Discussion Locked

Moderate and radical Muslims -- are they very different?

0 helpful
132 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

132 replies

by onbliss

How about the person having posting maximum number of tangential posts? I would get the mug and t-shirt :-)

I think Hal's post was on the mark.

by drowningnotwaving

What are you talking about?

Your analogy is like asking - "do you prefer to be vaginally or anally raped?"

My preference is neither, and I am fairly certain that the fact that the first happens is no justification for the second.

Thank god or whoever for the veterans who have, in their sacrifice, provided me with a life like I have.

But I am fairly certain that asking most veterans "does your horrific memory of the war and what happened to you or your mates make you feel that torture of prisoners is justified?" would lead to a high majority vote in the negative.

by drowningnotwaving

[i]But when the society or a person perceives a threat, is it practical to be civil? How many are going to show the other cheek when the first one is slapped?[/i]

I think, in the long term, history shows us it is impractical to be otherwise.

There is a great and vast difference between the concepts of civility (or lack thereof) and self defense albeit on a personal, regional, national or international scale.

Taking action to protect yourself is not whatsoever against the process of civility. On a basic scale it is what we call the law. We have and define rules that govern our basic behaviour and that go some way to protect against or punish those that act otherwise.

We'll argue the benefits of war and the military until our last dying breath and I really really really don't want to go down that path.

But just because we have war or defend ourselves and our countries when we must does not whatsoever justify the torture of prisoners.

[i]So how can an action that seeks to preserve the society and move it forward be considered backward, immoral or ignorant?[/i]

You are missing the point and becoming foolish. This action has NOTHING to do with 'preserving soceity and moving forward'. It's sole purpose is to destroy society and move backwards.

You seem to think there is a [b]positive[/b] benefit to torture.

(I shudder to ask, but ...) please tell me:

1. What positive benefit can come from torture?

2. How does torture move our society ahead?

3. Does the fact that the 'other guy' does it, make it okay for us to do as well?

(If the answer to the last one is anything but a resounding 'no' then please take your argument and logic to the following thread:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=205564&start=0

and try your "if it's good for them it's good for us" there.

{edited - pushed the button too quickly}

by oz_media

That reply was everywhere, so I'll take it for what it was; grouped letters in neat little lines.

Well it was a sincere apology, take it as you will.

I said your comments wer very American, which they are, definitely not common among anyone I've heard from, except a few gun toting redknecks of course.

As for torturing others to save my family.
If I was saving my family, it woul dbe because someone else is tryign to inflict pain on them. That would be called self defense. If I heard someone was out to kill my fam,ily, and I rounded up the guy that spoke out, would torturing him help? Nope, would it be right? Nope.

So your rachsly composed analogy doesn't fit at all.

Torture is wrong, inexcusable. There are so many ways of obtaining the same and better results than by torture.

I understand psychology, criminal minds, mass murders and what makes people tick, tortue has never helped uncover these horrors; understanding has.

To consider for a moment that unneccessarily inflicting pain to obtain information is correct, you are on the wrong side. There seems to be many thousands with that mentality, allied forces die daily trying to stop them form succeeding. Torturing people will nto help in any way shape or form. If so, WHO do you torture? The guy who will de for his country? The car bomber? The hijackers? Yeah that will accomplish a lot, for them anyway as that is thier goal; to die while opposing the enemy. Now the enemy tortures their people, what is ther next move? To give up information so they are not also torured?

by oz_media

My dad lost an eye in Korea, one of my grandfathers lost both legs in WWII (the other was killed).

Both my father and grandfather went on to live VERY happy lives getting used to a new way of life but they were alive and had a future still. I am positive both woul dtake thier injuries over torture anyday.

My best friend, when I was younger, was beaten in jail once (just a few too many speeding tickets but ended up facing some old rival inside) . Two months after his release from jail, he lost both legs in a motorcycle accident. his life went on to be as good as before, in fact mroeso because he really appreciated life mroe, whereas he was a bit of a depressive before.

He woul dunquestionably take the initial pain and inconvenience of losing his lmbs over being beaten in jail again. This I know very well.

So in your analogy, I woul drather live and be maimed than be tortured. Who says you live through torture anyway? once you spaek up, you are usually kiled, they have what they need. If you don't speak up, you are usually killed, they can't let you go at that point.

So either way, torture seems to lead to a long slow and very painful death, not a new lease on life.

by hal 9000

If you care to look at the Tibetan Buddhists they have been deprived of their homeland for several decades now and their Government and ideals have not died out if anything that have become stronger.

They do not measure things in a few years but in many life times to achieve the desired result without aggression.

The next time that The Dali Lama visits your part of the world go and see him you may find that you have a life changing experience at the very least you'll learn something from his pacifist belief system. Don't get me wrong I was taught to fight from a very early age and I used to be responsible for his safety when he visited here and he continually tried to talk me into following the pacifist path. When he realised that I was who I am he gave up on that and we talked quite a lot and they where very interesting thought provoking talks, where I eventually realised that I have several more life times to live before I can begin to hope to reach enlightenment but by the same token people like the Dali Lama have promised to return till all life is scared so I guess that I'm in good company and I can live with that.

Col

by oz_media

As for he analogy you offered, I would take the latter.

Being vaginally raped would throw a lot of what I believe in right out the window, starting with the birds and the bees.

Plus it would depend on who's raping me, I can be a bit of a whore too.

by hal 9000

That I know, they would string me up as it is against everything that they put themselves in [b]Harms Way to Stop![/b] Granted I don't mix with the Veteran Community a great deal but I know people who where in WW11, Korea, Nam, Gulf War 1, in Peace Keeping Missions in Rwanda and places like that and not a single one would agree that torture is an acceptable manner to gather information.

Though I'm sure than many would show me how some of the less messy stuff is done so I can make up my own mind, till I come to my senses and stop being a fool.

The real veterans are the ones who don't talk about their service in a boasting manner all will occasionally drop a line or two about something that they saw and then shut up. Getting any information out of these people is impossible as they just don't talk about what they went through except when they are with their fellow fighting personal on the official Annual Holiday here to remember the fallen and those who have returned. They tend to get drunk as skunks and then will brag about some of the things that they did during their service but even then they are guarded in what they say and like Human nature the world over they only remember the good things and tend to forget the bad things when socialising with their service mates.

Col

by onbliss

1 & 2. On its own not, because I consider it only as one tactic. Sometimes we don't have to use it, sometimes we have to use it. If it is used and helps us winning the war; then it is like using a gun to win the war.

3. Should a country stop using surface-to-surface missile because its enemy does not have it or use it?

I don't see why you have connected this with the thread about slave trade? India has seen some share of torture at the hands of some Middle-East and European powers. I have read essays and articles about horrific things. I see a difference between committing torture to oppress & destroy other culter against doing it to preserv one's culture and way of life.

I don't think it being positive or negative. It can backfire and cause problems too.

by onbliss

Dear Col,
No, I wouldn't get you wrong. I know you have had some kind of exposure with Buddhism, just not sure to what extent. I thought you would be little aware of Hinduism too :-) because of Buddhism's origins. To be honest, I am not sure if my belief system resonates with Christian belief system. I am Hindu and my upbringing was Hindu. So that should settle things regarding where I come from.

Since you seem to know about Buddhism, let me ask you this: What do you think happened to the Buddhists & Hindus living in Afghanistan, Indonesia, parts of India/Pakistan/Bangaldesh, parts of Central Asia, parts of S.E.Asia? What was done to them and how did it happen? I think you know the answer.

What happened to the prosecuted Zoroastrians around 10th/11th century? They fled to India. There are only about 100,000 of them left, and most of them live in India. So where does Dalai Lama has is base now? Dharamasala. Why? He had to flee. Where is the Tibetan Government in Exile? You know the answer. Tibetan Buddhists derive lots of determination because of him being still around. What happened to some of the Jews who were persecuted? Many fled to India to flourish.

You must have heard about the "Goa Inquisition", what had happened to Kashmiri Pundits and several ethnic cleansing around the globe.

You know all of these are facts; but if necessary I can dig up references too - might just take a while.

The point is not about India. The point is all these groups needed a support system to flourish when they were attacked and could not withstand the attack. And, they found something outside the place of their own origin. Unfortunately humans being humans have both good and bad within them. The good or the bad both need to be protected to flourish. Because each is going to try to influence or defeat the other. I am talking at the conceptual level and not any one particular religion or group of people. So it is upto us to decide what we are going to protect - the good or the bad. It is our choice. And the future depends on it.

I myself almost border being a pacifist. You can call me stupid, hard-hearted, a fool or anything but history tells me if one does not put resistance when attacked then s/he is reduced to something insignificant or destroyed. Well some might consider it better to die than kill others. No problem, it is their belief system. Others might not want to do that.
Over the years I have struggled to find several answers. Still searching. But I have come to the conclusion that I might hurt others if it becomes a [b]necessity[/b]. The necessity would hinge upon the "cause". If you are interested you could read "Bhagavad Gita" - its a fascinating piece of work concerning this subject. Ofcourse one can find flaws in some of its wisdom.

I did not want to bring religion or any country into this discussion. I wanted to show you that there are certain beliefs that are universal - A Christian, Muslim, Buddhisht or Hindu can hold. And like Sets in mathematics sometimes they intersect and have common elements, sometimes not.

by onbliss

...I think I have placed my points albeit all over the place in group of words in neat lines :-)

I don't see any pending questions that I need to answer. So let me just summarize and get out.

1. Avoid War (violence) as much as possible.
2. If war is necessary, fight the war to win it. The "cause" is very important factor for resorting to violence.
3. Torture is a tactic to be used, only if it is a necessity. Let there be some monitoring - checks and balances. Let the experts decide when it is needed and what is needed. As general public let us not remove this option from the experts because it is inhumane.
4. And I agree with all of you on the horrible nature of torture.

But if you need me to answer something more.... then I am here.

by jardinier

Okay so the majority opinion is that being maimed for life is preferable to being tortured.

And no, Oz, it cannot be assumed that every person who has been tortured will automatically be killed.

The fact that your grandpa was happy without legs does NOT as you seem to imply nullify the experience of my late neighbour Ted Connor who was a nervous wreck for most of his life after serving in WW II. Now this is something I know about as I myself have suffered nervous disorder for 25 years and have been on a disability pension because of this condition for 22 years.

It is a living hell. If it weren't for the meds that control the symptoms to a certain degree I would have topped myself 20 years ago for sure.

I have been beaten up, but I have not been tortured. I have, however, experienced prolonged chronic pain. Continual headaches for 13 years. And if you want to know what real pain feels like, you might try passing a kidney stone.

Pain ends. Blindness or loss of limbs is forever.

[b]I would like to hear the opinion of someone who has actually been tortured and survived.[/b]

by jardinier

Hi Bliss. I just had a glance at the Gita to refresh my memory as to its contents, and I can see why you are the only person (except for myself I guess) in this discussion who has a pragmatic or realistic view of torture.

Perhaps you would like to share with the rest of us the setting of the Gita and the theme that runs through it.

What is lacking from this torture discussion is a person who has undergone torture and survived, and a person who has spent agonising months in hospital having a serious wound treated, and then left with one or more limbs missing.

by onbliss

I do not wish to have an in depth conversation about it here. For reasons, that I can not place a finger upon, I feel uncomfortable talking about it in these forums. I think I am just scared of myself crossing limits.

But I will be more than happy to exchange emails in private with you on this subject, though. If you are interested, I can email you this weekend.

by oz_media

Does that count? A lazy eye? How about a mole on your kneck where everyone can see it?
I waited for hours to get home the other day, due to Skytrain construction,it was torture AND I had a sore knee, any luck?

How about walking 10 miles home from a bar after puking your guts out?

by dawgit

There are probably a lot more than you realize. While I haven't been able to pick up and really read the Bhavagad Gita since the late 60's when I was doing Far Eastern Studies. I'll still remember the basis of it. And I would say that life long (this one anyway) I've been constantly and consistantly pragmatic and realistic as to this whole thing commonaly called 'Life' on this place called 'Earth'.
And with that in mind, I don't think you'll find any-one who will just 'Talk' about it. Those who have been through such an ordeal usually don't talk. (Real life does not go like the TV shows like Opra)
Just a point, not a criticism. (I happen to argee with you) -d

by oz_media

[i]Your analogy is like asking - "do you prefer to be vaginally or anally raped?" [/i]

See my preferences above, and remember I am male. :)

by oz_media

Jules, "I have been beaten up, but I have not been tortured. I have, however, experienced prolonged chronic pain. Continual headaches for 13 years. And if you want to know what real pain feels like, you might try passing a kidney stone.

Pain ends. Blindness or loss of limbs is forever."

Los so flimbs is generally accepted in exchange for life. As for prolonged pain, I spent a great deal of my childhood in traction and doped on so much demerol and morphine that I don't remember much of it. I have also had whiplash three times, separated a disk, broken spinal vertebrae and other yummy but very painful and long lasting issues. But I am aliveand that's worth all teh pain and suffering I have lived through and still endure. I have had a splitting headachefro about five days now, it doesn't go away, just mellows. Then when that's gone, I will probably have really bad hip pain until teh next kneckache or heaache begins.

That's life, but life is what I have, I tried death (not by choice) didn't like it, remember?

I wasn't trying to imply anything at all, I was merely sharing personal experience.

MY experience, and the experience around me of those who have also suffered and those who face disability for life, seem to prefer life over death; even one guy who was pretty depressed now has a better outlook since losing his legs and living through it.

onbliss: 1,2, I agree, 4 I agree but 3 is ridiculous.

by jardinier

that torture automatically leads to death.

This is most certainly not the case.

With all that stuff you've suffered, I think torture would be like a Sunday School picnic.

Can't you just accept the obvious reality that torture does not automatically lead to death?

Did the Iraqi's at Abu Gahrib Prison die?

Did all the prisoners in the Japanese POW camps die? They most certainly did not despite the fact that one way or another they were tortured almost continuously.

Can you please leave the absurd notion of inevitable death out of the equation and once again try to compare torture with other types of prolonged and painful injuries?

by jardinier

With all these people who are experts on polls and totally cynical and skeptical about them, not one has responded to my poll question.

In case anyone thought it was a joke, it wasn't. But perhaps you are uncomfortable about addressing a poll which almost certainly is free of all the faults you describe in polls in general.

by jardinier

and may Krishna forgive both of us if I don't do it justice.

The setting is a battle that is about to take place and the warrior Arjuna sees that friends, relatives and people whom he highly respects are in both armies. He cannot bring himself to kill these people whom he loves and respects.

So the Lord Krishna (speaking as the absolute God) explains to Arjuna how insignificant and unimportant are the things of this world, including physical life, when compared with the things of the spirit. He admonishes Arjuna and instructs him carry out his duties as a warrior.

[b]Chapter 6, verse 1.

Lord Krishna said: "He who acts because it is his duty, not thinking of the consequences, is really spiritual and a true ascetic; and not he who merely observes rituals or who shuns all action."[/b]

The teachings of Krishna in the Gita are pretty much akin to those of Buddha and also of Jesus the Christ.

Here are links to two online versions of the Bhagavad Gita:

http://hinduism.about.com/library/weekly/extra/bl-gitatext.htm

http://eawc.evansville.edu/anthology/gita.htm

The best English translation I have read is that by Shri Purohit Swami.

The meaning is very clear, but it retains a dignity of language.

by jardinier

The poll question asked for a minimum of [b]three[/b] persons, in numerical order of preference.

by jardinier

As your chosen candidate has made more than five posts, you can list his posts (a minimum of three and a maximum of five) in order of how informative and useful you consider them to be.

by john.a.wills

I do not seem to have noticed any participant claim to be a Muslim. If any Muslim is following the thread, perhaps (s)he would care to make some illuminating remark.

by deepsand

There are far too many here that would be unable to control their irrational selves, so as to respond with unsubstantiated opinions based on cultural and religious biases, so as to render a well mannered discourse virtually impossible.

When your audience perceives you to be the enemy, one must expect to be held up to ridicule and scorn.

by just_chilin

They all seem to come from Pakistan and funded by the Saudis ... There is no threat, all we want is oil

This discussion is closed to new replies.