Discussion Locked

Moderate and radical Muslims -- are they very different?

0 helpful
132 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have repeatedly asserted here and elsewhere that the Muslim extremists do NOT represent true Islam. However the opinion poll given here suggests that I may be quite wrong.

[i]Based on a new Gallup World Poll of more than 9,000 interviews in nine Muslim countries, we find that Muslim radicals have more in common with their moderate brethren than is often assumed. If the West wants to reach the extremists, and empower the moderate Muslim majority, it must first recognize who it?s up against.[/i]

Hence this poll which suggests that the extremists are difficult to identify as separate from the moderates because in many areas they appear to be the opposite of what we may have assumed, e.g. impoverished uneducated people who are brainwashed into hating the West and especially the USA.

My apologies for assuming that the intent of the post would be readily recognised.

[b]Note:[/b]

[i]Respondents who said 9/11 was unjustified (1 or 2 on a 5-point scale, where 1 is totally unjustified and 5 is completely justified) are classified as moderates. Respondents who said 9/11 was justified (4 or 5 on the same scale) are classified as radicals. The data for this poll were obtained during 2005-06 from Bangladesh, Egypt, Indonesia, Iran, Jordan, Lebanon, Morocco, Turkey, and Saudi Arabia. Approximately 1,000 in-home interviews were conducted in each country. The sampling mix of urban and rural areas is the statistical equivalent of surveying each nation?s adult population, with a statistical sampling error rate of +/- 3 percent.]/i]

http://www.foreignpolicy.com/story/cms.php?story_id=3637&page=0

132 replies

by rob mekel

You ask a question in the title, than you answer to this question in your posting.
Give insight on where your info came from.

Now what is the point to your posting other then letting us know that there is an Article on the subject(title).

Then you go on on "If the West wants to reach the extremists, and wants to empower the moderate Muslim majority, it must first recognize who it's up against.
Isn't this statement always the case?
So more in general: If you want "something" you must know who(or what) you are up against!

My question is: What's new in your posting?

Rob

ps Tnx for the link :)
Reading the article I get the meaning on what you try to say in your posting and where you would like to go with your posting. Unfortunatly you ain't getting there because you don't say it (type it). Which is a pity.

by jardinier

and I would have thought it would be obvious is that persons like myself who have repeatedly declared that the extremists are a small minority who DO NOT represent true Islam, are quite likely WRONG, whereas persons who have repeatedly asked why the moderates do not vocally dissociate from the extremists are RIGHT.

I will edit my post.

by rob mekel

Don't edited it but add what you're point was about. In that way it stays clear on all the postings made before the edit. :)
That is, if it is possible.

Rob

ps As you say "... that persons like myself who have repeatedly declared ..." not all of us have read all the postings made on this subject. There for we can't all know who has what point of view on the subject.
[i]edited for the ps[/i]

by f4a6pilot

Sorry Julian, You are a better man than Sandy, Absolutely, or others whom I have clashed about issues. You admit your error.

You are to be commended for your repentance.

I am pretty hard headed about things too, but will admit my faults when I perceive them.

by oz_media

Jules, I think that, as in so many similar issues, the terms are in need of definition.

Representing true Islam?

now lets try and compare to a western issue: Christian crusaders; in such tims, I think that even those who were not REALLY practicing Christians, would actually defend the Christian crusade against attack form another religion.

It's not really that good of an example but there is a point; perhaps people that aren't RADICAL Islamists are compelled to support Islam extremists when it comes to defending them against attacks by what they see as Christian extremists (crusaders in their eye perhaps).

While these people would not normally associate themselves with these extremists in every day life, under attack, they may just find such support.

I don't like polls, they are more often than not, completely misconstued with some tiny outcome being overexaggerated to mean what it never did.

How questions are asked, samples are taken, and especially the leading questions prior to that key point will all control and steer an outcome; it's marketing 101.

If the leading questions FELT like anti-Islamic pokes, if the leading quetions were to downgrade the extremists, they can actually create more defensive support than actually exists in reality.

by tony hopkinson

made them.
This is a very iffy poll to base a policy on.

Poll americans and ask them whether guantanamo bay is justified. Given you'd probably get a pretty big yes, does tha mean they don't believe in freedom and justice?

Yet again a judgement of a completely foreign culture by western standards. I don't think 9/11 was justifiable either, but I'm a westerner as well.

Word the question correctly get the answer you want, is what this poll is.

by jdclyde

This one brings up the main point.

Polls are not a valid tool to base policy on.

Even if the wording is completely neutral, if it is an orally taken poll, the way someone ASKS the questions can lead to the answer desired.

Also, never forget our lessons on cause and effect. Just because "A" happened at a certain time, does not mean "B" caused it.

As for the general idea behind the poll, it is probably closer to the truth for many to want to accept, as many just too afraid of what that would really mean.

by rob mekel

opinion of you I do fully agree upon. :)

That is except the title.
As I do think that there are more posts that hit the spot.
( https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=205126&messageID=2130808 )

As with statistics, polls do tend to be manipulated by the statisticus/interviewer.

And as we all know: who is better in turning and twisting a policy then politicians. They can even turn negative polls in to a positive outcome.

Even after an election (Netherlands on last november 22) whom they have lost, heavely (down by 20%), some politicians claim they must be in government ?:|
The reason is: They are in the middle (in the political field) between (middle)conservative and left. The sad thing is that it probably will happen. :( But that is something that can get corrected at the next elections. :)

Rob

[i]edited for the (middle) part as there is a far right liberal party being conservative aswell. Yeah, politics in the Netherlands has a very strange land_scape[/i]

by jamesrl

I interned at a polling company in one of my university work terms.

There are ways to improve the accuracy of the data gathered, if the organization cares to implement them. Some large organizations do not chose to take the extra steps though.

Things that can affect the outcome of the results:

1) The wording of the question - it can be loaded to influence a result. If you ask : Are you fed up with the performance of the economy , you will get a different result than if you ask, "Are you satisfied with ther performance of the economy".

2) The order of the questions:
If I know that most Americans are unhappy with Bush about the war in Iraq, but not as dissatisfied with the economy, I can load the question by arranging to ask the question about the war directly before the question on Bush. The proper way to do this is to ask the more general question first, then ask the more specific policy questions. The Best practise is to ask an open ended question first - "What is the most important issue facing the country today", before asking other questions.

3) How the question is asked.
Yes the interviewers can bias the question through tone of voice. Good organizations monitor calls and coach their interviewers if there is bias. I had someone fired because he showed a bias through his tone of voice against one political party, and continued to do so even after to coaching. BTW I had all his interviews thrown out.

4) The order in which the options are presented:
In an ideal world if there are a/b/c answers the order in which those answers are presented should be rotated to ensure that someone isn't giving more weight to the first answer they hear.

In terms of polling, its also good to know that a poll is a snapshot of opinion at a given point in time, and opinion can change in a day, as news stories come out. It is more informative to look at how opinions change over the course of time and consider the context, than to focus on one poll.

James

by delbertpgh

I'm suspicious of the premises underlying this poll. The idea that taking temperatures about 9/11 gives you an authoritative index to radicalism doesn't hold water.

If some third-world magazine decides it wants to poll Americans to find out how they feel on imperialism, and take as the measure "On a scale of 1 to 5, how much do you think the invasion of Iraq was justified?", and count an answer of 5 as radical, bloody-fanged imperialism. You, JD, might disagree, despite the paper's editors, readers, and bloggers all feeling that this was a dead reliable measure.

Most of the developing world, and especially the Muslim world, feels it's under some kind of attack, or pressure, or suppression by the big western countries. It colors the answer.

Try this: do you believe in torture as a standard treatment for prisoners? No. What about leaning some guy back on a board and filling his nose up with water, if he's a radical Muslim who's got information about terrorist plans or threats to our troops? From what I know of you, probably you would say yes. But what if you have a whole jail full of guys, you can't tell one from the other, and you're sure that some have got real info, and a lot of others are covering up for the bad ones? Knowing you, I'd guess you'd probably say, "OK, fill 'em up!"

Plus, your comment, "it is probably closer to the truth for many to want to accept, as many just too afraid of what that would really mean", leads me to suspect you figure it's time to stop thinking and call all Islamic faith the enemy, and settle down to fighting.

by jardinier

So we live in an imperfect world, that's what.

I agree that this particular poll should have included multiple questions so that the answer to one question would counterbalance the answer to another.

Thus it would be like a personality test for example. There are a number of multiple choice questions that counterbalance each other giving the "mean" result.

As for polls in general, would you rather have imperfect or biased polls than have no polls at all?

As of yesterday, all positions in the Federal Labor Government in Australia have been declared open and on Monday there will be a contest for the positions of leader and deputy leader, as well as all the front bench positions.

I would not KNOW, but I strongly SUSPECT that the response from the public to a poll about leadership of the Federal Labor Party which showed a strong desire for a specific change of leadership, may quite likely (make that more than likely) have given the contenders the encouragement to contest the leadership.

The present leader is Kim Beazley and the deputy leader is Jenny Macklin.

The contenders are Kevin Rudd for leader and Julia Gillard for deputy leader. This will be a very important vote for Australia and Australians because, added to other factors, this change of leadership would almost certainly end the long reign of the far right wing PM John Howard at the elections to be held towards the end of next year.

by jardinier

Because the discussion has just started, this will save other people asking what is the point of my post.

Julian

by jardinier

I would have to be an ostrich if I were not prepared to reassess my opinion.

This is a recent statement by the Roman Catholic Archbishop of Sydney who is a very level-headed guy.

AUSTRALIA'S most influential Catholic has said the Koran is riddled with "invocations to violence" and the central challenge of Islam lies in the struggle between moderate and extremist forces as the faith spreads into a "childless Europe."

The Archbishop of Sydney, Cardinal George Pell, said reading the Koran, the sacred text of Islam, was vital "because the challenge of Islam will be with us for the remainder of our lives - at least."

But in a speech to US Catholic business leaders, Dr Pell said Western democracy was also suffering a crisis of confidence as evidenced by the decline in fertility rates.

Dr Pell said the September 11 terrorist attacks had been his personal wake-up call to understand Islam better. He had tried to reconcile claims that Islam was a faith of peace with those that suggested the Koran legitimised the killings of non-Muslims. While there was room for optimism in fruitful dialogue between faiths and the common human desire for peace, a pessimistic response began "with the Koran itself."

Errors of facts, inconsistencies, anachronisms and other defects were not unknown to scholars but difficult for Muslims to debate openly, he said. "In my own reading of the Koran, I began to note down invocations to violence. There are so many of them, however, that I abandoned this exercise after 50 or 60 or 70 pages."

Last year, Dr Pell courted controversy when he drew a link between Islam and communism. His speech on Islam and Western democracies was delivered in Florida on February 4 but only appeared on the archdiocese's website on Wednesday.

Dr Pell said every nation and every religion, including Catholicism, had "crimes in their histories". In the same way, Islam could not airbrush its "shadows." Claims of Muslim tolerance of Christian and Jewish minorities were largely mythical and he wondered about the possibility of theological development in Islam when the Koran was said to come directly from God.

"Considered strictly on its own terms, Islam is not a tolerant religion and its capacity for far-reaching renovation is severely limited," he said. However, like Christianity, Islam was a living religion and the existence of moderate Islam in Indonesia was proof of the softening impact of human intervention.

Democracy and moderation did not always go hand in hand and an "anorexic vision of democracy and the human person was no match for Islam", he said.

by drowningnotwaving

. . . brushes over much of his own church's past by admitting they had 'crimes in their history'.

What he doesn't acknowledge is that a review of some particular paragraphs in the Old Testament, as well as commentaries upon their application down through the years by various Popes, Kings and Cardinals, would make equally vile reading.

One thing that Pell did say is that the reaction of many Islamic people (and especially their leaders) to criticism is immediately intolerant and often violent (burn, kill or bash the critic). That's all too evident in the facts.

I don't know what the answer is, but I struggle to see that the criticism of the religious book by a leader of another religion is actually going to get us on the path to less people wanting to kill the other.

I think the Pope's visit to Turkey is much more on the path of doing something to build bridges.

by jardinier

Yes of course there is a lot of violence in the Old Testament, as there is also in the history of the Roman Catholic Church.

However we are not comparing the OT and the RC Church with the Koran. We are comparing Christianity and Islam in the 21st century.

We are talking about Christianity as practised today, which derives mostly from the New Testament, and Islam today which still derives only from the Koran.

by onbliss

... the difference in potential reactions or outlook between the moderates and radicals. I know one of the questions was about reduced interference. But we should hear out the ideas for solutions from both the sides.

Do we know how open the moderates are for reforms within their religion? Attending a religious service is not a sound measurement. It implies that by just being religious/traditional a person can resort to radicalism.

So I don't think you are wrong yet.

by drowningnotwaving

Are you saying that 'radical Muslims' are more reasonable than we may have been lead to beleive? Therefore perhaps a different approach may have some justification or value?

Does it come as a surprise that the 'radical' Muslim actually thinks and dwells upon more than how to kill lots of other people all the time?

If you were to take the concept of the survey and apply it to other religious or ethic groups, as has been discussed, do you really think the results would be dissimilar (in that the extremist and moderate view of the world wouldn't be all that different)?

Are you saying that 'moderates' are actually very similar to extremists and therefore there is a danger in dealing with them in any rational sense?

I'm finding it difficult to see the objective of the discussion other than to lump all Muslim people in the 'too hard' bucket and class them all as the (potential) enemy.

Please help! What am I missing?

by jardinier

is that [b]I may have been wrong[/b] in assuming there was a vast difference between the minority radical Muslims and the majority moderate Muslims.

I have posted a poll which indicates [b]I may have been wrong.[/b]

What you infer from the poll is up to you.

[i]If you were to take the concept of the survey and apply it to other religious or ethic groups, as has been discussed, do you really think the results would be dissimilar (in that the extremist and moderate view of the world wouldn't be all that different)?[/i]

Can you provide some examples of Christian, Hindu or Buddhist suicide bombers? I am pretty sure there are NO exhortations to kill either believers or non-believers in Buddhism or Hinduism.

No doubt [u]onbliss[/u] will correct me if I have made an incorrct assumption about Hinduism.

Interestingly however is the almost parallel teaching in the Koran as in the Bible with regard to [b]believers[/b] and [b]unbelievers.[/b] This is not at all surprising as Judaism, Islam and Chrisianity all sprang from the one source initially.

http://www.hti.umich.edu/k/koran

by drowningnotwaving

. . . but I am sure that certain folks have used both Christianity and Hinduism to justify their radical and deadly actions.

The former so many times it would be impossible to count, from the Crusades, through the Inquisitions through to the cold-blooded murder of doctors who save women's lives.

The latter, if nothing else through horrid misappropriation of the caste system and countless murders in that cause. I also guess that a student of Indian and Hindu history would know of many more.

Buddhism has certainly had its share of radicals although they seemingly tend to hurt themselves rather than others. But I am reasonably confident that a trace of history would again show at least a small group of radical buddhist believers/supporters turning to (what we now group under the heading of) terrorist activities to fight the hordes who have taken over their lands, temples and livelihoods.

But still Jardinier what would be your conclusion from the survey? The fact that you personally have learnt something is good but how would you now apply that?

What would you suggest as a possible course of action with the aim of easing the ongoing danger of terrorism?

Is it good news that the radicals also think sensibly about what is going on, or is it bad news that the moderates are often of the same opinion, or doesn't it actually make a difference?

Or, as (I think) Tony H said, is this another example of us trying to apply standard western thinking to a group of people that have a different manner of thought?

by delbertpgh

Christian suicide bombers? Gavrilo Princip, and the other five guy who with him attempted to assassinate Archduke Ferdinand in 1914, and thereby brought on the First World War. They all lined up along the parade route and planned to throw grenades or homemade bombs into the car, or in Princip's case, shoot with a pistol. They all carried cyanide. Some of them took it, too. However, the dose was bad, and they immediately vomited it up, landing them alive and in jail.

Those are suicide killers, my friend. Christian boys.

Princip, and the rest of the bombers but one, failed to carry out their plan for the stupidest screwups. The bombs didn't work, or they couldn't get close enough because of the crowds. Princip went off to a distant cafe, completely despondent, sure he would be arrested and executed, to sit and cry over a cup of coffee. Looking out the cafe window, he sees a car drive by, and it looks amazingly like the Archduke and his wife, who have gone off on a side trip... with no security... down a deadend street. And looking out the window again, he sees the Archduke's car again come into view, backing veeerrrryyy ssslllooowwwllyy up the narrow street, because it couldn't make the turn at the end. So Princip put down his coffee, walked slowly out the front door, and plugged the two of them, who just couldn't seem to avoid their fate.

It's such an improbable story, you might think that the divine hand was guiding them all.

by john.a.wills

It is possible to believe both that the U.S. is so sinful that it deserved the terrible tower-toppling and that the toppling itself was sinful. We might - or rather, Gallup might - distinguish the two questions and see how the radicalism categories came out then.

by drowningnotwaving

I take your point and I agree I was being somewhat broad-brushed in my criticism of Pell.

Unfortunately I think that there is a substantial real power base of the Christian right who seem to have taken the "eye for an eye" with a gusto.

And they are supported by an almost incomprehensively large financial power base whose vested interest is in running a war, not in peace.

And that is seen in the "punishment fits the crime" credo of many of these people.

It's also seen in the manifest loss of freedoms that most western peoples have now experienced in the name of fighting the faceless enemy.

I personally think that the New Testament and the teachings of Christ have very little part to play in the thought and decision processes of our current leaders.

The reality seems to be very much Old Testament thinking to me.

Can you really imagine (for example in the USA or in Australia) what would happen to the first politician - sorry, I mean one that is in real power and actually counted - that said to turn the other cheek? Or the "do unto others" bit?

by jardinier

I have repeatedly suggested in these forums that the Christian right in America are potentially far more dangerous than the Muslims. I have a lot of interaction with some of these people at Christian forum websites.

They could certainly teach the Muslims a thing or two about hatred and bigotry.

Close to 50 per cent of Americans describe themselves as "born again Christians." To me this is scary because as you have stated:

[i]"they are supported by an almost incomprehensively large financial power base whose vested interest is in running a war, not in peace."[/i]

Of the ones with whom I exchange views, a very high proportion believe firmly that the end times are near -- like within a few years -- and that Armageddon will be initiated with a war between Christians and Muslims.

As I like to say: "At least the Muslim terrorists have the decency to blow themselves up."

As for "eye for an eye" I am quite shocked by the posts made by some Christians in a discussion with a guy who is in love with married woman.

Many of the males have said proudly that they would do serious physical harm to anyone who tried to encroach on the territory of another man's wife. One even mentioned that he carried a 45 hand gun.

I posted several verses of Scripture which specifically prohibit revenge, but my post was ignored and the men -- encouraged by the women -- continued to boast about what harm they would do to any man who took an interest in a married woman.

by jardinier

For a start this remark of yours does not relate to the discussion:

[i]"But I am reasonably confident that a trace of history would again show at least a small group of radical buddhist believers/supporters turning to (what we now group under the heading of) terrorist activities to fight the hordes who have taken over their lands, temples and livelihoods."[/i]

Naturally everyone would and should defend their own property.

Colin has told the story about the invasion of the Shaolin Temple by Maoists. Not a single Maoist servived.

Now to your question: how would I apply what I have learnt? For a start I will study the Koran. I will be less skeptical when persons tar all Muslims with the same brush.

My "problem" is that the Muslims with whom I have regular contact are moderates from the Indian sub-continent -- Pakistan, India and Bangladesh. They are mostly in Australia on student visas. When they tell me that Islam is practised as a peaceful religion in their homelands, who am I to argue with them?

When I ask them why they don't publically dissociate from the extremists, their answer is: "Why should we? Surely it is obvious that the terrorists are not practising true Islam."

by drowningnotwaving

Look, the reason I wrote it, and why it has relevance is this.

Every religion or creed gives rise to a radical element.

In my opinion, that element uses their religion or creed to justify their actions, most importantly when their own self-interest is threatened.

Here's my opinion: It's not necessarily the actual religion or creed itself that says this, nor is it necessarily the belief of the great majority of followers.

Here's my next opinion: In the mind of the radical, they are perfectly justified and depending upon the situation or religion they think that they are also promised the path of eternal glory by doing so.

And here's another opinion: from the outside, we perceive their actions as either freedom fighter or terrorist. Their actions may or may not actually be significantly different whatsoever (they all usually involve death to some extent), and their goal is almost uniformly to return to a status of their own self-interest.

To use your turn of phrase (and one I'd use myself): "Naturally everyone would and should defend their own property".

I think a small and logical expansion of the word "property" to include all aspects of self-interest is a reasonable extrapolation, for the purposes of this chat. But that's just me.

(An example? Your example on the Shaolin temple was an excellent case of where most reasonable people would probably feel that the actions of the freedom fighters were justified. Is it too much of a stretch to see Al Qaeda's position of the removal of the US armed forces base from Saudi Arabia as a more modern parallel to a similar situation?).

I was very worried when you started this thread that it would be another "radical muslims - they're animals / savages" story.

But now I think maybe we are very close in thought: Until we actually understand what aspect of the self-interest of the other party is (or is perceived to be) under threat, we have no chance whatsoever of resolving the situation and getting a semblance of peace.

I think that a very safe generalisation is that the great majority of "moderates" (which I take to including boring old farts like myself) want to reduce war, reduce the threat of terrorism and violence, and live a reasonably normal life to the extent that their surroundings let them.

I am sure this is as true for the muslim population of the middle east, as it is for the jewish population of Israel, as it is for the christian population of Lebanon, as it is for the catholic population of Ireland.

I think the first steps are to a) stop spreading the b*llshit that the entire world threat is based upon Islam, because clearly other religions and creeds are also taking part (the sole purpose of such cr*p is to incite hatred and continue the bloodshed, not to solve any situation); and b) stop giving the radical elements easy fuel for their fire, and thus increasing their sympathy/support from their moderate base.

(And I am fairly certain that calling our current terrorist crisis the fault of Islamic belief (or like pointing out the bad lines of the Koran) will, over time, piss more moderates off and cause more problems than they purport to solve).

Once the larger elements of their anger are taken away, the radical's support from the moderates also reduces and thus the overall threat decreases. (Not down to zero, but decreased).

Evidence of this? The IRA, having been now in a position for some time where dialogue can actually replace guns, has lost much of its traditional financial support. Where did that come from? Oh, the USA. But I guess that is the 'freedom fighter v. terrorist' thing again. Remember, it's only 12 years ago that they rocket-attacked Heathrow and Downing Street, just to flex their muscle.

If, in 12 years, we could get to a realistic position where the current threat of terrorism and violence has been reduced in anywhere near a proportional manner, I'd say that would be a 'result'.

{Oh and Onbliss - don't get me wrong - I wasn't pointing out flaws in Hinduism at all. Just saying that it has it's share of radicals that use it in the name of killing. References - go to google, type in "Hindu Caste Death". But you can also type in "Australian Aboriginal Death" or "Maori British Treaty Death" or variants thereof. Every society had and often still has it's ugly people using good things to justify bad things}.

by deepsand

Religion has always been for many a tool by which to manipulate others.

Accordingly, just as culture molds those who would so use religion, so too do they mold religion to fit their aims.

by deepsand

Those Muslims with which I have had and do have contact with maintain that the terrorists' brand of Islam is a deviant perversion.

by onbliss

...I know people who hold extreme Hindu thoughts, who are of the view that Christianity and Islam are bent on the destructing other religions of the world; and hence feel it is their right to counter-attack.

Can you tell me what you mean by "countless murders" because of the caste system? References, please.

The word "moderate" has to be understood in the context of culture and religion.

by deepsand

Take a stand, present a cogent argument based on pertinent facts, and let us be the judge of how well you concede when bested.

by f4a6pilot

I have seen little or no repentance from Muslim leaders, or the general muslim populations in the Mid-East. I did see dancing in the streets after the attack. Generally, they have shown no real remorse.

The Mulim extremists have not turned. They are still out to kill those of us who will not become Muslim. Israel, and the US are their stated desired targets.

by onbliss

I don't think there are lots of religions that in some way or form condone killing or getting killed. Religious sanctions can be used to drive up the frenzy.
Ofcourse people from all religions commit suicide, I don't think many do it for the sake of religion. Some do it because of honor, some are brain-washed by their non-religious "cause" and some do it because they think they have no other alternative.

by jdclyde

I DO support things such as sleep deprivation and humiliation, but have NEVER supported the physical infliction of pain and suffering. (turning on the air conditioning again, I do not consider pain and suffering. yes, they should be uncomfortable at every second of the time they are being interigated)

Have I ever said that all islamics are a threat to the world? Again, no. (although it seems this discussion is saying exactly that). I am saying there are enough people in the middle east in positions of power that control ALL information fed to the citizens and will continue generations of brainwashing to make them think that we are the threat.

There IS a huge global threat to all non-muslims, but it is not from every muslim.

The world has been under attack from the radicals for decades now, but the mindless morons running the countries have refused to do more than a police action to arrest the people caught instead of holding everyone that supports and trains the groups as responsible as the groups are.

Syria and Iran are the biggest threats to life on Earth, not the US.

by onbliss

Both Syria and Iran have rich & hoary history. National prestige and diplomacy can be tapped to bring them back to mainstream world. I think that is what the people of those countries would want. There are bad people ruling them, agreed. But if only the mainstream world would like to talk to them..... Isolation is just going to push the sane people deeper into the radicals hands. With 2.2+ billion people in the S.E.Asia, globalisation etc. isolation is not going to work all the time.

Iran wants to be regional power and is probably going to attempt to become one we want it or not. Just better to make friends.

by hal 9000

Doing the same thing to the Muslims very recently in Northern Europe and it was NATO who stood back watching till mass genocide had occurred.

That is that the Christan's slaughtered many of the Muslims for no better reason than they where not Christian. The Christians there are still protecting those responsible who have been named for [b]Crimes Against Humanity[/b] and are still being looked for to be punished for their crimes. Seems that the [b]Good Christians[/b] of this area don't quite hold with the idea that they did anything wrong and are continuing to protect these people from the ramifications that they should face.

If it's good enough for one religion to do why should the Muslims who continue to hide these people do any differently?

Col

by jdclyde

so no, I do not believe in polls or the people that base their actions on them.

They are tools used to manipulate the public by saying MOST people think this way, and it leads the weak minded and the uninformed that are too stupid and lazy to educate themselves about the topics at hand.

As for the labor party and such, I admit my ignorance of that political system, and the positions of the various parties, so refrain from comment on them.

I DO know enough about global politics that even labels such as right wing really mean little outside of the current system as it is like comparing Celsius to Fahrenheit. Same numbers, but from a different scale.

by jardinier

just out of curiosity, but ignore what they say?

If you disbelieve in them so strongly, then I could not imagine that you would bother to read them.

Have you ever read a poll that has influenced your opinion in any way?

I distrust people who make ABSOLUTE statements about anything at all.

[i]I do not believe in polls or the people that base their actions on them. They are tools used to manipulate the public.[/i]

Perhaps you are referring to a particular type of poll, but I cannot accept a blanket statement that ALL polls are of the nature and purpose which you describe.

The particular poll held last week in Australia would I think totally contradict your assertion about polls. Was its aim to manipulate the public? I can see no evidence of this.

The poll was taken by The Australian newspaper which is owned by Rupert Murdoch who I think we can loosely categorise as right wing. The Howard Government which controls both houses of Parliament recently introduced new media laws that favour monopoly. Surely Mr Murdoch likes this law and he has purchased 7.5 per cent of Fairfax although he assures it is not a takeover move.

Consider the following:

[i]The move was immediately interpreted as News taking a "blocking" stake to ensure other companies attempting to mount a takeover attempt on Fairfax, would have to negotiate with News. Fairfax is considered a takeover target because it has an "open" share register, rather than one dominant proprietor.[/i]

As owner of the Australian newspaper, and in view of the relaxed laws of media ownership, it could hardly be seen to be in Murdoch's interest to condone a poll which would benefit the Labor Party and consequently be a threat to the entrenched Howard government.

Maybe later I will think of some examples of polls which do not set out to manipulate people.

by jardinier

Today (Monday) Kevin Rudd took the leadership of the Federal Parliamentary Labor Party from Kim Beazley by 49 votes to 39.

Julia Gillard was elected unopposed as deputy leader.

I predict that John Winston Howard who has won four successive elections and was prepared to stand against Beazley at next year's election, will announce some time early next year that he has decided to retire from politics (or stand down as leader of the conservative coalition) leaving the position vacant for Peter Costello.

John Howard is a very shrewd politician and I cannot imagine that he would risk losing face by losing the next election.

by jdclyde

How often will people that value the polls decide to not vote based on having already lost in the polls?

How many sheeple will show up to vote for the sure win because they want to be a part of the winning team?

How many sheeple that are completely ignorant of the issues, votes for the "wining team"?

Sorry, but my personal opinion is that polls do more damage to the world than they will ever do good. You can take a poll of that of course...... :D

by tonythetiger

with polls is the same problem we have with the media: Selective presentation. If the sanctioner of a poll doesn't like what the results show, they can redo the questions until they get the result they want to present, and we'll never hear about the unused ones.

by jardinier

that you personally AVOID reading polls? I asked jd if he read polls even just out of curiosity, but he did not answer the question.

Do you choose to remain totally ignorant of what is happening in the world because the media is biased?

by jamesrl

A couple of problems with that....

A reputable company would not do that. Gallup or any other professional firm will not let the client write the questions, they write them and then show the client. Gallup and any other "professional" firm would refuse to rerun unless it was clear that the question was ambiguous or confusing. Sadly there are some less than professional firms, but thats true in many professions.

Secondly, polling has a high labour cost. Not many clients could afford to rerun the survey over and over.

In Canada, media polls run regardless, but polls sponsored by political parties only get to the press when they are positive about the sponsor's party. Thats selective.

The media should also show all of the questions asked to get the whole context. Media do sometimes focus on just one question or issue, and ignore the rest. Thats like telling only part of the story.

Its also important to use the exact wording of the question. Which party do you support is not the same as which party will you vote for.

James

by drowningnotwaving

It's not the poll. Ask a question, count the hands.

I'm a salesperson. I make my living being able to interpret numbers to my advantage no matter what the number actually is.

Now, someone actually trained in media and mass communication . . . .

I saw a beauty the other day (in Australia as it turns out):

"One in every eight people think Nuclear power is the way to go, and 38% of them want the government to commence building the power stations now".

do the math . . .

by hal 9000

As usual after missing my afternoon sleep I couldn't sleep late at night so I got to watch Post Midnight TV. I say part of Mississippi Burning and it all became clear to me.

Now the majority of White Southerns in Mississippi where not Klan members nor supports but they where willing to allow the KKK to thrive and continue on it's merry way without standing in it's way. I would hazard a guess that many of the Muslims would be very similar in thought.

I know that it's simplistic and very basic with no research but it makes sense and explains why so many people are ready to accept things that happen. And it covers both sides.

Col

by jardinier

right on the head. That sounds like a perfect parallel to the current situation among Muslims.

by hal 9000

But how many of the Radical Christians will accept this as correct? After all they have the only correct religion so everyone else is wrong. :D

Col

by onbliss

One would suspect that the "badness" actually gets condoned. When calls for reform emerges from within a group, it results in far more gentle/peaceful transition than when the cry for reform is raised from the outside.

by tonythetiger

what is moderate and what is radical is that [b]someone else[/b] does the defining. I mean, maybe the 4s are the moderates and the 1s and 2s are pacifists!

I think the world would be a much better place if resist the natural urge to put people into categories and start holding them individually responsible for their individual actions.

by drowningnotwaving

it isn't in the interests of politicians or the media to 'not' have handles or collective labels or profiling or whatever you want to call it.

Nor is it in their interests to have smarter people like yourself questioning those generalisations and pointing out the fundamental flaws (and to a certain extent the basic malice) inherent in them.

A dumb and scared electorate is in the best interests of all parties and I think they all work hard to ensure, overall and over time, it stays that way.

by tonythetiger

I'm not so sure I'm all that smart... after all, I sometimes think that what I think is important :)

by jardinier

Howard won the last two elections (2001 and 2004) precisely on that principle.

In 2001 it was the conveniently-timed (for Howard) arrival of boat people, mostly from Pakistan and Afghanistan, on the northern shores of Australia. Not only did Howard use xenophobia and racism to appeal to the Australian people, but he also told blatant lies regarding some aspects of the boat people --the "children overboard affair" -- which he has never recanted even though his lies have been proven as such.

In 2004 he repeatedly told the lie that under a Labor Government interest rates would rise. This of course gave him support from a large section of the populace who had mortgages.

There have in fact been four increases in interest rates to date since that time.

by onbliss

....an enemy combatant not be tortured to get information? As long as there is some informed guarantee that the information is going to be reliable why can't a government/group resort to torture?

Yes I have not been tortured, and would not like to get tortured; [b]but if[/b] it is one way to elicit information, why not?

by delbertpgh

Prisoners of war are owed respect. People who manage prisoners need to treat them with dignity, or they lose their ability to feel for another human being, and become unpredictable animals.

The idea behind the Geneva Conventions was that prisoners cease to be your enemies, and shouldn't be abused. Everybody has soldiers; once they can't resist, once they can do no harm, they should be well treated. I hated the North Vietnamese for the way they tortured American prisoners; I was taught to despise the North Koreans for the brainwashing techniques they used; I was told we were better because we didn't believe in that junk. Saddam tortured, for intelligence, for punishment, for fun. Now it seems to be regarded as routine for us, too.

Since you can't tell how much somebody knows, or even if he knows nothing of military value at all, you can torture him until you are sure that he's just making up stories to get you to stop, and then repeat the treatment every few weeks thereafter, just to make sure he hasn't seen the light and changed his ways. Or, you could choose not to torture. You could find yourself alone on Saturday night and all the movies are reruns, with nothing to do but go down to the cells and soften people up for their interrogation the next day. Or, you could choose not to torture.

It's about us, and what we believe in, and what the hell do we do with our interrogators in uniform who come home to us after the war. You want to live next door to Lynndie England?

by onbliss

I made it very clear I don't want to be tortured. I would like to add that nor would I want it to happen to any people I know - family and friends. And personally, under normal conditions, I wouldn't be able to torture another human being. So my argument is to find out how do we humans a draw a line between the killings/torture. Which and what kind of cause does it serve?

Well if I could dictate things, then I would set a decree of no killing and all disputes to be resolved by a simple and gentle slap to the cheeks. It is never going to happen.

May be the leaders of the countries who want war should go to a stadium and kill each other and whoever lives is the victor. It is not going to happen. Leaders will send others to die for them.

May be in a war, innocent civilians should not be killed. Terrorists are not going to stop killing innocents, and neither are countries going to stop civilian killings er.. I mean collateral damage.

Yes I want humans to respect each other and live in peace and tolerate others. Is that going to happen? Looking at the history and biological nature of humans, it looks like it is not going to happen.

So how it is going to help the "better people" if they don't win a war? [b]If[/b] torture is going to benefit [I am not saying it will always benefit] the "good-cause", then why not? I put double quotes around the words better and good-cause because it is relative and each side is going to claim they are the better side with the good-cause.

Geneva Conventions, noble as it sounds does not appear to practical. Every country with a nation and people to protect would be just violating the noble ideas. History is replete with noble Kings and Warrior treating their POW kindly and justly. But why did they even start the fight.

My point - Don't fight. If you (in a general sense) are fighting then finish the fight or atleast be sincere and just. Else it only means you value a far greater cause than the cause for which you went into a fight.

Even without personally being in a war, I know it is horrible. Is it possible for all of us to just stop fighting and live in peace. I don't think so.

by drowningnotwaving

a) ditto delbert's answer. You become a monkey swinging from the trees instead of having any right to the claim of human; and

b) much information gained during torture is unreliable and inaccurate. That's why it ceased to be used by many intelligence agencies, except as a weapon of fear; and

c) historically it means your own people tend to be in more danger if and when they are captured.

Why is there even a need to answer this question in a civilised society?

by onbliss

a) You might want to read my above response to DelbertPGH, if you have not already read so: https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=205126&messageID=2132335

b)I am not talking about the veracity of information. Unless it can be proven that we get ONLY BAD information we can not discount such tactics.

c)Yes, and that is part of the war. People on "my" side are going to get killed, maimed or tortured. Can't stop that from happening.

"Why is there even a need to answer this question in a civilised society?"

If the very existence of "civilised" society depends on it, then what? But maybe I should allow you to first define the traits of a "civilised" society and then I might say something on it to establish common grounds of what is meant by being civilised.

The topic of torture has come up often in these discussions, and I have as much revulsion to it as any sane person. Usually I have kept quiet. Guess I have been thinking about it and decided to say a few words now.

by oz_media

Sorry, onbliss, but the opening qualifier for your comment is what needs ot be considered.

[i]As long as there is some informed guarantee that the information is going to be reliable[/i]

That's the entire problem, information is NOT going to be reliable, if brought out through torture.

That's why we are forced to lay so many laws down that ensure a prisoner is not beaten to tell the story. It has been proven countless times that people whether innocent or guilty will confess to the most atrocious crimes is it is beaten out of them. Usually to stop the beating or endless interrogation.

So while the SUGGESTION may be acceptable, it simply does not work based on the disclaimer that you also include.

"As long as there is some informed guarantee that the information is going to be reliable"

There is NO guarantee, but there is high possibilty of someone NOT offering reliable information under such circumstances.

by onbliss

I did not say 100% guarantee. I don't think the intelligence gathered via spies and moles is 100% guaranteeable. Let the experts determine what is right and relevant. All I am saying is as a policy let us not remove this tactic away, use it if necessary and do not abuse it.

by jardinier

I am talking about AUSTRALIA where voting is compulsory -- that is to say it is compulsory to register at a polling place, but you can but a blank voting card in the box if you do not wish to be involved.

I gather from various discussions and posts here that many/most Americans are uninformed and disinterested in politics and news in general. This came up in a recent discussion where it was demonstrated that of 75 million Americans who have access to Foxtel, less than 1.5 million look at Fox news.

This does not apply to Australians. You can ask any person you like (I asked several today) and they will give you a firm opinion.

Australians in general choose to be INFORMED about the issues. How would I know? Because I am an extreme extrovert and talk to all manner of people each day.

This particular poll -- which I am not going to hunt up for you at this time -- was constructed in such a way that the questions were covered from opposite angles. For example -- who would you prefer as Prime Minister -- Howard, Beazley or Rudd?

It doesn't really matter what the "sheeple" thought. This was not a general election. It was an election among the 88 members of the Federal Labor Caucus (all members of both houses. Prior to the actual vote, a far greater number of members of the parliamentary Labor Party indicated a preference for Rudd than did those who indicated a preference for Beazley. Some were undecided prior to the vote.

All I ever suggested was that the results of the public poll may have given encouragement to those MPs who were initially undecided.

I suppose you will disagree that your President has a low popularity rating because this is established by polls.

You may care to explain and elaborate on this comment of yours: [i]but my personal opinion is that polls do more damage to the world than they will ever do good. [/i]

If you can present a sound argument supported by facts, I will happily listen to your point of view.

By the way, do YOU vote at every election or only when you choose to be a sheeple because you feel strongly about some issue(s)?

by jamesrl

When I was at the polling firm, I saw one survey that was on lukewarm at supporting the actions the company who commissioned it wanted to do. In other words, they wanted to change some packaging, promote the heck out of it, and sit back and watch their sales grow. The polling firm suggested that the packaging didn't matter as much as they thought, and if they just spent the same amount of money promoting the brand as changing the package, they might get a better result.

You can guess what they did....

I guess after "new" coke, some people use polls to make sure they aren't totally off in the wrong direction. If the poll isn't definitive, they will just interpret it they way they want and live with the consequences.

BTW some of the worst interpreters of polls are the media. They will read a poll and exagerate the result to make a story sell papers/ad time.

James

by hal 9000

Could refuse to fight for what their leaders believe.

How do you think the Politicians would behave if they knew that they had to lead their Armies into war with them watching on while the Politicians fought to the death with [b]Wet Mops[/b] then all the armies members where to sit in the stadium drinking beer and watching the antics of their so called leaders?

I can guarantee that War as we know would cease immediately as those who start them are Gutless Bastards who are unwilling to place themselves in [b]Harms Way[/b] but are only too willing to place others in that position.

If history has taught us anything it's the winers who write the History books and are the right ones. I've yet to see a historical account of any battle where the looses where described as the people with [b]Right on their Side.[/b]

The old saying Winners are Grinner's still applies and Torture doesn't elect accurate Intelligence it only gets what the person running the session wants to hear not the truth. However this is exactly what the Politician's want they are not interested in the truth but in scare mongering to stay in power by the Frightened Masses who believe the [b]BS[/b] from their Political Leaders that they are the only ones strong enough to protect the masses.

If that was really the case GWB would have prevented 9-11 and not be reacting after the event. That is the difference between someone who actually protects the people that they serve and those who claim to do the same job.

Col

by hal 9000

If you are referring to the one of the committees setup and composed by specialists selected buy the AU Federal Government and working within very restrictive guidelines to the questions posed by the Current AU Federal Government where it's leader wants Nuclear Power and setup several committees to prove that it [b]Green & Clean[/b] I would have to say that your figure is wrong in that case 100% want Nuclear Power.

But by the same token if you where to ask the people of AU the same question you would get a very low number agreeing mainly because of the costs involved to make Nuclear Power Available and the costs of disposing of the waste materials.

At a Prototype plant where they where emitting a large amount of EM Radiation there was a partition with every person who lived in the area signing it to remove this facility as it had the word [b]Radiation[/b] so that must mean Nuclear Radiation, not many understand the difference between EM and Nuclear Radiation they just see the word [b]Radiation[/b] and immediately begin to see deformed children glowing in the dark and the like.

Col

by jamesrl

But here are some reasons why polls are sometimes wrong....

1) Polls are a snapshot in time - the time when they are taken. Unless you are polling on election day, its pretty hard to predict the elections outcome. That doesn't stop peopel from trying.

As I said in a previous post, looking at a number of polls together can indicate movement and direction, but its difficult to assess polls from different companies the same way. You could be leading a week before the election, and still lose, but the polling usually stops days before the election.

2) People lie. They lie less about their opinions than their intentions. They are more truthful about who they support than whether or not they will actually vote. A much higher percentage of people tell pollsters they will vote than actually do.

3) People hate long polls. And so they will tell you things just to get through the call quickly.

Good pollsters can try to compensate both in the poll itself or in the analysis.

James

by drowningnotwaving

No, you can't be revulsed by it AND think it a valid tactic.

Where do you start and stop? If torture is okay for certain crimes (real or perceived) then do you really think it is that difficult to extend it out a little bit to crimes that are not really thought of in the same manner?

In your mind do you perceive different levels? Do we electrocute terrorist suspects, but only use the thumbscrews on suspected murderers? In your mind are there levels that are acceptible and those that aren't?

And does this happen BEFORE a court case or AFTER it? Does the state 'sanction' the punishment?

Does the suspect have their lawyer present while this is happening to make sure the voltage doesn't get pumped up a little bit? Or is that just "what happens sometimes".

And if the suspect is shown to have been innocent, then do we pay them recompense? Do we torture their accusers to the same extent for vengance?

And if and when they die, is there an inquest and inquiry into the validity of the process? Or is that subject/discussion, such as under the new anti-terror laws in many countries, not even allowed to be spoken about in public by the victim or their families or representatives, for fear of treason-like charges?

And when it's your brother, wife, nephew or neighbour that you have to face afterwards and say "well, it may have hurt, but it really is in all of our common good". Can you honestly say that?

by onbliss

Well unless I truly go kill or torture someone, I would never understand it, won't I? Well the very sound of it sounds horrifying to me, and I don't think personally I have the ability to do it. Yes I am a hypocrite for allowing someone else to do the dirty job that I won't do.

[b]So everything I say is hypothetical on how I am going to behave when causes/principles are in question.[/b]. I do not desire war nor torture, but if it is a [b]necessity[/b] then I say we should think and act; and not just dismiss it because we are "civilised". We are not talking about killing innocents or civilian indiscriminately. We are talking about combatants who possibly could know answers. We are not talking about disrespecting the dead .... I could go on.

Let me answer the last - most emotional - question first: Yes.

And the answer for all other questions: I don't know. The government/military should do whatever it takes to win. Why the big brouha for sanctions when the same government can sanction a war to kill other human beings? The same government/group does not hesitate to kill other civilians and innocents but makes a deal of trying to win for thier cause?

Enemy combtant should be an enemy combtant. Period. If we are so sure that we are doing the right thing, why go through an entire drama or charade to just please somebody else? Wouldn't we be doing a great diservice to all that are being killed if we make war like it was an exhibition match?

So are you going to list the traits of being "civilised"? Also since you have asked me so many questions, let me tag another question:

Say two governments are at war - Government X and Government Z. If X believes that it is worthwhile to fight for their cause C which they believe is far civilised and superior to Z, but yet unwilling to compromise on say a principle T which could be decisive in the war; do you think X is doing everything that it can to protect the cause C which allows the principle T to flourish in the first place? If X is defeated, thereby causing C to die then doesn't T go downn along with it? What is your stance on it?

My stance is: NO War. NO Killing. IF must finish it without killing non-combatants.

by drowningnotwaving

I tried very hard to find the story but couldn't sorry.

I can't even remember if the story itself referred to a poll or just did the "a recent survey of the general public found ..." approach.

I just remembered the numbers because in a moment of madness, I chuckled and worked out how few people were being used in the story as the positive model for what the writer wants our overall opinion to be.

If I was to add another protagonist in the poll debate, I think it is hard to go past lobbyists as probably the most dangerous interpreters / filterers of polls.

by drowningnotwaving

albeit in your enthusiasm to demonstrate the point I kind of got a bit left in the dark over the T's and C's.

And sorry I have now read the other response - I'm sorry that in the process of our discussion I hadn't read it but it doesn't actually change my thoughts about your opinion. I'd personally paraphrase to fall into the category of "pragmatic morality".

I think that there are 'barriers' past which return is extremely difficult. Torture and preemptive strikes on sovereign states fall into that category. To take the easy path destroys your credibility in the future, in terms of diplomatic solutions to issues. It also makes it so much easier to repeat your crimes against humanity, as you've done it once and the second time is never as hard.

And it means when you call the other side "savages" you're on very, very thin ice.

If "we" claim any moral highground whatsoever, but act in these ways (as we have done) at what point do we stop?

Maybe it would actually be easier to carpet-nuke-bomb the whole place, wave the flag that we won and let 40 years of writing our own history absolve our sins. At least then we wouldn't pretend to be any better, we'd just be the last people standing.

by jardinier

[i]"One in every eight people think Nuclear power is the way to go, and 38% of them want the government to commence building the power stations now." do the math.[/i]

I cannot give an accurate comment on what you have posted.

However I presume you are comparing: "One in every eight people" with "38 %" and figuring that "one in every eight -- 12.5 %" is contradictory to "38 %."

The way I read the sentence you have posted is that out of the 12.5 % of people who think nuclear power is the way to go, 38 % of [b]this group[/b] "want the government to commence building the power stations now."

Please give the full context or figures and try again.

by jardinier

As mentioned elsewhere, the poll was conducted by [b]The Australian[/b] newspaper, which is owned by Rupert Murdoch.

Perhaps you are confusing the name of the newspaper with the country in which it is published.

Murdoch established the first national daily newspaper, [b]"The Australian,"[/b] in 1964. From memory it ran at a loss for about 10 years during which time it was subsidised by other Murdoch publications (including perhaps the now defunct "Daily Mirror" on which I worked for four years).

But he stuck it out and The Australian is now a highly regarded broadsheet.

I have done a search for the poll but with no luck.

by jardinier

What I am about to say MAY in some small way be relevant to the discussion topic.

As mentioned elsewhere, my main contact with Muslims is with young men from Pakistan, India and Bangladesh.

One of these young men -- let's call him "Ali" -- has befriended me and I keep him up to date with my personal life.

He has a wife and baby son who are currently in their homeland of Bangladesh, and a younger brother who also lives with him in Sydney.

Recently he asked me if I had any adult DVDs. "Yes" I said, "but they are pretty crappy." So I loaned him my small collection which he will copy and then return to me. I asked if he would watch them with his wife -- "definitely not."

Then he wanted to purchase some additional adult DVDs, so I loaned him a catalogue which I happened to have. However he said he could not purchase them himself because his younger brother might open the package. So he asked me to order them for him.

Ali and the other Muslims work at a petrol station. Well he was so paranoid about this purchase that he led me away from the office and looked at the catalogue by the light of a street lamp. I subsequently ordered the movies he had marked, and they arrived today in an innocuous looking brown cardboard box.

So I called into the petrol station to give him the box of DVDs and collect from him the purchase price. He was still paranoid and we had to go around to the side of the building while he gave me the money.

The relevance of all this cloak-and-dagger stuff to this discussion is that apparently Muslims DO have quite a different -- and stricter -- moral code than Westerners.

I cannot imagine that an Australian male over the age of 16 - 18 would regard the possession and viewing of adult material as something to be ashamed of and secretive about.

Thus I deduce that when Ali or any of the other Muslims from the Indian sub-continent say Islam is practised in a peaceful manner in their homelands, they are simply stating a fact.

[b]Special note to Colin.[/b] I never managed to get the magical 69 of the top 100 in site activity, but God in his mysterious and wondrous way has at least given me post # 69 in this particular discussion. ]:) ]:) ]:) ]:)

by john.a.wills

Christians and Moslems believe much the same about pornography, but Moslems are either less or more hypocritical about it, depending on angle.

by jardinier

because my friend "Ali" has offered to supply me with pirate adult DVDs which are available very cheaply in Bangladesh and are copied from originals from a number of countries.

by onbliss

...elaborate the traits of a "civilised" society.
Also if it comes to that, that we have to recommend whatever it takes to save a "civilised" society from perishing would you recommend that whatever? How much ever sad or awful it makes you - in your own mind?

by drowningnotwaving

the one in eight means 12.5% of the population to start with.

the 38% of THAT number (but that is my interpretation) is about 5 out of a hundred.

It was a trivial example of the power of how to state numbers in such a way as to make them seem much more than they are.

I use the same logic to justify my client's multi-hundred-thousand expenditure on software projects so I guess I shouldn't point the finger too much. Just as long as they pay the invoice of course . . . .

by delbertpgh

Sure, war is bad, but not surviving is also bad, and surviving as a slave or as a thug is also bad. Very little that is virtuous in public life can be secured and enjoyed unless people are willing to defend it by mortal force.

Saying that war is more awful than torture does not make torture moot. If the killing in war does not in some way support the mission of life and civilization, then it is nothing but murder. Just because there exist necessary evils, does not make evil okay.

We have a great deal of latitude on our care of prisoners, because as prisoners, they are powerless. Our treatment of them is a guide to our integrity.

by onbliss

I don't think I am phoo-phooing the horrors of torture or recommending it be performed on every prisoner of war. My point is torture should be an option on the table; and we can not summarily dismiss a tactic if it is going to help in preserving something that is cherished and valued. I acknowledge torture is bad and immoral. But sometimes we have to resort to immoral things. Indiscriminate torture of ALL POW is probably going to result in no gain of net intelligence; and probably that does not happen either. Neither am I talking about prisoner abuse meant just for amusement or merry. Let there be appropriate measures or monitoring system to ensure torture is done only when necessary, but let us not remove that option from the table because we think we are better than some one else. There might be no "us" as we no it.

Talk about integrity, life's mission, virtuous public life and morality is all fine as most of us resonate with such thoughts and ideas. But what if those very things stand to loose/die? What would you, I and we do about it?

If we are going to stand up and fight for something, then we should finish the fight in earnest.

by jamesrl

...If US POWs were routinely tortured?

I would argue your point about Geneva conventions. Germany treated most of its POWs by the convention (with some exceptions) because they wanted their prisoners treated well (to help morale at home). I doubt Germany would have had any compunction about killing prisoners if they weren't worried about it - when they knew that the Soviets abused German POWs, they did exactly the same thing. But for the most part British/Commonwealth/US POWs were treated ok.

Alternatively, the Japanese thought their own soldiers who surrendered were cowards who had no honor, and so they didn't have any scruples about mistreating their prisoners.

I am from the camp that believes what I've read about the questionable value of information extracted under torture. Some of those articles were written by FBI and US Military interrogators BTW.

What I have seen is that under torture, US pilots in Vietnam and Iraq admitted to war crimes they never committed. I saw that in a case of torture in Saudi Arabia, a man admitted to a murder he didn't committ.

James

by onbliss

Looks like my stance requires heavy disclaimers. Well I invited this on myself. I would not be okay if anyone was tortured. I don't want anyone to torture anyone to just while away their time after their afternoon snack or after their late night supper. I wouldn't want anybody to die for that matter, as well. But if it comes to it that the torture can help the cause, then that option should not be dismissed because we like to sip tea with two fingers and eat fruits with knife/fork. It does not mean we go abusing people and trampling moral conventions. My point is we should be able to distinguish things that are necessary and things that are not necessary; and conduct ourselves after due deliberations and thought.

I see that talking about Geneva convetions, you did say "with some exceptions".

If the information obtained under torture is not reliable, then let us just not do it. What I am appalled is people's reaction to the word torture and their absolute admanacy to hear the case for it - because they think they are just "better" than "others" and that is not what they would do. Obviously it becomes a tactic only if there is a case for it; else it becomes an abuse. There is a difference.

My gut feeling is that we as society have travelled so far from the reality of what protects us. It seems to be like a cocoon. I wonder how we all would react if each one of us had to fight things ourselves. Picture a situation where we all live in tribes and each male has to go out and protect the tribe.

To some it might appear that I am justifying the means by citing the end. I would like to point out that the "end" would need to be evaluated and qualified. Would I slap a child who stole my child's ice cream? No. Would I beat a guy who ogles at my wife? No. What if the some one tries to take my life away? Yes.

What is the End? That is an important thing to think about. How much we value the end is an important thing to decide. Is there something far greater than that end is something to deliberate. James, in the discussion about life vs money. Most of said we value life more than the money. Money comes and goes we said. Life, safety etc. are important we said. Few said, if there was no other option but to fight then they would fight. It is not about sending routinely POWs on conveyor belts to be tortured for the heck of it or to get some revenge that we are talking about.

If we value virtue, righteousness, kindness, morality, faith etc what would we do if those are attacked? There is a verse in Sanskrit: "Dharmo rakshati rakshitaha" that translates to "Dharma protects those who protect it".

So let me ask you this: If you knew torture to be the one last instrument by which you can save: virtue, righteousness and way of your life; what would you recommend?

All this argument is so ironic, because I don't think I have the stomach or heart to do what my brain recommends.

edit: It would be a problem, if my heart desires it. So far it does not. Good for me.

by jamesrl

If you use "evil" methods in the fight for good, do you become evil?

I'm not going to suggest an all encompasing answer. I think in the end a nuclear bomb saved perhaps millions of lives in WWII (whether the second one was needed is an entirely secondary question).

But think of this. If you are claiming to be the "good" guys, and you use torture, and as often happens, its discovered, doesn't that strentghen your enemies? Do you think after Abu Ghraib that Al Quaeda got an increase in recruitment? Did that help US servicemen or not.

And unless you capture someone of high rank, just what information to you expect them to have?

Its a can of worms, and I am not suggesting that I think any less of you for taking your side, I can see it too. But in the end, I think the end may only justify the means in some circustances and not every circumstance.

James

by onbliss

I think I answered the question in the title already in an earlier post.

As far as becoming evil. Yes one becomes evil; and that is a price we have to pay. I would consider why and for what purposes one becomes "temporarily" evil as a factor. The society should weigh the evilness of a person molesting a child or raping a woman against the "evilness" of a soldier torturing an enemy-combatant to elicit information.

And honestly though I would like people to generally think nice of me, in this case it would not matter what people think of me. I did think twice before sticking my neck out on this issue. If it means being rejected, so be it. Though I wouldn't want FBI at my doors :-) for articulating an action that I personally have no ability to carry out. In fact the stance is really a confused stance - it is some sort of internal fight - to do or not to do.

I do think we should ask ourselves questions about dropping bombs. Humans having evolved emotions and intelligence different from other animals, should use them and perform "unjustifiable" actions only when it is necessary. Was the second one necessary? I don't know. My heart can't even justify the first one.

No, my stance is not to support USA or any country. It is more of generic, and I will take little audacity to claim it is philosophical or tactical one. And, I do not claim USA to be good or bad. Why does everything have to be about USA :-)?

"And unless you capture someone of high rank, just what information to you expect them to have?"

I agree, and I don't know what they would know or not know. I recommend a tactic when there is reasonable suspicion that the person might know something. My point is from a common person's expectation; will someone abuse the system? Most probably yes.

"But in the end, I think the end may only justify the means in some circumstances and not every circumstance. "
I did say something similar with the ice cream and wife analogy, didn't I?

Sorry for pressing the issue further, but would you mind answering my last question about your recommendation in the situation I laid out?

by f4a6pilot

These are not people wandering the street and pulled off for questioning. These are people who resisted coalition forces and were taking arms against the forces in Iraq.

They are often foreign (non-Iraqi). They were armed and captured. The sectarian violence will continue. Will US troops be the target is a question. The enemy most of the Arabs agree on is Israel...

I do not consider sleep deprivation and loud music torture. That is effective and it isn't physically damaging to a detaineee. Scaring them with a dog isn't torture. Shooting them periodically would be. Cutting off captive's heads. That is torture, and murder.

There is a great deal of duress you can place a captive in to get them to speak without harming them. Those tactics should be used...

Conversely, I have waterskied. For me, It was alot like waterboarding... ;-)

by jamesrl

"So let me ask you this: If you knew torture to be the one last instrument by which you can save: virtue, righteousness and way of your life; what would you recommend"

If I knew with absolute certainty that with the torture I would be guarenteed to save a large number of lives, I might bend. But when does that happen? Torture is not a science.

With the atom bomb tests you had hard numbers to deal with. At Okinawa, which is Japanese soil, the Japanese resisted fiercely, and many civilians killed themselves rather than suffer the shame of capture. So it isn't to hard to weigh in the balance the fact that an invasion of Japan by the US would cause many times more civilian and military casualties to Japan alone than an atom bomb. So setting off a bomb saved many Japanese lives as well as US lives. My choice would be clear.

But in the case of torture, you don't know. Torture is a fishing expedition with no certain outcome.

I also don't think we should ask others to do what we aren't willing to do ourselves. I could kill someone in a war on behalf of my country.( I volunteered to serve but could not) I could enter a burning house (I have).

I could not torture. How can you save virtue and righteousness by being unvirtuous and unrighteous?

James

by onbliss

"If I knew with absolute certainty that with the torture I would be guaranteed to save a large number of lives, I might bend. But when does that happen? Torture is not a science."

Thanks for answering. Bending - It is one core point of our discussion.

"I also don't think we should ask others to do what we aren't willing to do ourselves."
Agreed. But "ability to do" and "willing to do" is different. I don't think it is going to be effective if the torturer himself/herself becomes the torture.

"How can you save virtue and righteousness by being not virtuous and unrighteous?"
Say a person tries to save a baby from getting crushed by a truck; the person saves the baby but gets crushed in the process. The goal was to save the baby (and of course not get killed), and the fact still is that the baby was saved. In one sense, the soldier might become not virtous and unrighteous, but the soldier would still have save Virtue and Righteousness from being destroyed; allowing future generations to nourish underneath them.

by jardinier

about this discussion. I challenge anyone to prove that the poll question is in any way biased, misleading, ambiguous or aims to get a pre-determined result.

[b]Here is the question:[/b]

Please list in numerical order of preference the members who you consider have made the most useful -- that is informative and factual -- posts to this discussion to date.

You may list a minimum of three and a maximum of five members.

[The person who gets the highest number of primary votes will of course receive a TechRepublic mug and T-shirt.]

by hal 9000

Information can be gathered quite reliably from other sources and we don't need to resort to Torture to get what we want to hear from some know nothing fool who is only doing as they are ordered to do.

If you condone torture you must expect the same thing to happen to your countries troops as well as making any Allies vulnerable to that tactic as well. If you accept that you'll see all your allies disappear so fast that you'll wonder what is happening.

Some things are never acceptable and should be disposed of at every opportunity. The Allies after the End of WW11 in Europe decided quite rightly to destroy all of Joesph's Mongolia's work as it was derived by subjecting people to subhuman testing so that all of the results of this work should be destroyed and never be allowed to be used for any purpose. They where quite right on that one and I'll fully agree with that decision till my dieing day. The moment that you give credence to work obtained through means like this you become a Lesser Person/Country/Society.

Your biggest problem is that you have yet to realise that this [b]Is Not A Conventional War[/b] that we are currently fighting and we will loose this [b]War On Terror[/b] because we still do not understand that this time the war is not being fought over land or the control of it as in every previous case but on an idea and the more that you descend to their level the more ammunition that you give these people to use against you and your country and the bigger the numbers of eager followers will be.

We are currently at war with a Stateless group who have no land to protect or loose but can hit us at every opportunity and we have no way of striking back at the root problem. We only strike at images of a perceived problem and by doing so increase the number of followers that we are supposed to be eliminating.

The Current [b]WOT[/b] is not a solution it is the reason that we are loosing and will continue to loose as we have no enemy to attack easily and no land to take away from them. This is like attempting to fight shadows and we are going to loose this one and what is worse will make us look just so much weaker as some $25.00 tin pot radical with nothing at all can manage to defeat us at will and we are powerless to do anything about him or his actions and are unable to prevent any further actions from him or his underlings who are growing stronger every day while we are weakening ourselves and depleting our limited resources chasing shadows that simply do not exist.

What we have to understand is that this is a different war and different rules apply as we are not attempting to win land like in every previous war that any of our countries have fought in we are fighting an idea and every time that we overstep the mark we create thousands of new recruits to the cause which we are ill equipped to fight in the first place.

If we where to wipe the entire Middle East off the face of the planet do you think that the [b]WOT[/b] will end? No It will just move to a different area and get more recruits who are even more fervent in their desire to destroy us as we are attempting to fight Islam not the terrorists who hide in the Islamic mob. That is how the current [b]WOT[/b] is seen by these people Christians attempting to destroy Islam and while that belief remains there is no possibility of wining or even reaching a [b]Stalemate[/b] we will loose and there is currently nothing that can be done to prevent this from happening!

Until you realise this you will be in a position of increasing the enemy with every move and falling even further behind in the ability to have a reasonable chance to walk away with some dignity after a Diplomatic outcome has been achieved.

Col

by jamesrl

You are going to judge all muslims based on one guy? Going to judge all catholics on Hitler?

As in any group, there are good and bad people. In Canada, the shops that sell these DVDs are quite often run by people who immigrated from China. Do I think all Chinese merchants sell pirate goods? No of course not.

BTW, my brother in law used to buy some of these DVDs and I've seen a few. The quality of the image on many of them is fair to poor at best. In some, the ones recorded in a theatre with a camcorder, you can hear the audience talking, coughing, laughing. I have never bought one, and having seen the quality never would. In others the video encoding is crap and you get pixellation and sound problems.

James

by jardinier

I am anticipating that the quality will be too poor to consider purchasing and viewing them.

I have picked up pirated VHS tapes at various places -- mostly private garage sales. The quality is so bad that I just chuck them out.

I now know how to detect pirated material by the labelling (lack thereof actually).

Yes it was a pretty stupid generalisation to make.

by onbliss

I am not answering to bulk of your post, because I am not talking about WOT, Muslims or USA specifically. And more over, I agree with some of the things you said about WOT.

It is something general about War that I am talking. I did accept that torture can be used against my own troops. It comes with the territory. I also addressed some of the issues in my other posts in this thread.

by oz_media

So currently your government approves SOME torture to obtain evidence? THEN they decide whether it is correct or not?

I don't think so.

by oz_media

C'mon onbliss. You mean that beheading American soldiers can be accepted? Your troops sexually humiliating captives is acceptable?

Your definition of torture is very different than your view of torture.

So do we now need to sit down and have another allied convention to determine which torturous acts are acceptable and which are not?

Torture is not an effective way of obtainin ginformation, in comparisson with other means.

Torture goes again every moral fibre of what America and other free countries are built upon.

Torture is he most incomprehensible act of cowardice ever demonstrated. No man can possibly show his face as a hero (regardles sof information gathered) if it was obtained
through torturous means.

I am shocke dthat an American would support torture in ANY form, no mater how controlled or "important' it was deemed. We have other methods, we must rely on them or become no better than those we battle against.

by onbliss

This is getting really annoying for me to say again and again: This is not about America. For heaven's sake please read my posts. My point is not about any one specific government or group. I have told you so many times, I am not an American. Blame America for what Americans do and not for the actions of non-Americans. Come on give them a break.

Well I don't want to get into a pet rant about the mutation of the word "hero" and how it is being used by the media. Saving a country or a cause that one is willing to fight is not about showing some face to somebody - family, friends or media.

There is going to be no moral fibre left around when groups that want to fight for it is wiped out. Here again notice it is not about AMERICA. Sometimes it is necessary for us to go against the very moral fibre that we stand for to save the moral garland for the future generations. If it means we become tainted, a coward or what not, then it is just a sad fate for us.

Cowardice: Webster defines it as lack of courage or resolution.

by oz_media

Sorry I forgot you are an implanted American, but not REALLY American. In 99.9999999% of the cases people are automatically considered American. The American view on immigration seems to be [b]FIFO "Fit In or F*** Off" [/b] Individual opinion, ESPECIALLY unAmerican opinion is strictly forbidden. Therefore you LIVE there you are one. Just as people deem me Canadian, but I am not, though in the US cultural assimilation is far stronger than the cultural diversity of Canada.

But suggesting that ANY form of torture, even under the strictest and most regiulated conditions at all would be acceptable, is just sad. Now I do realize that we do have forms of repression that are seen as forms of turture (prison), but every measure is taken to ensure that punishment is as humane and comfortable as possible.

That torture mentality is SO arachaic its not funny, just completely backwards to everything that we have learned over the years as humans. Yes I know you don't mean bamboo under fingernails or a hot poker in the eye but qny form of pyhisical pain or punishment inflicted upon another hum,an is just not acceptable.

If so, we must then turn a blind eye on what other people consider a fair form of interrogation, even if it means beheading someone's family to make them speak.

by onbliss

...sincere or insincere.

You are so wrong. I would have expressed the same view from any part of this world - the free countries, that allowed me to express this opinion. And if such countries are destroyed then I no longer can express them, neither would my kids. You see my point?

You are just making an assumption that I hadn't learnt anything from where I grew up or that I had unlearnt everything once come here. Your views also seem to imply that no two cultures or people across the globe can have a similar thought pattern. Not all good or bad originated in USA. I am not sure why you and some others continue to keep bringing USA in the picture.

Maybe you should picturize that we are talking about "Arthasastra" composed by Kautilaya? Or maybe you should consider that we are talking about "Bhagavad Gita" which actually is about the subject of war and how one person refuses to kill people. NFL coaches could learn a thing or two about motivating people. I don't know, I am just pondering. Would that put you at ease that people can come to similar conclusions from different backgrounds?

Okay, if you say torture is not acceptable let me ask you this; if it so happens that you land up in a situation where torture could offer you a remote chance of survival of you and your culture, would you use it or would you be ready to perish?

And tell me what do we as humans have learnt over the years. Seriously humor me with a good answer.

This is not about USA and its mutli-culturalism. That is a separate discussion. And I can say a thing or two having come from India.

by drowningnotwaving

It's simple.

I understand it is what the religious folk call the 'golden rule' as it is found in many guises in many religions or creeds.

I'll paraphrase it to:

[i]Do unto others as you would have them do unto you, your mother, your sister or your daughter.[/i]

And I am sorry - I have enjoyed the discussion and look forward to more with you Onbliss, but I have to tell you that, in this instance, I find your stance on torture abhorrent, immoral, ignorant and backward.

I hope it never happens to you or anyone you know.

by drowningnotwaving

Your stance on non-impact or psychological torture (such as sleep deprivation, loud music, dogs) is almost scarier than Onbliss's attempt to see it as 'just another tool'.

Let's examine sleep deprivation, just for the first one.

What can possibly be gained from it? We're not talking a couple of days on the booze, staying up all night with the lads. We're talking minutes sleep every few hours, for sometimes weeks at a time.

People are turned into delirious zombies.

Have you never felt a bit 'iffy' after a few nights late study?

Well times that by whatever extremely large number comes into your head.

You are no longer capable of thought, rationality or logic, let alone controlling body functions like seeing, hearing, standing straight up. There are many studies on this over the last 50 years that you can Google.

Add to that the fact that the people in our specific discussion's circumstances are often hooded, subjected to loud noises and verbal abuse from different directions throughout this process.

[i]Do you honestly think that any "intelligence" can be gained from this?[/i]

[b]The reason I suggest it is as evil as any other physical form of torture is that it's [u]sole purpose[/u] is hurt, fear and degradation.[/b]

There is no other purpose. And that makes the person doing it, and the people sanctioning it, as savage as anyone else in our sad and sorry history of terror and torture.

by jardinier

During a war we receive reports of the number of soldiers killed and the number injured. We may also receive reports of the numbers of civilians who are killed or injured, and perhaps even the number of enemy troops killed or injured.

But we just read these as numbers and do not think of the probably immense suffering undergone by the injured persons.

Can you imagine being seriously wounded and left to die in the desert or jungle with NO medical aid or morphine? I guess service personnel are supplied with suicide pills for such situations.

But for those who survive: which would you personally prefer? To be tortured but remain physically intact, or lose a limb or two or become blind or any other of the PERMANENT disabilities that may be the result of injury during war.

A former elderly tenant in my building had served in WW II. He developed a severe nervous condition with which he had to live for the next 50 years and which destroyed any possibility of a basic quality of life.

So I don't see torture as any big deal compared with the LIFELONG suffering that affects so many military personnel.

by deepsand

It makes even more sense when properly stated, which few people are ever taught.

[i]Do [b]not[/b] unto others as you would have them [b]not[/b] do unto you.[/i]

I.e., do not assume that others will like that which you do; rather, assume that that which you dislike will be disliked by others.

In short, if it harms you, don't do it to others.

by onbliss

You seem to be saying ta-ta already. Do stay on for some more time. Sorry if this post sounds like a lecture, sermon or seeped with patronizing attitude. No, I am just trying to explain my rationale and why I think we have to act "bad" at certain times.[b]I assume members at TR are quite well read & smart.[/b] It is easy to find out that what I am saying is nothing original. And as I said before we have become so "civilised" that we do not fully understand what protects and keeps us going forward.

Don't you think religion is just one source for getting "civilised"?

Webster.com defines the word "civilize" as following:
1 : to cause to develop out of a primitive state; especially : to bring to a technically advanced and rationally ordered stage of cultural development
2 intransitive verb : to acquire the customs and amenities of a civil community

If then one looks at the word "civil", one finds that some of the definitions are:
1 a : of or relating to citizens b : of or relating to the state or its citizenry
2 a : CIVILIZED b : adequate in courtesy and politeness : MANNERLY
3 a : of, relating to, or based on civil law b : relating to private rights and to remedies sought by action or suit distinct from criminal proceedings c : established by law
4 : of, relating to, or involving the general public, their activities, needs, or ways, or civic affairs as distinguished from special (as military or religious) affairs

In general one can conclude it is all about what it takes to maintain an orderly society where people are free to pursue their activities; and there is law & order, courteousness, etc.

So how did we arrive in the 21st century the way we are? In my opinion, it took "whatever" it took to get us here - good and the bad. The good behaving bad sometimes. Civilization is a result of trial and error so to speak. It is about religion, culture and politics blending to give a strong identity and a set of behavior. Civilizations die or morph when they become weak. Natural causes - disease, famine etc and Man-made causes - War, weakening of an ideology against a better/superior or inferior/bad ideology. Essentially when a set of people lose majority in terms of demography, they lose out to others. Over the period some people just die out, or convert to the ideology professed by the Winner. However be the case, the ideology goes away until it re-surfaces again in the same place or some other place.

Being polite, courteous, doing good all are perfect norms in every day life under peaceful conditions when there is no threat. But when the society or a person perceives a threat, is it practical to be civil? How many are going to show the other cheek when the first one is slapped? I know my argument might sound against pacifism; but once a society shirks off pacifism and is ready to fight then there are times when it has to act badly. So how can an action that seeks to preserve the society and move it forward be considered backward, immoral or ignorant? Abhorrent yes. Disgusting yes.

I do not want my family, friends, you, or for that matter anyone to be tortured. But if that is what is required, then as you say elsewhere, it is scary. Hopefully we wage war only when it is absolutely required and then just get it done with as much less pain and suffering.

edited: formatting, grammar