Discussion Locked

Ubuntu laptop can't run off battery

0 helpful
17 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a Compaq Armada M300 laptop running Ubuntu Linux 5.10, and I can't get it to run off the battery. The battery indicator always reads full, but I can't boot without the AC cord plugged in, and if I remove the cord while the laptop is running, the machine dies.

Wait, it gets weirder. The first time I plugged in my Cisco Wireless PCMCIA card--before I set up any of its configuration or drivers--the battery indicator reset to zero, and slowly recharged over the next 90 minutes. The system still couldn't run off the battery, but it clued me in that perhaps something rather serious was wrong.

I had a troubled install of Ubuntu on this machine--video driver issues that had me doing parts of it without benefit of the screen--so I really don't know if I screwed something up in the software, or if my hardware has gone bad. It could be I've knotted up the APCI somehow, or that my battery is just plain toast.

How do narrow down the cause of my woes as hardware vs. software, and if it is software, how do I solve the issue?

17 replies

by jdclyde

My guess would be the battery is toast. It isn't holding the charge. Do you know anyone with a similar system so you can swap batteries for a few minutes to test that?

Did it work fine before the Ubuntu install? (the battery)
What was on it before the Ubuntu?

If it is hardware, this will tell you right off. If Software, it is out of my realm.

by jdclyde

If a battery is left uncharged for any length of time, that will kill it real quick.

You had the rest phase out and didn't grab them for spare parts? We have had several of our old Ax Thinkpads die, and I snag them up ASAP! So if my A20m does have issues, I have the parts to get it going again. woo woo!

If you take it to a battery place, I bet they could test it and tell you right off! [i](not tell you off, tell you if the battery is bad!)

by Jay Garmon

I don't know if the battery worked before Ubuntu. I know it was dead under WinXP, and that I left it plugged in for days while I fiddled with the install. I didn't notice the problem until I was past the install process.

Also, this is the last of this model in the building, so I don't have a handy swap-out. Still, my gut says hardware problem.

by hal 9000

The first thing that I noticed when I installed Ubuntu last week was that there was no option for NB's so Jay this probably isn't the ideal Distro for a NB to start off with.

According to the Debian Discussion site Ubuntu isn't supported for NB installation and lacks quite a few of the extras that are useful for a NB like the ability to control the System Fans and the like.

But in this case with your description I would be looking at the first as a possible cause for this problem. The giveaway here is when you plugged in a PCMCIA card that the Battery power dropped to 0% and then recharged over a period of time would tend to point to a less than perfect battery.

Col

by hal 9000

I tried Ubuntu on my NB earlier today and while it installed OK and picked up most of the installed Items it did have a problem with the Wireless network connection, but it did run perfectly otherwise.

I would be looking at the Battery Pack as the possible problem here as if the Battery is OK it should run off the Battery without needing a mains connection this is something that is hardware related and not Software Related.

Col

by samthetrue

i dont know much about linux but what i was told when it doesnt work was:
make sure that it is pluged in all the way
reinstall driver
check if there is a manger for that device and if so check if it says error... if not check if there is suposto be one
check if there is a update for the product from the website (if any)

i dont suspect any of these will work if you havent seen anything telling you to do any of this but thats my 2 cents worth

by sleepin'dawg

If I'm not mistaken, your fossil is using a nickle cadmium (NiCad) battery and due to lax recharging procedures it has taken a "memory" set. With NiCads you have to discharge them until you have barely 10 - 15% left on the battery before recharging.
If you have recharged after only a few minutes of usage the battery has acquired a memory and while it will indicate a full charge it will crap out after the similar usage it was submitted to prior to the previous recharge.
It has been claimed, that if you haven't waited too long, you can try knocking the battery flat and then submitting it to a recharge of perhaps 24 hours. It sometimes works but you will never regain the total capacity it originally had; perhaps only two thirds or a half. Frankly, I think its done.
Other solutions might include sending it to Compaq/HP to have the battery rebuilt using fresh cells but the drawbacks will be time and cost.
The first that comes to mind, is how handy are you with a soldering iron. Find an electronics supplier who can supply you with the equivalent Nickle Metalhydride cells of a compatable shape, voltage and amperage; crack open your existing battery, trash the NiCads and reassemble using the NiMh cells. You will have acquired a power source that will probably give you more than 25% greater battery life and won't be as fussy about recharging schedules. You will be able to recharge at will whether after twenty minutes usage or two hours of use; it won't matter very much but one note of caution, never let the battery lie around while it is or until it is, absolutely dead.
You will have a problem locating the proper cells, especially if you wish to go with the original battery case. This is more a matter of cosmetics. If cosmetics aren't crucial and they probably aren't with this antique, then there are other solutions available, ugly as sin but can yield almost tiple or more battery life. As I said it won't be pretty it will weigh almost as much as the laptop itself b

by sleepin'dawg

You could try adapting a 12 Volt motorcycle battery as a power source. It can be done but as I say it won't be pretty. It will however, yield extraordinary battery life. Up to ten hours with the right battery, a small one not Harley size. Get a gel battery; they won't leak, while lead acid ones do.

Also, make sure all the contacts on the laptop and the existing battery are clean.

by sleepin'dawg

There is one feature lacking in Ubuntu and that is power management for laptops but while this means it's contraindicated for laptops it should still take more time to flatten a healthy battery than the times you mentioned.

by mjd420nova

The Compaq units have the battery recharging
circuitry on a small board that plugs into
the main board near the back plugins. This
board has a small pico fuse soldered to it,
check the current rating and if your handy
with the soldering iron, replace it. Then
either locate a replacement battery or
replace the cells in the pack you have.

DO NOT Place the old battery back into the
unit and try to charge it, that's what blew
the fuse in the first place.

This discussion is closed to new replies.