Discussion Locked

when to implement VLANs?

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I'm administrator of a branch LAN Ethernet 100mb/s using 4 cisco cat2924 & 2610 router to connect to HO with about 65 POSs an PCs,and 2 NT server one of them is oracle application server,and the other is file and print server, the performance of the network is very slow, I checked the compability of speed and duplex between the switches ports & NICs and their situation were very good, (i tried all the possibilties 100 to 100, autoselect to autoselect..etc, and still very slow )so i don't thinkthis is the problem, and the performance the servers is good, and my questions are, are there any methods to find out why is it slow, and is implementing VLANs could speed up my network?

5 replies

by rserao

There are a few things to look at..
I'd start by looking at the Cisco ports for alignment errors and fcs errors.. that would indocate that there is a duplex mismatch.. If you are using 3Com NICS try setting both to 100 Half.. I've had a hard time getting 3 Com to go to Full Duplex...
There are many other things to look at but I don't have enough information to go on .. like what's your IP scheme.. i.e. do the workstations have to go out over the WAN for DNS / WINS resolution, etc.. if so check the WAN link for adequate bandwidth.. As for the VLANs.. off the cuff, not sure they would help much.. they're most useful for solving problems like workgrouping geographically desparite desktops.. or isolating local traffic,...you may also want tolook at segment traffic with a "sniffer".. see where those delays are comming from....
Hope this helps....

by mshavrov

Hi! I don't think VLANs will help you. It is deal when you have huge LAN. Generally switches do all work to send traffic from sender to receiver without affecting each other with only exception for broadcasts. But since you have routers it localize broadcast traffic (until specially configured). So, check routing first. If you use static routing between routers it might become nightmare. With 65 nodes you can use RIP. Then try to analize WAN Links load. You can use MRTG to continuously monitor your links. Link load for more than 80 percent say you have to upgrade link or limit traffic. You should analize traffic pattern between HO and POSs to see which protocols and services create most traffic. For example, you may have documents or application data located in HO, but which can be safely moved to office's servers. So you should analize it carefully.

Good luck.

This discussion is closed to new replies.