Discussion Locked

Major Wi-Fi Security Crisis Looming...

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

There's a storm brewing, and although we have only seen the first signs, she's gonna be a whopper! I'm talking about what I call the "Wi-Fi Security Crisis", and if you don't know what it is, better read on...

Q: Would you let a terrorist walk in off the street and call their buddies in Iran or Afganistan using your phone?

Q: Would you allow a pervert to use your Internet connection to download child pornography?

Q: If you are a hotel General Manager, would you knowingly allow a thief to steal the data from a guest's computer?

EVERY DAY, this and much more happens at Wi-Fi hotspots around the world, but nobody seems too concerned about it -- WHY?

Some recent examples:

1. A US Military wardriving team finds an access point installed on the base granting open, unencrypted, unrestricted access to the internal US Military unclassified network. The access point is accessible from a K-Mart parking lot outside the military base.

2. A six-page, full-color article in Russia's "Hacker Magazine" describes in complete, step-by-step detail how to attack hotspots of three Moscow Marriott Hotels operated by MoscomNET.

3. Recent prosecution of a man for posession of child pornography. His defense that "he had an open access point so it must have been someone else" failed, and he's now looking at doing some hard time playing drop-the-soap with the other inmates.

Open, insecure access points aren't the only threat, but they make a great entry point. Just drive around with NetStumbler and see how many access points still have the default D-Link or Linksys SSID and even the default username and password for administrative access and you can have a small sample of the scope of just one of the problems.

Even if the hotspot has reasonable measures to protect unauthorized users from accessing the Internet, few operators bother protecting legitimate users from intra-site attacks. Once the attacker can associate with an access point -- any access point -- they can begin port-scanning and attacking any users associated with the same access point, and most often, users associated with any access point in the entire hotspot -- all without needing any connectivity through the gateway.

Insecure, unpatched client computers are juicy targets for data thieves, or anyone wishing to implant key loggers, root kits or any other malware. Such computers are all too easily found with simple, freely downloadable scanning and analysis tools. On the Internet, stolen identities are bought and sold like so much coffee.

Interestingly enough, when interviewing one of the major European authentication providers in preparation for writing another article, when asked what his company was doing about security, his response was, "We don't worry much about it, the only hackers are in Russia..."

For operators with these attitudes, the wake-up call may be coming sooner than they think. Just go to Google Video and search for Wi-Fi, war driving or wireless hacking and you will find videos with step-by-step demonstrations on exactly how to do it and what tools to use.

Hotels represent a unique problem. Most hotel IT Managers are ill equipped to understand let alone respond to the dangers wireless networks present. If the hotel is relying on a third-party operator to run their hotspot, the hotel IT Manager won't have access or control of that network and couldn't apply additional security even if they wanted to.

This is the case in Moscow where the three Marriott hotels rely on third-party operator MoscomNET to operate their hotspots. What baffles me is why virtually nothing has been done to secure the network since August 2006, when the Hacker Magazine article was published? To this very day, from the hacker's perspective, nothing has changed and the same vulnerabilities are still wide open.

One major flaw in the Marriott/MoscomNET Wi-Fi system is that they are still using MAC-address-based authentication. Such systems are wonderful for 'ease-of-use' but a total disaster with regards to security. (MAC addresses are the simplest thing in the world to harvest and spoof.)

For example, at the Moscow Marriott Aurora hotel, I borrowed a Wi-Fi adapter for my notebook computer, plugged it in and had instant, free access to the WiFi network. How did that happen? Very simple, the guest who borrowed the adapter before me returned it while time still remained on his account. The MAC address from the adapter automatically authenticated me to the system -- no other credentials required.

And what if I did something evil, such as setting up a P2P server pirating music? As I had never puchased an account, the previous user of the account would receive the blame. As for attackers just capturing MAC addresses out of the air and spoofed them -- they are completely untracable and can do whatever they want with complete impunity.

Who can be held responsible and accountable? Hotel General Managers? Hotspot operators? IT Managers? Authentication and roaming partners? There is plenty of blame to go around, but nobody wants to take responsibility or action.

As another example, I recently offered to give a free hotspot security analysis, seminar and consultation to six of the five-star hotels in the city of St. Petersburg Russia. I contacted the General Managers directly, and got not a single reply to take me up on the offer. This tells me loud and clear that hotel GMs either don't understand that there is a problem or will not admit it. It seems the safety and security of the guest's computer or any other security matters are of no concern.

Is the problem a technical one? Not at all! Every commercial-grade access point is easily secured with WPA or WPA-2. (Forget about WEP.) Newer commercial access points allow simultaneous dual-mode operation -- where the user can choose to associate insecurely or securely. This simple measure could reduce the risk of wireless eavesdropping to near zero. Only clients whose computers were incapable of operating in the secure mode would remain vulnerable.

So why don't hotspot operators implement even minimal security precautions? I suspect it could be:

1. Many WiFi operators simply lack the knowledge, skills and experience to properly secure and monitor their networks.

Let's face it, setting up a couple of access points to share an Internet connection isn't rocket science -- but properly securing and managing even a small system does require knowledge, skills and experience well beyond the capability of the local 'computer guy'.

2. Wi-Fi hotspot operators who are more concerned about profit than security.

Secure systems ARE harder to manage and harder to use -- which is another reason commercial operators are less likely to implement even the most basic of security measures. Real security would mean implementing encryption all the way from the client to the Gateway, and secure authentication -- likely implemented through a Public Key Infrastructure and digital certificates.

Of course I realize that some client systems can not support certain security mechanisms, but at least give the client the option of borrowing supporting equipment and/or notifying them of the potential hazards they could be exposed to.

What do YOU think? I invite you to share your practical experiences on this discussion! (Just no operating system or browser zealot arguments please!)

4 replies

by dumphrey

are dead on in the subject of a wireless storm hitting us soon. I live in a smallish town, but even here my neighbors had unencrypted wireless. I was receiving the signal from 3 houses away, it was weak, but usable. At work, we have wireless for our confrence room. I mandated WPA, but I also require authentication through RADIUS. For traveling sales people, I just give them a guest account and the WPA password for the week. This is still risky, but the effect is minimized compared to just WPA. At home, I have it locked down even tighter by addind in a PKI certificate exchange with the RADIUS server on top of just a password authentication.

by fred123456

I don't see this as big an issue as your making it. Its basically a learning curve and you reap what you sow.

If you go and buy a wireless switch and you don't secure it because you fail to read the instructions or understand the ramifications then its your own fault.

If I were to go out and buy a gun and then shoot my neighbor. I would end up arrested and on trial. Would my defense be, I'm sorry I didn't read the instructions? I didn't know I could kill somebody with it?

If you ever read the instructions in a WAP box you would notice they have pretty clear warnings as to the security issues involved.

If a company leaves themselves open to liablities like you stated, then its their own fault.

by marty r. milette

Home users are primarly facing the problems caused by people using their network for illegal purposes.

Here is a story from Canada: "Wireless security for home networks is in the spotlight following an unusual arrest in Canada, where a man stands accused of downloading child pornography over a hijacked Wi-Fi connection."...

Or in the USA, "Nicholas Tombros admitted driving around Venice, Calif., last year, searching for unprotected hot spots--an activity called "wardriving"--and exploiting them to distribute unsolicited e-mail that advertised pornographic Web sites." -- These are just to very recent examples.

When authorities search for criminal activity on the Internet -- where does the trail end? At the IP Address of the ISP's customer. Period.

If someone does their dirty work through an open or weakly secured (WEP) access point -- all they need do is forge their MAC address (maybe even using one of YOURS), and they become totally untracable and can make it look like it was YOU.

Most home customers sign a contract with their service provider that has terms such as you shall not share the connection with people outside your family, and/or you shall not use the connection for SPAM or other illegal activities -- if you do, your service may be terminated.

With the RIAA prosecuting people as fast as spammers can send out SPAM, with the IP Address often being sufficient proof in court to get a search order, confiscate your computers and prosecute you -- still think it is a reasonable risk to take?

Commercial operators like MoscomNET SHOULD KNOW BETTER, but by leaving access points 'open' (no encryption or authentication) and using MAC-address-based authentication -- they may as well hang a sign out that says "Hackers Welcome!".

In a commercial environment the stakes are even higher. There is usually a nice, fast Internet connection (2mb to 100mb are typical).

This invites even more illegal activity -- such as downloading/file-sharing (most often pirated or illegal materials) and sending SPAM.

In the case of a hotel hotspot, the hotel's mail server may end up on RBL blacklist because the hotel often uses the same Internet connection as the public Wi-Fi system.

I haven't even touched the risks faced by other legitimate customers using the Wi-Fi network whose PCs are not 100% patched and updated or who have no firewall or security whatsoever.

A Hotel IT friend of mine told me last year about a company executive visiting a hotel who had all the data stolen from his computer. What kind of data do you think the CEO of a company would have that could be valuable to his competitors? A LOT!

Many people poo-poo the problem and/or pretend it doesn't exist. Well, it DOES exist, and if you (or anyone else who asks) sends me their email address, I will happily send the 6-page Hacker Magazine article.

You may not be able to read Russian, but you should be able to understand the step-by-step instructions saying what you need to conduct the attack. (Including screen shots, html code, MAC addresses, SSIDs and a lot more.) If anyone wants it, my address is marty .at. milette.com (replace .at. with @)

by brobin

I'm not a Wi-Fi guru, but I know several people who are (or claim to be). I'll pass this on.

This discussion is closed to new replies.