Who is telling you that certifications would increase your pay? Is it your boss or the HR department where you work? I?ve been reading this in magazines since Novell first introduced their training matrix in the 80?s. The only time I required someone get certification is when I worked for a consulting organization and a new customer required ?proof of competency? for everyone who worked on site. If your supervisor told you that this is holding you back from raises, get specific objectives and rewards from him and the HR department. Otherwise he was using this as an excuse for why you are not getting more money.
Make certain any training meets the long term goals of your career and/or the organization where you are working. Do you want to go into management? Then getting a masters degree is a logical path. If you see yourself teaching or training others then a master combined with a PHD is your path.
If your objective is to increase pay at your current job you should talk to your HR department and supervisor to determine what their criteria is and how you fit into the departments long term objectives. Understanding what gaps will exist in the future will guide the training path at your current job. In other words look for the opportunities coming down the road and position yourself with training to be the obvious choice of the organization.
Perhaps you were told that in order to get a higher paying job outside of your organization you will need proof of competency or certifications in order to be attractive to a potential employer. This may be true in some circumstances. My suggestion is to find an organization you would like to work for and talk to a hiring IT manager about what he is looking for in a future employee. Does he give any merit to certifications over experience? What type of people is he interested in finding over the next X years. A little networking and research will go a long way to some answers.
Another approach is to create your own training plan complete with a business case for your current employer. For example if you spend time repairing PC?s the vendor may have some interesting perks for your organization if you are certified to work on their equipment. These perks may include access to online resources or getting access to level 2 support without jumping through level 1 etc? Show how you can save time and money if you are certified. This will help solidify your expertise within your organization as well as introduce you to a whole new network of employment possibilities.
Good luck!