Discussion Locked

VMWARE? A can of worms?

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hey guys,

I am considering consolodating our small office server environment with VMWARE they have 4 big ol towers, and it just seems like it can be stream lines. Let me know your experiences with VMWARe.

and contact me if you want to collaborate and have some fun on some testing. I always find it best when you are working with other people.

8 replies

by charliespencer

Go to VMware's web site. You can download their VMware server product for free. This will allow you to get familiar with virtual machine operations on a desktop. Then you can apply for a trial license of their product that will allow you to create virtual versions of existing physical machines. (This product used to be called P2V, but they've renamed it and I can't remember the name this morning.) You don't have to worry about server OS licenses, assuming you've already got licenses for your existing physical servers.

by charliespencer

That's a good question, and one I can't answer. I admit my initial response was tainted by my corporate experience. We buy our servers without an OS since we've got an Enterprise license agreement.

If he uses the physical to virtual migration tool, then removes the OS from the physical boxes, he should be covered legally. If he plans on building the virtual machines from scratch, I'm sure he'll be covered legally if he attempts to use an OEM license number, but there's the question of if the installation process will accept it.

Of course, we're assuming a proprietary licensed server OS. For all we know, it's an open licensed OS and a moot point :-)

EDITED - Hey, jscogin, you've got a penguin avatar. Are we talking about migrating Linux servers? If so, VMware is still an option, but the licensing issue may be different. I've been looking at it from a Microsoft viewpoint. If it's Linux, someone else will have to chime in on the licensing issues, if any.

by genera-nation

I'm sure I have come across a few in my time. Normally bought for the SME market who don't need the huge corporate license.

by jscogin

And i do lovethe look and feel of Linux but I utilize the MS products in 95 percent of my networking work.

Back to VMWARE... I am curious to some of the security issues, that have bee faced with VMWARE, from what I am reading the VMWARE structure opens up another arena of security threats admins need to be aware of.

Also, patches? Are patches applied to ESX server? is ESX server an OS? How does that work?

Hey guys, I am a lonily sysadmin looking for friends in the industry lol IF any of you want to share contacts, and maybe build a repor to bounce stuff off of eachother let me know!

Lets keep it going.

by rdejean

We've been running ESX for almost a year now and it's great. I have 12 (low utilization) guests on my ESX box and only at about 50% utilization.

There are some security issues in that if your ESX server is compromised, all of your systems are potentially compromised. This hasn't been an issue though, i've found ESX to be pretty secure. Yes there are patches that come out for ESX, but i've found it to be so rock solid and secure, that i haven't need to apply any patches yet.

Yes ESX is it's own OS. It is actually a heavily modified version of Redhat Linux. But it needs its own machine. Another thing to consider is redundancy. If you have all 4 of your servers on one physical machine, and the motherboard blows, then you lose all your servers instead of just one. With that in mind your server should be redundant as possible. RAID drives, dual power supplies, etc. Also if you can afford it, (though it gets pricey haha), consider a second ESX server.

by jscogin

I want to have a second ESX server and my main objective would be to provide fail safe redundancy in case one machine failed. Have you ever used ESX in this manner???

May i ask the speciifications of your server as well, to support 12 guests I assume many.

So in a nut shell my questions are:

0. What are the specs of your server? Any advice for supporting 4 low utilization guests?
1. How difficult was it to setup ESX?
2. What in your oppinion is the best method to transfer images from your old servers to ESX?
3. Have you setup redundancy? And how effective is the fail safe? (what happens when one box crashes, does other one take over no problems?)
4. I am looking for a tech partner/ friend/ fellow nerd, to collaborate with on test projects, and expanding skills, let me know if interested and if i can email you.

Thanks! i await responses.

by charliespencer

1) It isn't difficult if you understand the concepts and can keep straight on which system you're working on (VMware Host OS vs. Guest OS 1 vs. Guest OS 2 vs. Guest OS n). Hit VMware's web site and register for the ESX 30-day trial download. Or just pull down the free VMware Server tool and play with it. It's excellent for learning the basic concepts of virtualization.

2) I've worked with VMware's old P2V tool. It installed on a third system (I used a Windows XP desktop) to manage the transfer of the physical server to a virtual guest. While some felt it was an unreliable tool, I didn't have anything that I could handle in a couple of minutes. However, P2V has been replaced with a tool that is said to be far more reliable. I don't recall the name of the new product, but again, it's described on VMware's site.

3) One of the features of ESX is it allows you to make backup copies of the virtual machines. You can store the backups on tape or other medium. This is great for DR because with ESX you don't care what system hardware is used. Along as the system is capable of running ESX, you don't care about brand, mobo, processor, storage type. The specs don't even have to be exact matches of the original host. Load ESX and then restore the virtual machine backups and you're good to go. We have two sites separated by several states, so we store backups for each site at the other location.

This discussion is closed to new replies.