Discussion Locked

The rich are not paying their fair share of taxes. . . . .

0 helpful
146 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

..... or so says Hillary Clinton.

[i]"The rich are not paying their fair share (of taxes) ..... whether it's individual, corporate or whatever (form of) taxation"[/i]
- Hillary Clinton to an audience at the Brookings Institution

Full quote and context:

http://www.politico.com/blogs/bensmith/0510/Clinton_The_rich_are_not_paying_their_fair_share.html

Questions:

Define [i]the rich[/i]?

At what percentage should corporations be taxed?

Do you think the cost of corporate taxes are passed onto the consumer, or absorbed by corporate officers, or applied to (deducted from) corporate profits, or something else?

At what percentage should capital gains be taxed?

What percentage of total taxes collected should be paid by:

- the top 5 percent of wage earners pay?
- the top 10 percent of wage earners pay?
- the top 50 percent of wage earners pay?
- the bottom 50 percent of wage earners pay?

What is the maximum percentage a person's income should be subjected to taxation?

Should income be taxed at all? Why or why not?

Would you favor a consumption tax instead of an income tax?

Would you favor a consumption tax in addition to an income tax?

Should Social Security taxes be increased? If yes, on whom and by how much?

Should Medicare taxes be increased? If yes, on whom and by how much?

Should we pass on to future generations (our children and grandchildren) a system (a government) that taxes them more than it taxed us so it can pay for the promises made to us?

Would you be willing to pass-on your personal debt to your children and grandchildren?

Are you willing to pass-on your government debt to your children and grandchildren?

That's a good question to be the last.

All questions asked with sincerity. Please answer as such. Moreover, feel free to ask your own. In due time, I'll answer all questions myself.

Disclaimers:

- I do not believe that ALL taxes should be abolished. I believe taxes are a vital element to maintaining a free society.

- I believe in the Laffer Curve.

http://www.heritage.org/Research/Reports/2004/06/The-Laffer-Curve-Past-Present-and-Future

However, I'm not an absolutist on suggesting that either increased or decreased tax rates will increase (or reduce) tax revenue. For example, if the tax rate was zero percent, the revenue collected would be zero. If the tax rate was one hundred percent, the revenue collected would be zero. Therefore, the rate at which taxes are accessed and will generate the greatest amount of revenue is, at best, a percentage that's on a sliding scale.

Last question(s): If you agree with my [i]sliding scale[/i] suggestion, what's the best way to zero-in on the optimal rate?

If you don't agree with it, why not?

146 replies

by nexs

In Australia.
I know that if I every decided to move to the US then I'd have many concerns. Mainly in this area.

And health care. We have a good public heath system here, and from what I have gathered, in the US you must have private health insurance if you would like any hope of being cared for in a hospital... Not the best way to care for citizens methinks.
But, at the end of the day, money rules the world and if there's no way to make money from something it'll be in danger of being scrapped for something that can be..

Just one guy's opinion.

by santeewelding

Yours is the love of a policy wonk.

Don't misconstrue: my interest in this is intense -- life-long, but revolutionary.

Yours is evolutionary, and dead-end, as far as I am concerned. Hillary -- Hillary is a zombie. Don't you be one, too.

(Laffer -- I interviewed and grilled him once for a written piece.)

Scrap it all. Take a cue from the Founders. They got away with what they did because what they did was all they dared get away with doing at the time.

There are germs in what they did; germs of the radical; germs which even now might blow you away.

This all means I take you with but light seriousness and bemusement.

by jaqui

since the unequal taxation issue isn't new, nor really news.

everyone, corporation and individual pays a flat rate. No deductions, no refunds.
rate, say 7%.
the higher your income, the more actual cash it works to, but it's a fair exchange, since your tax percentage has dropped by roughly 18%. with no deductions to reduce amount owing, the overhead of administration of taxes is reduced, no refunds, lower overhead, and the overall amount of tax revenue has increased, making deficit budgets a very unlikely thing indeed.

by santeewelding

Except for that word, "deductions". If you are in business for yourself, and I take it that you have had brushes with self-employment, then you well know there to be bottom lines, plural. Wherein, all manner of the mischievous romps.

by jaqui

but getting rid of most of the mischievous romps would actually benefit the small business owner more.

by jackofalltech

no exceptions, no loopholes, no deductions, the govt would have more money than they knew what to do with it (for a while, anyway). But that will never happen because then they wouldn't have any control over us and no way to get pork or bribes.

by jaqui

they would never go for it.
it's just to much of a good idea, and politicos can't implement anything that would work.
it's in their contract. ;)

by jamesrl

Lets make it easy, stop all the monkey business that goes on with tax avoidance strategies which puts capital into intentionally unproductive business, radically reduce the size of the revunue service etc.

This is not to say I think we eliminate consumption taxes. In fact I think property tax should be less, and more of the costs should be consumptive in nature. Gas taxes should go up to cover all the costs of road infrastructure, or tolls. Eliminate gas guzzler taxes which penalize the type of vehicle you buy and tax you based on your actual usage (which gives everyone an incentive to use less gas).

James

by maxwell edison

..... the reason why such common sense and simple methods of revenue collection will never come to pass - at least in the United States - is because the real purpose of the tax code is less about collecting revenue and more about controlling people.

P.S. [i]... never come to pass - at least in the United States ...[/i] At least not until enough people muster up enough gumption to take back control over their own lives. But they can't do it with their hands out.

by nexs

Incur a second tax on the business owner, having the profit taxed, and then his wage (assuming he takes a wage)?

by jaqui

on the business setup.
small businesses like a consultancy [ one person show ] the business income is the owners salary.

the partnership, or "corporate entity" they have to pay themselves a salary, the business income belongs to the business not them, legally.

by santeewelding

Of what we call, "government", exists in large part to guarantee the sanctity of commercial free association and transaction, having no little to do with, "property".

You, like the Founders, are fixed on, "property". It's why, in California, they futz and wring their hands about taxing or not taxing candy bars, not to mention, water, which "they" justify by a CRV on the plastic bottle, so as not to enrage -- what's next: air?. Excuse me. They have done that with gas stations here. Air for your tires has been by legislative fiat been declared to be, "free" -- no charge, neverminding what it costs you the station owner to compress and store it in the first place. On and on...

What, I ask, does it cost for administration of civil law? Civil law guaranteeing the sanctity of transaction? Have you studied and are you steeped in just how much of civil law has to do with the sanctity of transaction?

Screw property. Screw income, which is property.

by delbertpgh

I haven't seen one of those since 1976. Probably the rise of homeless men led to guys walking into the rest room, observing the coin slot, and leaving a big steaming pile in front of the door rather than paying to get in. They suffered for all of us!

by delbertpgh

Knowing that their employees have to pay taxes, in addition to buying shoes and bread and paying rent, corporations have to pay twice, too, through increased wages. Oh, the humanity!

by nexs

So a (one person) small business owner with staff under 10 who takes a wage along with his workers WILL be charged?

I don't mean to say that every small business owner will take a wage, but those that do won't be happy. Nor would they be happy with changing their systems of payment, etc.

by tonythetiger

how much a dollar is taxed, or where it is taxed, than in [u]how many times[/u] the same dollar is taxed!

by delbertpgh

1. America's growth proves tax cuts work. (false)
2. Any tax cut will therefore improve growth. (false)
3. Tax cuts actually create more tax revenue. (false)

I do not dispute that extreme high taxes on the investing and managerial classes will drive down national wealth. It makes sense as an argument, though the evidence of our actually measured economic performance doesn't support it very well. For example, the 1950s were a time of great American economic power and growth, maybe the greatest ever. And it all happened under a 91% top income tax rate. At the time, the rate on capital gains was exactly half the payer's income tax rate, so you can guess how popular it was to receive payment in kind rather than in salary. Also, at the time of high rates, tax shelter scams boomed like they never have since.

The country continued to boom, in fact achieved unprecedented wealth across all social classes, throughout the 1960s. This was despite a 70% federal income tax and a 35% capital gains tax for the top earners. (And that's not even counting LBJ's 10% surtax to pay for the Vietnam war.)

Laffer curve devotees point to Kennedy's measures first, but it's hard to say conclusively what impact tax cuts had. It was something popular to do during a recession. We boomed before the recession, we continued to boom after the recession, and in fact the recession ended before Kennedy's cuts took effect. Did we grow better because of a more rational tax policy? Probably, I think, but the evidence is unclear.

The Reagan tax cuts came at the end of a long period of stagnation and inflation, arguably caused by unbalanced government growth and deficit spending in the Johnson/Nixon years. Paul Voelker, chief of the Federal Reserve under Carter and Reagan, drove inflation out of the economy by raising interest rates to 16% and letting them fall gradually over eight years. (In 1980 I got a 30 year mortgage at 12%, and in 1981 I was able to sell the house at a substantial profit, simply because I let the buyers assume my mortgage. A new mortgage would have cost at least 16%.) The resulting economic slowdown drove millions of people out of work, but as inflation fell, interest rates fell with it, and people went back to work. Reagan showed up at this precise moment with his tax cut program. Did tax cuts cause prosperity, or was it all the other stuff? Don't forget that Reagan also ordered a huge increase in government spending, financed on borrowed money. (Look up "stimulus spending" in your political dictionary. It makes you popular!)

The Reagan years saw extraordinary growth, but the new national income was concentrated at the top. Everybody (i.e., workers) was producing more wealth, but the investors and managers were keeping it for themselves. It's not surprising that as median income stagnated and top earner income boomed, taxes would increasingly be harvested from those top earners. It's where all the new money was going. Between 1982 and 1998 Fortune 500 CEO pay increased ten fold. Were they managing their companies ten times better? You could argue that, given the opportunity to keep much more of what they got, they made sure nobody else got it. Is that really a case of greed producing a social good?

It still made sense to me to cut taxes, mostly because 70% still seemed weirdly high. Also, I worked with a guy using computer services to match wealthy people up with tax shelters; I saw that you wouldn't collect money from people who'd do anything to beat the tax man. A lot of money was going into bad investments, whose sole merit was they produced fictitious tax losses. That was bad for the economy. (Guess what Ronald Reagan's 1979 tax bill was? Zero. He invested as a limited partner in a herd of beef. The partnership borrowed a huge sum of money to feed the herd, which was instantly expensed, so that the value of the partnership dropped deep in the red. Reagan's tax loss, calculated at year end, was far larger than the money he invested. Of course, he got it all back in the next year, when the fattened herd was sold for a taxable gain, but taxes deferred is money you can use, and that means money in your pocket. News of his tax game was a mild embarassment during the election, but it didn't make Jimmy Carter any more popular.)

Reagan's tax cuts definitely did not pay for themselves during the Reagan presidency. Other accountants have proved this conclusively. Maybe the distortions in income distribution helped make them pay during the Clinton presidency. When the rich guys of 1999 had all the money in the country and were driving up the price of stock that they bought from each other, it resulted in huge capital gains taxes, even though the tax rate was fairly low. (Global Crossing! PetsDotCom! Nasdaq 4500! Woo hoo!) It looked like for the first time in 30 years the government would actually run a tax surplus. Bill Clinton talked about paying the national debt down to zero. Rich guys and the Wall Street Journal started finding fault with a tax cut that actually paid for itself; they were complaining that the proportion of national income going into taxes was never so high, using statistics that seemed to argue the case, if you didn't look closely. It was at this moment of grievous over-taxation, where billionaires could be imagined to be lining the sidewalks of Wall Street with begging bowls, just asking for the simple kindness to let them keep a little more (lots more, really) of what a prosperous nation made for them, that George W. Bush showed up, with his mix of cleverness, ineptitude, and dogma. He regarded the forecasts of multiple trillions of dollars of surplus (specious forecasts, it turned out) as an opportunity to cut taxes, to the benefit of people like him and of people who would donate cash to Republicans. With the help of a stock market disaster and a terrorist nightmare attack, he made that work. We staggered through the 2000's in a sick, laggard recovery, despite the tax cuts; apparently the wealthy were stimulated not to produce a booming economy, but a booming credit hoax instead, which left us in the most dangerous financial crisis since 1930.

The record isn't clear. If you were as creative with your statistics as Arthur Laffer, you could probably support an argument that every tax cut was PRECEDED by a period of superior growth and prosperity. (That's ridiculous, but you could argue it from selected statistics.) One result of tax cuts seems to be that income distribution is more skewed toward the rich than it was since 1929, or maybe even 1899. A lot has been going on in our society besides tax cuts that influenced prosperity and income, so nothing is as clear as ideologues, left and right, would like it to be.

Another Laffer falsehood, implied, is that maximizing tax income is the proper objective of government, just as maximizing profit is the goal of business. It's not. Taxing the most possible from an economy is not an optimizing strategy. You need to figure out what your country needs in the way of government services, and then provide them, and pay for them, whether that's best for the economy or not. An economy is only one aspect of society.

However, getting to Max's original questions, I have a few rules of thumb. I think everybody should pay federal income taxes, from the burger flipper to the billionaire. Sharing in the tax burden encourages one to feel responsible for the country. Too many are getting away with paying nothing, and the electorate is getting to think that voting themselves checks from somebody else's money is proper doctrine. I think that when the total of all federal and state taxes exceeds 50% of income, however high that income might be, it has become unjust. One should be able to keep at least half of what one makes. Probably that means a federal income tax rate not to exceed 40%. I think that tax cuts have a far less stimulative effect than straightforward, predictable, uncomplicated tax policy; loopholes and special breaks are a means of gaming the system, and induce unethical behavior. I don't think long-term capital gains should be taxed at a rate lower than income; that looks to me like government telling people how they should structure their investments. Government directed private investments are rarely sound, and do not represent the optimum use of money.

Of course, the last five years have shown us that privately directed capital can make a huge mess of things, too. Gotta stay careful, stay watchful of those rascals with their hands on all of society's wealth. It's one of the other things you need a government for!

(Edited to fix typos & improve continuity)

by tonythetiger

The valve started leaking in my toilet. Water was spraying out of the top of the valve while the tank was filling, and some of it escaped the tank.

I could have replaced the valve for about $30, but I came up with a less expensive solution. I trimmed a plastic water bottle to fit over the valve without interfering with the moving parts.

I saved $30.

The government would always replace the valve.

by delbertpgh

Probably you'll have to replace your toilet valve some day. Until then, you have the use of your $30.

Consider, though: If, instead of you being personally responsible for your house, you had a landlord, you'd expect him to replace the valve. If you had hired a plumber, and he handed you a bill for $60 and said, "Congratulations, it would have been $90 but I ingeniously used a plastic bottle instead of replacing the broken part," then you would probably been disappointed in him. And if your government, for who knows what reason, had come in and executed a slapdash fix that will some day fail, instead of replacing the whole part, I'd be reading about your complaints about "typical government shortsightedness" right here.

By the way, have toilets gotten less reliable? I keep replacing parts every couple years, and I don't ever remember doing that in the 60s. The damn things just plain worked.

by tonythetiger

consumer. Inflation is the inevitable result. And inflation is the largest cause of the difference between the haves and have-nots.

by netman1958

As Al Bundy once said to Bud:
"Get yourself an Eljer. She'll never let you down. You can always tell an Eljer by it's flush; it goes BAWOOSH!"

by nicknielsen

[i]Define the rich?[/i]
The flip answer is "anybody who makes more than I do." On second thought, I wouldn't be surprised to find that this is the answer many people consider to be correct. A more thoughtful answer would be "anyone above the 75th percentile of annual income."

[i]At what percentage should corporations be taxed?[/i]
My personal feeling is the corporate tax rate should be the same as the personal tax rate. But again, a flip answer comes to mind: Given the legal fiction and Supreme Court decisions that corporations are people, if corporations wish to act politically as if they are people, they should be treated as if they are people for tax purposes and required to consider earnings the same as an individual considers wages, with no access to the usual corporate deductions such as depreciation, expenses, etc., when determining those earnings.

[i]Do you think the cost of corporate taxes are passed onto the consumer, or absorbed by corporate officers, or applied to (deducted from) corporate profits, or something else?[/i]
If those costs are not included as part of the price of goods and services, whoever is running the company has a damnfool for an accountant.

[i]At what percentage should capital gains be taxed?[/i]
Income from any source should be taxed at the same rate.

[i]What percentage of total taxes collected should be paid by:

- the top 5 percent of wage earners pay?
- the top 10 percent of wage earners pay?
- the top 50 percent of wage earners pay?
- the bottom 50 percent of wage earners pay?[/i]
Again, income from any source should be taxed at the same rate.

[i]What is the maximum percentage a person's income should be subjected to taxation? [/i]
Certain deductions should be considered as pre-tax income: FICA, health insurance, and retirement contributions come to mind. After those deductions, 100%. (I'm reading this question as "How much of a person's income should be subjected to taxation.") If you want to know what I think the maximum tax rate should be, you should have worded it that way.

[i]Should income be taxed at all? Why or why not?[/i]
If not income, what? A "per head" assessment against each state? VAT? Given that Americans want "smaller government," yet they don't want programs cut, there's not really any other remotely equitable means of raising the money to keep government going. Yes, at a flat rate of 25% (to start), regardless of source.

[i]Would you favor a consumption tax instead of an income tax?[/i]
At state level, yes. At the federal level? Haven't really looked into it.

[i]Would you favor a consumption tax in addition to an income tax?[/i]
Not at the federal level.

[i]Should Social Security taxes be increased? If yes, on whom and by how much?[/i]
I don't think so, but we do need to do something. Either freeze benefit rates for the foreseeable future or institute means testing, or both. The problem is we have too many people becoming eligible and not enough people supporting them; no matter how high you raise the taxes, it won't fix that problem. But, so far, Congress hasn't got the political 'nads to do anything other than dither.

[i]Should Medicare taxes be increased? If yes, on whom and by how much?[/i]
Should be able to cover this with a flat tax. For most of us, these are included in our FICA deductions, so an increase in one is seen as an increase in the other.

[i]Should we pass on to future generations (our children and grandchildren) a system (a government) that taxes them more than it taxed us so it can pay for the promises made to us? [/i]
No. This is our problem not our children's problem. Although they are nice, I didn't ask for those promises.

[i]Would you be willing to pass-on your personal debt to your children and grandchildren?[/i]
Damn, that's tempting! I'd love to, but I won't do it.

[i]Are you willing to pass-on your government debt to your children and grandchildren?[/i]
No, I don't think it should happen, but given the [lack of] action in Congress to fix these problems, I probably won't have a choice.

[i]Last question(s): If you agree with my sliding scale suggestion, what's the best way to zero-in on the optimal rate? [/i]
Start at a flat rate of 25%. Watch for a couple of years, then raise it to 27%, and watch revenues. Adjust as necessary.

edit: Unicode to ANSI

by tonythetiger

[i]Consider, though: If, instead of you being personally responsible for your house, you had a landlord, you'd expect him to replace the valve.[/i]

Because if the house gets too expensive to fix, the rent will be raised. It would be in my best interest to keep costs down.

[i]If you had hired a plumber, and he handed you a bill for $60 and said, "Congratulations, it would have been $90 but I ingeniously used a plastic bottle instead of replacing the broken part," then you would probably been disappointed in him. And if your government, for who knows what reason, had come in and executed a slapdash fix that will some day fail, instead of replacing the whole part, I'd be reading about your complaints about "typical government shortsightedness" right here.[/i]

If the government had done it, it would have required 8 workers and a supervisor, and would have cost $600 (plus parts, which under contract would have been about $450) :)

by mjd420nova

I think the government should eliminate INCOME taxes and instead institute a national SALES tax. That way, regardless of how much you make, when you spend it, you will pay your share. Even the illegal immigrants will have to pay their share. It might not make us very attractive to the tourists but we need to have some equity in how much the rich pay in comparison to the lower classes.

by nicknielsen

But, then again, it might not. It would depend on the tax base, any exemptions or exclusions, and the economy and how people are spending. If the tax base was broad enough (including services and pharmaceuticals, and excluding only groceries), we might be able to get by on only 8-10%.

South Carolina is currently learning that sales tax is a particularly unreliable form of funding for state activities. Their two largest sources of revenue are income and sales taxes.

SC sales tax receipts in $1000 (from audit reports at http://cg.sc.gov/publications/cafrarchives.htm)
2005 - 2,341,244
2006 - 2,533,540
2007 - 2,633,562
2008 - 2,458,786
2009 - 2,248,962

Income tax
2005 - 2,754,497
2006 - 3,115,907
2007 - 3,323,665
2008 - 3,344,965
2009 - 2,811,634

You will notice that income tax receipts rise from 2005 through 2008 and only fall in 2009, well into the recession. On the other hand, sales tax revenues start to fall a year earlier, and are actually less in 2009 than in 2005.

Caveats:
- SC rather foolishly caps sales tax at $300 for purchases of cars, motorcycles, airplanes, and boats.
- SC phased out the sales tax on grocery/food items starting in 2007.

So, they have an artificially narrow tax base and a state tax rate of 5% with a maximum of 2% more for city/county sales tax. And keep in mind that most South Carolinians are almost rabidly anti-tax and consider just about anything paid to government for any reason a "tax".

My major complaint with a sales tax is that it is not included in the price posted on the shelf. After each tour in Europe, I was always quite irritated to arrive back in the US, and go shopping for items totaling $100 shelf price and have to fork over $107 at the register. Surprise!

edit: getting the numbers right

2nd edit: Sales tax figures are in thousands of dollars

by charliespencer

Nick didn't mention that our legislature pushed through major property tax reforms a couple of years back, in an effort to appeal to that rabidly anti-tax base. The state legislature mandated property taxes formerly set by the school districts, but left the schools with no replacement forms of funding.

Technically it's against our constitution for the state legislature to pass laws that don't apply state-wide; that is, laws that apply only to a single municipality. When such an action is proposed, all legislators who don't represent the affected municipality refrain from voting. The only ones who vote on the bill are the handful of reps and senators from the represented district. "You refrain from voting on bills that increase my power at home, I'll refrain from voting on yours." If the sumbiches are so concerned with how the local county, city, or school is run, they should have run for those offices instead.

by av .

I'm more concerned about the 40+% of our population that pays nothing or receives government handouts. Those people need to pay something.

Maybe a flat tax across the board would be the fairest solution. Rich or poor, 5% of your income goes to the federal government. No more tax loopholes or tax deductions.

I think there should be a state income tax of 5% or less, across the board. No consumption taxes.

We need to focus on reducing the size of government instead of looking for more tax revenue to support the blob.

AV

by av .

Government (federal and state) should continue to maintain the major infrastructure and act as a watchdog over business, but they have to be more agile and do it for less. There is too much waste.

No-bid contracts and pork barrel spending is illegitimate. Having no term limits for Congress is illegitimate. Lavish perks, pensions and other enrichments for government officials are also illegitimate.

AV

by delbertpgh

I agree that everybody, including the poor, ought to pay some income tax. But it isn't like the poor pay no taxes at all. Between social security and sales, the working poor send at least 10% of their income off to government.

The working well-off, like me, pay about the same. And, as a home owner, I lose another 6% to property taxes, to keep school, city, and county going.

by tonythetiger

but the dirty little shell game is that they pay far more of other peoples' taxes that get passed down to them!

And we have these "enlightened progressives" who claim that increasing taxes on "the rich" will fix it... it doesn't. It makes it worse, because it all gets passed down until it gets to someone who can't pass it down.

The slumlord doesn't really care if the city raises his property taxes... he'll just up the rent!

by dwdino

They are paying too much. The top earners carry the biggest load.

If Hillary really wanted to carry her comments to completion, she would be left with only two options - decrease the tax burdeon the "rich" or increase the tax burden on the "lesser".

BTW, let her and her husband lead the way...

by tonythetiger

[i]BTW, let her and her husband lead the way... [/i]

You can't do that... They are "The enlightened ones". They're smarter than everybody else, and know best how to spend their money... AND yours... :)

by nicknielsen

They have this thing called "rent control," instituted in an effort to protect the "little people."

From that, you can no doubt deduce how slums come to be in the first place.

by nicknielsen

Given a day or two and the inclination, I could probably make a case that everything government does now is infrastructure: defense, commerce, transport, health, education, etc., in support of the objective that we all have an equal chance to succeed.

That's not what I think, but I could make the case.

by nicknielsen

who would argue that the only way to enforce standards is to pay for them.

Mind you, I'm not one of them...

by charliespencer

those questions I found interesting or had an opinion on. No responses will be forthcoming, but since you asked:

I assume all businesses pass the taxes on to their customers, just as they do every other operating cost.

Capital gains and other forms of investment shouldn't be taxed. Current tax policies don't do enough to encourage savings or investment, and too much to discourage it.

I favor a consumption tax. I would exempt groceries (not restaurant food), medicine, water, electricity, housing, and articles of clothing under $100 (with that figure indexed to the inflation rate).

I would not favor completely eliminating the income tax. Diversification applies to income as well as investment.

I don't have children, so many of these questions don't affect me directly. I support privatizing the majority of a contributor's Social Security taxes, or the option to apply a portion of one's SS payment directly to an individual's IRA / 401K / other retirement plan. I'll accept raising SS rates only when Congress stops writing IOUs and using the money for unrelated purposes.

I'm big on dedicated user fees. Funds for goods and services should be payed by those who use those services. Those services generally perceived to benefit all should be payed for by taxes paid by all - defense, environmental protection, foreign policy, food safety, etc. Services such as national parks, road construction, industry regulation should be paid by those benefiting from them.

All subsidies should be eliminated. Period. If you can't make it, get into some other line of work.

by tonythetiger

except I WOULD tax everything except "business to business for business" transactions (this would include all training and education intended to make an individual more desirable in the job market or to make him more valuable to his current employer)...

I like the idea of not taxing the first (poverty level) amount of spending. It gives those at that level the liberty of deciding for themselves what they need.

Not taxing food would give people who buy lobster and caviar a break they don't need (ironically, both of these items can currently be purchased with food stamps!).

The more (self proclaimed) "enlightened" among us will argue, but the results of taking more responsibility in the tax department will be more political power during the period between elections, especially for those in the middle... They can choose not to fund the government by only purchasing what they absolutely need.

by santeewelding

That I may have asked here long ago:

You are standing on broken glass and shell casings in the Oval Office, gazing out the window casing over the dwindling fires, when your First, stepping forward with a smart salute, says:

"Your orders, Sir!"

What are they?

___________

"casing", since that's where the broken glass came from, being mindful of historical accuracy.

by charliespencer

I assumed you meant I was already in office, the shells were intended for me, and I was being asked how to respond.

by santeewelding

I put (obviously) to Max.

He has, it would seem, the verve and penmanship to contemplate any of the bureaucratic but this. As I told him at the outset, his is the love of a policy wonk.

I want to know if he has the stomach. The way I'm reading what passes in the world, we may all need stomach.

by maxwell edison

[i]Define the rich?[/i]

This simply cannot be defined; it means different things to different people; at best, it's relative. And be advised, any time someone criticizes - or demonizes - [i]the rich[/i], be assured, it's only playing to the class envy emotion. As a retort, however, I might ask these questions as it relates to [i]the rich[/i]: have [i]the poor[/i] ever provided jobs and income for others? Is our goal to make [i]the rich[/i] less rich? Is our goal to punish [i]the rich[/i]?

[i]At what percentage should corporations be taxed?[/i]

Zero percent. Corporations NEVER pay taxes. That cost is ALWAYS passed onto the consumer.

[i]Do you think the cost of corporate taxes are passed onto the consumer, or absorbed by corporate officers, or applied to (deducted from) corporate profits, or something else?[/i]

See above.

[i]At what percentage should capital gains be taxed?[/i]

Zero percent. Savings and investment should be encouraged. If something is taxed, we get less of it. Taxing savings and investment discourages it.

[i]What percentage of total taxes collected should be paid by:

- the top 5 percent of wage earners pay?
- the top 10 percent of wage earners pay?
- the top 50 percent of wage earners pay?
- the bottom 50 percent of wage earners pay?[/i]

This was a loaded question for those who actually believe [i]the rich do not pay their fair share[/i] of taxes. As it is now.....

..... the top 5 percent of wage earners pay 61 percent of tax revenue collected. Should they pay more?

..... the top 10 percent of wage earners pay 71 percent of tax revenue collected. Should they pay more?

..... the top 50 percent of wage earners pay 97 percent of tax revenue collected. Should they pay more?

..... the bottom 50 percent of wage earners pay only 3 percent of tax revenue collected. Should they pay less?

..... the bottom 47 percent of wage earners pay zero percent of tax revenue collected. How can they pay any less?

..... and the bottom ?? percent of wage earners, not only pay zero taxes, but they actually receive income at the expense of others. Should they receive more?

[i]What is the maximum percentage a person's income should be subjected to taxation?[/i]

If - and that's a conditional if (see below) - a person's income is taxed at all, the rate should be no more than 30 percent. I might add, no deductions, no B.S.

[i]Should income be taxed at all? Why or why not?[/i]

No. Tax consumption, not income.

[i]Would you favor a consumption tax instead of an income tax?[/i]

Yes. However, food (but not restaurants), medical, and educational should be exempt from taxation. I believe the following, although not perfect, is a good starting point:

http://www.fairtax.org

[i]Would you favor a consumption tax in addition to an income tax?[/i]

No. Absolutely not. Moreover, as a condition of a consumption tax, I would favor repealing the 16th amendment.

[i]Should Social Security taxes be increased? If yes, on whom and by how much?[/i]

No. Those on whom the increase would most likely impact are those who are in the early years of paying them. It would be the epitome of unfairness.

[i]Should Medicare taxes be increased? If yes, on whom and by how much?[/i]

No. Those on whom the increase would most likely impact are those who are in the early years of paying them. It would be the epitome of unfairness.

[i]Should we pass on to future generations (our children and grandchildren) a system (a government) that taxes them more than it taxed us so it can pay for the promises made to us?[/i]

No. The right and moral thing to do is figure out a way this WON't happen.

[i]Would you be willing to pass-on your personal debt to your children and grandchildren?[/i]

No, of course not.

[i]Are you willing to pass-on your government debt to your children and grandchildren?[/i]

No. If we wouldn't pass on personal debt, how can we possibly justify passing on government debt?

by santeewelding

Like many here, you futz about the ins and outs of consumption. Screw that.

You have said nothing -- nor has anyone else -- about [i]transaction[/i] and how it can/should/might be ordered.

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"You have said nothing -- nor has anyone else -- about transaction and how it can/should/might be ordered.[/i]

Nor have you.

P.S. Would you dare answer my questions, one by one, as I did?

by tonythetiger

Social Security and Medicare would be able to be funded from the sales tax collected. A separate tax would be unnecessary, and within a generation or so, Social Security and Medicare will probably be unnecessary as well.

[i]Should we pass on to future generations (our children and grandchildren) a system (a government) that taxes them more than it taxed us so it can pay for the promises made to us?
[/i]

I believe that the number mentioned by the fairtax people (23%) is higher than what is needed to fund programs at current levels. I believe that we would see positive results from this very quickly. So quickly that many will demand the government lower the percentage within three years... but I would be in favor of leaving it where it is until the national debt is paid off. If we instituted it beginning next year, I'd bet that the debt wouldn't take 20 years to pay off.

I believe the fairtax would make American made products more competitive in both domestic and foreign markets. It would be a DISincentive to companies leaving, and an incentive for foreign companies to move here and during a recession is the perfect time to implement it. We must move fast though... do it first... because when other countries start seeing their money come here, they'll either move to stop it, or to emulate it. Not that that would be a bad thing... spreading "America" all over the planet. You see, I have no objection to a single world government... as long as it's like this one is SUPPOSED to be :)

by rfink

The way I understand the fairtax.org tax is that anything can only be taxed once. Using their 23% rate for example purposes. If I buy a "newly built house" for 200,000 the tax would be $46000. I would buy a used house and save the $46000. Same for automobiles, I would save $4600 on a $20,000 car.

I see the fair tax ruining home builders and the auto companies. If I'm missing something, please let me know.

The other issue I have with the fair tax is most of my life I paid income taxes on my savings, investments, etc and now I have to pay a 23% tax to enjoy the fruits of my labor. I getting taxed all over again.

by santeewelding

Yes, I have, spoken about sanctity. I don't expect that, you and others, fixed on relative value -- the so-called lesser and greater of us -- would have noticed.

by tonythetiger

The government managed to force businesses to upgrade their facilities for handicap access without the government paying for it.

by tonythetiger

[i]The way I'm reading what passes in the world, we may all need stomach. [/i]

you're wrong, but I fear that you're not.

by tonythetiger

[i]I assumed you meant I was already in office, the shells were intended for me,[/i]

They were meant for your predecessor. And maybe they found him.

by drowningnotwaving

[i]Lavish perks, pensions and other enrichments for government officials are also illegitimate[/i]

Okay, I agree on the level where someone is ripping off their allowances.

But in general, is it illegitimate to offer senior public servants the same perks that they may get in the private sector, if nothing else but to ensure that some level of seriously good talent is attracted and held?

The Public Sector can't do more with less, if the "less" actually means the least possible talent at the top of their tree. Can they?

How do you see this actually working?

by santeewelding

Running the whole affair like the military.

I met and worked with seriously good people at the time. Dorks, too, but their effect was limited by martial law -- flat-out eliminated, in serious cases.

by drowningnotwaving

but let's face it, the Military leadership have never, throughout history, shrunk away from the perks of their job! :)

I am sure there are exceptions - in many cases famous heros.

But in the most part, Generals don't fly cattle class and even soldiers get the pension! Both of which I feel is perfectly acceptible!

Except those flat-out eliminated of course!

by av .

In New Jersey, public servants have pensions. Some have several. Private sector has 401ks, no pensions. Their salaries are far above what one could make in the private sector. Their health care is paid for through taxpayer dollars. The rest of us pay most of our own.

Their unused sick time gets carried over and they get paid for it when they leave. Private sector can't carry sick time over year to year and they lose what they don't use. They even have their parking paid for. I have to pay my own.

The list of perks goes on and on for public "servants". If I had known better years ago, I would have chosen the public sector for employment. They have no problem at all attracting top talent.

I think if they scale back all of the perks public servants get, we might be able to keep the state from going bankrupt. Put public sector jobs in line with private ones. They will still be able to compete for top talent.

Federal government also has many, many perks.

AV

by maxwell edison

True [i]public servants[/i] are far and few between. Those who work for the government, however, either federal, state, or local, are as numerous as ants at a picnic. But they no more [i]serve the public[/i] than the man in the moon. Considering their higher wages, better benefits, and job security, they really [i]serve[/i] only themselves; if anything, the public [i]serves[/i] them.

I question the honesty of anyone who works for the government and claims to do so in order to [i]serve the public[/i]. (I make exceptions, however, for most of the military; some, but not all, of those who enter into public teaching; and some, but not all, of those who enter into law enforcement.) I know, and have known, a LOT of government employees, and without exception, they've all done it for the pay, the benefits, and the job security. In short, they see it as a better deal than they might otherwise find in the private sector.

Needless to say, I despise the term [i]public servants[/i]. Moreover, most of the true [i]public servants[/i] I've seen do it from the private sector, and they provide [i]their service[/i] for free.

Let the [i]public servant's[/i] feathers be ruffled. I don't care.

P.S. And Labor Unions for public employees should be illegal. It's the epitome of a conflict of interest.

by drowningnotwaving

How does a government entity operate BETTER if it reduces its salaries and "perks", as you call them?

What sort of talent would you attract?

- GIVEN you both already claim that someone who works in a Public entity cannot possibly be doing it from the goodness of their heart.

[b][i]Put public sector jobs in line with private ones. They will still be able to compete for top talent[/b][/i].

"Private Ones" can offer anything they want. That you don't get such conditions AV, is either a reflection of you, your selected job or your employer, no-one else.

I get a great salary, a car-park, a car, and free lunch and breakfast. I work in the Private sector.

Max, your attack on the freedoms of other people are nothing short of breathless.

Why should any group of people, members of your society, have their capability and legal right to association diminished because YOU think the government is too big???

Freedom or restriction? You were pretty quick out of the block on that one.

by drowningnotwaving

I agree, and I also take your later point that in general the public sector isn't necessarily responsible for all the 'DOING'.

Of course it is irrelevant to you, but in our part of the world, public / private partnerships in major infrastructure have been spectacularly unsuccessful. To the point that in some cases it would have been cheaper to use the gold old state roads department to build them in the first place.

In principle I agree that there are many case for the public sector not taking on a lot of the tasks that it does. But I feel the zeal with which some people think that the public sector should do little or no work is unjustified.

Having said that, it is very difficult to place boundaries around the specifics as there are always significant 'gotchas' whenever anyone raises examples.

I think your last point raises great discussion and a lot of inherent difficulties associated with "how big should government be?"

Over here, there are industries created by people who look for the loopholes in government monitoring, if that is the right word, of people's freedom being threatened. In earlier times these industries included anything from insurance sales people, real estate agents etc. Now, the examples are more isolated as the more "macro" industries are covered by licensing and legislation.

But my point is that there is a breed of person that is sometimes half-entrpreneur / half-rip-off-artiste, who will always look to find gaps in the legislation and rip off peple accordingly.

Caveat Emptor of course works to a degree, but in the same way we use police to protect banks, private citizens have some expectation of protection from blatant rip-off schemes.

Or do they?

And if they don't, why should a bank?

edit small keyboard, phat fingers ...

by santeewelding

I would cheer if the chief of our Internal Revenue Service elected to wear a brace of pearl-handled 45s, and a silk scarf, if that's what it took.

by av .

"Considering their higher wages, better benefits, and job security, they really serve only themselves; if anything, the public serves them."

Truer words were never spoken. There are exceptions as you stated. Police, fire and military personnel deserve the extra benefits. Teachers should too, but they have to get rid of their unions and tenure. Public education isn't doing the job because teachers are guaranteed a job once they get tenure. That has to move to merit-based pay based on performance.

Their feathers should be ruffled. Its about time. Lucky NJ has a new Republican governor, Chris Christie, that is doing just that. The sense of entitlement from public sector employees is absolutely nauseating. Finally, someone is willing to make the hard choices. I think I'm in love.

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/17/nyregion/17budget.html

AV

by maxwell edison

New Jersey - like so many other states - is facing some very difficult and challenging financial times, and they can't be solved in just a couple of years. It will take some long-term planning and dedication.

I hope you have Governor Christie for at least two terms (I don't know if your state has term limits). I also hope that the New Jersey State Legislature is (or will be) of like-mind as your governor, one that will work with him to implement meaningful financial reform, and will not yield to the partisan demagogues who will undoubtedly try block his efforts with the scare-tactics and character assassinations that have become the norm. Of course, that's up to you - the voters of New Jersey - to fill your State House and Senate with like-minded people.

I actually believe the federal government should yield to the states to solve those problems, not the other way around. New Jersey's circumstances, problems, and solutions are different than California's, different than Colorado's, different than Arizona's, different than New York's, etc., and as such, each state should be able to address them individually. I hope that you - and Governor Christie - succeed and show other states how they might solve their own financial problems.

I will say this, however. Governor Christie is only 47 years old. If he can make some real progress in New Jersey after two full terms in office - and especially if some other states follow his lead - he'll have an absolutely great platform to run for national office - i.e. the presidency. The best time would be 2020, maybe 2016; but you don't want to lose him in 2012. At least I wouldn't want to lose him if he were the governor of my state, especially considering the fact that presidential politics is different than state politics.

Maybe he will be the next Reagan-type presidential candidate; but, like Reagan, let's hope he has two successful terms as governor first - and to build upon.

by maxwell edison

[i]How does a government entity operate BETTER if it reduces its salaries and "perks", as you call them?[/i]

That government which governs least, governs best. I agree with Mr. Jefferson in that regard. You and I apparently have a [i]Conflict of Visions[/i] (credit to Thomas Sowell) regarding the role of government in individual lives. You apparently want more, while I want less.

[i]What sort of talent would you attract?[/i]

True [i]public servants[/i], I suppose. Those who wish to truly GIVE their time and expertise to the people, not take from them. Moreover, it's the private sector that drives the greatness of America, not the public sector. (It's that [i]Conflict of Visions[/i] thing again.)

[i]GIVEN you both already claim that someone who works in a Public entity cannot possibly be doing it from the goodness of their heart.[/i]

I do make that claim. Taking a $70,000 salary over a $50,000 salary is anything but the goodness of one's heart - especially if that additional $20,000 is taken from the private sector folks earning less.

[i]Put public sector jobs in line with private ones. They will still be able to compete for top talent.[/i]

The public sector should not compete at all with the private sector. Their respective roles are - or should be - different. (It's that [i]Conflict of Visions[/i] thing again.)

[i]"Private Ones" can offer anything they want.[/i]

You're actually incorrect - terribly incorrect. The private sector can only offer as much as the free-enterprise market will allow. The private sector cannot raise prices at will, but only as much as the public will tolerate. The government, on the other hand, can raise taxes, print money, and accumulate debt - on the backs of the taxpayer - unlike any private entity is able. Therefore, any competition between the two is not only unfair, but tilted towards the government's favor.

[i]I get a great salary, a car-park, a car, and free lunch and breakfast. I work in the Private sector.[/i]

Good for you. I don't begrudge that, nor do I judge that. I'm sure your hard work makes you deserving. But TAX DOLLARS do not pay for it.

[i]Max, your attack on the freedoms of other people are nothing short of breathless.[/i]

Excuse me? I don't try to restrict anyone's freedom - unless it infringes upon the freedom of others. And true freedom is not two wolves and a sheep voting on what's for dinner.

[i]Why should any group of people, members of your society, have their capability and legal right to association diminished because YOU think the government is too big???[/i]

Why should a [i]big government[/i] advocate trump my [i]less government[/i] preference? I can live my life just fine without infringing on their freedoms, but they can't possibly live theirs without infringing on mine.

[i]Freedom or restriction? You were pretty quick out of the block on that one. [/i]

No I wasn't. See above.

By the way, you're just another Australian suggesting to an American how to best govern himself. Why is it that I've never - NEVER - seen an American suggest anything to an Australian regarding how he should or should not govern himself?

by drowningnotwaving

No Max, like you following much discussion on this and other areas I have learned a lot, and do believe in LESS government. What I struggle with is how much less and how, in very practical terms, this can be made to work.

I want to get off the soap-box, roll up the sleeves and see what is necessary in the real world.

[b]That government which governs least, governs best [/b] speaks nothing to how to attract quality people into a limited government role and manage accordingly.

My take would be to hire the absolute best, target them to whatever appropriate change you wish to see, and pay them appropriately in both cash and kind - whatever the open market requires to attract the same.

[b]Taking a $70,000 salary over a $50,000 salary is anything but the goodness of one's heart - especially if that additional $20,000 is taken from the private sector folks earning less.[/b]

Are you serious? Do you truly see this as a long-term strategy for success? Is your only definition of a "good" public servant someone who works for free, or less than the lowest wage earner?

Do you genuinely beleive that there exists a pool of dedicated and highly talented people willing to work for a long-term career at less than your lowest wage category for the good and betterment of all other folk in the society?

IMHO it sounds more like a soap-box seminar rather than a sound strategy.

And does your strategy spread across all endeavours of payment by the public purse?

[b]The public sector should not compete at all with the private sector. Their respective roles are - or should be - different. (It's that Conflict of Visions thing again.)[/b]

This seems a somewhat trite statement. Given the source of employees is the open market, to suggest that the "Public Sector" can't compete is just silly. Where should they go for candidates - the Vatican?

[b]Why should a big government advocate trump my less government preference? I can live my life just fine without infringing on their freedoms, but they can't possibly live theirs without infringing on mine.[/b]

You skillfully, as is your talent, [i]avoided the question[/i].

Why should a group of people in your or my society work in conditions and rules that are significantly different to you and me?

I have the right of association and the right to collectively bargain, whether or not I choose to use it. Why should they not have that right, simply because their employer is the public sector?

(Given that the work "right" in this case refers to legal and common law enablements and protections, and given also I am talking your comman garden variety "Jo-ann Treasury Clerk", not a member of the FBI).

Would such restrictions serve to increase the appeal of talented people to the pool of available resoureces?

Re Australian:

If you note, I have only ASKED. I have not SUGGESTED anything.

The only time I mentioned conditions over here I prefaced same with "I know this is irrelevant"; it was just for the discussion of failed "Less is Better" policy adoption.

Again, you constantly point to LESS GOVERNMENT but don't say HOW MUCH LESS or HOW MUCH IS OKAY, nor really much about [b]how[/b] to make LESS work better.

If being asked questions from someone overseas offends, hey I'll apologise. It was not the intention. :)

edit shpellingk - take a bow and make a box!

by drowningnotwaving

Just wondering how many you think would be in the Military if their service was required for no salary, perks or pensions?

It was tried, by the way, just a few times over the last 2 millenia ...

Why is it that most western Governments have had to significantly improve every aspect of the [b]employment agreement[/b] with their military recruits over the last 20 years, if the recruits are truly doing it for the good of the nation?

edit p,unct'ion.

by maxwell edison

You asked, [i]Just wondering how many you think would be in the Military if their service was required for no salary, perks or pensions?[/i]

Just like 1941, as many as necessary to win and defend freedom.

They actually lied (about whatever) to get in.

by santeewelding

Max ignored me, too, a long while back when I took up, "government", with him in my alien way.

The two of you are speaking right past each other with your use of, "government". The fallout is completely predictable.