Discussion Locked

ObamaCare: It's not about medical care; it's about control over your life

0 helpful
752 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tY0ve87vQMs

If an employer was paying, say, $3,000 per year for medical insurance, and the premiums dropped 3,000 percent, then that would mean the Insurance Company would actually start paying the employer $90,000 for the privilege of providing medical insurance. Maybe that employer WOULD give everyone a raise with that kind of windfall! I'm all for that!

Imagine if GWB had made such a gaffe! How the networks, newspapers, and comedy shows would be all over it. Let's see if they treat their own King Barrack the same way.

752 replies

by patb071

Even if that was true (3,000% or $3000). do you think employers would give everyone a raise? This is just to make it so the governemt doesn't pay for medicare, etc.

by puppybreath

You're not allowed to point out any of his mistakes for at least four years.

After all, look at all of the terrible issues that he inherited.

;-)

by jfuller05

you can't poke fun at anything he and his administration does; that would mean you are a bigot.

:^0

by tink!

There are just far too many mistakes being made on this whole healthcare overhaul.

For 1, doing a complete overhaul at one time. Healthcare itself is such an exponential issue there is no way a single bill could properly address it.

I understand his intent, he promised Americans better healthcare and he's trying to fulfill that quickly, but he's going about it all wrong. Wrong angles, wrong approaches, wrong timing, wrong PR, etc etc.

Healthcare changes should have been made little by little so everyone involved (including the people) could understand what was going on and approve or disapprove each individual issue rather than Healthcare itself.

(Reminder - I'm not into politics, this opinion is based mainly on hearsay.)

by tonythetiger

is the refusal to acknowledge the relationship between the cost of claims and the cost of insuring those claims.

by jackofalltech

I don't understand how these Dems can vote for this thing KNOWING they're going to be voted out of office next election.

by whowasthat25

i have always found it interesting that americans will sign a blank check for war, but not for their own health.

just make it a war on bad health.

by jck

Like someone we know who once used a person with a PhD in one field as an expert in another?

BTW, FoxNews and other conservatively-aligned networks and their commentators/hosts did just fine in blowing smoke up Dubya's arse.

I guess Obama being a Democrat means he gets no bias?

Go figure. You're no more a libertarian than Karl Rove.

Freedom of speech is a liberty, whether inaccurate from idiocy or misstatement written wrongly in a speech.

Just because Obama is articulate and didn't have to have his family pay to keep him from failing out of Ivy League schooling is no reason to hold him to a higher standard than Bush.

...unless of course...you are really a Dubya fan...

I'd also like to point something out:

Legislation stopped getting passed when the Democratic majority was broken.

I guess if there's proof of anything that Republicans have been keeping the process from happening, that's one of the biggest indicators.

So...keep on keepin on...my brutha. :p

P.S.- I don't like a lot of things in the healthcare bill myself. And, I've gone to my congresswoman about them. I doubt she'll get either side to listen. They're both out to leverage for votes in November 2010 now than to make real progress.

Vote out the status quo. That's what I say. Vote for an Independent this year.

by puppybreath

a gaffe by a Republican is idiocy and a gaffe by a Democrat is a misstatement?

Thanks for clearing that up.

by jck

a gaffe by Bush didn't require reading a teleprompter that had inaccurate information.

He was able to bumble all on his own. He didn't need a speechwriters help.

by jck

Well, you truly must not know what "partisan" means, because I obviously pointed out in English (that is your native language, right?) that I don't trust either side of the aisle on issues, mainly at this point on healthcare reform.

Of course, your whole point is to go poking at Obama because he's "liberal".

So, keep on making fun of a man who is your president who achieved more on his own, didn't depend on his family's aristocracy, and can actually pronounce words like "nuclear" correctly and actually managed organizations without bankrupting them.

If you ask me, you are just patting poor Bush on the head because you feel sorry for him. Not because you think he's an intelligent being, and attacking Obama because he's not the status quo politician who won't sit there like a smiling face car salesman and blow a tube of smoke up your arse.

Or, maybe you're just jealous of Obama.

Who knows. Libertarians seem to be actually religious nut right-wingers who'll back someone because they can talk like a good ole boy rather than an educated individual.

Good luck. Go dip some skoal and drink some Evan Williams now, "non-partisan".

by puppybreath

"Legislation stopped getting passed when the Democratic majority was broken.

I guess if there's proof of anything that Republicans have been keeping the process from happening, that's one of the biggest indicators."

You had a full year with a super majority but you don't blame Democrats for not getting the job done. No, you wait until you have an excuse to blame those evil Republicans again. How pathetic.

Did it ever occur to you that the reason they couldn't pass the bill, even with a super majority, is because it's a bad bill and they know it?

by jck

[i]You had a full year with a super majority but you don't blame Democrats for not getting the job done. No, you wait until you have an excuse to blame those evil Republicans again. How pathetic.[/i]

First:

Super majority? Hang on. Please. Define for me "super majority" whereas it applies to Congress. I beg you. Is that the 60-40 they had? 2/3 vote needed? 75 votes needed in the Senate? If the 60-40 vote is a "super majority", is the 66-34 vote needed for some things a (to use a spaceballs term) "ludicrous majority"? :^0

Second:

The reason the bill did not go for a vote is because Democrats feared that Republicans would not let any other bills take shape without political war if a vote happened before Ted Kennedy's seat was filled.

The Democrats had gotten several pieces of legislation completed that weren't "cornerstone" pieces, but Fox and Rush won't tell you that...will they?

Now that Republicans have 41 votes in the Senate, you see that they who follow the GOP party headquarters orders are doing everything they can to stop it from happening.

In fact, Mitch McConnell, (R)-KY and Senate Minority Whip, has vocally made it his goal to do everything to stop this from happening even though members of his own party are now starting to break ranks and work to find common ground to put together this proposal to do what's right.

It's that blank stare, hard-line, "i know it all" attitude that some Republicans are taking that is old-school, non-progressive, and ignorant, and is blocking this country from making any progress that benefits all Americans.

As for it being a bad bill, I can say that is the case with any piece of legislation going through the House or Senate. They both have so many earmarks and pork in them nowadays that a funding bill for education can have an earmark to repaint an office building where a Social Security Administration office is located for $5M.

You're going to find an incredibly few, pure, focused, good pieces of legislation on the docket anymore.

That's just an undeniable, unavoidable fact.

BTW, I've never said there wasn't a bad part in that bill. In fact in discussions with my rep via email, I have expressed to her that providing healthcare and welfare assistance and housing assistance in this country to illegal immigrants is costing federal taxpayers tens of billions per year. And that if we stopped that, we could fund most (if not all) the healthcare initiatives we need to.

See, there's a lot more problems than setting up a better healthcare system ...like stopping the massive fraud that we let go on every day because "it serves a purpose".

by jck

Ability to read steadily:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ExFctZ__4Jk

Showing his expertise on the economy:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mfYFKzkgKKk&feature=related

Articulating a direct answer so smoothly:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c8ChWyZZAaA&feature=related

Bush letting the real truth slip:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HZW42AIdwe0&feature=related

Keeping the interest of America's youth:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wDwbP-LPGE4&feature=related

What a great orator! :^0

by jmgarvin

We will be a non-competitor on the world stage if we continue to treat health care as a privilege, rather than a right.

We are not getting the best and the brightest to immigrate here simply because they have a better quality of life where they are.

America has forgotten why it is so great.

by maxwell edison

My answer: because all too many Americans expect someone else to pay for it; and because all too much of it is paid for by someone else.

Point of accuracy: [i]health care[/i], per se, costs nothing, and it should be the sole responsibility of the individual - in as much as one's choice to maintain a healthy lifestyle. The delivery of [i]medical care[/i], on the other hand, is what's become too inefficient and too expensive. The point being, healthy people do not need medical care.

The dirty little secret is this: medical insurance - which adds a HUGE overhead to the delivery of medical care - does absolutely nothing to improve the quality of medical care - in fact, it reduces the quality. Moreover, medical insurance does absolutely nothing to keep the cost of medical care down - in fact, it increases the cost.

Considering such, why in the hell do we want to expand the system that created most - if not all - of the problems to begin with?

by jackofalltech

If, magically suddenly, health insurance disappeared, costs would drop tremendously as providers realized they had priced themselves out of the market.

by santeewelding

Develop that.

The difference between "health care" and "medical care".

If nothing else, it would clear the air of phantoms.

by jmgarvin

How could one possibly afford to pay for cancer treatments, under our current system, without insurance?

To further that, how could one, under our current system, afford simply procedures like removing bunion without insurance?

The answer is you can't. Sure the bunion surgery may only cost $5k out of pocket, but many people just can't afford that without some help.

I agree that we need to get rid of the whole idea of insurance, but good luck with that.

by stephanisat_z

then are you saying that you have a right to infringe upon the rights of the doctors, nurses, medical technicians, and other healthcare professionals to achieve that right? A right is something inherent to our beings; it is not a thing that enhances us or our well-being. I do not have the right to force someone to take care of me or my family.

by jmgarvin

By having a healthy productive member of society, I have another tax payer and spender in the private market.

It is counter productive to have sick people in society.

by maxwell edison

It's a responsibility.

One is responsible for one's own life. Do you agree or disagree? If you break your toe because you dropped a hammer on it, then it's your responsibility to tend to that little matter. Do you agree or disagree? If you get lung cancer because you smoked two packs a day for thirty years, then it's your responsibility to deal with that outcome. Do you agree or disagree?

The whole argument is not about rights or privileges. It's about responsibility. And once you pass on those responsibilities to anyone else, you'll also relinquish your rights to control the issue and determine the outcome.

This notion that [i]medical care is a right[/i] is one of the silliest - and most destructive - things I've ever heard.

by jmgarvin

1) I agree one is responsible for ones own health. However, when price is out the reach of mere mortals, how do we continue as a society? If I am losing productive members of society or redirecting all their income to medical care, I am hurting society as a whole.

2) I agree about the smoker. However, let's look at auto insurance. If I am a careful driver and I don't get into accidents or get tickets, I am rewarded on my insurance.

With health insurance if I don't smoke, drink, and I'm fit, I am punished because others on the same policy may be.

We also have to look at the aging population and ask, do we head to the world of Logan's Run or do we care for the elderly?

Medical is a right. If I was in a bank during a robbery and was shot, if I couldn't afford medical care, I should just die?

by theprofessordan

Because we have the best medical advances in the world. And why is that? Because of capitalism. Our system encourages companies like pharmaceutical companies to develop cutting edge technology so that these companies can make money. If you turn healthcare over to the government, the incentive for these companies to develop new technologies that will in the future save lives will go away and society will lose out. All you need to do is look at the great job that the government has done with things like the Stimulus package to see how badly they mismanage anything they touch.

by puppybreath

With this administration, there's bribes, threats, and of course a free ride in Air Force One for a few that can be easily coerced.

by maxwell edison

When and how did the insurance industry best serve the needs of the medical consumer without breaking the banks of the consumer, without running up the costs of delivering medical care, and without dictating when and how medical care was delivered? In short, when did it work best?

The answer is not now, when we have [i]health insurance[/i], nor was it when we had [i]medical insurance[/i], but when we had, what used to be called, [i]hospitalization insurance[/i]. When we used to walk into our doctor's office and the first question they asked was, [i]what seems to be the problem[/i], not [i]who is your insurance carrier[/i]? When we paid for - out of pocket - everything from bumps and bruises, checkups, and simple procedures like removing bunions and even setting a simple bone fracture.

Insurance was never even considered until one had to be hospitalized for a major procedure or ailment - thus, [i]hospitalization insurance[/i].

If we want to make it (the whole system) better, we need to get rid of third-party interference. If we want to make it worse, then implement even more third-party interference. If we want to make it better, put more of the responsibility - and control - onto the medical consumer. If we want to make it worse, then relinquish that responsibility - which will also relinquish control - onto a third-party payer.

And I also think that people actually expect to always have a cure for, and a way to prevent death. There is no cure for death, and there never will be - regardless of how much of other people's money - and/or our kid's money - we throw at it.

by maxwell edison

When other people have to provide goods and services to you (medical goods and services, in this case), you have no such right to demand it.

The underlying premise of your comment is just silly.

by maxwell edison

Your claim that being provided medical care is a [i]right[/i]; that is what I called silly.

[i]We hold these Truths to be self-evident, that all Men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.[/i]

unalienable Rights = natural rights = those which cannot be bestowed upon one person by another, nor can they be taken away by another.

A person has a [i]right[/i] to treat himself medically, but no [i]right[/i] exists to force others to treat him.

Your definition and use of the word [i]right[/i] is just dead-wrong.

by jck

I've pointed this out to you, and TonytheTiger as well, prior to this:

The rest of the country pays for your public roads, your public schools, your public parks, your public utilities, etc., through federal subsidizations.

Believe you me: Colorado is NOT one of the 5 largest tax providing states in this country. So, a state like mine is paying for you to have good highways even though boulderfalls and snow and ice ruin them year after year.

So, stop whining til you pay for all your own services.

You're on the dole too. It's just that it's "established" and you think that makes it right for you to have and use as you wish.

So "other people have to provide goods and services to you" too.

Remember that the next time you take that family driving trip on an interstate through the mountains.

by maxwell edison

.... the flaw in that silly argument. Paying for necessary infrastructure (roads, etc.) is vastly different than paying for another's medical care.

Moreover, as it pertains to Colorado (or any other state, for that matter), let's let the states keep their own tax dollars. I'm not in favor at all of paying tax dollars to the feds only to have them make the rules because they simply send it back.

by tonythetiger

is for everyone to pay exactly (as near as can be figured) the amount in taxes as the value of the services they use. If you can't pay, you shouldn't use. You were not endowed by your creator to force someone else to pay your way.

by puppybreath

So Obama never reads his speeches ahead of time, he just reads whatever he sees on his teleprompter.

Yep, that makes him FAR more intelligent than Bush.

We'll just continue to blame all of his mistakes on staffers and teleprompters.

by jck

you're saying intelligence is based on how far ahead you read your speeches?

Now...that is funny.

Again, just go back and look at Bush when he's prompterless vs Obama. Many time, Bush can't even remember what the topic is, let alone form a response.

Bush was just a bumbling idiot. His work ethic shows it (most vacation days by a president ever), his personal business career shows it (bankrupted companies, lost jobs), his educational career shows it (would have failed out of college if not for an endowment from his family), etc.

Of course, I guess it's wrong for Obama to have come up in middle class upbringing, work to get into an Ivy League school, and aspire to do community initiatives rather than pursue a high-paying career with a huge firm?

Sure, I'll fault Obama for being successful because of his own efforts rather than having to lay back on his family's name and opulence.

Right. Obama is so bad for being articulate and self-made. Good point.

by jck

watch the interview that Fox just did with him.

No teleprompter.

by puppybreath

says "But we have to pass the bill so that you can find out what is in it, away from the fog of the controversy.?

you're still OK with passing it? You want them to pass a bill without even knowing what it contains?

Unbelievable!

by jck

I stated to you before. I don't like either side of the aisle. Especially that they have been essentially buying votes by putting in earmarks.

At least the people of Nebraska had the decency to tell their senator to turn down earmarks that were unfair.

Of course now, the Republicans have taken everything behind closed doors. So, who knows what other deals are being made.

I bet there's more spit swapping going on now than at a statewide prom night.

by jck

Oh well. Maybe Rush will show you clips to make you believe the whole thing is how he wants it to be spun.

The interviewer evidently had no understanding of how an interview works, being that it's a essentially a Q&A session rather than interrupting the statement you asked for 75% of the time.

I think I'd rather watch Rush for 15 minutes than that guy who did it. How he ever got a job in journalism is beyond me.

Maybe because he's willing to pick a fight.

by jck

They have come out with new, broad terms since I had poli sci in college. Or, my professors never covered it. So much for higher education.

Evidently a supermajority is a requirement met that is considered anything above a basic majority.

We always discussed it as a "required vote".

So in the Senate, the Democrats had just the 60 votes needed before Brown's election.

Technically it's a supermajority. Of course as I said. If 60 is a supermajority. Then when 66 votes are needed, it is a supersupermajority?

It seems to make no sense. Of course, seems nothing does these days.

There are many "supermajority"s. So the term has a definition, but it's not statically defined.

You are right. I am wrong. Supermajorities exist like stars. They all work basically the same, but you can make as many different kinds as you want/need.

by tonythetiger

It's because he's progressive (e.g. Woodrow Wilson).

If he'd went to school BEFORE the progressives had the chapter on Wilson cut out of the textbooks, he'd probably not have wanted to be associated with the movement.

by jck

Is a term that's thrown around like "communism" is thrown around by those who don't like a government program to improve medical efficiency and treatment for everyone.

Progressive is also an insurance carrier, whose commercials with that woman annoy the hell out of me.

But, here's what is important: Obama wants to improve treatment and cut spending over the long term with regard to medical care.

Is Congress (both sides) really doing that? No. They're playing political footsie now.

To be honest I've even heard some partisan tones coming out of my own rep. I expressed to her this wasn't about Democrat this or Republican that. It was that both sides were wrangling for bragging rights in November, rather than doing what is right for the country.

Our country needs new leadership, and not the GOP or DNC backed drones that we get every year.

Personally as much as people think he's a kook, I'd like to see Jesse Ventura become president with someone like a Frank Keating as VP.

We need no-nonsense, forward-moving juggernauts to take over things and tell the two major parties to take their political agendas and stick it up their butts.

by tonythetiger

nothing in this bill will improve medical treatment or efficiency. All it will do is postpone the (full) cost of these services until after we're all dead.... our grandchildren will pay for it, however... dearly!

by jmgarvin

We agree the current system is broken and we agree insurance is the major part of the problem.

However, you cannot magically get rid of medical insurance and the lobby for the insurance industry is far too strong.

So what do you propose?

How would that person (that got shot) get care if they couldn't afford it?

by jmgarvin

You have a right to life and not to die because you are being denied medical care by your insurance company or just because you were in the wrong place at the wrong time and got shot in a bank robbery.

Further, we are destroying our productivity and providing disincentives for smart, useful members of society to come here or stay here.

Long story short: because of piss poor accessibility to the best medical care in the world, were are losing our competitive edge in the world market.

by jck

See in Maxwell's world, you are dependent on the "good faith" of others.

However if you have no family or friends and there are no compassionate doctors near in his system: you die.

I had insurance, and I *still* had to depend on a hospital to be willing to take my case as an emergency since I was in the situation of possible losing my ability to walk or even breathe.

So, insurance really is nothing good other than to pay money out to a few people who can afford to invest in it. And, often that profit they get from their investment is at the degraded service of a patient who needs proper care.

Trust me: I know. I went through over $130k in care last year. And, that $2500 out of pocket maximum they claimed i had??

It cost me about $5k.

Go figure.

by maxwell edison

You're working from a desired end-conclusion and working backwards to justify your desire to force other people to pay for your medical care. It's simply absurd.

The word [i]Life[/i] in the context used in the Declaration of Independence (and the Declaration of Rights) means that a person cannot own another person (see note); that a person is in control of his own life and his own destiny; that he is master of his own domain.

To suggest that another person is obligated to pay for another's medical care (or anything else, for that matter) is to deny that other person the [i]right[/i] to his own life.

Note: Please, no slavery comments. We already know.

by jck

[i]You're working from a desired end-conclusion and working backwards to justify your desire to force other people to pay for your medical care. It's simply absurd.[/i]

As are you.

You work from the desired conclusion that your view of the meaning of the forefathers is the end-all of opinion.

a) unalienable rights = natural rights?

Wrong. Someone naturally born in the USA does not get his or her rights in Mexico. Therefore, they are not natural but conditionally geographical at best.

[i]The word Life in the context used in the Declaration of Independence (and the Declaration of Rights) means that a person cannot own another person (see note); that a person is in control of his own life and his own destiny; that he is master of his own domain.[/i]

Under the forefathers, "the pursuit of happiness" included that of Benjamin Franklin getting drunk, and Thomas Jefferson's was having liaisions with multiple women including slave women he owned.

So, the Bill of Rights protects adultery and public nuisance?

[i]To suggest that another person is obligated to pay for another's medical care (or anything else, for that matter) is to deny that other person the right to his own life.[/i]

In the strictest definition, the Rights granted you by that document means no one else should be subsidizing roads to your ski resorts, interstates dynamited through mountains, etc.

It backs more of the model I'd like to see: that of Jamestown Virginia.

You earn your way unless too small or too infirmed.

If you are too lazy and no one takes pity on you, you starve and die.

People decide to work together and contribute toward a common good for all. Not just who they think worthy.

OF course, the forefathers had no medical insurance, big hospitals, walk-in clinics, social security, medicare/medicaid, AARP, or GOP or DNC.

They had each other. Something a lot of people have forgotten how to be: part of a community and common cause.

by jck

Running that highway off to Vail or Breckenridge is necessary?

Living 15,000 feet in the mountains is necessary?

You see what *you* want as a necessary infrastructure.

I see taking care of the medical well being of our citizens as more important than having federally-funded state highways to ski resorts that are privately held.

Silly? I don't think so. It's common sense.

Remember that "...,promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity" writing they did too?

I don't think giving only those with money basic medical care promotes a general welfare.

Otherwise, we wouldn't need Mexicans tiling the floor at your local resort hotel. We could be keeping tax-paying Americans healthy and working for the economic stability of our nation.

I guess to you, "he who has the gold makes the rules" tho.

Go figure.

by maxwell edison

Natural Rights differ from legal rights.

[i]"Natural rights are those which appertain to man in right of his existence. Of this kind are all the intellectual rights, or rights of the mind, and also all those rights of acting as an individual for his own comfort and happiness, which are not injurious to the natural rights of others."[/i] --Thomas Paine, Rights of Man, 1791.

jck, why do I bother with you? You really don't have a clue.

by jmgarvin

You keep changing the topic.

What about the person that was shot? Does that person die because they can't pay for medical care?

by tonythetiger

Pelosi is considering "deeming" it passed.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-executing_rule

Unconstitutional in my opinion, but Democrats think it will allow "deniability" this fall.

The CBO said $840 billion, but if their track record of understatement holds, it'll end up somewhere between 8 and 14 trillion. And that's just in government spending!
Out-of-pocket costs will likely increase as well!

by maxwell edison

..... in a bank during a robbery, that would, most likely, be covered under the bank's liability insurance. Any lawyer worth his salt could make that happen.

Okay, now you'll change it to a guy getting shot on the street!

But we're not talking about these rare and isolated incidents. We're talking about blanket medical care for everyone, under all circumstances, regardless of anything. Your anecdotal stories about isolated and uncommon instances is only a ploy to divert from the real debate.

by jmgarvin

You are dismissing arguments that you can't answer is what it boils down to.

You want to have other insurance pick up health insurance. You are just doing a shuffle, not a fix.

by maxwell edison

I answered your question.

It is YOU who is dismissing the underlying premise upon which any argument should be based.

YOU want to force other people to pay for YOUR medical needs, plain and simple. I, on the other hand, am willing to accept full and total responsibility for my own needs - medical or otherwise - and just let the chips fall where they may.

Moreover, YOU want to act charitable with other people's dollars under the guise of caring about others. But you don't really care about others - unless you can do it by forcing everyone else into your warped way of thinking.

YOU and your ilk are bankrupting this country, plain and simple. The 12 TRILLION (plus) debt - and growing - is because of YOU and YOUR ilk making people dependent on government. YOU and your ilk are destroying America.

If you have kids, you tell them it is THEY who must assume YOUR debt.

We have less freedom and liberty in America today than we had yesterday. And tomorrow, with the passage of government takeover of even more private business and private lives, we'll have even less.

Consider this. Wars are waged to regain freedom and liberty, not to relinquish it. And unless things change quickly, keep your powder dry. When you attempt to force people to do things they don't want to do, you better be ready for the consequences. Unfortunately, it will most likely happen on the watch our kids inherit. I hope you're good with that.

by maxwell edison

..... to pass legislation without a legitimate vote on a clear and concise bill, will go down in history as the most corrupt Congress in the history of America, AND as the Congress that put our Republic, the United States of America, on the road to its final destruction.

Sleep well.

by jck

Kinda like Bush Jr. and Reagan running our country into economic demise?

BTW, Max. Don't know if you heard the news this morning, but the Congressional Budget office says that the legislation is going to save almost $200B over it's 10 year projection.

Boy, $20B a year back to put into roads, schools, military, etc., would be such a travesty now wouldn't it?

Have a nice day.

by pser

"Kinda like Bush Jr. and Reagan running our country into economic demise?"

You've got this one, jck!

Keep 'em in check brother, I ain't got much time these days to post OT....

by puppybreath

they did promise transparency and change with this administration.

So they'll be transparent on how they'll beat the system and will change any rules that get in the way of their agenda or will make new rules to make it easier to fleece the public.

by maxwell edison

America is doomed. I just don't know what I can do about it.

If you have a suggestion, I'm all ears.

P.S. For some reason, I really think you understand what I mean.

by santeewelding

Growing nervous. Real nervous.

Further, in addition, what I can do about it begins with the notion of concentric circles.

Lord, God, have mercy on who would breech the nth, as well as, me.

by jck

the Congressional Budget office says it's going to cut the deficit.

That is fiscal efficiency.

So, your grandchildren will not be paying for anything...and, mine won't cause I don't even have any children yet. :^0

by jck

I have no clue?

You go down to Nogales then wearing some jewelry at night and see how much "Natural Rights" you have.

It has nothing to do with law. Has to do with nature, and who the "alpha" being is there.

And I guarantee you, the alpha there is the 20-some drug dealer with the automatic rifle at your head.

Natural rights my arse. What you consider natural rights are privileges granted you under law...nothing to do with nature.

Go figure.

by jck

Max will say he is for it and that it is "needed", but that it's not "necessary" because he might have to pay something into a system that he doesn't want to.

If he doesn't get a benefit from it, it's a rip-off of the taxpayer.

If he gets a benefit from it, it's "necessary".

He still can't justify US taxpayers paying for new highways all the time through passes in CO where rockslides and weather tear them up when all they do is go to resorts and posh communities.

Why not put those roads to industry sites instead, where thousands are employed rather than a resort where maybe a hundred are? Fiscally more responsible.

But, it doesn't indulge the right people who have the politicians in their pocket.

Max and others like him remind me of a guy named Scott DePace who works on a satellite radio show. He sees his indulgences are necessary and, sadly, even to the point of missing his childrens' small activities so that he gets to have what he wants.

Personal need = must have
Personal sacrifice = must avoid

It's the twisted, rose-colored selfish world that a lot of America lives in nowadays...sadly enough.

Oh well. Just let me hit the lotto and I'll solve it for myself. I'll take my jackpot and go live in a cottage in rural Ireland and drink Guinness and walk the coast daily.

by puppybreath

Why would you quote the CBO when all they've done is guess?

"Although CBO completed a preliminary review of legislative language prior to its release, the agency has not thoroughly examined the reconciliation proposal to verify its consistency with the previous draft. This estimate is therefore preliminary, pending a review of the language of the reconciliation proposal, as well as further review and refinement of the budgetary projections."

So you want them to pass a bill before anyone sees what's in it and before the CBO can use valid data to determine projected costs?

Brilliant!

by theprofessordan

for those that are stuck in the middle. The truth is that the rich have medical insurance and the poor have medical insurance (which we all pay for). I just don't think that the answer is to turn it over to the most inept group of people alive, the government.

But I will side with you in the sense that we do need a way to address the middle ground, the self employed, the unemployed or the people whose jobs don't offer health insurance.

by theprofessordan

I really can see both of your points. Max you are correct that health insurance is not a right, it is something that you earn, that you purchase. On the flip side, Garvin was correct in that we need to show compassion to others. Life matters. I am blessed to have a good job that offers me health insurance. But October of 2008, I got laid off and from November of that year up to June of 2009, I had no insurance. My kids had CHIP but my wife and I were basically uninsured. I did worked as an Adjunct Professor during that time and I collected unemployment, but like Garvin's example, if I had been shot or in a car accident, I would have been SOL. The last comment I have to make is in regards to people not migrating to the U.S. because of the issues with health care. I don't see that as an issue myself because people coming to this country have drive and ambition and aren't looking for hand outs. Trust me, you don't hear them complaining like natural born US citizens to.

by maxwell edison

The best solutions to those individual problems are not found through a larger and more intrusive government bureaucracy controlling an entire industry. In fact, not only will it fail to solve those problems; and not only will it make the whole system worse for everyone; and not only will it drive, what is most likely, the final nail into the coffin of Lady Liberty; but it will bankrupt the nation and pass an enormous debt onto the backs of the next generations - your and my kids and grandkids. Medicare alone - and that's not considering Social Security - is a $50 Trillion unfunded mandate.

The solutions lie in those things that made America great in the first place - and that's not government control over what was once free enterprise, and it's not government interference into the lives of those who were once free individuals.

Like I told jmgarvin, those anecdotal stories about isolated and uncommon instances is only a ploy to divert from the real debate, and to replace a realistic and rational approach to finding solutions with emotional knee-jerk reactions that only serve one's need to "feel good".

P.S. I also take exception to the [i]we should be compassionate[/i] argument. You can be compassionate towards others, and I encourage you to be so; I can be - and am - compassionate towards others; but when one person tries to force another person into compliance with his own notion of compassion, we're walking on a slippery slope - especially when others find it not compassionate at all, but rather destructive.

As an example, there is absolutely nothing [i]compassionate[/i] with a system that made so many people dependent on government, was instrumental in creating several generations of fatherless families, and breaks the spirit of individuals. I'm talking about LBJ's [i]Great Society[/i] programs, and the ill-fated [i]War on Poverty[/i]. Not only did the effort fail to reduce the numbers of people living in poverty (whatever that definition is), but it created more of it.

Get ready for the Great Society II.

P.P.S. Perhaps a good rule-of-thumb is this. Government has no business conducting business, and business has no business governing people.

As such, perhaps one might find solutions by considering two things: the government has delved too deep into the business of business; and the medical insurance industry is no longer conducting business, but rather governing the practices of free enterprise (the medical delivery system) and the choices of free people. As such, the best fix to free enterprise problems are free enterprise solutions.

P.P.P.S. Why is it that we always refer to those in Congress as [i]idiots[/i], but yet we turn to them to solve our problems? Who are the real [i]idiots[/i], here?

by maxwell edison

The government of the United States of America was created to guarantee and protect those [i]natural rights of man[/i]; the government of Mexico was not.

I suppose that's why Mexicans flock into the USA in droves, while Americans are not exactly flocking south.

Like I said, you have no clue.

Debating with jck is either too easy or an effort in futility - or perhaps a lot of both.

I'm amazed at how much you say, jck, but how little you know.

by dr dij

we in the US tend to want health care with EVERYTHING POSSIBLE done for health problem. We have this grandeur delusion where nothing is too expensive for us. Billion dollar aircraft carriers, jets, and same goes for health care. Even when we DON'T have the money.

There will be two possible outcomes of govt health care:
1) they keep the spending reasonable meaning that then people get care rationed. This is probably the more sensible option.
And our will to survive will dampen this possibility - 25% of medicare goes to people in the last stages of life

2) they spend whatever anyone wants for healthcare and spending goes out of control, mirroring today's out of control private spending.

Govt already controls 25% or so of the current spending which is why out of control to some degree, plus people wanting ever more capability from their health care providers.

the second thing that people plugging for govt health care is that 'the insurance companies were 30% overhead' that wasn't supposedly needed.

What actually happens in govt health care is that there is just as much overhead, in a different form:
fraud.
Currently 30% of medicare is fraudulent according to many estimates.

This is likely to increase to even larger amounts for a new plan like this, and will only be slightly decreased when people become enraged.

Govt buyers have no incentive to save. either on medical supplies or drugs. Lobbyists will plug for increased payments (tho they did just reduce medicare payments).

by dr dij

is that it will mean changes,
some of us will like the free care
others will find problems like I mentioned and these will be real people who don't like the care much as some don't like the state of care for veterans (govt run) or medicare (govt run), not just tea party gripers.

i.e. it won't be a panacea
it may also encourage illegal immigration. people cross now to have free hospital care for newborns and citizenship automatically bestowed on the baby.
as in countries of the EU the low wage immigrants are major beneficiarys of free health care.

if we choose the endless spending option of universal health care, we will go broke

if we choose the rationing, some people will die. (not as horrible as it sounds, will likely be people who would have been 'not long for this world', and would have died soon after regardless of what was done)

our current system rations by virtue of being able to pay for the procedures or life prolonging devices and people die now from lack of some of these. yet we can't give every possible device or care to every possible person, there is not enuf money, allied health people trained to do these or places to put all the people.

What I'm saying is that it is a big mess, with or without govt healthcare and it won't be cleaned up instantly by implementing this.

My wife is worried that we also may be penalized by govt for me not covering her under my healthcare plan. We made a conscious decision not to as it would take another couple hundred a month out of my paycheck and we are already living partly on savings.

I told her that it wasn't likely as poor people who have no job will likely be given free care.

by tonythetiger

[i]We have this grandeur delusion where nothing is too expensive for us.[/i]

My dentist wanted $6,500 to straighten my bottom teeth. I said "I don't think so." :)

[i]Currently 30% of medicare is fraudulent according to many estimates.
[/i]

If medicare actually paid all of what it was billed, the fraud would be two and a half times worse!

by dr dij

I think my previous dental company was committing fraud: they billed blue cross for something like $3,900 for crowns that I saw on the EOB. Yet I ALSO paid amounts for those same crowns directly to them.

At one point when I was OFF insurance and I told them that I would pay cash, the price didn't change. Looks like they were double dipping.

Just because my dentist is a red hot gal doesn't make this right.

I'm hoping to help invent a robo-dentist process that can do common procedures including growing and reforming new teeth or implants for much cheaper. Well I can only dream!

by tonythetiger

You know, Medicaid pays on average 30% of what it is billed, medicare 40. They consider it payment in full, so it balances on the government sheets, but guess where the other 60 or 70% comes from? Higher prices to everyone else, of course! In fact, a good case could be made for the government being a significant factor in the higher medical costs we are now enjoying.

Oh, and the clever little trick Democrats are pulling, putting the medicare fix in separate legislation, puts it in the red. Of course, every estimate the CBO has ever made has been low... by a range of 45% to over 2500%!

Like your buddy, Perriello said... "if you don't tie our hands, we will keep stealing."

http://tinyurl.com/yetn6zg

by tonythetiger

[i]However, when price is out the reach of mere mortals, how do we continue as a society?[/i]

One mortal at a time.

[i]We also have to look at the aging population and ask, do we head to the world of Logan's Run or do we care for the elderly?[/i]

Care for whomever YOU [u]choose[/u] to care for. I'll do the same.

[i]If I was in a bank during a robbery and was shot, if I couldn't afford medical care, I should just die? [/i]

The bank would probably pay your expenses, either medical, or final...

by jmgarvin

I just don't understand the arguments. If the bank is going to take care of it, why not just fix the messed up insurance industry?

If we dumped all the money we are paying in Iraq into medical costs, we could cover everyone in NORTH AMERICA...you do realize that, right?

by tonythetiger

[i]You have a right to life and not to die because you are being denied medical care by your insurance company or just because you were in the wrong place at the wrong time and got shot in a bank robbery.[/i]

if you are trapped in a burning house? Can you force someone to come in and rescue you?

by stephanisat_z

Rights are inherent. The Constitution states what the government cannot do; it does not grant us rights. It is counter productive to have unemployed people in society, so do people now have the "right" to a job? Health care is essential, but it is neither a right nor a responsibility of the government.

by tonythetiger

is simple. One human, in isolation, can do, say, or think, anything within his capabilities and his desires. The only thing a government CAN do is take away from that.

The question is: What right does a government have to do that?

by puppybreath

in no particular order:

Tort reform

Amend the McCarran-Ferguson Act to allow interstate competition for health insurance.

Prohibit the federal government from regulating insurance companies, except for normal laws and regulations that apply to all companies.

Make the exclusive regulator of insurance companies the state of the company's home office.

If you force the insurance companies to have to compete with one another in a free market, they'll either have to give the consumers what they want at a fair price or they'll be forced out of business.

by jmgarvin

The Fire Department.

They will actually come save you from a burning building and it is run by the government.

by jmgarvin

The cost of health insurance, the ability of insurance to drop you when you get sick, and the total lack of impetus on the insurance companies to actually want competition?