Discussion Locked

Internet connection sharing & its effect

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I administer 2 LANs both of which have one Internet connection using 1 56k modem for each connection. We run Windows NT on one LAN and Windows 2000 on the other. At times we have 25 to 30 users using the Internet and everyone complains its to slow. A college suggest that it is due to our recent change of ISP. But on further investigation through my ISP I was told that our 56k bandwidth is split and shared between the number of users using the Internet at the time e.g. if we had 30 users accessing the Internet at the same time each user would receive 1.8k bandwidth. Is this true or is my ISP hiding something from me. To me it makes sense but my college disagrees.

Thanks
Nathan

7 replies

by dmiles

Iam not sure what the college knows,but let me know because using ICS with two computers I see their is a slow down in performance when I am surfing the net with both computers.
First the bandwidth us 56K is not getting the maximum amount of baud rate and without any modem optimizers,I am connected at around 45.3,so I would thingk that you would need to see if the ISP would maximize your baud rate to the max. that it can provide,which may be what the college is refering too.

by mel "blazing_saddles" dundee

If you are running a 56k line through a router and your users connect via a switch or a hub to the router, in most cases it will be first come first serve depending on how you have configured your connection
25-30 users over 56k would be slow.
Youprobably need more like a 256K connection. Remember 56k is 56kbit/second and you need to divide by 8 to relate this to say a 1MByte file. That is on a 56kb line you will get a maximum transfer rate of 7kbytes/second taking somerwhere near 150 seconds to download a 1Mfile for one user only. Now if you want to do your calculations for 30 users and what you need
this may give you some idea of the bandwidth capacity required. 256k ddr ( dial on demand ) sounds about right to me but it depends entirely on your usage.

by mckaytech

25 to 30 users on a 56k line is a very heavy load, even if all they are doing is Web browsing. If any of them are doing downloads, it gets even worse.

The available bandwidth will be split among all the users but won't be split evenly. Some traffic is more bursty than others and the router will do it's best to fit everyone's packets into the available bandwidth. Also, remember that a 56k dialup connection does not, and cannot, guarantee any particular speed. Upload speeds will never be more than 33.6k and download speeds will never exceed 52k and may be much worse than that.

What you probably need to do is do some testing using www.dslreports.com or a similar service to see what kind of speeds you're actually getting. If you're not routinely getting total download speeds of 44k+, then you probably need to squawk at the ISP.

paul

This discussion is closed to new replies.