Discussion Locked

WHO'S BEHIND CRIMINAL BOT NETWORKS?

0 helpful
26 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://redtape.msnbc.com/2007/04/whos_behind_cri.html#posts

The most important quote in this article to me is:
[b][i]Driven by revenge[/i][/b]
.
.
[i]Last year, a noted Russian spammer nicknamed PharmaMaster ? he usually advertises pharmaceuticals ? felt his business was endangered by a Silicon Valley anti-spam startup named Blue Security.

PharmaMaster initiated an attack that crippled Blue Security?s Web site. The firm countered by placing information about the attack on its corporate blog, hosted by popular blog site TypePad, owned by Six Apart Ltd. PharmaMaster then hired a bot herder to conduct a denial-of-service attack that shut down all of Six Apart?s blogs, including those hosted on its Typepad.com service.

Eventually, Blue Security surrendered and got out of the business of anti-spam software.

?PharmaMaster paid $1 million to take out Blue Security,? or about $2,000 an hour for the attack, said Schiller, the Portland State professor. ?But (PharmaMaster) was making $3 million a month, so it was worth it.?

[b]At the time, security experts said the Blue Security attack was so severe that only a few of the world?s largest corporations would have been able to withstand it.[/b]

Given the power that the bot herders wield, questions inevitably arise about whether terrorists are behind such crimes. There is no clear answer, and security experts are divided on the issue.[/i]

They took out a security company. And the quote that only a few of the largest corporations could have withstood that attack just scares me.

The fact that they were willing to pay 1 million to take out a company shows how much money, how much influence, and how dangerous this criminals really are.

dan

26 replies

by now left tr

If you can control enough of them it could be the guy next door with his T1 connection. Seen any fancy cars pulling up lately?

by danlm

That came off of msnbc, which has reader feedback.

You had responses that stated this was over blown, that the writer was just trying to put a scare into people.

To people that wanted to totally stop doing business online.

Chuckle, the only response I liked was to officially attack the bot nets with government resources. I like that idea. So, you take out the drone computers. Bet the people learn real quick to protect their pc's. Seriously, MS, Google, Yahoo, AT&T, eh... NSA to all dedicate their bandwidth and computer strength to one full day a month to retaliate against these bot nets. With the day never being released until after it was over. Bet it would make a difference.

But, alas. It's like all other forms of dealing with criminals or terrorists. Your hands are tied by the civil rules of engagement.

Dan

by w2ktechman

I thought it was funny but not practical, if the governments took over the botnets, then people would actually be pissed off and do something to keep the governments off of their systems...Lol

by w2ktechman

Their exploits don?t rival those of Brazilian gangs, experts say. In 2005, more than 50 Brazilians were arrested after allegedly stealing $33 million with targeted, Trojan horse program that stole online banking passwords.

Domingo Montanaro, a computer forensics expert and banking consultant in Sao Paolo, Brazil, said Internet crime gangs there operate almost with impunity. In a recent case, he said, he helped nab a ring of 100 criminals that had gained access to 10,000 Brazilian bank accounts.

?Criminals in Brazil do some incredible stuff because police cannot fight them anymore,? he said. ?They are not even using techniques to hide themselves. We only arrest maybe 3 or 4 percent of them.?

That the police are doing less because it costs too much to fight it, or the gangs have become too powerful. Just like drug lords, they have become out of control, and they make too much money for underfunded police to do anything about.

I would expect that many countries have the same problems, which means that there may be a much more massive trend before it gets better.

A few thoughts, Do not use online banking, if you must, get an account that only has access to look at it, not to transfer anything.
Take the extra 10 min. to go to your bank.

when shopping online, use an account with limited funds or a limited cap to minimise losses in case of theft. I use PayPal and a credit card (pay into before spending). I will fund them and then make my purchases. In case it needs to be quick, I do keep a small amount (less than $400) in each, so at very worst, I would be out $400 (or $800 if both were hit). If more people did this it would be less profitable for these botnets to happen.

Other thoughts, switch to another browser, and turn off flash/activeX, and other 'fun' items. Download only what is needed and investigate before downloading (usually a quick google search can help). And finally, awareness for people to STOP opening the SPAM emails.
If I do not know who it is from, I am hesitant to open it. I will not open Any attachment unless I am certain it is OK, AND I do not click on links in email unless I am certain it is ok. At the first thought of an infection, I pull the LAN cable and have the system checked out. Finally, when not in use, turn the system OFF.

Thanks Dan, good find.

by capodieci

Hello all,
just one small consideration: do average normal user even know what an activeX is? I drive a car, I don't need to know how the engine runs. A few years ago computers where used just by enthusiasts, nowadays also my 75 years old mother goes online, but she has no idea of what can happen in her computer. How can I explain her what a firewall is, what people can actually do without her knowing it?
Those criminals makes money not with computer experts that knows how to protect themselves, or that at least are aware of the risks that being online has, they make money with this huge new Internet population made both by young and old people that are not interested in computer, but they use it just for some practical things: buy a book on amazon, make a payment, transfer founds, etc. Those are the preferred victims of the web-criminals: people that will become aware of risks only AFTER they become a victim.
IMHO the solution is not telling people NOT TO do this or that, to change browser and disable Java, activeX or flash. They don't even know what you are talking about!

Regards,
Roberto

by ken-lm

Good point,
users cannot be expected to deal with technical matters when media advertising is so focused on "dumbing-down" computers and software themselves, this isn't the users fualt...
A few years back, the balance between people that used computers, and people that knew how the damn things worked was not too bad... but again, the companies had to expand their market. This expansion obviously headed directly for the people that either should stay far away from computers, or people that just don't know any better.
It's all about the $$$... What do we, the IT community get?? Massive security risks caused by the users themselves... hair-pulling service desk conversations... and a mass of librarians, nurses, carpenters etc. thinking it's perfectly fine to click on the "YOU HAVE WON THE SOUTH AFRICAN LOTTERY" email link and enter their PIN # into the first field that comes up...
B-E-Autiful.

In reference to your comparison to driving a car without knowing how an engine works... Dig up some old car advertisements from before the 1960's. It seems evident that people then were expected to know much more about the machine they were purchasing. Not to say all were experts, but were at least aware...

The progress is the same...
Companies turned cars plastic and automatic everything, now it costs 100 times more to fix them. Then companies turned computers friendly, bubbly, and "simplified" (HAH!), now there's people losing their identities and money in a virtual freakin world!!
-lyle

by tig2

I use a pre-paid Visa gift card for any plastic expenditures. I wash email for any attachments or links unless you are on my "white" list. I carry my DL with a tape mask over the number. If I need to present this document to law enforcement, I remove the tape. For anyone else that wants to see it to validate identity, the tape is there to protect my privacy. Depending on who your are, my mother's maiden name might be "sandwich" or "peanut". I never answer that question the same way twice, and all I have to do is remember the answer I gave to you. Using mnemonic association, it really is pretty easy.

Check out http://www.privacyrights.org/ for more information about your privacy and how to protect it.

We talk a lot about what corporations are doing to protect information, we need to have the conversation at the individual level. And we need to become willing to look at some unpretty truths about how the world is working these days. We can't just stick our heads in the sand.

by danlm

I met my current wife on IRC, which I still frequent. Bot nets pretty much started there.

First, it was script kiddies running applications that would flood the network with connections. But, they were all of the same ip. Or proxy ip's, which could be detected.

Then came the virus bots, which started joining irc networks and would either show a url in channel or offer to send you a file. People are stupid, they would either accept the file or click on the url. This then infected machines, which then were used to build bot nets. This was pretty much before the spam got as bad as it is now.

This was still pretty tame stuff though, because they would just attack IRC networks.

It began growing up then where they began using the bots(infected home machines) for dossing people/networks/business's. Dalnet, which had over 100,000 people connected to it was attacked(dossed) and almost taken completely off line. These bot masters would set up a fake irc network and have their infected machines join that network. The bot masters would sit in channels and issue commands to the bots in who they wanted to attack and how.

The good bot net masters had access to servers with dns. I know of a bot master that attacked our irc network with dos, and had it configured that the attacking ip's looked to originate from the server that was being attacked. The script kiddies were growing up. This specific person was finally arrested for running bot nets on foonet. The owner of this data center allowed this individual to run the bots for free, but had him attack various business's to the point that their web pages went off line.

Now, as I understand it. Bot masters have moved off irc, and now run their bot nets from web pages. I see this happening a couple different ways. They still infect machines with their bot virus via irc or spam. These bots get their commands from a web page of who to attack. The web page is probably hosted on servers that were hacked, most likely in china or other countries that don't take security seriously.

I'm sure that organized crime was watching this all and roped these people in one way or another. The script kiddies provided a new way of extortion. Now, they are training them how to do it.

Now you have freaken bots on yahoo, irc, msn, and what ever other chat networks are out their still infecting people. They learned it from IRC. What use to be pure scripting is now dedicated programming.

Yup, its a lovely world we live in. Yes it is.

Dan

by techden

According to some of the security articles on here recently, Dan, the US is still the biggest offender in terms of lousy security allowing botnets to propagate. Don't blame China, Dan - look in your own back yard first!

by danlm

I seen an article where the most drone computers or what ever you want to call them are in the United States. I also don't doubt that there are a number of compromised servers here in the U.S. either. Guess I made that statement by the number of ip's that try to brute force my home PC are from China, Korea, Indonesia.

But, your absolutely right. The U.S. is right up there on the lists that I have seen also.

Dan

by 2shane

Ohhhhh sensationalist bullshit... = drumming up biznez

Your atrical smacks of the media contraversy and speculative crap designed to wind people up and to generate web traffic.

I think your a fucking idiot.

by danlm

Just and idiot that would let the world crash around him before he opened his eyes.

Go on sheep, just keep dreaming there are not hundred's of thousands infected home pc's that are used in bot nets for spam and ddos attacks. Ignore the fact that root servers(6) were attacked by bot nets in February and went off line. yup, its sensationalism. You must not consider the deluge of email you get as spam, and not take the time to read that they are sent from infected computers which also could be/are used for bot nets.

Who's the idiot. Actually, your not an idiot. Your just stupid.

Have you checked your security logs lately stupid? Ever seen the number of ip's that probe it? Do you know how to read a security log? Do you know what an ip looks like? Do you have a clue?

Dan

by marty r. milette

Your posting is really amazing!

What rock have you been sleeping under to not have the slightest clue as to what is going on in the world?

Take a break from project management and do some reading on Internet security and the problems the world faces today.

Please do it BEFORE your next posting.

Cheers...

by pgm554

It's bad enough that a lot of users don't keep up with patches and virus updates,but when you have great number of M$ machines that are unpatched because of WGA piracy (about 36%)issues,it adds fuel to the BOT issues .

So what we have are 36% of the desktops that are becoming unpatchable ,which means there will all ways be new bots available to cause havoc.

M$,like it or not,contributes heavily to this problem by enforcing WGA.

by w2ktechman

But if the WGA is keeping 36% of systems getting updates, then it is surely that 36% of the Windows systems in use are pirated.

by pgm554

Let's say there are 100 million XP systems worldwide and according to M$,they are about 36% piracy rate.
36 million unpatched to semi patched systems.
Even at 1%,that is 360k machines that can be used to do the bot thing.
Not a small number.
M$ is damned if they don't do WGA and we are damned if they do.

by runningwolf

Not necessarily. My work machine and home machine don't have WGA on them because I don't want them phoning home and they are legit. So now you say, "If they are legit, then what's the problem?" My problem is just because MS say's they won't collect a certain type of info today, doesn't mean it's not going to happen in the future. Look what they did when they sent that crap down the pipe to every machine that had automatic updates enabled without telling the users what was coming.

by dvlhntr

thanks for the update.

last time I read this,

http://www.securityfocus.com/news/11392

article date 2006-05-17....

Blue Security was an Israeli comapny.
.... and that is just start of the things that I take issue with from that msnbc article.

I still want to know how anyone figures that "PharamaMaster" paid one Million for the attack which lead to the end of Blue Security.

Sounds like someone is taking math lessons from RIAA again. One million, yeah this prof is getting an e-mail.

by marty r. milette

The price of botnet attacks are well-known and well-established.

The price of infecting PCs is also well-known, and a good source of income for many people.

Most recently, I learned of one technician in a Russian computer store that was being paid $.50 for every computer he could infect.

His system -- incredibly devious and effective: When building up a computer to ship to a customer, include an infected driver disk. The customer would install the bot software themselves!

I happened to have purchased some computers for the office and discovered this as I was building up the new systems. Install windows, install the drivers, POOF - machine infected. (Before even having a chance to connect it to the Internet.)

Prices of stolen IDs, credit card numbers and everything else in this underworld are well known -- if you move in these kind of circles.

by mwradio

I wish I could find it again. There was I guy right here on TR that put a new Motherboard in his Dell because the old one croaked. He then lost his activation on that copy of XP. (While I was looking for that one I found several similar cases for other manufacturers!)
Dell wouldn't help him and Microsoft told him he had to buy a new O/S License!
Now, I know that he could have backed up his data and reinstalled the O/S from his recovery CD and it would have been accepted just fine again with the new Mobo because it would have a Dell BIOS identifier. But he did not know that. And of course even that would have been hard to do unless he has a second hard drive to back the data up to, Or the system still runs in anything but safe mode so you can burn to CD's. Or you have tools that allow you to do so from another source ie. Ultimate Boot Disc 4 Windows. But the average user doesn't know this. Plus all the hours repatching the system afterwards. And does anybody know... can you still Get patches from Windows Update for a XP machine reinstalled with a System Restore disk that is pre SP1? Haven't they gone beyond "Lifecycle"? Don't you have to at least get it up to SP1 somehow?
(I don't have this problem... yet... because I have an SP2 disc.)

So at this point you have a guy out there who has lost his system or goes to a cracked system with no patches due to WGA and product activation!

Do the math... this kind of horror story could account for a Lot of the "36% pirated systems".

by w2ktechman

MS crossed the line with WGA, there are probably ( I do not have the stats) less people that purposely killed it than are pirated. However, many of the pirated versions are probably from people who thought that they were getting the real deal.
Since you disabled the patching, you would/should be responsible for your system, not MS.
Anyone who tried patching their system and could not should be responsible for contacting MS and working out the issue, or moving to a different OS.

And I do agree with you, I do not trust MS either. I used to laugh at Windows Update when it flashed the message that No Information was being sent to Microsoft. But then how would Windows Update know what you had installed on your system???

But to say that MS should be responsible is wrong, at least for this argument.
They are however contributing to the problem, and should be responsible for all of the browser scripting additions and putting the browser INTO the OS in the first place.

This discussion is closed to new replies.