Discussion Locked

Running small business LAN @ home w/VPN

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I provide IT administration a small company which currently has about 10 employees working at the central office in addition to 30-40 employees who only use the e-mail portion of our network using a POP3 client.

We are hoping to move out of our present physical office and, in order to reduce overhead considerably, convert our business to a "virtual office" environment, running the LAN from someone's home and having everyone connect through VPN using our SonicWALL Pro firewall (which is already set up).

Our network infrastructure consists of one NT 4 Server which functions as a PDC/file/print server and one NT 4 Server running Exchange 5.5.

Ultimately, I want to have about 15 users accessing our network from their homes via VPN andthe rest simply continuing to access Exchange through their POP clients. The VPN users will mainly be working with MS Office applications and QuickBooks and utilizing the Exchange server to transmit e-mail and work with public folders. FTP may be a possible future development.

Keeping in mind that low cost is key, does it seem reasonable to run the LAN from someone's home, or is there a better solution that is still low-cost as compared with working in an actual office? What breed of broadband is recommended? Will cable modem be sufficient, or do I need to go with xDSL or possibly even a fractional T1? Will I need to purchase a router or should the connectivity provider be able to handle my routing needs? Is there any additional equipment or software I should consider for the protection/stability of the server environment and/or the remote users?

Any suggestions that can be made relating to this scenario would be greatly appreciated. If any of you have dealt with similar situations, please share your thoughts.

Thanks.

11 replies

by acattr

Cost Effective answer:
Have everybody vpn in to access the PDC's files/printers. It will work fine, slow but fine. Cable sometimes does not offer static IPs, which you will need for vpn. I've had a couple of vpn horror stories on cable. Don't consider ADSL, the upload(speed at which people connect to you) is normally 1/8 the download speed. SDSL is pretty stable now, its my choice for cost effective broadband. A full T1 will cost you, it may require purchasing a router. Cisco 1720 with built in DSU goes for under $2000, great router. Microtech makes cheaper and easier to configure routers too.

Best Solution:
Best Solution is to make the clients feel like they are actually at the office. The best solution would be a fast solution. The best solution is to have users connect to a windows 2000 terminal server, loaded with the applications they require. Understand that VPN is limited to the bandwidth that you and the client posses. On any broadband solution the most uploadspeed you can get is 1.5Megabits per second. Not that great for running applications like quickbooks that open up 30megabyte or more files. 30megabytes/1.5megabits = 160 seconds. Long time to open up quickbooks. Printing over VPN is a nightmare asraw print data takes up huge amounts of bandwidth. If security is a concern, you can have users VPN in to access the Terminal Server. VPN gives the abilityto copy files they need from the file server. A new terminal server would be best. Considering such a small network, upgrading the most powerful server to Windows 2000 server will do.

What you will need:
An additional 40 megs of ram per user. A terminal server client license for each non 2000/XP connected user. A license to Windows 2000 Server. Appropriate licensing for the installed software.

Installing TS on 2000 is a matter of clicking a checkbox on add/remove software, and then installing your software.

by instrumentality

I used to work with Terminal Server and Citrix Metaframe (I found Citrix to be a far cry better than Terminal Server on its own) at a previous job and I love the stuff. However, since we're currently running and licensed for NT 4, the cost to move to Win2k Server plus client licenses plus install time would be pretty signficant. It would be nice, but I'm not sure that we can handle the cost.

I do follow what you're saying about loading QuickBooks files over the wire and such, however. I'll keep that under consideration.

(I'm not clear on how this rating system works - apparently I have to mark your answer unhelpful in order to continue to receive feedback.)

by timwalsh

What you propose is definitely do-able. However, the implementation must be thoroughly thought out.

Is it reasonable to run the LAN from someone's home? How trusted is this 'someone?' What happens when this 'someone' goes on vacation and the server drops dead? What happens if this 'someone' quits or is fired?

Breed of broadband: bandwidth is the determining factor. Will the VPN users be running applications from their own computers or from a Terminal Server? What type and size of files are being shared? What type of broadband is available in your area? Between DSL and cable, it's really a toss-up if both are available. You need to look at the specific services offered in your area. You will also need business service vs. home service.

Additional hardware: hardware needed for basic connectivity will usually be provided by the ISP for DSL/cable solutions. For T1 solutions, it may depend on the vendor. You need to ask. For remote users, unless they are using dial-up connections, I would recommend hardware firewalls (such as those offered by Linksys).

The technology is there. The hard part is putting in place the necessary policies and procedures to make it work for you.

by acattr

I understand how you feel. I prefer Citrix myself, but for a company of your size, buying Citrix would be overkill.

by giovedi

I think that the best solution would be a fast solution that feel users working on LAN. This "suggestion" will be made with a terminal server slution, loaded with the applications they require, like Windows2000 Terminal server (but is a little poor in printer's managing), Citrix Metaframe (but is a bit expensive) or NewMoon Canaveral iQ (the right performance at the right cost). I've tried all three solutions, and I think the third the best in your enviroment. If security is key, you can have users connected by VPN that access to the Terminal Server. In your enviroment a new terminal server would be increase the overall performance.
To get the solution you will need:
additional 64 megs of ram per user, a terminal server client licensefor each non 2000/XP connected user, a license to Windows 2000 Server, New Moon Canaveral iQ, then appropriate licensing for the installed applications.

by techkid

Does each machine already have Office and Quickbooks on it? If it doesn't, then you would definitely need a T1 or at least SDSL for Citrix and/or Terminal Services. The site where the LAN is actually located definitely needs a high upstream to support 15 remote clients. ADSL and cable usually don't provide more than 384k upstream and usually don't include static IP's. If they're authenticating to a domain, downloading emails and attachments, sending and receiving files, storing they're home directories on the server, plus the extra overhead of IPSec... I don't think that would be sufficiant. Plus, what happens if that WAN link goes down? All 15 people would be left high and dry waiting to authenticate to get their files, which could be a few hours or god for bid a day or two where they wouldn't be able to work. I work with a lot of different broadband providers and it's not exactly the most stable technology yet. And usually the support people aren't trained as well as they could be.
If each machine does have the aformentioned software (which I think is the way to go), then I would say get rid of the domain structure and just have people connect to the LAN to sync files, transfer files, store backup copies of files... stuff like that. You could always outsource a website to a hosting company. They almost always include a number of pop email accounts and would run you about $25 per month. If you outsource your website/email, it'll also save you on exchange licenses, exchange maintenance, security updates, patches, backup of mailboxes, server hardware failure and repair costs... and lots of unnecessary headaches. If you want people VPNing into your LAN you will still need a static IP but if all they're doing is syncingfiles, the bandwidth could be reduced which would potentially save you that $25. Plus, the 15 remote users would be more likely to get by without broadband at their homes.

This discussion is closed to new replies.