Question Locked

Tape backup media's response to environmental conditions

0 helpful
20 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Being rather new to the realm of managing tape backups, I was surprised recently by hearing of someone declining to install a tape backup system because of the climate that they lived in. Apparently the area was very dry and dusty and they had been advised to stay away from tapes. They're planning on using hard disks as their backup media. It seemed as if the dryness was the primary motivation to stay away from tapes. I've never heard of this before and my initial search couldn't find much on the web about it. Anyone have any experience with this?

So, what do companies that have offices in places like Flagstaff, Las Vegas, or Albuquerque do if they're too small to humidify their servers' area? Disk-to-Disk-to-Bank Vault backups? :)

Thanks,
Nonapeptide

20 replies

by michael kassner

Most tape manufacturers have two separate humidity rating and being too dry does actually come into play.

1. 20 to 80% Relative Humidity: Non-archival Storage
2. 40 to 60% Relative Humidity: Archival Storage

This is the spec given by Quantum for their DLT tapes. I would think that this could easily regulated with a simple humidifier in the storage room.

by nonapeptide

The average humidity of the town that this anecdote comes from is about 35% and it is currently at 10% humidity as I type. Maybe disk to disk isn't so bad after all.

Thanks for the info.

Anyone else have experience with "less than optimal" conditions for tape backups? How's about some disk to disk storage experience? Like, will I ever stop feeling funny about people unhooking an external hard disk and carrying it home as a means of off-site storage (obviously a small-business scenario)? There's got to be a more elegant way... or maybe I need to stop looking for pretty solutions. :-/

by hcream

We use the Iomega REV 1000 changer which can hold 10 harddrive cartridges(35G each). For a disk-to-disk backup in a SMB, it's a good solution.

by hcream

I live in Florida and I always thought the heat & humidity here are bad for tapes.
But then , all office buildings in the US are using similar climate control technology regardless of their location. I don't see there should be any concern about using tapes for backup(indoor).

by michael kassner

I see more of an issue with static electricity from the low humidity than anything else.

I am not an archival expert, but you may want to see what upper management expects from the backup system, they may think it is no problem to retrieve a file from last year. True archival backup as I understand it requires a system like grandfather/father/son, in which a copy of the backup is removed from circulation every so often.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grandfather-Father-Son_Backup

That is why tapes are normally used for this approach, since they are the cheapest media.

by nonapeptide

I chuckled at the mention of "Upper Management". My situation is a bit smaller. I'm working as a consultant for a non-profit organization. There are 9 employees, soon to be 10, and the closest thing to upper management is the Board of Directors. And yes, knowing exactly what they want from the backup system is something that I've been trying to ascertain. I was hoping for a least a week's worth of history to safeguard against accidental deletions. Much longer than that probably wouldn't work out too well. I was looking at the GFS scheme, but a sysadmin friend of mine said to look into using EMC Retrospect which can consolidate backups nicely on fewer cartridges and doesn't use the GFS scheme exactly.

Anyway, disk to disk is looking like what I'll have to learn how to maximize on.

Thanks

by rahouseholder

I worked with the army in Kuwait for a while. We used a disk to disk backup there as well. It wasn't the humidity that was a problem as much as the dust. It got into everything. A tape drive wouldn't survive 3 months.

by nonapeptide

Interesting to know. I suppose I hadn't taken the environmental factor into consideration. The dust wouldn't be the downfall of only the tape backup system, right? I would assume that just about every piece of equipment would be negatively affected.

Any special sysadmin tricks that you learned in the Army that you wouldn't have learned elsewhere? For some reason military IT fascinates me, especially after reading about Hajinets.

Thanks,

by rahouseholder

Actually, I was a civilian contractor. The one thing the did that I liked was they used a program called Harris Stat scanner that would scan all the computers on the network for security vulnerabilities and software updates. It could also be used to push the updates to the PCs when needed. At the time, it supported more than just windows updates so it was a nice compliment to our SUS server.

by michael kassner

I would appreciate learning what you come up with as an answer, if it would not be too much trouble.

by nonapeptide

However, its a bit small for my situation. Even though this place has a small head count, many of the files that they use are graphics and video. I think the total amount of data that I need to prepare for is around 1TB with the possibility of growth in the next 2-4 years.

I like LTO-3s and 4s except for the price and the fact that tapes seem to be a no-no in this situation. A RAID 5 array would be nice except for the need of regular off site storage (hard to lug a RAID 5 rack around). I like the Netgear ReadyNas NV+, but then that whole offsite situation strikes again. I'd need to get two so that one can be offsite at night while the other is backing up at the site... and then swap the two the next day. Not too bad... except for the total price. :-/

If that iomega REV 1000 had 150GB cartridges I'd jump for it.

Thanks again.

by michael kassner

I did not realize the size of your backup requirements. Have you given any thought to using one of the various on line backup services?

by nonapeptide

... and have you seen the budget that non profits typically work with? :)

That was considered but, unless you know something that I don't know (highly probable), I think that price would get me kicked off the project. Also, the site is in a moderately remote location with not-too-fast DSL.

Keep the suggestions comin'! I need all the help I can get.

by hcream

The Buffalo TeraStation series are worth a look. The 2TB NAS system is priced at under a gram. We have one 1TB system in the office(for archiving old projects)running 24x7 with no problem.

Oh, you do need to get a handle(from Home Depot?) to make it portable :^0

by michael kassner

I was not as sensitive to that aspect as I should have been. In my opinion you are in a very unique situation. Small budget (how much?) and a great deal of data to backup. It also appears that you are only going to worry about one day to the next as for file recovery. In that case your choice of backup would be what I would recommend as well.

I then would just make sure the "powers that be" realize what this all means. Most "non-IT" people do not realize that the file they made a month ago will no longer exist in its original form, i.e., having been altered along the way but not saved as a revision.

by nonapeptide

Rather than creating a new thread, I thought I'd just keep it within the context of this one.

Is Windows's built in NTBackup utility something that a small business could rely on? I use it for backing up my USB thumbdrives, but never considered it to be a serious option for an actual line-of-business solution. I've just read a bit more about it that made me reconsider this notion. Even though Retrospect is a relatively inexpensive solution compared to other backup software packages, NTBackup is a little more inexpensive. :)

Has anyone used NTBackup in a SMB role?

::scratches chin thoughtfully::

by michael kassner

If you are just backing up files that are accessed randomly NTbackup maybe sufficient. But if you have an email server or production application then it may not be enough. Third party backup solutions also are more feature-rich and easier to use.

An example would be backing up the mailboxes of an Exchange server. NTbackup does not work very well with that, third party backup applications have what are called agents installed on the specific server i.e., Exchange server allowing correct backup and simple restoration of individual mailboxes.

by nonapeptide

My biggest concern was if the program was robust enough to offer good incremental / differential backups and be able to conform to a rotating backup scheme. From my experience with NTBackup, it seems pretty rudimentary. The solution might start drifting into the realm of make-shifts, stop-gaps, and hacks. :-/

There isn't an Exchange server in this environment, however there will be a database server or two. I'm hoping to get them running on a SQL Server 2005 installation. I'm actually considering SBS 2003 R2 which would kinda give them everything they could ever need and a few things they don't. SQL Server can be scripted to dismount the database (or whatever the terminology is, I'm not a DBA, back up its stuff, and then the backup program would go over the files as well and store them on separate media. Supposedly NTBackup can backup files that are being used with the aid of Volume Shadow Copy.

I'm checking out NTBackup.us to see what else it can do.

Happy Thanksgiving!

by michael kassner

I agree with your assessment.

My main experience has been with Symantec/Veritas BackUp Exec. It is somewhat expensive but has all the bells and whistles. I only mention this as an option and not a product that I am pushing by any means.

This discussion is closed to new replies.