13 replies
by howard_davis Accepted solution
by robo_dev Accepted solution
The simplest solution is to physically separate the two networks, the middle solution is to physically separate the two networks with a router/firewall in between the two, and the trickier yet most elegant solution is to create multiple VLANs.
In general, I do not understand how it makes sense to have two ISPs to keep students apart from teachers, that can be done easily simply with VLANs, and that introduces more problems and cost that it cures, in my opinion.
There are multi-wan routers, which would be the most logical solution for multiple ISP connections, but again, if your goal is to keep students away from teachers, and vice-versa, that's more of a VLAN design issue.
by lyle148806 Accepted solution
The separation of the two internal network is a separate issue, either using physical separate networks or VLANs is the way for this, along with firewalls etc.
The two ISP links could provide redundant or load balanced access to the net, but unless your setting up to physically separate networks should not be part of the separation of the students and the teachers
by howard_davis Accepted solution
by -lukin- Accepted solution
Use the t1 for backup connectivity and the cable line as your main. Depending on the router you are using this is fairly simple to set up, as the T1 would just be a fail over in case of an outage with the cable.
Just create seperate vlans for students and teachers as was explained earlier, and the rest can be done through AD/Group policy depending on how you have your AD set up.
by howard_davis Accepted solution
by robo_dev Accepted solution
First of all, load balancing makes good sense.
Second, note that the 'advertised' throughput of a cable modem may not be all that consistent, as the CMTS (cable modem transmission system) relies on a shared topology to a set group of homes/businesses, so the fine print that says 'up to' 15mbs very much applies.
T1 service tends to be very consistent, and the bandwidth you pay for is the bandwidth you get. Also, depending on the provider, the availability of the CMTS may be inconsistent. In other words, you get what you pay for....
by howard_davis Accepted solution
by eugene.haney Accepted solution
Dual WAN with load balancing = great way to aggregate traffic. Firewall should be able to do that depending on licensing/firmware (check). This is a tricky implementation, if you have a lot of experience with the firewall/router manufacturer then go for it.
Make sure you configure VPN traffic for the dual ISPs for failover.
I agree with most posters here that regardless of the size of the organization you **should** implement VLANs to separate student/teacher traffic.
by howard_davis Accepted solution
by robo_dev Accepted solution
As a couple of people doing some Torrent downloads could kill that connection.
A proxy server that does caching can help things tremendously, especially if a whole classroom were going to the same web page, or if a whole bunch of students are looking at online videos.
by howard_davis Accepted solution
by churdoo Accepted solution
It's already been pointed out that separating the internet bandwidth and separating LAN functionality are 2 distinct issues, and it sounds like you've figured your your LAN design to some extent, so I'll speak only about your internet circuits.
You haven't mentioned, but are you hosting your own email on campus? Hosting any of your own websites? Hosting any other inbound services?
Seems to me, to LB a 15mb connection with a 1.5mb connection, is only adding 10% capacity to the cable connection for total aggregate bandwidth. And I understand that the cable spec isn't true sustainable throughput, but even if sustainable is half the spec you're still only adding 20% for total aggregate bandwidth.
IF you're hosting any inbound services like email, www, etc., consider dedicating the T1 to these hosted services, as the T1 likely carries an SLA more appropriate to hosting such services. In this scenario I would not add the T1 to the aggregate bandwidth pool for all "other" services (outbound browsing, etc.), but I would dedicate it to the inbound hosted services full time and use it as FAILOVER only for general outbound services.
My two cents even if that's all it's worth.
--C
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Networks posts
Sort by Trending