Question Locked

What are the credentials for your Physical Security white paper author

0 helpful
32 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is written in response to a featured article on TechRepublic today:

Physical Security in Mission Critical Facilities

My comments relate and question relates to it:

Mag stripe cards have been unused in physical securirty for years. Ask us physical security people how we answer the questions raised about who you are, why are you here and when are you allowed automatically, make the automated decisions, and get the preventative security plus the reactive security handled.

Neil Licht callhereweare@verizon.net 25 year physical security solutions provider veteran, launched a browser based solution and lots more plus CCTV etc.

Find a genuine expert if you are writing a white paper please!!!

32 replies

by santeewelding

Where [i]you[/i] are and what [i]you[/i] are talking about?

I sure don't.

So, I won't be calling [i]you[/i].

by nexs

The botnet crawlers will find his email address and fill his inbox with spam.

by neil licht

This is written in response to a featured article on TechRepublic today:

Physical Security in Mission Critical Facilities

My comments relate and question relates to it

by oh smeg

Perhaps some link to the original article may prove useful here.

I personally nearly marked the above post as Spam but I erred on the side of caution just in case I was being overly sensitive. :0

Col

by seanferd

Are you referring to anything specific? Look up the authors, then. Regardless, you sure aren't addressing anyone who is actually producing the whitepapers.

Unless, of course, this is just spam. But that would seem inconsistent with your previous posts.

by neil licht

This is written in response to a featured article on TechRepublic today:

Physical Security in Mission Critical Facilities

My comments relate and question relates to it:

by nexs

In your comment so people know what's going on.

by santeewelding

And put another down...more, to take advantage of sleazy self-advertising without paying: I'm pushing the button.

I wish I could do it with every instance of self-aggrandizement I encounter here.

by neil licht

This is written in response to a featured article on TechRepublic today:

Physical Security in Mission Critical Facilities

My comments relate and question relates to it.

I too offense at the lack of credentials the author had re physical security and was not advertising for myself. Rxperts do white papers so Tech Republic needs to find a real physical security practitioner , not an IT person to do a credible white paper on that subject.

No, I'm not advertising for me, I'm chastizing Tech Republic's definition of an expert and the worthyness of the white paper they linked to today, 8-4-10 about critical security needs, access control and its system design.

by neil licht

Link - In the newsletter today via my inbox: TechRepublic White Paper Membership

August 4, 2010

"Physical security in mission-critical facilities
Read up on the principles of personnel identification and basic methods for controlling physical access to facilities. (APC)"

Sorry, I thought the title would be the link. My error

by seanferd

First off, whitepapers are just advertising. I don't believe I have ever seen a whitepaper produced by a corporation that wasn't.

Second, TR is just linking whitepapers that the industry puts out there. I'm not sure how you can chastise TR for something that someone at APC wrote. Or not understand who wrote it, whichever the case may be.

Third, and please consider my bafflement to be genuine, I would have expected from any expert having differences with the conclusions of another to provide a better reference (more obvious title and a link). Also, I would have expected something more of an analysis or at least a point you hold in contention along with your counter-argument.

Further, Suzanne Niles qualifications are easily discernible. You could expound upon how fit these are in the context of physical security.
http://www.google.com/search?q=Suzanne+Niles+APC
Her qualifications are also described in the paper. They rather seem to suit one who edits papers and does presentations, in this case, given the research done at APC.

You may have also noted that the whitepaper is from 2004. (I assume that someone felt it is still relevant enough to link in the newsletter today - perhaps this is a bone of contention.) Yet I have not noticed the extinction of mag stripe cards. Perhaps others have noticed differently.

Run with it. You could have a very interesting post, indeed.

by neil licht

I am not an IT person and I did think Tech Republic sanctioned or picked their links as things that can guide their readership.

Mag stipes are not specified in any new or retrofitted system because its easy to copy them.

Prox, and as the author said, biometrics have become the choice and ofte, two credentials, one you know and one you carry are used. Its an imperfect system still.

I will thing about writing something that can help readers understand the physical security side and how it integrates with the IT managed networks.

Give me a little time to do so please.

by santeewelding

Our friend, didn't.

Pretty damned good white paper...unlike his quickie.

by oh smeg

But whys the OP complaining about the contents of this White Paper?

Not really sure what they are on about.

Col

by dawgit

And I read in it a lot more than just swiping Magnetic strip cards.
Of course my concept of Mission Critical will be vastly different than that of someone sitting in a providers office. That might be 'High Security' to him, but doesn't qualify as much to me.

by neil licht

Its apparent that non physical security people do not understand how physical security works. If you took issue with my comments re credentials, then show me your credentials. Mine ar 25 years long and I have moved an entire industry, physical security, into the world of being compatible with the IT sysetems in place.

I respect IT and how it works, learned that first and then went about matching a network based physical security management systeminto the standards and connectivity process IT uses.

Give me a bit of credit - Mag stripes are not used anymore and that is a red flag in the white paper that the author already is way out of touch and does not know current electronic access control methods, systems, solutions and should consult with those of us wh specialize in it.

I wouldn't proport to write apaper on IT although I understand how the connectivity, roadblocks,bandwidth, web, networking connectivity, sub networks, all the terms.

Given my expertise then in my area, Is it so hard to accept why I took issue with the white paper and asked about the author's credentials?

You should have done that as well - White papers featured on this site must be credible and the source expert.

Neil licht

by dawgit

Yet ;)
It might be because many of us have a different view of 'Physical' Security.
If you have ever worked in an environment where there were real serious people watching, with real weapons, loaded with real ammunition, then you might have a different perspective of 'Physical security' than others.
And the term 'Critical' means that someone can Die.
And 'Mission Essential' means will not fail.
Just a wee bit of a different perspective, no?

by jamesrl

And the content or the author isn't vetted by Tech Republic.

We in IT are used to white papers. They are generally trying to sell a product to an audience that doesn't respond to ads. We know they are biased. Thats why they pay to present them.

We don't take them as seriously as you do.

There are a few of us here who understand physical security. I've worked at places with guards with guns, full body scanners and the like.

Ignore the whitepaper, and share your thoughts with us.

by seanferd

Don't bother fighting, either. Just provide a bit more commentary on what you think, and back it up.

I would definitely read any thoughts you have on physical security, and I'm sure others would as well. You just kinda went off half cocked with the original comment, and people tend to react to that. Perhaps overreacted, as we do see plenty of spam and trolls. I figured that you were neither after looking over your several previous comments which you have posted at TR. If I hadn't, or if you hadn't posted anything previously. I may have had a somewhat different reaction myself.

No worries. Don't be a stranger. :)

by santeewelding

How do I finagle all this in order to grant you five thumbs, elevating you to one thousand?

by neil licht

Mussion critical is exactly what drives a well designed access control solution. Its not high security alone.

It prevents lots of theft, can be tagged to equipment that moves around or can leave the building so you can track it, can manage access to areas that are unsafe to the general public.

IT people should be involved in the design, not just to assure protection of their resouces but to assue the solution fits into the way they need it to be if it is to work well on thir global network and not bog it down.

by dawgit

As you've stated... different view points.
Different perspectives will certainly bring about different solutions too.
There is no one size fits all, and in reference to the original poster, no need to complain of others view points.

by nexs

Was what I was going to say, also.

I've spent time in a security company - guards division - so I feel I've got a fairly wide view of security measures.

Critical = Death?
Does that mean 'Business Critical' = 'Business Death'?

by seanferd

I would think it would be a lot more up-to-date than something from 2004! And the perspective of another professional is always good.

Yes, I do realize that mag stripe cards and card readers are chock full of vulnerabilities. They still seem to be in use, regardless of their failings. Hopefully, they are used less as time wears on.

by seanferd

As I also mentioned in another post, whitepapers are advertising, mostly, unless they are coming from an organization which is strictly research based.

by neil licht

I understand that "picture". Physical security refers to electronic access control, CCTV, alarm management, incident management.

The electronic systems prevent issues and alert the folks with the guns, etc by sensing-seeing things people can not see.

Its amazing in terms of the technologies available and what they can do and they are being deployed in Mission Critical environments.

Neil

by nexs

Physical security measures aren't deployed in only 'Critical' locales.

It all depends on what the needs for security is. Be it hazardous equipment/material, dangerous persons, sensitive data, etc.

Though, true enough, that the more 'Critical' the situation, the higher the budget.

by neil licht

Hopefully still full of Grace. I do appreciate the challanges and it does provoke thinking re how IT and Physical SEcurity must relate and understand each other's worlds.

WE do work together borrowing from each side so the entire process of security management-response works as it should.

Only in the last 8 years has Physical Security finally learned how to work with the IT people because ultimately, our stuff goes on YOUR network.

Its your expertise that makes that work or tells us that it can not work and we have finally learned to respect and trust it.

REgards, Neil

by santeewelding

The technology of "IT", translated to cocked and locked, does no good without the information and intelligence of "IT", which translates to, "What the hell do think you're doing?"

This discussion is closed to new replies.