Discussion Locked

Reaching distances with ethernet.

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
The scenario is I have to supply ethernet capacbility to great reach. What I have in mind is using a backbone switch where every new extended switch/hub will be connected to port of bb switch. Anyway, what is the max distane this two switches needs to have? And having the "four repeater rule," I believe repeaters have to be implemented end-to-end, is it rated as 1 or 2? in reference to the four 4 repeater rule? I believe the next switch is counted 2, right?

9 replies

by ann777

The 5-4-3 rule only applies to a Thin Ethernet (10base2) or a Twisted Pair Ethernet (10baseT/UTP) network.

185 meters max for each segment.

5 Segments max.

4 repeaters.

3 populated segments.

"Repeaters have to be implemented end-to-end" -- I don't understand this portion of your question.

There can be more repeaters/hubs in the complete network, and an Ethernet signal can pass-by more than 4 Repeaters/hubs, as long it does not have to go THROUGH more than 4 Repeaters/hubs. Essentially, if you have a central location for the server room, you can entend (like a spider up to 185 meters times 5 -- 925 meters -- from that central location using 4 repeaters on each spider leg).

by isys

How great the distance? If it's over 100 meters it's beyond Cat 5 copper. And if you use thin ethernet you only go out to 185 meters. I used multimode fiber to go the extra distance. You can get fiber backbone switches and hubs that accept fibermodules. And it's good out to 2000 meters.

by ckilday

I have a question: how many users have to be supported at the remote site? For small numbers of users, we have used Pair Gain REXX units. They take 10baseT ethernet and convert it to T-1 signalling (and data rate), allowing you to extend ethernet over POTS wiring (usually cat 3) up to a couple of miles. The units are fairly cheap and are also IP addressable, so you can ping them and do other troubleshooting. They also have console support and you can configure the remote unit from the one close to you. You don't have to worry about the repeater rules, but since you're dropping your data rate to 1.54 Mbps from 10 Mbps, you want to keep the number of users under 20 or so. Hope this helps. Best wishes,
- ck

by nettek

The 5-4-3 rule DOES NOT apply to switches (If you are using true switches, and not hubs). However, the maximum distance between two switches should not exceed 100 meters.

Switches have routing tables that "memorize" MAC addresses of all nodes connected to it, either directly or that pass traffic through the switch. For example, a 3Com 3300 24 port switch can store 8000 MAC addresses. You could, if you wanted, connect 10 switches in a row (which would reach 900 meters), and have PCs connectedto all 10 switches. Your only limit would be the 8000 addresses that each switch can store, and 100m between each switch.

This would, of course, not be an ideal setup. Although you can have many nodes on your network with switches, they are stillsharing bandwidth, especially if you have many PCs accessing one server, for example.

A good site for reading up on switches is
www.howstuffworks.com
Do a search for Ethernet Switches, and you will find good info.

This discussion is closed to new replies.