them but that kind of behavior can become dangerous to kids.
If it isn?t CP but some other material that clearly shows illegal activity then you still have the obligation to report what is there. Again, you could find yourself on the wrong end of an investigation if this information does get out some other way. Your ?boss? has inadvertently placed you in a really bad place. What exactly do you own him/her for that?
Of course, the final decision is yours and only you know what you?re going to do about it. If you say nothing then there?s a real possibility that nothing will ever come about from this and you?re completely free. You could confront the boss as has been suggested in other responses and that too could turn out fine ? or not. Or, you can cover your own behind and report this to whatever the appropriate authorities you feel should know. However you decide to go I would hate to be in your shoes right now.

by angry_white_male

If it's his personal laptop - then the content on it is none of your concern. Company laptop - that's another story (how you deal with it is up to you and your boss and whatever policies your company may have in place).

In any event, if he's connecting it to the company network - then be a good admin, make sure he's got good antivirus protection, anti-spyware, personal firewall, etc.

Look at it another way - I'd rather have the guy jerk off to porn on his laptop while away on business than paying for a hooker while his wife is at home with the kids.

by shraven

zlito
I think the only one being stupid here is you. If you don't even work for the company anymore what business is it of yours? I'm sure the guy didn't treat you right somtime and now you want to hurt him. Grow up. Nothing good for you will come of any further action.
We all do illegal things. How would you feel if your boss saw you driving in to work a little faster than the posted speed limit and called the police to report you?
You're a putz and a tattle-tale and a lot of other things and nobody likes you. Further more, I can tell from your posts you're not very intelligent, and don't know as much about computers as you think you do. But none of that matters. What does matter is that if you don't get over your need to police the world and impose your views on everyone you come into contact with you will never be successful at any job. Such people are never appreciated. So mull that over while you address that envelop to the feds.

by bank_it_guy

Some things you did not address in your original post that could help you here. First off, do you have any regulatory oversight at your business, or are do auditors do an IT audit at your shop?

If so, Policies are generally required detailing appropriate network usage. There are plenty of solutions which can monitor network usage for sites like porn, chat, gambling, or any number of things. Of course, if the downloading took place off network, then it comes down to a question of "Should I tell or not?".

I think your primary job is to do the right thing for the company. After all, that is where your paycheck is coming from. And the best way to protect the company is to make sure company IT assets are used for company purposes. If something violates that policy, you are just doing your job.

by gordon.rudd

After doing IT security for far longer than I care to remember...I have to say you are so wrong it is scary. In fact you are the person who would get fired ?for cause?. It is not now, nor will it ever be a job duty of IT to police users. IT implements corporate policy. Unless you have been specifically requested to determine the contents of this person?s hard drive by your HR or Legal department -or- a law enforcement agency with a valid warrant YOU not your President have crossed a line and should be fired.

Even if you notice a file name or extension that catches your attention during the file transfer you should not open to file.

by madyson

Unless:

? it's KP (Kiddy Porn), then the Feds can take it and do something about it.

? it's illegal software, then you need to contact BSA or SPA and they'll take care of it.

? it's stolen videos, then you need to contact MPAA (Motion Picture Association of America) and see if this group is converd by them.

? it's stolen music, then it's also a copyright violation, like the last one. There are other regulations for this too such as the NET Act.

Bottom line is that there are all kinds of regulatory standards, guidelines, and Laws that have been established that you could use in this case by contacted the associated groups that help enforce them. The issue is that if he has proof of purchase, bought it from an authorized distributor, and can prove he's innocent then he may come after you with a lawsuit, or if he?s well connected in the industry he could make getting employment precarious at best. You need to make a careful decision on this one, I would chat with the Feds first and see what assistance they can offer, they're usually very willing to talk about it first.

By the way if there is KP on that CD, you need to get rid of it now (turn it in or destroy it)!! You are breaking the law by having it and can end up in jail if someone catches you with it.

Good luck!

MAD dog