Discussion Locked

Wardriving - Legal or not?

0 helpful
557 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 6 of the discussion. Read the opening post

557 replies

by oregonnative

I do agree with your point about asking a business. Your personal integrity, after all, should be held to the highest of standards in my opinion. To continue a healthy dabate though...

Sticking with the water fountain idea, there are lots of folks that provide it as a free service. Same with restrooms. If I am in an office building and see a room labelled "Men", then I will feel free to use that room (for it's proper purpose, of course!). If however, the door is locked, it tells me that the room was not intended for public use.

In the same way, locks on bathrooms in private homes communicate something different. There is, among courteous people, no assumption that anyone can use the room and the lock on the door merely means the room is in use.

What I really have a problem with is the harsh condemnations coming from the participants on this board. I don't believe that most people are morons and I don't believe that every situation is alike. IT people are just as dishonest as anyone else; where do we get off with all these harsh words for everyone else.

Anyway, wojnar, you make a solid point that making assumptions about open wireless connections is wrong. It is always best to ask.

by santulli

If he has his own equipment why is he stealing someone else's

Maybe you should have thought out your reply before you became incoherent.
People like you are the reason we have such a low moral level of young people in America today. You use twisted logic to justfy bending or breaking moral and legal laws. If it's not your don't take it. Can I be more clearer?

by fain

OregonNative--
Your comments, logic and compariative analysis to the original topic is very interesting. If it won't offend you, for whom are you the IT manager? I want to check my portfolio and see if I have any stock in the company with whom you have influence.

by csr-tech

He is not stealing "equipment". He is using his wireless equipment to connect to someone else's wireless access point so he can access the Internet in order to check his email when he is away from his home or office. Obviously, if he was at his home or office, he would not need to connect to someone else's network, he would use his own. It's no different then using your own laptop computer and wireless network card to connect to a hotel's wireless network to connect to the Internet when you are staying at the hotel (away from our home or office). If you can't comprehend the physical aspects of this discussion, how can you participate in the legal or moral aspects of this discussion? It's obvious from your comments, that you can't.

by santulli

Normally intelligent people would know that using the phrase equipment in this instance would be a blanket statement for hardware, software and service. Let me take you down to the simplest explanation since you do not have the capacity to comprehend the terminology. If this thief does not have access to his own ?Equipment? (his router, modem) and is using someone else?s then he is stealing someone else?s ?Equipment? (router and modem) to access the Internet to get to his ISP. As far as using a hotel?s WiFi, again I?ll say this slowly so you might comprehend. THE HOTEL IS GIVING HIM PERMISSIONS, HIS VICTIM IN NOT!!! Also, and this may come as a complete surprise to you, there are lots of WiFi hot spots you can go to for access. But this would require some sort of payment, hence my original statement ?Stop being so cheap you loser and buy your own WiFi ?Equipment?! So know we know comprehension is not YOUR strong suit and by supporting this creep you obviously do not comprehend the meaning of legal and moral aspects either

by csr-tech

"Normally intelligent people would know that using the phrase equipment in this instance would be a blanket statement for hardware, software and service". No, I don't think any reasonable person would lump a service under the category of "equipment". As a matter of fact, most technical people are very specific when speaking about their area of expertise. That's why people who are not familiar with the "technical jargon" of a specific industry, may have trouble comprehending what is being discussed. As Uncle Rob said "if you want to be more clear, speak more clearly". Your confusing the wireless service by calling it "equipment" made it look like you did not even understand the issue being discussed. As I tried to point out to you, if you don't understand the issue being discusssed, how can you comment on it? My point about free wireless services being no different than private owner's WAPs was that the physical equipment and connection was no different. It was not a comment on whether it was right or wrong. Now you may understand the issue originally presented, but your rants about today's youth and low morals, etc., do not address the original issue, but certainly reveal your tiny, hateful, character.

by matthew yurksaitis

Very good point on how TV started and while you have a good point there, the part that makes "stealing" cable illegal (there are other ways than a physical connection by the way) from a subscriber who pays, is that the "wardriver" or "stowaway" gaining access to this service by using an "access point" which involves pay for service from the consumer, and using this without the consumers "express knowledge & consent" is in essence using a paid service at the expense of the consumer - thereby resulting in "financial loss" on the part of the consumer. If you were to gain access to a consumers cable signal (physical or otherwise) and your activity detected was illegal - then the consumer with the actual connection would be the first suspect in a potential criminal act they did not committ and even had no knowledge of. So as you can see the harm done is the fact that the cosumer is bieng cheated of the money provided for a level and quality of service they expect, and those service levels may be affected by the "wardriver" and the consumer is the looser. As one can also see this really croses a number of legal aspects i.e. right to privacy, legal prosecution for crimes etc.. So while one may attempt to justify "wardriving" by claiming "hey the air is free, and they left the window open - so I entered thier house to breathe thier free air" does not stand well as a legal argument. The point is that the consumer is harmed in these situations especially when the act is performed by a person who is expected to have sufficient knowledge of the technology and it's legal uses & restrictions. Just as the FCC has regulations on Radio & TV signals which make various aspects of broadcasting illegal & prosecutable criminal regulations on the use of the internet for fraudulent and other criminal activity is also enforceable. So what if the "wardriver" committs internet fraud using the "free access point" of a paying consumer - who will be investigated and held accountable? The Consumer, not the "wardriver", yet another instance of harm to the consumer.

by silversidhe

As I was perusing this topic and the replies I kept thinking "do these people ever poke thier heads out into the real world?" "are these the same idiots who screw up software with those backwards and screwy instructions?". Let me give you all a few real world examples -
1. My friend in Nashville uses both unsecured and secured wifi. She doesn't even know who belongs to some of the unsecured ones her card hooks her up to. Knowing alot of computer illiterates who do alot of stupid things I think it is a mistake to assume they don't know that thier wifi can or should be secured - the ones I know who don't secure don't care. It is like having a fruit tree close or leaning over your property line and not caring if someone helps themselves as long as they don't damage the tree or make a mess. I think she feels that this is pretty much what is going on as well. Of course if any of her neighbors has a computer problem they usually weasel her into fixing it. Lets not go into the friends and family who avail themselves of her "services" as well. I almost forgot to mention that she is inside her home - not in thier yard or on the street. I wonder sometimes if all these signals might be linked to some health threats down the line.
2. My student friend from Oregon who was visiting me got upset because she couldn't access anyone with her wifi card from my house. Apparently it is not a problem where she lives and since she got her new laptop hasn't ever been unable to connect. I think she got a rude awakening when she ended up with malware but not enough to take time out of her busy schedule to learn more about computers and security. My attitude that wireles means no security didn't seem particuraly helpful to her.
3. I have a homeless friend who will hook up where he can but right now he can't - he also ended up with a crashed computer.
4> I forgot to mention that friend #1 has also ended up with malware.
The people I know who won't secure are usually capable but uninterested - If thier ISP wants to control usage then that is up to them - maybe something like boxes. I find that when something is a problem you do something about it if it's important enough and ignore it if it isn't. This is definately in the "who gives a ****" category for most of the world.

by wojnar

I don't believe anybody here is saying you can't leave your connection open if you choose. The point is that you personally do not know if the connection you are linked to is intended for your use. Lets take your issues in a different way.

If your friend from Nashville did NOT want others connecting to the access point, do you have the right to connect to it anyway ? Most (and I have to admit the owners of all 8 access points I have installed) never read the directions and never know they could limit connectivity. They also were not aware that they could be providing access to their own systems and/or networks by hanging an access point off their computer. Is their ignorance license to steal from them ? I could be wrong, but I don't see anybody who is responding to this forum as being suprised to find out they could connect to unsecured access points. The question is: because I have this 'knowledge' should I take advantage of other people's property ? There are enough WiFi hotspots in major cities that nobody should have to resort to stealing.

As a consultant, I have opportunity to connect to many business networks. All but 1 of these companies do not allow my notebook to connect because of their security practices. If I happen to find an unsecured access point in their network, I can't assume they WANT me to connect. In one case an upper level administrator installed a wireless router in his office because he wanted to use a notebook and be able to move from desk to conference table without a wire. He never read how to secure it. I can't assume that the company wants me to connect to his unsecured access point because they were not aware of his stupidity. I have to assume the same of any prvate individual - unless specifically stated by THEM - I am not granted specific access to their internet service.

by daveo2000

You mention that "the owners of all 8 access points I have installed never read the directions and never know they could limit connectivity". Did you educate them on this matter?

by santulli

You are so right it?s scary. Just look at the size of the response to a simple question of right and wrong. What kind of people (who call them selves Americans) will go so far to justify stealing a fellow Americans band width by saying "you've made a mistake and now I have the right to take advantage of you"? To add insult to injury they use the absence of a law to help them steal. Do we have to wait for a law to be passed to stop us from taking what is not ours? Are they saying the lawmakers determine and solve all ethical questions? Year right! Whatever happened to common decency? WiFi hotspots are everywhere but because these thieves will have to pay for them they justify stealing. How about the victims, what about the degradation of their internet connection and the loss of service that they paid for? It all comes down to a simple statement, "if its not yours don?t take it".

by unclerob

"3. I have a homeless friend who will hook up where he can but right now he can't - he also ended up with a crashed computer."

- If he's homeless where does he setup his 'puter in the first place, let alone find power for it, have cash to throw a wireless nic inside of it so that he can surf the net on someone else's wireless connection.

I think his computer crashing is the least of his concerns, plus if he's your friend why don't you let him stay with you. It's christmas for pete's sake.

- By the way,
Merry Christmas & All the best in 2006 from all the "geeks who crack you up"

Man that's nucking futs, you are such a nerf!

by csr-tech

Your point "So what if the "wardriver" committs (sic)internet fraud using the "free access point" of a paying consumer" is not in line with the original post and points of the discussion: "And I am not talking about some clown that is hacking, or sucking up massive amounts of bandwidth so please don't waste anyones time with that angle." We are talking about connecting for a short period to check your email etc. when you are away from your home or office connections.

by matthew yurksaitis

Sorry about straying a bit there, but now back to my original point. Back to Business Law 101. One of the basic definitions of a crime is when "financial, character or personal loss or harm occurs to a person or persons" - of course this is a very high level definition, but for the purposes of this discussion I believe it should suffice.

In essence using an open access point w/o the consumers express knowledge and consent is the same as using thier service which they pay for - free on your part. In essence stealing from the consumer as they incurr financial loss as the wardriver does not seek to reimburse them, assuming either "stupidty or ignorance" of the consumer as a license not to pay them for something rightfully owed them, even if the use is only brief and for "legitimate purposes".

Here's an example of how harm/loss above financial could easily occur when "stowing away" on someone else's connection for "legitimate purposes". The wardriver checks their email, opens an attachment and activates/propigates a virus or worm on the consumers connection, this in turn infects the consumers computers and results in ISP shutdown of thier connection until the problem is resolved. While the wardrivers intentions for "legitimate purposes" the end result is financial and possible character harm to the consumer - for actions that were not there own.

What this really boils down to is what the definition of a crime is to make it prosecuteable, as well as the intent with knowledge to determine the severity of the crime. The mode/method used to committ a crime is part of the issue, but not the core of it and the intentional free use of a service a person pays for using WAP breaks out as follows: using a paid service which someone else pays for is the crime, the "Access point" is merely the mode or method. (Modus Operandi).

There are a number of public laws regarding "unauthorized access" to computer systems etc.. as well as a number of prosecutions in various states. Check out the FBI's internet fraud site as well as Federal and State prosecutions.

For the beneift of the readers "unauthorized access" means that you do not have express consent and authorization from the appropriate authority to access or use the computer systems or devices.

In this case the appropriate authority is the WAP device owner as they own thier computers, thier network (in thier house) and pay for thier connection service for thier network.

In regard to the "open radio waves" - if one merely accidentally received some of the consumers network traffic due to the device bieng improperly secured, the argument bieng presented in this thread may hold to be not prosecuteable. However; the difference between accidental and recieving and the issue bieng discussed is "intent" and intentional use for transmission and reciept with full knowledge that the wardriver is not paying for the service, and someone else is - in essence using other peoples money for personal use/gain. If the WAP network had a disclaimer stating that it was freely available for everyones use - use at your own risk - then there would be no issue, but unless the wardriver sees that message on thier computer when accessing the net, then the assumption lies in favor of the consumer - that they would want the security features and functions of the WAP and would not be freely providing this service to all w/o thier knowledge.

by matthew yurksaitis

Here is the text of computer security crimes used in a few different states as well as in federal law.

Sec. 53a-251. Computer crime.

(a) Defined. A person commits computer crime when he violates
any of the provisions of this section.

(b) Unauthorized access to a computer system. (1) A person is
guilty of the computer crime of unauthorized access to a computer
system when, knowing that he is not authorized to do so, he
accesses or causes to be accessed any computer system without
authorization.

(2) It shall be an affirmative defense to a prosecution for
unauthorized access to a computer system that: (A) The person
reasonably believed that the owner of the computer system, or a
person empowered to license access thereto, had authorized him to
access; (B) the person reasonably believed that the owner of the
computer system, or a person empowered to license access thereto,
would have authorized him to access without payment of any
consideration; or (C) the person reasonably could not have known
that his access was unauthorized.
(c) Theft of computer services. A person is guilty of the
computer crime of theft of computer services when he accesses or
causes to be accessed or otherwise uses or causes to be used a
computer system with the intent to obtain unauthorized computer
services.

(d) Interruption of computer services. A person is guilty of
the computer crime of interruption of computer services when he,
without authorization, intentionally or recklessly disrupts or
degrades or causes the disruption or degradation of computer
services or denies or causes the denial of computer services to an
authorized user of a computer system.

(e) Misuse of computer system information. A person is guilty
of the computer crime of misuse of computer system information
when: (1) As a result of his accessing or causing to be accessed a
computer system, he intentionally makes or causes to be made an
unauthorized display, use, disclosure or copy, in any form, of data
residing in, communicated by or produced by a computer system; or
(2) he intentionally or recklessly and without authorization (A)
alters, deletes, tampers with, damages, destroys or takes data
intended for use by a computer system, whether residing within or
external to a computer system, or (B) intercepts or adds data to
data residing within a computer system; or (3) he knowingly
receives or retains data obtained in violation of subdivision (1)
or (2) of this subsection; or (4) he uses or discloses any data he
knows or believes was obtained in violation of subdivision (1) or
(2) of this subsection.
(f) Destruction of computer equipment. A person is guilty of
the computer crime of destruction of computer equipment when he,
without authorization, intentionally or recklessly tampers with,
takes, transfers, conceals, alters, damages or destroys any
equipment used in a computer system or intentionally or recklessly
causes any of the foregoing to occur.

So as you can see there is both legal definition and precedent to support the fact that wardriving in the terms of unauthorized access to computer systems is a crime both at the state & federal level. Simply put, while a particular state may not have current legislation there is legal precendent to be found at the federal and state levels. Simply stated wardriving in terms of accessing the net for personal use is a crime.

by evolving opinion - ask me tomorrow

jdclyde you sure have hit a nerve!

Couldn't you pick something less complicated such as which is better Macs vs. PCs or Linux vs. Windows? All kidding aside, you prompted me to do some research and I found more than I could believe.

YES, it is illegal to use or access a WAP, with provisos:

1)Everything is legal (138 of 509) until you get caught. I.E. play nice and keep your head down

2)The Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (?CFAA?) makes
punishable whoever ?intentionally accesses a computer without authorization or exceeds authorized access and thereby obtains ? . . .
information from any protected computer if the conduct involves interstate or foreign communication. Another section of the CFAA
makes punishable whoever ?intentionally accesses a protected computer without authorization, and, as a result of such conduct, recklessly causes damage.? In the context of accessing a neighbor?s WLAN, liability with respect to both of the previously listed sections depends first on
establishing intentional access without authorization. ?Access? refers to the intent to access, not the intent to damage the protected
computer. The user interface on Wi-Fi equipped devices typically lists detectable access points automatically by a name the Wireless Access Point (?WAP?) owner designates. In a residential area, the WAP name may refer to a neighbor?s last name, such as in ?Jones Family Access Point.? The act of choosing an access point in this context could provide evidence of intentional access. The CFAA does not define ?without authorization? or what it
means to exceed authorization. Under CFAA case law, establishing unauthorized access or lack of authorization has involved reference to the means of access or its purpose. Courts have also found
unauthorized access through a ?Terms of Service? violation, even where the defendant did not receive notice of the terms. In EF Cultural Travel v. Zefer, involving a defendant who used a scraper tool to extract data from a competitor?s
website in order to underbid projects, the court also recognized that a lack of authorization could exist implicitly, rather than explicitly in
the form of a statement. For example, the court noted that ?password protection itself normally limits authorization by implication (and technology), even without express terms.? Of
particular relevance to the Wi-Fi context, the court found an implicit lack of authorization, rejecting the view that there exists a
?presumption? of open access to the Internet.

3)With regard to finding unauthorized access through a ?Terms of Service? violation, the AOL cases cited above provide precedent for
enforcing such terms on third parties with no privity of contract and no notice of the terms. Internet Service Provider (?ISP?) ?Terms of
Service? typically prohibit many different types of activities, including Internet access by those outside the subscriber?s household or business. Although the term applies directly to the customer
paying for the service, and not a third-party end user (or ?Wi-Fi interloper?), under the rationale of the AOL case cited above, violation of such terms by non-members can amount to unauthorized
access for the purposes of the CFAA.

4)Section 1030(a)(2) raises the issue of whether the unauthorized access involves obtaining information. Although Congress intended the CFAA to apply to theft-related acts, some courts have
interpreted information obtained as ?the showing of some additional end?to which the unauthorized access is a means. In this regard, access to any WLAN involves some exchange of information that
typically passes between computers (IP address, data packets, etc.) as a means of gaining access to the Internet. Since the statute does not specify exactly what information the end user must obtain, the end user who accesses a neighbor?s WLAN has potentially committed a
misdemeanor violation of section 1030(a)(2), which could then rise to the level of a felony if the acts involved commercial advantage or private financial gain.

KEY POINT HERE:
Criminalization of Wi-Fi interloping under section 1030(a)(2), wherein someone merely uses another?s WLAN to check e-mail or to perform other common, relatively unobtrusive acts, seems unlikely.

5)section 1030(a)(5)(A)(ii), concerns whether the unauthorized access ?recklessly causes damage.? The statute defines ?damage? as ?any impairment to the integrity or availability of data, a program, a system, or information.? Courts
have held that prohibited conduct under the CFAA that causes slowdowns and diminished capacity of computers, thereby impairing the availability of the system, also constitutes ?damage? under the
statute.

6)Although prosecutors have tended to use the CFAA solely to punish theft-related acts involving computers, the proliferating use of
Wi-Fi could change this, or provoke related activity at the state level or under federal wiretap laws, such as the Electronic Communications Privacy Act. The Electronic Communications Privacy Act (?ECPA?), also
known as the ?Wire Tap Law,? holds that ?[it shall not be unlawful] for other users of the same frequency to intercept any radio
communication made through a system that utilizes frequencies monitored by individuals engaged in the provision or the use of such system, if such communication is not scrambled or encrypted.?
Prosecutors have used the law to target certain acts of wireless interceptions and signal theft. The ECPA also imposes federal penalties, both criminal and civil, on anyone who ?intentionally
intercepts, endeavors to intercept, or procures any other person to intercept or endeavor to intercept, any wire, oral, or electronic
communication.? Violations of the ECPA involve five key elements. An individual must: (1) intentionally (2) intercept, endeavor to intercept, or procure another person to intercept (3) the contents of (4) an electronic communication (5) using a device. As with the CFAA, a court could apply these elements to the context of unauthorized Wi-Fi access quite easily.
As with the CFAA, prosecutors tend to focus application of the ECPA to specific intent crimes, such as accessing another?s WAP for the
purpose of eavesdropping, rather than simply using another?s bandwidth.

7)Wi-Fi also, through its very nature, potentially
implicates radio spectrum issues through its use of the unlicensed 2.4 and 5 GHz radio bands, as well as broadband regulatory schemes and antitrust issues through the fact that WLANs typically expand the use of a product that Internet Service Providers supply to customers
on a contractually limited basis. A practical advantage may lie in using the common law tort of
trespass to chattels to impose liability for unauthorized use of Wi-Fi, rather than statutes such as the CFAA, which Congress intended
primarily for punishment of theft-related acts.

8)beyond the Federal laws discussed above, that other Internet uses can trigger criminal sanctions under other laws, among them, Federal laws such as the Copyright Act, the National Stolen Property Act, mail and wire fraud statutes, the Communications Decency Act of 1996, the Child Pornography Prevention Act of 1996, and the U.S.A Patriot Act of 2001. Assorted state laws show a corresponding sensitivity to the wide variety of criminal acts perpetrated on the Internet.

9)Under California law, an action for trespass to chattels arises when an intentional interference with the possession of personal property causes injury. Courts have found the basic elements of
trespass to chattels (with the exception of damages) satisfied in many different types of unauthorized computer access cases. Nonetheless, the court offered relevant examples of what has constituted damages in other cases involving unauthorized computer access, including
overburdening or interference with the efficient functioning of computer systems and threatened harm in the potential for others to imitate the defendant?s activity.

10)POSITIVE NOTE:
Among the several defenses to trespass to chattels, apparent consent appears most likely to arise given current trends in the
implementation of Wi-Fi, particularly with regard to private residences. Under the Restatement, ?[i]f words or conduct are reasonably understood by another to be intended as consent, they
constitute apparent consent and are as effective as consent in fact.? Lack of log-in procedures, encryption, or other forms of security may
create a privilege in the would-be trespasser of apparent consent to use another?s Wi-Fi network.

Conclusion:
Turns out, unsurprisingly, that you're unlikely to be prosecuted or successfully sued for just checking your email via someone's open WiFi access point, but if you use up all their bandwidth, or use it to do naughty things, or do it professionally, the risks go up.

All the above comes from these sites:

http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2005/04/wifi_liabilitie.html

http://life.firelace.com/archives/wireless/wifi/index.php#000582

http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=692881

http://www.oreilly.com/catalog/macxunwire/chapter/ch04.pdf

http://www.tispa.org/Members/documents/surviving.asp

Read all those documents above for legal ideology.

Now you mentioned in your first post about morals ON ethics, but I would say MORALS & ETHICS, and that leads to these thoughts:

Why not help them out? (6 of 508)

I have always been one to think that people should be accountable for their [own] actions. Whether or not this is legal? Doesn't look like it's illegal to me. But since jdclyde did use their bandwidth and it helped him in his time of need, why can't he contact these people and tell them of their potential for a hacker to have a field day and give them a few tips on how to secure their network? If they decide to leave it open after that is their choice.
Posted by: smee63 Date: 12/23/05

Q> What is my obligation/responsibility to police/offer free/paid services to these people?

A> Legally none/none/none. Ethically/Morally to make the world a better place.

p.s. smee63, Thanks for asking the question.

One point that is missed here is that the isn't... (11 of 508)

One point that is missed here is that the isn't whether you are stealing, but from whom. If your neighbor were selling access, his ISP would have an issue with it. In the case above, you are still stealing from the ISP. The neighbor does not have the right to disseminate "his" access unless the ISP specifically allows it. Most specifically deny it. Just because you are not stealing from the neighbor, does not mean that you are not stealing. I use a rule that I call the "5 year old" rule. As you may or may not know, 5 year olds are very "black & white" and they keep asking until they understand. So the rule is this: if you can't explain why it is OK in terms that a 5 year old can understand, it probably isn't OK. For example, if you can't explain the why it is OK to illegally copy music and not OK to take a CD from the store, you shouldn't do either. Both are stealing in a very real sense and any 5 year old would understand that. And keep asking "Why?" until you finally give up. If you can't explain why it is OK to grab a signal out of the air and use it (either a little or a lot) and not OK to dial into an ISP (or tap into their bandwidth some other way), then it probably isn't OK. This 5 year old rule usually really clears up ethical issues.
Posted by: Zig Zag Date: 12/15/05

A> It is not stealing from the ISP. The owner of the WAP has PAID for the services (limitcap-unlimited bandwidth / limitcap-unlimited access i.e. 10GB throughput or 20 hours access monthly) and except the EULA, which is a tiered package of acceptable uses for a price, the home-user is generally prohibited from reselling access/bandwidth, but not from allowing others to use his account, typically his in-home family/friends. This does not mean that the ISP does not monitor bandwidth for excessive over-use and determine what the traffic is and whether the home-user needs to upgrade their account to support the bandwidth-usage if it is not typical home-traffic, but is income/business oriented. The home-user is typically not held liable for unknown access to his WAP, unless found negligent, and/or illegal activities, but that may/is changing.

p.s. Zig Zag, Thank you for your post & 5 year old rule. Children are great rationale breakers.

Two thoughts: How would you feel... and
If it feels wrong or unethical, it probably is.

I have posted more than my share.

Thanks for reading
SK

by winmail.network

How is it stealing if the ISP still retains ownership and full use of their internet connection? By definition, in order for theft to take place, the theif must obtain and the victim must be without.

It would be theft if you broke into the ISP and stole their routers. In that case, you would be in physical possession of an item that they no longer have posession of.

Theft = I used to have but no longer have because someone took it from me and now they have.

Hijacking is called hijacking and not car theft as long as the hijacker does not take posession of the car and leave the driver siting on a curb. If, in the end, the car jacker gets out and runs away but is caught later, they are charged with car jacking and not car theft.

I don't believe that it can even be considered wireless jacking because you're not forcing the owner of the access point to surf along with you.

You simply tune into radio waves that are in the air just like any other radio station. If that radio station gives no indication that it is restricted to certain users, they can not go after you for tuning in. That would be crazy!

Likewise, if you broadcast your access point all over your neighborhood and don't make it clear by means of a password that nobody else should listen in or transmit on that frequency, you absolutely can not (ethicly) go after someone for taking part.

Your wireless signal travels far outside the boundries of your physical propery. It is unreasonable to put the burden of identifying the source upon the person outside your property rather than requiring you to simply close the door via a password.

There are far too many people willingly sharing 802.11 signals out there for free to expect the end users to do the leg work of identifying the source of the signals.

That's your responsibillity as a wireless access point owner. If you don't want them on there, lock the door!

by Former member

That is about the most pathetic response I have heard... well... ever.

Just because I presently live in Utah(no, I am not FROM Utah, not that it matters), I have a reduced IQ or something?

Any other groups you like to discriminate against? hispanics? chinese?

by unclerob

so while you're at it, add wops to that list as well and technically I'm canadian also so if you want, you can add them also.

By the way....
Merry Christmas and all the best in 2006

by winmail.network

I'm not sure that wireless access was properly addressed in the Torah. Maybe somewhere along the lines of God telling Joshua to tear down the walls of a city that didn't belong to him and kill everything that moved inside the walls, and then claim ownership of their land?

I think that if your God is OK with that, he'd be fine with me hopping on an open wireless router to get my email!

=D

by matthew yurksaitis

I concur wholeheartidly with the "Just plain false" post. To presume that a person has no right to buy or use anything that they are not proficient experts on is just wrong. If that were the case then would you have your car? or house? or any appliances? that part of your argument is really pointless. On the point of your network bieng secure so as to be impenatrable - you may want to really be sure of this. On the key point - you may want to check with your ISP on the terms of your service before you brag publically about this, you may be violating your ISP contract and subject to prosecution yourself. - Just some friendly advice.

by wojnar

Legal precedent has established that the act of putting something in the trash and leaving it for collection implicitly forgoes ownership. Thats why cops do not need a warrent to search a person's garbage. I could probably site a court case but hey - all those tv cop shows couldn't be wrong could they. (they couldn't show it on tv if it wasn't true, right ?????)

by wojnar

Haven't you ever heard the phrase "ignorance of the law is no excuse" ? You can break a law without having a 'motive' and even without knowing its a law. Try telling a traffic court judge that you didn't know the speed limit was 45 when you were driving 90. You will see that it really doesn't matter that you are not aware of the law. Opportunity you got right - 1 out of 3 ain't too bad ...

Duress and insanity are the only 2 things that may make an action not punishable under the law. (but its still illegal)

by unclerob

You can be "more clearer" by being more clear when you speak.

I don't think people like anybody in this forum have anything to do with such a low moral level of young people in America today. Young people can thank their parents for their personal development & upbringing, don't pin that one on anyone else - Thank you very much.

Your own statements "use twisted logic" as you put it.

You can have a viewpoint if you want about the topic of this discussion but pinning the breakdown of moral fibre in American youth on this person's opinion just doesn't cut it. That's reckless, irresponsible and speaks volumes about the level of intelligence you presume to have.

Stealing is against the law. But like most other things that are illegal, unless the laws in place are clear enough, pronounced enough so that no one can claim ignorance and offer harsher penalties if those laws are broken, you will find that most people will continue to take advantage of other people and continue also to break laws because there aren't suitable deterrants in place to prevent this from happening. That is human nature and you can't blame that problem on anyone specific.

If you want the "moral level of young people in America today" and all people in America for that matter to improve, you need to begin with yourself - look in the mirror and see what you can do to improve - if you stand on the sidelines & do nothing, don't expect anything to change. Elect leaders with enough morality to spare, those that can set an exemplary standard and lead the way for others to follow. Be a good parent, be an active contributing member in your local community, be true to your faith in whatever religion you follow and lead the life that you think others should follow. If enough people do this, things might improve but until this happens don't expect anything to change, if fact you can definitely expect things to get worse.

My point is to be careful when posting the kind of reply that you did.

Let's hope 2006 is better than 2005.

- just my 0.02 cents cdn. ;-)

by alkema_p

In the case of simultaneous use the owner of the connection may experience slowdowns, and if the internet subscription has a data limit the wardriving = stealing, becaue there is loss.

by unclerob

he's probably you're neighbor if you're sitting in your own home and your equipment is detecting a strong enough signal that you can use, why not go over & knock on his door and in a polite neighborly type fashion ask if you can surf the net using his unsecured wireless access point. Explain to him that you mean no harm, wouldn't access his pc and would only be using his unsecured wireless access point to surf the net & check your email and that if it caused any disruption in his own service you would stop immediately.

If you're wardriving, then I don't know. I don't know how receptive a business is going to be in allowing you to use their unsecured wap even if you're honest about it and if you're not in you're own neighborhood, someone might think you to be strange and criminal like with a request of this nature.

If you're asking about an electronic means, I'm not sure. I'm sure there is probably a way but I've never investigated it. Technically if you're going to contact him electronically this would mean that you are in effect using his wireless access point to ride the signal back to his location & contact him and I would probably be freaked out if I got a mysterious msg from someone electronically, I'd probably think my system had got hacked into and would probably shut everything down hence the reason for enabling security in the first place.

You asked a good question, I'm afraid I don't have a great answer for you.

by daveo2000

As it turns out, just as in face to face meetings, there is a similar arrangement in electronic meetings. It is called a "handshake". Your wireless NIC locks onto the transmitted frequency from the wireless router (which is sitting there shouting to the world "I am available!") and says "can we talk?" The wireless router either replies "no problem" or "please provide me with some authentication that I can check against my records".
If the router has been properly configured using the instruction that it came with then it will do the latter. If the owner of the router couldn't be bothered with the instructions and is using the device ignorant of what s/he is doing then you will be given access.

The router can be looked at as the gatekeeper and the agent of the network owner. The router is completely capable of blocking most access if told to do so.

Since we are so deeply into analogies here why don't we use a building doorman when talking about breathing the free air? If I hire a doorman then I can reasonably expect that he knows how to open and close the door. If I don't bother checking to see if he speaks English and don't bother telling him that he should only admit certain people into the house (maybe his last gig was at a museum) then that is my bad. When somebody walks up to the door, rings the doorbell and says "Can I come in?" then what should he do? He was trained to open the door for people.

When your wireless NIC knocks on the wireless router's door and asks for permission to converse the router does what it was trained to do.

It seems that some of the more vehement folks here (can you say "santulli"?) are very quick to jump on the person asking the question. What if the question had been "I just bought a new wireless router and I don't want to bother reading how to set it up or paying somebody to set it up properly. Should I be held responsible for not abiding by my ISP's agreement?"

by wojnar

Not only did I inform them but I also stated that I would not support their systems/networks from a security standpoint unless the access points were set up in a secure way - no broadcast of SSID and full encryption. After explaining the risks, not even a single user asked me to leave the access open.

The users were suprised to say the least. Most never thought that anybody could connect without their knowing and assumed their connection was secure because they remembered putting in a password when they set up their connection. Most remembered setting up some security when they first got connected to a broadband source and assumed any body connecting would have to know their configuration (static ip address, subnet,...) to connect to their ISP.

Since I already am their first line of support, I feel its my responsibility to educate them as well as correct their problems.

Most users never read the information from the device manufacturer (or instructions that I left for them). Most times their response is the same - 'Average' users don't read what they think is going to go over their heads and don't want to see if they could understand. But that is no excuse to take advantage of the 'average' user.

by Member 33073540

I think this activity is basically the same as walking through your neighbor's yard to get to a friend's house. Most people could care less if someone walks across their lawn and if they do care, they'll put up a fence. Just as someone who really wants you off their wireless network will enable some sort of defense. The question is not so much one of just making the connection, but what you do with the connection. If you download illegal files, use up all available bandwidth, etc. that's a problem, but usage that causes no harm is not in itself wrong. I don't mind if a ramdom driver uses my driveway to turn around, but If he parks all day, that's a different story. It's not that someone should not use it, just a question of how...

by wojnar

...but do not walk through my yard without my permission. Since my home-owners association doesn't allow fences I can't keep you out that way but the absense of a recognized sign doesn't imply you have permission to my property unless you are granted specific rights by local law. That is the bottom line.

Most users don't even know they are being taken advantage of. You can't determine its ok for you to use somebody elses stuff. Only THEY can grant access. If the user doesn't know others can have access without permission and don't know (because they never read the access point info) they could restrict access, it is not ethical and - as numerous posts have shown - quite illegal to use their connection. This discussion isn't about if you think its ok for others to use YOUR link. The question is do you have the right to use what is not specifically identified as available to you ?

If I were to have you consult for me and gave you access to my network, does it mean your neighbor can come in with you to my business and use my network ? If you think its ok, I have a company that you can cross off your list of potential clients.

by matthew yurksaitis

While one could agree on the surface with the analogy you present except- generally nieghbors give verbal consent to the use of thier property in this manner so as to be neighborly. Generally, nieghbors wishing to cross properties also request permission from the property owner. Once the permission is given, usually it is implied from then on - unless the property owner states otherwise. The difference here is that the "wardriver" does not ask permission to "cross" the wireless connection but does it secretly, and further he then uses the "crossing route" to bring stuff back & forth (trafficking stuff across the route - if you will).

So while on the surface, if you as a friendly nieghbor have given consent to allow folks to cross your yard at least they asked, and you are bieng nieghborly. The wardriver does not ask, does not even given the owner the change to be nieghborly just assumes consent and does thier thing. This in short is the same as if someone started crossing your yard behind your back when you did not want them to - at that point it is tresspassing.

There is a way to contact the owner of the device and request permission and for the owner to either give or deny permission the wardriver however does not do this. Also there is a way for device owners to post a message of Unauthorized use or Authorized for Open Use. Unless the device owner specifies consent, the default of non-consent is presumed by law.

by matthew yurksaitis

I have posted a blog on this topic as it appears that quite a few posters are not aware a present state & federal laws on unathorized access & use of computers & networks.

by snap

Of course you should be able to use this kind of connection, as long as YOUR purpose is legal!
Just think of somebody setting up yard lighting for his own purpose, but it might also shine onto the footpath outside his property. Should we feel obliged to cross the street to the other footpath so as not to benefit from his floodlights?
Maybe we could turn the issue around - what if this neighbour's RF emissions disturb something in your property - can we then request that he shuts down his network?

by wojnar

Lets use a little common sense here. There are some major flaws in your statement:
1) you do not need special equipment to use the 'spilled light'
2) your neighbor is easily able to see the spilled light and could in fact limit its usage or 'spillage'. Your neighbor does not know how far his RF signal is able to be seen
3) your neighbor is not diminished by your use of the spilled light (doesn't matter how many people see it, the amount of available light does not decrease)
4) the light carries no additional use besides what is apparent - it is the end result of a process and does not serve to facilitate additional functionality outside of its visible characteristics. The RF siugnal is useless unless enclosed by other processes and has no real usage without specific hardware/software.
5) You are not stealing the RF signal (which would be analogous to seeing the light spillage) you are stealing the paid-for process that the RF signal plugs into.
6)When stealing the connection, you are making a knowledgable decision to place a required piece of equipment in a state where you have access to something that you know is not free and that you did not pay for.

Feel free to stop by my house and use all the RF coming from it. Touch my purchased service (ISP) and the law will take care of you.

by nconst

My quick two cents:
This is a familiar topic of discussion which comes up regularly with co-workers and friends.
My desktop in my home office is plugged in directly to my cable modem. Should I decide to work elsewhere in my house, I'll plug in the wireless router. (never bothered to set up any security to prevent unauthorized access). I unplug the wireless from the cable modem once I finish using the laptop. This may sound a little "Flintsone-ish" but it's a definite way to prevent anyone from tapping into my internet connection. PERIOD. My personal bottom line is that if someone taps into your wireless and begins to download illegal music/movies (even worse illegal porn)guess who the the "internet police" go after? The person who is paying for the connection.
If that's not enough to "lock the door" I don't know what is. So when not in use pull the plug!

by wojnar

So what you are saying is you don't want anybody to use your connection but you can't be bothered to secure it ???????

It may be me but I don't see any logic in what you are doing. If its not 100% secured it is NOT SECURED. Why gamble with security when with less than 5 minutes worth of effort you can be certain ?

by nconst

I could be wrong. But this is my logic. I am not an expert so I can only assume that with security enabled there could exist a remote possibility that some hacker today or in the future could hack into my PC / internet connection. By unplugging the wireless when not in use I know that without a doubt 1,000% that I am secure. (This is not to mention the occasional vulnerability that is exploited. Here again, I cant be bothered loading the latest patch).
My "Flintstone" approach give me piece of mind that some internet cop wont come knocking at my door one day charging me with downloading illegal material.
I's my method and it works for me.

by wojnar

Please, please tell me we don't have to prove spying into another's home IS illegal. Ever heard of Peeping Tom laws ? As long as reasonable caution is taken to not be seen (eg. standing directly in front of the window)you are not allowed to take extrodinary measures - telescopes, etc - to see into another's house.

By the way - by placing a receiving device in a position that you can use your neighbor's signal, and connecting it to a network or PC you ARE 'going out to get it'. I don't know of any computers that pick up WiFi unless they have a receiver and TCP/IP software turned on.

Actively or passively, you must do something unrelated to 'normal' computing in order to not only receive the signal but use it to your specific advantage. Web pages will not mysteriously appear on your screen unless you go get it (of course there is always spyware but thats another discussion).

by oregonnative

I really cannot believe the sustained insane discussion coming off of the fingers of all these IT guys.

IT executives have a reputation similar to religious fundamentalists. They believe what they believe (for whatever reason) and will go to any extreme to defend it. Peeping Tom laws apply to a person who jumps an open Internet connection??? I say that's getting bizarre.

The point that it is inappropriate to snag an unguarded wireless port can easily be made in a rational manner without giving up one's dignity. I honestly wonder what those suicide bombers in the Middle East do for a living. Some of their extremism looks awfully familiar to what I am reading in this discussion.

by unclerob

- if the packet of data travelling across that unsecured wireless pipe is actually naked (not wearing a shirt or pants or underwear), and I see it then I guess I'm a peeping tom (or rob to be accurate)

I agree, this conversation had some decent posts at the beginning but talk of peeping tom laws really indicate to me that we should let this one rest and agree to disagree.

People on both sides of the fence on this one aren't going to shake hands & agree on anything anytime soon.

The few points of merit that I've gleaned from this entire discussion are:
- Wardriving Part 1: The act of Wardriving, driving around looking for wireless hotspots is currently legal. You can drive around looking for wireless hotspots, that is totally legal - all this initial act really does is look for (not connect & use) available wireless networks both secured & unsecured.
- Wardriving Part 2: When you stop and start to connect to unsecured wireless networks (or secured depending on how saavy you are) to access the internet, email, or this person personal network, that is illegal and constitutes some breach of the law. The penalties for performing this illegal feat are hard to ascertain and vary depending on your area.
- You can technically wardrive (or war-sit as it were) by sitting inside your home and view the wireless networks (both secured & unsecured) that are close enough in proximity in your surrounding neighborhood that your wireless nic can pick up on the signals and let you know that they're available.
- Hooking a ride on these wireless signals from inside your own home is technically illegal too although I can understand the arguments people put forth about using wireless signals that are being broadcast into their own personal space.
- Stealing or "borrowing" someone's internet connection via an unsecured wireless connection is not the same as stealing or borrowing a car, taking a dip in the neighbor's pool, walking through someone's unlocked house, finding a wallet on the street, servicing your neighbor's wife and any other uncanny analogy that I've read in this discussion so far. These are wireless signals people, they are not tangible, physical resources. No physical weight, color, odour, taste or touch can be attributed to them. They are intangible, you may have some passing through your ears at this moment and not know it. Is it cool to connect to the internet on someone else's wireless connection, NO definitely not and I don't need a long winded (speaking of which this post is getting long) discussion on morality & ethics and erosion of moral fiber in American youth to tell me that either (thanks Mr. Santulli, great posts by the way, something about twisted logic used by terrorists). The act of using someone else's internet access by way of wireless connection is not legal and is not to be condoned but also isn't technically killing anyone either.
- User WOJNAR seems to be going on post happy ride and transmitting his opinions frequently on every other user's posts. Although this is legal, it's beginning to be bothersome (just kidding, well maybe not). His last post about having to turn on your tcpip software makes me question his knowledge on this subject altogether but I'll reserve my opinion because I can be crusty too now that I'm getting older. And for the record, you can technically tell Windows XP to connect automatically to any unsecured wireless networks that are close enough for your wireless nic to make use of. It's very convenient and allows a person to use his pc instead of futzing around with config settings everytime you want surf the net and read your mail.
- I have yet to see a wireless router that the average user (average tech skills, we're not talking Bill Nye the "IT Guy") can setup wireless security on in less than 5 minutes. This was something that WOJNAR also mentioned in one of his posts. I say average, I didn't say dumb, or not technically inclined because although the people in this forum have a clue as to what's necessary in setting up & enabling security on their wireless routers and pc's in general, the "AVERAGE" user does not, hence the problems with spyware, virus's (or virii) that affect the majority of computers.

- geez, wasn't this post about a peeping tom and someone being naked or something?!
... that's probably the only reason I took a "peep" at it in the first place, when you get old your mind tends to get fixated on weird stuff like that.

So in conclusion, be cool, stay in school, don't steal or do drug or perform any other crimes for that matter, be responsible to yourself & your community and set an example for other to observe & follow. More people start doing this, others will learn & do the same and heck, we might even get civilized enough so that we don't have to worry about "peeping tom" laws.

... just my 0.02 cents cdn ;-)

by wojnar

but what I am trying to say is that when plugged in and connected, without utilizing the built-in security available on your access point/router you are 100% UNsecured. During the time you are on your wireless connection (couple of hours maybe ?) there is no security at all and everyone has full access to shared resources on your PC (unless you are running a domain server at home).

By simply: 1) setting up a shared key, 2) using encryption and 3) turning off the SSID broadcast you can make your wireless online time fully secure. When done with the connection, you can continue to unplug for total access point security. In other words take 5 minutes to secure the wireless access so that when you need it and are using it, you are not opening yourself to trouble.

One other side comment - another feature of many routers is a hardware firewall. If you leave your PC on and modem connected, you again have no security from outside intruders. XP's firewall is not bad but it doesn't stop people until they already are trying to access your PC. A freestanding hardware firewall will stop intruders before they even get to your PC and make you virtually invisible on the internet. Hope this helps.

by wojnar

No, OregonNative, we are not talking about peeping tom/Rob laws as applicable. Just my poke at Uncle Rob's homorous comment from earlier in the thread (follow the dotted lines !). My tongue firmly in cheek - but not obvious enough - Sorry.

I think we can all appreciate Uncle Rob's summary. Thanks Uncle Rob (but please don't look in my window ...).

by silversidhe

I hope you have some kind of protection on your system while you are connected since this is when you are most likely to be infected, hacked or screwed! Think of it as a rubber - not 100% effective but lessens your chance of getting something nasty. You are right about one thing: wireless=insecure. There is probably no way to be safe on wireless so my flintstone suggestion to you is to only have one computer that you use for wireless internet and don't cross contaminate (connect or share files) with any other computer.

by inertman9

i read somewhere that a new law is being considered/drafted to make it illegal to leave you wi-fi unsecured. like many states have laws making it a crime to leave your car running unattended so as not to allow crimes to occur as easily. just last winter in denver, a cop left his patrol car warming up in the morning and it was stolen. there's always going to be criminals to screw it up for everyone else, now they're trying to make being stupid criminal.

by jdclyde

Seatbelts, motorcycle helmets, age limits for smoking and drinking.

All examples of saving people from themselves.

It is even illegal to kill yourself.

Holding people accountable for all of their actions is not always a bad thing though, especially if it affects other people.

by inertman9

but both of these laws are ot just to protect the stupid from themselves, it's to remove the temptation of crime from the criminals that stupid people present, and to catch actual criminals (at least in theory). in the case of wi-fi, there are people who drive around w/ a wi-fi finder and hack from stolen bandwidth. if this is removed they'll have to hack from their own dominion, and then be smarter to not get caught.

by tonythetiger

A public official who accepts a gift of an ink pen from a contractor is ethical. One who accepts a gift of $50.01 in value is unethical. One that accepts a vacation to the Bahamas has broken the law.

Even the law has it's degrees, which don't always make sense. Steal something less than $500 in value and it's petty theft, and you could get 6 months. $501 could get you 10 years. But defraud thousands out of millions and your back down to the 6 month range. Go figure.

by tonythetiger

that Joe User doesn't know that he left his door unlocked.

I knowingly left mine unsecured (so if you're ever in the neighborhood, please feel free), and in the last year or so I've had 6 different people (or at least 6 different MAC addresses) hit it, at least for a few minutes (only one of these people is known to me). The house we just bought is right across the street from a small park (it's cool to have a big front yard that someone else mows :)) and my wireless covers almost half of it. I see people working with their laptops while eating lunch, etc, and I assume they found it quite by accident (I have found one that way while using my PDA at work).

Do I care? Well, if they were using up all of my bandwidth I might, but until that would happen, I'm not going to change anything. I prefer to secure the computer itself (yes, I know, computers can be broken into, but then so can your typical home router).

(added)

also don't think it's an ISP issue. They are getting paid for (in my case) 768k down and 256k up. What percentage of that is used by me and what percentage by someone else is not really their concern, as long as I am not selling it. From their perspective, someone connecting through my network to check their email is no different than them knocking on my door and sitting down at my computer to check their email.

by tonythetiger

If you pay for cable TV, and your cousin comes over to watch the game with you, is he stealing service?

by tonythetiger

You buy a giant bag of popcorn and are walking around the mall chomping away. It you're not too careful, and a few (or not so few) pieces fall to the ground without your knowledge, is the dumb kid who picks them up and eats them stealing from you?

by tonythetiger

"Perhaps it is raining, and I duck into someone's open garage for a second until the rain lightens, then continue on my way. As long as I don't touch anything in the garage, would that really be an unethical thing to do? I'm not sure if it would even be illegal, since the door was open."

I know positively of a man who was arrested and jailed for almost exactly that (when a downpour started, he ducked into a carport and sat in a lawn chair for nearly an hour)!

by jdclyde

that hackers coming from random hacked locations has nothing to do with this law.

It is entirely about the internet providers loosing INCOME from people tapping into their neighbors open access point.

Follow the money.

Our prestegious law makers don't understand tech enough that they would ever understand or care about wardrivers hacking. They DO understand people that contribute to their re-election losing money.

by inertman9

good point and i agree. but to think that law enforcement or any of the myriad of credit card and/or reporting agencies don't think this is important to stiffling the id theft epidemic would be a questionable train of thought. however, you still make a vaild point, i must be just naive enough to think that money is't everything.

This discussion is closed to new replies.