Question Locked

What is the best way to...

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am not sure if I should be posting this as a question or a discussion but here goes...
I own a small systems integration company and I am working with a client that is looking to centralise their file/mail applications (looking to use exchange) for ease of management, bandwidth, backup, redundancy. At the moment they have 1 central office with a SBS server and 15 users and approximately 50 remote (laptop users that could in the future connect from anywhere there is an internet connection) users. In 3 years time, it is anticipated that there will be 300-350 remote users. These users also like to use other apps (word, excel and others) offline as well.
My thinking was to deploy terminal services or possibly citrix (I dont know much about citrix at this stage).
What I would like is to have people who know or who have done similar things to talk about some general principles about this type of project.
e.g. How does terminal services compare with citrix in price/capabilities?
Is terminal services/citrix the way to go? (they will be using a windows environment - but definitely NOT vista) or are there better alternatives?

Thank you for any feedback/ideas that you post.
P.S. - I am new here and I just read and contributed my first post to the "how to hack lan" question. I am not dodgy I promise!

4 replies

by hal 9000

And see if the version that you currently have will support the current Requirements for available Mailboxes and have enough room to set rules. Then look at the projected growth and see what will be necessary to make Exchange work to that extent.

It might support the current user Load but there is no way in Hell that any version of Exchange will support that big a set of users as the place grows. You are going to have to setup a set of Clustered Exchange Servers so I would be looking at using Exchange 2007 as it supports more mailboxes and has more room to incorporate Rules but it's a 64 Bit Application so you'll need a 64 Bit Server.

Terminal Services or CAL's are the way that extra computers can log into the main server cluster and download the necessary items but they are not cheap and just 2 X 5 Pack CAL or Terminal Services will cost more than the OS initially cost so with 65 users you'll need to license the Server Software to support these. You'll also need to find an economic way to allow the company to grow as they don't need to be in a position of shelling out a couple of K every time they need to add another 20 users which is just slightly more expensive that 10 CAL's by a few hounded $.

Personally I haven't used Citrix in a production Environment as I'm not a great fan of it but you may like it. I find the licensing requirements just way over the top so I'm not interested.

As for a scalable Mail Server I would be looking at a Decent powerful Custom Made Mail Server running SUSE Enterprise with Apache doing the work of the Mail Server it's much cheaper more scalable and just plain simpler to maintain and keep secure.

That ones your call though M$ Complex and Expensive Licensing or Something Simple and Cheap, you'll get SUSE Enterprise Version cheaper than Exchange with much better support depending on the hardware involved. As this is going to be a [b]Mission Critical[/b] device you need reliability above anything else so you need Great Hardware not Budget Hardware which is constantly breaking because it's being overused.

With a company projected to grow this fast I would be looking to one of the major makers to supply the hardware and one with a tie in with SUSE so your only option there is IBM who offer a 48 Hour Fix for problems found with SUSE and here I'm not talking about some little bit of code that doesn't work as expected but core operation items that can cripple a business for months till it's fixed by the software supplier. The simple things are fixed by a phone call.

As for remote users you could buy your own hardware configure it as required on a M$ Volume License and sell onto the Remote Users so that they have immediate access to the Network once their membership/whatever has been accepted you can enter in their mailboxes as the NB gets shipped so all that they need to do is open the box plug in and they are ready to run. You could get a great deal on Build it yourself NB like the ones available from Clevo buy in bulk and more importantly keep the hardware standard across the range and be cheap with superior hardware and a Cloned Image for every new NB supplied.

Clevo's head office is listed here and there are various sub branches world wide listed in the Site Reference page.

http://tinyurl.com/33g6yj

As far as M$ Volume Licensing goes that's easy as all you need do is buy the licenses and then buy more s required you get 1 install CD for each product so it's a good idea to copy it and work off the copies.

http://tinyurl.com/yx6xol

If you want to go with pre made units you can buy directly from the different makers but that will remove the ability to pick and chose the hardware installed and the ability to use Volume Licensing for M$ Products like Windows and Office. Even if you did manage to buy without an OS installed you wouldn't have standard hardware any more and every batch of new NB's would require a new image to be made that you could load up the different NB's. Of course as the years go by the same applies to the Clevo's as well but at least you would have longer periods of standard hardware to work with and then once one model is replaced you can switch to a different model to use as the standard base installation till that is replaced.

But that's your option on how you wish to service this business become nothing more than an add on reseller for something that they are capable of buying over the counter anywhere or become a Value Added Reseller that makes the company need to return to you for further upgrades and expansion to their systems.

Col

by the b_rad h

that has given me heaps to go on. I have also just downloaded a trial version of open exchange to have a look at and will download a trial version of the server version.

I think that we will look at an IBM (I am a big fan of IBM servers anyway) with SUSE Enterprise Version as you suggested. I am going to download a version of this soon too and have a look at it. That way I can leave all the users on MS Exchange on their desktop/laptop (they will absolutely scream if I tried to move them over to Open-Exchange) and have a more robust server solution.
Lastly, I cant think of any way around the cost of terminal services licenses and the cost of volume licensing. Is SPLAR an option here?
Thank you again for taking the time to post such an extensive response. As a wannabe geek - I salute you!

by toivo talikka

The numbers you mentioned deserve careful planning and selection process in the early stages: once the plan is in motion, it would be difficult to turn the tide. Is the business rock solid at the moment and is it going to expand according to the projections and is the technology going to remain the same? Are the end user needs going to grow?

Are the end users going to use laptops or tablet PCs with wireless access which tend to be more expensive than desktop computers? As Hal suggests, you can make a buck and your client can save in a big way by buying in bulk. You can also get them to budget for spare machines for quick replacement when a laptop is stolen or damaged, plus a support helpline - you or someone working for you.

Have you had a look at the Linux Terminal Server Project http://wiki.ltsp.org ?

There is also Xvnc Terminal Server which can use Vncviewer to connect to the server, allowing multiple clients to connect using their own logins.

There are also Groupware products you can access remotely just through the browser with calendars, appointments and other functions. In addition to Open-Xchange, the community version of which can also be installed on Fedora server for free, instead of Suse Linux or RedHat Enterprise Server, eGroupware is another interesting product to look at. It all depends what the end users and the business needs.

If you are planning to chart the open source options, have you had a look at OpenOffice.org 2.1? If the end users exchange documents and spreadsheets mainly with the Head Office, there are savings to be made by going to an open source solution all the way, by getting laptops with desktop Linux and OpenOffice.

You could start with a simple low cost solution based on OpenWebmail or Outlook POP clients for remote users running on the server with Sendmail and Apache. Webmin for user and mailbox administration is quite adequate. I have had this solution in place now for two years for a client with 20 Head Office users and 30 reps around Australia.

This discussion is closed to new replies.