Discussion Locked

One Subnet or Two?

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Network with 2 Subnet: 192.168.0.0,192.168.10.0.
about 300 workstations
A linux Server act as a Gateway.One NIC with binded with 2 IPs(192.168.0.250,192.168.10.250)
We have this problem now:
when some workstations try to open files on servers which is located on another subnet,sometimes error occurs(fail to open word,access files)

Now,I suggest two solutions:
1.Add another NIC on the Linux Gateway.
2.Use 255.255.254.0 netmask,and change these two subnet into one
Which is better?

Any assistance is high appreciated.

6 replies

by chvaughan

Tell me more information about the networks.
1. how are the machines getting their IP's assigned?
2. What are the IP range for each network?
3. How many machines on each subnet?
4. Do you know why the subnets are seperated?
5. How are the files being access? Browser? Telnet? Mapped network drive?

300 unit's can function on one subnet. Just make sure there is not a good reason they were seperated to start with. Be sure yiou understand the impact of changing subnets, ie.. how manysystems will you have to touch, plus other network equipment on that subnet. The simple solution might be to put the files on a server on the subnet where they are needed!

by kevin_li

Thanks:
1.Most clients get ip by DHCP.some have static IPs.
2.192.168.0.0 range: 192.168.0.1-192.168.0.254
192.168.10.0 range: 192.168.10.0-192.168.10.254
3.Because clients get ip by DHCP,so numbers of Machines on each subnet is not static,butI nealy half on each one.
4.why they seperated: a. isolate the broadcast
b. only 255 clients with the netmask 255.255.255.0
5.Mapped Network drive.(some time try to open big word or access file)
telnet and browser should be ok.
P.S.: we have wins server on this network.
any each workstations notype is Hybird.

by ckilday

Another question about your network: Are you using switches or hubs for your connections? If your segments are hubbed, you could be experiencing timeouts due to collisions. As you say, you have two segments with about 150 users on each one. In order to access servers on the other segment, everyone has to go through the single Linux gateway. As the other person responded, it may be time to consider installing servers on each segment so the users don't have to traverse the gateway. If you are using hubs, give serious consideration to replacing them with switches. It removes the collision problem altogether. Some switches are manageable, stackable and still under $700 ea. for 24 ports. Non-managed, stackable units run around $300 for 24 ports.

Another consideration is your protocol. Netbeui sends a lot of broadcasts and contributes to congestion. TCP/IP is "better behaved". Hope this helps. Best wishes,
- ck

by kevin_li

No,all this connetor is Switch,no hub.
and TCP/IP is the only one in my network.
what I wonder if I put them into one Subnet(all 300 workstations),what would be the performance like?

This discussion is closed to new replies.