Why do people pay taxes on their labor to the IRS?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Software
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by nicknielsen
Now show me the money. According to slide 4 in this presentation (http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/66xx/doc6609/08-15-Slides.pdf), 43% of federal revenue in 2005 was from individual income taxes. If income tax collections ain't going to the government, where is the money going?
It would seem that I'm not the only one who doesn't wish to be confused with "facts."
by nicknielsen
[i]It wasn't about which news source. It was something that happened. These are court cases. It is something that happened. Do you insinuate that you don't believe this news story unless it's in the Wall Street Journal? Why would they bother with it? [/i]
If this story is so important, why wouldn't the Wall Street Journal cover it? In fact, if it's so important, why hasn't it been covered by [b]any[/b] of the national media? Nothing on CNN, nothing on Fox, nothing on MSNBC. I should think, as much as conservatives hate paying ANY taxes, that Fox at least would have been all over this one, but nobody has covered it. Why not?
[i]There are other links and analysis by professionals, not sensationalists or aliens, that ask the same question I did here. [/i]
You keep referring to other links, but you never provide them. You might be more believable (or at least less irritating) if you did so. [i][u]Where are the links??[/u][/i]
[i]As you know, 45% of the people still believe that Bush did 9/11...[/i]
45%? Really? No, I didn't know. What's your source for this one?
[i]...it is hard to find a serious informed reference.[/i]
That line essentially describes exactly why I dismiss both you and your claims as trivial.
Edit: formatting
by johnbeaman
The news media hates the subject of taxes, and most refuse to mention anything except the sensationalist propaganda stuff. Editorial privledge.
That still does not answer the question of why the fact that Tom Cryer won was in question. Your claim that this fact is trivial is just plain stupid.
Last time: If the IRS could not prove that we have to pay the income tax, why are so many people paying it? Find out why.
Do your own research, find out the truth, or keep paying the extortion. I don't have any more time for your ignorance.
If you don't belive me, then find out the truth and present that, don't keep saying that 30 years of my research is trivial when you have done none. Then spouting all your lies and BS. Keep paying for nothing in return but don't tell me I am a cheater or breaking the law when I don't. That's slander. Prove it or STFU. The IRS couldn't prove it, so how can you?
by av .
Tommy Cryer was acquitted by a jury of "willfully" failing to file a tax return. He still has a civil liability to pay the taxes.
Are you willing to take the chance of going to prison, John? There are plenty of people like you that do go to prison. Here's a link for you:
http://www.irs.gov/taxpros/article/0,,id=159853,00.html
There are so many legal and less risky ways to reduce the taxes you pay. Why risk prison?
Tommy Cryer may have convinced a jury he didn't "willfully" not file tax returns, but he is likely on his way to being disbarred from practicing law.
AV
by nicknielsen
The link you provided is exactly what I (and everybody else) have been asking from this pinhead: links with court cases supporting his opinion. He accuses me and others of being stupid, of not reading his posts, and of being less than intelligent and essentially dupes, but he provides no links to legal precedent.
Then he wonders why nobody takes him seriously.
by johnbeaman
If Tom Cryer proved he doesnt have to pay, why do you pay?
That is the question you keep forgetting.
Links already supplied.
Other cases already mentioned:
Joseph Banister
Read more here: http://www.alamoministries.com/content/english/newsreleases/turner.html
Vernice Kuglin
U.S. District Court, Western District of Tennessee (Memphis) # 03-CR-20111, USA v. Kuglin.
And you say I present no cases...
Which links would you trust, or want me to research for you, for free?
I haven't paid in 25 years, after thorough discussions with the IRS. Why don't they "come after me?" It must be because I found them out, called them on it, and they chose to let it go. If I was violating the law, the would giggle with childish glee in "catching another tax cheat" and publisize the hell out of it to scare everyone into paying the extortion money they signed up for by filing a 1040 when they can't find the law that says I have to, proven in Tom Cryers case (and others).
I believe:
- 1. The tax law is legal and constitutional.
- 2. That tax does not apply to you or me.
Question:
- Then why are you volunteering to pay it?
Answer:
- Because you have been misled.
Solution:
- 1. Find out the truth. Not easy, but doable.
- 2. Find out yourself, you won't/shouldn't believe anyone elses opinion.
- 3. Think of how much you have/will pay if you don't.
Oh, and don't let all these turkeys get ya down.
Earlier, here
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5218-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=234660&messageID=2308367
JohnBeaman posted a link to here:
http://www.w3f.com/patriots/tomcryer.html
Following that, I found a link to a DOJ page:
http://www.usdoj.gov/usao/law/news/wdl20061026.pdf
that says:
"It is alleged in the indictment that CRYER created a trust, listing himself as the trustee, and received payments of dividends, interest and stock income to that trust. The indictment further alleges that CRYER concealed his receipt of these sources of income from the IRS by failing to file a tax return on behalf of that trust."
I don't think many of us are receiving income from a trust.
by johnbeaman
The IRS could not supply the law that said he had to report income because there is no law in existance that says that. An attempt was made a hundred years ago and it was found unconstitutional. That is why they use weasle words in all their "code", and define words and phrases elsewhere so in reading a small part you think it applies to you.
Income.
Personal income.
From whatever source derived (IRS CODE)
If he was a janitor would you say that didn't apply to you?
by johnbeaman
It is the fact they cannot supply a law that says that your income is taxable, or that you have to file a 1040 because there is none
...from whatever source derived ..." (IRS Code) indicates that be it trusts, or any other "income" it still holds true.
by johnbeaman
We are all liable for many taxes, and I pay my fair share of all of them. This is not one of them. The content of the trial that is of note is that the IRS could not prove that he had to file at all.
If he doesn't have to file, then he isn't giving up his 5th amendment rights against self incrimination either. If he doesn't file, he has no contract with the IRS that they can always find him in violation of. If he doesn't file, the IRS has no clue to what they think they should be able to steal from him.
Are you seeing the pattern? With so many years of people not realizing, or assuming, without finding out the fact that they don't have to file at all, we are being controlled by this ignorance.
Yes people go to jail. Innocent people go to jail when their lawyer screws up, or the judge influences the jury, or they argue their case on the wrong premise. This is true in may cases, not just the income tax. When the IRS and all its resources go agains the little guy, they can win right ot wrong, and have. Example: spending almost a half million to collect $4,000 of a celebraties back taxes. You MUST ask yourself why they would do that. Visibility of their success. Another: The IRS spent $7.2 million dollars to harass 900+ people on a mailing list of subscribers to an anti-irs newsletter. With no other results. No value to the "taxpayers".
He still owes the taxes? Where does it say that? Another unsubstantuated opinion of a neophite.
He is not still liable for something that cannot be calculated. "It is still only a question." Read the trial info again.
Tell the local grocery store owner to pay the gangs extortion money too, it's easier, and less threatening. Great advice...
The IRS claim that something is frivolous is an opinion, not law. Only biased judges allow the point.
Why would he be disbarred? What law did he break? Again your personal prediction, not fact.
Your opinions are interesting, but not factual, so I would prefer discussing them in that light, and prefer you not state them as though they are indeed fact.
If you don't believe that I know what I am talking about, at least find out why you pay when Tom Cryer doesn't have to.
Find out why you file a 1040 when Tom was found not-guilty of failing to file one. Don't believe all the BS from either side of this issue. Find out for yourself.
Trust me, many small "pieces" infer different conclusions than the whole of it all.
If you don't have to pay, and the money pays for nothing you get, it is called fraud, and you can take the IRS to court over that too, and get all of your money back. Figure out how much that would be, and what you would be allowed to keep for the rest of your years, and tell me it isn't worth finding out the WHOLE TRUTH.
That is all I am recomending here.
by av .
The facts are that he got off because he convinced a jury that he didn't "willfully" not file a tax return. The IRS didn't prove their case and Tommy Cryer exploited that, as lawyers often do.
It doesn't mean that the IRS is done with Tommy Cryer. Tommy Cryer didn't prove that he doesn't owe the taxes, just that he didn't "willfully" not file a tax return.
Lawyers are supposed to uphold the law. Tommy Cryer may have found a way to wrap the IRS up in their own BS, but in the end the state ethics panel for lawyers will have their day with him, as will the IRS.
There are plenty of smart lawyers and smart people out there, but those people use the legal loopholes to avoid paying taxes because they are smart. Being a tax protester is like having a target on your back. If they don't get you now, they'll get you later.
The rules for trust accounts are different than people filing 1040s. Cryer created a trust to shelter his income and claimed that he did not need to report income paid to the trust. That is not a 1040.
If your theories are as sound as you say, why don't more tax protesters win in tax court? You're way off on this, John. Legal is the way to go.
AV
by maecuff
And you still haven't answered the question, "If my taxes don't pay for the military and other government services, what does?"
EDITED - On the page you linked to, there's a link to the DOJ indictment. Quoting from that page,
"It is alleged in the indictment that CRYER created a trust, listing himself as the trustee, and received payments of dividends, interest and stock income to that trust. The indictment further alleges that CRYER concealed his receipt of these sources of income from the IRS by failing to file a tax return on behalf of that trust."
I don't think many of us receive payments from trusts.
I watched enough of that video to see who was responsible. I wanted to get some background before I invested 15 minutes.
It didn't take long to find this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rd9McZFN6bg
another Aaron Russo video where he says the U.S. government is lying about the Sept. 11th attacks. Sorry, that moves the man right into the "conspiracy theorist" camp for me. I can't regard his opinions as credible.
From my earlier post today, quoting a link on a page you linked to:
"It is alleged in the indictment that CRYER created a trust, listing himself as the trustee, and received payments of dividends, interest and stock income to that trust. The indictment further alleges that CRYER concealed his receipt of these sources of income from the IRS by failing to file a tax return on behalf of that trust."
Few of us receive income from trusts.
by faradhi
It is there. The law establishing an Income tax.
That is clear as day. Now unless you can provide me with a link to a law that repeals what I posted, I have met a reasonable burden that there is in fact a law that requires income tax.
by faradhi
There is no limit to how many posts you can make here.
Further, Tom Cryer, avoided the charges because he set up a trust. I cannot speak to taxes as they relate to trusts. I can, however, speak to income tax. I provided a link to the actual code that is pretty clear. Income is taxed.
by johnbeaman
You can't post in a thread branch past a certain number of sub-entry LEVELS, that is why I couldn't post inline. Re-read what I said.
You can pick at detail all you want. Tom Cryer was found not guilty because the IRS couildn't prove he had to file for income taxes period.
Again you are ignorant. There is no tax on income. - The "income tax" is a tax on international activities, and your income is used as a basis for how much tax you pay on those activities. GO read the IRS code!
That is why it is all legal, and has to be according to our constitution.
You have been fooled along with many for years.
by faradhi
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/uscode26/usc_sec_26_00000001----000-.html
and here it is again
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/uscode26/usc_sec_26_00000001----000-.html
what part of
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/uscode26/usc_sec_26_00000001----000-.html
is confusing you?
by johnbeaman
It has to do with depth of the thread, and I already explained that.
He was found not guilty because the IRS could not find the law that said his income was taxable. There is none.
If Tom was a Janitor would you also say it doesn't apply to you?
It is about income '... from whatever source derived...' (IRS Code).
No, you can't speak of income tax, because you don't know enough about it.
Like your assertion on posting limitations.
There is no tax on your income, that would be unconstitutional. The law (and the code) only states requirements on international activities. The amount of the tax you pay for those activities references your "gross taxable" income to figure out how much you have to pay.
You need to find out more.....
by hal 9000
[i]He was found not guilty because the IRS could not find the law that said his income was taxable.[/i]
Where is your proof of this? There is no proof of this supposed fact as you claim only the claim of the person who for some reason managed to get off.
If you want to be believed you need to get a copy of the Court Transcripts and look at the LAW used to get him off.
Not the claims of the individual who may have got off a Charge that is in no way related to what you are claiming here.
Until you provide the requested information there is no possibility of you being believed. This is just Common Sense as who in their right mind would refuse to pay what they are asked to without proof of a bill being presented. For all That I know this clown may have got off because he refused to fill in a Tax Return after paying Tax all year and was due for a refund.
If that is the case he hasn't not paid the TAX only not complied to File A Return after paying Tax and not wanting a refund.
Surely you can see the differences here.
Col
by johnbeaman
First, you must realize that it would be difficult, when you actually think about it, to ask for proof that something does not exist. The only way to do that, is to look at absolutely everything that exists and then by logic, say it doesn't exist if you have not found it. We could say that Bin Ladden does not exist because we can't find him. Same idea. Problem is, how do you know you have looked everywhere? How do you know something hasn't changed in a previously looked spot since you looked there? Etc. Etc. There are many things that cannot be asked backwards. Some of these questions are.
There are "permissive" laws, and "prohibitive" laws. Prohibitive laws say you cannot do something, and only say that. They don't say what you can do, as the possibilities are endless. To look there to prove what you can do means you must read every law to see if what you are looking for is specifically prohibited. It's kind of like asking "where is the law that says I can visit my grandmother?" It doesn't exist specifically. Does this mean you can't? No! So you have to interpret what you know, or research and analyze all of that to come up with a good answer. Most peoples opinions are based on what they know, and this can be seriously limited or biased. Most are seriously ignorant when it comes to taxes. (Ignorant only means they are unaware, as I in: am ignorant about brain surgery) Most have no clue when it comes to government funding. You have to find out from someone that has researched the issue and accept their findings. You may not find a quotation or expect anyone to even believe it then. Case in point, many replys to my post here. Listening to the media, or your friends, or some of the clowns here is not going to get you your answers either. In fact you can almost be guaranteed that you will be lied to. Maybe not intentionally, maybe just to rile you. Maybe because of their gullability or ignorance. Probably a combination of all of these reasons. They all have an agenda, that is NOT in your favor. You have to find out for yourself, because most all of what you read and hear is propaganda and BS.
The 35 million non-payers of the income tax, was a figure I read back in the 80's, and most references recently are that it is estimated to be near 100 million now. It could be more. There will never be a government document that states that number for many reasons. Think about it. Why would they want it public? How would they know anyway? The best way is to take the census, and subtract the known number of "payers" to get your figure.
Why would the IRS tell you that the average person, living and working in the 50 states are not required by law to pay this tax? It is not in their best interest. You have to read the entire IRS Code, the Constitution, Bill of Rights, and all the amendments to figure it out. That is what Tom Cryer did, and that is how he knew. Then the trick was convincing a judge to allow him to present all of it, as most won't, and then let a jury decide without the judges interference. Rare. Many have tried and lost. Not because they were wrong, but because the "system" is against them, or they didn't know what they were doing sufficiently.
It is also kind of like the government unemployment figures. They really have no clue, and unless you ask every person in the country if they are employed, you cannot get an accurate figure. Our government unemployment figure is based on the number of people collecting unemployment benefits, so we know their number is way too small since many don't file for it, or are no longer collecting.
To answer the question of how our military get paid, and other government services, we have to go find out that specific source of funding depending on the item. It doesn't come out of a pool of money like many think. We would have to examine the "budget" to find that out, and the document is way too big to publish here. I know for a fact that the "Graduated Income Tax" does not pay for any service or benefit we get from our government. There are thousands of other taxes we pay for them. Example: all our roads and briges are paid from gasolene taxes, not the income tax. One guy here thought the income tax paid for his retirement. Rediculous. To give you a list here of all the taxes that I pay would take years of research and tons of documentation. To say I don't pay taxes is an ignorant statement. I just don't pay the extortion.
I DO know that the "Graduated Income Tax" money collected, specifically goes to pay the interest on the fee we pay a private company for the contract of printing our own money. The fee is not based on the printing costs, but on the face value. (Absurd.) This is an old scam that most all countries fell for, but the US was not doing until the 1930's when a group of Congressmen got together during a Christmas recess to pass the bill providing for it.
The origonal "income tax" was voluntary to help pay the war debt of WWI. The wording is
so convaluted to make you think you have to pay it. Tom Cryer proved, in court, that you don't. If it helped our people, or paid for anything we get, then it wouldn't bother me so much. It isn't really a tax on income anyway. That would be illegal. It is a tax on international activities that use your income to determine how much to pay. Your state taxing board says to use yur federal tax statement to calculate your state tax.
They don't tell you you owe them income taxes either, and that is why they say, in essence, is what ever you ave volunteered, or are required to pay by law to the federal government, we will accept your decisions and amounts too. They are leaving it up to your decisions with the feds.
I could use the internet, and Google to look up all of this specifically, but then so could you. I don't have the time right now, as I am really busy on a project. And if I told you, why would you believe me anyway? Many here have suggested that Tom Cryer didn't do what he did because one of the news reports sources has done questionable stories. That doesn't make this story of Tom Cryer winning untrue, so why are they trying to use that to judge the validity of my initial question? Do you think I should even bother to refute their logic? Or ask their opinion on anything at all? Not if their thought process was that flawed. Sorry.
I know this does not answer all of your questions specifically, but hopefully you can take it from here and find out for yourself, for only then will you truly believe it. I think it would be worthwhile, or I wouldn't have suggested it in the first place.
by w2ktechman
I really doubt the 100 million unless homeless, unemployed, and employed who make too little were all counted. Also, are they counting illegals?
This is misleading at best, to state such high numbers when in truth, many/most would not meet the requirements to pay.
As for road taxes, it depends on the state. Some states have toll booths on the freeways, others charge a gas tax. Sales taxes are as well, paid to the city/state. You have stated that the military, and govt. Pension/Disability plans are not paid by the Income Tax, so where are they being paid from? I did not ask you to look up everything, just a few. So this time I will cut the criteria to just include, if the Military is not paid for by the Income Tax, how are we paying for it?
P.S. -- Your 1930's date stamp is way off. Especially when referencing that we were paying for WWI with it. In actualities, from my understanding, it was in 1913.
by johnbeaman
Say something intellegent.
It comes from Bruce Willis movie.
by maecuff
the words 'say something intelligent' to 'A Negligee Thinnest Mostly'. But I'm pretty sure Bruce Willis never said that in a movie...
And I'm pretty sure my post STILL makes more sense than yours.
by johnbeaman
He didn't file a 1040 at all because the IRS couldnt prove that you have to file a 1040 on income, period. All the rest is why they took him to court in the first place. It has nothing specific to do with why he won.
In a nutshell: Personal income from non-international activities (which is only used to calculate the taxing amount on those activites, and is not therefore a tax on the income itself) does not warrent the filing of a 1040 according to the law. That is what the IRS code and the law says.
The IRS obviously couldn't show otherwise because it isn't true.
Get it?
by hal 9000
[i]He didn't file a 1040 at all because the IRS couldn't prove that you have to file a 1040[/i]
What exactly was this guy charged with and I mean Legal Documents here as a reference not some words that can be edited by anyone who wants to edit something.
Also you need to prove that the correct charge was issued as it is possible that someone was not convicted because the wrong charge was laid.
[i]In a nutshell: Personal income from non-international activities (which is only used to calculate the taxing amount on those activites, and is not therefore a tax on the income itself) does not warrent the filing of a 1040 according to the law. That is what the IRS code and the law says[/i]
You say this a lot but offer no proof so please post the Link to the Court Transcripts so that we all may look.
Only a complete Fool would be prepared to enter a Court and attempt to fight a Case like this on the provided Evidence. As there is none that will stand up in a Court of Law!
I can just see it now
Defendant [i]But Judge you are wrong because JohnBeaman told me different![/i]
Judge [i]Who is this JohnBeanam?[/i]
Defendant [i]Some Guy that Posted on the Internet[/i]
Judge [i]Will he be appearing in this Court?[/i]
Defendant [i]No I don't actually know who this person is or how to contact him.[/i]
Judge [i] Well what makes you think that he is right?[/i]
Defendant [i]He must be correct as it was posted on the Internet and the Internet is always correct.[/i]
At that point you would get locked away as [b]Insane!
But you would get off the Charge.[/b]
Col
by johnbeaman
I said:
He didn't file a 1040 at all because the IRS couldn't prove that you have to file a 1040.
That is my opinion and many others as a good summary of what the trial was about and why he won. I am not going to post the trial records here.
Why do I have to prove anything? I stated a fact: Tom got off because the IRS couldn't prove he was liable. Go read what happened instead of asking me to do it for you. That is the whole reason for his thread.
I never asked you to believe me. Only an idiot would reference me in their defense. Just bringing that up is absurd.
All your additional ramblings on that point are similarly absurd.
Why do I need to prove it was the "correct charge"? You make very little sense here.
by johnbeaman
They limit replies here, so I cant answer your diatribe in-thread sequence.
NickNielsen: You still don't get it do you?
Question: If Tom Cryer won in court, because the IRS couldn't prove that anyone has to file a 1040, and pay taxes based on his income, then why do most people?
Why do you?"
Answer: Because you have been led to believe that you have to.
maecuff: You make no sense at all. The "wrong answer" was from a bruce willis movie called diehard. Why do you cloud this issue with your ignorance?
by maecuff
by johnbeaman
Nothing.
by johnbeaman
The government collects gasoline taxes from all the states.
They then give some of it back to the states for roads and bridges funded "by the federal government". These are called interstate highways, and the government is responsible for interstate activities.
We pay a lot of taxes for many services, but not one dime of the "income tax" goes for those services.
Pensions and Disability are paid for out ot your SSI contribution.
The military is paid from the general fund, and by borrowing from the SSI pool.
How many people are unemployed? You can look up how many are collecting unemployment benefits. How many people are working? You can look that up too. Now, tell me how many are actually unemployed? What about the people no longer, or were never elligable for unemployment benefits? You can't without a census because the government can only lie to us and say how many are unemployed when they can only say how many are collecting unemployment insurance. This does not represent the correct answer to the question.
You have been duped into believing they are the same number.
For the same reason, how many don't pay the "income tax" is also adifficult calculation. Assuming it is only the homeless and poor is silly.
by johnbeaman
I can respect that you don't trust his opinions. All I was asking is that you looked at the facts, and there are many of them here.
I only posted that link for background attitude, opinion and info.
Again, like others, you dismiss the facts because you don't like a particular messenger.
I have no reason to trust him. His positions on other topics prevent me from trusting him on this one.
I don't know that what he asserts are facts. Just because someone says something in a video doesn't make it true.
by hal 9000
If it's posted on th Internet it's TRUE. :D
Well at least some continue to think that. No matter how misguided they are I can just imagine someone going to Court and using something like that as [b]Supposed Evidence[/b] if the Judge didn't cease the trial immediately and have the defendant put in for Observation as a Possible Mental Patient the trial would fail. As the Judge failed to make sure that the defendant was capable of pleading.
Col
by johnbeaman
by johnbeaman
Palmetto : Cryer not guilty of ...:
Cryer was found not guilty of filling a 1040 or stating this as taxable income because the IRS cannot find a law that says he has to. Period.
The rest is why they took him to court. You are missing the reason he was found not guilty.
The law and the code is totally legal. The fact that you think you have to file or are liable to pay a tax you don't owe, by law, is the question here.
by johnbeaman
Where?
There is no tax on income. Not legal by the constitution. The IRS couldn't show that and is why Tom Cryer won his particular case. If the IRS can't show it, why do you think you can?
There is a tax on international activities where your "taxable" income is used to determine how much you have to pay. There is no "income tax".
Reading a small part of the code, and attaching your own (and not the IRS) definitons to those terms makes you believe/read something that is not fact nor truth, nor law.
You've been duped!
by johnbeaman
You said bruce never said that.
If you are fiamiliar with the movie, then why
do you catagorically say he didn't?
He did.
What does that have to do with the tax issue?
Nothing.
by johnbeaman
by faradhi
well just in case, I hereby inform you that you are being mocked.
oh and by the way, here is the law establishing a tax on income.
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/uscode26/usc_sec_26_00000001----000-.html
by maecuff
Well then, I don't care about the point.
And I didn't say that Bruce didn't say that. I said that he didn't say my rearrangement of your post.
You confuse easily, don't you.
by johnbeaman
Do you want to get off on a tangent and on your spelling, or can we stick to the subject?
Your reference:
(http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/66xx/doc6609/08-15-Slides.pdf)
It only says what it says. For instance, it doesnt say that none of the SSI went to pay for the military, did it? Or that none of the income tax went to pay for disability or pensions. No, that was not the purpose of the document.
Those are only category totals, and not detailed allocations. The only point they are addressing there is spending related to GNP.
by faradhi
Tom Cryer had criminal charges against him. The charge was Willful Failure to File (tax evasion). This is a criminal charge and carries with it the need for the Government to prove that Tom knew he had to file, and had the intent to avoid taxes by not filing.
That is where the government failed to meet the burden.
Now, until there is a Civil ruling that states that Mr. Cryer does not owe the money, this case proves nothing except that Mr. Cryer did not fail to file with the intent of tax evasion. It just means he is not going to jail.
Further, the tax laws for Trusts are diffrent from individuals as was pointed out many times.
edited to add
oh yeah and
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/uscode26/usc_sec_26_00000001----000-.html
now don't let the vicious pack of facts deter you, keep up the good fight. Keep believing what you believe even in the face of overwhelming evidence like http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/uscode26/usc_sec_26_00000001----000-.html
by johnbeaman
Your statement is quite good, but still carries the taint of what the feds want you to think. Sux, I know.
The IRS cannot provide the law that says you have to file a 1040 on personal income on non-international activities. Period. Your links/citings only apply IF and WHERE it applies. You need to research that first.
The fact that he claimed he did not "willfully" fail to file has been thrown out
by some judges as irrelivant. Those judges are called constructionists, and should be impeached as they mislead juries and attempt to make up new laws from the bench. Many get away with it for the same reason most believe that this tax (and your references) applies to their domestic income.
The overwhelming evidence, as you call it, is mistakenly referenced. Your citings state what has to happen, by law, IF that specific law applies to the parties. In Tom Cryers (and many other cases) it has been proven to not apply to them. That was the point.
If you assume this applies to your case, and you accept what it says, and you are screwed.
They have had 80 years to convince you thru weasel words, tradition, false patriotism to believe it applies to you. It doesn't.
If those references don't apply to you, then what they say is irrelevant. Continuing to read them will only take yo off on tangents like so many posters here.
by nicknielsen
[i]I believe:
- 1. The tax law is legal and constitutional.
- 2. That tax does not apply to you or me.
[/i]
You can't provide links because there aren't any. This is all your opinion.
If, as you say, the Infernal Revenue isn't coming after you for taxes, I can only conclude one of four things:
- your income is strictly cash and is not being reported, in violation of the law;
- you have no income and are living off government programs;
- you have no income and are living off your spouse; or
- you are lying out your ass.
by johnbeaman
All of this has been explained many times here. For me to repeat to you what you have been told already is obviously a waste of time because your only interest is to prove me wrong, and you seem to have no other motive. You arn't interested in learning the truth. It's only a typical defense to hide your ignorance.
If you read the documents required, and understand the actual meanings, you will come to the same beliefs that so many others, like Tom have.
if you only wish to try and prove me wrong, which you can't, you make up crap and ask me to prove it ain't so. (Prove aliens don't exist. Not possible. You can only prove that they do, by showing one.) Your logic is faulty. You can only prove what is, or examine everything to show something is missing, or ask a person in authority. Like the court asking the IRS to show the law, and they could not.
If you think my belief points 1 and 2 are false, then go collect the $50,000 with your proof. The IRS couldn't, in court. What makes you think you can?
I am none of the above listed assumptions.
I just have no "taxable income" because I have no federally approved "taxable activities", according to the law. There are other possibilities than your limited knowledge on this subject can come up with.
I already went over this with the IRS 25 years ago, and they agreed with me.
by nicknielsen
by nicknielsen
However, I don't have the time for prison or money for court costs.
You keep providing links that explicitly include certain groups. Are you trying to say that American law only applies to an individual if that individual is part of a group that is explicitly identified?
[i]I just have no "taxable income" because I have no federally approved "taxable activities", according to the law. There are other possibilities than your limited knowledge on this subject can come up with.[/i]
Maybe I am limited, but I can't think of many possibilities that don't involve violating the law somehow.
by nicknielsen
I was wondering when this would happen. You dismiss any questions or evidence in opposition by belittling the evidence, then by accusing me of ignorance, then by accusing me of slander because I name you a freeloader
By your own admission, you have not filed a personal income tax return for over twenty years (http://tinyurl.com/2adjuc). Numerous other posters have provided reputable links to the requisite part of law. Here they are again: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/uscode26/usc_sec_26_00000001----000-.html
http://www.irs.gov/taxpros/article/0,,id=159853,00.html
Last time. [b][u]You[/u] are trying to convince me that you are correct, yet you provide no concrete evidence of such.[/b]
by absolutely
http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=56855
[b]victorious[/b] lawyer Tom Cryer: [i]"The
Founding Fathers intentionally restricted
the taxing powers of the new federal
government as a measure of restraint on its
size. By exceeding that limited taxing
authority the federal government has been
able to obtain resources beyond its
intended reach, and that money has enabled
the federal government to exceed its
authority," he said.
For example, he said, the Constitution does
not empower the federal government to
regulate education, or employment, and
agriculture, yet it does so.
...
"There are three points that are
important," he told WND. "There's no law
making the average working man liable [for
income taxes], there's no law or regulation
that allows the IRS to contend that
earnings are 100 percent profit received in
exchange for nothing, and the right to earn
a living through any lawful occupation is a
constitutionally protected fundamental
right, and it is exempt from taxation."[/i]
So, is that what [b]you[/b]
consider "crazy"? Interesting.
by hal 9000
Is it worth the risk of fighting?
While that may be the intent things change and since that Document was written there have been 2 World Wars in which America was involved at the behest of the People in the US. So while a document may say one thing it is quite possible that changes have been made over time as required and with the acceptance of the People. After all I am led to believe that the majority of Citizens of the US not only wanted but insisted that the US get involved in both World Wars and they expected to pay for that privilege. After all the Government couldn't be expected to pay without the contributions of the people could they?
To be quite honest it is not reasonable to fight something like this unless you are 100% Certain of a win and even then it may not be worth while. Attending Court isn't an easy thing and after you take into account the lost Time and money most find it not worth while following up on.
Only a complete Idiot who wants to either show off or thinks that they have something to prove would be interested and these type are not overly stable at the best of times. While attending Court to fight something like this certainly isn't the Best of Times either.
But if you want to you are free to take up the challenge and run with it as long as you like. Just remember the costs involved as the days roll by and the costs mount up on both sides which the looser has to pay. I do not know many that would find this Reasonable or Economical to fight actually.
Col
by johnbeaman
They are too busy trying to prove you wrong as a false insinuation that they are right. They attack trivia to cover up their ignorance on the subject at hand. They are to imbarassed to admit they have been hornswaggled. They are too afraid to stand up for their rights.
"Ignorance of the law is not an excuse", and our founding fathers expected that a government "of the people, by the people, and for the people" would encourage them to not be as freaking ignorant as this lot.
As Snoopy once said, "It's hard to play chess with a checkers mind."
by tig2
Lots of things.
I pay my taxes because it is the right thing to do. I disagree with the rules that don't apply across the board but I pay regardless.
Is my money being wasted? Probably. What control do I have on that? None.
I am not a sheeple. I want to know what the country is paying for. I also want the right to at least b*tch about when they do it wrong.
We have no "American values" any more. We haven't had for a long time. What should we do about that?
P.S. Didn't read the thread, just reacted to the OP. Sometimes I do that.
edit to fix a missing contraction
by johnbeaman
right thing to do?
It is "right" to pay a tax you don't owe which provides no services? Look up the definition of fraud.
In one statement you say you have no control, and yet you try and convince us you arn't sheeple.
You say you want to know and you you don't try, you go along with the extortion and "tradition". How can you expect the right to complain when you have no right as you have given them all up to an extortionist. You FIRST have to know the subject matter you are complaining about, or you add to the misinformation pool. That is why so many think this tax applies to them. It doesn't.
It was never an "American Value" to be tricked, and be ignorant of our government, though it does seem to be a widespread trend.
Find out the truth for yourself. Not easy. Many are doing that and are no longer slaves. This country was built on Liberty, not democracy, as a democracy is akin mob rule.
Don't give all that up by being a democrat.
by faradhi
Here is the Constitutional Amendment that allows the Income Tax.
http://www.usconstitution.net/xconst_Am16.html
Here is the actual law establishing the Income tax:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/uscode26/usc_sec_26_00000001----000-.html
Here is the Definition of Income
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/uscode26/usc_sec_26_00000061----000-.html
So other than having One and only one case where the 12 stupidest people that can be found in LA acquitted a tax dodging arsehole, do you have anything that shows that any of the laws were repealed. Although, I am relatively certain that Cornell did not get it wrong.
My Ace university trumps your pair of websites any day.
by absolutely
But in this particular case, it's funny how
strident you are about the validity of tax
laws. I have the impression that if proof
positive were provided, you'd still opt to
pay your taxes, and continue to insist that
the law requires you to do so. It looks
like you have so much money, you want the
government's help getting rid of it. Just a
bit funny.
by hal 9000
That there is not enough money to justify a Court Action on the evidence supplied here.
After all if I could avoid paying Taxes I would be quite happy but I'm not about to spend $25,000,000.00 to save a estimated $5.00 that just doesn't make any sense.
If you or anyone was silly enough to walk into court to defend an action like this on the supplied evidence the Judge would only have 1 alternative The defendant would be subject to Mental Examination and locked away for Their and Society Safety. They are obviously unfit to plead the case and if they actually found some Legal Representative who followed their instructions that Person should be Certified as well. However I don't think that anyone would be that silly.
Col
by faradhi
If you think I will pay income tax out of the kindness of my heart. I don't know what in the posts would give that impression other than I never explicated stated that I would not pay taxes if I did not have to.
So to clear things up, I would not pay taxes if anyone can show me where the law I cited was repealed or that an Appeal court has ruled that the law was unconstitutional after the 16th amendment and Income tax law I cited were passed.
--edited to add
If you notice, I live in a small town called Bartlett. The town borders Memphis. I live in Bartlett, because I did not want to pay Memphis and Shelby County taxes. Bartlett taxes are much less and tend to be very well spent. I only offer this as a little proof that I do not pay taxes I don't have to.
---edited to use the correct You're in the subject.
by johnbeaman
That is why they think something other than the truth and the facts. Because most people have been duped, why would they go against the masses and assert their true rights? Why would they admit they are too ignorant to discuss the subject? Instead they take things out of context, and make ignorant assumptions and then claim them as fact.
They don't, and is akin to joining the flat earth society. Or saying we caused global warming. (It's a cycle our solar system goes thru. The Mars polar caps are receeding too.)
As long as you keep paying the extortion, they will have the resources to squash those ill prepared.
by hal 9000
Post a Link to the Trial Transcripts. If you do that you can look at the same time as to what was actually brought up and why a case went the way that it did.
Listening to some crackpot and believing his ramblings without testing his credentials is both stupid and silly and will lead you directly to Jail where you do not get to pass go or collect $200.00.
If you are unable to post usable Links at least obtain a transcript of the case and read it yourself first before blundering on here and making a bigger fool of yourself than what others already think you are.
Provide the Links before continuing which you have been asked more than once and are either unable or unwilling to do.
Col
by hal 9000
What exactly was won here? Remember you need Proof! If you expect someone or many to follow you you need to produce Evidence that is acceptable in a Court of LAW!
Not what you have provided above you need real evidence not the ramblings of some idiot who should be locked away.
Unfortunately for you I work with Legal People and what you have provided here is not evidence of any type at best it is Hersey and not acceptably by any Court in the World.
Honestly you would stand a much better chance of walking into a Muslim meeting place claiming that you are a Jew & Proud of it. Most would just ignore you as a [b]Nut Case![/b]
Col
I just don't believe the circumstances of his case apply to anyone else. If they had broad application, all of the personal finance magazines, newsletters, and web sites would be reporting this in 3-inch type. Those convicted of evasion would be filing appeals left and right. Tax lawyers would flood the airways with advertisements like the personal injury ambulance chasers do. (Q. Why don't sharks eat lawyers? A. Professional courtesy.)
Remember, tax evasion is what they got Al Capone on. If he couldn't beat it, neither can you or I.
I also don't buy any of the stuff about taxes not being used to pay for the services the government provides.
by johnbeaman
As I said, the numbers are very hard to calculate. I was told it was 35-50 mil people in the 80's, and the last I heard was that it is just over 100 mil now. I have no "official count" from anyone because the government would never tell you, so those reporting it have to extrapolate.
I have explained where I believe the military budget is paid from in earlier posts. It comes from the general fund, and what they can borrow from the SSI trust fund.
Local roads are funded by both city, state, and federal taxes. Interstate hiways are paid for by both state and federal taxes on gas (all this also includes desiel and propane too). The fed taxes are used to bully the states into complying with their wishes, like the old 55mph speed limit issue.
The "payment for WWI" has been discussed many times. The income tax was sold to the people for many years as a patriotic issue to help pay for the war(s) including a huge pitch by Donald Duck in the 40's and 50's too.
1930 comes "after" WWI, which is when the drive to help pay for it would have occured...
Since the whole income tax issue about non-foreign activities liability was resolved and found illegal, and corrected, etc. They had to sell the people into volunteering to go ahead and do it anyway to help pay for the war. What they didn't tell the people was that none of that money went to help pay for the war or the debt on the war.
The main purpose of the income tax for domestics is to track what the people are doing, and a way to harass them should the government chose to.
Thought: Why does the IRS use the ATF as their enforcers, as that agency has nothing in it's charter about income tax? (ref the stamp tax) If it is a crime to not pay, then why isn't the justice dept involved?
Pensions and disability are paid out of the SSI funds. Has nothing whatsoever to do with the Income tax.
State sales tax money does not go to the fed at all, as far as I know. The reason is, that it is not interstate nor international activities.
by absolutely
And in my own research I haven't found
enough support for John's analysis of the
16th Amendment to stop paying my own taxes.
But, I find the concept of not paying the
federal income tax more intriguing than
many here seem to do, which I also find
intriguing. Why am I interested in not
paying taxes to the Feds? Well, Col, if
you're ever in Boston, let's discuss it
over tea!
by johnbeaman
It is obvous that Tom Cryer found enough evidence. D'OH!
The 16th ammendment was to clarify the tax law to insure it complied with our Constitution which basis it cannot violate. It inferred no "new power of taxation".
The SECRET CONCEPT you need to get to the bottom if this is:
1. The Tax Law is 100% legal.
2. The 16th Amendment Changed nothing.
3. Amendments cannot change the Constitution, they can only clarify it.
4. All these documents pertain to a "person" that is liable.
5. Keep going backwards to "who" is this "person", who is this "taxpayer".
6. You will find out, if you dig back far enough, that it isn't YOU!
That is why Tom won, I won, and many others.
hang on to the single concept that "the IRS could show no law that said all of this crap applied to Tom."
It is a lot of work, it takes a lot of time, but think how much you have already paid, and will continue to pay for something you don't owe, and for no services in return.
I thought it was worth it. It WAS/IS!
by johnbeaman
That is your opinion, not fact. And it is a false statement on your part and a slanderous claim, so I would prefer to carry this discussion to thinking adults instead of whining children.
You are part of the tremendously ignorant crowd that is only interested in having people listen to your crap. You can't discuss the issues presented, but only want to divert the subject because you have nothing else to offer. You are quite transparent.
by johnbeaman
If you think you are so smart, why couldn't the IRS just show that in court?
If this is "the law" on this issue, as you claim, then why don't you go collect the $50,000?
If this was the case, why has no one else collected it? Because it just ain't so.
You can't because you are too ignorant on the subject and have insufficent knowledge to understand what that reference REALLY says, or you wouoldn't have made such a false statement.
One more time.... There is NO TAX ON INCOME! The federal government cannot do that as it doesn't comply with the constitutional requirement.
The federal government can only tax international activities, and uses the "taxable income" to figure out just how much they want you to pay should you be required to, or volunteer to.
The income tax, as stated is 100% legal because it has to be. What you don't realize is that it doesn't apply to you. All this weasel wording is to con you into thinking it does. You have been duped! Accept it.
Tom Cryers case (and others) proved that in a court of law.
Get over it.
Your ignorance is showing.....
by johnbeaman
by johnbeaman
Personal income is just that. If there are no international implications then the IRS cannot require him to volunteer his information and calculations topay a tax he isn't required to pay. If he doesn't have to, where is his liability? What does he "owe?" He doesn't. How can he owe something he has been shown he doesn't even have to report?
The rest of your comments are like "they did it with mirrors" and the like. Your doubt is understandable, your scepticism is healthy as long as you use it to find out the truth, and not just use a small amount of information just to bash others that don't believe as you do.
Most of the world (with no scientific knowledge) believed the world was flat too.
That doesn't make it so, but it does make it tough on those that know the truth derived from the facts.
That is why a "democracy" is a terrible form of government, because it is defined as mob rule. The mob is not necessarily correct.
Rules for filing on a trust have nothing to do with people filing a 1040. Trusts are trusts, personal income is personal income.
Drop the trivial persuit. There is no connection.
If he was a janitor would that mean his win would not apply to you? No, because the IRS code says "from what ever source derived" which means you are missing the point, off on a tangent, and making excuses for the extortionist.
,br>
You also insinuate the he as a risk with his bar status. Show me the Bar's statement to that issue, or please stop slandering the man.
by av .
I said they were different.
If you think the IRS will ever let him go, you're wrong. As incompetent as they are, they will eventually make him pay. Its a good thing that he's a lawyer. Hope he has deep pockets.
Knowing lawyers as I do because I've worked in the legal field for 15 years, I'd bet that there is an ethics hearing in his future. It hasn't happened yet for him on this issue, but I don't think his legal peers will look too kindly on his exploitation of the tax laws.
AV
by johnbeaman
How has he exploited the tax laws?
The laws are what they ar, and it is up to the people that use them to determine what is appropriate for their case.
Your job definition then says you are a "law exployter" by your own definition.
I see your mind is made up, so I won't attempt to confuse you further with facts.
At least you admit he won, and that the IRS couldn't show a law that required him to state that income as taxable.
Could you, with your access, post a link to the transcripts, or equivilant for all of us?
by johnbeaman
You made it so simple you make no sense.
It isn't up to me to provide proof. The court already did.
What evidence do you want? I only offered the evidence that Tom won for the reasons stated, nothing more.
If it's not acceptable in any court of law, why did that court of law accept it? You make no sense.
I can see why so many people have been duped if you are representitive of those that work as law clerks.
Now you see why I believe a law professors analysis of the court case (with many references):
http://www.w3f.com/patriots/tomcryer.html
and disregard yours as ignorant meanderings.
by johnbeaman
You don't believe because you don't want to find out, and prove to yourself that you have been duped.
The news media will report nothing that doesn't help them promote their socialistic agenda. They hate the subject of taxes because it requires a lot of research and knowledge. They avoid it because they don't know who to believe without first doing the research.
Why do you think Toms case wasn't in 3 inch headlines on the major media? UH, because they don't want you to know, because they have an agenda!
I also don't buy any of the stuff about taxes not being used to pay for the services the government provides.
And yet you refuse to find out where it really goes... Oh, Your mind is made up, You don't want to be confused with facts...
(It has been stated specifcally where it really goes by numerous people here that have done the research that you refuse to do.)
Tax evasion is criminal because it is not fulfiling a contract (your 1040) that you signed.
Tax Avoidance is legally avoiding the whole issue because you are not legally required to participate. (Tom Cryers case in point).
You need to know the meaning of the words you throw around...
by johnbeaman
Some believe that the Constitution was devinely inspired, and written by great men that expected us to not be so ignorant about our own country that we couln't run it (of the people, by the people, for the people) intellegently.
Your recomendations are that we succumb to this extortion. (look up the definition.) You partake in the fraud (look that up too) as you are paying and getting nothing in return. You not only do this voluntarily, but you are recommending that everyone else do it too. I pity you and your posterity.
Many good men died to give you what you have. For you to accept this slavery and promote others to also be too lazy, and follow you is absurd.
If you wave the American flag too, then you are a hypocrite.
by hal 9000
It is very succinctly stated above what I am saying. You do not go to court and spend $25,000,00.00 to save $5.00 that is insane and [b]Bad Business![/b] Even a complete Nim Non must be able to understand something so blatantly simple.
The simple fact of Life is you only fight something when it is in your bests interests not for the sake of fighting as if you indulge your self in doing that you do not have any income to pay TAX on.
So there is no point in the fight. As you obviously can not understand the Basics of Free Enterprise I have to seriously question your ability to understand the infinitely more complicated Tax System.
Col
by johnbeaman
You must be joking.
Is this another tinfoil hat accusation?
Did the aliens tell you to say all of that?
Tell our founding fathers that is was bad business to do all they did. Tell the Marines that it was bad business to sacrifice their lives for your freedom.
Tell THEM there is no point in fighting.
by johnbeaman
It only applies to certain people.
Tom was not one of them any more than I am our you.
Then why do you bother quoting it?
It is obvious that you don't know to whom it applies or you wouldn't. It's that simple.
Don't get me wrong, most think it is all they need to know. Tom Cryer didn't fall for that, he dug deeper.
Do you know the legal definition of "taxpayer"?
It means those who pay this particular tax. ONLY!
I pay a hell of a lot of taxes, but not this one, so I am not a "tax payer" by the IRS definition. Therefore all laws that apply specifically to "tax payers" does not apply to me. (nor you unless you fall for it). Are you now getting a flavor to the methodology behind this scam we have all been living with for so many years?
This is why assuming who a law applies to is foolish. The one you cite, being non-applicable, is a great example of this point. But you will never know this unless you dig.
by johnbeaman
If I write on the outhouse wall that John Lennin died, are you going to refuse all other evidence that it really happened?
You need to grow up.
by johnbeaman
I said they were incomplete and insufficient to stand alone. I also said I believed all the tax laws are legal, and believe I am not violating any law. That is because I dig deeper that one quote.
You also have to cite who this applies to. You don't. That is why your claim that this "part" says it all. That is false.
Tom Cryer knew it din't apply to him, and I agree. That is also why we both won and don't pay this extortion any longer.
If you think it applies to you, and is complete, then you have fallen for the trick.
Your first clue should be your usage of the word "part".
by johnbeaman
I have posted links to lawyers analysis, the IRS code, news stories, and the law. If you want to dig deeper, then do so, I recommend it, but quit asking me to get you specifics because when I do, you will just ask for another because you are afraid to find out the truth for yourself.
If you haven't read the transcripts then why are you claiming, and expecting credibility, that none of this is true?
You shouldn't take anyone elses opinion for it anyway, you will never believe it unless you find out for yourself.
I just said, "If this is true, why do you pay?" In your case it is because you want someone to do it for you, as you let them tell you you had to pay, and so you do.
,br>
Go look up the definitions of "sheeple", and "slave". You might also consider the phrase "chosen ignorance", "blaiming others", "But I never was told". etc. pretty shallow excuses.
by johnbeaman
He was found not guilty because the IRS could not find the law that said his income was taxable.
Where is your proof of this? There is no proof of this supposed fact as you claim only the claim of the person who for some reason managed to get off.
You are too lazy to look for it. There are links all over this page that show you what you say I need to show you. If you haven't bothered to read lawyers analysis (links posted here) or the trial transcripts, how can you claim it just ain't so?
You need to learn to do things for yourself. It's called growing up.
by johnbeaman
Smart. But people could say you had an unkind heart and are a tax cheater for doing that too.
Your motivations and decisions are based on what you know. If you don't realize that the 100% legal tax laws don't apply to you, and you are doing without realizing there is nothing wrong by not paying it, then you're "doing it out of the kindness of your heart" makes no sense. Because you think it helps. It doesn't. Find this out and you may not be as kind hearted toward this particular tax.
All the law you cited is correct, but your analysis is based on incomplete documentation. Because of that, you assume it applies to you. It doesn't, and no laws need to be changed. Requesting that shows you don't understand the law or the tax code.
I found out, and so did Tom. You can too, but you have to dig.
Do you have links for where the military funding comes from?
As for WWI and WWII these were not a 'tax' but a voluntary Liberty Bond (or War Bond). The Donald Duck reference was not to pay for WWI, but WWII.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_bonds
As for this "The main purpose of the income tax for domestics is to track what the people are doing, and a way to harass them should the government chose to. "
I do not think that is the main reason. Or even much of one. Most likely it was greed, and build capitol for the country (reserves) while being able to import items and sell them cheaper (instead of carrying larger taxes for importing).
I never said that sales taxes went to the Feds, I said city/state.
Provide some evidence that isn't web based. Refer me to a physical publication. Point me to a law library. The people I know who work in the tax field (and trust more than web postings) say this is a load of poop that rears it's ugly head every couple of years.
Incidentally, his last name was spelled "Lennon", not "Lennin".
by faradhi
[i]There is hereby imposed on the taxable income of?
(1) every married individual (as defined in section 7703) who makes a single return jointly with his spouse under section 6013, and
(2) every surviving spouse (as defined in section 2 (a)),
a tax determined in accordance with the following table: ... [/i]
Source: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/uscode26/usc_sec_26_00000001----000-.html
With Taxable income defined as...
[i]the term ?taxable income? means gross income minus the deductions allowed by this chapter...[/i] source http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/uscode26/usc_sec_26_00000063----000-.html
The law is pretty clear. I am not sure what else you expect. You say I do no understand. Yet you offer no other interpretation.
All you have is one case. I agree that John cryer won. I do not know why cryer won because I do not have the transcript no any account from the jurors. Additionally, I do not know for sure that his case can be consider a precedent in courts. I do not believe it can. I have found no case where a trial ruling has been used as legal precedent.
Further, since he was found not guilty. There is no higher court ruling that would establish this as legal precedent.
Lets say your right. And we all follow you. Do you think for a moment that Congress would hesitate to pass a law that circumvents whatever ruling that the courts make. That is the origin of the 16 amendment.
by johnbeaman
The law is pretty clear. I am not sure what else you expect. You say I do no understand. Yet you offer no other interpretation.
There is hereby imposed on the taxable income of?
(1) every married individual (as defined in section 7703) who makes a single return jointly with his spouse under section 6013, and
(2) every surviving spouse (as defined in section 2 (a)),
a tax determined in accordance with the following table: ...
Source: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/uscode26/usc_sec_26_00000001----000-.html
STOP RIGHT THERE!
every individual (as defined in section 7703) who makes a single return
The rules apply to those that make the return. What if you dont make one? Then the rule doesn't apply. What if you can't find a law that says you have to make one in the first place? ( Tom Cryer) Why bother reading this section at all?
Did you read 7703 or section 2a to see WHO this applies to?
Did you read the beginning of the tax instructions that tell to look there for your particular classification? You will find all kinds of rules for international activities, but none that apply to you unless YOU ASSUME they do, which is the BIG mistake.
Tax code applies to domestic people with foreign income, or foreigners with domestic income. No where does it say that you or I am part of the "class" of people that this applies to. That means none of this applies and all the issues in it are irrelevant, but people love just arguing those details, like tax accountants. Tax accountants, and tax lawyers help you do your taxes legally and by the code. They do not, and have no reason, to tell you that you don't have to do it at all. Why would they, the'd be out of a job.
Lets say your right. And we all follow you. Do you think for a moment that Congress would hesitate to pass a law that circumvents whatever ruling that the courts make. That is the origin of the 16 amendment.
They cannot pass a law that is contrary to the Constitution. The 16th amendment did nothing but to clarify the tax laws so they would comply with the constitution. They added no new power.
"[T]he Sixteenth Amendment conferred no new power of taxation but simply prohibited the previous complete and plenary power of income taxation possessed by Congress from the beginning from being taken out of the category of indirect taxation to which it inherently belonged." - http://www.gpoaccess.gov/constitution/pdf/con027.pdf
Forget the 16th. The phrasology is set up to make you keep thinking it is about you and all that. It doesn't.
The law is pretty clear. I am not sure what else you expect. You say I do not understand. Yet you offer no other interpretation.
The law is pretty clear in this regard ONLY if you ASSuME it applies to you. I offer my intrepretation after years of study. I can point out some things, but why would you believe me anyway? You really have to learn how all the pieces fit together, without that and normal assumptions, you are continually trapped into assuming that it applies to you.
Tom proved it doesn't.
If you don't know the difference between a direct and an indirect tax, then even talking to you about this is a waste of time. I am only trying to get peoplr to realize that Tom case is a great example as a starting point to find out why the tax law is so convoluted. and to dig into it. It is convoluted to keep you from understanding it, and to make you think you owe a tax that you don't. To me it is obvious. To those that don't dig, the opposite is "obvious" to them.
Keep digging, and I hope I can continue to help point you in the right direction. I certainly cant give 30 years experience here in these little replys.
by hal 9000
And you seem unwilling or unable to provide it so why should you be believed?
[i]He didn't file a 1040 at all because the IRS couldn't prove that you have to file a 1040.[/i]
So you say but really where is the proof?
[i]That is my opinion and many others as a good summary of what the trial was about and why he won. I am not going to post the trial records here.[/i]
Well I say that he didn't get convicted because he's Pink with Purple Polka Dots. As you admit that this isn't factual with supporting evidence but only your opinion what makes you think that you should be believed?
[i]Why do I have to prove anything?[/i]
Well put simply you started this and want to be believed so the onus is on you to provide the proof.
[i]I stated a fact: Tom got off because the IRS couldn't prove he was liable.[/i]
The key words here are [b]I Stated[/b] which is correct you did state but offer no proof so it is not believed.
[i]Go read what happened instead of asking me to do it for you. That is the whole reason for his thread.[/i]
Why are you unable to furnish the links? As you say you started this thread and now you refuse to answer questions that fall at the very foundations of the entire thing. Looks like you have something to hid.
[i] never asked you to believe me. Only an idiot would reference me in their defence. Just bringing that up is absurd.[/i]
Well what did you expect to happen? If you want people to look at what you have to say and even be part way believed you need to provide evidence of what you claim. Not continually repeat yourself Ad Nausium with nothing new to say and wonder why people do not believe a single word that you post. But you are finally getting to the root of the problem [i]Only an idiot would reference me in their defense.[/i] Yes only an Idiot would be involved in this as it currently stands.
Also referencing you in a defence after you post something like this may be a good idea as it draws attention away from the defendant and places a Burden of Proof on the on the Prosecution to prove that the Defendant wasn't swayed by some person who is guilty of Conspiracy and Perverting the Course of Justice. Which you are because you are unable to provide any proof of the things that you say.
[i]Why do I need to prove it was the "correct charge"? You make very little sense here.[/i]
Unlike you I didn't start this or continue on with it demanding that others believe me no matter what because I said something. You are the one pushing this cause and as such if you are unable to provide the proof that is requested you are the one that looks the fool that they are.
[b]Now every one tin Foil Hats on and stop your brains being read. :D :^0 :0 :p
Col
by hal 9000
I want to believe but with the offered proof I am unable to so why can you not provide the additional links requested?
Col
I'm not the one making the tin foil hat" remark. You asked what it had to do with the topic. I agree that it's not a fact, but it's farahdi's opinion, not mine. I was just explaining it.
"You are part of the tremendously ignorant crowd that is only interested in having people listen to your crap."
And this makes me different from you? You apparently are only interested in having us listen to you. Isn't it time you concluded your attempt to help us isn't getting anywhere, that you've made your best effort, and if we don't want to listen maybe you should stop wasting your time on us?
by johnbeaman
Why do you post such rubbish?
If you are trying to be sarcastic, I think you will actually convince most of the people here that it is true, not a sarcastic remark.
Anyone that goes to court without proper preparation will get what he deserves.
Because something on the internet doesn't make it right or appropriate by the fact that it is there. The same holds true that you cannot discount it because it is there as your only criteria.
Your statement is rediculous...
OH, I forgot, you are just being silly.
Too bad many will take it otherwise.
by johnbeaman
Read this entire page, top to bottom:
http://www.devvy.com/notax.html
Devvy Kidd has done 10 times the research as I have.
I recommend you trust her opinion.
I recommend you read it over again and again.
Sincerely,
-John
Sort by Trending