Discussion Locked

To Upgrade or Not to Uprade

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We have a small network of computer running Windows 2000 Pro. We have two servers running Server 2003 and Exchange Server 2003.

We're also running a few legacy DOS-based programs.

I can see a future need to update to a newer operating system for the workstations, but the big question is when should we do it and which OS should we choose?

XP still seems to be the best option, but how much longer will it truly be supported?

Will the legacy programs work in the new OS?

Should I just sit back and wait for Windows 7?

7 replies

by selltekk

Personally, I think your best bet would be to download the beta of Windows 7 and start testing all of your production applications on it.

At this point, XP is your most viable alternative if Windows 7 isn't an acceptable option, but as you said, its support roadmap is coming to an end. Vista has some acceptance in corporate IT departments, but it's use isn't widespread enough for my taste, and Microsoft is already moving ahead with Win 7. I also read somewhere (techrepublic RSS feed?) that Ballmer said it was OK to skip Vista...so what does that say about it?

In my opinion, Vista, while pretty and functional, has too much bloat for wide deployment for many companies simply because they don't want to have to upgrade all of their hardware.

I am testing windows 7 beta on a fleet PC here and it seems to run fine with only 512MB RAM and a single core 2.4 GHz processor. It also seems to run all of our standard apps, but we don't have any legacy (read: 16bit DOS subsystem apps) applications to worry about.

The beat can be downloaded for free too, so grab an extra one of your fleet PCs and give it a test.

Good luck!

by jamesrl

This is the sticky part.

The older the version of Windows, the more likely a DOS app will work. Windows 2000 and XP use a souped up version of the NT kernel and a DOS emulator to run DOS apps. There is a reasonable amount of information out there on how to tweak and troubleshoot older DOS apps to work with XP.

XP will be supported for some years to come.

XP would be your safest bet.

James

by oz_media

Perhaps TODAY XP would be the best anwswer, but would you really recommend upgrading an entire company to XP this late in the game, especially if Win2K is currently doing the job and they are planning for the future?

Who wants to upgrade the whole company network every 4 years?

by oz_media

Win2000Pro was my favorite MS OS of all, unfortunately that notebook died and instead of takign time to fix it, I had need for a quick relacement, enter Vista Home Professional.

I am one of many users that have had NO problem at all with Vista, the problems people constantly complain about are non issues (for the most part) that can be turned off or are a problem with using old, antiquated hardware. I find its fast, responsive, runs anythign i need ot run (graphics, recording software, web design, MS Office, Video rendering etc. no problems)

one benchmark test from a fellow TR peer here, https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-10879-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=280962 shows that with various build, up against equivalent XP builds, Vista was slightly faster right across the board.

My aim though is not to get you to install Vista on your PC's, but to illustrate that while you have conveniently omitted Vista from your interests, why would you feel that another, brand new OS (Win7) will be teh answer worth waitign for?

Any new Os has issues with hardware support, though I found the Beta's of Win7 to have no issues with drivers, but then again neither did Vista because its a new machine.
If you are looking to add a new OS to existing boxes, which are curretnly running 2K, I am pretty confident that no matter what you install, you will need to replace the older machines.

Your legacy programs would need hands-on testing in house, nobody can make such a call on the fly, but new OS's are usually pretty good with legacy APPs, though XP was a horror show when first released (by far the worst realease MS has ever tried, it wasn't until SP2 that it became stable and somewhat secure, Vista still beats XP security).

So go buy a box or two, new with a heap'o ram, and test them with your legacy apps and while they will come with Vista preinstalled, just partition them out and try XP too.

But the time Win7 is on the shelves, Vista should be at SP2, which may prove to be pretty nice for people currently having issues running on older boxes.

XP is on the way out, Win7 will be in its infancy and facing the same issues ALL releases do, compatibilty, speed tweaks etc.

by jdclyde

hopefully they have learned a lesson from how they pushed Vista, that Win7 (whatever the name will end up being) will appeal to more people that are having a harder time getting a budget for replacing systems.

XP was a hard sell at first during a decent economy. Trying to do it while everyone is laying off half their workforce is going to be next to impossible for many.

by jdclyde

There is not a valid business expense at this stage of XP's business cycle to move from Win2k to it.

Wait until you actually HAVE a reason to move to a new OS, rather than doing so because of possible future needs. Move to what is out at the time, as the systems you will buy at that time will be more powerful than what you would buy now.

Remember, you have to be able to show on paper to your boss WHY they need to spend all the time and money to move to the newer OS, so I would focus on that for now.

by the scummy one

start testing on Win 7 and look to get the apps working on Win 7 if they will not (legacy apps). That way, when it is time to upgrade, you already have a lot of things taken care of and it will go smoother.

This discussion is closed to new replies.