Discussion Locked

One thing I really appreciate about this place...

0 helpful
16 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

It's how there can be a thermonuclear explosion of rage in one thread, and then the same people can be perfectly civil in another one, right next to it.

I found out the rarity of this when I just now got kicked off a discussion group... apparently I was bad for calling a pompous ass on his ill-supported views, and even more bad for sticking up for myself when his compadres started in on me.

Seem I have a character flaw; when three different people start harping on me for being a fascist because I want proper arguments and not misunderstood aforisms - well, it turns out that under those circumstances I start writing arguments cast in plutonium. They didn't like that one bit. EDIT: Don't worry, it was in my native Danish... I know that language well.

But then, ok, it would've been pretty futile to stay there, seeing as how that would've been a sort of insurgency that I can't really justify. I just didn't realize just how badly out of sync the respective views of good conduct were.

So, I'm just venting a bit, now. Hope you don't mind.
But hey, this can be another Rants'R'Us thread, like that one Jaqui did a year ago ;)

16 replies

by seanferd

These are not for everyone, apparently.

Yep. At TR, generally, I find you can walk away to another thread with the same characters and you don't have to be concerned with anything bleeding over. Generally.

by santeewelding

Kicked off here or some other site?

The trick in either case is to strike fatally and leave no opponent alive. In order to do that, the Force must be strong with you. Argument otherwise is trifling and a waste of your time.

by ansugisalas

Can't tell if they were fatal - but anyway, those things don't kill right away... it's the eventual blood loss what gets them.

EDIT:No, not here. An informal debate mailing list for debating the state of the Danish tongue... apparently it was supposed to be just a place for lamenting arbitrary events so as to be able to wallow in ones own betterness... not my kind of scene, and not a play I'm really capable of pulling off, either. Funny thing is, I was invited there because they wanted to get some life into it, because they had a steady gang of people with pretty much the same opinions on things. Now they know they like it that way, too. :D

by nicknielsen

I made a serious attempt to learn it in the late 70s/early 80s. I was temporarily diverted by "ein øl" (Thy Pilsner, in this case <:o) ), but I persevered.

After a couple of years, I knew many of the words, but still had not succeeded in learning to gargle my tongue. :^0

by hal 9000

To expect Logical Arguments from some here.

Remember never let the Facts get in the way of a rant by those who truly believe what it is that they are rabbiting on about so stupidly. :0

Col

by charliespencer

There have been a number of times when I've been cyber-screaming at a member in one discussion while supporting him or her 100% in another less than 10 minutes later. Jaqui and I have come to blows several times, but disagreeing with someone doesn't mean you can't respect him.

I don't have much experience on forums outside this one, but I find the standard around here is for a reasoned, supported position. Attempting anything less risks mass mockery.

by jaqui

and yet we also manage to remember, it's opinion differences, not personal dislike. :)

and those differences are what help us to re-examine things, possibly even learn something new.

by ansugisalas

You'll usually hear them complaining how their tongue is dry... that's why Carlsberg had such a good basis for going International :p

by gsg

I would rather have a well thought out argument with someone who could back up his/her views with well thought out evidence or reasons why that person took the view, and then read/listened to my view with my well thought out evidence or reason, than to have a discussion where people don't support their views.

Come on, try to convince me that your opinon is right by giving me some reasons. Don't just get mad at me becuase my opinion is different, yet not be able to support why you think your view is correct.

It sounds like you're better off being off that forum, because they sound like idiots, or worse, fanatics. Fanatics don't care about supporting why their opinon is correct, they just want to bully you into supporting their opinion, and if you won't then you're the "enemy".

by ansugisalas

One of these people took offence with me when I first joined, because I wrote derisively about the DPP - that's the infamous Danish Peoples Party - (Dansk Folkeparti). But since they are hyperpopulists, and against every value I hold to be Danish, I usually call them the Un-danish Mobrule Party = Udansk Pøbelfront.

One person there who was ok said I probably could get back in if I keep a less aggressive style.

Yeah - Thanks, but no thanks. I can be civil, I think, but why would I want to go out of my way to suffer fools, when I can spend that time on better things?

This all reminds me of an anecdote about the Ludvig Holberg a great Danish-Norwegian playwright (1684-1754):
He had, to his credit, managed to irritate the royal armed forces, and one day an he came face to face with an irate officer on a narrow sidewalk on a muddy Copenhagen side street.
This officer, red faced and fuming, plants his legs widely, spanning the sidewalk, and sneers : "I don't step aside for Idiots!"
Holberg raises an eyebrow, steps into the muddy street with a flourish, saying : "[b]I[/b] do."

Can you imagine the suffocating rage in that petty lackey's mind, as he realized how historically he'd just had his figurative nuts cut off - at eye level?

by ansugisalas

With Finnish I subscribe to the saying that "it's not difficult, just different".
With Danish, I think it's probably the other way around "not so different (from english), but difficult".
Especially the r-sound and the glottal "std" (a complete or partial closing of the larynx, that is, the vocal cords, mid-sound)... but also a funky way to produce word stress helps mix it up.

Og ja, jeg kan godt huske at Thy Pilsner er en rigtig god øl!

This discussion is closed to new replies.