Discussion Locked

The rich are not paying their fair share of taxes. . . . .

0 helpful
146 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

146 replies

by nicknielsen

That's also New Jersey. Here's the situation in South Carolina, and, I suspect, many other states without public employee unions. (Numbers in [-brackets-] refer to links at bottom.)

[i]In New Jersey, public servants have pensions. Some have several. Private sector has 401ks, no pensions.[/i]

In SC, public employees have pensions. If they are eligible for more than one, they choose one and only one. By law, they contribute 6.5% of pre-tax income; they have no choice. [-1-] If they want a 401(k), that comes from what's left.

[i]Their salaries are far above what one could make in the private sector. [/i]

Average annual pay for SC state employees in 2009 was $36,931. [-2-] DOL reports the mean wage in SC as $37,040 as of May 2009. [-3-]

Some current IT job listings in SC [-4-]:

Senior DBA (Oracle Master Cert preferred), hiring at $63,877-$82,930 annually
Computer Operator II (mainframe), hiring at $24,881-$28,000 annually
Help desk technician (temp/part time), $8.50/hour

[i]Their health care is paid for through taxpayer dollars. The rest of us pay most of our own.[/i]

For full family coverage on the standard plan, the state pays $602.56 per month and the individual pays $294.58. For the cheapest available HMO plan, the state's contribution remains the same, while the individual's cost jumps to $741.22. [-5-][-6-]

[i]Their unused sick time gets carried over and they get paid for it when they leave.[/i]

Up to a maximum of 90 days. Not bad for 30 years.

[i]Private sector can't carry sick time over year to year and they lose what they don't use. [/i]

Nothing in law says they can't carry it over, but the accounting is so much easier when you can start accounts payable from zero each year.

[i]They even have their parking paid for. I have to pay my own.[/i]

I suspect almost 61,000 SC state employees would love that, because they have to pay for their own, too.

Some of the other "perks" in SC:
* No overtime pay. Comp time is exchanged for overtime on an hour-for-hour basis.
* Traveling? Use your own car. Mileage is reimbursed at $.505 or the IRS rate, whichever is less.
* Away from the office for the day? Meal costs reimbursed in full, as long as the total is $25 or less. Breakfast - $6, lunch - $7, supper - $12. [-7-]

And the best part, all those happy customers, every one of which knows
a) you are overpaid;
b) you are under-worked;
c) your only objective is to keep them from getting what they deserve; and
d) the only reason you work for the state is because you can't hack it in the real world.

=====

Links:
1. SC Retirement System - Active Members
2. Employee Demographics (one-page PDF)
3. May 2009 State Occupational Employment and Wage Estimates
South Carolina

4. SC Jobs Portal
5. 2010 Employee Benefits Guide
6. Insurance Rates
7. Travel Regulations

by drowningnotwaving

... they all got paid, with perks.

Let's not degrade this into a "are you questioning the loyalty of my military men?" argument.

I'm not.

I am pointing out that, with significant historical precedent, Kingdoms and thence Nations learnt that a purely Volunteer Force, on its own, was less likely to win than a paid professional Army / Military.

To the point that, now, such a purely voluntary force does not exist in the western nations.

I am using this as a specific point with which to question your premise regarding who, and how long, is prepared to work in a public sector role for either free or less than the lowest wage earner.

You said you trusted the military more than other examples of publicly paid employees, so let's use that as the example.

by jamesrl

I worked for an agency of the Canadian Federal Government for a few years. As such my organization was run like a business with a board of directors (most from private industry, some from government). We did reseceive research funds from the government, but we were expected to pay operational budgets from our revenue.

So saying all that, our salary scales were based on Federal Government standards.

Certainly we were not paid as well as the best in private industry. We looked to pay on average the median wage in the industry - 50% of organizations paid more, 50% less. We made up for it with a generous pension plan. We needed to, or private industries would be paoching all the staff, and we'd spend even more money constantly training new staff.

As for job security, I was laid off, as were about 15% of the Federal workforce between 1995 and 2004. Now I know its Canada, and not the US, but if we can do it (under a Liberal Prime Minister even) so can you.

I do think that there should be less job security than there is in most government positions.

by nicknielsen

[i]Why is it that most western Governments have had to significantly improve every aspect of the employment agreement with their military recruits over the last 20 years, if the recruits are truly doing it for the good of the nation?[/i]

Because they aren't just doing it for the good of the nation. There as many other reasons as there are members of the military. But all of them have one thing in common: since 1974, every one entering the American military has voluntarily, without threat of conscription, sworn an oath to "support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic." In taking that oath, each has written a blank check, payable to the United States of America, for an amount up to, and including, his or her life.

Isn't that worth a little bit more than minimum wage?

by drowningnotwaving

[i]I question the honesty of anyone who works for the government and claims to do so in order to serve the public.

Their salaries are far above what one could make in the private sector. Their health care is paid for through taxpayer dollars.

"Considering their higher wages, better benefits, and job security, they really serve only themselves; if anything, the public serves them."

Truer words were never spoken. [/i]

With sentiment like this, I can only surmise that, since a Politician is the highest level of public service, they too should pretty much volunteer their time?

Bringing back the brown paper bag to politics, perhaps?

by maxwell edison

by drowningnotwaving

Read them all - they weren't onerous. Even read the piece on NJ's Christie.

Well on the face of it - phew - there do seem to be some "out there" clauses of employment.

Notwithstanding I am sure that the figures are questionable, e.g. Nick Neilsen's post with research, and the discrepancy between some of the figures include in all the articles, no doubt about it your Federal government employees are on a good wicket.

(Trying hard to avoid comment on your local issues ... )

Here's the thing and I'll try very hard to limit to few questions -

* If you want a smarter, better, smaller public service - for instance one that manages a lot of things that are ultimately supplied by the private sector, how do you do it ?

* Do you seriously think that can be acheived by paying LESS to get the people of the calibre that can manage such enterprises?

* Alternately do you think it will be such a doddle that any person can do it?

(PS: My take is that in your ideal government, with as small a government populous as possible, the average wage of government employees will raise significantly. There should be heaps fewer of them, capable of managing large outsourced projects on behalf of the folks. An analogy is when the backs of the mining sector unions were broken: HEAPS less workers, but those that remained earn truckloads for higher skilled work).

* How do you do it if you insist that, in the employment of staff, the public sector cannot compete with the private sector?

And finally:

* If being able to freely associate and collectively bargain is an accepted "norm" / enabled right (whatever term suits) in your society, why on earth should the subset who just work for the public sector NOT be afforded the same norms/rights?

It would seem to me that your prblem is not with the Union. It's with 25 years of government who have enabled this to happen.

{NOT THAT YOU CARE BUT We too have had similar issues. The public service conditions over here much more closely align with 'standard' conditions most workers enjoy.

Over the last 20 years and, funnily enough, in many cases commencing with (our equivalent of your Democrats), simple concepts of 'tenure', of not being made redundant, of not being able to be sacked, have been radically reduced. Not many PS workers expect or consider they have a job for life. Albeit they may expect their chances of employment in the private sector are scarce. I think, as one of your articles commented regarding your past, they forego the opportunity for large salaries on the basis of some more protection than the average private sector worker.

The conditions under which workers can be terminated are identical in public and private sectors as these are structured in our IR laws.

NOT that you care.

by tonythetiger

[i]If I buy a "newly built house" for 200,000 the tax would be $46000. I would buy a used house and save the $46000.[/i]

The person who paid that $46,000 is going to try to include as much of it as possible into his asking price when he sells :)

by maxwell edison

The business of government is governing; it should not be in the business of business. The business of business is business; it should not be in the business of governing.

Having said that, I believe that the role of government in the United States has infringed into the business of business way too much. As such, the first step in getting less of it is not getting more of it. Stop the growth first, and work on reversing the growth later.

There are more government employees today than there were a year ago, while employment in the private sector has lost jobs. Think about the dynamics in place. Less money is being made in the private sector, yet those earning less must now pay more to support those in the government sector. That's not the halt in government growth I would expect. It's not government serving the people, but rather the other way around; and that is wrong.

Nonetheless, to my comment about competition between the government employer and the private employer. I don't necessarily mean that as an absolute, so it would be a mistake to take it as one.

For example, local building departments need qualified and competent engineers to review building plans, inspect building sites for code compliance, and so on. As such, salary and benefits offered for such a position should be commensurate with the industry norm.

But the government goes too far. For example, civil engineers industry wide, can expect to earn between $50,000 and $80,000 salaries. Civil engineers working for the government routinely earn well over $100,000. Moreover, the benefits offered are well above the private industry norm, oftentimes valued at $25,000 or more. And that doesn't include the lush defined-benefits retirement package. It's not uncommon for a life-long government employee to retire at a young age (55-60) with a life-long benefit of $60,000 - $80,000 per year.

But here's where the competition is unfair. Private industry simply cannot provide those kinds of things because they must make a profit in order to remain solvent. The government has no such profit motive to keep wages and benefits in-check with what the market will bear. Private businesses can't increase prices at-will to support such spending, while government can raise taxes and/or operate with perpetual deficits and/or print money. Private business can't pass-on debt to future generations. Private business would go bankrupt - and its officers sent to jail - if they operated the way government does. It's obvious that the two operate on unlevel playing fields and by a different set of rules.

Moreover, there are really two kinds of government jobs: those that can ONLY be performed by government (military, elected office, and so on); and then there are those that could be performed by the private sector.

Keeping with my engineering analogy, there's absolutely no reason why the government couldn't put out to bid myriad government engineering needs - reconciling park service maps with satellite photos, as just one example. Why pay a government employee $120,000 per year plus perks up the ying-yang when it could be put out to bid in the private sector and get done just as well?

The government OWES the taxpayer the best value - the best bang for the buck. Giving such jobs to government employees is tantamount to giving no-bid contracts.

Competition for the best and the brightest is fine - as long as both parties are playing by the same rules. Unfortunately, the government can change the rules at-will to its own favor.

Bottom line: IF the private sector can perform a function just as well - or possibly better - than the government sector, then that function should be put out to bid in the private sector. (Can anyone spell USPS?)

And it's worth repeating:

Private business would go bankrupt [b]- and its officers sent to jail -[/b] if they operated the way government does. It's obvious that the two operate on unlevel playing fields and by a different set of rules.

by santeewelding

Is a [i]transitive[/i] verb, Maxwell. You present it as [i]intransitive[/i].

Am I mistaken that "government" has something to do with what you are saying?

by maxwell edison

Ask me that question in the morning over a cup of coffee; not during happy hour after a couple glasses of scotch!

Nonetheless, regardless of the difference between transitive verbs and intransitive verbs, if you can't discern the difference between [i]what I said[/i] and [i]what I mean[/i], then perhaps you should knock yourself down a few notches and join the rest of the world. I would think pretty it's lonely up there in your literary ivory tower.

(Maybe I should have used the (non)word [i]irregardless[/i] and really pushed your buttons!)

Have a nice evening, Santee; and thanks for the chuckle.

Cheers!

by drowningnotwaving

NOW I understand a lot more. My response to the soap-box-like comments was perhaps understandable, perhaps over the top.

It appears from the information that you have presented that YOUR public service employees in some circumstances have certainly been able to take advantage of the largesse of successive governments of all persuasions.

It may well be time to 'break' the Union.

I can't see how you can take away people's right/privilege to actually BE in a Union.

[i]As such, salary and benefits offered for such a position should be commensurate with the industry norm.[/i]

100% agreed and over here they pretty much are. Generaly a little less but the return to the employee is a little less stress and a little more job security, although not guaranteed whatsoever.

by maxwell edison

As a disclaimer, let me say this. I have no problem with labor unions. In fact, I acknowledge the positive things that have resulted from them - especially during the first half of the twentieth century.

However, I believe that labor unions have grown too big for their britches, so to speak. Intimidation tactics, bribery, and political influence are synonymous with labor unions.

Having said that, the role of government is to serve the public. The role of unions is to serve the worker (or so they claim, but some might argue that it's to serve themselves). There's an obvious conflict of interest.

Building on my previous post, put government functions out to bid in the private sector, irregardless (for you, Santee) of whether those private bidders are union or non-union shops.

Bottom line: Unionized government employees present an obvious conflict of interest. And the public interest should be the trump card, not the losing hand.

by santeewelding

I'm serious.

Take the verb, "to exist".

It is intransitive. You don't get to go outside the concept for definition. Nothing relative can serve you. Even lexicographers have problems with it. The Collegiate, for example, has it as, "to come into being", which is relative and transitive.

To present government as intransitive -- self-occupied -- is to present it as a giant ingrown toenail. You help no one with your explanations. All you do is bitch about the pain of (unions) and (taxes).

by drowningnotwaving

We'll agree to disagree.

All workers, with very few exceptions, deserve the right to association and collectively bargain.

YES the Union / Employer pendulum swings and sometimes wildly. Your statement: [i]Intimidation tactics, bribery, and political influence are synonymous with labor unions[/i] could also be said for companies in 'the good ol days' and in particular of PS employers / employees throughout history.

Indeed one of the specific reasons for impoving working conditions of many PS employees, in our neck-o-woods, was to reduce such temptation and activity. They often were, truly, the "brown paper bag" days.

In this case, my take is that the "public right" exists, no doubt. But so does the "public duty" to ensure that the public sector workers are paid / managed / whatever in a manner commensurate with prevailing employment conditions, including their right to be represented by Unions.

As mentioned, that your PS Unions have taken the mickey out of the Government, is as much (if not more) the fault of the government than the Union.

Unless I am mistaken, even (many of) your police forces have Association / collective representation, as does ours, often involved in negotiating employment conditions.

by drowningnotwaving

In our neck-o-woods, our most recent government (prior to the current govt that is) was HUGELY successful, in terms of reducing unemployment to its lowest in decades, reducing prevailing interest rates AND puting our government into a massive operating surplus.

The "step too far" was an attempt to cease collective bargaining.

Even though Union membership has dropped over the last 20 years, even though a lot of people feel their role either redundant or self-serving, this fundamental threat to (what we consider) a fundamental social privilege proved THE major reason why that government was brought down.

Just a digression.

by drowningnotwaving

:) but I am learning and discussing and it's civil (well IMHO of course), so is there truly an issue?

I would submit my reaction in earlier posts reflects what was written, clearly not necessarily in all cases what was fully meant (upon delving).

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"All workers, with very few exceptions, deserve the right to association and collectively bargain."[/i]

My exception is government workers. What are your exceptions?

by drowningnotwaving

Would be the Military. I think you sign up and you sign over.

I am sure there are nefarious arms of various security bodies that may fall into the same category.

I think all other employees deserve to have the same opportunities afforded them as, well, other employees.

Does something being in the "Public Interest" remove public's obligation? Surely not - IMHO of course.

by santeewelding

A lesson in grammar.

It was touch to the hem of Absolute Reason.

It was, once upon a time, alluded to by [b]drowningnotwaving[/b], as the spaces between the keys, without which, you got no keys or "government".

by maxwell edison

by drowningnotwaving

So your answer to your incompetent government managers and politicians is to take away the "rights" (at least those privileges enjoyed by a major slab of the population) from another major slab of the population?

Your answer includes, whilst qualified later, still (seemingly?) includes wholesale stripping wage and conditions from major slabs of those employed by the State.

Go back to the top then - how will you attract and retain the talent necessary to operate this uber-tightly-managed public sector operation?

PS I have to say your blaming the 'existence' of the Unions for this debacle that many of your States seem to find themselves in, smacks of "lack of responsibility" and "blaming someone else".

Your insistence that a group of employees - one that no matter what is done will remain a large sector of the workforce - cannot enjoy the same freedom that the rest of the workforce enjoys, flies in the face of, well, Freedom. Such is your stance and by such juxtapositions will you be seen.

The world has shown - America has shown - unfairly strong Unions can be broken. As can unfairly harsh employers. You don't need to BAN them to break them, and BANNING them doesn't appear to necessarily work in the long run (a.k.a the ANC and Solidarity to name the upper echelons).

As you should know, Max from your strong and emotive pleas re freedom: Societies who get into the habit of BANNING things in the hope that they stop fundamenal human spirit, either get into a long slope of continual banning OR simply fail.

by drowningnotwaving

There other methods of curtailing the power of unions and the methods in which employment conditions are negotiated.

[i]We have to escape this cycle or it will crush us. One way is to take labor negotiations out of the hands of vulnerable legislators and assign them to independent commissions. They would have a better shot at achieving a fair balance between appropriate salary increases and the revenues and services of local municipalities. The electorate won't swallow any more red ink.[/i]

I did read your articles. :)

by jdclyde

Is it "fair" that one person pays nothing while another pays over a million?

Is it "fair" that one person pays $2000 while another pays $500,000?

Or should it all fall down to percent of income?

Or should it only be "the rich" that should pay while "the poor" only receive?

My Aunt recently passed on a petition from MoveOn crying about how Hedge fund managers only pay 15%, and how it wasn't fair that they pay a lower percent than fire fighters and teachers. (a large portion of their income is collected under capital gains, not income, thus the 15%) Based on the income figures MoveOn provided, the evil managers pay in each year what it would take the teachers over 3000 years to MAKE. Is that "fair"?

How many leaders in Congress and the Senate have recently had issues for failing to pay THEIR fair share of due taxes? How many of the recent appointed positions were filled by people with the same issues?

Going into an election cycle, so it is time to start up the class warfare again. Lets all hate "the rich"?

by xnavydk

Im not going to read the 100++ posts but I have thought about taxes off and on the last few months because owing sucks. I claim no exemptions and have nothing to reduce my taxable income and paying in Single and zero and still owing is what yanks my short hairs.

Yes it is still my fault I owe, I should have known what the amount on my current taxable wages was and either paid the additional $$ or reduce my taxable income by investing and other such vehicles at my disposal.

but I don't want to complain (too much)because when I had exemptions (3) kids, I paid little and got a return for over 20 years.

but now I am still flummoxed how the single person, as far as individual tax payers are stuck holding the bag the majority of the people who pay in.

For example. some folks use the tax system as a savings of some sort why is beyond me.
loaning the govt your money for a year with no interest is beyond odd. sock what you would have paid in additional taxes in a CD, and if that's not feasible, contribute that monthly amount to a 401k.

anyway, as always I am off on a tirade. to answer one of your questions:
I also think the IRS should be abolished and taxes paid by people on a fair percentage value of consumed products and services (sales tax) and a flat rate tax based on income. There should not be a benefit for how many puppies you have. There has to be taxes, the state and fed have to pay for stuff that's necessary and fund stupid stuff like welfare for people too stupid or lazy to get a fluxing job.

A chief of mine used to say, Kids were not issued in your sea bag. Meaning the navy is not responsible for them, YOU are.

I don't earn an extra $10 an hour because I have children over a person who doesn't.

wow my thoughts are all over the place on this one. ::hits the the post anyway key:: it related to the any key

by tonythetiger

[i]Im not going to read the 100++ posts but I have thought about taxes off and on the last few months because owing sucks. [/i]

If anything, you're better off owing a little as long as you can afford to pay... Just as overpaying is an interest-free loan to the government, underpaying is an interest-free loan to you!

Perhaps you can even put the difference between "S0" and "M9" in the bank and make a little money off of their money while you're holding it for them :)

Banks and other businesses do that all the time with YOUR money. Even the one you WORK for (ever wonder why in this day and age they still hold back a pay?)

by maxwell edison

As I previously said, labor unions in the free market place are fine. Knock yourselves out. Let business management and the consumer decide whether or not to capitulate to union demands.

If a chain of grocery stores goes union, and prices are increased and/or customer service decreases as a result, the customers who oppose it can vote with their feet and their dollars.

There's a reason union membership has been on the decline for several decades in the United States, and that's because the consumer didn't want them anymore, and their excessive demands bankrupted not only businesses, but entire industries.

Government is different. The government is a monopoly. There is no other consumer choice.

It's not right that union demands result in higher prices for the consumer - the taxpayer - who has no other option. And letting the business of government go bankrupt is not an option. On second thought, maybe that is the best option. Then people might get their heads out of wherever they've been planted and realize that government - just like unions - has gotten too big for its britches. It is too bad that entire industries - or governments - have to be destroyed for them to see it.

By the way, labor unions and socialism are not too distant cousins. They both have very common roots.

by tonythetiger

is the "closed shop" concept. Long ago I was in a situation where I actually LOST money when the shop went union (I voted 'no'). For a union to come in and force a change to a contract I personally had with my employer, and that we were both happy with just seemed wrong.

by tonythetiger

Overtime equalization.

When management makes a mistake and calls in the wrong person, union members are told NOT to point it out beforehand... that way the "wrong person" gets the overtime, and the person who grieves it gets compensated as if he had worked the hours.

by drowningnotwaving

As your commentators put it - the collusion between the Union leadership and the Politiciansin their various legislatures is mind-numbing. Who heard of a Union politicking for MORE taxes??

I agree, these small examples are unbeleivable. What ideas?

Separating the Legislature from the employment negotiations is one way.

Moritorium on all wages, perks and new hires for X years (say, until such time as the unfunded component of the pension fund is funded).

Outsourcing the "pension fund" to a more traditional 401K style of fund, at the same percentage contribution as 'the general population'.

Getting more Christies with the real guts to cease programmes that can't be afforded and accelerate the outsourcing of activiies that, as you say Max, should not be the provenance of Government.

TONY Absolutely banning the concept of the 'closed shop'. Agreed 100%. For the most part we have one this but there are still small pockets / industries that keep their monopoly.

Curtailing your entire Lobby industry, of which your PS Unions seem to have learned how to do it very well.

On examination I am sure these ideas are a) not original and b) full of holes. I don't mean them to be flippant nor do I think they are "well just do it and it will work".

But I am pretty sure that banning people from association is a proven, failed strategy and (looking from the outside) doesn't address the issues of your politician's agendas.

It's your politician's agendas that are the issue, according to the majority of the notes Max included.

Best of luck.

by av .

He is our white knight on a shining horse in NJ. He says that he doesn't care if he is a one term governor, he's just going to do what we elected him to do - cut the government. Its tough to elect a Republican in this very blue state, but FINALLY, people showed up to vote because the state is nearly bankrupt.

I have to pinch myself when he talks about capping our property taxes at 2.5 percent per year. We pay the highest in the nation. It isn't uncommon for people to pay $15-$20,000 per year in property taxes because thats how we fund our very corrupt school system.

Taxpayers sent a message this time. I'd love to have him as governor for two terms. So far, he is ruffling a whole lot of feathers, but is receiving bipartisan support for most things and most important, the taxpayers support him. The unions, particularly the teacher's union, are pulling out all the stops to defend their fiefdom, but it doesn't work with him. He stands his ground.

The Dems don't like that he won't impose a millionaire's tax to close the budget gap. They tried to introduce a bill, but he said outright he will veto it. He is making deep cuts in government waste instead and I think thats great. No more gravy train for the entitled.

I think each state has their own unique problems and its up to them to solve their issues. The federal government has enough to deal with.

If Chris Christie can make this state fiscally sound, I have great hopes for him as the next Reagan one day. He is a strong leader, honest and he doesn't back down. He doesn't tell you what you want to hear, but he tells it like it is.

AV

by drowningnotwaving

Just a question - are these analagous to what we call "Council Rates"?

That is, the amount paid annually by all residents (or more accurately according to each specific adress) in a local government area, to assist funding the operation of that Local Government?

Further, our rates are a function of the "unimproved land value" of the property, which is established, and increased annually, by an quasi-independent Board.

Our rates are relatively "expensive" - we pay about $1,850 per year for our property.

Is this the same thing?

by av .

The perks offered to public employees today are simply unsustainable. Its paid for by taxpayer dollars and with high unemployment, at 9.7 percent where I live, there are plenty of people that will do it for less.

Public employees have always been in it for the many perks they get. They don't care about anything else but themselves.

Yes, there are companies that offer you more perks, but that is the exception and not the rule nowadays.

Government is too big and too costly for the rest of us to support and its time for the gravy train to stop. I've never taken advantage of government services personally, but some people make their living by doing just that, at the expense of the rest of us. That has to stop and its time for people to take responsibility for themselves.

AV

by av .

The problem is that only a small portion of property taxes provides for the local government. The rest of the taxes go to fund the schools.

For example, the portion of my taxes to support the local government is about $1500 per year. I pay about $8200 per year in property taxes though. The rest of it goes to fund the schools.

Mind you, the only government services I have is when the plow the roads in the winter during snow storms. I maintain my own well, septic system and pay for garbage removal outside of that.

AV

by maxwell edison

With that kind of talk, you'll be called a racist, a hate-monger, a greedy SOB (or DOB), selfish, self-centered, and mean-spirited.

That's what they do, you know.

by av .

I have my flack jacket on. I guess I'm just jaded. I don't mind paying my fair share, but things are out of hand now because the public money has run out. Such is the problem with entitlement programs. Eventually the gravy train dries up.

I'm a strong believer in personal responsibility and I think that is also in short supply today. I'm not asking anyone else to make up my losses to my retirement accounts from the great recession. Thats my problem and I'm going to have to work longer. It sucks, but thats how it goes.

I'm no millionaire, just a middle class person who has worked and saved for most of the 40 years I've been working only to see a big chunk of it ripped off in the great recession and then to see the government try to take what is left to give to someone else.

If they want to call me the Queen of Mean because I'm out of money, than so be it. I think its time for people to take responsibility for themselves. Times are tough for everyone today.

You do take lots of flack for your opinions, Max. I have to say that the more I learn about how governments work, the more I am starting to agree with you.

AV

This discussion is closed to new replies.