Discussion Locked

Logical and Physical design

0 helpful
12 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Explain the difference between logical and physical design of a network and could you illustrate and example?

12 replies

by Member 26122104

Logical drawings are more of a high-level view of the major design components of a network. i.e. shows Chicago office connecting to Internet and WAN1 and WAN2, NY connecting to Internet and WAN1, LA connecting to WAN2

A physical drawing shows actually physical components and connections. i.e. shows Chicago fastethernet LAN connecting to 2 cisco routers 1 with t1 connecting to ISP router and 512K frame-relay to NY WAN1 router, and 1 with t1 connecting to LA WAN2 router.

HTH

by mshavrov

Sometimes it's close things, but sometimes it is oposite. Let's start with logical design. Sure first you should logically construct oyur network. Define which sites should be interconnected, how it should use IP addresses, which traffic should travel through WAN links, should you split LAN traffic for different group of people. If you use NT, define where will be located Domain Controller, plan Backup Domain Controller for remote sites to provide redundance in case WAN link goes down. Should you use DNS? DHCP? WINS? Firewall? Should you have redundancy? On this stage you may not count all PCs and Servers. You should just define all ways how information flow. Do you expect company growth in next 3-5 years?

Then go to more detailed planning. For example, how many servers do you have? Will it be on the same IP segment? How will you interconnect segments? What is estimated volume of traffic between servers? How many users will be in each location? Will be enough selected WAN bandwidth for calculated traffic?

by mshavrov

Then you should start selection of Network Hardware. Do you have any vendor preferences? Does they have standard hardware which fits to your scheme or you have to order custom-build configuration? Is this specific piece of hardware fits to your productivity requirements? For example, will this LAN switch work if you will use it as backbone or you should buy more powerfull.

At last step you should plan how to interconnect all pieces of hardware. In case you use VLANs you should determin which ports on switch will be used for which groups. Design some "standard rules", for example, LAN Switch "uplink" port is port number 1, and "downlink" - last port. Which Firewall port will go to which segment? Do you mark cables to know, for example, which PC connected to which port?

As you can see it's very related processes and it smoothly flow from one to another. So, start with logical and soon you will not know where you are :-)

Good luck.

by s_pryce

simply put the physical design of the network is what bits are plugged into what and where. The logical design is how the network looks to the systems involved.
For example a physical design is that 12 workstations in two locations are plugged intoa hub in each location. The Hubs are connected to a router/switch which also has a server connected to it. The logical design may be flat, all devices are on the same network, or you may have multiple logical networks segmented as you see fit by a variety of different methods. The logical view is how the devices see the layout, they either think that other devices are on the same network or there is a route to the network via another device.
Hope it helps.

This discussion is closed to new replies.