Discussion Locked

Snowfalls are now just a thing of the past

0 helpful
148 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

148 replies

by ansugisalas

they're everywhere!!!
-Wait - that's not my line.
I didn't look up "how" just then... that would be putting my trust (and the implied authority) in the arbitrary arbitrations of lexographers.
I extracted the meaning from usage, but I need the pen and paper for that.
Does means, manner, method differ from "state of affairs and train of events"? How?

by santeewelding

That you did not address, "of".

And, proceed apace, I will, to query how you would miss asking after means, manner, and method of, "state of affairs".

Be careful. You spiral down.

by ansugisalas

query that... the result was... expansive. The state of affairs is meant for and derived from, lesser things. Now-things and here-things. I scaled it up as far as it'd go, and it exploded the frames, spilling into the default : all
So, 'of' isn't in it any more, since 'of' pertains to subordination, and all does not subordinate itself. 'Of' was the launching ramp, so to speak.
Maybe I feel that all ordinates itself, and itself alone. Maybe, but that's another piece of paper.

by Member 25348569

If you read my earlier post on this you'd have seen that snow fell on only one or two days in any year up to 2009. That makes it rare in my book compared to what we used to get when I was young.

I suppose if you want to read articles that state "plenty [of snow] has fallen in 9 of the last 10" when the Met Office's figures give only one or two snow days per year for East Anglia and most of Southern England. you're perfectly entitled to. But don't throw them at me. I live here.

British newspapers are increasingly given over to hysterical headlines. If a couple of bus routes on steep hills are suspended because the unions won't let the drivers drive, "Snow Chaos". Only in Britain could the commuter train services be suspended because of "the wrong type of snow". (As happened in 1991).

The article that you linked to is guilty of a little selectivity. However you cut it, Spring has advanced in Britain by at least a couple of weeks compared to fifty years ago. We are getting warmer and, whether you believe that it's anthropogenic, or not, that's going to result in changed patterns of weather and that may well be even less snow here. And, maybe, more somewhere else.

To deny that the Earth, on average, hasn't warmed over the period since the Industrial Revolution kicked off, is a pretty weird thing to do in the face of the simple evidence of the thermometer. Deny Man's influence on the global climate if you wish - I can't stop you and don't particularly care to try - but it's really a waste of time posting "evidence", from an [b]American[/b] website whose sole stated purpose is climate scepticism, about British [b]weather[/b].

by Member 25348569

My thoughts about climate change hang on a simple of premise: that we can measure the solar input into the Earth and that quantity of energy that is re-radiated back into space.

If input equals output, if the system is in equilibrium, then that makes for a fairly simple black-body problem even given the cyclic nature of the Earth's orbital perturbations and the whole thing about GW is crap.

It isn't.

by nicknielsen

I'm not arguing that is isn't getting warmer; it is. We appear to be in an interglacial period between Snowball Earth and Greenhouse Earth, most likely emerging from a stadial period into an interstadial period, with the associated climate change. I'm not arguing that humans haven't affected the rate of warming; we are part of the ecosystem and generate a significant amount of greenhouse gases every day. I'm arguing the thesis that "Man-caused global warming" is not only fallacious, but unprovable.

Should we be doing what we can to reduce our impact on the environment? Of course. Can we totally eliminate our impact on the environment as some seem to want? Barring extinction, no. Should we reduce our impact at the expense of our society, as some appear to want? No.

As George Carlin once said, "Why are you worrying about the Earth? The Earth is going to be fine. Humanity's f*cked, but the Earth is going to be just fine."

by purpleskys

"listened" to the dialogue in the video? It sounds very choppy and very dubbed or spliced together. I also dislike the fact that the lady speaking on behalf of environmental awareness was improperly represented with poor information making the pro-gas burning, head stuck in the sand guy sound more prepared for a debate. So, my opinion, find a better put together video or at least something a little more professional...that wasn't it.

by puppybreath

You've used statements like:

"I don't think he was talking about anywhere outside Britain. And, until 2010, he was RIGHT!"

and

"you'd have seen that snow fell on only one or two days in any year up to 2009."

but offer no proof to these statements. I find it interesting that you always require those that oppose your views to provide proof (which you always dismiss for one reason or another) but expect them to accept your opinions as gospel. Sorry, but you saying it doesn't make it true.

So in your own words: "you can, of course, support that statement with anything other than a Maxfactopinguess?"

by Member 25348569

Anyway, I generally don't quote meteorological information about the UK from anywhere but the UK Meteorological Office.Why would I? I don't feel the need to find some flaky site with an obvious agenda, financed by god knows who to supply me with carefully-selected data sets tailored for the required conclusion. Although GW opponents will most likely apply conspiracy theory and assert that the UK Met, being government and part of the establishment are not to be trusted to be impartial.

I could lay out the UK Met figures but because it takes a bit of work to find what you want to know (and it helps if you know what bits of the country are where), you can find the data in a more easily digestible format here, among plenty of other places: http://diamondgeezer.blogspot.com/2010/12/snow-days.html

Now, one thing that I would like to say is that this whole thread is the ridiculous heaped on the idiotic. Max's original post linking a British scientist talking about Britain to the snow in the US was ridiculous, but I thought I'd join in the fun.

Then, we get post after post about how the scientist was WRONG so all of the GW theories come tumbling down with him. However, most of the hype is journalistic misunderstanding or their normal desire form a story regardless of the facts.

Here's something from another site (get you conspiracy theories ready) http://www.noaanews.noaa.gov/stories2010/20100915_globalstats.html

by puppybreath

Interesting information.

But from your provided site (diamondgeezer):
As a whole, the mid 1800s where very snowy (the little ice age ending), but the nearer the end of the century came, the smaller the snowfalls grew, until the early 1900s, they were little or average, emulating the 90's. It looks as though the ends and beginnings of centuries record little snow, whereas the middle two quarters receive lots. The pattern continues. 1909-15 recorded little or average snowfalls, nothing really to write home about, other than a few falls of up to 2.5 ft, but no real consistency in the cold/snowy periods. London came away with practically no snowfall in 1912-13, whereas Northern Britain was quite snowy. This decade was far from good for snow lovers! I bet they started talking of no more snow for the UK again, as we are doing now. Shows how wrong they were...
The snow drought ended abruptly in 1916, with enormous falls of snow in the mountains, 10ft in the Pennines, Black Mountains, and the High Peak District. Several general falls of snow recorded. A very snowy year.

That sounds like a documented cycle that you are continuing to go through even today. So why blame it on global warming?

by Member 25348569

is that the South of England doesn't get a lot of snow except in the odd year so, if the Earth is warming, we'll probably get even less. That's what Viner was saying, too.Got his timing a bit wrong, that's all.

The Earth is warming - has been inexorably for most of my life.

Just FYI, East Anglia is the bulgy bit on the right-hand-side of the map of England and is as flat as a pancake and just above sea level so "snow in the High Peaks", which, like the Pennines are both high and up North or the Black Mountains of Wales doesn't really count for anything. The worst Winters in the UK in the last Century were 1947 and 1963 although 2010 was the coldest December ever recorded down here. January wasn't. Still, that's weather for you.

The first signs of Spring, catkins and crocuses, are already showing. Gets earlier every year. :)

by ansugisalas

since your scientist isn't on the list either.
We're here in the slums, in the wastelands, working the Jugger circuit, fighting for scraps - hoping to one day earn our way into the guarded vaults of the Enlightened.
Didn't you know?

by puppybreath

is that the South of England doesn't currently get a lot of snow because it's normal for the cycle they're in. Even if the Earth is warming, you'll probably get more snow as the cycle continues into 2020.

I agree that the Earth is warming - I just don't agree that it is causing huge changes to the climate or that humans can do anything to prevent it. It will cool off again as it continues to go through its own cycle.

by puppybreath

my scientist already has his "enlightened" secret decoder ring so he's close enough to being "enlightened" that his scientific conclusions carry more weight than your scientist's conclusions.

So my scientist is smarter than your scientist. Deal with it.

by Member 25348569

because it's low down, further south than the North and because we have mainly a maritime climate. London's average low in the coldest month, February, is above 2C, the average high is 8C. I know I'm sounding like a cracked record but WE DON'T GET A LOT OF SNOW. So, for anyone to extrapolate that a rise in average temperature might produce EVEN LESS snow, to the point that some time in the future, snow might be a real rarity, is not really very difficult.

Unless and until we get into the next ice age, it just isn't going to snow much here.

by ansugisalas

you mean the "enlightened" secret decoder ring with the mind-control feedback loop that My Scientist made? Swapping the rings was so easy with these tentacles... ;)
But, your scientist sure is cute doing the involuntary light fandango down main street in a wetsuit and a feather boa... ]:) :D

by dogknees

Doesn't say that there will be "No more snow". ie never again will a single snowflake fall in East Anglia. It's says and diminishing amount will fall. Which it has. Look at the running 5 year average to see the trend and it's pretty plain.

by tigger_two

And being a reasonable being- i.e. self motivated and self concerned- I only know what is affecting me and my personal back yard regarding snow.

I have lived in Frozen Tundra for close to 15 years. The first winter I lived here was unseasonably warm and our snowfall was minimal. There were NO floods as a result of Spring's arrival.

The next year we had a late snow season and it followed "normal" habits. A snowfall early in the season melted entirely and we were good to go until the second or so week of December after which we experienced "normal" snowfall until Spring's arrival in April... which didn't kill my bulbs.

The next year we had colder than average days through the winter months, a mild increase in snowfall, and some flooding. My bulbs bloomed happily and that was really the important thing.

Some years we have gotten early Spring flooding due to snowmelt and some years we have seen flooding due to extreme rain. One year that I recall, Spring didn't get to northern communities until around July. By that time, I had moved away from my bulbs so I don't know what happened there.

This particular year has been absolute ugly. Northern communities frosted over early in the game and we didn't get the melt we usually experience after the first snowfall. It has been colder than a well digger's butt in the Klondike since mid November and VERY difficult to get around. If we ever deserved an early Spring, this is the year... and then the river valleys will very likely flood as a result.

In short, we've completely BLOWN the five year average and this has been the toughest winter we have experienced since I moved to Frozen Tundra.

This week will NOT be a week for heat lovers. Our overnight lows will be in negative numbers and even negative double digits. I don't plan to put my nose outside after 2p until Saturday when I have to... and the overnights will be at least in positive digits.

A five year snapshot is an unreliable timespan to use as any definitive data source. A snapshot like that taken five years ago would have clearly indicated that my husband had every reasonable expectation of living to be 80. Take that snapshot today. He died in September.

Want it in weather? Five years ago we had a "normal" winter for Frozen Tundra. Around 60 inches of snow for the season and dealt out in reasonable bites. This year? Not so much.

The issue of Global Warming has to consider such variables as what the earth is doing all by itself. And [b]regardless[/b] of any of that, it should address the politicizing of the issue. As in, that isn't really the right plan either. I agree with Max on this one.

Will I get a reasonable Winter if I give up my 4WD truck and buy something Hybrid? Is that a promise I can get in writing? Do I get any credit for driving a small, highly economical vehicle for thirty years?

by ansugisalas

Now they figure that the reduced polar ice cap leads to a colder atmosphere locally during winter...
Less sunlight reflected back into the atmosphere, leading cold periods to become colder.
I haven't seen the maths for that, though.

by nicknielsen

This is our thesis
- [b]THIS DATA SUPPORTS OUR THESIS.[/b]
- This data doesn't support our thesis
- We know what's best for you, why are you fighting us?

We can see the results of climate change for ourselves But I don't think we know enough about the interactions in the atmosphere to do more than speculate on causation.

by ansugisalas

There are people who think they do know... and they can't agree!
But one side is paid for by Big Oil, so ... that doesn't help their credibility.

by ansugisalas

Cornwall is literally cleaving the Gulf Stream, one part goes north around scotland, the other goes south around and up the channel...
The Gulf stream can even be felt here in Finland... Turku is 200 kilometers closer to the gulf stream than Helsinki, and we have warmer climate in westerly winds. Easterly winds are affected by the russian mainland climate, so that throws it off...

by oldbaritone

Anyone remember those days?

OMG - the world was going to run out of oil before the end of the decade. The next Ice Age was coming, and the entire planet was going to freeze over, and everyone would die. And that was if we didn't die in a nuclear conflagration being planned by the evil war-mongers on "the other side."

Then it was "global warming" and we were all going to boil to death.

Now it's "global climate change" and the doom-and-gloomers are still at it.

Bottom line, yes, the climate of the planet will probably change. It's been happening cyclically for over a billion years. Man's carbon consumption might mean something, but the reason the oil is underground in the first place is that at some time in the past it was plants and animals on the surface of a changing planet.

Glory hounds, nay-sayers, and doomsday prophets have been around as long as history has been recorded.

Sorry, Chicken Little, but even if the sky IS falling, there isn't much you can do about it.

by fregeus

I had to look up the name to find out its North East of London.

If it did snow 18 days in 2010, then I think his theory did not materialize then. The weather is weird and unpredictable, I'll give you that, but it still didn't come true.

I read a heck of a lot about climate change for I find the subject interesting and intreging. The stuff I find concerns mostly the North American area, being from there. Now all that reading may not make me a scientist, but it still allows me some "educated guessing" from time to time.

TCB

by puppybreath

is heavily invested in "green" technology and will be filthy rich as soon as they can convince everyone that their industries will save the planet.

It's always been about money and power on both sides. It never had anything to do with saving the planet.

by ansugisalas

When Oil was just getting started?
But Puppybreath, what's wrong with becoming independent of Oil imported from guys like Chavez and OPEC? There does seem to be more benefits on the green side, so maybe any excuse for polyps to get interested is better than letting them just laze through with the status quo?

by puppybreath

with becoming independent of oil. My point is that many of these "independent" scientists are simply repaying those who support them. Big oil has its scientists who rely on big oil paychecks to survive and "save the planet" scientists rely on grants from backers of green technology to survive. Neither side can be trusted to provide totally unbiased data and let the public decide for themselves. There's too much at stake for them personally to do so.

by j-mart

You state :

" I'm not arguing that humans haven't affected the rate of warming; we are part of the ecosystem and generate a significant amount of greenhouse gases every day. "

Then add :

"Man-caused global warming" is not only fallacious, but unprovable.

A large part of the CO2 man generates is from industrialization and the burning of fossil fuels. If we are responsible for increasing greenhouse gas, we also must be responsible for the warming.

by Member 25348569

There ARE no backers of green technology. The only nominally green technologies are biofuels, backed by oil companies and biofuels are probably worse for the planet than any amount of oil, and hybrid cars. Hybrids are a huge confidence trick. All they are is a petrol-driven mobile generator running an alternator to charge a battery that powers an electric motor that drives the wheels.

The people driving the green agenda are governments. In this I absolutely agree with Max, It's all about tax and control.

by nicknielsen

The rate of warming and the warming itself are two different things. All indications are the Earth's climate was already warming when [i]homo sapiens[/i] began its global diaspora as the Wisconsin glaciation was ending 12,000-plus years ago. If that's the case, the thesis that mankind caused such warming is fallacious.

As I said, I'm not arguing we haven't affected the rate of warming, just that we didn't cause the warming in the first place. It may seem a very fine difference to you, but the scientific difference is immense.

by puppybreath

I was referring to companies like Silver Spring Networks which produces hardware and software to make the electricity grid more efficient. It has been described as a "green energy" company. It was estimated that Al Gore's interests in this company and others like it would make him a billionaire if he can push his global warming agenda forward.

by ansugisalas

something can't be fallacious and unprovable (infalsifiable) at the same time ;)
Also; bear in mind the Logical Fallacy of Argument from fallacy: assumes that if an argument for some conclusion is fallacious, then the conclusion itself is false.

by Member 25348569

Whilst I am not a fan of Al Gore, I don't think that you can criticise him on this one as he just put his money where his mouth was. Carbon trading is a bad idea, and Gore has lots of interests in that arena, but wasting energy is a bad idea too and I can't see what's wrong with the example that you gave. If he was NOT investing in green technology, people would argue he was a hypocrite.

It comes down to whether you think he is "profiting" - surely, the American Way - or "profiteering". Gore owns a venture capital company so I have to say that it's the former. No doubt, his opponents are trumpeting the latter and, it would seem, you among them.

Neil :)

Be aware that I may never forgive you for putting me in the position where I feel that I have to DEFEND Al Gore!

by puppybreath

First you say "There ARE no backers of green technology. " Then I point out a company that Gore is invested in that is described as a green technology. Your response back is "If he was NOT investing in green technology, people would argue he was a hypocrite."

So which is it? Are there backers of green technologies or aren't there?

by Member 25348569

Nor medium sized and precious few, even, for small.

Gore's 50million USD or whatever is small, small beer when compared to the vested interests of the oil companies, the electricity suppliers and the motor industry.

No. There are no BIG backers of green technologies. And precious few small ones. Government does not back the technologies, merely hijacks the movement so they can levy more taxes.

No "huh" at all. Fairly obvious what I was saying, I would have thought. Unless you want to split hairs.

by puppybreath

what's YOUR definition of "BIG backer"? If a small group of people invest 300 or 400 million would they be considered big backers, or are you trying to say that "big backer" only applies if one individual invests that much? Talk about splitting hairs.

BTW, I have no problem at all with Gore or anyone else investing in whatever they want. But I do have a problem when they use scare tactics, misinformation, and skewed data to try to convince the government to force the public to use their products just so they can make a profit.

by Member 25348569

Any company where a significant amount of money and effort can be targeted at a point with a single required outcome.

"If a small group of people invest 300 or 400 million would they be considered big backers". Invest in what? There is nothing to invest in.

"scare tactics, misinformation, and skewed data to try to convince the government to force the public to use their products". Like what? What data? What products? Post some links. And, please, some that don't have Al Gore fronting them because, over here at least, we know enough to take no notice of him.

by j-mart

Hybrid vehicle technology makes good engineering sense, but it's fundamental value is not necessarily an ecological solution, but more of a better and cheaper way of building automobiles. By replacing transmission with electrical components and electronic controls, hybrids should be much cheaper. This basic approach to transmission of power from a internal combustion to the driving wheels has been applied to large diesel locomotives for a long time as it is much simpler and cheaper than the mechanical equivalent.

Electronics and cheap micro-controllers make this technology, now a good alternative to mechanically based transmissions. Good engineering, a reason to adopt this technology, anything else bollocks.

by puppybreath

that you're just arguing for arguments sake.

I mention Silver Spring Networks as a "green technology" company that is getting investments after you claimed that "the only nominally green technologies are biofuels".

Then you come back with a vague claim that there are no "BIG backers" of green technology. When pressed for a definition, your first three examples are are big oil companies. Gee, I wonder why they wouldn't invest in something that would help people reduce their oil consumption!

Then you throw out questions like: "Invest in what?" "What products?" and add "There is nothing to invest in." And this is after you admitted that Gore and his ilk are INVESTING in companies like Silver Springs Networks (a green technology company) that has SERVICES and PRODUCTS they are trying to sell.

If you don't want to accept the reality that GW is nothing more than a scam to relieve you of your money and freedoms, that's your right. I won't waste any more time trying to explain it to you.

by ansugisalas

I think the "green underdog" view is now out of date.
Green is now a buzzword, but it will remain to be seen whether the buzz-ards (as opposed to old-school greens) are actually green, or just painted over in green lead-based paint.

However, we all also know that the politicians would've much rather just stuck with the graft they knew, keeping up reliance on foreign oil for ever...

As it is, I see no more harm from the green buzz than from other buzzes, and there are the benefits of reducing reliance on oil imports.
So, I don't see what the resistance is for...

A part of it is just a scheme, sure, that's realistic.

However, without schemes, the politicians will be perfectly happy doing absolutely nothing - prolonging the reliance that we all can agree is a bad thing.

So, what's the drawback?

by nicknielsen

or his editors who put them there, but the use of quotes around the word skeptics makes me want to consider him a "scientist". After reading about three pages, I found myself starting to hate myself for not being green enough.

by puppybreath

you shouldn't start hating yourself until they use real scientific methods to prove their hypothesis.

I think you'll have a long wait.

This discussion is closed to new replies.