Question Locked

What to do when warraty work goes bad?

0 helpful
13 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Warranty work causes more problems - ACER is BAD!!
ACER Australia do not support their warranty work!
I had a windows 2003 server R2 sending out an alert that one of the hard drives in a Raid 1 0 setup was failing and being rebuilt. After about 4 warnings over 2 weeks I contacted ACER Australia through their web site and a tech rang me up. I expalained what was happening and I was only half way through my 3 year warranty.

They sent out a Tech to replace the drive within 2 days. Good so far. When installing the drive which he said would take 30 minutes he did something wrong and after 5 hours he finally owned up that he could not start our server.

He asked for our raid back up but we received the server with the system preinstalled so we did not have a backup. He then said there was nothing more he could do and left!!!

I had to get someone in to rebuild the server. I spoke to ACER and their first response was "unless you can prove we did it, there is nothing we can do"

I have sent the logs of what was found on the server and its rebuild but now they just ignore me, by not responding to my emails or calls.

It cost $3,600 to get it fixed and we were without it for 3 days.

What can I do to get ACER to reimburse my company??

Baegis

13 replies

by churdoo

That SUX! I don't have an answer to your question; just wanted to commiserate I suppose. Good luck!

by jdclyde

because you will probably have to sue them over it.

Make sure you document EVERYTHING.

Everyone you talk to (by name/employee number) with time/date/ and what was discussed.

Everything that was done, and why.

Good luck with that.

by nimmo

I had to call HP for a warranty job on one of our clients Proliant server, they came out really quick (next day support so they should) anyways I get a call from the tech "yep all done I have replaced the motherboard and the server is up and running".

I log in a little later to find that not only did they not turn RAID back on but the tech put a G5 board in a G4 server, therefore I couldn't just turn RAID back on.

I had to image the server, shrink the volumes (once the drives got formatted the MBR takes some room), do a HIR restore, and keep my fingers crossed.

After about 4 blue screens and numerous rebuilds I finally got it up and running (couldn't charge the client, had to wear the cost) for HP's incompetence.

I called the tech told him what happened (not to rip it up him but tell him he should make sure that he checks the parts and hardware configuration before he does work)

HP and most likely Dell, ACER, etc.. have a clause that states that they are not responsible for any loss of data so we had to wear it.

I'm not going say never buy HP because they have great products and support (when you get a compedant tech)

So sorry to hear and unfortunately ACER most likely have that type of clause which means you have to bite the bullet and wear it.

by jdclyde

and your support is for the hardware only.

Any good tech should ask if you have current backups before doing anything that COULD kill an install though.

by nimmo

Because of this clause they don't have to but should, I did some contract work for HP along with other companies some years ago and I always asked but technically I didn't have too. like you said they are working on hardware not software.

But more to the point any good administrator should have current backups, we have every server we look after run an image every night to an external drive.

Even though there is always a backup to restore it still isn't the point, if the tech did the job with the correct hardware there wouldn't have been any issue in my case.

by oh smeg

I never touch a HP Product at all these days and I used to be one of their agents on selling their products. If you look for the Warranty Department it used to be Listed under Service Department in Melbourne that was it not HP Service just Service Department in the Melbourne Phone Book. Really useful as Tits on a Bull.

Because the Book didn't have any details for Warranty work on a Tape Drive I rang the QLD Supplier who I dealt with and was asked how I got that Phone number apparently if I wanted to order something it was OK to ring it but any other queries where a no no and they just didn't want to know.

Anyway the Bottom Line is that HP [b]Do Not[/b] repair anything they replace it with new stock so in the case of a minor failure like a belt breaking in a Tape Drive they give you a new one and because it's a new model all of the existing Tapes are now unreadable. Just a bit drastic for something so simple to fix and then continue working. They do the same thing with their scanners come MFD one customer had one where the light wasn't turning off and I was told I didn't know what I was talking about so when it failed which it had no option to do anything else they simply replaced it with a new one. The customer was as Happy as a Pig in Mud until I asked what would happen when it was no longer covered by the Warranty which expired in 3 days time. HP's directly said Buy a New one which is as rough as guts for a device that was supposed to last 5 years was sold as a 5 year investment and budgeted for a 5 year life to find out after 1 year you had to buy a new one when this broke.

HP does have some excellent Printers but thee are made by Canon so I just cut out the Middle Man and buy the Canon Units they at least repair their High End devices and don't fill up rubbish bins with hardware that requires a 50 cent part.

I personally have not worked or sold any HP product in 10 years or longer now and have no intention of ever handling their products again. Though Acer has a Bad reputation for Warranty work they at least only sell the low end of the market so it's acceptable to throw that stuff away as it costs more in Labor then the unit is actually worth to buy new. Unfortunately you no longer get what you pay for you get hardware from these crowds that are priced to what the Market will Bear and you are getting complete Junk at as much as they can sell it for.

In the case that is mentioned by the OP here as they didn't keep Backup they got exactly what they deserved they lost their Data and it was going to happen sooner rather than Latter and if they are not now running a DR Plan it's going to happen again and again till they work out that Computer Hardware [b]Is Not[/b] Reliable and you need to keep Backup's of everything you do in such a fashion that it can be restored to different Hardware and work. Until they realize that they are in for a lot of Pain & Suffering and I have no Sympathy for them at all. :)

Col

by baegis

We did backups every night of all data and the system state. We did not have a backup of the original raid as it came to us preinstalled and we did not realise we should have made a copy even if we knew how. I am an accountant and computers are my interest. We are too small to have a dedicated IT person so I look after the everyday stuff and use an external comapny for the more complicated areas.
Under the Australian Trade practices act a service compnay must excerise due care when performing warranty work or they are liable which I think has happened here.

Baegis

by oh smeg

Was that the Tech can only fit what HP supplies him to use. I used to do contract Work for HP repairing computers that their Techs couldn't and the stuff that they supplied left a lot to be desired. I would order the correct Part only to find out that it had been discontinued and replaced with something new that required masses of work to fit and get running again.

Or in the No Win Situation like some Evo Systems I knew that they worked perfectly but because of the crappy Property PS's that HP used I would order 10 PS's and hopefully find that may work with that system. But I could plug in a 350 W Antec and the unit worked perfectly but you had to use one of the HP Supplied PS to repair the thing. The HP Techs who where then nothing more than Valve Jockeys would replace a faulty substandard part with what was supposed to be a new substandard part and when it didn't work pass it on to me. Then HP would simply ignore orders for Superseded Parts and nit wasn't until I rang them asking what had happened to Order Such & Such they would say Oh that's been Superseded with such & such so you have to order that part.

They would have to be better now as they couldn't get any worse than what they where then and remain in business.

Col

by nimmo

So it wasn't just me when I ordered parts and got the wrong ones. LOL

I only did contract work for a year for them but it happened alot.

by oh smeg

Unless I ordered them by Part Number and they didn't bother telling me that the Parts had been Superseded.

Defiantly not the easiest crowd to deal with I have no idea how their Customers feel about them but I was anything but happy and I didn't have to face their customers. I wouldn't have of liked to be in that position trying to tell them that I was waiting for Parts that where never going to arrive till I asked what was happening. :D

Col

by nimmo

Unfortunatly the majority of the time I was working I had to meet someone onsite, and yeah kind feel like a dick when you need to say "oops sorry HP sent me the wrong parts".

by oh smeg

But I personally think you will be wasting your money through the courts trying to get anything at all in the form of Compensation.

You should however been able to hand the Tech in question the Install Disc that came with the new system and let him/her repair it to your satisfaction which didn't happen here. :)

The Techs only responsibility to to repair the system with parts that are available and quite often with systems Under Guarantee you are faced with new parts that are not directly compatible with what broken/failed part was removed so a OS Rebuild in some form has to be performed. Here I'm supposing that this is a [b]Mission Critical System[/b] and as such if you where not advised to Backup at least 1 HDD and have it available at all times you where very badly advised by either the place that sold it or the [i]external company[/i] that you use if they where even asked to look at this unit that is of course.

This is a perfect example where cheapest is defiantly not the best as you don't get the Knowledge required to properly support this device while it is in service. As you didn't loose any great amount of Data I don't see that the Business has suffered any real damage that warrants compensation as you failed to provide the required components that where needed by the Field Service Tech to return your system to the way you wanted to use it but no doubt had it working with your Data Restored.

Whenever I supply a new Server to any client I don't give them the option to option to complain and reject the costs of a Backup of their OS in the Form of a HDD that is a copy of the OS/RAID whatever I just hand it to them for storage after I install the server so that in the event of a failure I can have their Mission Critical Appliance up and running in the shortest time possible. None the less it never fails to amaze me just how often I go to a business and find that the Backup Drive that I supplied has been used and I only get called in after the Original Drive and the Backup have been trashed and I need to reload the OS from Scratch. In every case the business in question thinks that they are saving money by not calling me in for what is Warranty work that is performed [b]Without Charge.[/b] It always ends up costing them a lot of Down Time which costs them considerably more in both Lost Production and the fact that I charge them for the work as it is both unnecessary and the fact that they have messed up the device which [b]Is Not[/b] Covered by the Guarantee. I don't mind a mistake being made, but I can only see using the Backup and destroying the Data on it Deliberate Tampering to cause problems. Of course recently when I went to reload a System and found 4 extra HDD's which couldn't be reconfigured in any form of RAID and the Owners Specific Insisting that no one had touched this system since it was installed so I said Sorry I must have made a Mistake I'll take those 4 X 3K Drives away with me as they are not being used here. At that point they admitted that they had fitted these and then proceeded to wreck the Installed OS and Primary RAID with the OS on it and then not learning from the mess that they created they then did the same thing to the Backup and couldn't understand why they had broken it.

The same thing happens when you have Encrypted Data on a Server and do not tell the Tech before they start to repair the dead unit. If they do not know they are unable to take the necessary steps to protect the Data and this is perfectly Normal and accepted even the TPA Commissioners and Courts as beyond the Techs control or expected understanding of what should be on the System.

Basically if you don't tell them they don't know and they do need all of the requests that they make supplied in full so that they can do their job to your satisfaction.

Of course if you deal with 1 company for all your Mission Critical Hardware and Service they will have records of what exactly you use and generally carry the necessary stuff with them and know what is being done in that business. They are then in a much better position to provide the assistance that a business requires in as short as time as possible with the best results.

Basically the Techs are not Physic and need to be given all of the Information Required before they start about the configuration of your Systems. Many Times these Field Service Techs do not work for the place selling the systems but either the Country Distributer or maybe even be a Contract Tech for the Distributer so at best they only know what can be done here and not the actual configuration that is in use.

Don't get me wrong here I'm not defending the Tech in question here or Acer as they are beyond defense from my experience but none the less I personally don't think you have a leg to stand on here as you failed to comply with a Reasonable Request of the Field Service Tech who was dispatched to fix some faulty hardware which from your Post above was achieved.

Personally I think you would be better off spending the money you would throw at this case on a Better Support Service that would help to protect you from problems like this down the track. But that's just my humble Opinion you are welcome to do as you like here and spend the companies money which ever way you or the Business is happy with. Just under QLD and Federal Law you don't have much of a chance here as there is no real damage done. That is from my personal experience of appearing in Courts as a Claimed Expert Witness over many years. :)

However if you make a big enough stink Acer may pay you out rather than bother to fight the case but that will all depend on the person you get on the day of the request and how they feel. They are not under any obligation to do anything here as they provided the Parts and Service Personal to repair their Faulty Equipment Under Guarantee and have done this.

The real problem here is the place that this unit was purchased from as I have yet to run across any Retailer of equipment like this that truly understands the difference between Domestic and Business Systems. They like selling to Business who don't know any better because they make more profit and have no outlays so they are laughing all the way to the Bank and I have yet to see proper advice offered by these places [b]Yet.[/b] But as they are cheaper than a Professional Business Supplier they stay in business making more of a mess as time goes by.

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.