So many zealots, so little time
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Windows Forum
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by ploosh
Free is a confusing term, especially in the Linux world. Sometimes it is used to describe the dollar cost associated a vendor transaction. Other times it is used to describe the "state" of the software code, "free as in freedom". Most analysts realize that there is always a cost, no matter what.
In essence, it's a matter of scale. The larger the scale of the project the more your costs will potentially rise - and vice versa. The cost analysis performed on your potential project will determine that.
But, in perspective, someday when you go to buy MS Windows Longhorn to test on your computer you will give a vendor some money. When you go to download Ubuntu Linux, you will not have to pay anything - that transaction will be "free".
by jdclyde
Richard Prior, when they just get done saying how a mastermind like that would lay low and so they would never track him down, comes flying into the company parking lot in his new sports car with the music just a blaring.
ah, the good ol' daze....
by jmgarvin
by jmgarvin
as with everything else, there is no such thing as a free lunch. There is always overhead and there will always be some cost associated with computing.
Free in the case of linux means more freedom and no crazy licensing schemas (ala MS or Macromedia)
by jmgarvin
Distros are a religious war! I like Fedora Core 3 for home use and simple servers. I like Red Hat for "real" servers. Debian is good too, but I just don't like the "feel" of it. I also quite like Slackware for clustering or for IDS platforms.
I agree that Red Hat is the way to go for that type of serving. It works well in most roles, but keep in mind that clustering will really make it shine.
IBM also has great support, but I haven't used them for years. Sun is also top notch with their support, but their hardware makes me unhappy. I like how you can custom order your packages so that you can have your geological survey server and your mail server installed (and partially setup) correctly on delivery.
by oz_media
Although I've only been really working with Linux since Netware and Ximian did their merger, I have swapped out several MS systems (and upped a NW server or two) to Novell Suse Linux (Suse 9.2 desktops) and Ximian. I have installed a few Novell Desktops but the client had me swap them out for Suse as the NW desktops were still pretty cut down.
But as for usability, learning curve etc. Clients have LOVED Suse desktops, it uses KDE 3.3 ( I believe that's the latest version, could be 3.2)so it's pretty darn solid and the desktop works exactly the same as windows, the software is just as easy to access and use and for the most part, open office (packaged with the desktops) handles almost all MS functionality with the exception of some Excell macros, which will be added soon I'm sure).
The thing to consider is, Suse has been around donkeys years but is still fairly new as far as workstation desktops and development. In it's INFANCY it has danced circles around MS stability, is just as easy to use, and only has a few limitations with teh suite that is in the box. It also allows access to about 2000 titles you can download for nothing or next to it, right from teh desktop pulldown menu, so the package for what you pay is light years ahead of what MS offers.
No user complaints, less desktop visits, les crashes, people that use it have loved it because finally they can actually get more work done in the day without all the problems.
Hey it's a free opinion okay, you want a more comprehensive one you can pay for it, just send me email. ;-)
by apotheon
Actually, getting mom/grandma/whoever a Mac is a pretty good idea. It's not quite as good in a number of ways as an all-open-source unix would be, but a relative know-nothing won't ever miss the differences. In fact, some benefits look like detriments to those that don't know what they're doing.
There are a number of philosophical reasons to recommend against a Mac no matter what the technical needs, but there aren't really any philosophical [b]or[/b] technical reasons to recommend against one [b]as compared with a Windows PC[/b] these days, unless you have some specific business need that [b]requires[/b] a Windows machine.
As for being an MCP proving you're unbiased: perhaps it would be instructive to know that I'm Microsoft certified as well. I would hope that lends me some credence in the eyes of readers, but I won't hold my breath. Heh.
by jmgarvin
Because of .Net much more of your code is more portable and with the JIT compiler you will find your homemade apps are a little more efficient on everyones system.
The problems with .Net are pretty minor and at least MS is working towards making code portable (although there is much to be desired in that respect to other OSs).
C# is a spiffy language and the built-in libs for C++ are pretty sweet.
by apotheon
Admin competence is key, to be certain. So too is your choice of platform for the job. It's pretty bad practice to choose technologies based on the biases of the admins.
I feel for you, being in the position of having to deal with hiring policies that prevent you from getting the admins you need to do the jobs according to a clear assessment of technology needs. That doesn't mean that the various technologies don't have strengths and weaknesses that make them more or less suited to particular jobs.
In an ideal world, you'd be able to continue running that webserver on FreeBSD. If you really cannot do so because of a particular admin, though, you'll just have to suffer, I suppose. That doesn't mean that a Windows solution is the "right" solution for the job, though. It just means you've got a problem admin and a bad situation that comes with him.
by jdclyde
you are taking for granted that the *nix desktop would not be running a GUI while the windows system would be.
Now with both in a gui that the five year old could use, which is "better"?
Guess you would have to go back to real questions like cost of hardware to run and stability.
Better?
by apotheon
MacOS X is a huge leap forward for the Mac. It's incorporation of a BSD/Mach derived kernel and OpenStep derived GUI framework make it one of the most credible personal computer options going. It's an extremely well-suited OS for end users who don't want to know what their computers are doing, and provide a number of benefits for those who do, as well.
MacOS X doesn't suit my needs nearly as well as a customized Linux setup, but as you noted Mac hardware can run Linux. In fact, the most-portable Linux distribution, Debian, has a Mac architecture port available (so Yellow Dog isn't the only Linux distro available for the Mac). Luckily for me, Debian also happens to be my distro of choice. I'm sure there are other distros with Mac ports available as well. I'd like to add a reasonably modern Mac (perhaps a Powerbook) to my collection of computers, in fact, and set it up as a dual-boot with Debian.
Having more options is a good thing. Ignoring options because of bias is not a good thing. You're right, though: Windows mostly looks like malware, compared to Linux and MacOS X.
by jdclyde
as soon as people no longer have to be skilled in anyway, they are easier to replace and less of a value to the company and thus rate a lower wage.
Highly skilled people make a higher wage than some shmoe off the streets that can only type data into a prepaired form.
And back when I taught lotus 1-2-3, I started in DOS teaching working people how to use the application.
Look around your office and decide which of the people sitting their would take more than a week to replace, including yourself.
This dumbing down has also led to people not having proper respect for admins that HAVE TO KNOW what they are doing and have had extensive training to do what they do.
by apotheon
The "Run As" feature is broken, anyway.
Actually, to be strictly accurate, the "Run As" feature isn't broken: the permissions system on which it's built is broken. Even when you're not running something as the Administrator, malware and security crackers find it disturbingly easy to escalate and bypass system privileges to do damage to a Windows system. The "Run As" feature is pretty much useless except as a tool to make end users think twice before screwing things up. Often, end users don't bother to think twice, anyway. You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make it drink, as the old saying goes.
by scsadmin
It's just my opinion but I think people get confused about what they are discussing. Everyone has to remember that the people on this forum and anyone else they are likely to have an argument with over Linux vs Microsoft are already computer professionals. I think a number of us already use both OS's and the rest wouldn't have that much trouble if they tried.
So part of my answer is that for people like us linux is better, I think its a more secure OS etc etc all the other arguments. While there is a learning curve when switching to linux as a computer professional you should be used to this, there are thousands of programs out there and each time I come across a new one I start learning from scratch again.
Having said that I also think the windows OS is a great OS (no flames please). Why? Usability/familiarity. All my users are happy using windows because thats what they have used for years. Even upgrades from 98 to XP or whatever the OS still feels familiar to them. This wont change. It really doesn't matter what people like us think. Even if someone in charge of upgrading a companies computers gives users and management an option they are going to go with windows.
Something I think causes some of the conflict in forums like this is that there are two types of computer professionals.
Type 1, comprised of two groups; server administrators, network admins etc who use linux professionally. Enthusiasts who have used computers extensively at home and value linux highly.
Type 2, people who are in professions like programmers, where the OS isn't as important to them. They are happy to stay with windows because thats what they know and changing to linux wouldn't really improve their work (as with everything there are exceptions).
well theres my 2 cents worth
cheers
by dabouncer
by apotheon
Gradually, the M (for Manual) in RTFM is getting replaced by a G (for Google), making RTFG the new RTFM. Heh.
That's hilarious. I'm always amused by answers easily found in Google that people don't bother to find on their own.
by jmgarvin
It seems people are getting to lazy to even google answers anymore. How hard is it to type in a search and find your answer?
I mean come on...asp to php conversion or howto asp to php
by hal 9000
Some people are unwilling to look because they just might find that the money that they have spent on their current certifications are not all that important anymore.
Why would you go looking for something that is against what you believe in. ?
Col ]:)
by apotheon
by apotheon
I guess you're not familiar with the term "open source software". See, the way this works is a bunch of people that want a particular piece of software to exist and work well, and who have programming skill, work on this piece of software. They develop it, improve it, and ensure that the source code is publicly available so that others who want it to work well can also contribute time and effort to it.
These are people that are "in it" to have a good piece of software. This is not about fleecing the end user, squeezing every last nickel possible out of customers in exchange for as little work as possible. This is about producing [b]really good[/b] software so that they can use it themselves, and getting others to help in the same endeavor. Everybody benefits because everybody has a vested interest in seeing the software improve, and because nobody has a conflict of interest that prompts them to create crap software.
Frankly, I trust those motives a lot more than Microsoft's corporate vision. Besides, in my extensive experience with both open source and Microsoft software platforms, it's a fairly well established trend that Microsoft's offerings leave something to be desired pretty much universally.
by jdclyde
by dpatillo
Have you guys ever watched the boot up screens on a SCO BOX? A lot of SCO is licensed from, you guessed it, MICRO$OFT in the form of Xenix. Microsoft owns/owned Xenix. Why do they need to "license" SCO to get *nix technology? The answer is "They do not need to!" Remember, the source code of linux is free.
The thing that would be devastating to linux is for MS to go totally open source. I hate to think about it!
by apotheon
I would absolutely [b]love[/b] Microsoft to go 100% open source! I'm not married to the penguin. I like it because it's good, and because it's open source. If Microsoft went all OSS, it would either get wiped out entirely or its software would finally really start getting good. Either way, we win.
Plus, y'know, all those Microsoft-created compatibility issues would evaporate.
by jmgarvin
Then when I have to kludge together some app and wonder why it isn't making a library call correctly (is it me or is it the OS) or if I need to get down and dirty with the system, I like to see what is happening other than (There was an error at 0x20897587)
Down with the black box, up with open source!
by jmgarvin
by jmgarvin
by rick.smith
by hal 9000
To say that "Ms is far and away the best value"
Well I've worked with banks and Government departments and I didn't see a single Windows Server in the place for two main reasons the first is that they are inherently insecure and two they suck up way too much of the system resources just to run the OS before you even start to load a high intensity usage to the server.
With the reintroduction of "Thin Clients" Windows is just pure and simple unsuitable for these as you have lost 30% of the system resources before you even start that is the amount used by Windows itself with the minimum site licenses installed it only gets worse the more licenses you install. The idea was to get away from using floors of buildings as server rooms but with a Windows Server room that is what you need but with a Nix server room you require far less hardware. So just where is the saving in costs?
Col ]:)
by jdclyde
About refusing to acknowledge a problem even when presented with facts, a user in the linked discussion at that point seemed to imply that if you had a problem installing XPsp2, it was your fault or the fault of your other software vendors. I then linked to many issues on the MS support site discussing many of the problems people are having that have nothing to do with third party software.
My *nix servers have all been up at least 160 days as of last week when I checked. They went down last because I work at an industrial plant with lots of dust so I have regualar cleanings. How long have your servers been up non-stop? What was the reason of the last three reboots?
Desktops, I have several users that will experience 3 to 6 crashes a week. I have applied all patches, and have them running 512 ram. Blame third party for this? It isn't always the same packages being used when the systems go down.
I have many reservations about linux as a desktop and have pointed some of them out. File structure is a big one. And yes, too much choice can be a bad thing.
Security isn't the responsibility of the end user, it is the responsibility of the ADMIN. If the systems get exploited, it is the ADMINS fault. Either for not having them properly protected, or not having a product that could be properly protected.
You mentioned police to prevent crimes. You can also do things to prevent your house from getting broken into. Lock windows and doors. Have around the house well lit. Remove shrubs that could be used for concealment. plants around the house should be of a thorny nature, esp under windows. You don't have to CHOOSE to be a victom.
Now that I have clerified, I fully expect to hear in detail why I am wrong.
by unclerob
I can almost hear you yelling in your post, calm down just a wee bit (or don't, it's your blood pressure, not mine!).
I don't refuse to acknowledge any problems with Microsoft & Windows, I just don't find a need rant about how bad things are and why we need to jump ship to another platform.
Although I will agree that SP2 has caused problems for some users personally I haven't experienced any ill effects of rolling out SP2 to any of my WinXP boxes here at work. Maybe we're lucky or maybe this is just how it works for some & not for others - I wish I could say.
My W2K servers (and one remaining NT4 server) run non-stop, if I have had to reboot them in the last 160days which probably did happen at least 3-4 times, it was to apply the latest & greatest offering of security & critical updates from Microsoft. This was done during off-hours, didn't impact our office or distribution center and took a few minutes per server. Not a big deal really for a 160day period that you quoted. It works out to maybe once a month and while I'm doing that I dust out my servers inside & out as well.
I will say this, 3-6 crashes a week is way too much. My head would spin if my users complained & reported that many crashes per week. We log all of our helpdesk calls into a database and I would have carpal tunnel syndrome if I had to log 3-6 crashes per user per week! Too many users, too many machines and just one of me at my site.
I can't comment on your specific windows installs but it would definitely appear your having problems at your end. My users are running p4 boxes with 256mb of ram, I'm probably the only user that runs with 1/2 gb of ram in my box which is overkill for most users. Maybe in your situation, it's the hardware itself? Are you running brand name boxes on the desktops (IBM, HP/Compaq, Dell, etc.) or are you working no name brand beige boxes which might be just fine too.
Also how do roll out the windows installs? Do you create a drive image after setting up one pc perfectly and then rollout that image to the other hardware or do you setup each box separately? What kind of maintenance routine do you run on your pc's? Disk cleanup, defrag, pagefile defrag, registry cleanup, spyware & antivirus scanning & removal, etc. Do your users have unrestricted access to the net or do you have a firewall/content filter in place that restricts where they might go. How do you roll out windows updates to each desktop? Do you manually install the updates or do you push them out to your users using SMS or SUS(that's what we use, it's free and works well). What office apps do you use? Office XP or do you use WordPerfect or OpenOffice? We're pretty much a microsoft shop, all of our apps (or 98%) are Microsoft aside from a few Adobe, IBM & Oracle apps.
I guess we're agreed on the ADMIN & security issue so need to go into that one.
My original post didn't mention choosing to be a victim, obviously no one sane does. My point was to stop blaming Microsoft for all the security issues and support legislation for harsher penalties against those individuals that are caught that take advantage of security weaknesses and inflict damage on those user's pc's that are unprotected.
In the end, I don't hate Linux, just the opposite, I think it's pretty cool for those that know what they're doing, I've personally setup several test linux boxes to connect to our LAN using several distro's such as redhet, suse, lycoris, mandrake, beatrix, DSL, gentoo, ubuntu (and Corel Linux when they a dist available).
However, IMHO it's not a viable option at the present time for mainstream corporate or home use. Too many linux flavors out there, competing with each other, it's hard for anyone to pick a standard and stay with (I guess you could argue that redhat or suse is a safe bet, a few years ago I would have thought Mandrake was Linux king). That's not to say that this won't change in the near future. I've never setup a linux server but I'm guessing my experience would have been similar to my linux desktop installs.
I'm also sure Microsoft spends time examining all of the linux distributions that are comparable and you can bet that if an interesting feature in a linux os is discovered, it will be lifted, copied and ported over to the latest MS OS offering (Microsoft is probably the best at this type of work, everyone will admit that)
Is this really a question of who's right or wrong? No, just a debate over which product is better and why people should use one over the other. You have your opinion and I have mine and I'll leave it at that. I don't wish to step on anyone's toes as mine are beat up enough as it is.
- that's my 0.02 cents cdn.
by techrepublic
by techrepublic
by jmgarvin
by jdclyde
Installed correctly? I clicked on the "I agree" didn't I???/
As for the avitar, I haven't gotten around to making my own yet and the ones TR has are so limiting, ya know? It has been changed several times, and was the red dice last.
I have kept the M$ and Windoze to a minimum in here. It is all in good fun as I get it back everytime I turn around. You just take things way too seriously.
And I have been fairer with MS than many here have been with *nix. So how does that paint them? My main beef with MS is they need the competition to get them to make a higher quality product than they have. When Win2k server came out, it was pitched as more stable than windows NT. Buy this because it is better than the last crap we fleeced you for.
Biased? Maybe. Disappointed? Maybe. Zealot? I wouldn't think I am blined to one side as I use both daily and will continue to use both daily.
by techrepublic
by jmgarvin
by techrepublic
ITT TEch? You or someone spent a lot of money to indoctrinate you. Good job clone. Don't you have a $mil to go waste now?
The last IT department I was in charge of, had a per PC operating and captial budget INCLUDING all development projects of <$500 per year. Most of it was salary. And we were definately over staffed, a good 30% of our time wasted in meetings with stake-holders in the software development process not wanting to take responsibility for anything.
You thought what I said before was crazy -- like a fox if you ask me -- check this. My LAN optimization strategy was sitting for a few minutes at key times of the day watching my switches...the little blinky lights. Then based on my understanding of the various roles of people in the organisation, I would make adjustments to user groups I would divide up using $80 5 or 8 port switches based on usage patterns.
I bet you any money when my users on old P90's running RAID 0 promise drive arrays presed the power swich in the morning, opened their e-mail, and loaded their bloated XLS files, they were ready to work before your Windows 2000 boxes even presented a login prompt.
If you think all this is crazy, you should see what I can do with database apps across a WAN without a single SQL server anywhere.
Hey your team is in the majority, you have a lot of peers. Still if its $ and user-satisfaction we are interested in (remember when that used to be the point of IT in business?) I'll take you on any day.
by jmgarvin
I didn't go to ITT, I went to New Mexico Tech and I am working on a PhD in computer science from there. I generally focus on information security and hacking. Pulling out the ad homs are pretty lowbrow...
1) Sounds like a typical IT department
2) Makes sense, many people do this because they have to. Hell, I worked at a place with a bagillion (give or take a few) VLANs because of the wonky topologie(s?) that were put in place years ago. Before I got to it the whole network would be borked if someone unplugged a SINGLE cable from virtually any site. Typical IT stuff.
3) Uh, I'm not married to Win2k. However, I'd choose 98 over ME any day. Why? Stability. ME has serious issues with stability and the support is still terrible. While 9x is unsupported by MS, there is still plenty of vendor support for at least 98, if not 95.
4) You lost me on running a database over a WAN with no db server...Are you saying that the dbs were decentralized (possibly run on the clients) or that you just weren't running SQL?
5) I agree with you here. You have to have customer satification or you won't have a job. ME has no place in that. I'd use 98 or 2k (possibly XP, but I have my gripes with it as well) over ME.
The major issue here is that you claim ME is stable and far better than 9x or 2k/XP. I competely disagree. ME is a mess of an OS and will NEVER be anything more.
by techrepublic
Well some people like extra options...I mean, isn't that the pitch for ever increasing resourcing hogging millions of lines of new OS code? Take a modern PC, and stick a Win9X on it. ME in particular will utilize all that RAM and work your USB 2.0 devices properly. It is really fast. Really very fast.
I use Linux too. I think this is the difference between me and your average IT bloke. If you free your mind, you can apply the right tool to the right job.
I like to work backwards from the task at hand. Let's take the Windows 2K verses XP debate. A high percentage prefer 2K. I like XP better. Why do most techs hate XP Home? Cause it doesn't support old apps as well. Ok. Why then is it "cool" to be supportive of old apps (16 bit) when its 2K or XP Pro we are talking about, but out of the question when its ME we are talking about?
Another angle. If a cracker owns Linux/Unix, there is more they can do...more devistation. If you own a Windows 95C box, what can you do? These arguments always seem to indicate a demand to have it both ways. The OS that is more "simple" is bad when you suggest a use in one case, yet the fave OS's have all these extra administration features, that techs love, but also make an exploit more devistating.
Would I run an Internet exposed host on a Windows PC period...not likely. But if the task at hand is to give a generic user a way to surf the net, run Office X, and do some e-mail, why give them OpenBSD? You can, but why would you?
If the task at hand is to get all-in costs down for a client, then what is the better choice? And if your user base is all in one location, do you need all the remote control features of a Linux or 2K or XP Pro? Maybe you do if the user base is 5,000 users, maybe you don't if it is a lot less than that.
Its complicated for sure, doing the right thing in a given situation. But being dogmatic seems to add little value from my experience.
Especially of consideration is the amount of the IT budget going to infrustructure, at the expense of say software development. I'm pretty proud of my record on this.
I built a hard-drive based backup appliance using NT 4.0 and a Linux distro three years ago for two major reasons -- unreliable tape, and quick restores for users. Now I see such appliances selling for tens of thousands. I wrote mine using primarily XCOPY running NT, and a BAT file. Total cost hardware and labour, maybe $2000 tops.
For that client, 80% of our IT budget went to the development of their key app. The IT ran on 8 years worth of old equipment and software, and some old-fashioned know-how.
Hacking is a lost art. Cracking is still misunderstood. Dogma is rampant. IT budgets and managers only "see" branded products and respond to propaganda any more.
It is simple really. The quality of your network and all the devices on it, speak more to the quality of you people. This is not a popular thing any more. The suits at the door from Microsoft and HP aren't going to tell the low-cost story. Just to pay for their flights and hotels, they have to suck you in to X% of expensive products. They aren't really solving your problems in a lot of cases, you are solving their problems. That's why the big vendors spend so much on advertising in places executives go. So when you or your boss shows up suggesting spending $500,000 on branded "sollutions" they are ready to support.
I've lost almost all respect for both IT and executive management. I think this is fair, as they long ago lost repect for creativity, experience, and thinking outside the (glossy) box. You can probably pick this up from my attitude in these threads.
I AM daring someone with a huge IT budget to hire me, and watch me return most of the budget at the end of the fiscal period. I'm an enimgma in IT, and its an easy sell to make me sound "dangerous" in the boardroom. But here is hoping someone out there isn't a frightened clone, and rings me up. Someone who likes to watch $$$$$$.
My next idea? Deploying a fleet of Mac Mini's across a corporation, that interface to a corporate catch-all automation application strictly via e-mail. There will be Microsoft products in the rack, and there will be Linux in the rack, and there will be hacking going on, and it will be ultra-low-cost, and it will be very cool -- and most importantly, it will give my client a competitive advantage.
I've already had my "fun" playing with gear. I don't need a fat budget based on dogma and propaganda to enjoy my job. I get off on doing business...weird I know, but to the right ear, should be music. Waiting...
by rapell
Here is an interesting article I stumbled upon. Makes some good reading.
Do you see it happening? complete with SP1 & SP2?
Its an old article but will do...
read on:
http://www.eweek.com/article2/0%2C1759%2C1400161%2C00.asp
by apotheon
by rapell
what i wanted to point out here. As I read
through most of the posts it occurred to me that
the debate was more of MS Vs Linux(I dunno which
flavor) and so I wanted to point out that MS can
also have Linux, and then see what people would
say about it...would they still go with
Microsoft if it ventured into open source MS
Linux or Winix as someone put it or are people
becoming anti-microsoft, irrespective? will
microsoft hide a *nix based OS under Windows and
fail to make it open source and free? the
queries are infinite..
by jmgarvin
I wonder if MS is positioning itself to release a version of its OS based on the Linux kernel? I also wonder if perhaps MS is actually starting to copy some of the idead of the Linux kernel (this would be a good thing).
The whole SCO deal really makes you wonder exactly what is going on in Redmond.
by apotheon
by stubby
Having started my "IT career" in fixing hardware I didn't much care what OS or software was running on the box - I dealt with whatever it was at the time.
Be it CPM, DOS, *nix, MacOS, etc. However, when it came to advising end users what to use I always took the same approach. My first (and hopefully only) question would be "What OS have you used already or what OS are you most familiar with?". Their answer always helped me point them in the right direction.
Secondly, in the early days (15 to 20yrs back) I woul normally also ask what they wanted to do with the box. If it was DTP, then off to Macs you go. If games, then get yourself a DOS based box with QEMM as a memory manager ....
No one answer is ever right for all, but I believe I've helped more folks over the years with my non-specific approach than the die-hards out there and I've met a few of them.
Most Open Source is Free, that means you don't make a buck.
Any OS can be made secure and stable by people who know what they are doing. I agree.
Course, that means MS don't know what they are doing because though getting a little better, it's neither. Also it never will be without addressing it's architectural problems, most of which are very useful on the marketing front, to those for whom security and stability doesn't matter all that much
by jdclyde
I guess I didn't go into this enough to explain myself. I have several users right now that every year end I have to spend about two weeks changing all of their files over for the next year.
Everytime they need to keep track of a new account, I have to go and do this. I was hired to teach people how to work in spreadsheets, and run the network. Spreadsheet programming was not something I was suppose to be doing but the one person in accounting that made the sheets is not with the company and no one else wants to learn this so it gets dumped in my lap.
I was talking applications such as Excel, not writting a program with a user interface.
Now can I blame the users please?
by hal 9000
Why didn't you contribute to the Discussion of SP2 that was running a few months ago?
As you obviously have all the answers why are you unprepared to share them with the rest of us?
Col ]:)
by rknrlkid
I tend to believe that choice in organizations is arbitrary, based on the whim of whoever can make a decision at the time.
In 1987 while I was in the Army, the contract was with Zenith for the Z-248 system. It came standard with Lotus 1-2-3, Multimate and dBase III as part of the contract. In 1989, laptops were bought for all small units, and the software consisted of Enable. By 1992, Multimate was replaced by WordPerfect 5.1. EDS won a new contract (I think it was 1993), and their computers came preinstalled with Windows 3.1, but WordPerfect and Lotus 1-2-3 were added to them locally. When I got to Hawaii in 1995, everyone was standardizing to Microsoft Office.
No logic or reasoning apparently, just a decision based on whoever made the contract, and in some cases (like with WordPerfect) the preference of someone with influence. I think that has alot more to do with what is being run than what is technically "best."
by dogzilla
(Great discussion btw.)
Imagine an industry or individual company deciding to convert itself over to a different OS. For the sake of easy hypothetical purposes let's say ms-hostageward to some *nix distribution. Considering the true costs of training including the lag in performance and efficiency of people getting used to and learning something new... back up to speed with the new systems, what if they simply bought most of their employees a take home computer freely loaded with basically the new stuff. Costs of hardware can be kept low as *nix performance doesn't require as much pie in the sky resources as the typical latest hostageware does. Depending on the *nix distribution the software costs could be extremely low. So total initial cost of a 'home play' system might could be kept in the low hundreds.
Now here is where the intrinsic rubber hits the road. The real costs of training and getting back up to speed is pretty high often even when "simply" doing an "upgrade" of existing systems. But what if the users were passionate and self-motivated about the new change such that they are now spending additional hours on their new 'home' computers playing, surfing and... getting very familar, comfortable and proficient on the new OS?
I can foresee the IS staff initially traumatized by such a concept especially if they are also charged with answering the increased number of questions and doing some limited support for the 'home' users. On the other hand, isn't it much easier and more satisfying to work with a user when they are enthusiastic and pumped up about their new system and what they are doing? And if handled well from the beginning, a lot of the basics and intermediate stuff will flow through the users with little demand placed on the IS staff. Scarey for some shops to consider such a scenerio I'm sure but this is not unlike what helped get a lot of ms-hostageware in the door of entrenchment in many businesses to begin with.
by apotheon
That's a very good idea.
There's a $500 Linux laptop called the Balance available through Wal-Mart. That'd probably be a good candidate. With the right person negotiating the deal, you could probably even get a significant bulk discount.
by hal 9000
I see them just like Volvo drivers their owners seem to have some form of blind allegiance to the Apple Platform against everything else and they make the Windows Vs Nix look like child's play in comparison. I still have some very vivid memories of a trade show a few years ago where the Apple people where describing the XP boxes as "DOS BOXES" in a very derogatory way. That is something I have not even seen at MS meetings when talking about Linux.
But for my particular case a Mac would not be appropriate for the hardware requirements that are currently in use with the photocopier being a network printer the makers of the photocopier do not supply Mac drivers for all the functions and while you could have limited print ability from the Mac to the Photocopier you couldn't scan from it to the Mac unless you where prepared to write your own drivers and rework programs for it to work. Of course I'm not talking about the latest MAC OS's but something about 3 + years old.
In my particular case that would be even worse than attempting to explain just why it is that you click on the "Start" button to close the thing down. :(
Col ]:)
by unclerob
by dogzilla
by jdclyde
Yes, there are distros that you can download with no charge other than your time. If using in a corporate environment, esp if you are new to it, you will want to use a disrto that has support. I am not talking bulletin boards or tech boards but a tech on the phone if you have a problem. If your business goes down you don't have two days to wait for an answer on the tech board.
While the servers go down less frequently, any computer can crash and most times they are caused by an application or user doing something that would be classified as an "oops".
If your playing around at home, you can go the "free" route because it will only cost you time. In business you don't have time to spend.
For business stay with the Redhat or SuSE. Too bad Caldera has been hijacked by weasles, or that would have been where I would have been looking next.
And even the "free" distros can be purchased in a box. This gives you the disks already made up, and a manual on how to install. This manual is free to download, but then you would have to print it off. I go down the middle on a lot of this. Download some, purchase some. The purchase is a good start for people that are REALLY new, but if your comfortable with your dns/IP/gateway information (which you sound like you are) you could get away with the 4 disk image download.
Just know what you want to do with the install. If you just do an install (which is really easy) and then sit at fresh box saying "now what?" it won't be very helpful. Do you want a disktop? Do you want a server? Same disks, different install.
Good luck.
by unclerob
The more I read these posts, the more I learn that for the most part the IT Pro's answering these posts are disgruntled and angry for some odd reason (overworked, underpaid, not enough love?). I'm sure he tried Google and other sources for the info he's looking for.
Is it just me or does everyone seems to be an A$$ buster lately. I read your bio before previously in other posts, it seemed that you were very knowledgeable and professional, I guess appearances can be deceiving.
The site that you quote helps you convert asp to php but if you listened and actually read his post, he asked for an asp emulator to which you respond "Can't people use google anymore?"
From what he's mentioned, he's done the work already in asp, he doesn't want to have to recode everything again in php and who would if it's a big project. I'm sure he's not lazy either, he's just trying to do the job efficiently - who in their right mind would want to do all that work all over again along with testing involved to make sure his app works fine again. If it works in asp why not keep it that way?!
These forums should be a place for both current issue debates and technical assistance, if someone asks a question and you provide him a smartass remark like that, it makes me wonder how you act in real life both work & family life.
Hopefully you didn't get offended (too much!) by this reply, just pointing out that your response seemed a little crass.
by jmgarvin
If I came off as crass, I didn't mean to. It just irks me that so many people seem to post questions without going to google first. In this thread I also have seen a lot of statements that cannot/will not do something that it can do. So maybe I jumped the gun????
Anyway to go back to OPs question:
ASP emulation is possible, but there are inherient problems with that and probably should be avoided. He should probably convert to PHP (which may or may not be a chore) OR run the ASP on a seperate server (which is also a world of fun).
by hal 9000
Sure you can get a Linux OS for nothing other than the cost of the download but you can also buy it off the shelf so to speak just like Unix which is still very much alive and well thank you very much.
Just because your particular situation may not suit a Unix like OS doesn't mean that no one else's does. As for support you can get plenty and not necessarily on a pay as required basis, if you buy the product off the shelf so to speak the suppliers have to offer a service just like MS has to offer the same service. But if you download the OS and expect never to have to pay for support you are living in dream land as you quite rightly said no one works for free and I very much doubt you would either would you?
While I have not as yet had dealings with Novell on SUSE if their past record is anything to go by they offered a really good service and it was much better than what MS offered and they didn't first ask for a credit card to bill you like MS currently does.
But the real point here is basic security any Nix system is inherently more secure than a similar Windows system even with poor support as it is far harder to get things installed onto a Nix system undetected. When I first started working with computers they took up a large area and used Unix and the big ones still do if for no other reason than MS doesn't have a product to do the job on that hardware so you only have a choice between a closed source product like Unix or an open source product like Linux to work on these big high end computers as to which is the better is it all relative and depends on the person making the decisions just like which car is better for an individual each person will have a different answer but lets face facts Linux is a cheaper alternative to Unix and that is exactly why places like Novel, IBM and the like are going down the Linux road they can provide it and support it far cheaper than they can a Unix system on their high end units. ON these MS doesn't get a look in as they just do not have anything capable of running these things even part way right.
On the mid range servers you will get better performance on a Nix over any Windows OS every day and it is just plain and simple more secure as it is far harder to break into and even harder to install malicious software on no it's not impossible but it is certainly a lot harder than a Windows system which is so full of holes it isn't funny.
Look at Windows 2003 ES one of its new great features was the ability to only allow e-mail to be read by the receiver and the ability to limit it being modified printed or forwarded on but within 2 weeks of its release there was a patch put out to fill a major hole in it and as it was only connected with IE it wasn't considered as a Critical Patch because the whole idea behind Es was not to have IE installed or working. Well if that was the case just how did you limit the e-mail that was sent out from being altered printed or forwarded?
There is no "Perfect" system and no matter how hard you try there will always be improvements put out but I did get a laugh out of your observation about the frequency of patches for the Nix's and Windows. The fact that you seem to think it acceptable to have a hole for at least 1 month if not longer because MS only rolls out patches on a monthly basis now and you where constantly receiving patch updates from RedHat to me shows that RedHat was plugging the holes faster than MS was even attempting to do.
The fact that Linux is a form of Unix which has been around and proved itself as a solid performer decades before Microsoft was even thought of in that garage should at the very least tell you something. The fact that MS push the higher education schools to only teach MS products and even them only in a limited fashion should also tell you something to.
The last time I attended a higher education facility training people how to use Office I asked when they where going to learn about performing mail merges and I was told that "We do not do those advanced things here we only cover the basics that will be used in a working life!" Now just what is it that makes grabbing a customer list from a D-Base and sending out personalized form letters to them such an advanced concept? Back in the DOS and early Windows days this was considered as a minimum requirement for a WP operator but today for some reason it isn't important and is considered as a unlikely application to do.
Isn't that the very reason why MS Office got the market because they tied several office applications into one package that made it easy to transfer data between applications and now they do not want to use it. Why is it so?
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
It is exactly how I work every day but then again I consult for small business so I give them the best performance for their buck that is possible to achieve.
I generally run a mix of products in the LAN environment and while a lot of desktops have Windows on them a lot don't as well it all depends on what is required and what dedicated software is used. On every occasion I use Windows on the Office Managers unit and anyone entering data into the accounting package but the sales side of things quite often has Linux on it and it not only works faster but is far more stable and easy for the sales people to use, I do not expect these people to know how to use a computer but I do expect them to be able to download a camera images and e-mail them which they are more than capable of doing on a basic Linux Desktop.
I generally run all Linux Servers around the place just to save money and give them better hardware for their money and I'm still coming in under what the License fee for MS Server is.
From where I stand it is up to me to offer the best value for money for my customers and to that end I never buy brand name boxes or Notebooks but build all my own and keep the basic configuration across the business the same. It makes it easier for the business and the person who has to maintain it after all in an office environment you never need surround sound speakers the ability to watch DVD's or play high end games you need the ability to work in a tightly integrated work environment where the computers are a means to an end not the end in themselves.
Col ]:)
by jdclyde
In stead of looking to run Windows packages on Linux, maybe the solution is packages that are designed to run on linux that do the same thing.
There are many applications that have a version for linux, Windows, AND MAC.
Drivers, as more people use linux more vendors will cater to this market. Remember your marketing classes boys and girls. Where is the biggest oportunity for growth? An existing (saturated) market, or a NEW market that is just opening up? (how quickly people forget as soon as they get out of school everything they learned)
There are lots of games that are for linux, and as the market grows more will join in on this. Emulators are just to get you over the hump while waiting for the vendors to fill this new market.
MS compatable? As MS does everything they can to make sure that NOTHING but their software is MS compatable, does this sound like a real goal? Remember that MS is NOT the internet standard, even though they try to make people think they are. If they want to stay in the game, they will be the ones to not make every attempt to MAKE everyone else incompatable so everyone HAS to use their hostage ware.
What say you? Sound far fetched or right on?
by apotheon
You make these statements that seem to paint others as hysterics because they rightly place blame at Microsoft's feet when Microsoft releases a "patch" (more like an OS rewrite) that breaks their servers, and go on to misrepresent how they went about discussing their problems. Then, of course, you play the innocent, as though you're being unfairly accused of zealotry.
News flash: you're acting just like some kind of marketing cabana boy.
"I only wish they could have told me something more about the problem than the fact that it was a Microsoft conspiracy," you say. What about the online posted lists of suddenly incompatible software? What about the Microsoft knowledge base articles indicating common failures? What about [b]my own several-paragraph explanations of SATA failure because SP2 uninstalled the drivers for the adapter?![/b]
Troll. That's all you are.
by jdclyde
Where do you think the inspiration for this discussion came from?
After making blanket statements that could not be backed up, he would indeed play victom and that he was misunderstood.
When he accused Col of being the problem behind his P4 installs, it was pretty clear what this guy was all about.
When he started out with the claim that SP2 didn't cause problems, it was the techs and third party vendors. When I linked for him many of the problems that MS has on their site, he would just not answer.
What makes me laugh is how many people here called me a linux zealot just because I think MS should be held to a higher standard than they are now. They see only what they want to see which is the parts in favor of linux, but not the parts where I have been in favor of windows.
Oh well.
"But it's all right now, I learned my lesson well.
You see, ya can't please everyone, so ya got to please yourself"
by jterry
by jdclyde
of this post!
to get people to look at both sides, good AND bad to see what is available.
I didn't say stop using MS products, I just said they should be held to a higher standard than they are right now.
I also tried pointing out where one may be a better fit than the other.
As for calling names, the worst I EVER did was one instance of calling you "clueless" because you were taking postings as an attack on YOU and got your back hunched up instead of listening to what people were trying to say. That is the closest to a personal attack, as I TRY to confront the idea, not the person.
As for hating MicroSoft, it is more their business practices that most people hate.
Care to start over? No hard feelings here.
by jck
Lemme help you out, jdclyde. I'm not afraid to hurt feelings ]:)
jterry...please...do me a favor...and go back over and get under Bill Gates' butt. He's missing some lips there.
Linux desktop is feasible. You can run apps for Windows on Linux, so users would have the same look and feel and almost zero retraining would be necessary.
It's not as profitable or convenient for you maybe, but is a heck of a lot more stable. You're not worried about how productivity would increase or your systems would have less breakdown. You're worried that, in the short term, it will cause downtime that will make you look bad and make your people less productive.
Get your head out of the short-term backend of the business world and do what's right...don't use a half-cocked answer about doing what's right when you're only doing what makes you the most and is most convenient.
Sorry...had to stir the pot...time to go home and have a beer. GOOD NIGHT!!! :)
by jmgarvin
1) No insane licensing schemas
2) Most of the same apps
3) Stability
4) Security
5) VMware
MS, on the other hand, SHOULD be accountable for their poor business practices, their crazy licensing schemes, and their unreliable and insecure software!
by noorman
that 's an incorrect comparison ...
Your car's exterior can't be accessed by the whole world like a 'web'-connected (home) PC is.
Even then, it gets broken into and possibly wrecked where it 's parked or during a joy-ride !
You have to learn to drive a car, learn which switch does what, what that handle does, when to put in fuel, oil, water, air ...
I know, many a woman drives with semi-flat tyres, too little oil or water and come to a halt being without fuel (unexpectedly).
So, to drive a car you have to be a semi-mechanic or you 're going to be by the roadside a lot of times (waiting for the repairman) ...
by apotheon
[u]in alphabetical order[/u]
[b]Debian[/b] (Debian GNU/Linux): In purely technical terms, this is probably as close to the "perfect" PC-hardware server OS as you'll ever get. It's very Linux Standard Base compliant, does excellent minimal installs, incorporates the best software management system for knowledgeable administrators I've ever used, and is supported by the most extensive and thoroughly tested software archives in the world for any OS (as far as I'm aware, at any rate). Security patching is excellent and stability is rock-solid. Use Debian Stable for servers that don't have to be anywhere near "cutting edge", and Debian Testing for servers that need more up-to-date packages. This is best for system and network administrators that know Linux and know networking, or at least want to and are willing to learn quickly. There's not a lot of hand-holding.
NOTE: I'm a Debian user by preference. Its strengths as a server OS also suit my needs for a desktop OS. It's not for use as a desktop OS by those who don't want to know about how their computers work, however: if you're not a geek, you probably want something else to use as your desktop system's OS. In fact, for desktop systems, Debian isn't much less dependent on technical know-how than Slackware. Debian is the second-oldest surviving Linux distribution, and one of the three distros most often described as being a hacker's OS (because, of course, the technically proficient computer enthusiast likes what it has to offer), along with Slackware and Gentoo.
[b]Gentoo[/b]: The odd distro out, Gentoo is designed around a "ports" system that uses specially prepared source packages instead of precompiled binaries. This allows users to bypass some uncomfortable licensing details with some software, but for the most part that's an irrelevancy. The real benefit, to hear most Gentoo users tell it, is in being able to customize the software itself to your particular system setup. Considering I've never run into customization needs that Debian couldn't provide me, Gentoo strikes me as superfluous, but I can understand how some users could find value in it. I do not recommend it for a production environment with any real traffic, though, as keeping software up to date by compiling everything is prohibitively time-consuming and using binary packages with Gentoo negates any advantages it might have over certain other distributions. This is more a home-user enthusiast's distro.
[b]Knoppix[/b]: This is the canonical LiveCD distribution. It's great at what it does, which is not exactly easy to define aside from saying it benefits from maximum portability. It's not a business-oriented Linux distribution by any stretch of the imagination. There are about a hundred different Knoppix versions, aside from the standard "plain vanilla" Knoppix, some of which are more business-oriented, tech-oriented, server-oriented, and so on, but aside from the firewall versions I wouldn't really recommend it for business use. It works great for party favors, though. This is the warm fuzzy of Linux distros.
[b]MEPIS[/b]: This is a Debian-based distribution (aren't they all?) that is specifically designed as a LiveCD distro. There are actually a few versions, including the standard MEPIS, SimplyMEPIS, and ProMEPIS. Each has its strengths. They're fantastic demonstrations of what's possible with Linux, great for people who want a portable Linux without having a portable computer, and easy to install on a hard drive if you decide that's what you want to do. I wouldn't recommend MEPIS for permanent install on desktop systems in a corporate environment, or for use as a server OS at all.
[b]RHEL[/b] (Red Hat Enterprise Linux): This is probably your best bet for corporate deployments of corporate-supported systems with certification-based hiring practices. The business model, and the OS design, is centered around distributed ease of network management with strong vendor support and an internal IT/IS department made up of people who will eventually want to move into management.
[b]Slackware[/b]: The oldest surviving Linux distro, Slackware is a "hacker's OS". It is as "generic Linux" as you can get without building the entire system from source the old-fashioned way, thus creating your own distro. It's maintained by one guy, the same guy who started the ball rolling with Slackware in the first place, and it does everything the "old fashioned way". It incorporates none of the spiffy benefits of the other distros, and none of their problems, either. It's do-it-yourself without the long compile times of Gentoo, but also without the ease of performance tweaking. It has the "just do the work" simplicity of Debian, without the benefits of the excellent software management system Debian uses, but without the complacency that can be gained from that kind of crutch. It's solid, stable, and flexible. It's also kind of "bare metal", with no hand-holding or "user friendly" vendor configuration wizards. Do not use this in a business environment unless you've already used another distro there, and unless you've also used Slackware somewhere else. This is not for the inexperienced, period.
[b]SuSE[/b] (Novell/SuSE Linux): This is the other major corporate-backed distro for enterprise deployment in Europe and North America. If you're looking for an integrated, managed, large-scale migration from Windows to Linux, this is probably your best bet. If you're looking for single-vendor integrated solutions, this is probably your best bet. SuSE is currently a better option for full-network enterprise Linux than RHEL, complete with desktop systems, under most circumstances, whereas RHEL is probably better for corporate culture Linux servers and Windows desktops.
[b]TurboLinux[/b]: This is the strongest player in Asian markets, as far as I'm aware. I don't have much experience with it, but if you're planning on corporate deployment in an Asian market, you might want to give this one a look.
[b]Ubuntu[/b] (or Kubuntu): This is a Debian-based distribution designed specifically for the desktop. It actually mimics the kind of functionality many users have come to expect from Windows XP Home very closely, though it's not designed to mimic the look and feel the way distros like Lycoris, Linspire, and Xandros are. I don't recommend it for a power user, but it's great for home use and for replacing Windows XP where the user would be just as able to get work done with Windows 98. This is Linux for end users. The standard Ubuntu uses the Gnome desktop (fairly Mac-like) by default, and the Kubuntu variant uses the KDE GUI (fairly Windows-like).
-----
So much for brief. I'll stop for now. I might post about more distros later.
by jmgarvin
A good place to check on distros is http://distrowatch.com/
I'd like to add to the list Mandrake (or Mandriva if you please).
Mandrake - Similar to RH distros, but more focused on KDE than Gnome.
Linspire - A "windows" like distro for the masses. I'm not a big fan, but people seem to like it.
by hal 9000
At which they are showing off their latest Linux and I'll fill you in on what they have to show off after that meeting next week I think.
About the only thing I would add to this list is that if you want to stick to the free downloads it is about right but if you are wanting to buy the OS and software several of the above listed firms do offer more advanced Linux's than the basic free to anyone packaged Lycoris and Knoppix come to mind very easily as I've used their upper end products on several occasions with out a problem. They are a lot more useful than the free stuff that is available.
Col ]:)
by apotheon
The short answers:
For purely technical reasons, I'd recommend Debian on servers. On desktops, you should probably go with whatever your sysadmins are comfortable supporting, though Debian can do the job there too, and having the same distro on all systems will simplify network management somewhat. If you're looking for vendor-integrated systems with corporate support, go with RHEL (Red Hat Enterprise Linux) or Novell SuSE for both servers and workstations.
For more details, I recommend you see my response to jdclyde above, titled "I'll try to make this brief."
by apotheon
The software can be free. Associated costs don't just vanish because of that. You still have the migration, management, and maintenance cost concerns you'd have with nonfree software.
One can enjoy significant cost cuts by moving to open source software solutions, but a free program doesn't guarantee your sysadmin won't want a paycheck this week.
by alangeek
by noorman
I agree totally; M$ has gotten away too long with a lot of crap and broken promises, but still the 'TOP' buys M$ products and IT-techs get the shit ...
SORRY, 1 mistype and the post was already gone, read the next 1 please ...
by noorman
I agree totally; M$ has gotten away too long with a lot of crap and broken promises, but still the 'TOP' buys M$ products and IT-techs get the shit ...
They should have been in court, long time ago, for putting out such bad quality products.
Going back to the car trade; they would have had to take all those software packets back for 'crashing' as much as they do and for being easy to infect and get lots of job-hours lost, etc....!
by noorman
That 's easy; just do a restore ...
LOL
by hal 9000
As it appears that I'm coming across as anti M$ which I'm not it's that just some of the postings here are so incorrect or just plain wrong and not because of any deliberate attempt to mislead but through ignorance of the alternatives.
It really depends on what you need to do if you just need a Office application like a WP, Spread Sheet, D Base, Presentations and the like Open Office is a good alternative and can even be downloaded and installed on a Windows OS. It currently supports all the common file types and can work in each without a problem and save to whatever file format you need.
You start to run across problems when you mention specific applications like accounting packages as these are mostly used by small business as their accountant uses a particular package and they want their data to be easily transfered when Tax Time comes around so for things like that you are virtually tied to the M$ desktop. Currently Code-weavers has a product available called Win 4 Lin which allows some Windows Apps to work in a Virtual Environment on a Nix OS but while useful this is not really the answer as you are loosing performance by using these packages and possibly usability as well.
I do not like Windows Emulators for this reason and generally prefer not to use them, but for most other applications there are various applications available to run on a Nix OS and other than some specially written Windows Apps almost everything is usable on a Linux desktop but you have to chose the right one.
I actually use Lycoris Desktop LX for a lot of end user desktops as it has the look and feel of Windows so it isn't as off putting as Debian can be if setup for performance. The only thing with Lycoris is it is a light weight Linux so it lacks a lot of the nice things that come with the other distributions but it is an extremely easy transition from Windows and a very good starting point for those who want to learn Linux. Of course for networks you have to install Samba which doesn't come with this particular basic installation but it was only designed for single user desktops and to be as user friendly as possible while retaining the Linux features. It comes on 1 CD and then things like Red Hat come on 7 CD's and there is anything in between it all depends on what you need the end user to do, but all of these come with all of the common software already available to install if required. For a more advanced desktop I use the next version of Lycoris up or Knoppix which is a good alternative and networks perfectly with any existing Windows LAN. They both again come with a lot of the more common software that you would require like Open Office, a CD/DVD burning package, Web and E-Mail apps, graphic app and a whole range of other things that may or may not be of use depending on what is actually required.
Then there is Mandrake who has now seemed to have worked their way out of their previous problems and for as little as $5.00 US per month you can access their application Data Base with at least 100K of available downloads. Places like Source Forge and the like also have a vast range of applications available for downloading as well but again it all depends on what is required by the end user. I generally have Windows on the desktops of the Office Managers and anyone accessing accounting packages and then always Windows on any specialized propriety software that is mission critical for that particular business, but for places like Sales quite a lot of these Desktops can run one of the above Nix's without a problem and everything that is required can be done easily by the user to get the sale or whatever it is that they do but again it all depends on what other software is being used by the business if they need to share some propriety software around it's all Windows with Linux on the servers.
What you need to do is tailor a complete network for the business and fit the software to the needs required by the users depending upon what they are actually doing. The last small LAN that I installed had one Nix Server 2 LT's running XP and 5 Workstations 2 running XP one running 2000 and the others running Knoppix it was a nice tight integration and seamless to the users. This actually started out as the person asking for 3 computers and owing to their location 3 DSL lines in to connect to the Internet for each workstation. I suggested a small P 2 P network as a better and cheaper alternative as the savings in just one year on 2 DSL connections would have more than paid for the installation several times over actually. Then they where discussing Notebooks just as I left or actually an overseas trip and asking each other how they would manage to get e-mail to each other so I asked did they require some Notebooks which went down a treat. The a week latter I was rung and told that they had another business coming in so they would require a workstation for that which while being a separate business would be actually owned by them. By this time it was up to 4 Workstations and 2 LT's so I suggested a small Server so that one of the workstations would not need to be constantly kept running as I refuse to just add a modem to a multi port router and call that a network. I then suggested it might be a good idea to have the server out of the road in a side room so it wasn't taking up space in one of the offices. At this time I had still yet to actually see the building and was just working off what they thought they needed. Then a few week latter they came up with the idea to allow the field workers access to the network to enter in their time sheets so another workstation was required and the main sales office wanted a second monitor so the salesman could be one side of the desk and the customer the other side and both see the same picture another of my suggestions that one and still I had not seen the actual building but I had the basics already worked out for what they needed and there where at that stage only the minor details to work out like wiring the place with Cat cable and the like. I had already discussed the pro's and con's of a wireless network and I pushed for wiring the place just to keep costs down and minimizing security issues as I didn't expect them to have a real working knowledge of the system and I wasn't going to be there all the time.
This was all worked out before I even saw the building and I had most of the hardware built and ready to install before I even actually saw the building which while not my preferred way to work was the only possible way in this case.
The day that they took over the building I had a telephone guy in there running wires for the phones I was running the network cables and within 2 days they had a completely operational office. I also added UPS's for each workstation owing to the poor mains power in that area and a small ones for each of the LT's. The only real problem was the electrician which they organized so I didn't lose any sleep over the delay on that end. But within two days of them taking possession of the building and yard they had a fully operational network a Hosted Web Page and a complete phone system installed and running there where even 2 wireless phones so people could walk out into the yard to show off equipment and still be available if required on the phone.
The only real problem that came about was the insistence of the owners wife who would be working there for a decent laser printer that was capable of using A3 paper which I spent a few days looking for a suitable one only to discover that they had a photocopier that was net workable and usable as a printer that got to me a bit mainly because I wasn't allowed into the office in their house because "It was a mess" as if I was the slightest bit interested I just wanted to see if they had anything worth taking to the new place and since they where already taking the photocopier they didn't think to even look at its specs.
The wife and separate business are running XP Pro the Server is running Debian in a headless configuration and is accessible from any of the main workstations for maintenance purposes the salesman's and the outside workers stations are running Knoppix and the workstation in the owners office is running 2000 because of some program that he requires and that is the recommended OS for that particular program. All the workstations share the same M'Boards type of RAM, Video Cards the only real difference between these computers is the CPU's and the amount of RAM on one unit. Easy to maintain and keep up to date as required the Server is built on an Tyan Dual Xeon M'Board and the LT's are propriety systems again with P4 and 1 GIG of RAM installed with built in wireless and blue tooth other than maybe a USB hub they need nothing else and in all likely hood could be running Knoppix as well but because these would be traveling world wide I chose to install XP onto them just for ease of maintains if they where overseas and wanted to log onto an international ISP to receive and send e-mail mainly from their hotel rooms. Every workstation has a Canon 560 Printer with individual ink tanks and a USB connection for the digital cameras if it is required to print directly from the cameras, the already mentioned Photocopier come network printer which was shared across the entire network and then 2 Fax/Answering machines complete the installation. The DSL modem/router was supplied by their ISP but to my specs and everything was setup in a short time. The biggest problem and it really was not much of a problem was installing MYOB on the two computers and then importing the business data into the program and the main problem there was the owners wife who wanted access to the other companies financial transactions.
While a small installation it saved then several K just in MS license fees alone and they do not need the MS software to do the required job. They had set aside 25K for the installation and I supplied 3 extra units and a Server which all came in under 17K with much better hardware than they would ever hope to have got from the main off the shelf suppliers.
Col ]:)
by jdclyde
Just tried to explain things better that may not have been covered completely in the original post. What I was talking about, and why I was talking about it.
I am not trying to tell you to get rid of your windows boxes, just to not be afraid of the penguin that is coming your way.
Sorry if I came across as hostile, it was after midnight when I wrote it. Maybe I should have waited till morning? Next time (maybe).
It isn't even a right or wrong because so many things come into the mix to decide on which tool to use.
Cheers.
by noorman
yes, there is; it still uses FAT32 !
Give me NTFS any day (if it has to be Windoze)
by hal 9000
That was what caused both Jobs and Gates to wet themselves and rush out to build as good a mouse trap.
Which incidentally they have not as yet reached. If Xerox had of continued with that project there would be no Microsoft today most likely no Linux and we would all be using a form of Unix with a GUI interface on the front. Well everyone except the few Apple users anyway.
It was that Xerox prototype which gave both Jobs and Gates the idea of the GUI as an alternative to the command line or the menu system that was developed for DOS that was so commonly used at the time. Really what is better scrolling down a menu to get a app running on a system that only uses a very small footprint for the OS of having all these nice pictures of things {which incidentally most people still do not understand without the writing under the Icons} and the ability to place your own picture on the desktop with a huge foot print that consumes more system resources that the old DOS boxes had available?
I personally would be taking performance any day of the week as that is what has been driving hardware development so much over the last 20 odd years faster CPU's RAM and bus speeds but we then see it overlaid with massive OS's that are suffering dramatically from code bloat so that these very powerful computers that really far outstrip the abilities of mainframes of 20 - 30 years ago perform like a 286 on steroids and are generally slow to boot shut down and their clock cycles are clogged with useless OS instructions. So to get around the short comings of the OS the hardware is made even faster so that these things appear to start as quickly as the old 286's did when running DOS and booting into a menu.
MS has singularly failed to really address security issues until recently and even then the basic architecture of the OS is so fundamentally flawed that it will prove impossible to properly secure them from malicious code being executed unknown to the user.
Is XP nice for a end user with virtually no computer experience YES! but this could be as easily addressed with a DOS system being developed to a greater extent than it ever was. If the very basic DOS was rewritten to 64 BIT with a better file system wouldn't that be a better option and with the menus that where available toward the end of DOS even if they where only rewritten to take advantage of the new architectures of the hardware it would be just as easy to open programs as you could read the words of what they where. Even something as simple as the old 3 D Menu had 10 initial listings or menus that where then sub dividable into 10 more individual sub menus to 4 different levels, now even that simple program would hold the ability to launch far more programs than are currently stored on most current computers.
Is the GUI really necessary as you could program a menu to perform the same operations as you would use in a command line prompt without the need to even know even the most basic things when it came to command likes. I used to have a entire sub menu all ten items set aside for system maintenance things like defrag, XCOPY and just routine system maintenance.
What I'm asking here is that code bloated OS really a benefit over what was available to a properly setup DOS system and would something similar to a DOS system without the command line readily visible today be better than what we currently have offered from Microsoft?
Remember that all XP really is, is a glorified menu system with pretty pictures is it really an improvement? If you where to rewrite something like DOS to make it easier to setup LAN and Internet connections so easy that it did it automatically on install and had a much smaller foot print on the system wouldn't that be a better option for the better hardware that we have now?
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
And I can tell you it has not already been tried but it has been done and worked to such an extent that it wasn't worth the problems to stop it from happening. They solved the problem with a complete system rewrite.
When I was working Bank Security I accidentally triggered a bomb off when I went looking at a funny entry. That took down the entire Banks systems AU wide. After restoring the data and only loosing half a days work we where up and running again. After that I took the setup off line onto an isolated frame and started working through the sub routines and triggered off 3 more bombs. Because it was isolated I only lost the data on the backup that I was using but after 2 days of doing this I was told not to bother any more. By that stage the money had reached several million $ and I had traced it through 12 bank accounts which automatically transfered money to a different account when the ballance reached a certain level and so on and so on. I never did get to the bottom of that one but at least 25 Million was lost in the time it was left running and that is a conservative estimate.
I don't know how long it had already been running but the last ballance that I got before triggering the last bomb was well in excess of 80 million $ and that was no where near the end of the trail.
Col ]:)
by jmgarvin
"Well some people like extra options...I mean, isn't that the pitch for ever increasing resourcing hogging millions of lines of new OS code? Take a modern PC, and stick a Win9X on it. ME in particular will utilize all that RAM and work your USB 2.0 devices properly. It is really fast. Really very fast."
I can't disagree with this. However, I still stand by my claim that ME is unstable. You haven't refuted it and you stick by ME still. I prefer 98 over ME and would probably deploy 2k in a corporate environment when I need strict and centralized user control.
"I use Linux too. I think this is the difference between me and your average IT bloke. If you free your mind, you can apply the right tool to the right job."
Here I disagree. Most IT folks are pretty flexible. The problem is that management is not. Most IT shops are a mix of Unix, Linux, Windows, and probably some Macs. However, management has been sold on "Uber Solution X." Now USX will solve all your problems and make all your IT issues go away!
I also fully agree with the right tool for the right job, I just don't see ME as being it. The security features it offers are slim at best (much like 9x), but it is far more unstable than 98.
"I like to work backwards from the task at hand. Let's take the Windows 2K verses XP debate. A high percentage prefer 2K. I like XP better. Why do most techs hate XP Home? Cause it doesn't support old apps as well. Ok. Why then is it "cool" to be supportive of old apps (16 bit) when its 2K or XP Pro we are talking about, but out of the question when its ME we are talking about?"
ME is junk. 98 is far more stable and offers the same basic feature set. ME has a ton of issues that I just can't get past. I'd prefer to let 9x and ME die, but they are good solutions in some instances. However, I would deploy 98 given the choice.
"Another angle. If a cracker owns Linux/Unix, there is more they can do...more devistation. If you own a Windows 95C box, what can you do? These arguments always seem to indicate a demand to have it both ways. The OS that is more "simple" is bad when you suggest a use in one case, yet the fave OS's have all these extra administration features, that techs love, but also make an exploit more devistating."
Wow...just wow...You are lumping a bunch of stuff together here and you are mixing apples and oranges. I can exploit a system the same if I get control of a 9x box or a unix box. Why? I deploy different tools on different systems. It is also WAY easier to get control of a 9x/ME system and once I've done that I can control far more of your network in short order. However, if they are properly hidden, it would make it hard at best to even know how to get to them.
I'd also like to point out that getting root isn't trivial. Getting a shell account my let me get some access, but I'm still limited by the permissions set on that user.
"Would I run an Internet exposed host on a Windows PC period...not likely. But if the task at hand is to give a generic user a way to surf the net, run Office X, and do some e-mail, why give them OpenBSD? You can, but why would you?"
Nope. I would probably stick them with a 2k box connected to a domain because I am a firm believer in domain logins rather than local logins. Of course this is partially dogmatic and partially due to security concerns.
"If the task at hand is to get all-in costs down for a client, then what is the better choice? And if your user base is all in one location, do you need all the remote control features of a Linux or 2K or XP Pro? Maybe you do if the user base is 5,000 users, maybe you don't if it is a lot less than that."
After a recent discussion I'd go with thin clients. Not only are the inexpensive, but they offer you a level of security and usability that you didn't have before. I wasn't sold on thin clients until recently, but I've really grown to like how they work. My only gripe is that storage is hard to get sometimes because management thinks on a small scale....
"Its complicated for sure, doing the right thing in a given situation. But being dogmatic seems to add little value from my experience."
But deploying a broken OS is also of little value. Why are you so dogmatic about ME? Why not 9x?
"Hacking is a lost art. Cracking is still misunderstood. Dogma is rampant. IT budgets and managers only "see" branded products and respond to propaganda any more."
Agreed. I'm a hacker rather than a programmer. I'm a red team guy, not a blue team kinda person. I see things from the "bad guy" perspective and I take advantage of security holes in my own system to see what the flaw could do (worst case).
I'm trying to groom the next generation of IT gurus and I want them to leave my classes with the information to make honest decisions based on THEIR skill. I'm trying to turn them into hackers (in the real sense of the word). I want them to break things apart and analyze them! I want them to study things until they understand exactly how it works...the current crop of IT folks aren't like that...They are marketed to...
"It is simple really. The quality of your network and all the devices on it, speak more to the quality of you people. This is not a popular thing any more. The suits at the door from Microsoft and HP aren't going to tell the low-cost story. Just to pay for their flights and hotels, they have to suck you in to X% of expensive products. They aren't really solving your problems in a lot of cases, you are solving their problems. That's why the big vendors spend so much on advertising in places executives go. So when you or your boss shows up suggesting spending $500,000 on branded "sollutions" they are ready to support."
I agree again. Many vendors just want to sell you the lastest and greatest rather than actually selling you a product that will fit with your budget and infrastructure.
I'm a firm believer in customizing software and developing packages that fit MY needs rather than using some brand spaking new package that may or may not work.
"I've lost almost all respect for both IT and executive management. I think this is fair, as they long ago lost repect for creativity, experience, and thinking outside the (glossy) box. You can probably pick this up from my attitude in these threads."
It seems you and I are on the same sheet of music. Our major disagreement is over ME (which is interesting when you think about the whole thread context).
I think you need to leave where you work and find another place. That place seems to be sucking the life out of you. IT is a good place to be and most of us are in similar situations to you, but we at least have decent work environments.
I'd also have to say the the next generation of IT folks isn't going to come in with the same expectations that you have (had?) when you first started. You have to pass that spark on to them.
by hectoritnt
I always hated when my boss (or my dad) started a sentence like that. The reason I'm using it here is because I agree with you. There are thousands upon thousands of stories on how an MS based server got corrupted, infected or plain crashed. I believe that is truth because we are constantly telling people with a 6 months training that they can be System Administrators of an MS shop. The *nix people (you know those people)are usually very well in their OS and in many cases help on it's development.
I had worked for the last seven years on an MS shop (NT, 2000 and now 2003) that has not been infected and very seldom crashed. We have had a 99.956 uptime for the last 4 years.
It can be done. We are currently bringing one of the *nix flavors to the environment because we really want to make use of the full capability of the hardware working with Oracle.
I have no sympathy for MS or any other company and I will never say we shouldn't expect more from them.
I will say that if you take the time and effort to use the tools correctly, it should not matter what OS you are using.
by jamesrl
is a GUI running on a Unix base. It was a release that took a huge amount of time and effort on Apple's part, to change the underlying architecture, add new functionality, and maintain some level of backwards compatibility.
James
by techrepublic
by oz_media
Yes I've used VNC a few times and though ti was great, I use Remote Administrator now (form AdRem software) as it seems much faster even without adjusting refresh rates.
But there are many alternatives such as RealVNC and AdRem software for such purposes.
by oz_media
I would prefer 98 or 2K over ME. Me is just too much hassel, I have had a few friends buy PC's in teh 90's with ME on them and I had an endless flodd of support calls until either upgrading them to 2K or 98, yes UPgrade.
When 2K was released, it was intended for business use, ME was merely a stripped down version for packaging with low-end, retail PC's.
Nobody liked ME though and kept upgrading to 2K Pro, so THEN they release XP Home (better than ME but still stripped of most networking and admin tools.) SO they have succeeded in building 2 OS's with specific purposes. XP Homem is useless for a company and XP Pro offers more than most home users want, and it's RARELY seen in a retail box, and is mainly available in professional workstations, desktops etc.
If you buy a new PC with XPHome in it, you know it isn't designed for business use, well that and a crappy, carry-in warranty.
SO MS has decided they make an OS for home use and another for business use.
As for ME, well I despise XP for the most part, Pro isn't too bad but I would still take either flavour of XP over ME, even though it is nowhere near as resourceful as ME but actually can do something without issues.
ME was a kaibosh f an OS, it had no marketplace, sales bombed, it lowered the value of retail PC's, it dragged MS's already tarnished name through the mud even more and was probably one of thier biggest marketing mistakes.
Xp was a remedy but should have come out before ME.
People wanted 2K and that bugged MS, they wanted to end the life cycle and move people into something new, but it hasn't worked.
ME was not a product worthy of installation, it wasn't accepted by the industry and you either downed to 98 or upped to 2K.
The big IT swindle gone bad.
by techrepublic
I hated ME just like everyone else. This isn't an "I love ME" thread, its a "anti zealot" thread that I tried to turn into an "anit Dogma" thread.
1) In the case of ME, when it came out, hardware driver developers got confused, and put out some bad drivers -- probably mostly MS's fault. The drivers are better now, usaully because the vendors realized they can just use the 98-style technique.
2) I didn't know how to exercise the problem parts of ME at the time.
3) I recently deployed ME across my personal LAN, first as a joke, 2nd as a research project. I was about a put XP on my personal unit a few days ago, when on a lark I intalled ME, which I am sitting in front of right now.
Basically you get a couple of the nicer UI bits from 2k up, like thumbnail views of folders, outlook style icon bar on open/save dialgues, slick FTP integration, ZIP/Compression built in to Explorer. Basically it is Windows 98 with better USB support, and these UI improvements. Turn of System Restore. Remove boot-time utilities. You have a up-modern 98.
What the "feck" is stability? You mean the ability to run all day and night without rebooting? All my computers do that. Otherwise I rebuild them. I can assure you, no particular OS has the drop on running stable on bad hardware...eventually the hardware will get you.
98 was starting to get diffcult in terms of the security patches from MS...which are starting to break things. For example KB891711. On some 98 machines it makes a mess. No problems here on ME. I rebooted once due to a hung app -- WinAmp, doubtful it was ME's fault.
Anyhow, I'm being polite in the extreme. I HAVE the transcript from the OpenBSD hackathon recently, and know about the APM bug in the kernel loop. And the fact that some of the brightest people in the world missed it for years.
Computers are technical, not emotional. People are emotional. This whole thread is polishing the brass on the deck of the titanic. Very few people have the capicity or interest in getting to the guts of the truth about things. Or the balls to gamble billions like Apple did.
The biggest innovation I've seen in a corporate IT department lately, is someone figuring out how they can work a bunch of overtime and retire 10 years early. You retire from a "job" not from a passion.
by techrepublic
I figured a guy that called himself that would have to be smart.
:o)
by jmgarvin
"I hated ME just like everyone else. This isn't an "I love ME" thread, its a "anti zealot" thread that I tried to turn into an "anit Dogma" thread."
The "dogma" that surrounds ME happens to be pretty truthful. It is an unstable OS that is a Frankenstein of 9x and 2k. 9x is (was) far better at doing what ME only sorta did. Sure it has some cool built ins, but I'd rather have a stable platform.
"1) In the case of ME, when it came out, hardware driver developers got confused, and put out some bad drivers -- probably mostly MS's fault. The drivers are better now, usaully because the vendors realized they can just use the 98-style technique."
I'm sure, but most of the problems STILL haven't been resolved. You need to use the MS released NVidia driver or you will have stability issues out the yang. Get the 71.84 drivers and see what happens. Oh and if you are running VIA chipset you will have issues no matter what.
"2) I didn't know how to exercise the problem parts of ME at the time."
Nobody does ;-)
"3) I recently deployed ME across my personal LAN, first as a joke, 2nd as a research project. I was about a put XP on my personal unit a few days ago, when on a lark I intalled ME, which I am sitting in front of right now."
XP is a bugger too. If I had my druthers 98 and 2k would be built on and XP would die. While XP Pro is decent, I still can't total accept it, esp with the whole service pack 2 fiasco.
"Basically you get a couple of the nicer UI bits from 2k up, like thumbnail views of folders, outlook style icon bar on open/save dialgues, slick FTP integration, ZIP/Compression built in to Explorer. Basically it is Windows 98 with better USB support, and these UI improvements. Turn of System Restore. Remove boot-time utilities. You have a up-modern 98."
That just doesn't do it for me. I really don't want my system to BSOD or reboot on a regular basis because it doesn't like a certain app or driver. Sure, 98 has similar problems, but not to the extent of ME.
"What the "feck" is stability? You mean the ability to run all day and night without rebooting? All my computers do that. Otherwise I rebuild them. I can assure you, no particular OS has the drop on running stable on bad hardware...eventually the hardware will get you."
Yes and no. It also means an OS that doesn't have memory issues (ala ME and XP) can run without crashing and will gracefully recovery from a critical error. ME can't.
"98 was starting to get diffcult in terms of the security patches from MS...which are starting to break things. For example KB891711. On some 98 machines it makes a mess. No problems here on ME. I rebooted once due to a hung app -- WinAmp, doubtful it was ME's fault."
Agreed...However, 98 and ME aren't about security, IHMO....
"Anyhow, I'm being polite in the extreme. I HAVE the transcript from the OpenBSD hackathon recently, and know about the APM bug in the kernel loop. And the fact that some of the brightest people in the world missed it for years.
Computers are technical, not emotional. People are emotional. This whole thread is polishing the brass on the deck of the titanic. Very few people have the capicity or interest in getting to the guts of the truth about things. Or the balls to gamble billions like Apple did.
The biggest innovation I've seen in a corporate IT department lately, is someone figuring out how they can work a bunch of overtime and retire 10 years early. You retire from a "job" not from a passion."
Wow...that was one angry vent. You seem to be very frustrated and angry at your IT department and your job. I'm telling you, get out before it gets worse! There are jobs out there, start looking now!
by apotheon
I left Mandrake/Mandriva out of the list because I was spending too much time typing the post when I needed to get back to other things. I decided that Mandrake was a good one to leave off for the time being because it's not something I'd recommend for either business purposes or home use, generally, and because I don't know it very well in practical terms.
Mandrake is actually more analogous to Fedora than it is to RHEL, in terms of the technical merits of the product. That is to say, it tends to be more cutting-edge, but it also tends to be less stable, than RHEL. As a business distro, I'd recommend RHEL or SuSE first, and as a home distro, I'd recommend Fedora or SuSE first, because Mandrake only does the same things well as those others, and it doesn't seem to do them quite [b]as[/b] well.
Maybe that's just me, though.
by apotheon
MacOS X is proof that it's easier to make Unix pretty than it is to make Windows secure and stable.
Actually, MacOS X isn't just Apple effort. It uses a modified Mach/*BSD kernel and the OpenStep framework. Most of what's in MacOS X was bought or borrowed from somewhere else, and the only work involved was in integrating the various components.
There's already an OpenStep framework for unix unassociated with MacOS X, in fact, called GNUstep. I'm using it on the laptop from which I'm posting it, and on my desktop/workstation system, with Debian GNU/Linux in both cases. It's about the prettiest, most functionally smooth and flexible GUI that I've ever had the pleasure to use. I find the Mac implementation on MacOS X to be obtuse and unwieldy by comparison.
by apotheon
"The world of *nix has about 300 different operating systems all loosely based on a single concept but is constantly being changed by anybody who feels like they want to change it, without any documentation for a normal (Public) user on how to use it."
I'm guessing you've never used more than one unix verion. Unix is unix is unix. There's a consistent interface, a consistent set of tools, and a consistent design. That's sorta the point. Unix is far more consistent than Windows ever was (or will be, likely). Anyone who claims otherwise is lying or incompetent to know the difference.
"When someone has a question about the Microsoft product it is fairly easy to come by."
Nonsense. The Linux community has literally won awards and been declared the "best tech support of the year". Microsoft hasn't done anything of the sort, and you have to [b]pay[/b] for access to anything like competent tech support for expensive Windows products.
"The only reason the *nix products are lagging behind in the noteriety of Viruses and Spyware is that they are not noteworthy and do not get the Hackerz the attention and recognition they crave."
More indications of deception or ignorance. Popularity actually works to FLOSS's favor. The more people using it, the more attention any potential security issues receive from people that want to fix them, and the more people that can fix them there are with a vested interest in doing so. Meanwhile, with closed source software, the number of people writing security patches and the like doesn't change unless the vendor hires more programmers, leading to LESS security as it gets more popular -- a problem Linux doesn't have.
by hal 9000
A Unix kernel which would get them around this very problem and is a good reason to purchase the rights to the Unix package from SCO.
Col ]:)
by jmgarvin
by hal 9000
A lot of their security issues with Windows in one swoop. I really don't care which Nix that is used provided it is solid and fairly secure. But personally I for one can not see M$ going the Open Source way as they have spent far too long guarding their code and treating the basic Windows Code as the most important secret of the world.
When Mr Gates was invited into the Xerox facility and shown the Unix with the GUI interface and the networability that was allowed he then set about writing his own code to achieve the same thing so today we have Windows whatever and no matter just how much they test and patch it the very basic design of the product lends itself to security breaches, where as the Unix platform goes the other way and was addressing Security first and usability by uneducated users as second and a very distant second at that. Microsoft went the exact opposite way wanting everything to be as easy as possible and sacrificing Security in the process. They have now had so long with this mind set that I can not see them changing quickly and I really believe that they will only come out with some form of Nix back end with a Windows like front end when they have no other choice.
If that was to happen their products would be infinitively superior but they would be going against everything that they are currently promoting to the resellers.
Personally I think that the best that we can hope for is to see some form of Unix on the Server Market in this decade produced by Microsoft and only then if the Product Development manager thinks that it is necessary to maintain market share or venture into the high end of the market.
Col ]:)
by jdclyde
Wrong again.
First you throw out bad numbers, then make minor changes when called on them and refuse to answer direct questions.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=89&threadID=174762&messageID=1776249
Tell us, what is the up time RIGHT NOW of your servers? How many have been up non-stop for over six months? None, that is how many.
How many of your PC's have been up non-stop for more than a week?
Yes, it is all my fault and no one else has experienced the same problems or they wouldn't be my fault would they?
If they are common problems, how do you lay the blame at my feet?
Yeah, I'm the juvenile one here.
by jdclyde
I would think that would have to be the single worst job in IT and would take a near SAINT to keep from losing your temper with some of the people.
I think we also have a lot of programmers and managers in here that don't think of servers as part of what end users NEED to get through the day. (until that server goes down, then they remember real quick!)
by jmgarvin
Mandrake/iva is a decent distro, but you are right, it just isn't for the business customers.
I would say its merits lay in the desktop arena as they have made KDE easier and more accessible to the masses.
Sort by Trending