Discussion Locked

Problems with Auto-Negotiate?

0 helpful
1 reply
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We are implementing a new core routing switch for our client. The client insists on auto-negotiate on all ports, primarily because his new test equipment (a hand-held pinger device) does not operate at Gb speed, and his laptop doesn't have a Gb adapter.

I have personally experienced a few problems with auto-neg, and every network engineer I have worked with (Alcatel, HP, Nortel, Cisco) recommends against it.

I need something to try to convince him to re-consider. My issue is that he is likely to experience intermittent problems which we (and our equipment) will be blamed for.

Does anyone have any hard facts on specific problems caused caused by auto-neg, or perhaps war stories? Alternately, am I wrong to push him in this direction?

Thanks for any help you can offer.

1 reply

by deepsand

The "Discussion" forum is for matters of general discussion, not specific problems in search of a solution.

Post problems such as this to the "Question" forum, rather than the "Discussion" forum. There are those who specifically seek out problems in need of a solution, and that's where they go to look for such.

Additionally there are the benefits that:

1) The "Questions" forum provides for your feedback, by way of your being able to mark "helpful" responses as such. This does not necessarily mean that a given response contained the complete solution to your problem, but only that it served to guide you toward it. This is intended to serve as an aid to those who may in the future have a problem similar to yours, so that they might have a ready source of reference available, thereby perhaps obviating the need for them to repeat questions previously asked and answered.

2) The revised TR makes it quite difficult to find both "Discussions" and "Questions" that have not had a fairly recent post, owing to some functions comingling them in the listings. By keeping each type in their respective forums, it is easier for all to find what they are looking for.

This discussion is closed to new replies.