Discussion Locked

True Linux alternatives for MS Exchange?

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

My IT department has a dilemma. Our current mail server is running on a generic beige-box ooollld PC running linux. It was set up for us by a consultant ~5 years ago, running Debian I believe. We are a Microsoft shop, offering a service that runs on custom software we've developed. Ironically, this mail server has been the most stable out of everything we've had.

The problem is that the mail server is starting to show it's age. I believe it's been updated semi-regularly, but it is essentially a black box to us. It runs SpamAssassin, but we're still overrun with spam. We don't really have any idea what our mail load is; most mail is downloaded off to local clients in the office (using Outlook) via POP...some of us use IMAP, but we aren't the heavy mail users. Of most concern, though, is the beige-box hardware has started to show signs of failing. The mail drives themselves are backed up and have RAID, but still.

Due to a database server upgrade, we now have available a pretty decent server-grade box to "play with". We've talked about how re-building a mail server from scratch would give us a better understanding of how things work, and allow us to better maintain things. I have some linux experience now since the original server was built, and feel like I could reasonably work through the setup with enough research.

What we're debating, though, is whether to rebuild a straight linux mail server, or to jump to MS Exchange. The server we have available would be more than adequate for a linux system; it would fly on it. It's still a 32-bit CPU, though, and if we went with Exchange we'd want to go with 2007, so we'd eventually need all new hardware for a production system. It sounds like I can do a test setup of Exchange 2007 on this, though.

The stability and hands-off nature of the linux setup interests me. But there is also a pressing need for a true groupware solution in the office. We have an Active Directory domain. Aside from the tech department (which uses Thunderbird and IMAP), all other users use Outlook 2003 and POP or IMAP. We do have a need for calendaring, and resource scheduling would be nice, too. So, we could go and basically just rebuild what we already have, with updated software and hardware....or go a completely different route, solve all the requirements but be stuck on Exchange with its own set of problems.

Are there any truly good solutions out there that really compete with Exchange? I need something that seamlessly works with Outlook, that includes calendar and task scheduling support. I've seen mentioned Citadel, and it looks close, but I don't think the Outlook support was really there? It sounds like I could possibly piece together different parts of open source packages and build a sort-of solution, but I can't seem to find anything that really honest-to-goodness does everything that the Exchange-Outlook combo does, without sacrificing some essential functionality or another.

Any tips or advice? Thanks!

6 replies

by axent

I've worked with Zimbra in the past, and from what I remember it contains everything that you are looking for, including Outlook support.

Check it out at www.zimbra.com.

by forum surfer

I?ve found in my personal searches that you just can?t beat MS Exchange. Most decent Linux apps will require a licensing fee, at least for a mailserver of decent capability. These fees usually appear cheaper than Exchange on the surface, but upon further investigation into support and adding all the fees together?it will cost you about the same with only a negligible difference. Also, you said you are already a Microsoft shop. You won?t find anything that integrates into your current network, ADUC and outlook any easier than exchange if that?s the case. Exchange is somewhat of a gold standard, too?so when you Google answers for your problem you stand a good chance finding someone that has had similar issues before you ever even have to think of support. Not to mention it will be easier for you to find disclaimer plug ins, anti spam software and other 3rd party plug ins much easier with far more users reviewing that product. I?m not knocking the open source alternatives?but unless you?re willing to devote A LOT of time to learning their ins and outs I?d stick with Exchange. Mind you I?m not saying Exchange is a walk in the park, it?s a steep learning curve with checkboxes galore.

by dumphrey

I am a linux user, and an MS admin, and Exchange is a solid piece of work. When we have had problems with Exchage, its almost always DNS or Spam filter related. Integration with AD is flawless, single sign on access...
That being said, its not nearly as effecient at hardware resource management as a *nix based solution (suprise). And as for licensing, the old addage needs to be re evaluated. With Exchange 2003, a license also provided an outlook 2003 license. This is no longer the case in Exchange 2007.
For smaller shops, a linux based solution is much less expensive. Cost of exchange server 2007, + license, + 64 bit server/OS, + MS server license, + full office or Outlook license. But, these are one time expenses. A linux mai server on Red Hat Ent OS would have 2 yearly fees of up to $2500ish (total) for 25 users. So Exchange actually is cheaper over the long run (say 4+ years).
Other costs: support. Exchange is easy to find answers to questions, entire sites dedicated to it. Zimbra has, well their site.. Novell Open Exchange has well, Novell...
As for anti-spam, I would invest in an appliance instead of relying on the mail server to do all the work. yet another expense of hosting your own mail server.

by forum surfer

I failed to mention that I recommend Exchange for a large solution, 750-1000+ or more users. Outside of that I?d look elsewhere. If we?re talking less than 200 users buying Exchange would be comparable to putting a v8 on a barstool.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D5_UUDjWWyQ&feature=related

It can be done, but it is more than you actually need to get the job done and a bit pricey for what your end product will be.

Don?t get me wrong, I manage an Exchange server for a law office that consists of a whopping 24 people. He came to me for my opinion. I told him Exchange is too much upkeep and too expensive for a solution that small?.even though it is the gold standard of mailserver solutions. I pitched a few options, giving him pros and cons of each. But I also told him it was his money and his firm, and I would be more than happy to spend it on whatever he wanted. And if he wants to pay me to support exchange for 24 people, then I will support exchange for 24 people. I remote in 2-3 times a week to check on Exchange, and collect my monthly check with a smile.

by edmicman1

Thanks all for the suggestions! I've looked at Zimbra a bit, but also wonder what the future holds with MS talking to Yahoo, etc. I've checked out Scalix, too, and it's feature set looked impressive, too. Although, in the back of my mind I keep thinking that if I'm going to pay for software at all, we might as well pay for the Exchange tax anyway.

We've got about 20-30 users for email, so that's an interesting point that Exchange might be overkill. We do have access to the server software, but I wasn't aware that Outlook 2007 licenses didn't come with it. Plus, like I mentioned, we already have software that would run a linux install; we'd have to definitely get new 64-bit hardware to go Exchange 2007. Ah well....I'll mull things over a bit more....thanks for all of the ideas!

This discussion is closed to new replies.