So many zealots, so little time
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Windows Forum
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by seth
by techrepublic
I use Window ME -- yes that's right -- on most of my personal systems.
You say that in a crowded room of IT types -- if you have the guts. I have people that know nothing about computers at all, freak out on me, based on the prior freaking they got from their IT acquaintences.
Dogma is dogmatic. Here is some reasons:
* Far less use of hardware resources
* Still runs all current normal Windows software
* Uses two driver schemes
* Uses USB 2.0 more or less correctly
* Takes 5 minutes to turn off annoying out-of-box features
* Has some of the better UI features of 2K or XP, like; thumbnails, "outlook bar" style File dialogue
* Takes 20 minutes or so to install from scratch
* If you know how, you can lock down networking in a few mouse clicks
Basically, there is nothing wrong with it, especially after you turn off System Restore.
Peace out <>1337's
by jdclyde
and the only way to recover it is to reinstall ME. WHEN it works, it isn't bad but it just always was too much of a card house for me. Too easy for it to fall over.
But that is just me.
All my personal systems are win2k. Still have issues, but nothing a good reboot four times a day won't solve.....
Oh, and you CAN NOT use a palm pilot and sync to your server with ME. (unless they went back and added the goods since the last time I fought that beast.)
by ziskey
I'd like to believe this is a real topic, but every post I read confirms the opposite. If you have to reboot your win2k system four times a day, do you really have your systems installed correctly? Just as the same would be true if I claimed similar issues on my SuSe system.
I agree with the premise that computing solutions should be evaluated on a per-situation basis; linux, BSD, MS, *nix, DOS, whatever. However posting items claiming to be impartial when you're obviously biased is a bit funny. When people use terms like M$ and Windoze, I think it's pretty easy to see what side of the fence they're on (even without the penguin emblem) You're certainly entitled to your opinion, and I agree with parts of your argument, but to imply you're not a zealot? Funny...
by jmgarvin
HA...HAHAHA...HA...whew. So your claim is:
1) ME is stable
2) ME is secure
3) ME is just as good, if not better than 2k and XP?
Interesting troll, and rather than reply to either point, I'll just say this: ME is a broken OS. You cannot claim it fully functions on any level. It has issues with both integration and stability that have never been resolved.
by hal 9000
Or so I'm told. My only experience with it was when it first came out I loaded it onto a new computer that I was selling and ran it for about 15 minutes while I had a play. Then wiped the HDD and loaded 98SE and threw the ME stuff into that black hole here that seems to gather everything that I do not want to ever see again.
I know I have a copy here somewhere but I'm dammed if I can find it and really I don't want to either. :D
Col ]:)
by jdclyde
He did say on "personal systems", so it isn't the same as if he was running a business on this.
My EX LOVED WinME (had to add the "win" because it sure wasn't "me" she loved!).
No matter what I did, I couldn't get her to switch over to Win2k until the day she picked up a trojan that trashed the entire install. (yes, running the same AV and firewall as my win2k system).
I got her data saved, but darn the ME would never boot again. For some reason I couldn't "find" a windows ME disk anywhere..... (whistle whistle whistle)
But this does go to PROVE that MS users are their regardless of how bad some of the products are and LOVE it.
by joyceb
Hi all,
I just wanted to add another point in here. I am an American, but I live/work in Europe. I've also done work in the Middle East and Africa, and I have to say that when it comes to looking at trends in the computer world I agree with everything you have all said up to this point about marketing needs/wants vs. tech needs wants, and what corporate America does, and how *nix mibhg be better technically, but MS might fit better culturally, etc.
However, I'd also like to point out that the macro trends that drive vendors are changing. The US is currently the largest installed base of high tech, and the largest spender, as well as the home of the majority of technical development. But the fastest growing markets are all outside the US. Which country is next is up for debate, but the sheer volume of population makes this true. And the things that make Linux appealing - low costs, runs on older, cheaper systems, has free bits etc. are even more appealing in places where MS does not have an extensive entrenched user base. Additionally, many people in other countries, like many Americans, are proud to use local products, as well as sometimes having languages too particular for the big guys to localize for, and they need local stuff. Open source is terribly appealing to them, because it's easier to get there with open source than MS.
Corporate America is the driving force of many trends today, but so is Corporate Europe, and in partiuclar, the UK and Germany. The UK acts an awful lot like the US, while Germany has been much more open to the open source movement. There is a whole set of topics in there, but it is a point to consider and it isn't just that SuSE was originally German. Debian and Red Hat can be found in Germany too.
Eastern Europe is selling faster than Western Europe for most IT companies, and Asia is the next hot ground, whether that's India and Southeast Asia, or the possibilities of China. As those markets grow, mature and increase in spending power, I think we'll find that different products will meet different needs. I disagree with the poster who said Linux has missed the boat. If the poster means Corp. America, this is true for some (although not all) and in an absolute sense, meaning the world's IT market, and not just the US, then no, it hasn't missed anything at all, and it might be wise to read Clayton Christiansen or at least think about his concept of disruptive technologies and see how Linux and more importantly the open source movement are actually creating new spaces. Looking at what is best in a mature market is different than in one that has more green fields.
What happens in other countries may not affect your business, especially if it doesn't operate or partner in those countries, but it may affect your global operations, and it will also affect the vendors and how they respond as those other geographies come to represent greater percentages of their total revenue opportunities and costs.
Thanks for letting me jump in,
J
by noorman
in China M$ have already lost; they 're making their own OS(es) ...
No Windoze needed there !
by cass
by hal 9000
Because M$ has done an excellent marketing job on convincing a lot of the software houses to only write code for Windows?
If lets say MYOB for arguments sake produced a Unix application that looked and worked like the Windows version with documentation by MYOB wouldn't it be as good as the Windows Version?
Currently Microsoft is doing everything possible to prevent these software houses going Open Source or even Unix remember what happened at Corel?
Actually I like M$ Windows desktops provided they are hidden well behind a Nix server and not directly connected to the Internet and while what you say is currently correct there is still the issue of security that Microsoft while claiming to take seriously as yet doesn't seem to have come to grips with.
Provided that the Microsoft stuff is well hidden from the Internet I think its great as it is what keeps paying my bills but if all of those programs where on the Unix base it would be so much easier to maintain them and I would never have a patch wreck the entire OS again.
While no Nix is perfect that are by their very nature a lot more secure and harder for the "Script Kiddies" to crack which is a lot more than can be said for the Windows computers out there now.
As for documentation have you seen a XP OEM book lately?
But you need to find a better LUG to ask questions of as obviously you are on the wrong one if that is the response you are getting. It is almost as bad as ringing M$ and asking why is the OS crashing when I do this.
Col ]:)
by gentlerf
There is a *nix OS version that already does a lot of what you ask and is user friendly for even the moms and grandparents who aren't tech-savvy. Its MacOS X. And believe it or not, M$ even makes Office run on it. Since it is also a *nix OS, Mac OS X has available to it all that lovely open source software with a relatively easy recompile via the XCode developer tools which are downloadable from Apple's site.
Now here is a real surprize, I am typing to you on a machine that is 8 years old, should not have gone past MacOS 8, was one of the last Mac clones (Power Computing), and thanks to a gent named Ryan Remple, I'm running MacOS X 10.3.9, code-named Panther. I am even using some PC components in the form of hard drives and burners in it via a third party upgrade. To those who shudder at using an Apple OS on anything at all, one can even install Linux, as in YellowDog Linux.
Like you, I have had my experiences with CP/M, DOS, 'Doze and other OS's and realize that there is no "one true way." Even the current iteration of the MacOS isn't without its flaws. But from where I sit, it and Linux makes 'Doze look like a virus.
About time someone said it, although now I'm sure you have
galvanized the faithful witless bots of Microsoft Borglike
domination who will jerk that knee and spout some 10 year old
cliches (which weren't true then) about how tha Mac is somehow
not suited for their particular application, etc... Which can be true
of course- there really is no one size fits all solution- but usually
isn't...
by gentlerf
by noorman
by eschlangen
by jdclyde
If it is a desktop I use windows.
If it is a web, file, or ftp server it is linux.
If it is our AV server it is windows.
As far as prefering *nix, I only look as good as the tools I put in place. If I put in a server and can just forget about it for the most part then I have done my job.
What is the uptime of your windows servers right now compared to your *nix servers? All of my *nux servers are 150+ days. The Windows server is two weeks.
The main point was that some things windows does, somethings *nix does. It is not in the best interests of the end user to limit the tools that are applied based on what you "like" or don't "like".
The second point was that people that are obsessed with MS products should expect more from the products they purchase. Quit making excuses for the vendors and demand that they be held accountable for the product they are pushing.
As I said in a different post, I have another windows 2k server license I would be using right now, but my boss won't let me.
by brianmpenn
I have to beleive the vast majority of computer users are just 'comfortable' with Windows. Yes there are the died-in-the-wool fanatics on both sides, but by and large Windows dominates because it's easy and available. Windows' inferiority is directly proportional to it's market base. Windows is not (for the most part) marketed to the IT professional (exceptions do apply). Where Linux doesn't even have a market stragety, nor does it need one. The biggest thing to happen to linux is Novell. I'm waiting to see what the Provo company can do with an open-source business model. Your (and my) ability to see both sides of the fence comes from a healty understanding of how both systems operate. There are far too many IT pros that ONLY know Windows, and believe that if you want your business to work, you have to run Windows, because that is what everyone else uses.
The Linux learning curve is far to steep for the average everyday computer user. The acceptablily of Linux is only gaining momentem as the populace becomes more educated about how computers, and OS's operate. Additionally, a more educated user can make Windows and it's environment more stable.
+++Sarcasm alert!!+++
So now that I think about it, the less educated the user, the more jobs for us. *WINDOWS RULES!!*
+++Sarcasm indended+++
by jdclyde
by jdclyde
If you recognise linux at all it seems others will accuse YOU of losing your objectivity as well.
And people forget, there are GOVERNMENTS making the switch to linux, not just the geeks in moms basement. The old stereo-type doesn't fit anymore.
by rknrlkid
I think this discussion is missing a different, but important, point. The public is being sold this illusion that computers are "appliances" that anyone can operate and repair. This distortion of reality is what causes alot of the confusion. Computers are not for by average people. Computer use and repair requires an advanced skill set.
Computers are not appliances, and unlike toasters, require someone with training to set up and repair. Some things can be done by the user, but many of the tasks are outside of the average user's knowledge and experience. Using the metaphor of a car, the driver can put in gas, add oil, or water, but disassembly of the engine usually takes a mechanic. A user can install software, do a virus scan, surf the internet, but it takes training to do many advanced tasks. Have many of you received business because a user deleted files they "didn't think they needed" (like dll files) or removed the wrong thing from the registry?
The computer is a tool. Thanks to movies and TV, many think its this effortless, godlike machine that can do anything. Software companies perpetuate this myth with their "user-friendly" and "intuitive" interfaces that mask the real workings of the software which are more technical than the average user can handle. This is far from the truth. The reality is that "user friendly" is a marketing ploy, and computers are definitely not friendly to the average user, especially in a corporate environment.
by andeanderson
O.K. So you have forgotten when you didn't know the difference between a monitor and a tv.
It is NOT so much a loyalty to one operating system or the other. It IS the matter of being able to sit down at a keyboard and be able to use the computer without having to learn 30 different commands to accomplish the same thing, the GUI will win everytime.
Microsoft has the market on User Friendly Documentation on how to use their systems. The public doesn't care how it works, they just want it to work.
Just like you don't care how your car engine works, you just expect it to run when you turn the key on and if it doesn't start you call a mechanic.
Microsoft only has two basic operating systems and the controls for both are almost identical and are therefor user friendly.
The world of *nix has about 300 different operating systems all loosely based on a single concept but is constantly being changed by anybody who feels like they want to change it, without any documentation for a normal (Public) user on how to use it.
When someone has a question about the Microsoft product it is fairly easy to come by.
When someone has a question about one of the 3,000 plus *nix products it is almost impossible to get a straight answer and you have to find someone who knows that specific version of that specific product.
The only reason the *nix products are lagging behind in the noteriety of Viruses and Spyware is that they are not noteworthy and do not get the Hackerz the attention and recognition they crave. There are Viruses and Spyware out there for every OS out there.
Sooo... Get over it already. People buy and use the easiest product to use. That's why men buy electric razors now, instead of a straight razor, a hone to sharpen it with and a strop to put that final sharp edge on it.
The razor analogy is RIGHT ON! Think about it, why does MS still have such overwhelming market share if their products are inferior to the compettion. Answer: The software must be easy to use, read GUI, AND ubiquitous. Quality enters into it but only after the first too are satisfied. The questions that comes up is, doesn't software become ubiquitous by being the best and therfore chosen most? The answer is not always yes. Bundling, pricing, and marketing (and luck)will determine the defacto standard as much as quality. Office's displacement of all compettion category by category has shown this VERY clearly.
In the end governments and companies that move away from MS are likely to do this inspite of the average user's objection. This is not necessarily a bad thing. But don't be so naive as to think that "because you built a better mousetrap the world will beat a path to your door". Big business DOES NOT work that way, perhaps it should.
And most ironic of all is that all these tech decisions are made for largely non-technical (read business/ political) reasons.
I would be interested to hear anyones thoughts on this.
by jdclyde
then why did Dow Chemical go in a few years back and rip all the MAC's out of the peoples offices and put in Windows sytems?
Are you going to say Windows is easier than a MAC?
Also, the only people stepping up for this discussion are desktop people. Desktops are not the HEART of your companies computer network, but just a way to GET to the heart of the companies information. And the bigger the company, the less likely the mission critical systems will be a Windows server.
The main point is the politics of business that you bring up. The techs generally do not get to choose the systems that are purchased. CEO/CIO's have seen adds for Windows and so that is what they go with. A business model based on people not knowing about the product they are buying. Sounds like MS is doing something right! Too bad it isn't their application building instead of application selling that is their strong suit.
But take note, as linux gets more headlines these same CEO/CIO's will start looking that way. And with Novell and IBM on board, this will be happening more and more. If as a tech you advise against a linux server because it is too hard, I will bet they will be looking for a new tech pretty quick.
by hal 9000
I would just love to hear your reasoning as to why Word is so much better than Word Perfect.
I can still remember those days when you said "Word Processor" it meant Word Perfect and M$ Word was nowhere to be seen.
Col ]:)
by jmgarvin
Your comment "The world of *nix has about 300 different operating systems all loosely based on a single concept but is constantly being changed by anybody who feels like they want to change it"
Technically it is one kernel (you can check for yourself at kernel.org) and many distros. Most main stream distros follow the *nix conventions, others (like Red Hat) mostly follow convention, but they change some directory structure and minorly modify the some X GUI. If you know one "version" of *nix you know them all. It would be like switching from 2k to XP when you switch from Unix to Linux.
"The only reason the *nix products are lagging behind in the noteriety of Viruses and Spyware is that they are not noteworthy and do not get the Hackerz the attention and recognition they crave"
This is spurious logic at best. Just because something is popular doesn't mean it is automatically insecure and prone to attacks. Look at Apache. It holds about 60% of the web server market share and it doesn't have the problems of IIS.
"When someone has a question about the Microsoft product it is fairly easy to come by."
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA. Oh please! I had issues with animated windows in C# and couldn't find WHY it was animating poorly. When I finally figured out the issue, it was due to a built in DirectX library that wasn't fully documented!
by cq_west
Ironically, not only does SuSE have a method for going from Microsoft to Linux, Microsoft has a method for going from any version of linux to windows... server AND desktop. You just have to be a Microsoft Partner to get it.
I agree, there is no one common denominator for OS's. In some cases, *nix is a better fit for the job - however, keep in mind that the average *nix machine is also more expensive to maintain because you don't have as many skilled *nix users out there so the price is higher. In some cases, windows is a better fit, but keep in mind the up front cost can be quite staggering. (And just because it's Windows, doesn't mean it's any easier to maintain. There are just more people out there to do it).
My 2 cents...
by jtmail
You know, maybe this OS loyalty IS a religious thing. As a pastor, I have found that people choose a church based more on its "user-friendliness" than its teachings and practices. As XP continues its unfriendliness path and Linux gets more friendly, we are likely to see an OS loyalty EXODUS.
John T
Lakeland, GA
by jdclyde
by elamess
Your shrieks remind me of the losing party in the last presidential election. They cried like little girls over losing Ohio to Bush but at least that's over for now. What continues are the cries of frustration from you Linux folk who thought Linux would have bit Bill Gates in his wallet by now, surprise! If the Microsoft preference is a religion then the Linux movement is a cult. Of course, neither of these is true so why such zeal from yourself while calling others zealots?
As far as I'm concerned, Microsoft has one and only one flaw. They try to be all things to all people, and from the people I've known over the past 14 years of my IT career, people who struggle to run simple maintenance on their hard drives, Microsoft has a hearty challenge.
I've seen them sitting there in front of their computers cussing Bill Gates because they couldn't figure out how to arrange their desktop icons the way they wanted. Lord Linux, these are your followers. They're out there nodding their heads up and down over your article. They would probably buy into your alternative OS ploy, even purchase and install Linux. Then one day they will go to cuss a name because they will be unable to handle that operating system as well, but there won't be a public target for their angst. Would you mind if they use yours?
by jdclyde
So many people are getting from the original post only what they walk into the post with.
The Anti-MSers thought it was a battle cry, and the MSers thought it was an attack on their doorsteps.
It was to get both sides to not rule the other side out. Why is that so wrong?
And yes, I am an advocate of many services (but not all) running on linux [b]servers,[/b] but recognise that the linux [b]desktop[/b] isn't for everyone yet.
by rapell
by stutan
by hal 9000
Windows is great for the Desktop and for small servers if you can afford it but Unix is so much better for the servers that it isn't funny.
The real problem is that because some people only use M$ Windows and other software they think it is all that is worth using and because of their work do not realize just how good some of the other offerings are.
What M$ does extremely well is sell product to those who really do not need it like just how many people would be happy to work with 95 or 98 today with the far smaller overhead and cheaper hardware? Do they really need a 3 + GIG CPU and .5 GIG of RAM? when a 300 CPU and 64 MEG or RAM would suffice for the work that they do?
Today if people where not forced away from 98 SE just how many copies of XP do you think would be sold? I know when 98 & XP where sold together 98 consistently outsold XP to those paying their hard earned money. While 98 was no great security feature it didn't leak as much as XP has been doing over the years and I still know of several companies who refuse to switch from 98 to XP even though they are paying for XP Pro Licenses they want and demand 98 to be installed on their desktops.
What I have found interesting in this whole discussion is the almost total lack of understanding that computers are not limited to just the desktop but to Domain controllers and the like. It leaves me wondering just how many actual Techs there are posting here and how many data entry people are making up the numbers who can run the socks of one particular application provided that nothing needs changing in the way of Fields or Columns but just push the data in and then consider themselves as "Expert Computer Users." I know it is something that I would never claim to do at all but I do get a lot of call outs to rearrange the fields and the like in these preprogrammed items because none of the experienced people who use it on a daily basis actually know how to use the application but only enter data.
It reminds me of an old SF movie I saw a very long time ago now where everyone specialized in one part of the system but no one understood how the whole system worked so they would instigate changes in their own special area and then couldn't understand why their change made something else that seemed totally unrelated to the change that they made fail to work.
Currently I see IT heading that very same way and it will result in a disaster if it isn't halted.
Col ]:)
by unclerob
I read your post and although I agree with you for the most part, you mentioned computers not being limited to just desktop use but also running as domain controllers (and other types of servers). Although you are correct in making this statement, I felt that the entire discussion spawned by the original post was largely a desktop OS discussion which is why people have limited their responses to the desktop.
The original post included this blurb:
"The Viruses and Spyware that runs rampant on the Admin by default Windows systems are out of control. This verses the restricted user the *nix run at which even if you DID run an infected file the WORST you would do is trash your home directory, not the whole system."
Reading this led me as well as several others I'm sure to assume this was a linux vs. win desktop OS discussion.
I'll admit my experience with Unix is limited to being only a spectator, I've seen it but I haven't messed with it enough to have any real affinity for it. My own experience is with my small farm of windows servers, all of them running Win2k Server (several years ago it was NT4). Although our own location is small compared to the rest of my company, we have win2k dc's running at locations across the planet with never a hiccup. Although your UNIX servers may be more bulletproof and make better use of the server hardware than our win2k dc's, I've never had any complaints and they run 24/7/365 without any problems along with our other servers(yes the hardware specs for the dc's alone are stratospheric but you buy or lease what you can get, I'll never complain)
Just thought I would mention this since you thought the server side of this discussion was lacking (or missing altogether).
by ploosh
I am from the camp that likes to experiment with software and hardware to see which solves problems the best (while creating the least). Linux had always been on my mind as a better workstation OS, but as several colleagues indicate "pointy clicky, not command line." Because of this, Linux had not been friendly at the workstation level ...until now.
It's called Ubuntu (www.ubuntulinux.org). I installed it on a workstation at the beginning of the year on a dual boot system to try it out. The goal was to see what Windows programs I was dependent on and if it was possible to run Linux in a time critical, mixed network environment that included Windows and Mac users. Success came quickly.
I had tried other Linux distros (some of which I really liked) but Ubuntu requires almost no knowledge of working at the command line. I say "almost" no knowledge because I found myself learning the command line occasionally to tweak things, see diskspace, etc. - things the average user might not need to do (or you might not want them to do). Installation of applications and hardware configuration will require administrative access (also called "root"), but Ubuntu handles this using "sudo" which is not true root access. This is really beneficial if you are trying to limit what users can do to their machines. This type of security is also one of the reasons why Linux claims to be more secure than Windows - it requires permission to install anything (ie viruses). Trojans will always be a threat, but Linux provides some very simple, very obvious ways of solving some of the disastrous Windows flaws.
Finding and installing applications on Ubuntu is really simple if those applications are within the package manager. If not, you will need to hit the command line. The package manager is a pretty superior method for handling sofware compared to Windows, from a user perspective. It's basically a database that lets you know which dependencies your applications will require, indicates if you already have a version installed, if it needs to be updated, etc. It makes adding and removing applications very efficient.
Ubuntu also has a fantastic user guide and solutions to problems are solved by the user community very quickly. The project also has backing with deep pockets, a solid development team, and a commitment to remain free.
My advice: try it. Personally, I've come to really love this OS. There are problems (a la .NET), but I've found the transition from Windows workstation to Linux workstation to be far easier than it has ever been before. And it's only going to get easier - might as well be on the forefront of knowledge than those that will lag behind. :)
by hal 9000
While you can download for free every Linux Distro you can also buy them at the same time and then they come with all the documentation that is required and more often than not leaves the M$ offerings for dead in literature.
The functionality is also far superior than any Windows system I've ever worked on but I'm biased as I started with Unix systems and I just loved the way that they worked and how easy it was to control them. I'm constantly told this at every M$ meeting that I go to or whenever I ring the Techs at M$ for help they just insist that I'm expecting far too much from the system and I reply that I could do such and such with Unix 20 + years ago why can't I do it with this modern system.
Personally I think the .Net framework is a dead end that M$ was forced to go down to avoid paying for the Java add ons which the .Net is trying to replace and do away with Java. But as M$ by no means is as dominate as they seem to think they are I think it will be a short lived thing and even on the latest computers today that I install I have to install the Java Packages if only for on-line banking as these big boys are unwilling to go with the .Net framework for their log on pages.
Personally I don't think Linux will hit the desktop in the short term it will eventually get there once mission critical applications are developed that are capable of sharing their data with the Windows based packages that are currently available. For small business the Accounting Packages are a very big deal as they just send off their data to their accountants to work with for tax and if this has to be printed out and then reentered into a different package just to do their tax it isn't an economical thing to do.
Col ]:)
by hcetrepus
by jterry
by jdclyde
If using both Windows and linux in a mixed environment and advocating the same to many makes me a linux zealot then so be it.
The fact that you didn't personally have a problem with SP2 does not make you the zealot. People would be inclined to make that assumption based on your other replies to people that DID have a lot of problems and placed the blame everywhere and on everyone but MS and Gates.
And as I pointed out in the other discussion, LOTS of people are having lots of problems with SP2. MS wouldn't have so much information on it on their web site if it wasn't happening a lot.
But I guess that doesn't matter.
I am glad windows works for you. Not everyone had the option of doing a bare metal install when it came time to go to SP2. Will you be so lucky with SP3 comes out?
by rapell
I would suggest we all go Linux && Windows, drink, eat, and be merry. Why ever we never learn that you cannot leave on bread alone, but also....=))
by jterry
JD
I have to differ with you here. While XP is very bloated and I was really not looking forward to using it, I bought a new Dell box (P4 1G Ram)for home/ fun. It came with a Mcafee firewall and I added Norton AV and Spyware Doctor, I locked out all the ports, and run scans regularly. I have been pleasantly suprised. It just runs.
So while a *nix box would be arguably more stable I could not use it for the games/ productivity software I want to run. And that, like it or not, is the final word. Until a perfect emulator is developed you will NEVER see a wholesale transition from windows. And by perfect I mean it will support all MS compatible software functions (games and produtivity)and contain drivers for all WinTel hardware (high end graphics cards and assorted "must have" do-dads). That would be a dragon slayer (MS being the dragon).
I'm interested in any thoughts on this line of thinking....
by llamaking
I've got a nitwit of an admin who runs our exchange server. Granted that I set it up, but it has been up for over 200 days. I have to threaten him to do the microsoft patches. I've tried to get him into any kind of UNIX (starting with RedHat and FreeBSD), but he can't grasp them.
I have a real smart network engineer that likes to do everything on Solaris (sparc) with open source software, but he screws everything up by tinkering with it. I've tried to get him to understand Windows, but he's broken every windows machine that he's touched.
My internal webserver (10-20k hits per day) ran on FreeBSD for 600+ days uptime before being replaced by a IIS machine because the web guru couldn't be bothered to even try Chilisoft ASP. With him it's microsoft or a tantrum.
I wouldn't dream of having my admin and net engineer switch platforms. They couldn't handle it. They'd break everything. I can't get new ones either due to hiring policies. I run FreeBSD at home, XP at work and Linux, Solaris, Windows 2k-2k3, and FreeBSD in the server room. It's all about the abilities of the admins.
by hal 9000
Servers in the corporations what is the expense there? Currently on the big server farms or Mainframes M$ just can not compete as they do not have a product scalable enough for the needs of the business.
Do you remember the Hot Mail mess?
I have to disagree with your statement that there are not enough people available to maintain any of the Nix's either as there are still a multitude of Unix Mainframes being used after all where do you think SCO got the money to launch that action against IBM? If Unix was now a lost cause SCO wouldn't have the available funds to proceed with that case would they?
The fact that it is a very easy step from Unix to Linux only makes Linux far more attractive to the big end of town who are looking at cutting costs as much as possible while retaining a reliable and secure service. If they had to retrain all of the existing Unix techs to a Windows Platform the costs would be horrendous and the security would be even worse. I'll not even bother to think about the service either.
If we where to remove every Nix from the market now the Internet would collapse in a heap and be unusable and Microsoft clearly doesn't have a product to fill the gap so we would be without the Internet.
The TOC is a Microsoft myth propagated by studies funded by M$ on the premises that you need to retrain existing workers to use a Nix. In some case this may be true but in many more it isn't as there are many of us now using a Nix of some description and loving it. If I was forced to drop Apache and go with IIS I wouldn't be the slightest bit happy and while I could do the job I wouldn't be comfortable.
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
Mainly it was before the much touted M$ "Trusted Computing" came out and Windows 2003 was the first new M$ product released after that momentous event.
I got a real laugh by looking at the faces of those in the room that I was in saying just how great it was and that the demo machine had 4 CPU's. Most of these people could not comprehend a Dual CPU computer let alone something with several hundred CPU's in it. I can still remember the look of wonder on their faces when they saw 4 individual CPU usage monitors in the Task Manager they thought it was a miracle.
The fact that I was at that time using 4 Xeon's on the small servers that I was making didn't matter these people where transfixed by that sight. At the time I was wondering if I was in a room full of Professionals or interested armatures I'm still inclined to believe the latter.
But if you want to go back to the XP launch it was even funnier just the reactions on the face of the people there about all the new advances and there I was thinking about all the new as yet undiscovered holes. But it was never an issue to these people their opinion seemed to be well "It's newer so it has to be better" and there I was thinking I have already got the 98 Desktops fairly well locked down what am I going to be facing now.
But what was even better was the open question time after the release where the technical guys where there to answer questions a group of people gathered around them all bombarding them with trivial questions mostly about supported drivers and the like and I only got to ask one question which was "What is the Overhead required to run this thing?" Of course they chose not to answer that one. :D
Col ]:)
by jdclyde
is that the better linux does means MicroSoft will have to be more competitive and customer oriented. They will have to put out a higher quality package than they have become accustom to packaging.
This is a win for everyone, no matter which platform you like.
by jmgarvin
by jdclyde
then when you added the part of IIS being a web server I know you were just teasing me.
Companies without competition have no reason to work to improve the service or product they offer. Competition MAKES you improve your system.
Try to tell that to someone with a closed mind though.
[quote]
is that the better linux does means MicroSoft will have to be more competitive and customer oriented. They will have to put out a higher quality package than they have become accustom to packaging.
This is a win for everyone, no matter which platform you like.[/quote]
Well said. I just hope they get that kick in their pants sooner rather than later. :)
Guys, just do what I did 6 years ago with my mom- get her to
buy an iBook or iMac. 6 Years with no trouble other than the
occasional "How do I do this again?" calls. After 6 years on the
Mac she installs her own printers now, and has never called for a
virus or spyware.
My dads house with the 98SE computer? It's down (again.) so I
will stop by and ressurrect it (again.)
Mom just upgraded from the 300MHz iBook she got 6 years ago.
How many of you can state that you have a family member that
has a 6 year old Windblows device that you didn't need to work
on for 6 years?
BSD is great in the enterprise (I am MCP as well so am no fanatic)
but for home machines, Get Mom A Mac!
by hal 9000
That is the way to go Unix/Linux on the server end and the Windows machines well hidden away from the Internet safely behind several Unix Servers on the desktop.
It works very well for so many companies it isn't funny and I love it to as I know that so many of the nasties will be stopped by those terrible expensive to maintain Linux Servers that I just do not have to touch unless there are severe thunder storms or worse around. At these times everything gets closed down for its own protection and it is the only time that I've had to take a Unix/Linux server off line.
Col ]:)
by unclerob
You wrote "Why is it, even when presented with hard facts people refuse to budge on there religion of OS worship?". Here's a question, which hard facts are you referring to? Are people being presented with linux info on a daily basis by the media be it paper, tv, radio, etc? Answer is NO. People use what they know. Microsoft does a good job of advertising Windows & Office and any other products they intend to sell. Advertising is the only way for people to hear about something. There is plenty of linux info available on the net but it's not being pushed out to the average end user who in all probability has heard the term "Linux" used in some form but doesn't know what it is, what it can do and how to obtain it.
You also wrote (sorry to paraphrase) "Is having to not know as much really worth a system that crashes on a much more frequent basis than it's Unix and Novell counterparts?" How often are these Windows pc's crashing? At my place of work, we're all running Windows in one of it's forms (Win9x, Win2k or WinXP) and rarely do users experience or complain about crashes and these are users that really use their systems (email, multiple office apps, as400 client sessions, internet, printing, faxing, database use, custom apps, etc.) Windows prevails in the workplace because it does work. There can be times when a user can experience problems but they way you describe it, these problems happen on a non-stop, ongoing basis which really isn't accurate - if it was really that bad, people would stop using it.
You mention security as another issue "There is also the issue of security, and anyone that has ever spent at least five minutes at the SANS site would see that there is a much bigger turn around to getting exploits patched from MicroSoft than the *nix OS's. The difficulty of exploiting the *nix bugs is also much higher, as they do not have graphical script kiddie tools that can point and click their way into the system. The Viruses and Spyware that runs rampant on the Admin by default Windows systems are out of control. This verses the restricted user the *nix run at which even if you DID run an infected file the WORST you would do is trash your home directory, not the whole system." None of my users have ever spent 5min on the SANS site, they don't need to, they just run Windows and whatever apps they require to perform their jobs. Security isn't their concern, it's the job of the local systems admin to ensure that any windows security issue is taken care of. As long as it may take to get these security patches rolled out by Microsoft and sometimes it seems to be longer than required, it's not an issue that my users need to deal with. Also ADMIN by default windows systems aren't what your typical system admin would roll out to a user (or at least they shouldn't). All of my users run as RESTRICTED user types, users don't need to install software on their machines, that's a task that an ADMIN would perform. Allowing users to run their pc's with administrative privileges is irresponsible, that's how problems get started when unauthorized software installs take place without prior consent. Users are meant to use their pc's to perform work related tasks, if it's not work related they shouldn't be doing it. A home user is obviously at a disadvantage because he doesn't have a local IT dept to fall back on so people should operate their pc's with some responsibility and if they don't know what they're doing, they should ask a friend or do some research before attempting something unfamiliar - failure to do results in spyware, viruses and operating system problems. But that also applies to life in general, using common sense is always wise, and if you don't then don't complain when bad things happen.
People don't refuse to budge on the religion of OS worship because it's not a religion, I have a religion I follow and it has nothing to do with computers, mixing the 2 together in the same sentence has a conotation that's near sacriligious. People use Windows (ask them and I'm sure they'll tell you) because they don't know there are other alternatives to use and if they do in fact know, they're not willing to change because Windows is comfortable and familiar to them and Linux appears to be too difficult to pick up (appearance is everything). Maybe when Linux is paired down to a few real choices rather than the 3000 flavors that it currently sits at, users will be more inclined to switch over and try it out and be pleasantly surprised that there is a good alternative to use.
Until then it's hard to fault the general public for not switching over. The Windows world isn't that bad right now, and I can't fault Microsoft for every security issue out there just like I can't blame the police for not being at the scene of a crime just before it happens so that they can stop it in time. Let's place the blame on those criminals that enjoy perpetuating crimes that take the form of spyware, viruses, spam email and taking advantages of operating system security issues and make them truly responsible for their actions.
Your post may not have been a 'Nix vs. Windows flame war but it was definitely one sided. Take into account that if this was a Linux world and Windows was the new kid on the block, we'd be having the same discussion about the shortcomings of Linux and how we should give Windows a chance.
If you want people to switch, take a stand, tell them which exact distribution to download because there are too many to choose from(mention a workstation and also a server OS), provide a link to the downloads, provide a link for easy to use & understand documentation, provide a link to software that can be downloaded and also a link on how to download and install software on a linux box (an area IMHO that is truly lacking). Setup a one stop shop for all of these linux needs so that user's don't have to search thousands of websites to extract all of this different information. I have tried several different versions and haven't been truly satisfied by any one distribution, my most recent & pleasing linux discovery was Beatrix v2005.1 - not bad at all, this linux camp is starting to get the message on how to win over regular pc users who are for the most beginners and aren't technically inclined to know enough about how their operating system works and what they need to do to get it to work - they also make their linux dist perform 2 tricks, run entirely from the cd itself (which configure's it's network connection by itself) or allow for an HD install for permanent use. I liked it better than Novell's latest linux desktop offering which is as bloated as windows ever was if not more.
Until you & other Linux advocates can do this, Linux will not be a real contender for the general home or work user's desktop experience and will remain a tool only to be used by the technically adept - something most users aren't.
Just my 0.02 cents cdn - feel free to agree or disagree, that's what this place is all about! I look forward to your comments.
by hal 9000
The general desktop or home user will not be affected by the shortcomings of Windows only the System Admins and those who don't hide their M$ stuff very well behind a Nix front end. You can read that as SERVER.
Linux was developed so that people could have a low cost Unix which by the way was the first real OS that was used in computers that bridged different hardware layouts to a standard user interface and guess what it is still used on the mainframes and Internet servers out there mainly because of security but also because currently M$ just doesn't have anything scalable enough to fit the bill.
Linux is actually a "Real Contender" for the high end user which isn't the desktop although it is used in several high end desktop configurations where brute processing power is required and the waste of system resources can not be tolerated like CG work.
What I can not believe with this whole discussion is the way it has totally over looked the server and high end market and only focused on the desktop which really is only a small part of the IT industry. Admittedly it may be the most visible but it is by no means the biggest part of the IT industry and without a Nix of some description we would have no Internet that is so vital for all of those desktop users.
Why is it that the low end of the market seems to get all the attention and the mid to high end is forgotten?
Col ]:)
by unclerob
The low end of the market as you put it is geared toward your normal everyday user, there's more users in this market than in any other segment of the market - that's why so much advertising is in place in this area and why so little is in place for the mid to high end market. I don't believe the mid to high end is forgotten, it's just smarter & more efficient to focus toward the area which has the greatest potential for growth.
We're not (at least I'm not anyways) replacing servers every year and reinstalling server OS's every year, once these server solutions are in place, they're meant to function for a decent period of time before requiring replacement. I guess these static solutions aren't as sexy which is why they don't get the limelight that the desktop receives.
And although you are correct that Linux is a real choice for the high end user, there aren't that many of us high end users compared to the number of average users out there and that's a fact. In the end, we're all just part of the bigger picture - a large portion of which is made up by the average user who for all intents & purposes doesn't know that "without a 'Nix of some kind" (among other products) is responsible for enabling the current infrastructure of the internet.
You seem pretty passionate about this discussion on the server side of things with respect to the win-nix debate, I can respect that. It's always good to hear that the other camp has a good group of leaders, I'm always looking to learn new things and I'm not a 'nixophobe (made up that term which is hopefully clear enough). Proof is in the pudding though, Give us examples, point me to websites, give me your opinion on which 'nix distro's to try out, unix server products to learn about and experience. All I really currently know is Microsoft & Windows (both desktop & server platforms), as I said before I'm willing to learn.
Hal
Surely you realize that to a very large extent the prevalence of the computer in our daily lives is a direct result of the rise of the desktop computer.
The PC is the public face of computing. The PC has been the engine of inovation in the areas of productivity, ease of use, graphics, and communications. Big iron has evolved in a fairly straight line, faster/ cheaper more bang for your buck... but radical advances in how we use the computer have largely happened on the desktop. Think the GUI, the mouse, the personal printer, voice recognition, e-mail, music management, home entertainment centers, hard drive DVRs, PIMs.
These are examples of sea changes in what a computer is how you use it, and they come from the desktop not the mainframe. The mainframe is a means to an end. The end is the user interaction, that interaction more often than not happens at a desktop. In the sense that it has had such a huge impact on how computers are used I would argue that the desktop is the "biggest" part of the industry.
by wordworker
by newby7718
From a business analyst for more years than you can count candles on your birthday cake, you should always select software that does the job and THEN select the hardware that supports it.
In lab tests, with Windows, UNIX and other proprietary OS, running the same software with the same hardware specs, they all crash at nearly the same point ... when the hardware resources have diminished.
The only reason LINUX and UNIX are less prone to malicious programs is that they are not targeted as much as the most popular software. UNIX and LINUX have their own set of problems with setup, integration and compatibility with user interfaces and programs. And, the hackers are just begining to target those operating systems. Again, in a lab environment, I have witnessed what real programmers can do to corrupt LINUX and UNIX OS. If targeted they are just as easy to corrupt with malicious programs.
From my experience, the only place in a real network for UNIX and LINUX OS is web servers and firewalls. They can be setup and left alone to do their job.
As far as desktops and servers go, windows is still the best choice for most programs that are used today.
by hal 9000
If they can be corrupted.
Even the first hackers who broke into the Unix Mainframes didn't manage to break the systems or for that matter even corrupt a user account they just managed to delete files to make space to play with or copy the files to their own machines.
I got what would now be called a "Super Hacker" out of prison and put him to work for me many years ago and even he couldn't break my Unix systems but he could get any files that he wanted out of any computer connected to a phone line back in those days. If you are seeing the Nix systems broken they have not been installed properly as I've yet to see one broken but I've seen plenty opened up and things stolen or wiped off them to play around but never broken.
As far as your statement goes about Windows being the Domain of Servers and Desktops it is only the small end servers that are useful for a Windows system as it still is just not scalable enough for the larger servers that are commonly used in the financial industries all around the world.
Personally I would have thought that banks and Stock Exchange servers which hold the data a far more interesting target for the "Script Kiddies" than a Windows Desktop where they can not gain any real advantage from. If I was that way inclined a nice big International bank would be a far more juicy target for me than a home user or corporate Desktop where at best I might just gain access to a on line bank account or a credit card. Personally I would much prefer to hit a large International Bank for a fraction of a cent on every Interest transaction as it would be worth far more money to me.
But that is just my 2 cents worth.
Col ]:)
by unclerob
breaking into a bank probably brings with it a much higher penalty when caught as opposed to hacking into someone's home desktop pc.
Plus didn't they pull off that fraction of a penny on the interest charged stunt in that movie "Office Space", the only problem would be hiding that money because I'm sure it would add up to something fierce after a while.
Be careful, your 2 cents may only be 1 3/4 right now if someone tries out your idea.
by jdclyde
I am always willing to be proven wrong and if this is actually a valid test done by an independant lab I would love to see it please.
[i]"In lab tests, with Windows, UNIX and other proprietary OS, running the same software with the same hardware specs, they all crash at nearly the same point ... when the hardware resources have diminished."[/i]
Did they both reach this same point at the same time is another question I would need to know that answer of.
Thanks!
jd
by noorman
have you ever tried what 's described here ?
http://www.techspot.com/tweaks/win2k_compatiblity/index.shtml
I can't see why that program (developed for NT4) wouldn't run in Win2000 ?
by gorto
by cq_west
I would agree wholeheartedly with your observation. The problem is not that Windows or *nix is a better solution (admit it, they both have their application). The problem is that most small and medium businesses (and for that matter, home users) want to be able to use software they can pick up off the shelf.
While *nix does offer some great software tools that are just simply not available for the Windows platform, many line of business applications are tailored to the small/medium business owner that has a small technology budget. These individuals will go out and purchase several windows based machines, and windows based accounting packagequick, and a windows based productivity package (usually office) and start running their business there. They may not be aware that there are comprobable options in the *nix field.
I'll admit, *nix has gotten much more user friendly over the past few years. I remember installing my first version of *nix (almost 10 years ago) and finally getting it to work 6 hours later. The same install of windows 95 took me 30-60 minutes.
In the last year, I have been able to install *nix on several machines in much less time with less hardware compatibility problems (I even got it to run under Microsoft Virtual PC 2004). It still isn't as mainstream as Microsoft is yet.
Let's face it, the Dragon has the field (for now). Everywhere you look, especially as a home user or a small business owner, it's a Microsoft world.
The killer combination is ease of use AND being ubiquitous . The Mac is easy to use but the problem has been it's relative isolation. MS gets away now with adequate or even substandard products because they largely dominate the market.
In any area they are VERY good at marginalizing their competition while cornering a market.
The Mac has never been able to develop the relationships needed to become a dominate player. Software is a business. Business rules dictate who is the number one provider.
Your comment about desktops is interesting. I remember a quote from a head of a tech company years ago asking why any person would need a PC at their desk. If anything with the cost of the power of the hardware continuing to increase faster than the cost for availability of high speed network access, I would expect the trend towards DE-centralization would increase. I expect you will eventually see even large organizations with many "hearts" distributed amongst many super desktops in adhoc networks that pull data as needed. Centralized information management is only needed when it is more expensive to manage data in the operations. Where possible it is preferable to get business critical information decentralized but accessible.
by jdclyde
to different people.
To me, computing is any computer system used in work or home life.
In the work life, if that *nix server were to die, we would be in for a world of hurt as it is our life blood and doesn't matter how many pc's we have if they can't get to the file server or email server.
Another reason is the desktop seems to be the big discussion these days so people must have thought this was just another one. Oh well, even [b][i]I[/i][/b] can't be perfect ALL the time!
by andeanderson
You say "having constantly restricted users who can type in an admin password to install something and then have the OS revert back to a user mode".
Microsoft already has that. Microsoft calls it "Run As" and it was initially meant for Network Admins to be able to do updates and installations without having to log the user off and then login as administrator. But, the users are fast finding it and how to use it on networks that are not set-up correctly.
by hal 9000
In Native mode it sought of works.
But even the maker doesn't recommend anything newer than NT4 and since there are millions of $ in equipment around the place the cost of the disposable computer is way less than the fuel used on a single job. If they muck it up too the cost of backfilling will exceed the cost of the computer by at least a factor of 10 so the companies involved are not interested.
Actually now it works quite well as I can have a disposable NT4 unit on-site and the NT4 unit back at head quarters as virtually a stand alone server that only downloads specs via CD to the various site offices I do not have an security worries as there are no longer any form of Internet connections or any connections at all to the outside world I don't even need an AV program really but I use one none the less. When we tried this program on a 2000 platform it failed to work correctly and instead of allowing me to fault find it was cheaper to keep the NT4 station going when I first tried this I had both working with the NT4 as the control and the 2000 as a working slave comparing outputs. If the 2000 specs had of been worked to at least $100,000.00 Au of refill work would have been required so even if the on-site computer sets the company back a couple of K it really is small change and these units are only expected to last the life of the job, if they keep working longer it is an added bonus but the cost of replacing the on-site workstation is added into every tender.
Of course the real problems come about when you try to integrate the 2000 system running in mixed mode into a 2003 ES domain it just doesn't want to play nice at all and M$ solution is to move the 2000 unit to native mode which this program doesn't like at all.
After some very long meetings with the MS Technical staff here it was decided that I stick to NT4 units to run this particular program on as it drove them nuts as well. :D
We just couldn't get consistent results from the 2000 units which at first the techs didn't think was overly important as we where only talking about a 2 inch difference in most places but when I told them of what was involved in refilling those 2 inches they very rapidly lost interest and they didn't want to guarantee that it would work and certainly they where unprepared to foot the costs incurred if it didn't.
Col ]:)
by andeanderson
I just finished moving our company website to a Linux based Apache2 server.
What I did not realize, and no one said anything about, was that the *.asp pages I had developed for searching our product database would not work on a Linux system.
So, now I either have to return our website to the MS IIServer or do a database conversion and re-write the *.asp pages to something compatible with Linux.
Where is the emulator for *.asp?
by zteccc
You wrote "it isn't a religious issue it is a business tool." Let'd not forget that. Business is not about the OS, it is about the bottom line. Business doesn't care a bit what OS is installed as long as the bottom line is taken care of. If business can survive "well enough" without having to retool, it will, until the ROI can be proven to be so great as to force the retooling.
Some businesses are tied to a particular OS because of applications. Sure, most mainstream apps are available in some format on every OS, but many (most) businesses have some specialized apps. Those specialized apps tend to be the probelm when changing.
Unless a company is in the business of software development, they tend to simply purchase apps and write very few of them in house (after all, that is what software companies are for, right?). As a result, a business who has a specilized app which requires a certain OS is not going to consider switching unless the application is rewritten by the vendor to support the other OS. Now the vendor isn't just going to do this for free, are they? They've invested money, time and effort into their application on a particular platform and they aren't likely to retool for free just because one of their clients wants to change. Remember bottom line? If the change isn't going to be free, then will the upper management and the shareholders/owners want to spend the money just to change the OS for the comfort and ease of the IT department? Probably not.
Sure, all of a vendor's clients could band together and force a free change, but this isn't happening (can you imagine Hyatt, Hilton, Four Seasons, etc. banding together to force a vendor to switch to another OS?). So the result is that a single specialized app can force the inertia of remaining with an OS.
Many businesses have more than one specialized app. Consider a business that has ten such apps, none of which exist on a *nix OS. How do you recommend that this business convert? They need Windows to run these ten mission critical apps. Perhaps they could get a rewrite of one or two at a reasonable rate. They could rely on wine to run one or two more, perhaps three more have a *nix equivalent. That still leaves three that simply won't work in *nix. Like it or not, the best that such a business can hope for is that some of its servers and some of its desktops can be converted, but then they have to maintain a mixed OS network. They have to deal with complaints from end users on multiple platforms. This is expensive (think bottom line) and especially in smaller companies, is simply not going to happen.
Remember, an OS is a business tool, not religion. If it serves its purpose and the bottom line is doing well, there's no reason to change. Sometimes maintaining the existing system really does cost less than the rewrite of applications and the redeployment of a new OS and we need to acknowledge that (or work somewhere else).
When it makes sense to change, we should embrace it. When it makes sense to keep things the same, we need to accept that too, it is business, not personal.
-- Jeff
by firstpeter
by hal 9000
To different people. For me IT means everything from the printer on the end users desk to the Mainframe that is still used in the big places. But I started with computers when a computer took up floors of a building and I used Unix way back then.
Then the PC sought of started and I was forced to go to first DOS and then Windows and honestly there are things that I could do with Unix 20 + years ago that are just not possible to do in XP or 2003 ES as far as limiting the ability of users to access or alter data or even what they can access.
To me Windows Systems are way too open and just waiting for some form of hostile takeover either from inside the company or outside.
But what really horrified me was with the advent of Windows 95 I saw a almost complete dumbing down of end users who no longer needed to know how to work a program properly but just point and click to get things done. Now this may have been good for some business as they could employ untrained staff but what I have seen happen is the loss of all the highly trained staff who could work the software and the retention of the untrained staff who are only capable of filling in the blanks and incapable of redesigning the template when a new one is required. But these untrained people are now considered as "Power Users" rather than nothing more than "Data Entry" people who really only have limited skills.
Col ]:)
by jdclyde
And the funny thing about these untrained employees is that they still think they "know" a package.
If they can find a power switch to turn the system on, they are a power user. And then in the small businesses, it is this person that ends up being IT-by-default. Then they wonder why the server keeps going down. hmmmm, I wonder. But this is EXACTLY who many MS products are marketed to.
Copy a file? Move a file? I love "download this file to my floppy?" and then "download it back to this other system".
Anyone remember the work "directory"?
Hal
I find it facinating that the advent of win 95 which made the PC easy enough to use so that someone with no computer knowledge could use it, and made PC sales skyrocket is horrifying to you.
I remember when the PC was just a geek-only hobby product. The "a moron can use it GUI" is what made the PC a huge success.
I think in the future the PC will continue to be dumbed down to the point where, when the technology improves enough, you will see a sticker on the back saying "no user servicable parts inside" and a virtual version of same regarding software. Just like TV's, I remember opening the back and changing a tube(s) as needed. Solid state did away with that. The PC is moving there.
Look at some of the hottest software, file management search tools all created so the user doesn't have to know where they put their stuff. Now if only it worked for finding my car keys ;-)
by tcpip4u
I deal with making decisions on future technolgy day in and day out. Even in our compan I hear Linux this and open source that. However, when approached they can't give a legitimate reason why Linux is better other than its free and its more secure. However, is open source really free and more secure than its counterpart in Redmond, WA? Oh, reliability is another point that was brought up... hmmm gotta wonder.
According to the Gartner Group, there are pro's and con's in deploying Linux in any organization. Cost is a huge factor in the OS game but there are other issue that exist in open source as it does in Windows. Sure Microsoft charge quite a bit for their OS, but you get what you pay for. Security patches and hot fixes, its all part of doing business. IT pro's and consultants make it out as if Linux is an almost perfect OS platform, perhap this maybe the case but I get patch alerts for Suse and Redhat more frequently than the guys in Redmond. Microsoft patches and hot fixes might be bigger but the frequency of the patches and alerts go to Linux. Tech support, how many times have you called Microsoft tech support because of their so called "crappy" OS? Exactly because when their is a problem they try to get the information out to you ASAP. When it come to support for Linux their is no official source you can go to in order to find a solution without paying for it. There may be some learning curve invovled for home users in getting Linux to run but its pretty ridiculous when they need to get help.
About the migration path from Windows to SuSe that is being offered by SuSe(Novell).... What do you think is happening here? They are trying to piggy back on the Linux platform to get a bigger share of the pie. I just want everyone to realize that I'm not an OS basher or favor one over the other but this BS about one OS platform being better than other has gone too far. People talk about the two OS without having a great deal of knowledge in reference to ROI, reliability, support, availability of resources, and so forth. On the flipside, if Redmond wanted to broaden their share of the market do you think they would put out propaganda about their OS and the competitions, not to mention a full migration path... If people just stop to think about it its all the same. Does it cost less to hire a sofware engineer to develop code for SuSe vs. Windows. Is tech support available for both? Yes, but one you pay up front and the other you pay when you need it.... either way you pay.
I've worked with Unix, Sun, RedHat, SuSe, HPUX, and Microsoft and to me it does not make much of a difference. The people that enjoy using and supporting Linux go ahead, and vice a versa with people using Windows. Don't try to cram ideas down people that really don't care.
You said that "Corporate America using MicroSoft because that is all the non-tech execs know. MicroSoft does one thing well, advertise."
What do you think you are doing.... you are adverising the "Nix" almost a propaganda wouldn't you say... Just think about it... Its all the same. IT ALL BOILS DOWN TO MONEY, NO ONE WORKS FOR FREE!!!
by tcpip4u
by hal 9000
Is the Microsoft Knowledge base. Look up the scalability of 2003 ES it is limited to 128 CPU's which may sound a lot but really is small potato's in comparison to the real work units that are used in the banks and places like that. I used to do government work many years ago and places like the Defense Department could not live with Windows Servers as they are way too limited and far too hungry for system resources.
Even at the 2003 Release the HP Quad unit that MS had to show off was limited to 20% CPU usage on each and every CPU. I never did get a reasonable explanation for that one.
But look at what you get for your money with both products. With Microsoft you buy a OS and then software and for any desktop the software generally costs more than the hardware, with any of the Linux Distros you get it all and much more than you're likely to actually need in the way of software and I'm not talking about the free downloads but the ones that you pay for and a manual that will un rings around a company like MS.
Log onto the Tech-net MS forum and ask about large server farms or a mainframe most likely they will not know what you are asking or even worse suggest you use 2003 ES as a platform to work with which is so inadequate it isn't funny and it also gobbles up system resources at an alarming rate as a general rule of thumb any Windows system will consume about 30% of the available system resources before you load anything onto the unit, now you can get away with this on the desktop but it is unusable on the high end servers or if you do run it you need more processing power to get the same result and with no security as well.
There is a very good reason that Banks, Defense Departments and the like use Unix on their main servers that connect direct to the outside world that is because it is harder to break and almost impossible to get code to run without allowing its installation.
The big ISP's all use either Linux or Unix as currently MS just doesn't have a product that can fill this gap Hot Mail was a perfect example of this case, do you remember what happened when MS got their hands on that and tried to run it on Windows Servers?
Well it is now a little after 4.00 AM here and I have to be at a job by 6.30 AM so I'm going to try to get a few hours sleep before today starts again and I'm back to making money off the Windows installations that I've put it. :D
Just on a side note here this year the Desktop market is expected to shrink a little while the Notebook market is expected to continue its rapid growth, very soon there will be so few desktops left that they will be the pre-built boxes and the Notebooks will be the custom built units. Currently it is the Server and Notebook markets that are growing and the desktop is diminishing. I believe that the Intel site has that data although it may be on a restricted basis for Channel Partners only.
Col ]:)
by jterry
by cweb
Since I started in the IT field 8 years ago I have done almost nothing but fix Microsoft products. And I would guess that most of the readers have done so as well. So why should we knock MS? Their buggy, unstable platform has gave us the means to pay our houses, buy cars, and support families.
I was at a conference a few years ago when the MS rep took the podium he called out, "Did everyone make a lot of money selling Microsoft products this past year?" Amid the cheering (from the sales staff) I heard a loud voice (not my own, though I wish it was) call out, "No, but I made a lot of money fixing it!"
So true, So true...
Why, pray tell, would I choose a stable reliable platform like *nix that would eliminate the need for Sys Admins? Talking about shooting yourself in the foot...
by oz_media
Just as need a firedepartment even when the city isn't on fire, you wil always need admins for updates, installs, builds, security enhancements, and those with creative IT talents outside the patch and fix world.
I was a Netware admin for years and teh server NEVER crashed, it was taken down once in two years when it was physically moved.
But I was still needed for patching, testing, upgrading etc. Why would an auto manufacturer build a car that never broke down though?
They HAVE extended the life of many parts, newer cars with technoologu decades old are now designed to run for 80k without a tune-up, and they sell more of them than before without completely killing their repair market.
So there will never be a perfect platform, yet one that doesn't fall apart like a cardboard boat is more desireable. Novell and Nix DO require support, just not to the intense and exhausting level as MS products.
They allow a business ot function properly and the IT staff get to spend mroe time learning and improving the network than patching and backstepping all the time. I like my technology to move forward, with a few growing pais allowed of course, not to be a rollercoaster ride at a lower salary.
by jdclyde
First, my network is *nix while the PC's are Windows. I spend most of my time coming up with new ways to do what we are already doing or new things to try all together. If I spent all my time fixing broke by default systems we would never improve.
Getting a *nix system does not get rid of an admin, it HIRES and retains them. It is the simple looking windows server that causes managers and execs to not give it proper respect so the pay is lower and the turnover is higher.
[b]If your a consultant paid by the job[/b], MS is your meal ticket. [b]If it is your network[/b] that you have to keep up you want something that will work. If you bring in a system that crashes, it makes YOU the admin look bad, not the system.
by unclerob
by cweb
by ploosh
"Why, pray tell, would I choose a stable reliable platform like *nix that would eliminate the need for Sys Admins? Talking about shooting yourself in the foot."
This position is so fatally flawed I'm a little bit surprised. To answer your question, I'll give you some possible reasons why:
#1 Bad solutions are eventually replaced. If you are tied to the bad solution, you run the risk of being thrown out when that solution is replaced.
#2 Bad products might make you money, but they cost the person paying you. If the person paying you discovers there is a cheaper way of solving their problem than paying you (and Linux is often free), you've now lost money.
#3 If you are the person who can fix the old and support/reccomend the new, you have created two revenue streams
#4 Historically, Sys Admins are known for being able to make the complex tasks easier and more efficient. This mindset will translate into any system, thus creating your own value.
The list goes on and on....
by jterry
by tcpip4u
by jdclyde
started out on my quad-boot system. I had loaded 98/me/2k/redhat on each partition in case someone called me with a problem. I could then boot to that OS so I could walk them through the problem.
It was a shame when the ME was the ONLY partition to die. So I deleted the OS and mounted the partition for the win2k system. It is now the home of Diablo II.
by hal 9000
Here I was thinking that it was Xerox who built the first PC and integrated the network on a Unix Platform with that terrible GUI and pointing device.
Now wasn't it called the Lydia or something like that and when Xerox decided that there was no future in the PC they then brought in all the competition and showed them what they had achieved {read that as Steve Jobs and Bill Gates}
Today we are yet to see the same level of integration that they prototype had and you call that development? We have only made things bigger and faster not necessarily better. :p
Col ]:)
Right the PARC did develop some of the PC standbys of today. They did not choose to capitalize on them either which was in hindsight an epic bad call!
The Apple Lisa was another early GUI that laid the groundwork for the PC explosion.
But what is "better" to you? Modern desktops do amazing things and can be run by people with the most basic of skills (read young children, elderly, handicapped) with minimal, or no, training, just point and click. My three and five year old children can use the PC running their teaching software. Whereas a command line interface requires that the user has internalized the language of the interface. My three year old could not run DOS, or *nix.
Based on the fact that in one scenario the PC is usable and in the other it is not, I say usable is "better".
So again my question is to you, what is "better"?
by little-b
...you are pulling statistics from your buttocks! (-:
Approximately 27% of Corporations today are NOW using some form of Linux and according to surveys, the number is increasing in percentage the double digits. Sure, this is in combination with other OS's, but that is a hefty figure.
Like the previous posts indicate, Linux is becoming a viable alternative for servers and desktops in many corporations and will continue to do so. Even software like Symantec's LiveState Recovery software boots from a Linux kernel. Symantec has jumped on the capability of using Linux to host a storage system instead of having to buy expensive MS licenses. Almost all of Novell's products are designed to run on MS, Novell, and Linux and they support all their products on Linux as well as the SUSE NOS itself. Application vendors are starting in droves to program new products for the Linux platform. This is no small scale initiative.
This has gotten MS very worried! So what have they started?...an initiative to "simplify" their licensing structure to make it easier and cheaper for customers to upgrade. The mere fact that Linux is becoming attractive is now causing MS to shake in their boots and start becoming more reasonible, or at least, a little more competitive in pricing.
You, as a staunch MS devotee should be thanking your lucky stars for a MS competitor and should, in turn, buy some Linux servers to support the continuation of reasonable MS pricing.
Most corporations look at viable, safe alternatives when the pricing structure gets out of hand to support their goals. MS has dominated the market, but their pricing structure has gotten way out of hand for many businesses. The average company spends approximately $650 per year, per user on Microsoft licensing (all products like XP, Office, server licensing, etc.). The upside to SUSE Linux is the average cost for licensing is $150! If you have 25 users, that may not be much of a cost savings. But, corporations with thousands of users are beginning to take note. Sure, there will be a greater training investment, but it may be more cost effective to do a switch or at least, switch those who can fit into the environment with more ease.
Microsoft will not be replaced for a long time, if ever, but the use of homogenous networks that take advantage of the strong points of the various OS's in combination with the price breaks these technologies have to offer will definitely be on the increase!
by jdclyde
And most of the MS clones here won't remember a time when Lotus 1-2-3 was THE standard for all accounting and business.
The also won't remember that WordPerfect was THE word processor standard of ALL business.
If WordPerfect and Lotus 1-2-3 would have joined instead of trying to each come up with their own office suit, MS would have never gotten it's foot in the door. MS office was at the right place at the right time, nothing more, nothing less.
Standards changed before, they will change again.
The only thing that doesn't change in technology is that things change.
by ploosh
As far as office suites, Sun's OpenOffice v2.0 is pretty impressive (openoffice.org). Files can be saved to any of the major application file types or to the open standard. Exchanging documents between them has been seamless in my experience. The suite is a free download and has a Windows installer. It's silly not to experiment with it. After that, some cost analysis would show you the true value of implementing it.
One trend that is becoming obvious is that users are looking for flexibility in their technology. They want a platform from which they can move into multiple directions depending on need. You see this most obviously with entertainment where users want a platform and then the ability to use devices for voice, video, audio, games, GPS, etc. The base might be anything from a mobile phone to a PSP to a Windows Media Center PC.
This trend of flexibility will carry over into business applications as users find that the systems they use at home are not much different from those they use at the office: notebooks, mobile phones, PDAs, VOIP, whatever. Open standards will provide this flexibility. Open standards will also be your saving grace, as many managers and technologists have probably experienced the frustration of a latest user's proprietary "find" that is now their application or technology of choice.
by natem1
by unclerob
by vas_galati
by jdclyde
There are many in here that run rings around me and my humble IT workings.
As for which linux distro to use, that is a religion war all on it's own. Most will tell you the distro they like at home. Stay away from that. Ask what they use in a major corporation.
I started out with SCO Unix for our legacy cobol programs that are our life blood. Additional servers were on RedHat as we added email, intranet, internet sites, test servers and a backup server.
I am interested in what SuSE is doing and am just about ready to do some testing on it and it is the likely candidate for the next server. I like that they are pushing a desktop AND a server to work together, not one or the other. And Novell product have been rock steady for a long time.
All of mine are running on IBM rack mount servers, and I would rather have five small servers than one big server, which is the approach I take. Because I don't have more money wrapped up in licensing than I do in hardware it is easy to just throw another server in the mix.
This means if any one server goes down for any reason, we only lose access to one small part of the services offered by IT.
Users like Jaqui, apotheon, and HAL 9000 (col) are a few in here that would have a good feel for what is what out there. There are many more I am sure, but as I have been hiding in the Misc section for a while now I don't get as much exposure to them.
by berto
I think that they are also more vunerable(in part) because they are an "easier target". Now I'm mentioning this because my sister is a MS User to the bone, and I had a situation with her once in a chat room.(I know I see the tilted heads and dog ears, who has time for chat?lol) I can't tell you how many times for example I have visited a "Chat room" for instance only to hear people with wanna be cool names talking smack to people(My sister,for one). Which is why I got involved in this particular situationin the first place) on windows machines thinking they're untouchable because someone wrote a little protection app. in VB.(Three words for them... One Less Hit.)
While in linux/ I was once offered a challenge to take someone(a smack talker) out of a room. The task handled in about 2 min/45 seconds.
(Hmmmm, rubs chin and wonders if the poor guy ever saw a blue screen before he met me)
the point is that it has been said before, but I'll say it again. The reason windows is exploited is because it can be. QUICKLY!(You wont see anyone on a windows machine hopping onto a voice server(apache by the way) and grabbin ip's. It'l kick ya before you get in.
Now my computer experience started in 1982 on an IBM 4 phaze while doing data entry for the dept. of agriculture. I have seen a lot over the years. Quite simply, Open Source Works because the community never sleeps, young and old, there are always people providing soultions for the people interested in finding them.(Ahem,Homeland security hasn't told users to stop using Firefox)What are the Big Dogs running? Ping a homeland server and see what comes back.(It's not MS)I think that people should wake up a little when they think about security. I have for instance a 14 year old nephew that eats servers for lunch. Kids these days are "wicked smart" and breathe this stuff as we breathe air. They are "target marketed" into thinking that "Norton" can save them from anything when in reality it's the biggest resource hog of them all.(Lets bog down the machine we are working on so it will be more efficient,)lol.
People are afraid of change. Mostly because they relate it to pain, money<--a big one, fear, loss, whatever. Believe it or not there are still offices using windows 98. Where's the support or compatibility in that?
People(Front end users) don't change because they are lazy, or too comfortable in what they are doing. Hence the fear factor.It might mean that they will actually have to work a little harder.
A CEO would much rather have a new car or vacation home, than have to go through the headache of having to train his staff for the upgrade.
The companies that see the light (when the time comes)will already be set. It will be the ones that didn't change to the more secure O.S that will suffer the losses.
[quote]
If you can show me how to convert all my servers and desktops to Linux and run all my present applications and still be able to communicate with my customers and vendors, and do it all for FREE, I might give it a closer look. I wish Linux pushers would quit using the term Free! I have read some pretty convincing points from some of the remarks here and I plan on researching further into Linux, but I don't expect it to be free.
[/quote]
Unfortunately, too many people expect everything to be free (as in beer) as opposed to free (as in freedom) but you are right, don't expect it to be free. I think the "free software" revolution has been hurt because of the "hidden costs" associated with free software. Until people understand that it will cost (time and/or money) to install, configure & run the free software - things will not change.
Sort by Trending