Discussion Locked

why can't I ping the other computers?

0 helpful
28 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Using 10/100 fast ethernet NIC's and a 10/100 switch with 3 computers in my home network.Have uninstalled and reinstalled all protocols:IPX/SPX,NETBEUI,TCP/IP.Assigned address's to TCP/IP(192.168.0.xx Subnet mask 255.255.255.0).can internal loop ping using both 127.0.0.1 and the assigned addresses.can share files and printers with all computers.CAN'T PING THE OTER COMPUTERS.I want to be able to share a dial-up internet connection and to do this TCP/IP must be able to ping the other computers.Ihave removed and installed the NIC's into other slots and reinstalled the drivers,can still share files and printers but no pinging of the other computers.Have I left out some important detail?

28 replies

by timwalsh

Multiple protocols are probably part of your problem. You need TCP/IP if you are going to access the Internet. NetBEUI comes in handy in a Win9X network. You don't need IPX/SPX unless you are running Novell or a specific application requires it.
I'm assuming you are pinging IP addresses and not computer names. What type of replies are you receiving - "destination host unknown" or "request timed out"? Will none of the computers successfully ping the others or does only one computer have this problem?

If you are able to share files and printers, it isn't a connectivity issue. Therefore, moving NICs and reinstalling frivers won/t resolve your problem. Remove IPX/SPX and try pinging.

by meafixall

I am pinging the IP address that are assigned and I receive the reply "request timed out" all computers have the same status.In the past and when I first installed the NIC's I could not see the computers in network neighborhood, therefore unable to share files,When using only TCP/IP.After installing NETBEUI I could network.

by meafixall

I am pinging the IP address that are assigned and I receive the reply "request timed out" all computers have the same status.In the past and when I first installed the NIC's I could not see the computers in network neighborhood, therefore unable to share files,When using only TCP/IP.After installing NETBEUI I could network.

by meafixall

I am pinging the IP address that are assigned and I receive the reply "request timed out" all computers have the same status.In the past and when I first installed the NIC's I could not see the computers in network neighborhood, therefore unable to share files,When using only TCP/IP.After installing NETBEUI I could network.

by meafixall

I am pinging the IP address that are assigned and I receive the reply "request timed out" all computers have the same status.In the past and when I first installed the NIC's I could not see the computers in network neighborhood, therefore unable to share files,When using only TCP/IP.After installing NETBEUI I could network.

by meafixall

I am pinging the IP address that are assigned and I receive the reply "request timed out" all computers have the same status.In the past and when I first installed the NIC's I could not see the computers in network neighborhood, therefore unable to share files,When using only TCP/IP.After installing NETBEUI I could network.

by greybeard770

Sparta makes a very good point. More protocols is not always better. Start out simple. If you can share files by computer name, you don't see the whole name resolution process. It sounds like you are talking about Internet Connection Sharing. Try letting the other computers get their IP address from the modem sharing computer.

And first chance you get, get broadband and a NAT router.

by meafixall

I am using Zone Alarm.Could this be the problem?When assigning the ip address's zone alarm asks if the "new network" can gain access.

by meafixall

I am using Zone Alarm.Could this be the problem?When assigning the ip address's zone alarm asks if the "new network" can gain access.

by meafixall

I am using Zone Alarm.Could this be the problem?When assigning the ip address's zone alarm asks if the "new network" can gain access.

by meafixall

I am using Zone Alarm.Could this be the problem?When assigning the ip address's zone alarm asks if the "new network" can gain access.

by meafixall

I am using Zone Alarm.Could this be the problem?When assigning the ip address's zone alarm asks if the "new network" can gain access.

by mikemunnelly

Your network has to many protocols. The network is using either the IPX or NetBeui to share the files and printers. Right now, the TCP/IP is not working at all. Remove the IPX and Netbuei from all machines. Make sure that all machines have microsoft client services, TCP/IP as a protocol, and the ethernet card. Reboot each system in the network one at a time. When you have rebooted, check to make sure that the tab marked "default protocol" in the network configuration is checked (or grayedout, and checked). To simplify things, make sure the workgroup names are the same for all machines and that each machine has a distinct computer name.

The other problems you may be having could be related to the winsock.dll or winsck32.dll drivers you are using. Sometimes the "stack" gets corrupted, and the files need to be overwritten. Pulling off the driver and then reinstalling it, saying yes to all the "are you sure you wish to overwrite these files" will fix any common stack problems. I have seen cases where all the files have to be deleted and then the TCP/IP networking components reinstalled.

by acattr

YES. I can't stand that software. Especially when I try to connect to my clients over pcanywhere and they have it running. try disabling it and see what happens.

by 2nickles

As others have suggested, it is probably the ZoneAlarm software that is blocking the ICMP requests. Disable the software, and try pinging again. If the pings work, then it's a configuration problem with the ZoneAlarm Software. I'm not real familiar with the software, but I think that you have to add your other computers to the "trusted zone" (you can add an address range) to allow ICMP between them. Use the help files to configure this.

by meafixall

I have cleaned out ZoneAlarm from the system and still cannot ping the other computers..When I remove the NETBEUI I can no longer see the other computers in network neighborhood.

by meafixall

Thanks for all the suggestions,still not able to ping the other computers.I have removed all network related software and hardware,the ZoneAlarm software,and Naviscope which is a software proxy server.I then installed the Dial up Networking,the NIC with tcp/ip andstill not able to ping nor share files.Can only share files when NETBEUI is installed.I have no problem pinging sites on the internet.When using ipconfig all the info is correct.Route Print also shows all OK.I am at a total loss,I have looked at some friends home networks and found them to have the same setup,only on those machines I can ping the other computers.Just not able to see what is different.Is it possible that the NIC's from Linksys have a bug in them?

by mbatty

SOunds like you have tried most of the usual fixes. Tme to go back to basics. Before connecting to the Internet you need to get to a stage where all your machines on you rhome netowrk can talk to each other. As stated in previous answers, Firewall software will junk ping packets as default, so switch it off on all machines.

I assume that you are using 192.168.0.xx for the LAN cards on all machines. I cannot tell if you are using a DHCP server, so for testing purposes configure a static address in each machine. i.e make Internet PC 192.168.0.1, PC(A) 192.168.0.2, etc, using the TCP/IP properties in network neighbourhood for the LAN adapter.

This should give you basic IP connectivity on your LAN and a ping to the IP addrees should work. IPCONFIG is a good command for looking at the running IP settings,also NETSTAT -RN will show you the IP routing table in your machine. Try these out to debug your problem.

by meafixall

I am not using a DHCP server.I have assigned the computers the ip address's as you indicated.(I believe you meant "network configuration",in control panel,not network neighborhood).I have stated all this before,Iknow it should work as is but it doesn't.I will get a new NIC and see if it could be a hardware problem.

by 2nickles

Now this is a fun one. All the previous answers should have isolated the problem, but as of yet haven?t. Your last comment you said that you were going to get a new NIC, from what I seen I don?t think that you NIC is bad, but there might be a compatibility issue. You have three computers that can all see each other through the NETBEUI protocol, but cannot ping via TCP/IP, correct?

Lets get some more information:

PC(A) ? What operating system; what type of NIC; IP Address 192.168.0.1PC(B) ? What operating system; what type of NIC; IP Address 192.168.0.2

PC(C) ? What operating system; what type of NIC; IP Address 192.168.0.3

When loading the drivers, are you using the drivers provided by the NIC manufacturer or the Windowsprovided drivers?

If you do not already have one pickup a crossover cable for testing purposes. Make sure it is a crossover (pin 1 to pin 3, pin 2 to pin 6) cable and not a rollover cable (pins 1-8, 2-7, 3-6, 4-5).
With this cable you can hook up two computers from your network, back to back. Thus eliminating several variables, the switch, the other computer, the patch cables. I really don?t think that this is a physical layer problem, but it will be easier to isolate with only two computers in the scenario.

by meafixall

Correct!NETBEUI connects and shares files.Cannot ping other computers,can ping myself on all but not the others.All have win98_se OS.The cards are as follows: LINKSYS 10/100network card(NC100),LINKSYS 10/100LAN card(LNE100TX v.5),3com EtherLink 111(pcmica 10base-t)3c589c..The NIC cards are using the drivers supplied by Linksys and the pcmica card is self installing.Have tried the crossover cable and get the same results.Don't have a clue as where to go from here.

by jennchye

Did you check if the address resolution protocol, ARP is able to resolve your IP address to the MAC address of your NIC?

Do a arp -a on any machine after a ping test. The resolved MAC address shown have to be the same as the destination machine'sNIC.

by meafixall

After pinging and getting the message: Request timed out? I then did the arp/a and received the following text on one machine

Interface 192.168.0.2 on Interface 0x1000002
Internet address physical address type
192.168.0.1 00-04-5a-62-82-02 Dynamic

On the other computer

Interface 192.168.0.1 on Interface 0x2000003
Internet address physical address type
192.168.0.2 00-04-5a-72-3f-6a Dynamic

Now what doesthis tell you about my system?

by wlbowers

Dump everything on the networking except tcp/ip. Now go buy a SMC7004ABR Router Gateway. www.smc.com

The Barricade? is an ideal all-in-one networking solution for home and small business users. This platform independent multi-functional broadbandrouter combines a 4-port 10/100 Mbps dual-speed switch, a built-in print server, an RS232 COM port for fail-over dial-up or modem connections, an Internet firewall for security against hackers and other unauthorized users, and simultaneous Internet access for up to 253 users.

The RS232 port is the kicker. It allows you to network connect to a desktop modem or IDSN.

Good Luck Lee

by meafixall

This is not quite the type of info that I think is appropriate for the question.You want to add new hardware that should not be necessary. Many people are able to connect and Ping without any extra hardware,just a crossover cable with two computers works for them.Why not for me?

by meafixall

This is the answer that solved the problem.There was a vxd file left in from ZoneAlarm which was preventing the connections to ping.This file is "vsdata95.vxd" The file was removed in DOS before booting.Then there was the message that the file was missing,I continued to boot and removed the reg key using the "find" in regedit.Actually I am using a great reg editor called "VilmaRegestryEditor" it is freeware,I suggest that anyone that does work with the registry try this program.The problems that I had are gone and I am able to share my dial-up connection now.Thanks for everyones help and I hope this info will help the next suckker that uses ZoneAlarm.Personally I prefer BlackIce.

This discussion is closed to new replies.