I found things on my bosses
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
One question to ask yourself is are you responsible for what is on the company machines. If the answer is yes then you have two choices:
1. Talk to your boss and explain that this material shouldn't be on the company computer and that having it there puts you in an awkward posistion. Some people will respect the fact that you were willing to talk to them before taking any action. I personally would relay the need to discuss this issue in an email, just to cover you assets.
2. Delete the material and say nothing further.
As others have mentioned there is a big difference between illegal and immoral. As well as the fact that this person may not even know the material is there.
If you are not responsible for what is on the company machines talk to the person that is and let them make the decision.
by west11
by jagershot
One of the partners of the company, the CEO, called one of my techs to look at his PC because it seemed slow. The tech, whom I hired just weeks earlier, was actually excited to lend a hand but was warned to get in and get out since he is not one to be bothered. He calls me while I am in a meeting and claims that he has an emergency relating to the CEO's system so I walk out to discuss the matter with him only to find out that he found pornographic pics, videos and links. I say "only" for one reason, I understand the position/ power of the perpetrator and relative to that, he can do what ever he wants. Now, in my case, I wrote the internet and e-mail security policy and any other employee would probably be reprimanded for viewing and saving pornography on the company's system but this is one battle I will walk away from. I have since asked the owner to call me directly for service on his PC; I explained to him that there IS sensitive company data on his system and that most of my techs would not be privy to such data.
In your case:
Are you the decision maker for your IT department?
Is the laptop his personal property?
There are many great questions posed in replies above mine and I simply wanted to tell a story that may help you relate.
GOOD LUCK!
by rgoode
by cberding
Been there, done that. I've seen more than a few people fired for stuff like that.
In MO where I live, you are legally required to report certain things that appear on PCs (i.e. porn, etc.) as a tech. No questions there. You can be liable if you do not.
by overcharge
When I'm looking for items to support some of the junk I work on, I sometimes hit Dallas' 1st Saturday swap. You wouldn't believe what I've found on 'pulls'.
I found the internal communications from Frito-Lay on downsizing product while keeping the bags the same size.
I found the upgrade proposals for the C-130J series avionics, countermeasures specs, and a five year plan for competitive bids on three current fighter upgrades. (Probably should have sold it to their competition...or DOD. Any company with an IT staff that lax deserves to lose.)
This wasn't recovered using an un-erase utility, it was undeleted files.
I found the entire history of a family that showed their gradual financial decline, bankruptcy and the loss of house, business, and respect. That was one rainy 1st Sat that the repair section of a computer company was dumping the unclaimed repair items--at $5 per pop (non-working laptop that I had going in about a half hour.)
As to the original source of this thread: Grow some balls, wipe the shit, look the guy straight in the eye and tell him some stuff was lost in the transfer...or transfer it and use a milspec utility to wipe the offending crap off the old laptop. It's probably going to go out to some poor schmo that wouldn't have a clue and get busted for content...or fired by the same guy that put it there.
Hey Mike:
I certainly can agree with you on this one. I would also like to point out that data transfer and perusing through files are to different activities. It leaves a person to wonder how would one know of such personal things illegal or otherwise, if in fact the indivdual doing the data transfer were not snooping.
Even with the remote possibility that the files could be viewed during the data transfer, which I doubt. Then, there is the issue that how can one move from offensive materials to illegal stuff to even theft. It appears there is allot of assumptions made in the original post.
For example, stealing others' things. How does this individual even know if the items were stolen. Not to sound condescending. This is just another point I thought should be made and some food for thought.
by prplshroud
Highlights:
- This person is the President of the company
- It sounds like this person gets everything through the company
- Cars, computers, etc...
- You have since left the company
- You have in your posession a CD of said materials.
I've gotten some great advice from some pretty great people over the years in the IT field. The best advice I ever got on the uppie-ups is that "They're different". These people are not your pal, your friend, your buddy. They play by their own set of rules. The company they work for pays them huge money and they turn around and milk that same company for computers, cars, free meals, etc... Things they could well afford with the salary they make. One of my biggest beefs, being an IT person, is executives bucking the system, purchasing custom laptops and wanting to use them for work. As I said, they don't play by the same rules as everyone else, and they don't have to because they can replace you with someone else who will let them behave as they want.
These people can make your professional life miserable at the snap of a finger. You never know who knows who when interviewing for a position.
My sincerest advice to you now that you've moved on to a future position is to move on completely. Destroy the CD and let it go. It's not worth your time and effort. I'm sure you have plenty of other things you'd rather be doing with your spare time than thinking about this. You have no loyalties to that company anymore.
It sounds to me that you have some kind of serious vendetta against this person and you want to see bad things happen to them. Trust me, let it go, it's not worth the effort.
by unclerob
by allycatuk
Rob, I for one will have to agree with you, there was no reason for him to inspect the contents of his boss's files, and had he done it in an efficient way, he'd never have seen them in the first place. If he was so concerned about morality, he could have just not copied the files in the first place, but to go on and make a copy of them and then keep it after he left the job goes against the grain.
Also, nobody has picked up on the fact that he says in one of his posts that "he keeps up with the list of movies that are illegal" Does this not worry anyone but me?? If the company tech knows about illegal porn, then is he any less guilty? Hmmmm me thinks not.
Calling a user "computer stupid" is also not on, your job as a tech or network admin etc, is to educate and help your users, not belittle them.
That said, i'll get off my soap box lol.
by overcharge
The only time I've had to look at what goes across is when I'm side-lining, or have a couple of mind-numbing exercises going on--non-automated installations--which require periodic user responses.
If he has that much time, it isn't going to be from peeking that gets him fired, or at least it won't be that excuse.....
by sixten
what was written in the original post or you would have noticed that it stated: "... That was when I saw alot of jpg, pic, mpg and other things going by.
... I did not dig into the files ..."
He did not snoop, just sat there watching the progress of the copying.
by dbeast
There's alot of gray area in this whole issue, and much of it should fall under the umbrella of company policy (though it's usually more a case of "lack of policy"). The two guiding elements in end-users' behaviour is either they truly don't see their actions as illegal (or as "all that serious" - doesn't "everybody" do it?) or they don't believe they can or will be caught. Company laptops are an even grayer case as, due to the mobility and availability of these laptops to the user at all places and times, they are inadvertantly used as much for private, personal purposes as for work related issues. The three fields to juggle are: 1) What is downloaded over the company network and company time? 2) What is downloaded over the user's private, home network on private time? 3) What is left on the computer when it is on the company network?
In addition to the illegal character of actions, further implications are the repercussions this could have on the integrity of the company, exposing the company network to Spyware, Malware, Worms etc... (and many download sites are THE source for these hazzards). My company pretty much allows me a free hand to deal with these problems as I see fit - as long as there is proper documentation and a reasonable process of escalation. How far you can go and what you can threaten or do depends on where you stand in your company though... In general, I first try a general approach, claiming that I've noticed illegal downloads over the company network (or access to various sites or IPs on the firewall logs). I will openly announce that some of (or one of) the company computers contain illegal files, apps, downloads, etc, or that users' private downloads at home are exposing the company network to various possible hazzards... This usually results in two things: 1) The CEO immediately wants to know specific details of who and what 2) The culprit usually gets the hint and either stops or finds a way of covering his tracks (which I usually find out and then threaten to take action). I have found that people are usually more receptive when you make it clear that aside from being illegal, there would also be much personal embarassment if more details were known.
The fact that you refer to illegal actions could definitely (and ultimately should) be reported, but as I've encountered many individuals who really don't fully understand the implications of their actions, I try give a second chance. Miss that second chance and then I get nasty. Furthermore I undertake to occasionally post news articles relating to public cases of similar issues where all can see as a reminder. Every new employee who has access to the internet or gets a laptop first hears my rules, and I occasionally hold company enrichments which at face value emphasize network integrity and security issues for the end user, but also plant in everyons mind the feeling that I am aware of every single keystroke taken on any of the company computers...
The fact that it's the CEO is sensitive, but if you have a good enough line of communication with him (He did ask you to migrate his computer, knowing that you would likely have access to his soul...) you might find a way to convey that he "seems" to have on his laptop material which is best not to have for obvious reasons. Suggest that if he intends to continue, it might be advisable to keep it to his own personal private home computer and network only.
The loyalty dilema is complicated - You want to protect your place of work, you don't want to confront or offend your CEO and you don't want to be an accessory to criminal actions. In the case of extreme criminal action or beyond, I'd report it immediately, but try protect myself at the same time. On minor issues I think that being able to show that actions were taken to prevent the crime from being repeated is highly commendable, especially if these actions are successful. I feel that minor first time offences can go unreported to the authorities if I cn show that my actions were fruitful and at the same time allowed the perpetrator to save face without implicating or endangering the company.
by unclerob
by shellbot
by overcharge
They can only do it if they have knowledge of it. Sorry, but dropping a dime on a VP becomes he said, she said. Who besides him has access to the computer---YOU. Just wipe it and press on. You might tell him about external drives, however.
The usual reason we get involved is the gripe that the computer is s-l-o-w...and we find three copies of "Debbie does Dallas" and its kindred, with 30M of space left out of an 80G.
Had one exec who went to do a speech, and tried to load his PowerPoint presentation to his HD. His kid had 60G of Uberdownloads on his drive. Didn't quite make it. Good music, though.
I work on a network with hundreds of users. Im constantly finding Photo files, music files, etc. Because it uses space on my network more than anything (and we do have a policy in place against such things). I usualy ignore the material if its only a couple of files, I may mention it to the user if its more than a handfull, if its too much I would secure a copy someplace and remove the originals with a message to the user that these files have been removed and if there was a "business purpose" to these they could ask for them to be copied to CD. If I dont hear in short order then they are deleted.
Usually you can tell by name or storage location that they are of illegal or offensive I have on one occurance reported material to our HR department before removing.
by av .
If you are the unfortunate tech that finds this on a PC, you have to report it. Other porn, you need to get that person to clean up their act - whoever they are. I wouldn't turn them in, but I would strongly suggest to them that they do that kind of stuff at home.
The same goes for MP3's. The company can get sued if its illegal stuff. I would lock down the network so it isn't allowed.
For the tech, its a no win situation. Its best not to look too much unless its too blatant to ignore, cause once you've seen it, you can't just do nothing. You have to discourage it somehow. The best way is to diplomatically ask the person about it.
Techs are in charge of what information is on the PCs and servers on their network, so they need to enforce the company's policies. If they don't, they could be held responsible for letting it exist.
by dale.zjc
If the boss in question is a principle of the company, he's under no moral obligation whatsoever to meet someone else's moral standards with company assets he owns! Even if you run across illegal (pirated?) software, I'd tread very carefully and approach it from more of a "I'm just letting you know what I found..." kind of approach.
Chances are if he/she is knowingly downloading illegal software, the last thing he wants to deal with is someone playing moral policeman.
by unclerob
by bndplus2
You stated "He shouldn't have opened & viewed any files on his bosses laptop. He crossed a line."
If I see a file name that would appear to be in violation of company policy, I'm gonna at least take a closer peek at it. If it's something that appears to be what I suspected, I'll open it. If it IS what I suspected, I'll drop HR a line. They almost always say to proceed with the investigation. I'll then scour the entire system looking for further evidence, keeping chain of custody and best practices in mind.
You use the term "snooping around" - that is what is commonly referred to as "trolling" or "going on a fishing expedition". We don't do that, although we make it abundantly clear in the policy manual that we can - and do, on occasion - monitor systems and their use. If I bump into something in my daily travels that appears to be a violation, I'm expected to follow it up.
As for leaving the company and keeping a copy regardless, I agree that he should not have kept it (nor, I think, made a copy - what's the point? "I have this CD here with files *I SWEAR* I got off so-and-so's system"... Not what I would call "evidence" by any means...). He should at least have handed it over to HR on the way out (if at all - I mean, I still don't see the purpose of having it at all).
You further state "Why someone would snoop around on someone else's computer to view the files and their contents is beyond me, network admins aren't spies, any arguments to the contrary would be foolish."
This is somewhat correct; we are overseers. "Spying" can be open to interpretation. As far as I'm concerned, anything on my network is fair game, and the company has made that possible through well documented, published policies.
"Spying is illegal, let the HR dept worry about the enforcing company policy and reasonable use of company resources."
What we do is NOT considered "Spying" - "Spying" is when you are doing things serruptitiously, without prior knowledge. Since we have clearly stated that we can, do and WILL monitor systems for appropriate use, we're covered. And the statement that HR should "enforce company policy and reasonable use of company resources" blows me away, frankly. How are they going to find out about abuse if nobody tells them? And, realistically, the responsibility for maintaining the company's system resources is OURS and NOT HR's!
Needless to say I disagree with some of your comments.
Regarding the problem: if it's just porn, talk to someone in HR about it and also your boss. Then let them do whatever they want to do. Step out of it and let them take responsibility. If it's CHILD porn, then you YOURSELF have to notify the authorities. If you do not you are breaking the law. You notify the authorities and THEN you notify HR/Management - NOT the other way around! There is no decision to be made here - the law is clear.
Don't make decisions on your own, I suppose would be the moral of the story. If you see it, get someone else involved. Doing so reduces your liability.
A few years back, I had a top level exec who very commonly surfed porn. I brought it up to my boss who in turn brought it up to his boss. They decided to leave it alone. However, on my own, I redirected the sites he was visiting to another site, commonly www.disneyland.com. He realized what I was doing and we actually had a cat and mouse game going for a while... It was quite funny, really. But I was told that we weren't going to pursue anything about it, however I also had the ability to try to stop the conduct by redirecting the traffic. That was within my authority, so I did it. I suppose I could have gotten in trouble for it, but I doubted that would have happened because he wouldn't want to make an issue of it in front of others. Besides, I did that any other time I had a violation, so... It wasn't out of the norm.
As for the way this was dealt with, I don't agree with the way it was done. Looking at the file is one thing, but burning the CD and not involving others put this guys neck on the line.
Many junior admins face these types of situations, and do what they think is best to deal with it. It's called LEARNING... We've all made mistakes - it's a part of the process. Some of us don't have others to learn from, so we have to try to make due. That would appear to be the case here.
Hopefully his next job will allow him better professional guidance.
by smithwaa
by mipsv
OK, make a ghost backup for your CYA protection first. Its called backstabbing and its how the "corporate world" works. Do you really think he would help you if the tables got reversed? nope.
Don't you think he "asked" YOU to do this dirty work for a reason? He doesnt have the right to make you break the law or make you uncomfortable at work. Hell, you can already sue the company for pain and suffering (you are confused enough to post here, after all).
If you have HR tell them on a day your boss is out of the office. Call a lawyer first (its free at first - anyway). Tell the lawyer that you have a backup copy (and be sure you do).
The other advice is crap... though well meaning since nobody wants you to be the victum though you already are.
Proceed in this order:
backup copy -> lawyer -> HR (or another - pref. (older) female manager)
by ashembers
I think that we IT folks overstep our bounds sometimes and need to take a note from the police on what is punishable. They have rules on what is admissable during a court procedure, and how people come upon evidence to find guilt. We should be the same way & protect people's privacy because ultimately it makes a difference with what corporate culture we make.
So if it were me, I would pay attention to how I found it. If he were watching it on work time and it was visible from his monitor, then by all means call the authorities. However, if it was merely on his system, you could implement a policy where computers would be swept of content outside the known, used directories, as well as large video files for people that do not need them. Call it a "keeping the systems in top shape" type of policy & include other things like scheduled defrags, disk checks, etc. Then go and delete the illegal content later on. The point is that you need a policy behind you before acting on anything, because nothing else will save you from a ruined career that could have otherwise been trouble free.
by breadtrk
How many times does this have to be covered?
When it is MY machine on My network,using MY resources, there is NO privacy, none, zip, zilch, nada.
If it does not specifically belong on this network, it is gone. Period.
by dj413
Let's see if I have this correct. You worked for this company, saw files that you found offensive, backed these up to disk, left the company, and now wonder what to do?
First, get rid of the backups...as in totally destroy. They are NOT your property and the fact that you have them makes you a thief!
Second, who in this field has not seen these files? I agree that unless they are child porn, let it go. I'm only paid to keep the network running and handle issues with that, not to police what people see/do.
Third, send the files to the Feds?? And tell them what? You have no proof that those files will even be there on the laptop anymore, but you still have the disk. Ever hear of a disgruntled ex-employee?
I guess your only option at this point is to let this issue go....it is now some other IT persons problem since you don't work there anymore.
by networkguy55
Zito, you didn't say if he was the president of a large company (and thus answerable to a Board of Directors) or whether he was "Bill" of "Bill's Sales"
If a large company, I do not envy the position of being caught between the corporation that sets policy and the person who could squash your career like a bug. Avoid that political battle, even if it comes to a necessity of changing jobs. Better to leave on your own terms than get caught up in a no-win situation--if you report him or don't report him, you are opening yourself to being pink-slipped either way.
On the other hand, if he's "Bill" he *is* the policymaker. It is not your job to determine policy. It is your professional duty to recommend sound policy, but setting it is not your prerogative. In this situation, even if his computer contents violate policy, it's his policy to break if he chooses.
You state some of the contents were illegal. My actions would depend on whether they were criminal (as in kiddie porn) or civil in nature (as in P2P music sharing). If the content is criminal, you must report it to the authorities, or be considered an accomplice. If it is a lesser variety of illegal, you may be well advised to, as someone recommended earlier, develop amnesia.
by rdursch
I have read all 125 (at the time) posts for this article. I am not throwing my .02cents into the arguement. I just wanted to comment...
There have been sound pieces of advice, for and against persuing the issue, as well as some down right nasty comments. I guess the issue boils down to what you think is right for yourself. Not the company or the "boss". The company nor the boss will watch out for you. You have to do it yourself. You have to accept the consequences of whatever you decide. Weigh your decission carefully, then stick to it without second guessing yourself.
To all of the posters thank you for opening my eyes to the different view points. If I am ever put into a situation such as this, I will remember your thoughts and suggestions.
by brutbwgcp
by tundraroamer
I was just thinking those very words before I read this post.
It's true.
You may be the only person that can prevent disaster to your company.
Haven't you "accidentally" ever formatted a drive in error? Then just reinstall a ghost of the original install or reinstall the authorized legal corporate software for that laptop and hand it back with a note saying "oops".
It might be nice if you were able to save his actual business documents before the format and make sure he knows that.
A fresh copy of the IT corporate policy installed on the desktop is also a nice touch.
Or just tell him that you found things contrary to policy and you removed them.
by ron
by overcharge
I'm probably not the only one, but I'm probably one of the few that has been subpoenaed for what they've found on computers. I was upgrading and clearing out old files and ran into some triple-x stuff. Called and asked the owner if they wanted the porn to stay. The comment was "what porn?"
The couple was in the middle of a nasty divorce and child custody fight. Next thing you know I'm sitting giving testimony. Kid goes to mom.
A couple years later, I'm in the return line at Fry's and strike up a conversation with a guy and his girlfriend/wife. I mention I'm from ???? and he says his ex-inlaws are from there. I ask who and realize from the answer that it's a good thing that I'm not wearing a suit, 'cause he's the guy that lost his kid over it.
by sturner
It is positively, absolutely the job of IT departments to police the users. Our responsibilities lie in the ability to maintain a viable and working network, desktop, server, email ect ect ect. Anyone user's actions that cause a detriment to this is in the wrong, not the tech that finds it. There are a lot of things out there for download that contain malicious code that make let confidential information leek to the outside world, especially on a President system. Throw away the whole ?IT is there to make the users life easier? crap fact is the world can not revolve with out technology and we are there to make it work and make it secure and if that means someone cant get to their porn page so be it!
As for this whole argument of privacy of a company owned machine, there is no privacy as long as there is a usage policy in place. There are enough employment termination cases through the US to back that up to! Heck if anyone needs a good usage policy email me and I will send you the one we created and sent through legal.
by regbwright
If he is doing something illegal, it will catch up to him.
"Everybody gets what is coming to them." - Clint Eastwood.
You are responsible for feeding your family, that should be your only worry.
Btw, you are just seeing the title of files not the actual file when your copying files?
by drcard.dana
by alece
he should not be 'snooping' on other people's workstations. If it is not his position in the company to investigate matters involving the corporate security policy, then he has no business going after these files. By copying the files off the workstation of a company official and leaving company premises with that material, he needs to be terminated immediately. I would never want to be guilty of such an offense under any circumstances. Someone else on here mentioned that the people responsible for hiring at other companies have ways of finding these things out. They are absolutely right, there is such a network and in IT, that network is VERY well connected (they may have a secret IRC server somehwere and they all go there looking for blacklisted people). I know that sounds like a fantasy, but it sure seems that way sometimes.
The best thing he should do now is move on, learn from it and hope he can find a less-than-well-connected IT recruiter in another company after they have let him go. Maybe he should resign to prevent the blackmark from being entered against his permanent record on the secret database.
by sorincom
You have for sure a very practical standpoint.
But let me put the things this way: an exploited kid is living a daily inferno and a fat pig is enjoying this also on a daily basis.
What would YOU put first: the kid or your lousy job ?
You just can't compare speed limit with crime. And, by the way, WTH dit zlito find ??!
by jdclyde
A little blunt maybe, but not rude and not out of line.
What is your opinion of someone who gets a co-worker fired? Is this someone you would want to work with? Not me.
It was just a quick reality check on WHY he is thinking about prosuing this. If there isn't CLEAR policy that says what is on the laptop is forbidden AND that it is his job to report this, it is just asking for trouble.
some people just like to squeal on other.
Make sure he does the right thing for the right reason.
They are all things he should think hard about before deciding what to do.
by jdclyde
Don't you think that only a very poor boss would spend his time doing menial labor? That is what the techs that make half as much are for. If they get the same work done for half the money then he did good as a boss.
Even if he knew how to do it, he must not be very busy if he can drop everything to convert to a new system.
I think that the boss should at least understand tech, even if they can't do it themselves. It is the know-nothing bosses that promise the world to the rest of the company and then get mad at the techs for not "wanting" to get it done.
by jck
and it was a desktop in a secure network, why install VPN.
However, it's a laptop. That means it's mobile. He might use it outside your secure network. Therefore, what would you think to install for your boss?
Pretty obvious, if you ask me.
If your boss gives you autonomy, don't take advantage of it. But also, don't just sit and expect for someone to make decisions for you that coincide with what is supposed to be your area of "technical expertise".
When you let someone else become the expert for the tasks in your job, that is step #1 of becoming "obsolete". Bosses expect you to "take initiative". While this doesn't mean doing everyone elses' job, it does mean you better well be doing yours and doing it right and knowing the needed thing to do within your scope of responsibility.
Hence my advice is...mobile computing = VPN. No question.
by wayne
by sj3
You may be the one in trouble not your ex-executive. First, by your own admission, you are in possession of stolen company property. A full backup of an executives' laptop most likely contains a fair amount of company confidential information. Information that even when you were employed with the company, you were not entitled to. A request to an employee to copy information is not the same as giving them access to the content of the information. Second, you may have committed an act of perjury when you left the company if you signed or made a statement to HR that you had returned all company property. And last, at this point you have no proof legal proof that these backup CD's came from this executive's laptop. But YOU are in possession of illegal (as you say) movies, etc. and stolen company (possibly confidential) information. Legally you have no evidence of the executives? wrong doings only of yours. There may be enough information to warrant an investigation of the executive, depending on the nature of the so called illegal information and other factors. You should have gone to HR, your supervisor, etc. when you discovered the information because at that time you could have claimed a justifiable reason to having the information in your possession. At this point in time, you have no justifiable reason to have access to any of this information.
Just some things to think about
by mr 't'
As a 38 year IT veteran, I can state that State law as well as company policy cover me if I convert the pc, and don't look at the contents of files.
If I get caught looking at them, I would be fired and possibly prosecuted regardless of contents.
If I look at the files, and discover a felony, or evidence of child/spouse/parent abuse, or evidence that suicide is contemplated, and dont report it, I can be put in jail. Before I am fired.
Bottom line: I move stuff from a to b. the contents, filenames, etc are S.E.P. (Someone Elses Problem).
by veteran tyro
by endlr
by tonythetiger
by tetsu96
Last thing you want to do is give him the opportunity of deleting his information - especially if there's no backup of the contraband or if there's less scrupulious admins who'd delete it themselves (and offending backups) for their own advancement or personal reasons.
Data can be retrieved in most cases even if the user deletes it, but it's best left for the authorities if you commit to that course.
by oz_media
Call the cops, have them come to your office and root through his notebook on child porn allegations, have him say that he loaned it out to a friend for a week and has no idea what's on it.
YOU'LL lose your job either way, guaranteed.
If he's NOT guilty of child porn and has some picture sof his own kids in the swimming pool, or playing in the yard, YOU lose your job. If he gets off the the allegations and no charges are brought about, YOU lose your job. If he has a completely viable 'excuse' for the material, YOU lose your job.
Bottom line, YOU lose your job, trying to be the Internet police, very clever.
Addressing it, THEN monitoring activity for signs that he IS into child pronography WILL get you an answer, and something th epolice will act upon. YOU try calling the local law enforcement agency and tell them you THINK your boss may have child porn on his computer and other illegal information. Just don't hold your breath waiting for them to show up.
interesting thread, good discussion. one person had great advice (1.) another person had clever/entertaining advice (2.)
1. why is he looking at the files? it is not his business...and that can easily end the discussion
2. dont import the pornographic material. that is funny, very clever, but ultimately may have a negative impact on that persons standing in the company contingent upon the character of the CEO.
by oz_media
YOu took 'IT staff member' and replied:
" Assuming any job involving routine file transfers is a level 1 support position, where do I sign up for an front-line support job that pays $80K?" I made no mention of position, skill, or experience.
BUT, the AVERAGE IT guy in Vancouver can easily make 65-80K year with or without experience if they know how to find work.
You cannot put a price on a JOB, you put a price on the person. If you are one fo those people who feels (or is told), job 'A' pays $X, and job 'B' pays $Y every year, then you are simply not looking for the right employer or feel that certs or degrees disctate your income.
Sell yourself, be offered a job and THEN start talking about salary, you always get paid more this way because they want YOU not your paperwork.
nteresting thread, good discussion. one person had great advice (1.) another person had clever/entertaining advice (2.)
1. why is he looking at the files? it is not his business...and that can easily end the discussion
2. dont import the pornographic material. that is funny, very clever, but ultimately may have a negative impact on that persons standing in the company contingent upon the character of the CEO.
PS: if the guy had harmfull items like child pornography I myself would directly confront him and ask him what the hell he was doing. I would consider turning him in. if he had children himself I would turn him in.
by abnelson
I recently had a friend purchase a computer from a major retail chain. About two weeks after pruchasing it her son (14 years old) found a major stash of porn on the computer. She asked me to look into it, and although she thought she was purchasing a new computer I found another user had been created on the computer almost a month before she purchased it, and this user had signed up for internet access and downloaded a lot of porn. She did not even realize that ir was on her computer.
I am not saying this it the case with your boss, but I would be inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt and tell him that you found this on his computer, and suggest that it may have originated before he purchased the computer. If it is his, it gives him a heads up that this stuff is available to others, and may have an impact while giving him a face saving way of backing out of it.
Not every event is what it looks like on first glance.
Even if you investigated dates and they occured after he purchased the computer, you don't know who else he may have loaned the comptuer to. I try to give everyone the benefit of the doubt on the first incident. I use it as a trining exercise and a way to improve overall awareness of security issues. This is particularly important for older senior managers who may not have the experience with technology and security that a younger manager would have.
From your point of view, you cannot ignore this. You have to report it in some way, and giving him the benefit of the doubt and a way to back away from it allows you to report it as an incident that does not have a serious negative impact on your boss, but also puts it on file and starts to biuld a case for dimissal if it happens again.
that is a good point about giving the guy the benefit of the doubt. I do believe it is more likely than not that he would be importing the guys profile. it follows that the porn would be in a data path under his control.
remember this is the president of the company. I would never never take that to hr or whatever unless I found harmful material
note to hard rightwingers: I am not talking about barely legal teens here. I mean kiddie porn, snuff films (hehe, tell me they dont make those anymore) etc
confront a president of a company to his face or not at all, he might respect you. you go to hr and he will find a way to bury you
Work on personally owned computers can lead to other potential problems besides this one. What if some component coincidentally dies while you are working on the machine? In the future, never even let them in the door.
Come up with a couple of excuses and use them.
Try "Gee, nice machine, Boss, but it's a lot more sophisticated than what we use here", or "We don't have that version of Windows / other OS here, so I don't have any experience with it" or "I've got several company machines I must work on; why don't you try Best Buy?" or "Our file transfer software is an older version and isn't compatible with your new OS's .DLL files".
If you don't think your job is in on the line, just tell them straight out that you don't work on non-company hardware because you don't have all the tools needed to restore the OS and apps if you accidentally screw it up.
Executives are like kittens. If you feed them once, they'll keep coming back and they'll bring their friends.
by ssavonis
sorry but you are wrong on this. this is the president of the company. the president sets direction , if he chooses to use a personal laptop for business purposes this is what you support.
it is inconvenient to support machines that we arent familiar with and often it is inappropriate. this is not one of those times. come on guys
by jjoaq
I thought that you were a tech and not a snooper (peeping tom, nosy person or judgemental). Your job is to fix his computer, transfer files and do what you were asked to do.
If your morals get in the way, go find another job. You don't know who, what, where, when, or how this stuff got on his computer. Mind your own business and do your IT thing.
If the president requires a laptop, the company should purchase one for him. Then you can manage it like any other company computer, and it will be subject to company polices covering appropriate use. Explain to the president the advantages of this (easier to support since it's the same as other company systems, leasing allow a new one every 2 or 3 years, doesn't come out of his pocket when it breaks or is stolen, etc.)
I haven't met a senior executive yet that wouldn't like a second laptop. He can use the company-provided one and give his old personal one to someone else in the family.
by ethos21st
Palmetto gives good advice. Every company I have worked for
had company-provided desktops or laptops that were given to
employees for their use for company business, and it is usually
made clear up front that any and all information on that
comuper may be subect to monitoring, etc. In this case, you
indicate that it was the executive's own personal computer (not
"PC" but "personal").
Probably not a good idea to allow employees to use their own
computers but in this case if it was the company president, you
probably did not have any choice. Instead of posting this
dilemma on this very public website, however, you might have
discussed it with your boss.
by gawiman
First of all, many people do not realize that data transfer operations involve seeing file names. I've been doing this for 10 years and have seen millions of FN's flash by on the screen. In itself, that is not snooping - it's part of making sure the transfer job finishes correctly.
In that time I've seen LOTS of porn and just let it go right on by. It's none of my business; they're all consenting adults from actors to audience. As for trying to police what the guy does at work, that isn't my job except as outlined by company policy. Furthermore, who am I, the morality police?
MP3's may well be translated from his private CD collection - I don't know if they're stolen and it isn't my job to find out.
Child Porn is different - every picture has a victim and a service company I once worked for helped prosecute a guy who brought in his computer chok full of the stuff. We were proud to do it, and yes, CP would be worth losing a job over.
by sonictoad
I didn't get too far into this thread before I was hit with a few questions (and perhaps they are questions that others state later on)-
(1)What is it you are seeking?
Justification, validation, a plan?
There will always be at least 4 sides to any discussion. Firstly there's the side of what's "right" (the thing that lets you live with yourself and look at yourself in the mirror each day-no one here can tell you that). There's what's "right" (the thing that lets you keep your job). And then there's what's "right" (the thing that follows (or sets) corporate policy). And finally, there's what's "right" (the thing you wind up doing).
Basically, none of us can tell you want you need to do. We can only offer suggestions or personal history.
I think it is a big assumption on your part that the files are "illegal" just because they are current. There are screener copies of movies. There are legitimate pay per view/download sites where one may obtain music files, nudie pix, whatever floats their boat.
The second dangerous assumption is that the owner of the laptop was the culprit. While they are culpable because they own the laptop, you have no proof (from "watching" a file transfer) that they put the files there themselves. It would be very easy for the President of the company to say he didn't know anything about the files and accuse you of placing them there.
The final assumption that you are making is that it's your place to carry this burden of morality.
True, there are infrastructure risks that we're all aware of with dubious files, but there should be a clearly defined chain of command in any organization that you can follow to report those.
BUT, unless you are a qualified representative of the motion picture association or recording industry or law enforcement, I personally don't feel that it's your place to assess the legality of files on a machine (that you were just copying).
I know that there are those that see the network as "their" network in IT, but keep this in mind:
The PRESIDENT of the company bought the laptop (and probably bought ALL of the other equipment in the company, too). The issue of personal laptop for company use or company laptop is moot.
What it comes down to, is you just have to do what's right, and ultimately that means doing what's right for you.
But that's just my two cents.
by blueknight
If, as others have said, there was child porn, you have a legal obligation to report it to the police... as the news has shown us a number of times very recently, these guys are literally time bombs. I've had to track them and they're all the same and they never change.
If that laptop in question was a company machine, designated for company work, I'd drop a standard image on it of only the OS and software required to do the job. Nuke the old machine and drop a standard image on it too.
One response mentioned loaning him a CD burner to save the files to before cleaning the laptop. As long as YOU don't do the copying to CD. If you do, you then become an accessory to whatever crime has has comitted... assuming it was child pron or copyright infringement or whatever. I went so far as to verify this with my D.A. sister.
Personally, I wouldn't want to work for such a guy. First because of this morality issue, second because of potential copyright issues and most importantly, his mind is NOT on the business. It can't be long before business suffers for his inattention. He owns the company... you're screwed! Why protect a dirtbag?
I would report anything illegal I saw, especially child porn, then call my headhunter. End of story.
by robapacl9
Will the lawyers out there explaim to me what
" clearly illegal " is. Seems to me, we have nothing but high-priced lawyers in protracted court cases arguing the point in every venue imagineable. I wouldn't be presumptuous enough to even venture an opinion on what is "clearly illegal ". Is child porm illegal if the child was constructed digitally? If a hacker were to load it into someone's computer, would the mere presence of the porn be enough for indictment. Turning every over-the-shoulder spectator into an informant sounds like 1984 revisited. Does anyone remember the Hitler youths who informed on their parents for treasonous thoughts. The emphasis on the right to privacy is a national problem precisely because there are no standards that even the experts and authorities can agree on. Let them sort it all out. That's what they're being paid for.
by oregonnative
There is lot's of things that should be private on a network. It is a breech of our ethics to be "exploring" through data that is stored in an area expected to be secure.
However, I'm defending privacy of medical records, financial transactions, and legitimately secure information. I would not transfer illegal movies or pornography. Instead, I might create a backup image (for my protection) and give him his new laptop without the illegal stuff. Would he dare ask "Where did my movies go?" If he did, I might enjoy the ensuing transaction. If I got fired, I would have a great lawsuit.
by ethos21st
First, it is not unusual for employees to use their personal PC's
or Mac's at work, as a conduit to company e-mail, company
files, etc. Thus, one would expect that an employee using his or
her own computer at work (connected to the company network
when at work) would be using a computer with personal folders/
files as well as company folders/files.
It appears that YOUR JOB was to migrate essential company data
to the company President's computer, NOT to review, even open,
files that were clearly personal and none of your business. That
was wrong, and you should probably seek clarification from your
boss as to what the scope of your responsibilities are.
This appears to be a case where the hardware (the computer)
was the personal property of the employee (or he/she had been
authorized to use it at home for personal use) and the software
and/or files you were transferring were property of the
company.
If you and other IT "cops" are curious about your scope of
"investigation" or authority, I suggest you seek your boss's
acvice or your General Council's advice.
P.S. The mere fact that you posted this information on a public
website is troublesome, as any good computer-literate person
((including my teenage son) could find out who you are and what
your company is in a heartbeat.
P.P.S. In my spare time, I teach business ethics. You might want
to pursue a course yourself.
JB
your bravado is entertaining but you cannot find out (as an example) where I am or who I am (without a number of search warrants). false boasts rub me the wrong way
you can have more than a heart beat if you need it Neo
by jamesrl
Much depends on details not in evidence.
Are there company policies on porn? In some companies, if its found and not reported, the person not reporting is in trouble. I know at my last employer I would have been fired for not reporting items like that. We don't know what the policy was at the OP's place of work.
And as for "reviewing" the files, I agree that the OP had no business opening files. But are you not aware that if Windows explorer is set up the right way you get thumbnails of pictures, without opening any files. You would see this in the ordinary part of the duties of transferring files.
Also at my last employer, it was assumed that data centre personal would see sensitive material in the course of their duties, including medical records, HR records, and government classified material. So people in the data centre were carefully screened and cleared to Top Secret.
Was the computer a company computer or a personal computer used for business? There is lots of speculation here but no proof that it was a personal laptop. He just said he was migrating files from the old to the new. Again, there may or may not be policies in place regarding this. My last employer insisted that in order to use a non company PC to dial up to the company network, you had to have certain critiria, including having an active up to date virus scanner(paid for by the company).
While it might be possible to track the OP via this website, it might require some hacking. I am more than just a reasonably skilled computer literate techie, but I wouldn't make an idle boast like yours. Are you suggesting hacking TR would be ethical? You suggesting that there is no mechanism on TR to prevent the curious from finding out where the posters are posting from? Can you hack into the TR login file? What if they made up an email address for their login - or used one where the account no longer exists.
If there was evidence of something illegal,like kiddie porn then the OP has the duty to report it. If its not illegal but immoral, it depends on corporate policy.
If the original poster snooped, I have a problem with his ethics, but if he accidentally uncovered it in the course of his regular duties, he has an obligation to follow the policy guidelines of the company that hired him.
As for your ethics course, do you teach people to make judgemental posts based on half the facts - is that ethical? I don't think I will sign up thanks.
James
by armitager
I agree with ETHOS21st@...!!
ETHOS21st@... I must make mention that PC stands for personal computer, a mac and a wintel box are pc's. Let's not forget our history!!
by jamesrl
...What the scope of his job is. In some of my job descriptions, its been quite specific that I am to uphold and enforce corporate policies.
As I and other have said, he may have inadvertently discovered these things. If corporate policy says to report it, should he ignore policy because he accidentaly discovered it?
Whats this nonsense about personal computer - if it was a company provided computer, unless there is a stated expectation of privacy, there is none.
As for "our" history, mine goes back before IBM PCs. I'm not forgetting anything.
James
by av .
If he is using his personal PC for work, he should have to keep that stuff off of it. No one wants to see it. Talk about ethics, the president or whoever he is should be concerned about creating a hostile work environment.
I don't think Zlito went looking for it, but it was right in front of his face. Sometimes you can tell enough about a file by its name. You don't have to look at the file. I've seen it many times. He has to ask him what it is to find out if its company data or not. Maybe he won't have to transfer it. Or the president may not even know what it is. Maybe he didn't put it there, maybe his kid did and he wouldn't want it on there either.
Its not a matter of voyeurism. Its the PC owner's responsibility to keep it clean. What tech really wants to know the real intimate details of someone's life as told by their PC? Its things you would rather not know in my estimation.
The real people that need to get some ethics are the ones that have this stuff on their work PCs. Why don't you give courses to them.
As for hacking TR to find out who is posting this "outrageous" post, where are your ethics? Sounds like scare tactics to me.
by e_quintieri
I was a contract manager for other contractors for a client. One of my techs was in a middle of a migration for an employee when they discover illicit files transferring files.
I immediately went to the client contact and informed him of what was found. He agreed to speak to the employee about the content on his laptop and to review the company policy with them. There were no ramifications to me or the tech. In fact, he informed the tech that he should be notified any time this occurs.
I will admit I was nervous about going to the client, but do you what convinced me I needed to escalate to the client? I re-read the company's policy over and over. It clearly stated that non-standard, explicit material is not permitted on the company?s system... AND discipline can be up to and including termination.
In this instance we were asked to report this type of behavior. As contractor we had no choice to obey by the client?s wishes. Of course I drafted and email and had them reply has a acceptance of this practice.
by hermit47
by jascc1
by c.caffee
I have doing IT work long before it had the title IT.. And I have seen MORE than I ever wanted to see.. and one went on to the police to handle.
I Also know that today a lot of people in positions of power don't have a clue whats on the machine that he/she is using!
First and foremost, ask the user about the data!
Does it belong to them?
I have seen more than one laptop filled with the son/daughter (yes girls do porn too) pic's and the owner knows nothing of what?s going on. I have seen other people admit to owning the "data".
As to the fact it belongs to the President of the company, would mean NOTHING TO ME. I work with over 25 separate Construction companies, so the group of people involved is wide.
All I have ever had to do with anything I found in question, was ask about what I had found !!
The decision after that is yours.
by zlitocook
by j_khoury
I have been in charge of IT departments for well over 10 years in 2 major bucks companies. If I see contraband, and it may be a violation of law and/or company policy, the HR department would be seriously remiss in duty to frown upon my IT staff or myself from confronting any violating individual. I do scans of our major servers in search of illegal files (MP3, Video, etc.) The resources are the property of the company and I'll be damned if I am going to let this kind of abuse go on.
- Jim
by zlitocook
by hermit47
by premiumtap
How do you know they were illegal?
by premiumtap
by tntechone
Has everyone on this discussion thread forgotten that there are laws in this country to protect workers from being exposed to such things as porn in the course of performing their job? The presence of porn whether CP or not on a computer that you are instructed by a superior to work on in the course of your employment creates a sexually hostile work environment. It doesn't matter whether the computer is a personal or company computer. A company officer instructs an employee to perform a task that the officer would reasonably expect may mean that the employee may see what is on the computer.
Remember that Boeing did fire Harry Stonecipher for having poor judgement by having an affair with another company employee. They were both consenting adults, but the company believed that the affair was an embarassment to the company.
Is it a good idea for the tech to keep his/her mouth shut and let a secretary or other employee perhaps walk into the company officer's office while he is looking at his porn? The officer is not the company, even if he is the president. And people have a legal right to do their job without being exposed to sexual material. That's not being judgemental, that's the law. Society has already made that judgement.
by d.belford
Decide: is there anything illegal, eg kiddieporn and depending on the peculiarities of USA legal systems, anything else that is illegal.
No - then your range of response is governed by Company Policies.
Yes - Your call. If you become involved in handling the information then you assume some responsibility. There has been heaps of good advice on avoiding the issue in other posts
by macghee
by amused...
boring process?? You were snooping, admit it. If you know anything about profile and data migration then you would know there is no reason for you to be scanning the 'owners' files.
Frankly, you should not even be trusted with data unless you are charged with being the moral cop for teh company. Is the Company President aware of your outstanding moral acuity and perception that you can decide what is legal and moral for others and did he or your boss then add that to the job description? Are you an attorney at law? Ready to give a deposition as to why you were going through the Presidents files while you were transferring them rather than just migrating the profile? Are you sure you want that rep in the industry, not even a church would hire you, certainly not a diocese.
You don't have a moral problem, you have a personal one, minding your own business and abusing your authority.
Oh, by the way, I have been transferring systems and profiles for years and I dread it if I am asked to scan for files of a particular nature. So, you and I both know what you were doing, looking for something juicy on the Prez's PC you could use for fun or profit and now sensibilities are insulted. Hurts when a hero is made human, huh.
by shellbot
wow, nice one..I'm even feeling guilty now just reading that kevin620. And i've done nothing wrong :)
tis a fine line, but your right. I usually "don't look" at other peoples things on pc's. helps me sleep at night.
by pcchallenge
by amused...
What I really love are these other posters suggesting "blackmail" as an alternative while discussing legal options.
Seriously, file transfer is just that.
President of the company is also just that.
Want to practice your own morals at the job, become a 'person of the cloth', but if you have no ethics then you have no morals either.
by aurorail
by triadmonkey
I have never heard a bunch of whiners in my life. You're the kind of people that make me sick with your attitudes. First of all, the computer was his, you just transfered the files, thats it, period.. You need to get your head out of your neither region and see some sunlight, How do you know whats legal and illegal ? just by your years of being around? come on... Sounds to me like these other people said, YOU WERE SNOOPING. What gives you the right if it was his own personal computer.. As a private IT consutant I have strict policies on privacy, what I see in the course of my duties are confidential. I would never give up information unless ordered to by a court of law or if I was hired by that company for that specific purpose. as for all you network security champions out there what can I say... you talk about securing the network from " these kinds of files " whos to say he doesn't have a broadband connection at home and is getting this from home or somewhere else, and if there is spyware or a malicious file on it .. shouldnt your severs protections stop it?? Now last of all.. IF and I said IF, this was a company owned laptop then it would be up the the proper policing authority to regulate the material on the laptop,by actively inforcing a policy, suggestions were made about that.Think about it, turn it around and make the boss yourself and someone else is doing your laptop, say you had some pictures of your family and animals and kids.. but your wife/husband just happens to have on some cothing someone else considers offensive. and they turn you in because THEY think its offensive... think abut it..
When did america become the home of the whiners no wonder jobs in our field are going overseas..
by kennethl
I seem to recall using that one once, when an unlicensed version of software appeared on a piece of hardware in my network. I had a Corporate policy giving me the right to remove said software. I did so.
The CFO whose machine this software was living on, didn't seem to understand the situation and had me terminated.
So much for using the policy as protection.
And I lost the lawsuit! The files were deleted, where's the evidence. (He killed my backup tapes as well!)
So what do we do then? Hmmm??
by the witch
by ed.clark
If I take an innocuous file and rename it "Inflatable Nuns", how do you verify content without looking and invading privacy or violating policy. File names alone are not enough. Unless the file names are clearly representing kiddie porn e.g. alt.preteen.erotica and unless you have a policy already in place, let it go. I found images on a win 98 PC years ago, and called the cops. I was deleting files from a cache, and accidentally previewed one. I called the cops. I had to recount my methodology to the investigator and go thru a lot of stuff, only to have the investigator say that there were not enough images, and they were of an OUTDOOR NATURE, and not necessarily kiddie porn by their definition. Then I had to answer to my IT boss. I later found the employees cache of kiddie porn on another PC after he left the company. Nothing but heartbreak for me and no justice for the ex employee.
Be sure in triplicate before you act. A policy of an IT supervisor being the person to notify appropriate authorities provides a layer of reason on your side, places the responsibility to act on a supervisor or manager, and carries more weight with the authorities.
A boot up warning message on company PCs saying what is not allowed by company policy is always a good idea, along with the policy that any PC touched by company IT is to be treated as a company PC will discourage abuse of IT personnel by all but the most ignorant company big-wigs.
Sort by Trending