Discussion Locked

Why do people pay taxes on their labor to the IRS?

0 helpful
249 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Since your labor, and the income paid to you in the fair exchange of your labor for money, is not taxable, then why do people fall for the scam of paying a tax on it?

Fact #1: It has been shown time and again that our Constitution prohibits this tax.

Fact #2: The IRS, in it's attempt to get you to pay this "voluntary donation" is guilty of extortion.

Fact #3: Not ONE DIME of the money collected by the IRS from the "graduated income tax" pay for any government service. In other words we get zero from that payment. NOTHING.

Fact #4: Your employer does NOT have to withhold part of your wages. The IRS rules (not laws, as there is no such thing as "IRS Law"), states only how to do it IF both you your employer chooses to do so.

Fact #5: All "tax" accountants and Lawyers are schooled by the IRS. They tell them HOW to do it all legally, and under the IRS rules. They are never told that you don't have to.

Do you think for one second that H&R Block would tell you you don't have to pay the tax?
Why would they tell you you don't need to come to them and pay their fee every year?

----- Don't pay anyone to help you learn this... Go find out for yourself. -----

You may fall for this, as do so many other people, because you don't find out for yourself, you assume the news, and your peers are correct, and so the myth propagates.

This country was started under the premise "of the people, by the people, and for the people" which assumed that "the people" would learn what our government was, and what all the rules were. We have become a country run by ignorant idiots, methinks, by proxy.

Even the news media (used to be mostly factual) is now so biased and hateful, and talking to such ignorant people, that we are all falling for tremendous lies. Why else would anyone not laugh at Al Gores book on global warming, or Michael Moore's book on the 9/11 tragedy. They are factually wrong, and certainly should not be bought as they were sold, as "documentaries".

I think the answer to my question is one of four possibilities, or a combination of them:

1. The "people" are too lazy to find out."
2. The "people" are too scared to not pay the extortion.
3. The "people" are afraid to go against their peers.
4. Too embarrassed to admit that they have been screwed.

What say you?

Quote:

http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=56855

http://www.newsbusters.org/node/14077

And many other sources.

"The Internal Revenue Service has lost a lawyer's challenge in front of a jury to prove a constitutional foundation for the nation's income tax, and the victorious attorney now is setting his sights higher.

"I think now people are beginning to realize that this has got to be the largest fraud, backed up by intimidation and extortion and by the sheer force of taking peoples property and hard-earned money without any lawful authorization whatsoever," lawyer Tom Cryer told WND just days after a jury in Louisiana acquitted him of two criminal tax counts. "

Link: http://www.truthattack.org/cryer_MEMORANDUM.pdf

There are hundreds more cases like this.
When are YOU going to stop paying the extortion?

Or, do you already know better?

Like this Ex-IRS enforcement officer:

http://www.freedomabovefortune.com/

Still don't believe me?
Watch this 15 min. video featuring another IRS official:
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=1616088001333580937

Here is a law professors analysis of the court case (with many references):
http://www.w3f.com/patriots/tomcryer.html

This explains more:
http://www.getonyoursoapbox.com/node/49

What say you?
If this is all true, why do so many pay?

249 replies

by cactus pete

If the Congress enacts the tax law, and the Administration enforces the law, and the Supreme Court upholds the validity of the law, then yes, I think it's considered constitutional and you have to pay.

Good luck, though.

by johnbeaman

Because there is none.

The only laws you can show me are those you break when you violate a contract.

Your 1040 is a contract.

They can always find an issue with you not fulfilling your contract with them. Ask 10 different IRS employees the same question and you will get 11 different answers, because they don't know, they intrepret the "code" incorrectly, or just want to screw with you. FACT!

Go find me the law. There is a $50,000 reward if you can.

Yes, you think it is required because you are too lazy to find out the truth.

That is my point.

by cactus pete

You didn't address what I said at all. If the three branches of government all agree that I have to pay, I don't have a choice.

I am not going to spend the money and time necessary to fight something that has been lost in court time after time.

But all my best to you in your endeavors.

by charliespencer

Please provide links to references supporting your assertions and facts. Please post a link to the news article you quoted; I can't find it.

"Not ONE DIME of the money collected by the IRS from the "graduated income tax" pay for any government service."

Then who's paying my military retirement?

by johnbeaman

Well, none of it comes from the "graduated Income Tax".

Go back and read fact #3.

Ever notice when you make out a check, it is to the "Internal Revenue Service" for federal taxes.

Also notice that your refund comes from the "Treasury Department".

Guess what?

The money goes only one way, to the IRS.

Go do your homework. Find out where it goes.
You will be surprised.

And we don't need a flat tax to replace the Income Tax. We get NOTHING for it anyway. It is just more money to the theves.

BTW, I think your salary comes from money they steal from the social security fund anyway. You might check that out.

by charliespencer

"Well, none of it comes from the 'graduated Income Tax'."

That's not an answer. It's perfectly acceptable to say, "I don't know", when you don't know.

Ever notice when you make out a check, it is to the Franchise Tax Board."

Every U.S. income tax check I've ever made out was payable to "Internal Revenue Service".

"Go do your homework. Find out where it goes ... I think your salary comes from money they steal from the social security fund anyway. You might check that out.

Many of your assertions are unsupported. When questioned, your most frequent response, both here and on other threads, seems to be "Do your homework". If you have supporting material, please provide it. The "Do your homework" response gives the appearance you have no supporting material and are hoping someone else will turn something up for you. I'm sure I am mistaken in this impression.

by mfhawn

This is a tax protester-type argument that has been litigated hundreds of times in the courts and every case has been sided against the tax protester. In fact, you can get slapped with a hefty civil penalty for raising these ridiculous issues.

First of all, when paying taxes, the payee USED to be Interal Revenue Service. The Internal Revenue Service is under the Department of the Treasury, which is now the payee for income taxes. The switch from IRS to Dept of Treasury was not done for legal reasons.

As far as authority, I believe it was the 16th Amendment to the Constitution. Under Article I, Section 8, Congress is given the power to lay and collect taxes.

I'm no fan of the IRS, but what can you do. It's the law.

Oh, and the money DOES go into the treasury.

by w2ktechman

taking my money just for retirement!!! Ma'an, what a waste. Now I know where my money went, and I'm coming to collect!

If you dont want to see my wrath, please send me everything that you have collected previously, and I will 'forgive' this insult that you have cast on (and bragged about).
Please send payments to paypal at URASucker@paypal.com

After I receive the funds, I will 'forgive' this treachery :^0

by johnbeaman

Income Tax has nothing to do with Social Security, your retirement.

Again, go do your homework.
Find out the truth.
Don't be so gullable.

by charliespencer

I was a reservist. Unlike active duty retirees who start drawing their retirement immediately, I don't start drawing mine until I turn 60. I'd sent it to you, but by then the cost of a stamp will probably exceed the monthly stipend. If you care to send me a bunch of 'forever stamps', I'll hold them until the checks start coming in.

by charliespencer

I notice the link you added is not to the newspaper article you referenced. It is to a memorandum filed by the plaintiff in the case. It presents his arguments why he should not be liable. A link to the court's decision would carry more weight in supporting your argument.

Also, from page 5 of the memo:

"CAVEAT:

THIS MEMORANDUM WAS PREPARED AND WRITTEN FOR ONE SPECIFIC CASE AND MAY NOT APPLY TO OTHERS.

IT IS NOT OFFERED AS LEGAL ADVICE NOR AS A LEGAL OPINION RELATIVE TO ANYONE OTHER THAN THE PARTY IN THIS CASE AND FOR THE ISSUES PRESENTED BY THIS PARTICULAR PROCEEDING.

THE READER SHOULD OBTAIN INDEPENDENT ADVICE FROM A LICENSED ATTORNEY BEFORE RELYING ON THE APPLICABILITY OF ANY AUTHORITIES CITED HEREIN INSOFAR AS THEY MAY OR MAY NOT APPLY TO THE READER."

by w2ktechman

I was teasing Palmetto a bit based on his post. This was a joke post that obviously went right by you.

by charliespencer

You might want to include some Wikipedia links too. After all, they're on the Internet too, so they must be true.

I'm sorry I wasted your time, and I won't bother you again. I'll be sticking my head back in the sand now.

by johnbeaman

You head isn't stuck in the sand, it is another place where the sun doesn't shine.

Are you too lazy to look it up?

I suppose you believe Al Gore saying the sea will rise 20 feet in Florida too.

How gullable are you?
How much do you want to believe all other peoples lies?

Are you too lazy?

Is the added money you get to keep not enough?

Are you afraid of the IRS?

Follow the money....

I gave you whe World News article, and the defendants statement which explains why. You can certainly find the Plantiff's papers by looking it up on the internet.

Maybe you missed the point of all this...

The video gave the defendants perspective of the trial. His trial and being found not guilty is not the purpose of this post, nor is the news outlets where I quoted the story.

The point is that you have been misled and refuse to believe it. Your postings of trivial issues are typical of those in shock to the truth.

Watch this video:

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=1616088001333580937

by charliespencer

From Wikipedia, a source I don't take at face value, but at least they include links to source material without being asked. These are summations of other articles from WorldNetDaily, the source of your original post. I hope you can see why I question the accuracy of a web site that cites soy products as a source of homosexuality.

9/11 attacks - On September 13, 2001, WND published a commentary by Anthony C. LoBaido regarding the terrorist attacks on New York City and Washington two days earlier. In his column, LoBaido outlined what he regarded as the moral depravity of America in general and New York in particular, asking whether "God (has) raised up Shiite Islam as a sword against America".

United Airlines Flight 93 - In 2004, WND published a commentary by James Sanders entitled "The Downing of United Airlines Flight 93"[19] which proposed that, to defend Washington D.C., Flight 93 had been intercepted and shot with a missile by a military aircraft. It also alleged that the government had tried to cover up this information. The article stated:

"Witnesses to this low-flying jet ... told their story to journalists. Shortly thereafter, the FBI began to attack the witnesses with perhaps the most inane disinformation ever--alleging the witnesses actually observed a private jet at 34,000 ft. The FBI says the jet was asked to come down to 5000 ft. and try to find the crash site. This would require about 20 minutes to descend."[19]

According to a Popular Mechanics article entitled "Debunking the 9/11 Myths",[20] which mentions WorldNetDaily, there was a low flying jet in the vicinity on descent into Johnstown.

Soy/homosexuality link claim - WorldNetDaily published an editorial[33] in December 2006 written by Jim Rutz of "Megashift Ministries" where he claimed that eating soy at a young age increases the chance that a child will be gay, and that soy's estrogen content will feminize a young boy. Rusk is not a doctor or nutritionist, but has founded his own church. His claims are contradicted by research done by scientists at the University of Pennsylvania.[34] The article was referenced by Frank Rich in a New York Times op-ed piece on December 17, 2006, describing the reaction to homosexuality in the Republican Party.[35] The liberal advocacy organization People For the American Way mocked Rutz's claims in their online "RightWing Watch" feature, commenting "sometimes you just have to marvel at the things published by WorldNetDaily."[36] In response to the interest in the article, WorldNetDaily later published columns by Rutz providing documentation to back up his claims

Alleged North American Union - During the debate over the failed 2007 Immigration Bill, WND popularized opposition to an alleged "North American Union," a dystopian vision of a future America merged with Mexico. [4] WND blames a "shadow government" in the form of the Council on Foreign Relations for the alleged NAU plot. CFR Conspiracy theories are not a new phenomenon. The "North American Union" is considered a conspiracy theory by popular conservatives such as Michael Medved [5], and has been disputed in the mainstream media. [6]

Links to the original WND articles are available at

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worldnetdaily

See, I did the work so you won't have to.

by johnbeaman

If you have some time, watch this video:

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-1656880303867390173

The problem here is that it never says "you do not have to pay", and that is part of the deception.

Example, like the argument about "no WMD", I could also say, that Bin Laden MUST NOT EXIST because we haven't found him too.

We all know better.

Another example, Prove to me that you didn't curse 5 minutes ago. Silly, but valid.

You can't prove that either.

Asking me for proof means you want me to do it for you. I am not going to do that. You have let all your peers, parents, government, tax people, etc, do your homework for you in the past, and you can see what it has gotten you. (Assuming I am right.) You still pay the IRS.

Why would you believe me anyway?

How much proof do you need beyone the article I wrote? Did you even read it? Or check out the links? I suppose not.... Alas...

So, I can offer proof for days, and you will still question it, and continue to pay the extorsion for the reasons in post#1.

Maybe you actually will look into it, and realize how many people have been screwed.

I hope you learn the truth on your own, and compell your friends to also learn it. Just
telling them doesn't work.

Again: There is no law that says you have to file a 1040, or pay the graduated income tax.

You find the Law that says you do, and maybe you can collect the $50,000 reward that has been outstanding for over 20 years.

by charliespencer

"Why would you believe me anyway? How much proof do you need beyone the article I wrote? Did you even read it? Or check out the links?"

I read your article. Indeed, why would I believe you? You posted two links, both to material provided by the plaintiff in the case. That can hardly be considered impartial.

"Asking me for proof means you want me to do it for you."

You're the one trying to convince us, not the other way around. By undertaking the task, you assume the burden. Instead of the two biased links, you could have just as easily included links to the court decision.

"I can offer proof for days, and you will still question it..."

Again, you haven't offered proof; you've told me to go look for it. All you have offered is two biased links and repeated unsupported assertions.

Incidentally, Googling the terms

$50000 "tax law" reward

yielded no applicable entries in the first 25 results.

by johnbeaman

http://community.myfoxboston.com/blogs/Bob_Ward/2007/06/07/Tax_Standoff_in_NH

http://sierratimes.com/cgi-bin/ikonboard/topic.cgi?forum=22&topic=25

http://www.givemeliberty.org/features/taxes/usatoday.htm
Says that:

http://www.anti-irs.com/irs_court_cases.html
Offered the reward.

You are missing the point of this post.
It is trying to get YOU to find out the truth.

You have been lied to by people you trust for years.

I am telling you that they were lied to you as well.

You need to find out the truth for yourself.
That is the whole point.

by the scummy one

OTR had a thread about this with plenty of links and discussions already.

In my personal searching, it would appear that 13 states were said to have ratified the tax, but had not (or not done properly). Some of them did ratify it, but it was illegal for those states to (by state law).

All in all, it appears that the tax is illegal. However, all of this was found on conspiracy theorists sites, and none from governmental sites. But this would be expected considering the topic.

Anyway, I did not look deeply enough, because I have lots of other things going on. I will say that, there was not enough proof out there to get me to stop paying and risk prison, whether I liked the tax or not. Besides, if everyone stopped paying the tax, then how would our curent troop deployments get funded (or would we just forget about them?)?

by charliespencer

Not since I read your third "fact" that tax collections didn't fund government services. That's the exact moment you lost me. Somebody paid for those howitzers I directed for twenty years. If it wasn't the taxpayers, who was it? The manufacturer sure didn't give them to Uncle Sugar for free.

by dr dij

by repeating obviously false 'facts'. If the IRS doesn't have power of law, how were they able to garnish my wages when I didn't pay enuf taxes after a consulting gig?

Instead of trying to convince people of something that is obviously not correct, why don't you work on the real issue? The huge size of the federal govt.

The way the US govt and tax system works, taxes are never reduced more than a tiny amount and only temporarily. Plus with the power of borrowing they can put us in debt our grandchildren will have to pay off. And they have power of creating money, which immediately devalues everyone elses money at that point since the act of creating paper money doesn't create goods and services.

Give up this stupid bent and become a libertarian. Do something useful. Propose radical changes. How about:

term limits

capitol hill legislators can't get raises in years that taxes go up

eliminate ability to create bogus currency thru the fed

eliminate unrelated bills combined into one. i.e. they have to vote on any substantially unrelated bills separately. - this was done in Colorado state legislature

limit govt spending to the amount collected PREVIOUS year, since they just make up figures that they 'project' will come in , that are ridiculous, and exceed them anway

do not allow states to borrow to speculate in the market (happenend in orange county, ca and they lost big on it, really stupid idea)

limit ability of large companies to file lawsuits in US if they are not headquartered here and don't pay taxes here

From Palmetto, some obvious ones I should have put down:

no tax breaks / subsidies to biz. The tax rate will be lower if these are enacted. They don't need special treatment.

no special subsidies: we are subsidizing tobacco growers yet trying to stop smoking.

we are subsidizing sugar in florida with price controls yet only the sugar industry wants this, not the drink makers, and it is ruining our everglades in the process with fertilizer runoff and pesticides, heavy water use.

Municipalities / cities / states can not give tax incentives for mfgrs to move there in any form not directly related public use such as roads. NO free land or below cost land. No tax breaks for 10 years.... This subsidization means that the benefit from the company moving there is largely nullified so thro out these subsidies.

and some more radical ideas:
if you are forced to pay taxes, why not let you decide which programs get your money?
(details to be worked out) This would eliminate people wanting endless non-existant money spent on their pet cause / disease / project. Instead they could influence the total sum of money spent on their pet project and it would be only whatever was either allocated in votes or most popular. (this gets people to decide priorities between one or the other rather than vapidly saying 'fund both'). Total $ would be limited to be included in a balanced federal budget. (they could not spend more)

vote on politicians based on their proclaimed issues. e.g. if Bush was voted in on 'no new taxes' and he stupidly voted to raise them, anyone could call for quick immediate removal based on subterfuge / false pretenses. Politicians would be welcome to change their minds, they'd just have to have the change of heart back in private biz, not in the legislature.

No micromanaging of depts: e.g. politicians could not stop a dept from prosecuting a crime such as shoddy dam wiping out a town in Georgia. Bush admin came into power and canned the prosecution.

No pardon powers. This looks totally scummy. eliminate it.

Politicians could not make public statements unrelated to public policy. This seems a bit harsh but it is not their job to 1) legislate morality if they are not proposing a bill on this, 2) suggest consumer spending habits as some really stupid poli did recently, suggesting we go on spending binges to help the economy. (excuse me while I barf). THey do this regularly.

eliminate ability of people to vote on an issue they are not paying for. THis would prevent recipients of pork, transfer payments from being able to vote on increasing such payments which reduces what caused downfall in Rome, they subsized welfare class to uphold their power, at the expense of farmers and those outside the city. Farmers finally wouldn't ship grain to rome as the inflated currency was worthless.

LImit the ability to borrow long term for daily operational needs.

educational reqts for legislatures: the chinese did this for years. This could certainly help weed out some of the stupider govt employees in positions of control.

eliminate ALL govt worker pensions (partially vested will be bought out with deposits to 401ks like Chile did to social security system).

replace this with 1) forced 10% contributions to 401k for them and 2) govt matching of some % of this. This would eliminate the very incredibly sad and scarey case of state govts lying about amounts in their employee pension funds (NJ state is prime example of this, find numerous articles about it this year)

many more ideas could be implemented.
while some may sound outlandish, like 'Obi-Wan-Kenobi', they are our only hope. We've already started down the steep slope of decline and govt actions will only increase that slide.

by johnbeaman

The Graduated Income tax, on peoples wages did not pay for your weapons.

I am a taxpayer too. I pay all kinds of taxes, directly and indirectly, but NONE of the Income tax pays for any of that.

It's like people that say we would have no roads, and bridges. Well, That money comes from the gasolene taxes, not the income taxes.

Again you have to follow the money, and I am sorry you thought it helped pay for your howitzers, because it went no where near that.

by jdclyde

How long has it been since YOU have filed a tax return?

Have you requested a full refund from previous years that you DID pay taxes?

Good luck in a federal lockdown.

by johnbeaman

1. How long has it been since YOU have filed a tax return?

24 years.

2. Have you requested a full refund from previous years that you DID pay taxes?

Only for the back three, in 1983 as filing a 1040x can only go back that far as allowed in my previous contracts with the IRS. (They have a statute of limitations. I would have to sue them for extorsion to get it all back. Some people have been successful, I have heard, but have no references.)

3. Good luck in a federal lockdown.

You falling for that extortion crap again?

Still Don't believe me?
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=1616088001333580937

You remind me of the girl in yellow in this video.

by charliespencer

You start a topic with a controversial position and no supporting data except what you went back and added after I questioned you. Your sources include a biased attorney / defendant, several less-than-credible web site, and a blog entry about a convicted tax evader's arrest fears. No unbiased sources, no court decisions, no appeals court filings by the IRS, no opinions from state bar associations, tax law groups, or legal schools. No proof for any of the "facts" in your original posts. The custom here at TR is that the poster bears the burden of proof, not the readers.

You opine that maybe I don't get the point. Apparently I don't. What is it? What do you care if I pay taxes? And the tax money isn't being spent to fund federal govenment activities, what's it being spent on?

by johnbeaman

Bruce Willis as John McClaine said that to Hans in a Die Hard movie.

1. The IRS is a private Deleware Corporation paid by the Treasury Department as a collections agency.

2. They have no Law that says you have to follow the IRS Code, which is not Law.
Unless you file a 1040 which now becomes a contract to which many laws and the IRS code (included in this contract by definition) then apply.

3. The money does NOT go into the treasury, It gets paid to the Word Bank for the interest-only on our national debt. This paper/contract was sold to the World Bank.

4. The 16 Amendment summary says "no changes were made to the tax law by passing this ammenemdnt." It was only a clarification.

5. The Congress has that power, you are correct, but it cannot do so against the Constitution.

Would you like me to go on? Do I need to find out all the references for you?

Again, you are only parroting what you hear. Most of it is lies and BUll$#it or ignorant parroting. Find out for yourself. Tom Cryer did, and 100 million others as I have heard too, so can you.

by mfhawn

1. The IRS is a private Deleware Corporation paid by the Treasury Department as a collections agency. That is the most moronic statement I have ever read regarding the Internal Revenue Service.
2. They have no Law that says you have to follow the IRS Code, which is not Law.Wrong again. Public Law 83-591, 68A Stat. 3. Look it up.
3. The money does NOT go into the treasury, It gets paid to the Word Bank for the interest-only on our national debt. This paper/contract was sold to the World Bank. Wrong again. That's a myth from an imprisoned tax protester.
4. The 16 Amendment summary says "no changes were made to the tax law by passing this ammenemdnt." It was only a clarification. The 16th Amendment did clarify Congress' power to levy and collect tax, so I don't see how you think that supports your position.
5. The Congress has that power, you are correct, but it cannot do so against the Constitution. Show me the prohibition against income tax.

by johnbeaman

1. The IRS is a private Delaware Corporation paid by the Treasury Department as a collections agency. That is the most moronic statement I have ever read regarding the Internal Revenue Service.

Did you look up their Corporation Statement?
I think not, or you wouldn't have stated this error. Do I have to present the entire package? I was only trying to get people to find out for themselves.

2. They have no Law that says you have to follow the IRS Code, which is not Law. Wrong again. Public Law 83-591, 68A Stat. 3. Look it up.

There is no Law. You have to follow the "code" ONLY if you choose to enter into a contract with the IRS, but there is no law that requires you to enter into a contract with a third party. The IRS "code" is not Law or they would call it that.

3. The money does NOT go into the treasury, It gets paid to the Word Bank for the interest-only on our national debt. This paper/contract was sold to the World Bank.
Wrong again. That's a myth from an imprisoned tax protester.

Show me where it goes if you don't believe me. It goes to pay the interest on our printed money. It pays for no funded services. It goes to the Federal Reserve. The Federal Reserve is not a government agency. It is no more "Federal" than Federal Express". Again weasel wording to make you think it is your obligation to be fleeced.

4. The 16 Amendment summary says "no changes were made to the tax law by passing this amendment." It was only a clarification. The 16th Amendment did clarify Congress' power to levy and collect tax, so I don't see how you think that supports your position.

It was a clarification on what taxes they were allowed by the Constitution.
Income Tax is not one of them. It is a generic statement, that is required by law to include the already stated underlying laws, most importantly, our Constitution. Here is some history:

US Constitution says:
1. Direct tax must be apportioned (divided equally amongst the people)
2. All indirect taxes must be the same (uniform) throughout all the states.

. The Income tax now does not meet either definition.
. Congress started trying to institute an income tax in 1894, Supreme Court ruled Not 4. Constitutional !
. 1916-23 Many Supreme Court cases shows 16th amended provides no new power of taxation.

Uh, that means that the "income Tax" cannot be made law according to the Constitution. It can ask for you money, and you can volunteer it, but there is no LAW that says you have to pay. The only "LAW" is that which pertains to HOW you must do it according to your VOLUNTARY contract with the IRS.

The 16th Ammendment cannot contradict those oints, but are inherently included.

Go look up the citations yourself.

5. The Congress has that power, you are correct, but it cannot do so against the Constitution. Show me the prohibition against income tax.

Uh, again:
US Constitution says:
Direct tax must be apportioned (divided equally amongst the people)
All indirect taxes must be the same (uniform) throughout all the states.
The Income tax now does not meet either definition.
Congress started trying to institute an income tax in 1894, Supreme Court ruled Not Constitutional !
1916-23 Many Supreme Court cases shows 16th amended provides no new power of taxation.

Taxing your income is never stated because it cannot be done. Show me where it says that a person, living in the 50 States, a Citizen of this country, has to pay a tax on his income. You cannot.

All you can find is summaries, and weasel wording. Why would the 1040 say "voluntary compliance" instead of "income tax law? Because paying the income tax is voluntary and not required by law.

Again you only have the superficial position with little or no facts, only passed on parroting, and pieces.

Again, I claim this is all true, and recommend you find out for yourself instead of being extorted. If you choose to voluntarily pay this request by the IRS, then you are being robbed by your own ignorant choice.

by maecuff

It's not the first post I've seen with that title. Have a suggestion for you. Instead of 'beep', try using 'ding dong', it's more appropriate. In your case.

by johnbeaman

Are you saying the article is wrong?
Are you criticizing WND, or the facts I state?
Typical, if you cant refute the facts stated, you attack the messenger.

Facts:

Corporate income taxes, which are constitutionally legal, provide for the lion?s share of [appropriated] military spending. Personal Federal Income Tax goes to servicing the national (i.e., Federal Government?s) debt to the Federal Reserve Bank, which is a private enterprise. Personal Income Tax is not used ?for helping the government to build the society? as Kris seems to think, but to repay a loan created to print money since the Federal Reserve Act took money creation away from the government and gave it to the private bankers.

US Constitution says:
Direct tax must be apportioned (divided equally amongst the people)
All indirect taxes must be the same (uniform) throughout all the states.

The Income tax now does not meet either definition.
Congress started trying to institute an income tax in 1894, Supreme Court ruled Not Constitutional !
1916-23 Many Supreme Court cases shows 16th amended provides no new power of taxation.
Supreme Court says your labor is your property.
The government can tax on profits & gains, not labor and wages.

Now, disprove these facts, don't attack the WND. Thats childish.

BTW, I didn't get my quote from wikipedia, they just quoted the same source, it's all over the internet on other news websites.

You don't like WND? Click this one http://www.newsbusters.org/node/14077
The issue is about the message, not the messenger.

by charliespencer

"Facts:

Corporate income taxes, which are constitutionally legal, provide for the lion?s share of [appropriated] military spending. Personal Federal Income Tax goes to servicing the national (i.e., Federal Government?s) debt to the Federal Reserve Bank, which is a private enterprise."

Once again, I'm asking you to support your statement. Please provide some source showing that corporate taxes go into a different account than personal taxes. If all the checks are payable to Dept. of Treasury, how do they sort them out? (I stand corrected on making them payable to the IRS, but it's been several years since my withholdings didn't cover my taxes.)

"Are you saying the article is wrong?
Are you criticizing WND, or the facts I state?"

Yes, all of the above. Based on a half-dozen other WND articles I read this afternoon, I have no reason to believe this one either. Since this is the initial source you've provided on this particular court case (most of your other sources refer to other cases), then I'm also saying your "facts" are wrong.

So what's the deal, your boy Cryer beats a rap and you think his case will apply to all of us? Why aren't the thousands of convicted tax evaders hiring lawyers and filing appeals? Why aren't hundred of tax lawyers taking out ads in the Wall Street Journal offering to start class action suits? If this case created a precedent allowing us all to quit paying taxes, wouldn't it be all over television, newspapers, personal finance magazines, somewhere other than the less-than-trustworthy Internet?

You keep telling us to stop believing what we've been told, but the problem is all of your sources are less credible than what we've grown up hearing. Why should I believe them more than my college tax accounting professor, the corporate tax accountant where I work, or my buddy the tax lawyer in my National Guard unit?

by mfhawn

WND is definitely not a credible news source. They are constantly having to retract ludicrous claims after someone takes them to task.

by charliespencer

While we're at it, eliminate government subsidies to all private industries, including agriculture and energy. If you can't make it on your own, join the buggy whip and slide rule manufacturers. How does the "sacred" family farm differ from Joe's Shoe Repair?

Use the savings to pay off the debt we've stuck future generations with, and only then should we be talking about tax cuts.

by johnbeaman

The IRS has definitions, which everyone is expected to know when they read anything stated by iRS publications.

1. Income is equal to Gross Income which is equal to Gross Taxable Income

They have slowly eliminated the "clarification" words in order to decieve you. It looks like it worked in your case.

Again, if your wages are not taxable, (see Constitutional references in previous posts) then none of that applies to you, does it?

You are reading inapplicable documents.

Unless, of course, you volunteered to enter into a contract which is backed by Law against you violating your contract.

The IRS uses weasel words that try and convince you that what they say applies to you. Well, it only applies if you volunteer.

There is no Law that says you have to file a 1040. If you can find one, you can get rich.
No one has been able to do so in the last 25 years or so I am led to believe.

All those documents must be read with the underlying documents first.

All your links have YOU missing in the definitions of what "person" they are talking about. You have to look back to find out the "person" (class) that it applies to. You are NOT one of them.

by johnbeaman

The question of the ratification is done for that exact reason. So there will be questions, and like a magician, you don't see what is REALLY happening because you are too busy with the trivia.

You also don't hear about victories in Iraq by the media either, or stories in the media about all the WMD that WAS found either. You must consider the source.

Our troop deployment gets not one dime of the Graduated Income Tax. (or does any other government service)

You then, choose, by your own admission to be willing to pay the extortion money.

NO!, "All in all, it appears that the tax is illegal."

It is totally legal, IF YOU CHOSE TO VOLUNTARILY PAY IT!

All the people (willie Nelson included) were found guilty of tax evasion. That means he lied in his signed contract with the IRS.

Remember, Tax Avoidance is not Tax Evasion and the IRS also says it is most patriotic to pay the minimum tax allowed. (According to their code, which you, by contract, agree to, and if you violate that contract, ONLY THEN are you breaking any law.)

The point here is that there is NO LAW that says you HAVE TO volunteer!

US Constitution says:

1. Direct tax must be apportioned (divided equally amongst the people)

2. All indirect taxes must be the same (uniform) throughout all the states.

The Income tax now does not meet either definition.

Congress started trying to institute an income tax in 1894, Supreme Court ruled Not Constitutional !

1916-23 Many Supreme Court cases shows 16th amended provides no new power of taxation.

Supreme Court says your labor is your property.

The government can tax on profits & gains, not labor and wages.

But... If you volunteer to pay the extortion money....

by johnbeaman

You are skimming. Read the details.

Why you you have to pay to fight something that you don't have to do?
If you continue to file a 1040, then you have a good chance to be audited, and will suffer beyond the extortion you are now opaying.

If you don't volunteer, you get to keep your wages. If asked where is your 1040, just state the law, like I did 25 years ago, and you get to keep your own money.

My only endeavor is to show you the truth, the facts, and hope you will do your homework before you pay money and continue to get nothing in return.

by faradhi

and take your medicine like all the other nice patients before the men in the white coats come with the butterfly net and the oversized jacket.

Everyone knows that the IRS is actually a front for the Area 51 aliens. You see they have been watching us for years and they set up the IRS to fund their master plan to rob the earth of the hidden metal lithlatneium that is used to make their space crafts. I know you have never heard of lithlatneium. That is because the aliens that run the IRS keep it a secret by sending the CIA after any scientist that finds it.

FACT: Bin Laden is actually an alien that funds terrorism to distract the governments of the world from discovering their presence.

FACT: Global warming is actually a by product of the refining of the lithlatneium. It is actually happening but not from humans. It is the ALIENS.

FACT: JFK was actually killed by the Aliens because he found out about them and was going to blow the whistle in Dallas.

FACT: Elvis is still alive because he amused the aliens and he is the only human that will survive.

FACT: I write worse fiction than you.

FACT: 5 of the Supreme Court justices are actually controlled by the aliens. This is so they can keep ruling for the IRS in cases. The mind control can be used thousands of miles away.

FACT: satellites are actually mind control relay devices that allow the aliens to use their powers across the board. (Normally line of sight would be required.)

FACT: The international space station is actually a large mind control satellite that will enable the aliens to control whole cities. Current satellites only allow the control for a few people at a time.

See I can make up stories too.

Sheesh. I love conspiracy theorists.

by johnbeaman

There is no conspiracy claimed here.
Just that the Income Tax is solid law.
The problem is that you think it applies to you.
It doesn't.
That is fact.


P.S. Cute ideas, but I don't believe any of them, sorry.

by faradhi

I would provide you with proof of my assertions, but the aliens suppress all the media stories about them. I know because I have written several articles and submitted them to the Washington Post, New York Times, Los Angeles Time, Chicago Sun Times, Newsweek, Time, Rolling Stones, Playboy, and Enquirer. All returned rejection letters that say the same thing. "Please see a professional about this story." Wierd.

So I took their advice and tried to find a Professional journalist to critique the story and not one would help. They kept saying that they are not the professional that the media is talking about. I asked who is the professional? All said that they couldn't say because they were not qualified. They suggested that I see a Doctor. Now I knew that a Doctor could not help me get my article published. I wondered why would they send me to a Doctor. That is when it occurred to me that the aliens are using mind control to keep the journalists from helping and the aliens were trying to distract me.

Then I thought, how could the aliens be controlling the journalists during the day when they don't have line of sight from the moon. The moon is their base of operations. That is when I discovered that they must be bouncing their mind control rays off satellites.

Now, you may be asking how I am unaffected by
the mind control. Well a mixture of ketoconazole and Zinc pyrithione liberally applied to the scalp will deflect the mind control.

Hey, I have provided the same amount of credible proof that you have. I have looked at the other posts and have yet to see you provide any credible proof to your claims.

And yes you are making the assertion so you have to provide the proof.

by johnbeaman

by repeating obviously false 'facts'. If the IRS doesn't have power of law, how were they able to garnish my wages when I didn't pay enuf taxes after a consulting gig?

How are they false facts. All are seriously researched.

You had to pay them? Well,it's because you entered a contract agreeing to pay. It is that simple.

Don't enter into the voluntary contract, and there is nothing to pay (or not) and no law to be broken, unless you can sho me the law that says you have to volunteer.

The rest is your parroting and being misled by the media, and those that thought they were telling you the truth.

Unfortunate.

I am not proposing any changes at all.
I only want you to find out the truth, and the facts. And quit being extorted.

by johnbeaman

US Constitution says:
Direct tax must be apportioned (divided equally amongst the people)
All indirect taxes must be the same (uniform) throughout all the states.

The Income tax now does not meet either definition.
Congress started trying to institute an income tax in 1894, Supreme Court ruled Not Constitutional !
1916-23 Many Supreme Court cases shows 16th amended provides no new power of taxation.
Supreme Court says your labor is your property.
The government can tax on profits & gains, not labor and wages.
Yes, they have the IRS tax Code, but where is the law ?

Question.
Where does it say that this "code" applies to you?

If you can't, then you have been misled, as I claim.

by faradhi

The Aliens are controlling the IRS. You are just too lazy to look.

The 16th amendment has been upheld by the Supreme Cuurt time and again. You just choose to ignore the cases that others have given you.

However, none of that matters because the aliens invented this argument just to distract you from the truth. WAKE UP MAN! You are being controlled by Moon aliens from Traxlavanit!

by johnbeaman

The 16th amendment does not say that you or I have to pay a tax on our wages. If it does, show me.

I am ignoring WHAT cases people have brought up? Where are they? I haven't seen any.

Why have IRS agents and others that know all of this confirm my claims? Why have so many people been acquitted, or found not guilty?

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=1616088001333580937

If you are so sure this is bogus (or alien crap) go claim the $50,000 reward.

by w2ktechman

The Aliens have taken over the government and media. G.W.B. is a puppet not for Cheney, but to the Aliens themselves. Ahh, it all makes sense now.
Thank You for pointing this out and enlightening us all.
Now, where is my tin foil, I need a new hat

by faradhi

Use a combination of Zinc pyrithione and Ketoconazole.

Only a 1 to 1 mixture of both will properly protect you. The tin foil actually attracts the mind control satellites.

by the scummy one

this computer chip that is embedded under my skin. How to safely remove it.

I was thinking of sulferic acid until it was visible, but then I thought it might hurt...
The docs cannot remove it, because then they report it to the Aliens, and then they add a new chip.

by johnbeaman

That you turn this into a joke because you can't discuss the subject as an adult, or a professional?

Your Blog Name says it all....

by nicknielsen

AMENDMENT XVI

Passed by Congress July 2, 1909. Ratified February 3, 1913.

Note: Article I, section 9, of the Constitution was modified by amendment 16.

The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration.

by johnbeaman

That statement is true as long as it doesn't violate the Constitution. If you don't also read in that fact into the statement, (left out on purpose cause everyone is supposed to alread know this) then you are misleading yourself by your lack of knowledge. Most people interpret it the way you do, Until they find out the facts. Dont' feel bad.

US Constitution says:

1. Direct tax must be apportioned (divided equally amongst the people)
2. All indirect taxes must be the same (uniform) throughout all the states.

- The Income tax now does not meet either definition unless you include the Constitutional limitations on that law. Then it is totally correct. Without it, as you left out, because they want you to forget that part, and assume it applies to your wages, is the name of their game.

- Congress started trying to institute an income tax in 1894, Supreme Court ruled Not Constitutional !

- 1916-23 Many Supreme Court cases shows 16th amended provides no new power of taxation.

- Supreme Court says your labor is your property.

- The government can tax on profits & gains, not labor and wages.

-Yes, they have the IRS tax Code, but where is the law ?

- Where does it say that this "code" applies to you?

It doesn't.

You remind me of the blond in this video:

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=1616088001333580937

So your statement indicates you do not understand. Most don't.

If my statements were false, why have so many people been found not guilty of the IRS charge of not filing an income tax, like the one referenced in the post?

My question was why do people pay?

The answer is, because most people do not understand what you just quoted really means, or how it applies to them. Your reply proves this to be true in your case, as with so many others.

by eric_andresen

This appears to cover all the bases ...

http://docs.law.gwu.edu/facweb/jsiegel/Personal/taxes/JustNoLaw.htm

And what is the diference between a code and law? Municipal building "codes" state all kinds of things about how your house must be built to include certain provisions. You may be required by another municipal "code" to keep your car off your lawn for extended periods of time.

Are they laws? No. Can you be fined or have legal action brought against you for defying them? You bet.

by nicknielsen

Just that same old lame link to that same ol lame video?

Here I though the digital age was supposed to eliminate record-skip.

by faradhi

Ok here is what you do.

supplies needed:
1 9 volt battery
2 short thin copper wires (thin enough to be threaded in a needle)
2 sewing needles (size depends on size of wires.
Isopropyl alcohol
1 Gal Zinc pyrithione
1 Gal Ketoconazole
1 Can of Black Olives
1 thong
2 buckets

Clean the needles with the Alcohol.

Take the 9 volt battery and two wires and the needles. connect the wires to the two battery terminals. And thread the needle on the other end.

Take the black olives out of the can and poor the olives in the pocket of the thong and place on your head.

Poor some alcohol over the place where the chip was inserted. Then insert the Positive needle in your skin until you bump in to one side of the chip. [b]It is very important that you do not insert the negative needle until instructed[/b]

Take the thong off your head and place it in your mouth.

Poor the one gal of Zinc pyrithione in one of the buckets and step in using your [b]left[/b] foot.

Now poor the Ketoconazole in the other bucket but do not step in it yet.

At the same time, step into the Ketoconazole while inserting the negative needle.

This will disable the chip.

Remember to apply some Ketoconazole and Zinc pyrithione on your head to prevent the Aliens from using mind control to have you report to have the chip reinserted.

You can tell when they are attempting mind control because you scalp will begin to itch.

by nicknielsen

Your refutation of any argument against yours consists only of [i]...the superficial position with little or no facts, only passed on parroting, and pieces[/i] and the phrase "Look it up."

You "claim" all this is true. You are trying to convince me, but provide no supporting evidence. By any rules of debate the onus is on you to do so; why should I do the work?

Your failure to provide supporting evidence for your premise reduces it to a fallacious argument.

Confucious say "Please to remove cranium from inappropriate location."

by jmgarvin

"Our troop deployment gets not one dime of the Graduated Income Tax. (or does any other government service)"

How do we pay for governmental services. Things like roads, the military, police, firefighters, trains, etc?

by johnbeaman

Too bad he didn't read further into the law. This is an example of why so many people thought all of this applied to them and their personal wages, which by IRS code is not taxable.

He left out the part that defines WHO all this applies to.

It applies ONLY to those that live here and have foreign income, or, those living abroad and income from here.

Nowhere does it state that it applies to you or me, and it is very easy to miss that point.

If what I say is not true, then why did a jury of 12 find 12-0 that he was not guilty?

Go look into this:
June 23, 2005

Former IRS CID Special Agent Joseph Banister Acquitted
of Tax Fraud And Conspiracy

Government Unable To Prove U.S. Law Requires Income Tax
Withholding or Filing

Just another case that proves it just ain't so.

Internal Revenue Code 861, 26 U.S.C. ? 861,
titled "Income from sources within the United States" is a provision of the Internal Revenue Code which lists "The following items of gross income shall be treated as income from sources within the United States", for purposes of various taxes imposed by Subchapter N (sections 861 through 999) of Chapter 1 of Subtitle A of the Code.

- the section 871(a) (26 U.S.C. ? 871(a)) tax on certain items of income of nonresident alien individuals not in connection with a United States business, generally equal to 30% of certain amounts received by such nonresident alien individuals;

- the section 871(b) {26 U.S.C. ? 871(b)) tax on certain items of income of nonresident alien individuals effectively connected with the conduct of a United States business;

- the section 881 (26 U.S.C. ? 881) and section 882 (26 U.S.C. ? 882) taxes on the income of certain foreign corporations; and

- the section 887 (26 U.S.C. ? 887) tax on the "gross transportation income" of certain nonresident aliens and foreign corporations.

This defines WHO section 26 applies to.
Your friend forgot that part. Most people don't read all the way into the tax law. Why do you think it is so complex? so you won't realize this!!!

Are you any of those required to pay, in this section? I think not. I know it doesn't apply to me. That is why the IRS quit asking me 25 years ago for a 1040. I refuse to enter into a contract with extortionists.

Once upon a time, everyone thought the earth was flat. Today, almost everyone believes they owe federal income taxes. However, when the actual words, written in the IRS tax code are examined, an ugly truth begins to emerge. And the truth is, that most Americans have been systematically and intentionally defrauded into paying a tax they do not owe.

Did you ever wonder about the ?voluntary? nature of federal income taxes? If the law requires one to pay, why does the IRS call for ?voluntary compliance?? If one is charged with violating the law is his or her appearance in court voluntary? Does one serve time in a federal prison voluntarily or is there some sort of mandatory attendance associated with a prison sentence?

The reason for voluntary compliance is simple. The federal government is barred by the Constitution from taxing the income of most Americans. To tax each and every endeavor within the states is to regulate ALL activity, and where is the limited nature in that? The federal government is allowed by the Constitution to regulate international and foreign commerce, so they imposed an income tax applicable to income from international and foreign commerce. However, they still would like some of YOUR money, so they wrote the law in a very convoluted and easily misunderstood way.

The reason cities have codes, and send out their police department on you is because they are "administrative Codes". If you reside in that city, you are required to comply with them.

If yuou are not a resident, then you can claim the laws ar inapplicable as they have no jurisdiction on you.

I know that, and was found not guilty for failure to have current car insurance or license tags on my California registered car while in Arizona.

My att'y waved all my fees for the education I gave him.

By the way, the Insurance thing is the government requiring you to enter into a private contract with a third party, and is not constitutionally allowed. It can be part of a cities administrative code tho. That was part of my argument, and was another reason they found me not guilty.

by faradhi

http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/uscode26/usc_sec_26_00000001----000-.html

The section in it's entirety that imposes an income tax on all individuals.

The sections you state only expand the law to include nonresident aliens and foreign businesses. It does not change the law repeal 26 U.S.C. ? 1. So until you can provide a link that shows 26 U.S.C. ? 1 repealed then I would say that the IRS may just not consider you worth the effort. Maybe what you owe would not pay for the prosecution. Maybe, just maybe, you're not that important.

So unless you can prove that the aliens don't really exist, I fart in your general direction.

by big ole jack

Go ahead and try not to pay taxes, because I'd love to see IRS agents smashing down your door with their 9mm Glocks fully loaded and pointed at your stupid head if you somehow think you are "exempt" from paying taxes. The consitution has something known as an "Elastic Clause", which if you studied history correctly, allows the government to make ammendements and changes to the constitution from its original state. As others have stated, if all three branches of government agree that income is to be taxed to support the government and its various social and military programs, then who are you to argue against it? Are you one of those that somehow thinks he is entitled to free government services at the expense of others while you are somehow "exempt" from having to pay a dime? Who in the f**k do you think you are to be on your high and mighty horse to spew your bullsh*t here? You remind me of the common urban welfare recipient scum who wants a handout at others expense, yet expects not to contribute anything himself. You've started a post on a topic you cannot support without resorting to non-credible web bases sources and have opened yourself up to a flaming war. If the purpose of your posting this nonsense here was to get a response, you will certainly get one, but it won't be one in your favor because the patrons of this site are all law abiding citizens who are not tax evaders or cheats.

David Koresh of the Branch Davidians also claimed he was Jesus and was somehow immune from federal law, until the FBI and ATF stormed into his compound and proved him wrong....dead wrong!

by johnbeaman

Go ahead and try not to pay taxes, because I'd love to see IRS agents smashing down your door with their 9mm Glocks fully loaded and pointed at your stupid head if you somehow think you are "exempt" from paying taxes.

I wish you well too...

All of this was already explained, including the fact that in 25 years they haven't bothered me for the same reason these people were found not guilty of the crime you are also accusing me of..

The constitution has something known as an "Elastic Clause", which if you studied history correctly, allows the government to make amendments and changes to the constitution from its original state.

Where is this clause? You ask me for proof of what I say, I ask you to show me the clause.

As others have stated, if all three branches of government agree that income is to be taxed to support the government and its various social and military programs, then who are you to argue against it?

Once again you are wrong because you don't know the law, or the facts. Show me where it says the income tax pays for social programs, or the military. It doesn't. I have stated many time above where it goes.


Are you one of those that somehow thinks he is entitled to free government services at the expense of others while you are somehow "exempt" from having to pay a dime?

I don't pay extortion money when the law says I don't have to. That is the same reason that so many people that have found out the truth don't pay this specific tax either. There is no free lunch. You are an appeaser, someone that keeps feeding the lion hoping it will eat him last.


Who in the f**k do you think you are to be on your high and mighty horse to spew your bullsh*t here?

I asked a question.

If it was bullshit, explain this:

----------------

June 23, 2005

Former IRS CID Special Agent Joseph Banister Acquitted
of Tax Fraud And Conspiracy

Government Unable To Prove U.S. Law Requires Income Tax
Withholding or Filing

During the trial, Banister's former supervisor at IRS's San Jose
CID office, Robert Gorini when
pointedly asked, was unable to cite any U.S. law that required
Banister to pay income taxes.

Banister, who was forced to resign in 1999, gave a presentation in 2000 which reviewed his detailed investigative
research of U.S. tax law which concluded that not only did the IRS
lack any authority to impose income taxes on the any workers labor, but there
was no legal requirement for the business to withhold any taxes from the worker's paychecks.

----------------

You remind me of the common urban welfare recipient scum who wants a handout at others expense, yet expects not to contribute anything himself.

I contribute more than you know. I have researched this issue for over 30 years, and written many documents and have had many people thank me for saving them.

What have you done, besides feed more money to the extortionists, money that goes nowhere to pay for any service by our government? And spread the lies like those above that anyone that knows the smallest bit about our Constitution and the Law will tell you you are full of crap. You are part of the problem because you propagate the fairy tales, and bad assumptions without finding out for yourself what is the truth.


You've started a post on a topic you cannot support without resorting to non-credible web bases sources and have opened yourself up to a flaming war.

I asked a serious question. I get false accusations and irrelevant comebacks. I have given you two court cases,
video by IRS agents, citations from the tax code, and what do you give me? Old wives tales.

Some old retired guy wants to know how he is going to get his pension check, if I don't pay income taxes. His retirement money doesn't come from income taxes. I cry for him because he doesn't know that. Nor do you.


If the purpose of your posting this nonsense here was to get a response, you will certainly get one, but it won't be one in your favor because the patrons of this site are all law abiding citizens who are not tax evaders or cheats.

How is not paying a tax I don't owe, being a tax evader or a cheat?
How is that not being a law abiding citizen as you claim?

Where is your facts, citations and references to claim that?

All of this was explained, including the fact that in 25 years they haven't bothered me.

The Koresh case had nothing to do with income tax either.

The ATF is for Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms.
They have nothing to do with Income tax.
Why are you off on that tangent?

Read some of the other posts to see where all this law is stated. References and everything, stop claiming I am providing NO SUPPORT to my claims, I have.

And, why have many people have been found not guilty of exactly what you say?

http://irscases.blogspot.com/

You obviously do not know how to read the law.

Lets start with this:


The Internal Revenue Code general definition of the terms "includes" and "including" is as follows:

The terms "includes" and "including" when used in a definition contained in this title shall not be deemed to exclude other things otherwise within the meaning of the term defined.


Keep this in mind for a bit here.


Internal Revenue Code section 861, titled "Income from sources within the United States", is a provision of the Internal Revenue Code which delineates what kinds of income shall be treated as income from sources within the United States. The language of Section 861 is the statute which excludes some portion of the income of U.S. citizens and resident aliens from taxation under the provisions of the Code.

Section 861 is the only income derived from "taxable activities" becomes "taxable income" (taxable "gross income" minus allowable deductions - 26 U.S.C. ? 63). The list of taxable activities is located in Subchapter N and in Section 861 regulations. Individuals with domestic income must go to the Section 861 regulations to determine if the activities that generate their income are taxable or not. Regulation section 1.861-8T(d)(2)(iii) defines the taxable activities. Since the domestic activities of residents of the United States (Americans and resident aliens) are not shown to be taxable, the domestic income derived from such activities does not become taxable "gross income."


etc...
And anyway, why have so many people been found innocent for failure to file or pay?.

Cheats?
Who said anything about cheats?

If I am following the law, how am I a cheat?

The taxes I pay go for all the services and support that we DO get from our government, but not this extortion.

Quit flaming. You are outraged because you are too embarrassed to admit you have been fleeced for years.
You assume that you had to pay the tax. So do a lot of other sheep.
It was told to you by many that also believed it. With good intentions as well. You can't stand to see that these people you respected were wrong.

Totally understandable that you are upset, but don't shoot the messenger, please.

Back to my origonal post question...
If all these people were found not guilty, why are so many other people still paying the extortion money?

If there is no law that says I have to pay it, and none of it goes for any services, why pay it?

I suspect it is because the people don't know, or afraid to find out, or would rather pay the extortionist... etc.

So, Since I already know why many don't, I want to know why others keep paying, adn I really wanted that answer.

I have had enough of the tangents and unsupported claims about what our constitution says, with not one quotation referenced. Your outrage is understood, but the fact you have been hosed, is no reason to get mad at me. OK?

Go watch a video...
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=1616088001333580937

by nicknielsen

[i]I asked a serious question. I get false accusations and irrelevant comebacks. I have given you two court cases, video by IRS agents, citations from the tax code, and what do you give me? [/i]

We asked for links to valid, reputable, web sites. You gave us Youtube, WorldNewsDaily, and a shout-down-the-opposition blog.

We asked for the source of your contradictions to established law, you tap danced, citing areas of law that only tangentially apply.

By your own admission, you have not paid taxes since 1984. This failure to contribute classifies you as a freeloader. It's people like you who lead me to wonder if my 24 years in the military were simply so you can be as stupid as you want to be.

by big ole jack

I really don't know what else can cause brain cells and other neurons to malunction like that, other than thermal overload and shutdown...LMAO!

by big ole jack

I could swear I had something inserted up my rectum by aliens which is now making strange high pitched beeping noises everytime I take a dump. It's not a conspiracy theory...there really are aliens out there and they are abducting and probing us every single day.

by big ole jack

Forget the original constitution, because it's not 1776. The laws have changed so much over the past 200+ years since the constitution was written that the original document is no longer applicable to modern day law. The constitution does not dictate federal and state fiscal policy, which is why the IRS and Treasure Departments were created. When the constitution was written, there was no treasury department and the founding fathers did not mention taxation because of the issues they had with paying taxes to the British monarchy. With that stated, how does a nation support its military, roads, infrastucture, etc. if it does not levy taxes from its citizens? Where will the money come from? The gov't can't just print more money or pull it out of their behinds!

by faradhi

Been screwed by the aliens.

I keep trying to tell this guy but he is another victim of their mind control.

It is sad.

by faradhi

I suggest a man's thong because it will hold more olives.

It is entirely up to you if it is new or used.

Truth be known, I just wanted to get you to put a thong on your head. ]:)

by big ole jack

He has made it loud and clear that he is a tax evader. If he refuses to pay taxes, then he has no right to be in this country. Deport him with the rest of the illegal alien filth that comes here to rape our economy.

by nicknielsen

He's probably a "natural-born" citizen anyway. But since he didn't contribute, ban him from using anything supported (no matter how indirectly) with tax money. This would include roads, hospitals, businesses (access, you know), and pretty much everything except his own little patch...

Never mind, kick his sorry butt out. Let him not pay taxes (or try not to!) someplace else.

by johnbeaman

Everything you mention is covered and paid for by other taxes.

The misconception that you get something for the "income tax" is running rampant, and why so many don't understand this issue at all.

I am amazed how many people think it does, claim it is fact, and yet have done no research on the issue, only parrot the old wives tales like this.

by johnbeaman

Most of your assumptions are wrong. That is the point.

I only asked: If the IRS couldn't prove anyone has to pay, why do we?

None of this money goes for those services you mention. I have studied this for over 30 years, and not paid this extortion money for 25 years. I first did some research, like Tom, and found out we've been scammed, lied to, and harassed.

I also encourage everyone to find out the truth. All I get is lies and alien BS from
ignorant people.

Your attitude, when presented with a gift of great value seems childish.

by johnbeaman

If I am required, show me the law.

If you can, go collect the $50,000 reward.

I am not a "tax evader", go read the definition.
"Tax Evasion is illegal, Tax Avoidance is not."

The rest of your post is only hate rhetoric, and shows your extensive ignorance.

by jdclyde

If this is all as you say, they why are there not specific court cases that can be sited?

by nicknielsen

Every time we've tried to pin him down with links to reputable sources, he's been least in sight.

by jdclyde

It was the husband of one my boy ex's friends.

He was convinced that this would work, but his wife was not going to put her name on it and take the chance of losing everything.

He was also the same weasel that was always looking for the next "get rich quick" scheme. A plotter and conniver.

by johnbeaman

You show how stupid you sound.

Read the thread, there are references everywhere.

Don't read, don't know, belive your own crap.

Propagate your crap instead of the facts.


"[T]he Sixteenth Amendment conferred no new power of taxation but simply prohibited the previous complete and plenary power of income taxation possessed by Congress from the beginning from being taken out of the category of indirect taxation to which it inherently belonged." - http://www.gpoaccess.gov/constitution/pdf/con027.pdf

In one of the first income tax cases to go to the Supreme Court, Stanton v. Baltic Mining Co., 240 U.S. 103 (1916), Stanton's attorney made the point 35 times in his briefs and oral argument that the 16th Amendment created a new class of taxes, that is a direct tax not regulated by the apportionment rule. Rejecting this argument, the Supreme Court stated in its opinion, "By the previous ruling [Brushaber] it was settled that the provisions of the Sixteenth Amendment conferred no new power of taxation." - Therefore, there is no exception to the apportionment rule for direct taxes.


Filing a federal income tax return is, in fact, voluntary, because there is no statute or regulation that requires the vast majority of U.S. citizens to file and pay income taxes -- or to have taxes withheld from the money they earn.

Neither the IRS nor the Congress can cite an authorizing law or regulation.

If this is wrong, then go collect the $50,00 reward, or shut the f up.

by johnbeaman

The court case is referenced.
Headlines, etc.
Why do you post such ignorant lies?

There are many additional references in all of these that I give you here:

http://www.shreveporttimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=2007707130321
http://www.makethestand.com/article39.html
http://www.mefeedia.com/entry/3057732/
http://chris.pirillo.com/2007/07/19/stop-paying-income-tax-america/#comment-528791

Other cases:
http://www.sierratimes.com/03/08/10/ar_IRS_vs._KUGLIN.htm
- Explanation: http://www.unitedstatesgovernment.net/irsvskuglin.htm

http://www.davidmgarvin.com/results.html
http://www.retrax.com/sites/ontrial/results.htm
http://www.save-a-patriot.org/files/view/long.html
Etc...Etc...

Great reading of a fight still in process, and explanation of Tom Cryers win:
http://edbrownextendedentries.blogspot.com/2007/07/tom-cryers-trial-summary.html

Where do you get off saying there are no cases? Are you incapable of reading?

Your statement is a flat out lie.

Here is a good summary of this whole issue:
http://www.couldyoubenext.com/snsE_021304BobSchulz.htm

Again you don't address the question: If this is true, why do so may still pay?

I think it is because people continue listen to ignorance and lies such as yours, and believe it true, and pass it on so others believe the lies.

The courts say otherwise in Tom Cryers case, and others.

by nicknielsen

Even a couple that aren't biased as all hell.

Where was all this to start with? You might have had a better time of it if you had provided all this up front.

by faradhi

Crush them and then rub them all over your arms and legs. The Aliens hate the smell of olives.

by big ole jack

I think we proved our point and the nutter went back to his psychiatric ward. This is what happens when you allow mental patients to surf the web...LOL.

by johnbeaman

Ladies and gentlemen...the troll has left the building!

No, Still here.
They limit how many you can post here, so my responding is limited.

I think we proved our point and the nutter went back to his
psychiatric ward. This is what happens when you allow mental
patients to surf the web...LOL.

You haven't proven anything except your ignorance. Your arrogance
and lack of facts or references, or quotations, makes you look like
the idiot you obviously are. That is also why you have no clue to
what is being discussed here. You still believe the lies, and when I give you my research, you laugh.

Well people, believe the idiots, like Big ol Jack(ass):

Forget the original constitution, because it's not 1776.

Forget it? Why? That has to be the dumbest thing you've said yet.

The laws have changed so much over the past 200+ years since
the constitution was written that the original document is no
longer applicable to modern day law.

No longer applicable? Where does it say that? You try and act like you
are knowledgeable, and yet you say such ignorant things.

Our Constitution limits what the Federal government can do. Read
the tenth amendment. It can't do what is up to the individual states.
That is why it can only tax businesses, and foreign activities. Your
ignorance and misconceptions makes even discussing this with you
impossible.

The constitution does not dictate federal and state fiscal policy, which is why the IRS and Treasure Departments were created.

Again you pull this kind of crap out, with no references, as you demand of me, which I have provided, and you expect people to believe it. Our Constitution and Bill of Rights explains exactly what it can dictate. But you obviously haven't read any of it.

Article II of the U.S. Constitution says no direct tax shall be levied upon the public except through reapportionment after a census is taken. The 16th amendment which "authorized" federal income tax should have never been passed because it runs contrary to the body of the Constitution. The original definition of amendment has been changed to accomodate this illegality. Originally an amendment could not be brought forth that ran contrary to what it was amending; i.e. amendment was defined as : amplify, clarify, expound, extend, but the only thing that cannot be brought up in the amendment process is that which runs contrary to what is being amended. The founding fathers understood this definition, that is why there was a provision for a constitutional convention.

When the constitution was written, there was no treasury department and the founding fathers did not mention taxation because of the issues they had with paying taxes to the British monarchy.

Uh, again you haven't read it, have you? If you had, then you wouldn't make such stupid statements.

With that stated, how does a nation support its military, roads, infrastructure, etc. if it does not levy taxes from its citizens?

With Excise taxes on international activities, business and corporation
taxes. The government cannot tax the peoples income. You have not (obviously read the tax code) or the law. The federal government cannot tax the income of the American people directly, (read the Constitution)
they have to play a game.

The "Income Tax" is not a tax on your income
anyway.

The income tax, is a tax on "activities that the Government is allowed by the Constitution to tax." The amount of income is only used to determine how much tax you pay for those activities. But you haven't read anything, either the Constitution, the Bill of Rights, nor any tax code. That is why you look so stupid to any knowledable people. I have quoted tax law professors opinions, and the actual law, and yet you claim otherwise.

Where will the money come from? The gov't can't just print more money or pull it out of their behinds!

But that is exactly what it can do. This proves you have no clue to any of this. You ask questions that prove you don't know. You make unsubstantiated claims that also prove
you ar so ignorant on the subject that you can't discuss it, you can only bash those that do with you rhetoric and bullsh!t.

You have not a single reference, bash the news providers instead the facts, and bash anyone that doesn't believe your childish ignorant tripe.

1. The news story said thae Government failed to prove that anyone has to file Income Tax.

2. I only asked, if this is true, why do so many people pay it.

And all you can do is reply with total lack of knowledge on the subject, or complain about the news source.

Keep laughing while you pay, and I (legally) do not. I know where the money goes, and what the laws say, you do not, that is obvious.

I was asking a serious question, and your laughter is a typical defense mechanism to obscure your tremendous ignorance.

Rich people don't pay these taxes, because they have figured this out. The middle-class keeps paying because they don't, for what ever the reason. Over 35 million people have also figured this out, and don't pay this tax.

All this other stuff only shows that most people don't know, and many assume it is patriotic to pay the extorsion. They also assume that they get something in return for the money they do pay. It is "fraud" when you don't get something in return when you pay money). It is "extortion" when you fear for your property or life when you pay only to ward that off. Go read the definitions if you don't believe me.

Follow the money. None of the "services" we get from the government are paid from the "income tax". So all those types of questions and assumptions are invalid, and only a tangent that does not address the question.

Read thru this thread again and you will find references all over the place to support my position, and yet that is still not the question.

The reason for this thread, again is: "If tom Cryer was found not-guilty because the government and the IRS cannot show the law that says he has to pay, then why do people still pay this tax?".

This thread was to recommend that you find out the facts instead of believing all this crap that you hear from people that have no clue. Watch out for those that don't even know what our Constitution says, like this guy. Like so many others they lie out of ignorance, maybe not intentionally, but still lies. The more you hear these lies, and refuse to find out for yourself, the more you believe them.

I recommend you find out for yourself, as millions have, including me.

by johnbeaman

I reference a few more in my replies too.
Maybe you haven't read thru this thread.
Or, just want to laugh to hide your ignorance.
In any case, what does this have to do with the question?

by johnbeaman

There are many references and quotes, and facts supplied in this thread.
You'r ignorance, or refusal to read those facts don't change the truth.
The documentation is provided, you might try looking at it, before you continue with your childish diatribe.

by nicknielsen

I have perused your quotes, viewed your video, browsed your links, and am left with a question: Where are the reputable, accepted sources? Where is the Wall Street Journal? Groklaw? The (pick one) Times?

I'm supposed to change my behavior based on what you say, a blog, and a Youtube video? There are "facts" and then there are facts. You appear to be dealing with "facts."

If I can provide "facts" that jumping off the rim of the Grand Canyon is non-fatal, will you do it?

by johnbeaman

The fact is he won.
The fact is many people pay.
The question is why.

Most want to find out how he did it.
That is why the references to his side of it.
What difference is it which news article you read that states he won? It is still fact.

It does not compare to your silly example.

I have over 30 years research on this. I don't pay this extorsion either. The IRS knows that almost 100 million have figured out the scam they are pulling, and don't pay. The ones that felt guilty about "not paying their fair share" have researched the money trail. They no longer feel guilty. It is a scam. None of the money goes for any services. That has been explained here, and you can dig further to find out more if you wish.

Most people don't have the money to fight, or bother taking the time to do the research. How much more money would you have to spend if you didn't pay this "tax"? If you pay 20% on a 50K salary, then it would be worth $10,000 a year. It would seem worth the research.

Look what Bush's tiny tax cut did for our economy. Imagine what would happen if no one paid this bogus "tax"?

The rich don't pay because they figured it out. Guys like Tom Cryer figured it out too.

Do you think the IRS is going to report this?
No, they will report the Willie Nelson tax story to make you think the same will happen to you if you don't file. It is not the same situation. Willie was found guilty of lying on his contract with the IRS. That is "tax evasion". That is a crime.

"Tax avoidance", what Tom Cryer did, is not illegal at all. He proved it in court. I didn't have to go to court. Many others don't either. Only the sensationalist garbage makes the news unless you push it.

Again: If this is true, Then why are we paying?

All this other ignorant nonsense, is just that.

Don't get me wrong, I am ignorant about brain surgery. Ignorance is not a bad thing. We are all ignorant on some subjects. On this one, I am not, and I tried to share that with those that are.

by johnbeaman

None of the Graduated Income tax pays for anything you think you get "for free" from the government. Fact. (Stated well in an above reply by someone other than me.)

There are far more references here in this thread, you obviously refuse to read them.

read this:
Here is the story on Tom Cryer, and a law professors analysis:

http://www.w3f.com/patriots/tomcryer.html

The income tax, as stated is legal. I never said it was not. It is the misunderstanding, and misapplication of that law, and code, that is the issue here.

Again..... The question you seem to forget
If this is fact, proven in court, why do people still pay?

by nicknielsen

I spent 24 years earning everything I get, and it isn't much. In fact, when I start collecting Social Security (if it's still there!), I won't draw the full rate based on my FICA contributions because I'm already drawing military retirement. Isn't that special!

All this is beside the point. Compliance with the income tax has always been voluntary, nobody stands over your shoulder to make sure you file. Twist the data how you may, money paid in income tax ends up in the coffers of the United States government.

Your attitude appears to be that you don't wish to support the United States government; that's your choice. Given that choice, you should refrain from using anything that exists as a result, even indirectly, of spending by that same government...such as the internet, highways, hospitals, automobiles, etc. Utilizing without contributing makes you a freeloader. In fact, my personal opinion is that you are breathing air I will need later in life.

Don't call me, I won't call you.

by johnbeaman


I don't get a damn thing for free from the government

None of us do. We pay far more than we get back. This scam is just one example.


I spent 24 years earning everything I get, and it isn't much. In fact, when I start collecting Social Security (if it's still there!), I won't draw the full rate based on my FICA contributions because I'm already drawing military retirement. Isn't that special!

This scam has nothing to do with your retirement. It is a government run retirement plan. Has nothing to do with the "income tax".


All this is beside the point. Compliance with the income tax has always been voluntary, nobody stands over your shoulder to make sure you file. Twist the data how you may, money paid in income tax ends up in the coffers of the United States government.

But it doesn't. That has been explained.


Your attitude appears to be that you don't wish to support the United States government; that's your choice.

I do support our government, more than we have time to discuss here. I pay a ton of taxes, most all which go to services we all get. I just don't pay this extortion.

Given that choice, you should refrain from using anything that exists as a result, even indirectly, of spending by that same government...such as the internet, highways, hospitals, automobiles, etc.

Gas taxes pay for the highways. Not the income tax. This is a good example of what so many people believe. Since when did any of the income tax pay for the internet? Come on now, you are smarter than that.

Utilizing without contributing makes you a freeloader. In fact, my personal opinion is that you are breathing air I will need later in life.

I freeload nothing. I pay all of the taxes that we get back in services, and more. I just don't pay this one, and neither did Tom Cryer, and the IRS and the government couldn't prove he has to. That is the bottom line.

by johnbeaman

The Post was:

The news story said The IRS couldn't prove we had to file.

It wasn't about which news source. It was something that happened. These are court cases. It is something that happened. Do you insinuate that you don't believe this news story unless it's in the Wall Street Journal? Why would they bother with it?

When was the last time you saw a news story that wasn't negative, or bashing someone?

The YouTube was to get his side of the story, since he was that one that won, and usually you want to know how/why he did it. You don't go the plantifs web site. D'oh.

There are other links and analysis by professionals, not sensationalists or aliens, that ask the same question I did here.

I have to repeat myself.

"If this is true, that the IRS can't prove we have to pay, why are we paying?".

I also encourged people to find out for themselves, and all I get is lies and BS and ignorance, or harassment.

This is not a "funny" thing, it is serious.

Like all these crappy replies here, it is hard to find a serious informed reference.

As you know, 45% of the people still believe that Bush did 9/11 and there is more of that on the internet than the truth. The people don't seem to realize what they have been told for years is bogus.

Sensationalism and harassing a serious person seems to be the norm these days. I hoped it would be different with technical people, as they are supposed to be smarter than that.

Unfortunately, they arn't.

by w2ktechman

Can you show me a reputable link that states 35 million people are not paying?

Also, links to where our money goes?

And finally, how govt. employees are paid (including military) if not from our taxes?